What REALLY Happens When You Correct Your Dog...

Dog Training
13 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 15, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker debunks the common myth that correcting a reactive dog causes the animal to associate the trigger (e.g., another dog or person) with the punishment. He argues that proper conditioning ensures the dog associates the correction with its own inappropriate behavior, not the trigger itself, allowing for effective behavior modification.
All right, guys, I'm sick of dog owners getting false information and frankly just lied to,
and it's at the risk and expense of their beloved dogs. And so I'm going to just go over one of the
big myths I see out there on the internet and go and break down exactly why it is that.
And we need to call it out because it's important for dog owners specifically who are looking for
advice to understand and be educated on what some of this stuff means. Cause it's, it's a very
common misconception. And I, and I, and I think if you, I don't know, so let's dive into it.
So the idea that if you correct a dog for a particular thing, typically due to a trigger
entering the environment. So let's say you're in, um, you're in a room and another dog or another
person walks in and your dog reacts, or you go out for a walk. I think this is more common.
You go out for a walk, your dog reacts, and then you have this idea, like, what do I do in this
situation? My dog is reacting to this other dog or this other person or whatever it is, bicycles,
cars, wheelchairs, skateboards, whatever your dog is reacting to. One thing I hear from dog owners,
because they go in the internet and they look things up and they say, what do I do if my dog
reacts to X, whatever that is. Right. And typically what I hear from owners is they say, well, I read,
I heard that you shouldn't correct a dog for reacting to a particular trigger because it's
going to make them fearful of that thing. I'm going to show you guys an example, exactly an
exact example of why this isn't true. And, but before I get into that, I'm going to go over
why it's not true. This isn't a subjective thing. This is a objective sequence. Objectively,
like I've done it hundreds of times. I'm going to show you a video of this happening.
This is not like, Oh, well, Tom kind of trains is, you know, whatever it's like, well, no,
I'm telling you it's not real. Like that ideology is not real. So for an example,
a dog, a dog who enters your environment or whatever that trigger is. And the dog goes,
Hey, I need to react now why they're reacting does play a role in this, but it's another topic for
another day. But the dog reacts and freaks out. Ah, shoot. Dang. I'm excited. I'm pissed. I'm
angry. I'm upset. I'm scared, whatever the dog's freaking out. Now we add a correction to that,
to disrupt the behavior, to stop the behavior, to discourage the behavior, right? So we leash pop,
we yell, we whatever you want to do. That's that's again, that is subjective for sure.
However, you want to correct your dog. Like we have to teach them, wow, this sucks.
My dog's breaking their neck and their back and this is stressful and it's dangerous. And it's
all the things like, you know, all the things start to build up where you're like, I hate this.
You know? And so does your dog. And so it is the trigger who's getting barked at by your dog. I
can assure you it's a lose, lose, lose, lose, lose three or four L's across the board. Nobody wins.
It sucks. It's stressful, bad. Okay. So we correct the dog when they do that action.
Now let's use our critical thinking skills here, people. Let's say, and for those of you listening,
I have my phone in my hand. Let's say this is the trigger. And then this pen, which is near the
trigger is the dog. Okay. So the phone goes out of picture. All of a sudden the phone comes into
picture. The dog reacts to the phone coming in, bark, bark, bark, bark, bark, bark, bark, bark,
bark. Now the handler, me, you, any other trainer, any person that can think critically here will
discourage the behavior of barking. Stop doing the barking. The barking sucks. The barking is
dangerous and wildly inappropriate and stressful and on and on and on and on and on. Okay.
So now the dog stops the barking, but the trigger is still standing right here.
So the people who say, well, if you correct the dog, and if you're watching this, you can see
the pen, which represents the dog. If you correct the dog for the trigger entering the situation
and the dog is going to think that, oh, well, when the trigger comes in, we get corrected. No,
incorrect. It's when the behavior that we don't like happens is when we get corrected,
but that sink in for a minute. So the trigger enters the mix. The dog reacts.
We correct the dog for reacting. The dog stops reacting and the trigger is still standing right
in front of the dog. Not the dog is not getting corrected. The dog is not getting any type of
punishment. The dog is getting affection and praise and food when the dog is standing in front
of the trigger without barking. So again, trigger comes in dog barks. We correct the barking. The
dog stops barking. The trigger is still right here at no point in time. If you know anything
about dog training, sorry, I had to say it that way or conditioning in general,
will this dog associate the punishment, the correction, the adverse, the stress
with the trigger. It should only be associated with the behavior we didn't like that causes
all the stress, anxiety, and danger. Okay. So I just, I hear that often and I just want it to
make sense. Why would anybody say that? I don't know. Because if you understand conditioning,
it's the same exact thing as positive reinforcement. If we take food or reward the
dog likes or wants and is expecting and we walk out and the dog knows we have the food and I say
sit and the dog puts their butt on the ground and then they get paid. The dog knows the behavior
that they did ultimately unlocks the food. So the thing that they did gets them what they want.
Same exact thing in the other end of the spectrum. The thing that they did gets the pressure,
the correction, and the discouragement and the disruption. So if I walk down the road,
that doesn't mean my dog gets a piece of food a hundred, you know, just for being on the road.
Excuse me. My dog only gets a piece of food when they do something. I ask
whatever comes out of my mouth. And so that is a huge misconception and a absolute bold lie
that dog owners get told all the time. You should never correct your dog.
