A History Of Flying Saucers And UFOs

Truth exists
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
The history of UFOs and flying saucers is one of eyewitness reports, debunkers, and conspiracy
theories. But what happens when we take a factual look at these supposed sightings of strange craft
in the sky? This episode we're talking to historian Professor Greg Akigian about his new book,
After the Flying Saucers Came, which is a global history of the UFO phenomenon.
Hi, I'm Greg Akigian. I'm professor of history and bioethics at Penn State University in the
United States. I'm a historian of science and medicine by specialty. And over the years,
I've worked primarily in the history of the ways in which scientific and medical establishments
and governments have understood ideas, feelings, people, and thoughts that were
marginal, shall we say, or deemed to be outside the mainstream. And that's how I got into the
topic I guess we're going to discuss today. Yes, that's right, which is going to be Flying
Saucers because it's in relation to your book, After the Flying Saucers Came, which will be out
by the time this podcast comes out. It's described as a global history of UFO sightings. So I guess
the first question is, what led you to choose this particular topic, thorny as it is?
I was led to this topic in part by those interests I just described,
though it does sort of seem to deviate from what I normally work on. Well, you know,
the first thing to say is that I was always fascinated with this stuff when I was growing up.
Most anybody I've ever met in talking about the book and the project with people,
anybody I've ever met who's been interested in this said it started in childhood. And I was
a really voracious reader and consumer of anything about aliens and outer space visitors
and things like that, though that interest waned. And I grew interested in lots of other
things that are unrelated to this. But I was talking with a colleague of mine,
a historian who was working on a book project that involved looking at something I never knew
happened, which was this kind of renaissance of the occult right after World War II in Europe.
And I had asked her at the time, I said, you know, did that whole flying saucer thing,
was that a craze in Europe at the time? She said, I don't know. You ought to look into it and write
something about it. And I just dismissed it out of hand. I was like, I don't have time for that
nonsense. But I spent one summer, I was ill, so I couldn't do traveling as I normally do in the
summer in archives. So I just started going through some digital databases of newspapers
in Germany in the late 40s and 50s, and bam, all these headlines about flying saucers.
And I thought, wow, that's cool. Maybe I'll write that up. I wrote it up as an article.
And then I thought to myself, well, I'd love to see how many other historians like me have
written. Must be tons of historians have done work on this. And then I found one,
one sole book on the history of the subject in 1975 by a historian, by the way, who later on
becomes a subject in my own book because he becomes a kind of true believer and a major
figure in the alien abduction phenomenon. And that's how I got hooked. And I thought,
OK, I'm diving in. It's such an interesting thing to write about because it's sort of like
you don't have to believe that the reports are true in order to factually catalog the history
of it, do you? No. And in my estimation, you know, sort of the way I come at this is from that very
perspective. I make it very clear from the start, I'm not here to try to present evidence that
aliens have been visiting us. But I also don't come from the perspective of the debunker who's
here to just tear down and every opinion, every sighting, rather to do something that you don't
have enough of because, you know, the discussion about UFOs has always had a lot of acrimony
associated with it. I'm here to sort of say, well, hold it. Let's take the kind of general ethos of
most historians and say I'm here to, as you say, chronicle the way in which we've come to think
about and talk about and debate about this subject, that that history is one that we really haven't
thought long and hard about. And especially in this day and age, with a lot of things going on
when it comes to discussions about space and SETI and things like that, seems to me is the time
to sort of revisit that history and think about how we got to the point where we are now.
Definitely. In your opinion, does it all begin with Roswell?
No, it doesn't begin with Roswell. In fact, Roswell is a blip, a really minor blip. It's a very tiny
footnote. When you look at it in the wider perspective, it actually starts a little earlier
than that with a private pilot by the name of Kenneth Arnold, who's flying around Washington
State, around Mount Rainier, looking for a crashed plane. There was a reward for anybody who found it.
And he sees these strange nine kind of pan-shaped objects that are flying at high speeds.
And he comes back. He lands on the ground. He says, I saw some weird stuff and reports it to
the authorities and also the media. And the media starts asking him questions about it.
They ask him, how did these things fly? How would you describe it? He said, they kind of flew like
a saucer might if you skipped it over water. And a very enterprising journalist knew a headline
when they thought of one and called them flying saucers. And within six weeks, Gallup does a
survey of Americans. Within six weeks, nine out of 10 Americans had heard the term flying saucer.
So it starts with him sometime earlier. Roswell pops up as a story for about two days and then
disappears and is never heard of again until you get into, I think, the late 1970s and early 80s.
Some of the cases, like the one you just described, as a neutral person coming at it,
when I've read reports like that, sometimes you can find yourself getting lost in it and
almost sort of just thinking like, that is absolutely incredible. Did you ever find yourself
almost struggling to remain neutral to the point where you're just thinking it's a pilot,
someone who should be trustworthy, you know, someone who knows how aircraft should work?
