Electric bills are climbing across much of the country while tech companies spend hundreds of billions of dollars a year on new data centers.
In rural Louisiana, a single facility under construction is expected to draw several times the power of the entire city of New Orleans. The question underneath it all is simple: who gets the bill?
The answer is less obvious than it looks, because the system that decides who pays predates AI by a century and was built for a very different kind of growth. What that system does with the cost of one enormous customer is where the pressure on household bills begins.
Ari Peskoe directs the Electricity Law Initiative at Harvard Law School and has spent years studying how the grid gets paid for. He joins us to explain what the data center boom is doing to power prices and why decisions made now will shape household bills for decades. ----- 00:00 – Intro 02:45 – Where Will the Power Come From? 03:38 – Data Centers Driving Power Demand 05:12 – Who Pays for Grid Expansion? 08:50 – Why Transmission Upgrades Are Costly 11:24 – Will Data Centers Raise Power Bills? 14:32 – Should Data Centers Pay Their Share? 16:03 – Can Data Centers Go Off-Grid? 10:03 – How AI Is Reshaping the Grid 20:58 – Why New Power Plants Take Years 23:55 – Can the Grid Keep Up With AI? 25:55 – What Regulators Need to Fix 27:53 – Data Centers Enter a New Era ----- Let's Stay in Contact: • Substack - https://substack.com/@themarketinsidershow • X (Twitter) - https://twitter.com/MktInsiderShow • Linkedin - https://www.linkedin.com/company/market-insider-show/ ----- 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘦𝘹𝘱𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘦𝘥 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘷𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘰 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘨𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘥𝘰 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘯𝘦𝘤𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘳𝘦𝘧𝘭𝘦𝘤𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘰𝘧 𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘬𝘦𝘵 𝘐𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳. 𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘯𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘦𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘱𝘶𝘳𝘱𝘰𝘴𝘦𝘴 𝘰𝘯𝘭𝘺 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘴𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘣𝘦 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭, 𝘪𝘯𝘷𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘵, 𝘰𝘳 𝘭𝘦𝘨𝘢𝘭 𝘢𝘥𝘷𝘪𝘤𝘦. 𝘈𝘭𝘸𝘢𝘺𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘶𝘭𝘵 𝘢 𝘲𝘶𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘧𝘪𝘦𝘥 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘧𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘣𝘦𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭 𝘥𝘦𝘤𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴. 𝘚𝘰𝘮𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘴𝘤𝘳𝘪𝘱𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘮𝘢𝘺 𝘣𝘦 𝘢𝘧𝘧𝘪𝘭𝘪𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴. ----- #ElectricityRates#Utilities#ElectricityBill#AIPower#DataCenter
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Ari Pesco of Harvard University explains how the AI and data center boom is causing a surge in electricity demand. He warns that traditional utility models, which spread infrastructure costs across all consumers, may unfairly raise rates for residential users to fund corporate expansions, urging regulators to shift these financial burdens directly onto data center operators.
The demand for power is going up significantly because of data centers and AI boom. Who's
gonna pay for all of this? Today we sit down with Ari Pesco with Harvard University who's been
studying all of this and looking into what's gonna happen next for consumers and how the data center
boom and AI boom will impact the rates and power supply. The past 15 or so years of electricity
consumption in this country, which on a national level had been flat. But now this growth is in
large measure attributable to these individual facilities. That we end up paying for the
infrastructure, can you explain how it works? This business model of socializing the cost,
spreading the cost to everyone, that worked well generally for the past 100 years or so.
And they profit primarily by building infrastructure and there is no bigger
opportunity for them right now than to build infrastructure to meet the energy demands.
I'm Siamak, welcome to Marketing Insider. Ari, it's great to have you and welcome.
Thanks for having me on. We want to talk to you about power and data centers. You've studied this
a lot and a lot of people are wondering, do we have enough power for these data centers that
are planned to be built? Look, we have enough power today, the lights stay on around the country.
The challenge is that our demand for electricity on a national level is expected to rise
in large measure due to the growth of data centers. These are facilities that the sort of
new generation of these data centers can consume as much electricity as a large city. And so data
centers are not new, they've been part of the sort of architecture, the backbone of our internet
since we've had the internet, but it's the size of these facilities that has really accelerated.
