Your Most Controversial Wine Opinions - Ranked from reasonable to insane!

World of Fine Wines
5 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 12, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAgnes from No Sediment and another expert evaluate controversial wine opinions, debating topics such as regional quality, pricing ethics, and tasting philosophies. They challenge elitism in the industry, defend the value of classic regions, and emphasize that personal enjoyment is the ultimate measure of a wine's worth.
Hi everybody, this is Agnes from No Sediment and today we are going to rate your most controversial
wine opinions. We have done several videos before where I mostly focused on just a few
controversial wine topics that I have come across over the course of my wine career,
which I just realized spans 20 years. Wow, time flies! But quite regularly you also share your
own opinions in the comment section and very often the topics you bring up are simply too
complex for a short answer. So I asked you to share some of your most controversial wine opinions
and today I am going to give my take on them. Rating them as reasonable, questionable,
indeed controversial or straight down insane. So if you took part in the conversation of my
previous post, chances are great we will tackle your opinion today. Shall we? I was really
impressed because we received more than 100 comments in less than one week, so of course I
cannot tackle them all. So let's just start with the first one. New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc drinkers
don't like wine. I will go straight ahead and say that this is insane. I love New Zealand Sauvignon
Blanc and the great examples from New Zealand are absolutely amazing and I love wine as well,
so I am living, breathing example that that's not true. Madeira wine and Porto wine are top tier.
Reasonable and absolutely true, nothing controversial here. Only wine stored under
floor or wall is worth drinking and then there's a question mark, so I don't know. I will say this
is insane because they are great examples worldwide with amazing wines that have not been
aged under boil or floor and you know those are still worth drinking, so this is just an insane
comment. Terroir is real in broad strokes, climate, region, but the mystical soil flavor signature
marketed by wineries is not reliably detectable in chemical analysis or blind tasting. The main
point of this argument is absolutely reasonable and I will specifically tackle this topic in one
of my upcoming podcast interviews with Professor Alex Maltman, Professor of Geology Alex Maltman.
He asked a question that you answered through all this hour because his question was can you
taste the soil in the wine and he did not know that you were my next guest. It's a very good
question and nothing wrong with the question and it's right up my street. Make sure to watch that
video once it is out. I think it will be in a couple of months though. Wine needs to be enjoyable
at release, it can get better with age, but in quotation marks it needs time can be an excuse
for unbalanced wine. Reasonable, absolutely true. I will support this claim always. The notion that
wine somehow is of bad quality or unacceptable quality during its release or first years of its
life, it's just wrong. Great wine will be great when it is young and great wine will be also great
when it is getting older and at older stage as well. So let's move to the next one. If wine is
meant to age 10 more years, wine youtubers, I'm looking at myself now, need to stop taste testing
them against other wines that are meant to be consumed now, then act surprised when the famous
but too young wine loses the blind. Super controversial, I just said it addressing the
comment, wine is great and should be great upon its release. Bad wine will be scored badly when
it is young, when it is mid age and when it is getting older. So here it is not the issue that
great wine was young and therefore it was scored lower. Here it is either the issue of the taster
who maybe cannot pick up the slight differences of a younger, maybe more powerful, more structured
wine or it is the issue of the wine and indeed it is not as good as maybe we are led to believe.
Pinot Noir is an inferior grape variety and wildly overrated and overpriced. Wrong and insane,
it cannot be inferior grape variety because it has been with us for several hundreds of years
and there is a reason it has persisted with us, with human beings. However, I do know people who
have honestly and openly stated that they are not fan of Pinot Noir and that is fine and that is
their opinion and their right to enjoy and drink the wines that they prefer themselves. You know,
drink what you like. Alright, so the next one I have put several comments together in a group
so maybe initially these comments will seem to you as they are not alike but they are really
very similar in one specific point of view. Let's see. So the first one goes,
the easiest way to size up the quality of a wine shop selection is to look at its German selection.
