This week, Marco Rubio declared a crusade against the International Criminal Court, citing the ICC’s aim to deny America its sovereignty on behalf of globalist elites. But the New York Times recently reported that the U.S. is managing Venezuela’s oil export revenue. Does the "Donroe Doctrine” run against the administration's wider outlook on nationalism? Meanwhile, two fatal ICE shootings, in Maine and Houston, call into question if the public can stomach immigration enforcement ahead of the midterms. Plus: Thoughts on Christopher Nolan’s Odyssey and Young Washington.
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 02:13 Marco Rubio Against the ICC 11:45 U.S. Control of Venezuela 17:17 ICE Controversies in Houston and Maine 37:21 Nolan's Odyssey and Young Washington 53:48 Closing Remarks
Spencer Clavin and Mike Sabo discuss the Trump administration's foreign policy, focusing on Marco Rubio's efforts to dismantle the ICC to preserve national sovereignty. The episode also covers U.S. involvement in Venezuela, the political fallout from ICE enforcement incidents, and a cultural review of biographical cinema and Christopher Nolan's adaptation of *The Odyssey*.
Hello and welcome once again to The Roundtable, your weekly publishers and
editors' podcast from the American Mind. I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor of the
Claremont Review of Books and 24-7 Christopher Nolan correspondent for the American Mind and
pretty much everywhere else. I think it's basically my job this week. I joked with the guys before
this month that all of July was just going to be me writing about The Nolan Odyssey.
I thought I was joking, but then it's basically going to be all of July. I have so much to say
about this movie and we are going to get into talking about it on this podcast in case you're
interested because the press embargo has been lifted. And even though it's not in theaters yet
for the masses, I have gotten a sneak peek and we can talk about that plus Young Washington.
But all of that is down the line. I'm joined today by Managing Editor Mike Sabo.
Ryan Williams is out. He's got his responsibilities to do with the fellowships, of course, and also
he's going to take some well-earned R&R. So you're going to get the two of us for a bit here.
And there's no shortage of stuff to talk about. We do want to mention that, of course,
Lindsey Graham, the senator from South Carolina, has died on the 11th. He passed away quite
suddenly. We are going to talk about this, but Mike had the very nice idea, which I think is
probably good general practice, that we're going to wait a week before we assess in detail Lindsey
Graham's effect on American politics, his history, his career, his legacy. Not because I think either
of us has anything particularly scathing to say about it, but just because it's probably
proper and respectful and we should probably do more of this to wait in the wake of death before
we get into the nitty-gritty of good, bad, and all the rest about somebody's career. So for now,
all we're going to say is requiescat in pace. May he rest in peace and may light perpetual shine
upon him. More on his legacy probably next week. There's lots of other things to get into,
and we want to begin by checking in on our boy, Marco. I think we've talked more about J.D. Vance
recently than we have about Marco Rubio, in part because his role in the Iran war has been
particularly pronounced. Our listeners will probably already know that the agreement ceasefire,
which we discussed a few weeks back, is now basically toast. It seems to have ended,
and so we're back in a new stage of this projected conflict. I didn't go back and
listen to what we said about that deal memo back in the day, but I'm pretty sure we were kind of
like, well, we'll see where this goes, and it turns out it went nowhere. We'll have yet more
of that to talk about. We're also going to talk about Trump's immigration policy down the line,
but we want to turn our attention briefly to another dimension of international politics,
and that's the part that Marco Rubio is presiding over. The New York Times,
which is really unmatched when it comes to writing headlines that make its enemies sound awesome,
has a piece up called The Viceroy of Venezuela. This is by Sam Sifton. He's writing about and
perhaps talking about how Rubio is running the country of Venezuela by proxy. We may address that
in a bit, but first, let's talk about this new, I guess I would call it a policy agenda item,
which is to dismantle the International Criminal Court, the ICC. Rubio had a video on X and an
article in The Wall Street Journal detailing why the Trump administration thinks America needs to
set its sights on the ICC. I think it's an extension of what Rubio has been talking about
for a long time, what the administration has been talking about for a long time.
Just going back to my travels to Hungary earlier this year, that's what administration officials
there at that conference spoke about, was the breakup of the global order. It reminded me
almost of Michael Anton in a Flight 93 election where people were accusing him of Caesarism and
advocating for open tyranny and this stuff. It's like, well, no, he was just advocating
voting for Trump in an election. This is the same thing. Rubio ends this saying,
the US is launching a diplomatic campaign with a simple message, sovereign states over globalism.
This is just nearly an extension of everything in a culmination, I think, of everything that
they've been discussing. It's just simply extending the logic. He's just saying,
to continue that paragraph, this is only the beginning, using all the tools at our government's
disposal, working beside every ally with whom we can make common cause, we will dismantle the ICC
brick by brick if necessary. Obviously, done for rhetorical purpose, but at the same time,
I think that this is what this, I guess, Trumpian nationalism, going against this
globalized order that itself is breaking down. I think Rubio wants to work ahead and work to
put something new in there. This is about sovereignty, obviously. You have to view
this in light of America 250. He makes an interesting, actually, bipartisan case. He
talks about how President Clinton, during the Clinton administration, refused to submit to the
Rome Statute, and that was the ICC's founding charter, the Senate ratification, due to his
quote, concerns about significant flaws in the treaty. Then he obviously talks about the many
high-ranking international officials that have gone against the Trump administration,
that in one case, they were mad of the administration's deportations of violent
criminals to El Salvador. There was a former ICC chief prosecutor declared that President
Trump's strikes against narco-terrorists amounted to a crime against humanity.