So I could give you just one example. The company Meta is in the process of building a facility
in northeast Louisiana, a rural part of the state, that when it's completed in a few years
will use five to six times the amount of energy electricity that the city of New Orleans uses
on a hot summer day when everybody has their air conditioning turned on and consumption is at
its peak. So a single facility, five to six times as much electricity as the largest city in that state.
Where the electricity would come from? Do we have the capacity to generate this kind of power?
Yeah, look, for that particular facility, the utility down there, a company called
Entergy, is planning to build several gigawatts of new natural gas fired
power plants. And to put that gigawatt into perspective, a nuclear power reactor, sort of a
modern one, the largest ones that we can build, one nuclear reactor is about one gigawatt.
So they're going to build, I think, five or six gigawatts of new capacity to serve this one
particular data center. So, you know, on an energy perspective, that's like building five
or six nuclear reactors for this one facility. How does the power need increase from here?
So how much electricity do we have across the nation and how much do we need? Does it need to
double, triple to meet the demand of these data centers? Well, look, there's a lot of uncertainty
about how much demand we'll see from these data centers. We're certainly not at the level of
doubling or tripling on a national level. The projections are sort of a couple percentage
increase per year, perhaps over the next decade or so. And that sort of compounds. So it's certainly
significant. And it's also significant in the context of the past 15 or so years
of electricity consumption in this country, which on a national level had been flat. And that was a
change from the history of this industry in our country, where since the electricity industry
started, really the very late 19th century, we've been on a persistent path of growth
of electricity usage. And that growth had been correlated with population growth and with
economic development. But we kind of saw a fundamental change in our economy starting
around 2008, where our economy could grow, our population can grow, even as electricity demand
stayed constant. But now we're getting back on that growth trajectory. Data centers are a major
driver, but not the only factor driving an increase in electricity consumption.
Where do you see the impacts will be on electricity rates? You've done a ton of
studies on this about electricity rates going up significantly. And what do you see the rates will
go and how will we get impacted? Yeah, so the challenge here is the business model of your
utility. About 70 percent of American homes and businesses have their electricity delivered to
them by a for-profit utility. This is an industry worth well over a trillion dollars. These are
publicly traded companies. And they profit primarily by building infrastructure. And
there is no bigger opportunity for them right now than to build infrastructure to meet the energy
demands of this next generation of data centers. Now, the traditional business model of these
companies is to build infrastructure and then to spread the costs of that infrastructure onto
everyone's bill. And because these are monopolies, you have no choice but to pay that bill if you
want to keep getting electricity service. And this business model of socializing the cost,
spreading the cost to everyone, that worked well generally for the past hundred years or so when
we saw growth in electricity needs correlating with growth in population, economic development,
the sort of hallmarks of progress that we think about in our modern civilization. But now this
growth is in large measure attributable to these individual facilities. And so it doesn't make sense
to share the costs of this infrastructure with everyone. What makes sense now is to assign those
costs directly to these couple of facilities, these handful of facilities that are driving billions of
dollars in utility spending. And there's another factor at play here as well, which is that in much
of the country, utilities rely on interstate markets to buy electricity. And in any market,
when demand for a product goes up, and here it's the demand for electricity that is increasing,
prices tend to increase as well. And that's going to be particularly true in this industry where it
can take many years to bring more supply, more power plants online to meet this demand growth.
So those two factors, this infrastructure build out and the change in prices in some
interstate power markets, that's going to raise prices for everyone. Effects are going to be
different in different parts of the country. So it's hard to give you a, I can't give you a number,
a particular percentage. And I think we also have to talk about the fact that prices here are
ultimately approved by regulators at the state level and at the federal level. And there have
been some steps taken to mitigate these effects. And there's much more that can be done to make
sure that these costs are paid for by the data centers and not everyone else, but we still have
some way to go to make sure that that is the case. So you mentioned the infrastructure that we end up
paying for the infrastructure. Can you explain how it works? So, you know, one example, one
problematic area for rate payers out there is the high voltage, the high capacity power lines
that make up our interstate power network. So you might see when you're driving along a highway,
for instance, you might see these very tall metal towers with power lines strung between them.
Those are high voltage power lines. They are the backbone of the nation's electricity system.