If they're reactive to other people or other dogs, because it's going to make them
associate that person or that dog with a correction. That would be,
I don't even know how you would do that. Honestly, I'm trying to think, hold on.
I think the only way you would really be able to do that, if you were so bad at dog training,
that you walked into a room, your dog saw another dog, you corrected them and ran out of the room.
And I don't know anybody that would actually do that. The idea, and I'm going to show you in this
video. So this isn't, so you might be watching this going, Oh, Tom, I disagree. I'm going to
show you in this video, exactly me doing this in real time, evidence based theories and built off
of real dog training and evidence right here. So what you're going to see, we're going to play it.
Leave it. I did not think he was going to react to that.
Okay. Let me see. So you were just too late there. Okay. Leave it easy there, Mr. So leave it.
So see how that doesn't matter to him.
Let me see the collar real quick. So listen, when, when he starts to go, I need to kill this
dog, I think for no reason, because it's not even, it's the most, listen, that's the most
neutral animal you could ever get. It's literally not, not real. And when he's throwing up hands to
the dead dog, that's a problem, right? So, so you're going to be in really rough shape once you
see a real dog, right? So we're using the pager, leave it. Good. See that? That's what you're
looking for. Good. Leave it. Good. Leave it. He doesn't like it. That's the point. Okay. So the
goal is just like when he hears that jerky snap open, he's like, I want that. I know what that
is. Dogs are very conditioned animals. They know that equals yummy stuff. Okay. Sit good down.
Good. When we say, leave it. And he says this pager. So next time we say leave it, he's like
done. We're done. So one second. Now our job is to also teach him that dog didn't do that whole
vibration thing. You did that vibration thing. Right. And right now he's kind of like, I think
the dog did that. And this is totally normal for him to go. I don't, right now he's avoiding
the dog, which to some people, they would be like, God bless. I, yes, please order more. I don't,
there's dog is so reactive to every dog that they are like, I don't, I'm totally okay with
this avoidance right now. He's, he's conflicted about what just happened. My job is to say dogs
right here. You're getting paid dogs right here. You're getting paid dogs right here.
You're getting paid the moment he goes, that's when it turns on and he'll go, Oh, okay. Right
now he's like, what the hell? Okay. So that's the goal here. Good boy. Sit. Yes. Good boy.
Good job. Yeah. It's a good boy. Nice work, buddy. Good boy. Much better. He looks back at
me. He's going to get paid. Yeah. Good. So that whole react, rat reactive stuff is what turns
that vibration on. And that's what we want to clearly explain to him. I correct the dog
with a pager, which is a vibration. The moment the dog stops barking. Now,
mind you, you guys see in this video, this dog is reactive so bad that he jumps up in the air
and smashes his own skull off the ground. Okay. That's how bad this dog is reacting.
And so when I turn the vibrate on, which is the same thing as your iPhone going off,
it's discouraging and correcting the dog for that reaction that nobody wants. And that the
owner's paid a lot of money to try to figure out how do we decrease or delete. And so you see the
dog get corrected. It discourages the dog. The same thing that the dog was reactive to
the dog is now sniffing, getting near and getting paid. So that theory and that lie and that myth
is not true. And if anybody needs clarification, send them this podcast or this video,
because unless you're doing things terribly wrong, which happens, there's no, there's no way the dog
is going to associate the trigger with the punishment or the correction. It should only be
the behavior. So the dog understands, Oh, it's the freaking out on the leash and breaking my own
skull. That gets me corrected. Not the other dog. Of course. So guys, that's it. I mean,
that's it. I can't express to you how many people have been lied to with that dog owners coming to
me saying, Oh, I can't correct my dog. I, you know, they, so the sequence kind of goes like
this. They come in, they go, Hey, my dog is super reactive. We're going to have to put my dog down.
I have to kill my dog. If this doesn't work, I say, all right, well, we need to correct the dog
for the behavior first. Oh, we can't do that because there's going to be stressed involved.
And I don't want to stress the dog out. What do you mean? Well, I read and I was told by another
trainer that correcting the dog for this behavior is going to make the dog associate. The other dog
is a terrible thing. I'm like, first of all, that's already happening. That's called leash
reactivity. So we don't have to worry about that getting worse or that becoming, because that's
why you're here. Okay. Second of all, if we understand anything about conditioning, about,
about training at no point in time, should the dog think that the punishment is happening?
Cause the triggers around it should be because the dog is reacting like an absolute dangerous fool.
Mic drop. That's it. It's really that simple. And I'm just, it hurts me to see dog owners lied to
and be scammed out of their money from people who do stuff like that. It's not true.
So on the video, I laid it out black and white. Here's some evidence. Bingo. We had a dog
doing super dangerous, stressful stuff to the point where the dog owners couldn't even walk
the dog. I corrected the dog. And four minutes later, the dog is sniffing the trigger,
not associating the correction with that dog and deleting and boxing out the huge reactivity of the
dangerous. This on the leash guys, if this was helpful, make sure you leave a comment,
leave a like, if you're watching this on Spotify or listening to this in any other podcast platform,
make sure you subscribe to it and follow our podcast. We put videos out like this
multiple times a week, plus guests, doctors, veterinarians, specialists, neurologists,
et cetera. Thank you guys. See you in the next one.