Were there any real standout cases that you thought, that is just absolutely incredible?
Yeah. They pop up all the time and there's lots of head scratchers. And then there are times you
read something and you say, this doesn't pass the sniff test. But there are absolutely so many
instances where you sit there and you ask yourself that. Now, you know, you come to it and you say to
yourself, especially if you're talking about historical cases where you can't really talk
to anybody anymore, you're left there saying, geez, I wish there was a little more information
about this, or I wish somebody had had a camera at the time or things along those lines. But you,
particularly, yes, when you hear seasoned pilots, for instance, talk and describe things that they
see, who are very knowledgeable, who will say upfront, you know, I'm not one of these UFO
people, right? That is really arresting and it makes you pause, it gives you pause.
And so there's no question in my mind that the great Swiss psychologist, Carl Jung,
put it really, really well. He said, you know, things are seen in the sky, but we don't know
what. And even the authorities, whether it's the UK Ministry of Defence or the United States Air
Force, all have historically fully admitted, there's a whole bunch of cases we can never,
ever explain, we'll never explain. And they make us scratch our heads, but we're sort of left
with a big question mark.
You must find that throughout your work as an historian, as you say, reports of any event
where there's no one around to ask. I'm just wondering how you sort of approach the subject,
maybe differently from, say, an astronomer or an astrobiologist?
Right, right. So what it is, is in the end, it seems to me, there's a couple of things that
it's important to keep in mind. One is language. The language that's often used in the whole UFO
world, if you will, is often very sloppy. I mean, just think of something like the term UFO,
Unidentified Flying Object. Even though it sounds precise, it was minted to replace flying saucer,
because flying saucer was seen as a kind of biased term. UFO is also biased in its own ways,
right? Is that really an object? Flying implies piloting, right? And it implies design, you know,
all of these kinds of things. It's fair to say the same thing holds true with the distinction
between sightings and reports. A sighting is an experience that someone has, right?
But we know that the vast majority of people who see something odd never say anything,
certainly to officials, never to the media or the police or the Air Force. They might say something
to their friends or family, but don't do anything with it. Something has to lead somebody to actually
then report it to some institution. And, you know, it might be a UFO group, it might be
authorities, and they then write it down in some sort of form. It could be a real messy form,
it could be a police officer who's ho-humming it all the time, or it could be a form of some kind.
So what I'm interested in with the stuff of history is really reports. It's these documents
that we have. And again, they oftentimes aren't very detailed. So part of what you do, therefore,
as a historian, is we are ultimately left with trying to work with records, documentation.
That can be a recording, that can be an interview somebody has, but it oftentimes is reports and
self-reports, but also reports by others. So it becomes a conversation about how do we discuss
reports of flying saucers? How have different institutions and different groups grappled with
it, and made that into something that they see as worthy of a conversation, and sometimes worthy
of some sort of action on the part of people who can take action? And do you find any sort of
narrative consistency throughout all the different sources? Because presumably, if it was a particular
species of alien civilization that was visiting us, there would be a consistency, wouldn't there,
in description of craft, and the species themselves, and all that sort of stuff. Did
you find any sort of consistency or is it all over the place? Well, what's kind of interesting
is that's one of the things that changes. I would say when you look particularly in, say,
the first decade or decade and a half of the phenomenon, there is a lot of diversity in terms
of what's reported. So historically, lots of different things, crafts have been seen,
or things that aren't even crafts, right? So the most common thing that people see are lights.
That's the most reported phenomenon. Maybe it's different colors, maybe they flash off and on,
but lights, very, very vague, very blurry, not much more detail than that. But you hear people
talking about cigar-shaped things, saucer-shaped things, globes, hexagonal objects, all sorts of
things. But you really see the diversity when people said, I actually saw the occupants of
these vehicles. And that's where in the 40s and 50s into the early 60s, it's a very, very wide
range, very diverse group of beings that are talked about. Everything from little, small,
as they called them at the time, little men under four feet tall, sometimes as small as under 12
inches. Other times they're large, hairy monsters that sort of look like Sasquatch. There are
robots, there are men, there are females, there are androgynous beings, there are bulbous head,
ugly beings. Some are absolutely gorgeous and look like fashion models, all sorts of things.
What happens over time, and this is what's interesting to me, is that those images start
to winnow down and there becomes a kind of a homogeneity to it all, a kind of a standardization,
if you will, in descriptions. And that to me, in part, is something that signals a role that
culture is increasingly playing in terms of helping to shape those images into images that
are familiar to everyone. Yes. And there must also be idiosyncrasies with regard to the language
that's used at the time of the report or the movies that are out and the songs and popular
culture and things like that. Do you find that reflected in Flying Saucer Reports too?