They connect the very large power plants that generate our power down to the neighborhood level
where it's delivered to your home or your business. And because this next generation
of data centers are demanding so much electricity, again, as much as a city, utilities are finding
that there's not enough capacity in the existing network. And so they need to expand the capacity
of network. They need to build more of these high voltage transmission lines or upgrade the capacity
of some existing lines. This can cost billions of dollars. These are very expensive projects.
And, you know, it's these data centers that are triggering the need for these expenses. And again,
the utilities, in large part, with very few exceptions, still have this traditional
model of when they expand this infrastructure, they spread those costs to everyone. And so
this is happening right now. There was a paper put out at this point now more than a year ago
by an organization called the Union of Concerned Scientists. They looked at utility construction
plans just in one year in just seven states and found $4 billion of these power line upgrades,
transmission line upgrades, that were because of data centers. Again, those costs, again,
spread to everyone in those states. You can look more recently, last year, across one region of
the country where we have this alliance of utilities that stretches from New Jersey over
to Chicago. They together planned $12 billion, again, just in one year of large scale projects
that, again, will be paid for by everyone in the region, even though it's data center growth
is the primary, not the only, but the primary driver of these costs.
You mentioned you couldn't give us percentage points, but in these scenarios, it's hard for
people to understand what does $4 billion mean to them. Is there going to be a significant rise,
like rates doubling or going up by 50%? What are your thoughts on it?
Right. Again, it's certainly not a doubling. We're not certainly there yet. I think what I would say
on that is that we don't know where we are in the data center buildup. There's a lot of
uncertainty around this is caught up in what the future of artificial intelligence is going to be,
what the technological model will be for that, what the business model will be for that,
but we know now that these companies are spending hundreds of billions of dollars a year on
new data centers. If that continues, then we're going to have the power industry racing to keep
up. One utility industry estimate is that the utilities will spend $1.4 trillion over the next
five or so years for infrastructure. It's a massive, massive number. If we're in the early
innings of this data center buildout, the cost effects will increase over time for rate payers,
unless regulators act now to put the right rate structures in place that are protective
of consumers. I can give you one quick actual concrete example. One of these interstate markets
is run annually. It's called the Capacity Auction. It's designed to make sure there's
enough power plant capacity in the region to keep the lights on 24-7, 365.
The price of this annual cost of this auction had been very low. It increased by a factor of 10
in one year as this data center demand started to materialize. Again, this is just one regional
auction for this area going from New Jersey to Chicago. One calculation I saw was that for your
average residential rate payer, your average person living in your standard home, they were
paying about a dollar a month for this auction. Once the price went up, it was now $8 a month
just for that one auction. If you do the math on that, an increase of about $85 a year.
One more estimate I'll throw at you, which is that Virginia happens to be the data center capital of
the world. It's been that way for decades now. It's seeing this next generation of data center
build out as well. The Virginia legislature commissioned a paper in 2024 about data centers,
including the impact on electricity rates. That report concluded that unless they act to change
the rate structures, an average person in Virginia, average homeowner, could be paying $400 a year
for data center related infrastructure and energy.
Wow. Now, the thought is that because these data centers will come online and they're going to
consume more electricity, but they pay a bunch for that, right? Shouldn't that trickle into
their infrastructure costs or the infrastructure costs will get charged to everybody separately?
No. So the idea, I think the way to protect consumers here is to kind of change the
fundamental business model of the utilities, where again, they spread those costs to everyone,
but we're not quite there yet in terms of making sure that data centers are paying for all of their
electricity. A big step forward is that we're starting to see requirements put in place that
data centers contract for new power plants themselves. In other words, rather than relying
on a utility to build the power plant, the data center would have to contract with a
private developer for the new power plant. That would protect consumers because it's the utility
that has the unique ability to spread the cost to everyone. If there's a private contract
between a data center and a developer, there's really not that same ability to spread those costs
to everyone. So we're starting to see some states kind of put that sort of requirement in place.
It's by no means universal at all. And again, that's just one component of this.
We still have those transmission costs that I was mentioning, discussing earlier.
