Sabrina Carpenter Is NOT Who You Think She Is...

Sabrina Carpenter
10 followers
7 Video Views·Jul 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video provides a critical analysis of Sabrina Carpenter's public persona, questioning whether her \"hyper-feminine\" branding represents genuine female empowerment or a calculated appeal to the male gaze. The creator argues that Carpenter utilizes an infantilized aesthetic to blur the lines between girlhood and adulthood, ultimately reinforcing patriarchal standards under the guise of feminism.
There is something very strange happening with Sabrina Carpenter.
And I don't mean strange in the normal pop star way,
like she didn't go and shave her head or suddenly join a cult.
Although, fun fact, her aunt is actually a full-blown Scientologist.
She also happens to be the voice of Bart Simpson.
But that's irrelevant.
The strange thing about Sabrina Carpenter is that
no one can actually work out who she's for.
Hot take, I know that Sabrina Carpenter has said that everything that she does
in her music is for the girls and the gays,
but I personally just don't think that's true.
Sabrina Carpenter is not male-centered.
Her music is for women.
When she takes it off, shows a new color, new shade, that's for women.
I said on this app a while ago that Sabrina Carpenter is like
Red Pill content for women.
The Sidney Sweeney of pop music, if you will.
You can't tell me that Sabrina's VMA performance was male-centered in any way.
You can't tell me that she's not a feminist because she expresses sexuality.
That woman is a whole ass weirdo and her entire brand is to be a weirdo.
And no amount of rampant and overfunded bot campaigns
will ever change my mind on that.
I keep seeing the same argument online over and over again
and nobody can seem to agree on what the answer actually is.
Is this the male gaze dressed up and sold back to us as empowerment?
Or is this genuinely just for the girls and everyone criticizing it just doesn't get it?
Because on paper, this should be a pretty easy question.
I mean, just look at her recent album cover.
Her on all fours in a little black dress with a man holding her by her hair.
If you'd had to guess who this image was built for, you would say men, obviously.
And the craziest part is, is that it's not just this cover.
It's her entire style and the way she presents herself, which is insanely controversial.
But we will talk about that later in this video, okay?
The point is, you'd think she's selling the male fantasy, right?
Except a lot of straight guys genuinely couldn't care less about her.
Like genuinely weirdly uninterested.
Meanwhile, teenage girls are calling her music peak girlhood.
Women are the ones defending her the loudest online
and articles are calling her the feminist icon we never knew we needed.
So which one is it?
I know I'm late to this discourse and everyone has already talked about this over a year ago,
but I feel like nobody actually came to a conclusion.
And since then, things have just gotten so much more concerning
and that is exactly why I wanted to make this video.
Not because I want to drag up a year-old controversy that everyone already yelled about,
but because I think everyone yelled about the easiest part,
moved on, and ignored the deeper thing going on underneath it.
Because everyone keeps acting like there's only two answers to this.
She's either for the girls or she's for the male gaze.
And as someone who's not a Sabrina Carpenter superfan,
I thought the answer was going to be obvious.
But after looking into the rebrand, the performances, the lyrics,
the aesthetic, and the way people defend her, I don't think either answer is enough.
I think something much stranger is happening here and we need to talk about it.
Before I start, I really want to make it clear that this video isn't necessarily about
Sabrina Carpenter herself and policing what she does with her image.
It's more about the way that people as a collective, especially young girls, view that image.
So please, if you're a fan and you're gonna leave a hate comment,
please just listen to this video with an open mind, okay?
That's all I ask.
Okay, so before we talk about the album cover that made everyone lose their minds,
I think we need to talk about her overall image.
And the best way to do that is to go back right to the start.
And I don't just mean go back to 2023 when she released Espresso and became a worldwide hit.
No, I mean go back all the way to the start
when she first came into the public eye.
You see, what many people might not know is that she actually started her career
over a decade ago on the Disney Channel show Girl Meets World.
This is how I first knew her as Maya, the quirky best friend.
But it's important to know that Disney around 2014 wasn't like Disney in the 2000s
where you'd star on a show and all of a sudden your career would take off.
No, there was no wrecking ball swinging for her, okay?
This is really when the Disney Channel hype was fizzling out.
Sabrina did get a little bit of fame from the show
and starred in movies like The Hate U Give and Tall Girl,
but nothing really catapulted her career.