Well, again, what I love about this history, it confounds every sort of preconception I had. So
I, like most everybody else, was ready to think, oh my God, there must be so much of this kind of
influence of pop culture on certain UFO sightings and reports and the way people describe things
and what happens. And in part there is. There's no question that the pulp science fiction of
the first half of the 20th century had a direct impact on the way in which sort of the early
people promoting the alien visitor story, the way they engaged with it. They were very influenced
by it. And it's not a surprise that most all of the really early, those first few years of people
pushing this narrative, they came out of the pulp science fiction world. So they were very influenced
by it. But where you see something that doesn't quite connect that way is with film. So, you know,
the idea has been always that, oh, I guess films must have a real profound influence on, say,
upticks in this number of sightings. And that doesn't really bear out. You have a very big,
for instance, wave of sightings and reports in the United States, for instance, in 1952.
But there's no major big UFO film from that time period that takes place. Or you could take
something like Steven Spielberg's 1977 film Close Encounters. It's interesting. I talked to one of
the folks who leads one of the big organizations that were looking into UFOs at the time. And I
asked him about it. And he said, what we saw at the time was not an uptick in new sightings.
People weren't seeing UFOs right after the film. But what they did see an uptick in was the number
of people coming forward saying five years ago or three years ago, I saw something that seemed
like that. So it triggered that. And we know from the UK, for instance, that following, what is it,
1982 Spielberg's film E.T., there was actually a downward movement in the number of UFO sightings.
So it doesn't neatly map on to popular culture as much as we like to think at times.
What about, say, geopolitical stuff? Because you often hear people say,
it's not a coincidence that it all kicked off during the Cold War and the Space Age.
That must be what caused it. Did you find that?
Yeah, I definitely would argue that the Cold War plays an absolutely critical role in this.
The UFO as we know it is unimaginable without the Cold War. And it's a specter that haunts
the entire history. You can see it in the sources, in the evidence, right? People are constantly
making references to UFOs. So, for instance, in those early years, one of the questions that
comes up, right, is, OK, the flying saucers are here, they're aliens. Why are they here in 1947,
1948? Why now and not five years earlier, 500 years earlier? And the argument that starts
being put forward is, well, the aliens have seen the atomic bomb explosions. They've seen that we
have unlocked the key to atomic energy. And they are scared. They're either scared for us or they're
scared about us. But they realize we are now, we have reached this sort of level of civilization
that makes us a qualitatively different species. And so that already there from the beginning is
this idea that aspects of the Cold War are folded into this. What I don't see is a lot of what some
people have argued is the case is that various kinds of bad news, right, bad times promotes
more flying saucer panics or flying saucer reports. That seems to me to be a bit of a
problematic argument, because it seems to me prone to cognitive bias. As I always say,
pick up a newspaper from any time period you'd like. And outside of maybe when the Berlin Wall
fell, you will see nothing but mostly bad news. And that's because, as journalists will tell you,
right, journalists are very good at reporting bad news, have a hard time knowing how to make good
news interesting, right? So that seems to me to be a more problematic argument.
I think there's also, certainly in Europe, I would say, and maybe, you know, elsewhere beyond
North America, I think there's a sort of view that the UFO flying saucer phenomenon is sort of
inherently characteristically American. Do you find that a large majority of sightings and reports
are based in the US? And does that then suggest that it's to do with cognitive bias and popular
culture and the culture of the society? No, it's a good point. I mean, look,
I would say the evidence shows that the United States plays a very critical role. It's a hub,
okay? It's a hub in that the news emanating out of the United States is what triggers all this.
And throughout its history, whenever there's a new development, like the newest stuff that's
gone on since 2017, it is something that gets reported everywhere else and everyone else
throughout the world, in the UFO world, especially, stand up at attention and start
thinking about it and writing about it. That said, it's very clear within a few years that
there are hubs that are popping up throughout the world and other places. And the influence
is actually goes in the other direction at times. So there are places in Europe, in South America,
where you see a really pronounced concentration, not only of sightings and reports,
but also activities by UFO organizations. So I would say in Europe, Great Britain, France, Italy,
Spain, all played a very, very big role. Whereas in Germany, for instance, it was a much more
muted phenomenon. One can sort of discuss why that was the case. In South America, Brazil and Chile,
Argentina play major, major roles. And my argument would be, it has to do with whether or not you
have a kind of a civilian UFO organization infrastructure in places where that gets
built up and is sustainable. That's where you see this ability to sort of now articulate these
narratives and lay out these sort of programs to study the phenomenon, but also to have an
impact worldwide on how these things are understood and viewed. That's really interesting.