This is all a piece of, again, what the administration's policy, what Secretary
Rubio has been talking about on foreign policy for quite a long time. Obviously,
this was set in the Wall Street Journal for a reason. Again, this is just to extend
the policies, I think, of just the second Trump administration in total.
And with the mood of populism worldwide, there is a mass global rejection
of the post-war order taking shape, and a big part of that is this skepticism about
all supranational power. Not because we just want to have a free-for-all,
but because the concept itself was always a little bit murky to begin with. It was like,
we didn't want to do more World War, that's perfectly clear, and that remains true. Nobody
wants that to continue to happen. We are not trying to throw off these international shackles
because we're so hungry for an orgy of bloodletting that we just can't wait to get our
teeth into each other. That's not what's going on, and that's not why people have this problem.
It's because the matter of international law was always a little bit fake. It was always
going to have to be a voluntary agreement undertaken by sovereign equals, or nothing
at all. That is, you can't actually create supranational bodies and preserve national
power. So there was always a bit of waffling about this, and I think there were some people
who imagined that we were going to move beyond the nation-state as a locus of power and as a
sovereign entity. That was all going to be gradually dissolved and subsumed into this
one-world government, and of course, as many at Claremont have pointed out, it ain't going to
happen. We don't want it to happen. It's a recipe for tyranny and misery. The nation-state isn't
perfect, but it remains the best thing that we've got, and it remains the kind of Goldilocks of
sovereignty. Indeed, representative government is only really possible within its bounds,
and that's something we want to preserve, including all of these people who are mouthing
off about our democracy, et cetera, et cetera. You got to keep nation-states in place, which
means really that bodies like the ICC don't get to say what countries like America
does, whether or not we're members. We're not a member of the ICC. We're not party to it,
but be that as it may, when you read these paragraphs in Rubio's piece, like,
Chief Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda of Gambia talking about war crimes by America. I don't want to be
mean. That's just not somebody I'm interested in hearing from, and it's nothing about the
nation of Gambia particularly. I don't even really know anything about the nation of Gambia,
to be perfectly honest. I don't care to know that much about it. I don't want to hear from them
about us. I only want to hear from one nation about America's role in the world, and that's
the United States of America. We get to make those decisions, not because we're perfect,
not because everything that we do is always going to be flawless, not because we're the one nation
in the world that can do no wrong, but because we are us and we get to make our decisions,
just as I would hope other nations get to make their decisions. But again, that's their problem.
So this seems eminently reasonable to me. I like to see this a lot more than I like to see
what's going on with the war in Iran. The war in Iran has just become really messy, and it does not
seem like it's going well for Trump, and it does not seem like Trump has a lot of great options
except to save face. And even there, I'm not sure how he's going to do that. He's pulled many more
rabbits out of hats than I have ever had reason to doubt him about. In other words, I've doubted
him about all sorts of things. He's pulled through on all of them. He may yet, I don't know, salvage
the Iran thing. But if I were advising him, which would be a bad idea, but if I were, I would say
less of the Middle East adventurism, more of the railing against and indeed doing a lot to
dismantle these useless international bodies, which Rubio is absolutely right, are run by
people who hate us and that have no business butting into our affairs. No, I think that's
exactly right. Yeah. And if you look at all the errors that the second Trump administration has
done, I would say Iran is the first and foremost. That's backwards looking. I mean, it's a politics
of the past. It's a politics of Bushism. It's a politics of this kind of messianic view of the
United States that I think was so important and understandably so came out of certain circumstances
and situations in a post-World War II context where we were just at the apogee, we're at the
zenith of just our power. I mean, we destroyed the world essentially. So that makes sense.
And then I would say that the strengths are really coming from the four looking aspects, which is
nationalism versus globalism. It's trying to extricate ourselves from anything that will
take our sovereignty away, no matter how small. So I think that the instincts of the Trump
administration or Rubio are right on in this instance and that all we need is actually much,
much more of this and following much more of these instincts. Because I think if that happens,
I think good things are going to result in that. Yeah. We should briefly mention this other
dimension of it, which is that Rubio in his 20 different roles within and without the
administration can add leader of the nation of Venezuela. Now, I think the Times is trying to
overstate this because it does undercut everything I've just said about national sovereignty to an
extent, if indeed it is true that Rubio is just running Venezuela. But really what seems to be
going on here is that, you know, after they took out Nicolás Maduro, a name I just now love to say
in the most obnoxious way possible, after they took out Maduro, Venezuela's vice president,
Delcy Rodríguez, gets a call from Marco Rubio saying, basically, look, you're going to work
with us here or there's going to be a world of hurt. Subsequently, Rodríguez agrees, or as the
Times puts it, bends the knee. And now we're in this situation where there are all these amazing
details, like the U.S. Treasury is receiving Venezuela's revenue from its exports and then
distributing it to Venezuela in the manner, as again, the Times says, of parents handing out
allowances to children. What do you think, Mike? Does this undercut everything I've just said
about national sovereignty or is this just the down road doctrine in action? And down the road,
we're looking at a free Venezuela? Yeah, no, I think this is a transition phase.