Another one goes, German reds are the new Verdot. The best Spätburgunders can rival the best
Burgundies. Absolutely reasonable. Australia is criminally underrated. The oldest Grenache,
Marsagne and Shiraz wines in the world. World-class Riesling, Chardonnay, Sémillon,
Pinot, Grenache, Cabernet, Shiraz. Next one goes, nobody has yet to match France in the wine game.
I know several people who would very strongly agree with that. Burgundy prevails. I have had
many wines from around the world but today I don't even look outside of Burgundy anymore
and to ice the cake it must have a cork. People, passion and pinch of craziness is required.
CDP, in this case it is Manchettino de Pape, is great value and quality that no one ever profiles
or compares to other regions. At best you get it in Grenache tasting. Bandole is similar.
Northern Rhone to a degree. YouTubers, wine critics alike ignore except for Clos de Pape and
Bucastelle for some reason. So those are two really well-known wine producers in Chateauneuf
de Pape. I do love them as well. So altogether in these comments I don't see anything that
controversial and let me explain why. We all tend to fall in love and certain wine style,
grape varieties, winemaking regions and we will always always support wine region or country that
we are coming from. So that is only natural and in that love we will always feel that other people
around us maybe don't pay enough attention or don't share the same passion as we do. I almost
feel similarly with the band The Who. I constantly feel they are underrated because I cannot find
people who would share the same passion and love for them and they are amazing. This however starts
to become controversial if in pursuing our love for our specific winemaking region, grape variety
or wine style, we start to bash other winemaking regions, other grape varieties and other wine
styles. So in general I would say that all of these opinions that we had a lot in our comment
section, they're not really controversial, they're very reasonable, they're very human-like and I
understand the feeling. But we should remain respectful towards other winemaking regions,
winemakers in general and other tastes as well. So let's move to the next one which says
drink what you like in brackets is the most anti-small artisanal wine production message
out there and just equates to drink what's available and don't feel bad about it. I will try
to be as kind as possible addressing this comment. I will just say it is insane and it is wrong in
so many levels. First of all whoever made this comment they took this drink what you like as a
personal attack towards artisanal winemakers and it is not. Just seconds ago we talked about people
enjoying Chateauneuf-du-Pape, liking or not liking Pinot Noir. We discussed Germany rivaling the best
winemaking regions of France and we discussed fortified wines such as Madeira and Port wine
and we also discussed wines that are aged on their floor or wall. None of those opinions are
anti-artisanal wine. They are expressions of personal taste and curiosity and that is exactly
the point. Drink what you like does not mean never explore. Drink what you like does not mean
only drink what is available in the supermarket shelves. Drink what you like actually means that
no one should feel embarrassed of what they like in their wine glass. I started my wine journey
by enjoying off-dry Gewurztraminer. I pretty early liked New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc with generous
amount of residual sugar if I'm being honest and my palate developed and evolved and it still
develops and evolves. That's how almost everyone enters the wine world. We have to start somewhere
and by making people feel bad about what they enjoy, what they drink, we only further alienate
them from the wine world instead of bringing them in. I would even argue that comments like these
hurt artisanal and small family-owned winemakers even more because by saying that what you drink
is wrong or your taste is bad, people just want to leave the wine world altogether. They never
will want to explore the wine world further. They will never want to go and taste Jura or
I don't know Jerez or you know small grower champagne estates. The bottom line of this
comment is that it is not only insane, it is elitist. So let's move to the next comment.
