How Old Is War? The Origins of Human Warfare and Violence Explained

Memorial Warrior
7 followers
#memorialwarrior
#Storiesaboutsoldiers
#Stories from WWII Veterans
# Moments of War
#Perspectives of War
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis presentation examines the anthropological and archaeological origins of warfare, arguing that it is a cultural phenomenon rather than an innate biological drive. By analyzing prehistoric sites, weaponry, and primate behavior, the speaker explores the tension between human aggression and altruism, ultimately suggesting that cooperation is as fundamental to the human experience as conflict.
There's this really famous story, right, of this Japanese soldier who kept on fighting I think
two or three decades after World War II ended. This individual, Hiroo Onoda, came from a family
in Japan that subscribed to the Bushido code of the samurai warrior. He is sent to the Philippines
and then right around 1944 his commanding officer left him in the jungles and said,
my last order to you right now is to stay here, never surrender, never take your own life,
and keep fighting. The war ends a year later. Leaflets are dropped into the jungles saying
that the war is over. And he just didn't believe. This guy who kept on fighting three decades later
right until very famously they had to really prove to him that the war was over. The old
commanding officer was located, came back to the Philippines, found him, relieved him of his duties.
It wasn't necessarily that he wanted to fight. I mean maybe he did or maybe he was just doing what
he was told to do. But he said the reason why he kept doing this was because of honor. I tell this
story because for me this encapsulates the idea that warfare for us is a cultural thing. We fight
for beliefs, we fight for slights of honor, we fight because our families tell us to, because
our country tells us to, because the gods will us to. For me as an anthropologist, the story
of the origins of war is as old as the story of humanity itself.
Today in four major war zones, over a hundred maneuver battalions, the performance of the
United States Army has made it abundantly clear to the enemy and the world that it is holding
the line for freedom and will not be driven from the battlefield. We're standing here today
at the Wisconsin Veterans Museum in downtown Madison, which has been here since 1901,
serving a mission of education and inspiration, telling the stories of our men and women who have
served from the Civil War through the present day. Whatever your feelings are about war, it is
essential and vital for us to understand these histories and these experiences, to tell a larger
story about humanity and humanity's relationship to war. It's a story that goes back not just
centuries or thousands of years, but hundreds of thousands of years. And it's one that has inspired
me because of my own family history. My father related to the Korean War, and my mother related
to the Vietnam War. It is a story that is best told through an anthropological lens.
Before we can even embark on that journey, we have to define what we mean by warfare.
So defining warfare is always the big question, right? The issue is there's probably as many
definitions of warfare as there are papers that have been written about warfare. If you're a
military historian, you might define warfare at a level that we're never going to see in the past.
War that's done nowadays is very, very different. Someone today can sit in an office and push a
and the button can have a drone shoot out a missile. That's very different than what happened
in the past. For some scholars, warfare is defined as something that is relatively recent, modern.
I've even seen criteria attached to war, where unless you meet a minimum threshold of battle
fatalities, some would argue maybe it's a thousand. Unless you meet that minimum threshold,
you're not looking at war. I think that putting a number on it is maybe not the best way to go
about looking at war from a historical time period, because there weren't that many people
for a long time. Living in big, massive groups, like we live in what we call city-states or
nation-states, that's a fairly recent adaptation, a recent way of living. The other reason why
putting a number on it becomes difficult is we can't know how many people were involved in war
until we have written records. So if you're going to put a number on it, you're going to sort of
bias yourself already. When we think about war, we have these images that get conjured up
about certain kinds of technologies or tactics or strategies, certain kinds of forces amassed
on a battlefield that look very different than what warfare might have looked like with various
societies of the past. The idea of warfare being restricted to conflict between nations, I think,
is problematic. The definition of war as between nation-states works now, but as anthropologists,
we tend to take more of an all-encompassing view of warfare. A more useful definition that allows
us to study warfare as a phenomenon would be looking at armed conflict or forms of
organized aggression and violence between various communities. Organized violence between socially
distinct people. Historical records from the last several centuries give us plenty of examples
of warfare among nation-states. But for archaeologists to start going back further in time,
we don't see the same kinds of nation-states that we see in the last couple centuries. We see other
kinds of societies that are just as complex, large-scale, and powerful. And we see clear
evidence between the centralized authority and forms of violence. On the temple walls of Angkor Wat,
we see clear depictions of armies, of elites, and royal figures sitting on top of war elephants
in the same time period, about a century apart. But on the other side of the world,
in the area right outside of St. Louis, modern-day St. Louis, we have a site known as Cahokia.