I think if you look at the alternative, what if we just did what we did and then backed out? And
then Delcy Rodríguez, by the way, who was already in the Maduro administration, was up there in
power, was the vice president, was part of his whole project for a long, long time, especially
all going back and all tied to Cuba. And you look at all the leftist regimes that are currently
falling right now. So you see the network, you see the spiderweb. What if we would have done
that as an alternative? And I think the results would have been very poor. We would have not
gotten out where we wanted to. So I think that this makes sense, even though it may not cohere
exactly with John Quincy Adams' type of foreign policy, republicanism kind of as an example and
a standard. I think that this has to be done at least in some way, shape or form to make Venezuela,
to have them transition to a country that we can actually rely on, that's not going to be doing
the kinds of things that they were doing in the past, narco-terrorism, just a huge hub for leftism.
So I think that, again, is this the perfect situation? No. But I think that, look, I wish
the Times would say what they wanted instead. I just don't know what kind of the alternatives were,
especially given the situation. And again, if you want the full-on, full-bore
General Doctrine, I think this is just the price, in some ways, of what you're going to have to pay
to have that and to get that done. I mean, yeah, there is a version of future events where
we say, first of all, you, ICC, you, European Union, you, whatever, are not going to run
the whole Western world or the whole half of the world. And then we say next, because we are,
right? It's always been on the table that America is transitioning into a more aggressive and open
ownership of its sort of protectorate powers. And that would really be a challenge to the
isolationists. I think it's something that we would probably prefer as much as possible to
avoid. But it's also very much the kind of thing that happens to successful republics as they grow
older. But I don't want this republic to be in its old age. I want us to be in our
sprightly, vigorous youth and just embarking on the next quarter century of our history.
So I will say that, I guess, just in closing that, you know, it's not like we're not aware
that the cards, the tea leaves might point in this direction. I also think there's a lot of people
on the right and the left who want very much to avoid having that happen. So I hope sincerely that
as much as I joke about, you know, running Venezuela and Rubio being the man for all
seasons, I do think in reality, he as well probably hopes that he will be stepping back
from this entanglement in due course, or at least allowing, turning Venezuela into an ally,
which as you say, Mike, it's not as if the previous situation was so peachy, keen and hunky
dory. We were still very tangled up with Venezuela, just in a negative way and a way that was hurting
us and causing all sorts of problems to our citizens. So really, first and foremost, this is
in American interests, or it was undertaken in American interests. There are dangers,
there are dangers to everything. And one of them, I think here is a kind of ongoing entanglement in
other nations affairs, even as we tell those other nations to butt out of box. Now that's
our right. And I would prefer for it to be us, you know, telling other people what to do rather
than other people telling us what to do. Optimally, I would hope that we wouldn't, nobody would tell
anybody what to do. And we would just run our nations as nations, because that does seem like
the right course of action. And I still do believe in that as a matter of political philosophy.
But we shall have to see. While we're on the subject of troublesome matters for the Trump
administration, we should discuss these ICE shootings. You remember ICE, we were talking
about them a lot not long ago, obviously, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, still
maintaining a series of quotas for sending illegal immigrants home, still
enacting something that the people want or said they wanted. But obviously, it's gotten
complicated by the fact that the public, although they are in favor of deportations for criminals,
although they are in favor of securing the border and so on, aren't so much in favor of chaos in
American cities. And above that are kind of squeamish about deportations, even legal
deportations when they come down to people who aren't actually doing anything wrong besides
being in the country illegally. And so that has proven a real pain point for the administration,
I would say. And now in Maine, Bidford, Maine, an ICE officer fatally shot a man while they were,
I think it was while they were surveilling him, watching him outside of his house.
But there was also another one, this is why I'm getting these a little bit mixed up,
but there was also a traffic stop in Houston where a federal agent fatally shot a Mexican
immigrant. So all of this has caused, obviously, more sturm und drang. And Prakas, on the left,
has been pointed at as another example of why the ICE is wrong and must be abolished and will
probably feature in all kinds of DSA campaigning and so forth, and midterm campaigning as well.
There have been some immediate reactions to this, including ICE agents getting directed to halt most
traffic stops, which is where these things are happening. And traffic stops are high
pressure and dangerous situations. And so that's perhaps part of the thinking there.
Tom Homan talked about this as a short pause rather than an overall revision of policy. However,
I gather they're just trying to get their officers under control. And the other added dimension of
this would be that there've been a lot of major efforts to hire more ICE officers and put them out
into the field. And so there've been questions raised about whether these guys are really
getting the training that they need in order to pursue these objectives effectively.
So I lay all of this, Mike, in your lap and I ask, obviously, we want a secure border. Obviously,
we want illegal immigrants deported. All of these things are not just things that we think are right,
but that the public generally seems to agree are right, all things being equal. However,
is this nevertheless going to be bad for Trump during the midterms? What should he do,
do you think? And how should he navigate the politics of this?