When you were writing the book and you were researching it all, did you yourself or did
you come across anyone who was attempting to explain each case? Because I always sort of think
that there are so many reports, it can't just be that everyone's a liar. It has to be the case that
some people truly believe what they've seen, or they have seen what they've seen, but it's not
necessarily UFOs, alien species come to visit us. Was there any attempt by you or did you come across
any attempts to sort of explain the strangest cases away? Oh, I see that all the time. I mean,
over the years I've been working on this, I've gotten to know lots and lots of UFOlogists,
of UFO researchers of various kinds, and also talked with people who have had experiences
having contact with aliens or some other kinds of beings. So I've chatted with a lot of folks,
and it's a pretty diverse group of people. I mean, that's one of the things that's also for
outsiders, I think there's a lack of appreciation for just how many diverse perspectives there are
when it comes to this phenomenon in terms of how people approach it.
So you see with a lot of folks I know, they are not really altogether different from the people,
say, over in the UK defence ministry who were very sceptical about it. They're not terribly
different. They themselves will tell you, oh yeah, 95%, if not more, are easily explained.
And in fact, many UFO investigators I talk with, this is one of the things they do all the time.
They get a phone call or they get an email, they look into the case, and they find out it's a
rather mundane explanation. Somebody was floating Chinese lanterns or somebody actually saw, you
know, the Elon Musk Starlink satellites, which, you know, if you see those things in the sky,
right, that is weird. If you don't know what that is, I would call that a UFO sighting, right?
So they do those things and they love doing it. They love it. And that is one of the things I
talk about in the book is the motivations for why people get involved in this stuff.
And it is that ability to be a detective, to crack a case. It's really not altogether different from,
think of your favourite true crime podcasts where everybody's invited to chime in and maybe we'll
crack this case, this cold case. So cracking cold cases and new cases for a lot of people is
extremely exciting. It's what keeps you going. And it keeps you going in the hope that maybe one
day one of those cases are going to come along that might be the one that says, this is not going
to go away, right? After you finished writing the book, did you find it hard to leave the subject
alone? Because I find that myself, it's just such an interesting topic, isn't it? Yeah, it is hard
to leave it alone. I won't be leaving it alone because now, of course, I get a lot of people
wanting to talk with me and contact me about discussing it, which is fine. That's what I wanted
to do about this. And it means also that, yes, I'm going to be working on a new project. The new
project is looking at writing a book about the whole controversy surrounding the alien abduction
phenomenon that was particularly really, really lively in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s. So no,
once you've met the UFOs, they don't leave you alone. They drag you right back in.
Just to finish off, I did want to get your thoughts on the more immediate modern era,
particularly 2017, all the stuff that the Pentagon and the US Navy, and also that argument that
people now make, which is there's no excuse now, really, because everyone has a smartphone in their
pocket. Everyone has a camera in their pocket. Surely we should have footage by now. I just
want to close by getting your thoughts on that question and also what you think about what's
out of the Pentagon and NASA now taking things more seriously. Yeah, the everyone carries a
camera now argument is one I've heard a lot about. And it's actually convinced some
old time UFO investigators that maybe there is not much to this anymore. I've gotten this response
from other UFO researchers who say, we know our iPhones are very good at taking a picture of very
nice food at a restaurant, right? Or your friends at a party. It's not very good. It's not a very
refined or precise instrument for tracking something as complicated as a UFO, right?
So that's part of it. And with regard to 2017 and what's happened since then, yeah, what's new about
it is a couple of things. First of all, the fact that intelligence officials in the United States
have come forward to say unequivocally, these pilots saw real objects. These are not computer
glitches. These are not optical illusions. Something is there. OK, that's unusual. That you
didn't tend to get over the decades is that kind of admission and also their admission that they
have maybe been derelict in taking seriously the reports of pilots, that they've ridiculed them,
that a certain amount of peer and hierarchical pressure has really influenced people not to
report stuff and that that's dangerous. From my position as an academic, what I really find
exciting and interesting is NASA's intervention. NASA said coming forward, getting this independent
panel and this panel saying, OK, we think this deserves and warrants investigation. Let's go
about this in a serious fashion because NASA is about civilian science. It's not about classified
projects. And so adding that legitimacy to me seems to be the really, really unprecedented step.
And that's the thing that I think opens the pathway for people from all sorts of disciplines
to begin considering having conversations about what research projects might look like.
And that's, I think, where we are. That's where we are now. And we'll see over, I think, the next
because I know there's work in the pipeline right now along these lines. I think we'll see over the
five to seven to 10 years where this all sort of takes us. Absolutely. Yeah, it's a fascinating
subject, as I said, and it's one that I personally sort of I enjoy following. I enjoy watching all
the documentaries and enjoy reading the book as well. But yeah, Greg, I want to say thanks for
coming on the podcast. Good luck with the book when it comes out and good luck with your next
venture on alien abductions. I mean, recording the history of that is going to be really,
really interesting, isn't it? Yes, it is. It's going to be a handful. But yeah, I look forward
to it. Thanks for having me on.