Plus, it was clear that acting wasn't really her main focus at the time.
What she wanted to do was music.
So from 2015, she began releasing back-to-back albums
which included very different types of songs from what we know her as today.
There were songs about her mental health struggles, teenage struggles, her dad.
She even wrote a song about a lawsuit she was going through.
But unfortunately, none of them really ended up being commercially successful.
But what I really want to focus on is her image during these eras.
It's hard to describe her exact style because it's not your typical girl next door.
It's more like cool sister type of vibes, if that makes sense.
She would wear streetwear-inspired clothes and had an overall more grungy look.
And that lasted all the way to the year 2021
when even her concerts at the time had that grunge edge to them.
This was also the first year when she started getting a little bit of mainstream popularity,
but unfortunately, it wasn't for very good reasons.
Long story short, a 17-year-old Olivia Rodrigo
released her breakout single called Driver's License
which was about her ex, Joshua Bassett, leaving her for a 20-year-old Sabrina Carpenter.
In the song, Olivia didn't say anything bad about Sabrina.
In fact, what she said was that Sabrina is everything she's insecure about.
And also at first, no one actually knew if the song was about Sabrina.
It was just speculation based on pitches.
Well, that was until a few weeks later when Sabrina released a song called Skin
where she's essentially just bragging about the fact she stole this teenager's man.
It's safe to say that the public quite literally despised her existence
and how are you supposed to make a music career after that?
This obviously made her very, very sad.
But honestly, not as sad as I will be if you don't subscribe to my channel right now.
I'm so sorry, that was such a bad joke.
But um, yeah, please subscribe.
It would honestly make my day.
Anyway, so what did we learn from the Ariana Grande video
when an artist has way too much controversy around them?
When a persona isn't working, you just rebrand.
Sabrina's entire image transformed into this hyper feminine vintage babydoll aesthetic.
Think 1960s girly vibes with tiny babydoll dresses, laces, bows and big blonde curls.
It all feels incredibly youthful and playful.
Now on the surface, there is nothing inherently controversial about this image.
Plenty of women wear bows and cute dresses.
However, the difference with Sabrina is what she does whilst wearing them.
Sabrina has become one of the most sexual pop stars in mainstream music today.
Her songs are filled to the brim with sexual innuendos and references to sex.
And it's not just something she occasionally sings about.
No, it is her entire brand.
And as you can probably guess, her tour only amplified this.
At one point, the stage cuts to nothing but Sabrina's silhouette
simulating intercourse with a man.
As well as a whole lot of other things that would probably give your nan a heart attack.
Of course, this is when people started to question her image.
And again, I want to make it so clear that it's not because she's being sexual.
Pop stars have always been sexual.
It was that she was doing it whilst presenting herself
as this sweet, youthful, childlike character.
And those things do not sit comfortably together.
Now, to be fair, there is a very clear defense for Sabrina here.
You could argue that she's just embracing her sexuality
and that she doesn't have control whether or not creeps take that image wrong.
And honestly, if that was all there is to it, I would agree.
But of course, it doesn't stop there.
Whether you want to admit it or not, Sabrina actively feeds into this image.
For example, you have the baby doll dresses that she wears
which a lot of people like to defend as just simply vintage fashion.
And I mean, technically, yeah, it is just a piece of clothing.
Good job for pointing that out.
But I just think that argument is so dishonest
because it's not like Sabrina saw this baby doll dress in Zara
and thought, yes, that looks cute, I'll wear it.
The whole point of this current image
is that she's trying to lead into this tiny doll-like version of femininity.
Also, let's just stop for a second and look at the history of the baby doll dress.
The baby doll dress was invented in 1942 by lingerie designer Sylvia Pedler.
Because of the fabric shortages during World War II,
they could no longer make these long nightgowns.
So they decided to shorten it.
And that is how you ended up with the baby doll dress.
But Sylvia hated the name baby doll and she never used it herself.
It only got that name in 1956 after the movie Baby Doll was released.
The movie was about a 19-year-old who acts like a child,
sleeps in a crib, sucks her thumb and goes around seducing men in her baby doll dress.
It was so controversial that it was banned in 77% of cinemas
and this was the 50s, so that's how you know it was bad.
So from the very start, it's always had this
uncomfortable combination of innocence and sexuality.
Which brings us to Courtney Love in the 90s.
Because Courtney Love is probably the most common example I've seen
when people try to defend Sabrina.