Well, I think if things like this keep happening, I think already Trump is facing some difficulties
in the midterms. I think Republicans more and more, even though, yes, in some of the redistricting
cases and them gaining more seats, I think they will still lose the House. I mean, this is just
historically what happens against the party of the president, I think, in midterms historically,
especially recently. So that's not going to be a surprise. I think in these two cases,
the first one in Maine, it was, like you said, ICE was conducting targeted surveillance
on the known address of an illegal alien with a final order for removal, an illegal alien.
I'm just reading off of ICE's, this is from DHS, this was posted on X, they said,
an illegal alien departed the residence in a vehicle, ICE law enforcement attempted to conduct
a vehicle stop, the vehicle attempted to flee the scene, and fearing for public safety, an officer
discharged his weapon, the driver of the vehicle was struck, and emergency services were immediately
contacted, he passed away from his injury. So we'll see with investigations what's going to happen.
And in Houston, this one is actually a little bit more interesting. So they found actually
three bags believed to contain meth were actually found in the van that was stopped, and the man
who was killed was a Mexican national, and that was according to a federal search warrant affidavit.
And then also, there was actually a third one that happened in Florida on Tuesday,
and this was a 28-year-old man who was killed after he was hit by a tractor trailer while
running from immigration and other federal officers. So like you mentioned,
ICE had actually ordered agents to halt all vehicle stops, but Trump actually earlier today
had actually overturned that order. He wanted them to just return to what they've been doing.
So that's kind of an interesting back and forth there. But I think the optics and comms, I mean,
obviously, I feel like our whole world kind of revolves around that, and it shouldn't,
but it does in some ways. If this kind of keeps happening, I think it will hurt Trump a little
bit more and more and more, especially with some of the more moderate Republicans, the electorate
overall who wants immigration, clearly. I mean, they're for deportation, maybe not all of them
for mass deportation, but I mean, they clearly have bought into the president's agenda, I think,
immigration. But yeah, I think that the administration, they do have to watch out
that this doesn't really start souring the public towards that idea, towards immigration
enforcement, that this just comes naturally with shooting people. So I do think that they need to
be careful about this. And then too, I do just want to put this all into context about what ICE
has been doing in general, because obviously these hard cases are the ones that get magnified.
But in general, I think this was in June 2026, so just last month, Tom Homan said,
I think 10,000 people have been detained nationwide, and that was just in a five-day
period. Actually, sorry, that happened actually earlier in July. So that was doubling earlier
daily averages, which were about, I think, 2,000 per day. There was a high-profile operation in
the Rio Grande Valley, and that was 238 illegal aliens arrested in a single day in June.
And so since it was January 2025, since the beginning of the administration, there's been
about 540,000 deportations. The first six months of fiscal year 2026, ICE carried out about 234,000
removals. So the levels are increasing in a big way. People are being deported. So I think Trump
is seeing what he wants to see, but at the same time, I do think that they do have to balance
certainly some of the negativity and some of the shootings that have happened.
How they do that is up to Homan and is up to Trump. That is certainly something that they
have to be aware of and be careful with more and more and more as the midterms come up.
Yeah. The media and communications dimension of this is really interesting to me, I have to say,
and I hate to talk in cold-blooded terms about legal law enforcement and also deaths,
which are always tragedies even when they occur in the course of, even if and when these turn out
to be part of, if there was legitimate resisting of arrest going on or whatever. I guess what I'm
saying about that is I personally don't know, I don't think we know yet the details of these
particular events with enough clarity to speak about them specifically. I do think that some of
these killings that have been obviously much reported upon have been very bad and have looked
very bad as well, but you put it in very important context, Mike. You raise a bunch of information
which you won't find in CNN, for example, including that overall the president's agenda is
getting carried out and that that agenda broadly reflects, I think, what people want and are
looking for, and that even some of these stops that we're talking about now might fall under
that heading, even though there are also ones which I think are ugly and bad.
None of that is going to get communicated across mainstream media channels. I think we can just
say, of course, we know this. We know that the press is going to jump instantaneously on anything
that looks ugly and involves grieving mothers and so on and so forth and hold as many of us
as possible emotional hostage to these images, which again, I'm not saying these images aren't
disturbing. I'm not saying that some of these stories aren't disturbing. I'm just saying that
we also know that they're going to be highlighted and pinpointed while everything else that you've
read from ICE's own self-reporting is going to be downplayed or contradicted in the press.
The question for me is, how much does that matter? Because we are living through a period in which
outlets like CNN and The New York Times are hemorrhaging public trust and places like X
are becoming sources of information for people, for good or ill, sometimes for both.
The question is, at least on my mind, does Trump just press ahead with this and say,
look, the overall picture, the overall reality here is that I'm doing what I was elected to do.
Yes, there have been some blunders along the way. Yes, the scale of this enterprise is such that
there are going to be really awful encounters between law enforcement and criminals or even
just the public. Nevertheless, I persist. Or is that a bridge too far even for Americans who
support him? Because Americans don't like these breaches of civil liberty even just a little bit.
