Could entire stars simply vanish?! One of the strangest mysteries in astronomy isn't about black holes or aliens. It's about stars that seem to disappear without a trace.
In this conversation, astronomer Beatriz Villarroel explains the VASCO (Vanishing & Appearing Sources during a Century of Observations) project and one of its most astonishing discoveries: **nine star-like objects that appeared and disappeared simultaneously on a single photographic plate**, long before the satellite era.
We cover: • Why hundreds of "missing stars" had to be investigated one by one. • The automated search pipeline developed by Enrique Solano to analyze decades of astronomical data. • Why about 600 disappearing objects demanded closer inspection. • The famous image containing nine transient objects that still challenges conventional explanations. • What these discoveries could mean for astrophysics, observational astronomy, and the search for rare cosmic phenomena.
📬 Subscribe to my Monday **M.A.G.I.C. Message** for science insights, meteorites, giveaways, and impossible conversations: (https://briankeating.com/bvyt)
🪨 Win a **4.5-billion-year-old meteorite** 📖 Get your **FREE copy of Flatland** 📚 My books
Brian Keating is Chancellor's Distinguished Professor of Physics at UC San Diego, a leading observational cosmologist, and Principal Investigator on the Simons Observatory. His research focuses on the Cosmic Microwave Background, inflation, and the origin of the Universe. On *Into the Impossible*, he interviews Nobel laureates, pioneering scientists, entrepreneurs, and thinkers exploring the biggest questions in science.
An astronomer discusses a search for \"vanishing stars\" that instead revealed thousands of mysterious, short-lived transients. While initially considering various natural and artificial origins, the researcher discovered a unique cluster of nine simultaneous flashes. Statistical analysis suggests these objects are sharper than real stars, indicating extremely brief flashes of light.
young astronomers and children and actually also professional astronomers,
were going there and looking for the vanishing stars that we were hoping to find.
And then we had this automated process with a very super,
like, well, very advanced thing that Enrico Solano developed.
And both were searching for vanishing stars.
And so we actually went through something like 600,
yeah, I think something like 600 million objects with the automated analysis that Enrico did.
We did all that, the whole northern hemisphere and even more,
and we found zero vanishing stars. I mean, zero.
The failure, right?
I mean, we did report it, maybe, maybe the super, like, the theoretical astronomers that
are believing in failed supernova were not as excited.
But instead, we found all these like thousands and thousands
of objects that appear and vanish within a plate exposure.
And initially, we were thinking, okay, maybe it's some M dwarf flares.
Maybe it's some kind of, maybe it's optical afterglows to gamma-ray bursts.
And that was the initial thought. So we were writing about all the possibilities.
I also, I think in 2019, we were also including the SETI possibilities, because I had a figure.
I remember the referee was telling me to tone down the aliens.
And then I felt compelled to include, to do the opposite, of course.
And I included a picture, figure one with a green little alien in it as one of the possibilities.
And there, the referee gave up and just approved it.
Well, we also included all the other changes.
But, you know, it was very, like, early for me.
And then we had this, I had through this visual wetting of 24,000
candidates alone during three months.
You know, you get crazy after that.
I promise you, it's working to get a little.
And so I had this table two there.
And then there were a hundred, like, coordinates that I identified as interesting
with these single images that could have been M dwarf flares, whatever.
And the really interesting thing didn't come in that paper.
It came when I decided to look through that table yet one more time.
And we suddenly discovered that one of these images had nine objects
appearing and vanishing at the same time, but in a small image.
And we were like, what is that?
Were there segments, like, if you, if you look at a transient,
were they all basically the same?
Like, there'd be some blurring or smudging.
I mean, obviously some things like, you know, we'll talk about cosmic rays later, of course.
We'll talk about, you know, asteroids and planetary objects and near-Earth objects
that do come and go perhaps, or, you know, bolides or meteoroids and things like that.
But what was the characteristic of these transients?
Let's say, let's stipulate that they are, you know, some sort of technology,
although obviously we're going to talk about that.
It's contested.
But let's say it was, would that have the exact same transient, you know,
behavior in a photographic emulsion as it would say in a CMOS camera or similar advanced camera?
What do you actually see?
Like, can you describe them for the people that are listening?
What do they look like?
So what we saw was nine objects that looked just like stars,
like any kind of stars in the plates.
And when I manually tried to look at the brightness profile,
so what we astronomers do to separate something that is round and is a round dirt,
because you can have bubbles, you can have plate defects that are round and also are star-like.
So what you do is to look at the brightness profile
for a star of a certain magnitude and compare to the brightness profile
of another, of a real star that you know is real and that is there in multiple catalogs.
And this camera, sorry to interrupt you, but the camera has a support for the secondary, right?
So it must have some diffraction spikes or some telltale sauce for point source function,
the point spread function.
And what you're saying is that the point spread function looked identical for
these objects as for a true point source like a star, right?
So we just compared and it looked identical and I was comparing to
the stars that had similar magnitudes.
So they just looked identical to me when I was measuring.
Now, later we learned that there are some statistical differences,
but when you just manually were trying to look at it,
then it looks very similar for like if you compare one and one.
What is the new phenomenon that you said you found statistically
looks different when you examine it statistically?
So today, and actually that's thanks to some of the critics,
if you take a big sample of these transients
and you compare it to a big sample of the stars, you see that they are
slightly, not much, but a little bit sharper and more narrowed, the brightness profiles
than they are of the real stars.
And that fits very well with what happens if you have a very short flash,
because then you have less of time for atmospheric turbulence to disturb the profile.
So then it's slightly more narrow.
I want to just highlight something you just said.
You said, thanks to my critics.
And I just thought of where I heard that exact same sentence before,
and it was in my conversation with Nobel Prize winner John Mather.
John Mather won the Nobel Prize for co-leading the COBE,
Cosmic Background Explorer, FIRAS experiment that determined that the CMB is a black body,
despite what all my haters and critics.
And I have my own trolls out there, Beatrice.
You're not the only one who has haters and trolls, okay, my friend.
So I have a lot of people that hate that.
Oh, I just I talk up the Big Bang so much.
And I make up this fact that it's a black body, but it's not.
It's not a black body.
Only carbon can make a black body or metallic hydrogen.
There's a lot of nonsense I have to debunk a lot of times, okay.
But what John Mather and his team found was that the CMB is not only a black body,
it's the most perfect black body that you could possibly imagine,
signifying a long period of thermal equilibrium with high optical depth
and uniform absorption and emission.
Now, why did he say that?
He told me in the interview I did with him six years ago, seven years ago,
that he was very thankful to his critics.
And I've heard that many times, actually, from the late Ray Weiss at MIT,
who won the Nobel Prize for LIGO.
They say your critics sometimes reveal some of the shortcomings of your argument.
And by hearing them, it can make them stronger.
Now, obviously, you can go overboard.
You can have people that are malicious, malevolent, and do things as trolls do.
And they're not interested in the light.
They're interested in the heat.
But I did want to I always like to point out,
we have a lot of young scientists that listen to this program, Beatrice.
And I always love to highlight when a scientist says something that's particularly important,
that can help guide the career and the choices and even the emotions of a scientist
as he or she starts off young.
So thank you for that explanation and for being candid and honest
and having the integrity that a good scientist should have.
So I really do appreciate that.
And it led you to do something even better than if the critics didn't exist.
So thanks to the critics.
So one of the things that's fascinating to me is that
it's kind of, you know, I often have thought about light
when I'm when I'm out on the beach with my kids late at night,
and they're looking at a star.
And I'll say to them, like, we don't know if that star is still there.
You know, it could be gone, right?
It could have vanished.
I like to visualize.