They'll say, well Courtney Love wore baby doll dresses, so what's the big deal?
But that's because Courtney used those dresses to send a message.
She'd wear these sweet little baby doll dresses,
then pair it with smeared lipstick, ripped tights, combat boots and messy hair.
It took the idea of this sweet, innocent girl and made her look disturbing on purpose.
It was supposed to make you feel uncomfortable.
That is very different from what Sabrina is doing.
She wears it because it perfectly matches her cute,
doll-like image that she's trying to sell.
That is why it's controversial and I'm sorry,
but Sabrina knows exactly the type of image that she's creating.
And no, I'm not saying that every baby doll dress is secretly evil
or that short women can't be sexual because that would be stupid.
I'm saying that I just think Sabrina Carpenter
plays into this infantilized version of femininity.
Because this goes so much further than just the outfit she wears.
The hugging soft toys, the pictures on a playground,
the constant references to how short she is.
Oh, and who can forget that one time she did a photoshoot referencing Lolita.
You know, the movie about the young girl getting groomed by the middle-aged creep?
Now, she did come out and defend this shoot,
saying that Lolita wasn't the inspiration.
So, I mean, take it as you will.
But I just think the fact that people believed this comparison is the problem.
Because that just means that her brand is close enough to that danger zone
for the accusation to feel believable.
Flash forward to the time when she did a lingerie photoshoot for Skims,
which literally looked like it was set in a teenager's bedroom.
At first, I genuinely thought,
okay, surely not.
There is no way that she is dressed up in lingerie in a teenager's bedroom.
No, that has to be a coincidence.
So, I went digging to try and find if this was just the usual vibes for Skims,
if they had all their celebrities on this type of backdrop.
And honestly, what I found genuinely shocked me.
Their usual vibe is sleek, neutral, and modern.
So, why was this the aesthetic choice for Sabrina's lingerie shoot?
And before you say I'm reaching,
Sabrina literally talked about this shoot in an interview saying,
I felt like I was a young girl again playing in my bedroom.
That is not an interpretation.
That is her own description of the shoot.
So, now we're pairing lingerie modeling with an intentionally childlike setting,
which she says herself made her feel like a young girl.
How do you justify that?
It just feels like she actively leans into this aesthetic
that purposely blurs the line between womanhood and girlhood.
But anyway, straight after this backlash,
you would think that she would, you know,
take a step back and maybe re-evaluate how she's coming across.
But no.
In fact, straight after this, she goes on SNL
where she does a sketch about middle schoolers
grinding on each other at a school disco.
I wish I was joking.
She even has fake braces on and everything.
Again, you could argue that these shoots were completely out of her control
and she didn't have a say in any of them.
And to that, I say, well, let's look at some things that were in her control.
For starters, you have the song Juno,
which she wrote after watching the iconic 2007 movie.
If you don't know the story,
Juno is a 16-year-old girl whose life got turned upside down
after an unexpected pregnancy.
And I think it's important to know that
this movie is so much more than just a quirky comedy.
The overall message carries this deep emotional weight
as she struggles to navigate this pregnancy
and deals with an older man grooming her.
So, in knowing that and knowing that Sabrina wrote this song
after watching this specific movie,
let's hear some of the lyrics.
Can't help myself, hormones are high.
Give me more than just butterflies.
If you love me right, then who knows?
I might let you make me Juno.
Why is she singing about wanting to be a pregnant teenager?
This is strange.
Not to mention that this is also the song
where she does a different you-know-what position every night on stage,
which goes insanely crazy viral online.
Doing that to a song romanticizing teenage pregnancy is...
Hello, it's insane, I have no words.
Of course, you then have her outros
that she would do to her song Nonsense.
Every night at her concert,
she would end this song with a different sexual innuendo
and it was pretty much for the sole purpose of being clipped
and having it go viral on TikTok.
And I mean, it worked.
And to be fair, some of these were genuinely funny.
They were tongue-in-cheek little ha-ha moments.
But then as the tour went on,
these outros started to cross the line.
One night she said,
Gardens by the bay, I wanna go there.
Then I'll take you somewhere that has no hair.
Another night she said,
I'm full grown but I look like a Nina.
Nina being the Spanish word for little girl.
So not only does Sabrina choose to present herself as doll-like,
but she's now explicitly comparing herself to a prepubescent child.