You can't just have a little bit as a treat, if you see what I mean. You can't just have a few
accidental killings as a treat. That ain't going to fly. On top of which, he may be factoring in
exactly as you said, the midterms, they're not a wash. We should care about them very much. Some of
these DSA characters that are running are really bad mojo. They're really bad people and they're
bad for the country. We shouldn't just give it up, but we should acknowledge that the incumbent
always has a rough time of it in the midterms. That shouldn't stop Trump from trying to do what,
again, at the headline, I'm agreeing with you, Mike, about this. At the headline,
this is basically what the public wants. I do think that there remains this kink,
and I've talked about this before, that what the public wants and what Trump is excited about and
what Trump's inner circle is excited about aren't quite the same thing, even though they overlap in
this very big, important Venn diagram. People do want a total reversal of the Biden-era policy.
They do want criminals and dangerous people out of the country. I think it's not only the New York
Times' dishonesty that causes them to recoil and balk from more of that. I don't know that they
side for a second mistaken or wrongful killings, which would be in a separate category altogether
that I think we would all agree shouldn't happen. That's bad. But even just dialing back a little
bit and asking about the guy that is working at Home Depot or something, going in every day,
has a family and kids, but is here illegally. I don't even think people want to see that guy
surveilled in his car and dragged out of his home. Again, you pointed out that these people,
which we began by talking about, are not that guy, or at least some of them don't seem to be.
But what do you do with that guy is, I think, just a very charged and difficult question for
Trump in this big, messy middle between the easy, low-hanging fruit, the obvious
mistakes that you want to curtail. In the middle, there's stuff that Trump and his base and his
supporters and even many listeners of this podcast may want that the public may not want
overall, or at least may not like to be confronted with as a thing in progress.
I'm not really asking any particular question here, Mike. I'm just sorting through my feelings
in a real-time therapy session with you and asking what is your response, if anything.
No, I think those are all important considerations to think about. Again,
especially in our visual world, in our world where, I think, as you rightly say, this is not
just a left, liberal, mainstream media thing. Republicans, people who generally think even
agree with what Trump is doing can think, okay, that's too far. I don't want to see that. That's
more than a mistake. I mean, that's a huge error. But I think we do need to step back and just
think about, look, why does this need to happen in the first place? Because presidential administration
after presidential administration did not do their job on a key promise.
Yes, you're totally right about this.
Under Article 2. This is a thing where, look, I mean, if you're a nation, you have borders,
you have sovereignty, you need to protect those things. So I think that's the first thing we need
to remember. Trump is doing the hard things that I think are necessary. And again, I'm not saying
every single aspect of that has been done with a plumb, but so be it. He has been put in a very,
very difficult situation. And to his credit, he is trying to do something about it. He is trying
to act on it. So I think that is something we need to remember in all of this too.
And I would say with these particulars, I mean, I am no expert on ICE training,
on what the officers are getting, on what Tom Homan is instructing them on, any of this.
I would say though, DHS, Mark Wayne Mullen, Homan, I think they should just sit back and again and
possibly in private, just re-evaluate these things, figure out, okay, is this prudentially
speaking a smart thing to do right now given the media coverage? Not only that, are there
actually any problems with the training? Are there problems with officers they're getting in?
Do they need to change requirements? Any of those things. And I think all of this can happen at the
same time, but I think again, setting it in, kind of looking at it from the 30,000 foot level and
just seeing this is what Trump was handed to him. Not only in 2024, obviously you had the Biden
surge, but 2016 and everything that came before that presidential administration after presidential
administration that did not take this seriously. So I think that just, all these things need to be
remembered and I think that first and foremost. Thank you, Mike. You're a very helpful political
therapist. I feel a lot like I have a lot more clarity on this now. Yeah. You know, everything
that you've just said is important and it is meaningfully nuanced. So the context is still
something that is so easy to forget. So easy to forget how hellacious the Biden years were. It's
so easy to forget how badly, as you say, both parties have fallen down on the job here. How
this thing was allowed to metastasize into an existential threat to American sovereignty,
which ties it in nicely with the things we were just describing before. And in that way,
Trump's mandate on immigration is in fact meaningfully connected to Rubio's statements
about the ICC and that both of them have to do with reasserting the fundamental premise,
which should be the first thing before we get to anything else. The fundamental premise that
Americans run America and we have borders, right? We're a country. These are things that Trump
very much was elected by a broad based coalition of people who want to reassert that, who think
that the other stuff that's been substituted in place of those points of view is all completely
cuckoo bananas, cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs. And they're right. America is America, is run by
Americans, needs borders. And since that has been so grievously forgotten, neglected, even denied
by a variety of different administrations, we would do well to recall that it's not as if
the situation before was victimless or good. It was in fact existentially threatening.
So now you've got this case where things have been going badly for a long, long time.
You've got Trump in the mix who has always been kind of a loose cannon and he's responding to
people's legitimate and intense frustrations with the situation. And in the immediate term,
it made sense for him to move with great alacrity to show that he was delivering on this key issue.
This was one of his strongest assets, I think, and one of his best issues across the board,
even from the jump from his first term onward and from his first campaign onwards.
Now, the situation is slightly different, not because that context that you've just
outlined has changed, but because very, very quickly the American people have forgotten.