Now there is a lot of talk about that because there's a backlash that doesn't allow these
data centers to be built fast enough. And some people were saying, there's thought that
why don't the data centers build their own power plants? And do they still need to be
connected to the grid? And how does that work in this mix? In theory, no, they could be totally
isolated and islanded system that's not connected to the network in general. My understanding is
that the data center companies don't want to do that because if you can connect to the network,
you get all the benefits of that connection and the reliability benefits. Because if you're islanded,
and your power plant goes down, as power plants do from time to time for any number of reasons,
then you're out of luck and you're out of power. But the whole point of the network is redundancy.
We intentionally overbuild the network so that if any component goes down,
or even several components go down, you can still reliably receive electricity.
One thing though that we are finding is that there's sort of a hybrid approach
that may be appropriate here where the data center does connect to the network,
but it also has its own power plant that's also connected to the network.
So it's largely self-sufficient, but still, when it needs to, can rely on that network.
And that's leading to a lot of very technical debates between regulators, utilities,
and data centers about what's the right amount to charge the data center for that sort of
backup service. We have the data center developers we haven't really talked about.
These are some of the wealthiest corporations in the world, and they've become increasingly
sophisticated about this space. They have now large teams of experts who are out there negotiating
these deals, whether it's with a utility, private power plant developer. And so they're very
sophisticated players now and are certainly capable of figuring this out. They're now feeling
some pressure from the White House, from the public generally, to pay for their own infrastructure.
But they really need the utilities to help them with that, to put in place the right structures
that are going to prevent the sort of infrastructure costs being borne by everyone.
And as I said, this is a business model that utilities have relied on for 100 years.
And I think to some extent, they just want to keep the status quo intact because again,
that's been a reliable way for them to make money. And this data center opportunity is
really a generational opportunity for them to build infrastructure in a way that they have not
done in quite a long time. And Ari, do you think we're going to have a significant change to the
grid here after these developments happen? Since we've had the past couple years, this
data center boom, we've seen a lot more interest in natural gas fired generation, natural gas power
plants, both from these hyperscale companies, from the utilities and the industry more broadly.
So I think we're seeing an acceleration of natural gas development that's coincided with
the current administration in D.C. being hostile to wind and solar. And it's to be determined how
of a slowdown we may see on that front. The potential downside for the public, I think,
is that this is essential shared infrastructure, this high voltage power line system. You just
think about your daily life and how important electricity is. Probably everyone takes it for
granted, but it's absolutely critical to everything that we do. And it ought to be designed
for the public benefit and not for the benefit of a handful of the wealthiest corporations
in the world. And so my concern is that as we may be spending hundreds of billions of dollars over
the next decade or so expanding this system, that we not design it just for this one particular type
of consumer. Keep in mind the reliability benefits for everyone, the potential to use it to expand
clean energy for everyone and to lower the cost of power for everyone, which is the promise of what
this system can do. When it comes to bringing new power plants online into a utility system,
is that very difficult or does it depend on the state and regulations or is it something we can
achieve fast? Yeah, so I mean there's a few challenges if you want to build a new power
plant. One challenge right now is that, as I mentioned before, natural gas is now the preferred
fuel and building a natural gas fired power plant involves acquiring a number of component parts
that are scarce these days. And so the industry, the sort of suppliers of these components are
racing to catch up with demand right now. But right now you may have to get on a years-long
waiting list to get some of these key parts. A second challenge is getting a permit from the state
to build your natural gas fired power plant or other type of power plant.
And different jurisdictions are going to take different amounts of time for that. Again, if you
want to build, go to Texas because they'll probably process your application pretty quickly and give
you that permit. Other states is going to depend on what type of plant you want to build. Certain
states may not want to see more natural gas. Other states are somewhat hostile towards wind and solar.
And the third piece is now once you have those processes in line, you got your components,
you know where you're going to be able to get that permit, you have to connect to the high voltage
transmission system because that's how you deliver your power to consumers is connecting to that
system. And that process has all its own bottlenecks that the industry has been trying to solve for
several years. There's been some progress there, but it may still take a few years before you get
permission to interconnect to the system. Is it the permissions that takes a long time for
the connection or is it the technology? So here it's the permission. It's not government
permission. It's utility industry permission. I mean, you know, connecting a new large power
plant is not sort of just like plugging something in, right? You have to make sure that the system
keeps working, that all the physics work out. And historically, those studies had taken a long time.