And when I see all of this laid out in front of me,
I can't help but ask the question,
who the hell is this for?
Who is the target audience?
Historically, the answer to that question has not been girls.
It's been men.
Specifically the kind of men that this image has always been made for.
The type of men who want their woman to look innocent enough
so that their attraction to them can feel innocent too.
I wanna make it so clear that that is not a Sabrina Carpenter problem.
That is a decades-old aesthetics problem that she happened to walk into,
whether that was intentional or not.
But then we get to her recent album cover,
which is just the icing on the cake.
The album is called Man's Best Friend,
and the cover shows her on the floor, on all fours,
in a little black dress and heels
with a faceless man behind her holding her by her hair.
Next to it is a promo image of a dog wearing a collar
with the album title on it.
She is literally sexualizing submission to a man,
comparing herself to a dog.
You do not need a PhD in feminist biology
to understand why people were outraged.
Glasgow Women's Aid, an actual domestic violence charity,
put out a statement calling it regressive,
saying it leaned on tired tropes that reduce women to pets
and normalize an element of control and violence.
But Sabrina didn't listen to any of the women who were offended by her cover.
In fact, she called them pearl clutches.
She even released a separate, in her words,
God-approved album cover that people could buy instead,
basically laughing in women's faces.
So by all accounts, if we're talking about classic male fantasy,
this should be it.
It's almost cartoonishly male gaze-coded.
But here's where it gets weird.
Because when you actually look at the reaction from straight men online,
it's not exactly mass worship.
There are obviously men who find Sabrina attractive, okay?
Let's not be silly here.
But there is also a surprising amount of men who just don't like her at all.
Some men find her annoying.
Other men call her aesthetic too much.
Some nitpick her body in the most predictable and depressing way possible.
It's just overall a weird amount of disinterest.
If this cover, if this whole persona was peak male fantasy,
then you would expect straight men to defend it with their lives
and make it their personality for a whole week.
You know, like how they act with Sidney Sweeney.
But that's not really what happened.
The loudest defenders were actually women.
The loudest critics were also women.
The men were just kind of standing there in the corner,
not really saying anything.
So sit with that for a second,
because that is actually the mystery at the center of this video.
If Sabrina's image is built for the male gaze,
then why do so many men seem so unbothered by it?
If Sabrina is selling submission,
then why are so many girls calling it empowerment?
The reason why Sabrina Carpenter is so hard to criticize
is because she doesn't present herself as a woman who loves male approval.
She presents herself as a woman who thinks men are a deeply unserious species
that we unfortunately have to share the earth with.
And that's not a joke.
Pretty much all of our songs are about how useless men are,
how they embarrass her, how they disappoint her.
And that is why so many women connect with her.
Because her music kind of feels like a group chat, you know,
in a you-will-not-believe-what-this-idiot-just-texted-me kind of way.
For example, there's her song Man Child, which is all about an insecure man.
There's a moment in the song where she's describing the man
and she gets the audience to chant the words stupid, slow, and useless.
Oh, and if you are a man in the crowd,
then watch out because they're all gonna be pointing at you.
Then you have her song Slim Pickings,
which is about using a man only for sex
because his personality and brain are non-existent.
Next, there's her song Hey Man, where she sings all about men being incompetent.
You get the point.
In an interview, Sabrina revealed her secret for writing hits
and it is quite literally just call men stupid in as many ways as you can.
And it seems like it works because her audience absolutely loves it.
It's exactly why she's seen as for the girls
because regardless of what her image is,
her music immediately just dismantles it.
Even when she sings about extremely sexual stuff,
most of the time she frames it in a way that she's the one in control.
She's the one initiating it.
She's talking about a guy in a way that men have always talked about women in their songs.
That is why so many fans defend her aesthetic.
They see the sexualized image and they say,
no, you don't get it, she's reclaiming it.
They see the babydoll dresses and say,
no, she's just playing a character.
They see the album cover and say,
no, she is just making fun of the way men see women.
But they never actually stop for a second and think about what that actually means
because apparently you're not allowed to.
If you have even the slightest bit of criticism against her,
you are suddenly labeled as anti-women.
That is not a joke.
Vogue straight up called the backlash a symptom of puritanical society
that can't handle a woman looking like she's enjoying herself.
Which is interesting because it completely misses the point of the backlash.
But I mean, whatever.
It just shows you how highly people view her.