And it's analogous in this way to COVID, that we forgot how bad things got. And now we're
just back to kind of complaining, complaining about things and feeling anxieties, which is
our natural state, it seems. But that does mean, and I haven't thought about it from quite this
perspective until you put it this way, Mike, it does mean that Tom Homan has a bit of leeway
to step back and ask, can we do this better? Can we train our guys better? Can we take
more care with our hiring process? Does it not just have to be the South Park joke about,
come join ICE if you got rejected from your local Dairy Queen? I'm obviously being flippant here,
but it would be one thing if Trump were being pressed to deliver with as much alacrity as
possible, results, results, results. But actually that's not the thing that politically the public
is demanding. And therefore Trump can both deliver on his agenda and set himself up well,
one hopes, for the next two years to continue to do the good work that he's been doing before all
while also not rushing headlong into execution on this that leads him into genuinely bad mistakes,
including, I think, the constant hiring of people right out the bat, these quotas that lead to,
I think, over hasty action in areas that genuinely are sensitive and do involve,
we should always recall, like actual human lives that are not just about political points or
they're about people, both on the side of the officers and on the side of the people that are
being policed. It's not just about the mistaken traffic stop here and there or whatever. It's
also about the guys that are being put in these positions and sometimes being set up to have their
lives ruined by not being trained effectively and so on and so forth. I feel like I have a lot more
clarity about this now, thanks mostly to Mike. We hope our listeners do as well. I can now
recommend real-time recorded podcast therapy sessions, which is perhaps not something that
I would otherwise have been willing to do. But since this has all been a bit heavy and
philosophical and also political, let's talk about the movies. This is something we don't
always do on this podcast, but every now and then when it has a political valence, as it
currently does, we like to check in on the culture. Mike and I, as it happens, have both
seen movies. Each one of us has seen a major movie of the summer that the other has not seen,
and I thought we could just review with one another what these movies are and also how they
have affected the political landscape, because both of them have a major valence when it comes to
how people are thinking about American culture more generally and this very
politically charged summer of movies that we've had.
So Mike, you saw Young Washington, which I had a chance to see and I missed my shot and I feel
bad about it because I really want to see it and I'm going to see it and I'm getting
a lot of great reviews. This is Angel Studios, if I'm correct about that, the guys that did
The Chosen most famously and have done a bunch of other content in this vein. It's what it says on
the box. It's a movie about Washington when he was young, before he was George Washington,
the indelible character whom we all know or think we know, I guess, from our history books.
There's something untouchable about Washington in his fully mature developed form. He is
a larger than life figure and he seems to have been that way in reality. So it's not like you
can get under the skin and be like, well, we talk about honest George Washington who could not tell
a lie, but when you really peel back the curtain, there's all kinds of juicy scandal and nastiness
that nobody knows about. It's like, no, he really was a hyper-virtuous dude.
So this movie, I think, takes an interesting approach, which deals with him when he's
not yet full-fledged and he's contending with a lot of his insecurities. It's primarily about
the French and Indian War when he was an officer in the British army and that was doubly complicated
by the fact that his birth was not of the highest. This was true also relative to the
other founding fathers as he was not the most well-educated or erudite or well-born of them.
He had a slightly checkered family background. But tell me, Mike, what you thought of the movie.
Just straight up, thumbs up, thumbs down. Was it any good? And then also, how do you think it is
landing or going to land in this semi-quincentennial moment that we're all in to do justice to
Washington and will people like it? So I think this is a movie for America 250. I liked it
overall. I enjoyed it, especially for, I think, a budget of about $20 million. It was impressively
done, I thought. The acting was good across the board. I mean, they got some serious actors in
this movie. Ben Kingsley played the, I think, Lieutenant Governor Robert Dinwiddie of Virginia.
So that's the man who signs George Washington, the young George Washington, into the Virginia
militia where he's assigned to the Ohio country. And basically, like you said, starts what then
ends up being the French and Indian War. He goes out there surveying, discovers, oh, the French
actually have a fort out here all built up, goes back to the governor, tells him. He takes the
battle ensues where Washington and his men built Fort Necessity. That goes very poorly for
Washington. He gets beat just because he sees that the French are not abiding by the old style of
fighting in the old world, lining up in the columns. They're doing what I think the Indians
in that territory have told them to do and have taught them to do, which is a lot more skirmishes
coming out of trees, that kind of thing, really using the natural territory and the natural
geography to their advantage. And Washington learns. He actually comes back after this huge
defeat, becomes actually the aide-de-camp to British General Edward Braddock, and he joins
the Braddock expedition to go back out to retake Fort Duquesne. So that's about where I think the
city of Pittsburgh is now. And then the end is great. There's another huge battle. The British
get ambushed. And then Washington, who actually is fighting ill, he felt ill with dysentery,
he recovers himself enough to get his Virginia militia, his men, going back out there to rescue
them. And it's an amazing sequence to an end that shows Washington's rise and his ascendancy and
the kind of character that he had. And as you point out, the beginning of the movie, it does
talk about how he kind of rose from... he didn't have much education, but he was really kind of a
self-made man. The Indispensable Man, as one of his great biographers wrote about him, and that
was the word that he used. So it's a great story, especially for Americans. Biography is such an
important thing. Histories can be great, but biographies of great men just going back to
Plutarch's lives. This is something that has been the education of citizens and of statesmen for a
long, long, long time now. So I think this is another good entry. There's rumors of actually
a sequel happening, 1776, that may be coming out in a year or two. We'll see. Hopefully they do
this. But there is just so much potential for this kind of story about American history, about the
revolutionary era and beyond, to really capture the story of America, just in all its aspects,
and to carry that on in future generations. So I really hope they do that. And I think they set
the stage well to have movie after movie going forward, obviously. Hopefully it doesn't become
some kind of tired franchise like the Avengers series and what that turned into. But I think
if they keep that same formula, I think things will go very, very well. The founding fathers,
Age of Ultron. It hadn't even occurred to me. But there's so much material there.