And around this particular settlement, we have clear evidence of a palisade wall. We also see
evidence of rituals related to burials and elites, where we have humans that have been sacrificed
as part of the mortuary rituals for these high-status individuals. It's these kinds of
clues that tell us a very clear connection between ideology and politics and power. And some would
argue that that's where warfare begins, is this time period where states begin to monopolize power
and promulgate forms of warfare. So the Talents Valley case is a very interesting one for the
purposes of warfare. The original interpretation was that at around 1200 BC, which is right around
the time of the Trojan War, that something very significant happens along this river.
And at Talents, what we find is 140 or so humans, skeletons of warriors. These are people who are
30 to 40 years old. They show evidence of marks on their bones where they were injured previously.
So maybe they're a warrior class of people. And we also can see they died violent deaths.
From these early investigations, it's clear that something significant may have happened here,
with lots and lots of individuals being involved. And the bone chemistry indicates that some people
were native, but many of them were from farther away. Perhaps there was a battle or a series of
battles that took place here. What's interesting about this is that this is not written down
anywhere. There's no historical record of these events occurring. The more recent evidence is
suggesting that potentially this might have been a caravan that was moving through and that was
ambushed by professionals. We don't know much about why the battle was fought. We don't know
what caused it. But we see so many people die, and then the site itself is fairly large,
and they've only excavated a small part of it. You know, it makes us think that at Talents,
something really interesting happened. Whatever the case might be, what is clear is that it's
organized violence that is occurring here. We also have some genetic evidence from the bones there
that shows that some of the skeletons are female. So suggesting again that warfare in the past was
maybe different than we think of it today. Various kinds of events like this are happening
that we might have no idea about from written records. So with cases like the Talents Valley,
we have a clear idea that groups of people are converging in one location and engaging in
conflict, organized forms of conflict and warfare. But we can look at other kinds of cases that maybe
are not so clear cut. If we go further back in time, about 5,000 years ago, back in the 1990s,
some hikers came across the remains of an individual in the Alps who has become known
as the Iceman, Ötzi. Ötzi, about 5,300 or so years ago, was walking in the Alps and died. And that
was a rough day for Ötzi. I mean, it sucked. And his body got covered in snow and ice,
and somehow over these last 5,000 years, with glaciers moving, the body stayed the same. So
it's an amazing preservation. We don't just have Ötzi's body. We have the clothes he was wearing.
We have the hat he wore, his backpack, the medicine he carried with him. We know he had
tattoos on his body. We know right down to his last meal, the contents of his stomach.
We also know from that evidence that he had injuries on his body. From various kinds of
investigations and scans, we could see that perhaps there was a laceration along his collarbone,
severing an artery. He had injuries on his hands. We also have an idea that he may have been involved
in some kind of fight with several individuals based on residues, blood residues. All of this
suggests that Ötzi probably was killed by at least one, maybe several people. When he was first found,
they had a very elaborate story of how he died, that maybe he got caught in a snowstorm. But we
now know that he was murdered. Someone shot him with an arrow in the back left shoulder.
Very clearly, we can talk about homicide. For some, maybe this is an indication of warfare.
But I think this is a bit more speculative, and this outlines some of the challenges that
archaeologists face. I don't necessarily know if it gives us that much insight into the origins
of war, but it certainly tells us that weaponry was there and people were using it against each other.
Is this warfare? Is there a larger cultural context of communities in conflict with one
another? Or could this have been a hunting accident or a family dispute of some kind?
That is still debatable. So I think it kind of gets to sort of the heart of the problem for
talking about the origins of war, is that we are sort of sometimes biased in how we want to view
the record. If you're coming in with a notion that humans are innately warlike, that's evidence of war
in the Copper Age. If we're more optimistic about human behavior, that's just evidence
of somebody who got into a kerfuffle with somebody else and got shot.
Was there warfare before cities and civilizations and farming lifestyles? For many researchers,
that's the sort of crux of the debate. For some, it is when we have those kinds of activities and
behaviors that warfare begins in earnest. I would argue that warfare existed well before them. As
soon as people start writing things down and talking about their societies and their histories,
there's discussion about violence of warfare. The Narmer Palate, dating to about 5,000 years ago,
clearly depicting evidence of sieges against towns of enemies laying at the ground,
that's about 5,000 years ago. For some people, that's the mid-Holocene, the beginning of war.