I think the wine rating on 100 points should be eliminated. I prefer the WSAT rating because it
most objective. It is insane. I don't understand why different wine judging and scoring systems
cannot coexist. For you, it makes no sense. For other people, it also makes no sense. For others
who understand it and who follow, it makes sense. So it really depends. We are different,
each and every one of us, and one person prefers three-star rating system, other person prefers
Febiqueri, other person prefers 10-point system, 20-point system, 15-point system,
three-glass system, 100-point system, and they can all coexist. Let's move to the next one which
also tackles the issues of the points. Luca Maroni, 99-point wine. I feel like they're lower
towards the 80 points. I will say that this is questionable. The reason for it, we always talk
that you should find your wine critic or your wine taster with whom your taste aligns. So maybe for
this person specifically, Luca Maroni says 99 points and you think it is 80 and for you that's
fine and for another, Luca Maroni says 99 and they taste it and they say yeah it is a 99-point
wine and I like it and I enjoy it. So I think the honest point here would be that you don't have the
same taste as Luca Maroni. I think some of the wine experts are biased by labels. They can smell
100 descriptors and rate a wine very good or outstanding just because it says champagne or
Barolo on the label even if everyone else thinks it's crap. Controversial. I have been to some of
the wine judging and scoring competitions. All the wines are tasted blind so we cannot be biased by
the labels because we simply don't see the labels. It is true that we know what we are tasting so
maybe there would be like 20 Barolo or 20 or 30 Champagne in front of us and then we would
know that we are tasting Champagne against Champagne not Champagne against Cremant or Cava or whatever
and within that category you would see that there are certain wines that are golden medals you know
94-95 plus then there are certain wines that are receiving silver medals then there are certain
wines and bronze and there are Barolos that do not get any score at all. So it is not that it is
Barolo or that it is Champagne. It is that this specific wine within its category is scored highly
because it stands out within this category. That's one thing. Of course there are these individuals
wine critics that sometimes receive the samples and then they score the wines knowing what the
wines are but in general I would like and I would want to trust wine critics and what they do and
of course we never know what is happening you know behind closed door when there's one wine
critic and one wine in front of them and how they score it. So the next one. Most reds benefit from
being chilled. Reasonable. I cool my red wines sometimes. Reasonable. I cool my red wines as well.
I actually prefer them slightly chilled and let's be honest our room temperature is not the same
what it was 50 years ago. Next one. Restaurant wine pricing is built on consumer ignorance.
If they listed the retail price next to their markup price all restaurant wine sales would
plummet. Somewhat reasonable. Somewhat questionable and controversial if I am being honest. Of course
there are certain restaurants whose pricing strategy is somewhat questionable. I will agree
but usually those restaurants are being honest. We are working only for tourists, for customers that
we do not expect coming back. So one-time visitors and this is how they make their money. But we
cannot expect for restaurants to have the same markup as brick-and-mortar retailer and we cannot
expect for brick-and-mortar retailer to have the same markup as online wine shop. In the restaurant
we are having wine served to us chilled from a wine fridge in a polished wine glass. We are
sitting at a clean table. We might even have candle or flower on the table. It is being served by a
nice person who talks about the wine, who maybe explains us the wine. We have music, we have ambience,
we have nice comfortable furniture. Then we stand up, we go to the restroom, we have toilet, toilet
paper, we have hand washing soaps, we have towels and you know in the best restaurants we would also
have a hand cream. All of that cost money. And if you are enjoying wine on the terrace in certain
regions and countries getting that terrace permit can be very expensive and time-consuming. I am not
even discussing that retailer chain stores will have much greater negotiation power than a single
restaurant will do because they move greater volumes. So when I go to the restaurants I never
compare the price of the wine in the restaurant's wine list with the price in the retail shelf. Those
are two completely different concepts. So I will say this is very very controversial. Let's move to
the next one. While wine conventions and tasting events are fun, you cannot judge a truly great
wine from a single tasting pour. Great wines require and deserve an entire evening to slowly
savor and experience the wine unfold. Reasonable? I completely agree with it. I think the idea of
these wine fairs is more to introduce you with the general style of the wine and maybe you know
what they offer altogether and how this wine developed and where you are at. And of course if
you're a true wine lover and you did enjoy what you saw, the short preview, you will come back to that
wine and you will purchase it and then you can sit back in your nice couch and enjoy the
wine through the course of the evening. Anything above $40 per bottle and you're just paying for
reputation and marketing. While there is a certain truth to it, I don't think it is the $40 mark here
and I will take the lowest hanging fruit here, champagne. We are harvesting grapes by hand in one
of the most expensive agricultural lands in the world, in the climate which is highly unpredictable.