I love hearing this. Like I said, I kind of missed my shot at seeing this movie,
and now I don't know when I'm going to get to it because, as we'll discuss in just a moment,
it's all Odyssey all the time for me, for the foreseeable. But I am going to see it,
and I'm really excited to see it. Especially because Angel Studios, this was true of The
Chosen as well. We've had a lot, and this is an old story that we don't need to really rehearse
at length. But there's been obviously a bunch of conservative discontent with
mainstream media, and especially with Hollywood and with creative content.
And there have been, therefore, a lot of efforts to create alternative media that do conservative
themes or have the same attitude toward America and her founding principles that the majority of
the public have, which are like, they're good. We like them. We like America. We like praying.
We like families. All that stuff that most people think, and they go to the theater every day and
they get told, no, you're stupid for thinking that. Wouldn't it be great if there were awesome
movies that people could see that didn't tell them that, that actually lifted up the best
of this country? And The Founding Fathers are a great place to start with that.
But there's also a danger, and it's a danger that's afflicted a lot of so-called right-wing
art, and we've written about it in The American Mind and elsewhere. There's a danger of making
this into a consolation prize and looking like the junior varsity team. And there's a lot of
conservative art that gets made that is like, okay, it's not really because you're being
persecuted for your beliefs that nobody would make this movie. It's because this is not such
a great movie. And Angel Studios has always avoided that. They've always had really high
production values and creative, interesting takes on stuff that would otherwise pose a
challenge. I mean, look, they did one about Jesus, so they're obviously not afraid of
dealing with subjects that people have reverence for. And when you talk about subjects and make
art about subjects that people have reverence for, you take risks. Because if you're going to
portray the full humanity of these situations and you're going to make true art about it,
you also have to show weakness, you have to show things that maybe offend people,
you have to branch out. And people have made this critique of The Chosen as well.
But I just think Angel Studios does it really beautifully, and they do it with a lot of respect
and a lot of honor toward the Founding Fathers, or certainly toward the religious material that
they do. But they also, as you say, they get top talent and they make glossy productions.
So yeah, I would think it would be really cool if we could do this, because we do have these
incredible... I mean, they are kind of like superheroes, and they are our superheroes,
the Founding Fathers. And finding a way to portray them in a gritty, realistic way,
while also living up to their stature, would be amazing. So I actually would rather see
the Founding Fathers' Age of Ultron than Avengers' Age of Ultron, since those guys
weren't even real. They don't even shoot those lasers out of their arms in reality.
Do you know that's not a real thing? Anyway, we have to close pretty soon here,
so I will just very, very briefly give my note on The Odyssey, Christopher Nolan's
blockbuster epic. This is, I think it's fair to say, the anticipated movie of the summer,
not just because it's Christopher Nolan, he of Batman Begins, and did the Tenet,
or was it an Inception? I mean, Interstellar, I could go on and on. He's kind of our Steven
Spielberg for this era, right? He makes the big summer blockbusters. He does it in these
massive ways that I always kind of associate with, like, these big synth sounds going like,
wah, you know, he has a sense of huge scale. And so when it was announced that he was going to
produce an Odyssey a while back, I think it might have been 2024 that he said he was taking this on,
nerds like me, and I would say specifically this nerd, as in me, got really, really excited,
just so stoked, because The Odyssey and Homer generally is a huge, it's huge material, of
course. It's epic, literally. And it often gets made in this kind of deflationary modernist way
that tamps down the myth and the legend and the excitement. And I just thought, okay, Nolan,
whatever else Nolan may do, he's not going to do that. This is not a guy that shies away from big,
dramatic stories, or from science fiction, or hopefully from fantasy as well. The Odyssey is,
among other things, a fantasy story. So then some stuff happened in between then and now. Nolan
started announcing all of these, you know, casting choices, and trailers came out, and stuff went
through the woodwork that got the idea into people's head that this was going to be a woke
Odyssey. There was the fact that Lupita Nyong'o, a wonderful actress, but a black woman, was going
to play Helen of Troy, who's a Greek person. And of course, we know that this kind of racial
recasting only ever goes in one direction, and people are kind of fed up with it, that all
these white or off-white people are always made darker, but no black characters are allowed to
be played by white actors. People got mad at that. They got mad about Elliot Page, formerly Ellen
Page, that is the trans actor playing, it turns out to be Sinon, or as I think they weirdly say
in the movie, Sinon, turns out to be this Greek hero who deceives the Trojans about the horse.