There are also tons of articles describing her as, and I quote,
a hugely empowering artist and someone who is a modern day feminist icon.
A feminist icon.
Remember that.
The way they talk about her,
they talk about her like she's the modern equivalent of the suffragettes.
Like her music is actively paving the way for women's rights.
So I wanted to see if that actually held up.
Not just take people's word for it,
but actually see where this for the girls reputation comes from.
So whilst I was digging,
I found this TikTok of a girl asking the question,
what is it about Sabrina Carpenter's content that makes people say she's for the girls?
And the comments genuinely surprised me.
Pretty much everyone was just saying it's her lyrics
and how her songs take the piss out of men.
That is why she's for the girls.
Which, I mean, I guess that makes sense.
But then there was another comment that I kept seeing over and over again,
which said that her music is peak girlhood
and her lyrics are peak girl experiences.
And that kind of stopped me in my tracks.
Because what exactly are we calling girlhood here?
Because it's definitely not being on your hands and knees
whilst a man pulls your hair.
So it must be the music itself.
And as someone who isn't a Sabrina Carpenter super fan
and has only heard the hits,
there is no way that a couple of songs calling men stupid
is what these girls are describing as peak girl experiences.
There's just no way that this is empowerment to her fans.
There has to be more.
So I dove deep into her last two albums to try and find out
if her music is actually as empowering as her fans claim it to be.
And what I found genuinely shocked me.
Because as soon as I looked at her music,
the entire she's for the girls argument started to crumble.
Here's my first problem.
If her music is supposedly for the girls,
then why is every single song about men?
That is not an exaggeration.
Every single song on her last two albums have been about men and nothing else.
And when I saw that, I kind of had this realisation of,
wait, why is it that people call Taylor Swift male-obsessed and not Sabrina?
And I'm not saying this as a Swiftie either, okay?
So there is no bias here.
But for her whole career,
Taylor has been criticised for writing quote-unquote
too many songs about her ex-boyfriends,
which is wild considering her catalogue covers everything
from mental health to friendship to actual gender commentary.
And yet she's the one who gets called male-obsessed and not Sabrina.
What, because all of Sabrina's songs actively criticise men?
But criticising men and de-centring men is not the same thing,
and that is a very important difference.
Yes, a lot of Sabrina's music is anti-men,
but it's still completely male-centred in its structure.
Men are still the conflict.
Men are still the reason this song exists.
Yes, the man may be stupid, but he is still the main character.
So you can see why I worry when I see all these young girls call her music peak girlhood,
because what they're actually saying is peak girlhood to them,
revolves around men, around their drama,
and I find that really concerning.
What's even worse is that the more I looked into her music,
the more I realised that her music is anything but empowering.
And stay with me here, okay, as I explain this.
So, Sabrina does this fascinating thing
where she constantly talks about how disappointing men are,
but she rarely ever holds them accountable.
For example, let's look at her song Please Please Please,
which is about dating someone your friends don't approve of.
This song has been praised as the girl power anthem of the modern dating era,
but let's take a second to actually look at the lyrics here.
All I'm asking, baby, please please please don't prove I'm right
and please please please don't bring me to tears when I just did my makeup so nice.
Heartbreak is one thing, my ego's another.
I beg you don't embarrass me, motherfreaker.
Let's actually look at what she's saying here, okay?
She's not threatening to leave him or holding him accountable.
She's not saying that I deserve better than a man that embarrasses me.
She's basically begging him to behave in front of her friends
so that she can pretend that the relationship is all sunshine and rainbows.
Let's just look at the next line, okay?
I promise them that you're different and everyone makes mistakes.
So she already knows this guy's a walking red flag,
but she still continues to make excuses for him.
She lies to her loved ones to protect his image,
choosing to stay in this toxic relationship because,
I guess, that's just what you have to do as a woman?
And a whole generation of young girls heard that and said,
yeah, that's deeply relatable.
And look, I get it because it is deeply relatable,
but that is exactly the problem.
It's relatable because so many of us girls have been trained to do that.
And it's no wonder when you have cute little pop songs like this
turning serious issues into fun jokes.
And again, I need to make it so clear that my problem is not with the song itself.
I don't have an issue with the song.
She can sing about whatever she wants to do.
That is not the issue.
My issue is that people see this song and call it a feminist anthem.
What, because she called her boyfriend embarrassing but still stayed with him?