We are having two fermentations. We are aging that wine for around two years and plus in the cellars
and we are bottling that wine in a very expensive bottle. So sparkling wine bottle is usually tends
to be more expensive than still wine bottle. Of course there are always exceptions. So it is only
natural that the prices are higher for these wines and because these wines are coming from such an
unpredictable climate, you know one year winemaker wins because the climate and weather is very
generous and kind and other year the winemaker loses. So it is ups and downs. So it is not as
straightforward as one might think. And then I have another question. When did marketing on its own
as a concept became bad? It is good. Because of the marketing I have discovered so many great
producers. One that comes to my mind immediately is this fabulous winemaker Juan Carlos Sancha
in Rioja who makes wines from indigenous rare rediscovered grape varieties. The value is
amazing and if I wouldn't have been to the wine fair where he was invited that is part of the
marketing I would have never discovered it. So I don't understand why we always keep bashing
marketing as a concept in general. That's fine. We would never know all those small artisanal
producers if it wasn't for certain marketing. So let's move on. Oh, very questionable, very
questionable. American made wine deserves to be thrown down the drain. So before I answer is it
American made wine or is it American wine? Because there are a lot of wines in Europe as well made by
Americans. Anyway, completely insane of course that's not true. There are many hybrid wines
especially whites that are better than their vinifera counterparts. I will say this is
questionable. I think this topic might require a video on its own but the simple explanation
will be that we don't know or we don't have yet enough experience with vinifera. We have
several hundreds of year experience when it comes to growing them and when it comes to
making the wines and with hybrids we simply don't have that. And this is one thing where I think
there is a lot of marketing being invested to make us think that they are better. I don't think that
they are yet there. They might get there one day for sure but at this moment I think all together
we lack experience in the grape varieties yet. Honestly, my most controversial wine opinion is
that I'd have another glass tells me more than half the tasting notes I read. Reasonable, it
makes sense in my books absolutely. I have told you several times that one of my favorite ways to
evaluate wine comes from one of Hugh Johnson's written books. He said that the first bottle that
is finished, that is empty, is the best wine. And I in fact have made a video which was quite
challenging to film but I made a video where I tasted several wines that I like with my friends
and then we rated which bottles were the first ones to finish. So if you want you can go and
watch that video because it actually talks about this very idea and it's very very reasonable.
Ingredients and finding agents should be required to be on the label either as a list or QR code
that leads you to the web page with them listed. People should be able to find out what they are
drinking without hiring a private investigator. I believe wine quality overall would go up.
In general nothing controversial with this idea. We indeed should be able to know what we are
drinking and I think starting with 2024 at least in European Union you are required to have
ingredients on the label either printed as a list as this commentator said or via QR code. However
there is one part of this comment that I think is more controversial and that is the idea that
wine would somehow become of better quality if we would have those ingredients listed. I am not so
sure about it. In general I would argue that wine quality is really high nowadays. We have fewer and
wines with faults. Fewer and fewer wines with certain taints you know and off flavors. What
concerns me though is growing assumption that any additive is inherently bad. Let's take sulfur
dioxide for example which I think is one of the most misunderstood additive in the wine. I believe
it is one of the most important tools to protect wine from various bacterial spoilage and oxidation
risks and this pushing towards lower sulfur dioxide additions in the wine has led towards
increase in certain faults in wine. Let's say mousiness. Mousiness is closely linked with
reduced levels of SO2. That is to remind you that additives are not always bad. They have reason and
they have purpose in wine. If we are going to start judging wine by how short the additive list
is in the wine, winemakers will become very creative and what they can for example start to do
is to use other manipulations with the wine. Let's say vacuum distillation. Let's say reverse osmosis
and in my books that is more manipulative than adding SO2, than adding tartaric acid to you know
increase acidity or to add monoproteins and you don't have to display or inform you know the
consumer about it. So that second part of this comment is slightly controversial in my view.