There's that part of it, there's the part of it that, you know, in the trailer we see,
and this is true of the movie, they use this very kind of lowbrow, deflated language, whereas Homer,
of course, writes in this beautiful archaic Greek. They couldn't do that in the movie,
but they could have used, you know, some of the original dialogue. So people got
really set on the idea before seeing this movie that it was going to be a woke disaster,
and declared, including like Elon Musk declared, this is a desecration of Homer,
which put little old me in a kind of funny position, because I am not averse to saying
that this is a bad movie, and I hope that my bona fides as an anti-woke lover of the
classics, scholar of the classics, are well established at this point. I've spent probably
more ink than anybody alive deflating and attacking people who use their stupid agenda
to destroy the greatest works of literature and civilization that we have to offer.
And I believe this is just a travesty when people like Emily Wilson, or Donna Zuckerberg,
or Curtis Dozier, or Don El Padilla Peralta, or any of these other people that I could name,
when they take these treasures, which are ours, which belong to all of us, which are some of the
ennobling and enriching products of the human soul, but also bomb for the human soul that is
available, and they deprive us of them by distorting them, by giving their stupid,
whiny interpretations of them, by chiding and censuring them with their arrogant,
modern points of view. All of that disgusts me, and I think this is obvious and clear.
But as I said on this podcast, nobody had seen the movie. And I'm just not quite ready. I wasn't
quite ready to judge the movie before I saw it. I don't know if that's crazy, it makes me a woke
lib or whatever, but it turns out people got really, really mad. People get really mad when
you say, like, let's just see, because Christopher Nolan deserves the benefit of the doubt. He's not
actually a ferocious wokester. I got to see a press screening of the movie, and as of just
recently, this is kind of straight from the horse's mouth, because I'm just now allowed to talk about
what I think of it, and it gives me great pleasure to report that I was right. This is a good movie.
This is not a woke takeover. The parts of it that people have gotten so crazed about are really very,
very minor. Some of them work, some of them don't. It's not a perfect movie. It's obviously not as
good as Homer, and if that causes you trouble, you know what you should do? You should go read
Homer, because he's really great. But I think people, and I totally sympathize, I think people
were really tired and worried that this was going to be yet another assault on something that we
really do cherish and hold dear, and that is the Homeric poems. Even if you don't have that close
relationship to them, people know that these are wellsprings of our civilization. They don't want
to see them desecrated. I just want to say, if that's you and if you're feeling that way, I
totally hear you. I had that worry as well. Put your mind at ease. Go see this movie. This is a
really good movie. Again, there are things that Nolan changes that I don't agree with. There are
things that he leaves out that I don't like. The lowbrow language does not, in fact, work for me,
but the spectacle of it, the scale, and above all, the love, the respect, the care for the
source material is 100% there. This is the Odyssey on screen. This is not the woke Odyssey.
If you're on the fence and if you're having doubts, I just don't let the online kerfuffle
stop you from going or from judging it in advance. Go see it. If you love it,
read the Odyssey. If you hate it, you know what you can do? Read the Odyssey.
The one thing that I hope comes out of this movie above all else is that people are inspired to go
and read Homer. Here are my translation recommendations, just real quick off the
bat and then we have to close. Robert Fagles is a fabulous translator of Homer, both the Iliad and
Odyssey, and you can hear his version read aloud if you go on Audible by none other than Ian
McKellen. Ian McKellen, Magneto himself, Gandalf himself, and a fabulous Shakespearean actor who
does a beautiful rendition. A new version by Daniel Mendelssohn is also really, really worth
reading. So is the Richmond Lattimore translation, which I cut my teeth on as a boy. There's
Fitzgerald. All of these are worthwhile. I would say first and foremost, go to the Fagles with
Mendelssohn and listen to McKellen reading it. Do that whether you love, hate, or feel
indifferent toward Christopher Nolan's Odyssey, but go see that too. All right, we got to stop.
This has been a blast as always. Mike, I always really enjoy doing these one-on-one with you.
These are so fun. Thank you for joining me. Thanks to all of you for listening. If you want
to know more about the stuff that we do, you should go to AmericanMind.org. You should go to
ClaremontReviewBooks.com, where there is a relatively new issue of the CRB awaiting you
with lots of juicy stuff in it. You should check out our DC-based Center for the American Way of
Life at dc.claremont.org. You should go to our Substack at claremontinstitute.substack.com,
where you can become a Digital Plus subscriber. There's lots of worthwhile stuff. There's extra
paid episodes of this show and the Close Read, our other podcast. There's the opportunity to
see Nolan's Odyssey. If you think I'm totally wrong and it is a woke desecration, you can yell
at me there. That's where you can yell at me. I won't listen to you if you yell at me on Twitter.
I just won't. But if you yell at me on our paid Substack, I will actually pay attention to you.
So if that floats your boat, go become a paid subscriber. And I think that's it. We will be
back later on next week. Thanks very much to our production and engineering one-man crew,
the Brother G, Ryan Gannon, and thanks to you all for listening. We will talk to you next week.