What exactly is empowering about begging a man to treat you with basic respects?
If your partner is constantly embarrassing you, breaking your trust,
making your friends worry,
then the empowering thing to do would be to walk away.
Ditch his stinky butt.
And it's just strange because you would not expect this type of song
from the way that people talk about Sabrina.
And yet, the more I looked into her music, the more confusing it got.
Because here's the thing.
If Sabrina is really this feminist icon that people keep claiming she is,
then why are so many of her songs putting men on a pedestal?
Let me just give you a couple of examples, okay?
Take her song, Tears,
where she literally jokes about wanting to drop to her knees
because a man does the dishes.
The dishes.
Since when did cleaning up for yourself become the sexiest thing a man can do?
That is the bare minimum.
And yet the song treats him like husband of the year.
And then there's her song, House Tour,
where she literally compares her body to a house
that's been built solely for a man's pleasure.
I'm sorry, what?
How is this in any way empowering?
This is quite literally the opposite of empowering.
You're describing your own body as something designed for a man's enjoyment,
as if its purpose is to be owned by him.
And by the way, that is not even the start of her lyrics
that are similar to this, okay?
Her entire catalogue is filled with these lyrics.
And it's just like, as someone who is celebrated as this woman
who's supposedly flipped the script on men,
these lyrics seem incredibly old-fashioned.
That is what I find so fascinating about Serena.
On the surface, she rolls her eyes at men.
She calls them stupid, useless, and incompetent.
But underneath all of that,
a lot of her songs still buy into incredibly traditional ideas about men and women.
The man barely has to lift a finger before he's treated as some hero,
but the woman's body is still framed in relation to what it can offer him.
That is not exactly this feminist revolution that people keep telling me she's leading.
And if you think I'm exaggerating,
there are tons of articles which describe her as the leader of modern feminism.
Just listen to this quote.
Sabrina Carpenter is the feminist we didn't know we needed.
There is no doubt she is at the forefront of a new wave of feminism,
one about expression, positivity, and self-love.
And honestly, I read that and I'm just confused.
Because again, think about all the lyrics we talked about today,
and remember that they are all coming from this album cover.
This is the album these songs are in.
I'm sorry, but am I living on another planet?
I literally have no words.
I just can't understand it.
As I was doing my research for this video,
I saw a lot of people defending these lyrics and cover, calling it satire.
Every time someone says this looks straight up like she's performing for the male gaze,
someone replies,
no, you don't get it.
She's making fun of the male gaze.
But here's the thing with satire.
It actually needs to do something.
If you put a woman on all fours with a man holding her by her hair
and title it,
Man's Best Friend,
that image reads as objectification.
There is no way you can look at this album cover
and not think of it as anything but her putting herself beneath a man.
And you know what's funny?
I remember when this album cover first came out
and all her fans were so quick to say,
no, no, no, wait,
because it's going to be revealed that it's actually her holding her own hair
and it's not a man.
They were so convinced that that was going to happen
because even they were like,
uh, what is going on here?
But that never happened.
That was really just the cover.
Now, maybe the intended meaning is
I'm critiquing the way that women are sometimes treated as pets in relationships,
which, fine,
but where's the critique in this image?
What makes the viewer uncomfortable with the power dynamic
rather than just simply noticing it?
There's nothing.
If I dress up as a sexy maid and I say,
don't worry, guys,
I'm just doing a parody of domestic labor.
Does that magically mean I stop looking like a sexy maid?
It might be satire to me,
but visually it's still doing the thing.
Calling something ironic doesn't change how young girls see that image
when they scroll past it with zero context.
That paired with songs where you excuse toxic men's behavior
and say your body was made for them.
I just don't get it.
Here's the complicated thing about the male gaze, okay?
The male gaze does not care if you're joking.
A man who enjoys seeing a woman be submissive
is not necessarily going to stop enjoying it
just because someone online says,
actually, she's reclaiming it.
Men have been doing selective listening since the dawn of time.
You think simply calling it satire is going to stop them?
It's not.
The other defense I kept seeing is,
well, she chose to do it.
She's an adult.
She's a girl boss making millions off it.
Therefore, it's a feminist act.
And when you put it like that,
sure, it sounds empowering,
but is it really?
I feel like we've been trained by modern internet culture
to believe that as long as a woman has control over her own body,
as long as she's the one cashing in the check,
then literally anything she does with her body
is a form of taking back the power.