Red wine and cheese go well together. Red wine, cheese and heavy metal go together fantastically.
Reasonable of course, I would know. Well the only thing I can think of is how probably worldwide
there are only six wineries that can sell their juice for $300. The rest talk about marketing.
We keep talking about marketing. Not to drop names but Opus One, my world. I've had 60 bucks tough
that rivals it. Questionable if only that this person is referring to the six wineries which I
don't know which ones this person is talking about and I guarantee you the reason they can
sell their wine for $300 is because of marketing for sure. I feel like burgundy is not worth the
are charged for them at least not here in the United States. Domaine Leroy 2011 Premier Cru
for $10,000. 91 point wines for over $1,000 a bottle is just idiotic and you can get much
better here in the United States for quality. I don't care how rare it is or that there are not
a lot of it of the wine. If I made wine from grapes in my backyard I would be terrible but
could I charge $1,000 per bottle because I wouldn't make a lot of it. Well of course the
examples that are mentioned here in this comment are extreme. Burgundy is not all four digit or
five digit numbers and naturally and it is not only about how little you make of course that
is one part of it but also the quality you know and the prestige and availability of these wines
of course also play an important role. To be honest I have also had my fair share of you know
thoughts about burgundy and their prices but the only people to really blame in this are us because
we are the ones who are willing to pay that price and burgundy would be silly to not take you know
the money that has been given to them and of course if it is not the winemaker who does it
then it is the intermediaries that you know support the price inflation. I do understand that there is
some pain for me the same. I will say that this is questionable because there are still a lot of
good value I don't want to say great value but good value burgundy available and we just have
to look beyond these really great names that were mentioned here. Wine critics, sommeliers, scholars,
educators, youtubers, influencers are responsible for current wine prices. While I understand
where this is coming from I cannot completely agree with it so I understand the idea that you
the wine professionals are blamed for wine being too elitist to you know excluding the regular
people and making maybe making wine too mystique and too complex that it just it feels almost
impenetrable the wine world altogether. However wine is an alcohol and we have to understand that
currently there are different issues at play in the wine world and it is much more complex
situation and it is not only wine professionals and youtubers and influencers and writers
that are to blame. Maybe it was 10, 15, 20 years ago that we could talk about it but nowadays
no the process that we currently see is way more complex than this. So controversial opinion
I will happily drink any white wine under screw cup. Me too. Cork is unnecessary for whites.
Cork is also unnecessary for any red consumed under five years from bottling. The Europeans
will scream but it's tradition. I live in the new world so tradition has less importance.
It's the quality of what's in the glass and I don't want cork taint. Studies show aged whites
under screw cup retain freshness over whites under cork. I will say that it is quite reasonable
but altogether there's a lot of extremes in this comment. There are really top top quality corks,
natural corks made that can act the same way as screw cup. So the studies that this is referring
to it is not as straightforward because it really depends on the cork and the one thing that we have
issue with cork of course we talk about cork taint that has diminished in you know percentage
greatly over the last 10-20 years but the one thing I want to mention is the consistency.
So with screw cup there is much higher greater consistency that the wine will be fine while with
natural cork it is slightly less because while the cork could look completely sound and fine from
outside inside there might be you know some issues some ruptures and some you know breaks
that actually will also impact the wine while it is aging. So altogether reasonable some of the
extreme ideas of this specific comment questionable. Wine from classic wine regions are overhyped
and are garbage in terms of price to quality ratio. Wrong. Insane. I will say Loire Valley
is classic. It is definitely not garbage. It offers amazing quality to price ratio.
Rhone is classic. Rioja is classic. Jerez Doro is classic. They offer great value price ratio
and it is not garbage and I will give you one better. Bordeaux is as classic as one can get
and I think this region offers amazing quality and amazing value when it comes cent per cent
for sure absolutely so insane oh and this is it we're done with the comments so thank you very
much for watching this video thank you for putting yourself out there and commenting and let me know
in the comment section below of this video if you disagree with some of my views or you know
opinions and meanwhile make sure to watch this video next