Again, the industry is trying to solve that problem, trying to do it faster. But what often
is the case when you're adding a very large scale, either power plant or consumer of power,
like these data centers, is that the utility discovers that, in fact, there's not enough
capacity in the network to handle this new generator or consumer. And so it has to upgrade
the network. And that's really what also can often add many years is building out the capacity
need in the network. Do you think we're going to be able to build this infrastructure as fast as
the data centers are demanding? And again, I don't have the most precise numbers on this,
but to give you just one example here, the Texas market, which actually includes almost
all of Texas, you can measure it in gigawatts. Again, as I said before, one gigawatt is one
nuclear reactor. The entire Texas market in terms of the demand is about 85 gigawatts maximum demand.
At some point, I saw a figure that the request to connect to the system from new data centers
was more than 200 gigawatts, right? So the idea that you would almost triple the size of the
system over sort of a five to 10 year period seems kind of crazy. It's kind of ludicrous
that you could build out the system that quickly. Now, the thing is some of those requests aren't
real. They're speculative. They're the developers that want to see if they can connect quickly,
find a data center customer right there, and just sort of make a quick buck off of it. But
once they realize they don't have a plan, they'll drop out. And so it's hard to know
how to sift through that and know what's real. The industry, again, is getting better at that.
But so the sort of sky-high projections are not attainable. There will be something, you know,
demand is going to increase. The industry is going to build out the system. We'll probably
have some disappointed data center developers in that process. From the perspective of sort of you
or I worried about perhaps the national economy, our competitiveness, our electricity prices,
is any of that going to matter to us? I'm not sure of that. Maybe we would be upset if we really were
at a major deficit, really couldn't meet the moment, really couldn't develop what may be a
promising technology. Maybe that would really matter to ordinary people. I don't know if that's
going to be the situation. Do you have any thoughts for the regulators and people that
what should they do to fix this? Should there be a national regulation on this where
that the payers, the users of power should pay for? Yeah, these are long-term investments.
You know, when a utility builds a piece of infrastructure like a new transmission line,
it's going to be paid for over a 30, 40 year period. It may be there for much longer than
that. And so we got to get the structures in place now and then we have to monitor how they're
actually working over time. So one unfortunate consequence of this is that regulatory agencies
are often at a disadvantage compared to the utilities they're supposed to regulate.
Regulatory agencies tend to be small. State legislatures tend not to enjoy giving them
more money and more resources. Meanwhile, the utilities that they're supposed to be regulating
are these multi-billion dollar companies that have a lot of resources. And one classic challenge for
regulators is that it's the utilities that hold all of the information about what infrastructure
might be needed, how much it might cost, how you operate it, etc. They have the expertise too.
They have the expertise, they have the information. Regulators are always trying
to catch up and it's just hard to regulate utilities. And I guess what I was getting
at was that this data center challenge is requiring a lot of regulatory attention,
which means rather than regulators spending time thinking about how the power system can be made
better for everyone, they're having to spend their time and resources just trying to protect
everyone from the consequences of just a handful of these new facilities. Some people are arguing
that the companies that have gotten into the AI space and they're building data centers,
they used to build software. And when you build software, you just need some technology,
some equipment to build it. But now they're getting into building heavy infrastructure,
which might take years and years. What are your thoughts on that?
Well, as I said, these data centers have been part of our internet backbone
for decades. Google has had its own data centers for a long time, Facebook, etc. They all have.
But again, what we're really seeing is a change in scale. And that matters for how much energy
these facilities consume and therefore how much money utilities are spending to supply
these facilities. So these may have been small warehouses you would have never noticed if you
drove by one on a highway. And now these facilities are physically imposing. And what you don't see
is, again, the fact that they are using as much electricity as a large city. And that's what's
really new here. Ari Pesco, it was great to have you on Market Insider.
All right. Thanks so much. What do you think about this conversation with Ari?
Do you think we have to create regulation for data centers to pay more for the buildout of
the infrastructure? Or do you think we should leave it alone and let the utility companies
deal with it? Tell us in the comments. I'm Siamak. This is Market Insider. We'll see you next time.