And I'm not saying that's wrong,
but in my opinion,
I just think that is such a low bar for empowerment.
It basically just means nothing.
If empowerment just means a woman did something voluntarily,
then anything can be empowerment.
Wearing lingerie is empowering.
Wearing a potato sack is empowering.
Selling skinny culture to young girls is empowering.
Marrying a man who calls you female is empowering.
At that point,
empowerment becomes less of a serious topic
and more like a participation sticker.
And honestly,
let's actually be real about the money aspect of this as well.
There is nothing disruptive or radical
about giving a male-dominated industry
exactly what it's always wanted from young female pop stars
since the dawn of time.
Being a thin, hyper-feminine, submissive blonde doll
is quite literally the safest business move
a young woman in pop music can make.
It's what sells records.
Calling it empowerment
just because a woman is at the face of it
isn't the feminist act you think it is.
It's taking old school objectification,
wrapping it up in a nice little pink bow,
and selling it right back to girls
who think they're consuming a feminist revolution
when actually,
they're funding the exact same thing
their grandmothers fought to get away from.
Because remember,
Sabrina Carpenter is not working alone.
In fact,
she is not even at the top of her food chain.
Guess who's at the top controlling her?
As you can probably guess,
men.
They're the ones who have the final say.
They're the ones cashing in the biggest checks.
They're the ones profiting off this image.
And yet,
so many people seem to ignore that.
They all think that she's this independent feminist artist
that's making all of her own money
when no,
she's a part of this massive machine.
And right at the top is the very people
that she claims to be so against.
Honestly,
this is where I think her image comes back into this.
The baby's old dresses.
The,
I look like a little girl.
That is not happening in a vacuum.
She pairs it with lyrics that are all about men.
Imagery of submission,
crawling around on her knees.
So when people react
and when people have criticism,
they're not looking at just one lyric.
They're looking at the entire image.
That is why the male gaze conversation
keeps coming back around to her.
I don't think Sabrina having a majority female audience
disproves that argument either.
If anything,
I think it makes it more interesting.
Because maybe we've been asking the wrong question
this entire time.
Maybe Sabrina isn't selling male fantasy to men.
Maybe she's selling male fantasy to women.
Now, before you lose your minds,
I'm not saying that all women secretly hate feminism,
okay?
I'm saying we've spent our entire lives
being told that becoming that image
is the same thing as being powerful.
That if a man wants you,
then you've won at life.
And I think that could be why women defend her so hard.
She's not necessarily every straight guy's dream girl.
She's more like a woman's idea
of what the dream girl looks like
after growing up with the same beauty standards
and movies and music videos the rest of us did.
Tiny, girly, blonde, a little dirty,
but still cute enough to feel innocent.
She gets to crawl around on stage,
joke about sex,
say that her body is to be owned by men,
and somehow it's still called empowerment.
And again, this is not me coming for her personally.
This is not me policing what she should do with her body, okay?
That is not the point of this video,
and I really, really hope people hear me when I say that.
My point is, when these massive organizations are out here
calling her the feminist that we didn't know we needed,
I worry what effect that is going to have.
Because when I look up this discourse
and I see all these young girls saying,
no, you don't get it,
her music is just peak girlhood,
that is so sad to me.
Because what they're saying is that
their idea of the best version of being a girl
revolves around men,
not around friendship,
not around trying to figure out who you are,
not around any of the stuff girlhood
is supposed to be about.
Just being wanted by men,
that is the peak.
And the fact that they say that out loud
without even thinking twice about it
just means that the damage is already done.
So no, this video is not really about Sabrina Carpenter.
It's the fact that we have raised a generation of girls
who think being wanted by a man
is the highest version of themselves they can reach.
And that's the part that really needs to change.
It's time we get a real empowering female figure
that is not managed by a corporation of men.
And in saying that, if you do need one, I am right here.
But anyway, thank you guys so much for watching.
I really, really want to know
what you guys think in the comments,
especially if, you know, you disagree with me.
Tell me your opinion,
tell me what it is that you believe
and I cannot wait to have conversations with you.
And if you made it this far,
please comment the word power
so I can see who doesn't have a short attention span
and I can like all of your comments.
Please don't forget to like and subscribe.
Thank you guys so much for all your support
and I will see you in the next video.
Bye!