But if we go further back in time to about 7,000 years ago, some of the earliest farming villages
that we have in Europe, with clear evidence of violence, of fortified villages, of even massacres,
we can go even further back to sites like Jericho, dating to about 10,000 to 11,000 years ago.
Jericho does come up quite a bit in discussions of warfare and the origins of warfare.
The site is really interesting. It has a wall that looks like it collapsed and has a tower.
As for the archaeological interpretation of this stuff, it gets really tricky because at that time
in that area, there's no other evidence of interpersonal violence, really. There are no
other sites that have fortifications that have walls. So we, I think, sometimes see walls and
we think, well, why build a wall? We want to keep people out. But walls can have other functions,
too, right? Walls sometimes keep people in. So if you want people to pay a tax before they enter the
city, you might want to build a wall. Maybe the walls exist for protection against flooding or
what have you. This is a sort of litmus test. Some researchers look at that and would argue
it's probably for flood control, maybe to keep animals in or out, but it's not warfare.
Others, however, look at those sorts of indicators and suggest there is a healthy
concern over security. And potentially, this is one of the earliest examples of a fortified
settlement that we find anywhere in the world. I guess my point with Jericho is that we kind of
get walled in, so to speak, right? We see these things and we define them by, oh, the only reason
these things exist are for war, because that's what we sort of want to think about. So there is
this sort of notion that if you're hunting and gathering, which is the majority of humanity's
history, when there's trouble, it's much more efficient and less costly to just pick up and
leave. Once you start investing in land, however, this is where you live. This is where you have
various beliefs about your surroundings, rituals that are related to the land. Your ancestors may
be buried here. You're less likely to just pick up and leave, and you're much more likely to
defend that territory. So with cases like Jericho, for many people, that's the earliest,
and that would explain the emergence of warfare. But we can actually point to other archaeological
cases that extend the time depth even further back. My name is Dr. Anna Meakin-Milks. I'm a
Paleolithic archaeologist, and I specialize in early weaponry. We're here today in Clacton-on-Sea
in the UK, because about a hundred years ago, an extraordinary discovery was made.
Now, when we think about early weaponry, we might be tempted to think about
violence and warfare, but in fact, we need to think more broadly than this.
So I think we do have some clear examples of human violence and probably organized violence
later on in the archaeological record. Tollens Valley is a nice example, I think, where we can
say that looks a lot like organized violence and quite a scaled-up level of violence. However,
I think when we start to move back in time, we start to get a little bit more speculative
about the nature of some of the trauma that we see on the human remains that we find.
I would argue that signs of trauma can sometimes hint at signs of warfare. So with something like
Otzi, we have evidence of trauma, we have evidence of violence, and of homicide, but we don't know
for sure if it's evidence of warfare. We can look at other kinds of cases that can give us a wider
view of the cultural context. Sites like Jebel Sahaba in modern-day Sudan. The dating of the
site is really difficult, but maybe 13,000 years ago or so. The end of the Pleistocene, the end of
the Ice Ages, site number 117, where we have something like 60 individuals in this cemetery.
This is part of hunter-gatherer societies that have come and put their deceased members into
this particular cemetery context. And what's interesting about this is with these 60 individuals,
about a quarter of them show clear signs of trauma on their remains. They died through sort of acts
of what we call interpersonal violence. Hit on the head, or like shot with an arrow. Because again, we
find embedded arrowheads in their graves. We also see more than half of these individuals
exhibiting signs of healed trauma. Suggesting that, you know, there was, if not endemic warfare,
certainly violence was a very common thing in their lives. That's why this particular kind of
case is very important to consider, because this is before full-scale farming, this is before any
kinds of cities existed anywhere in the world, this is before large-scale civilizations, complex
societies, and yet we see signs of organized violence potentially happening. So Jebel Sahaba for
quite some time, for a couple of decades, has been widely viewed as one of the earliest examples
of organized violence that we can see in the archaeological record. There is another case that
has come up quite recently from modern-day Kenya, the site of Naderuk. It's a rather recent find.
Archaeologists just announced it a couple of years ago. And at the site, there's a bunch of
skeletons, including 12 individuals, who seem to have died and weren't buried. They just died there,
they got covered eventually. There are signs of trauma on their bodies. We have points that have
been embedded, made out of obsidian. There's at least one or two individuals, the way they died,
and the way they were lying on the ground, may have been bound with rope. What appears to have
happened is that they were potentially ambushed by another group of people, a larger-sized party,
and then killed and left in place. The other aspect that is interesting to consider is that
in looking at some of those artifacts, the obsidian points for instance, they appear to
have come from some other source. So it is possible that we have groups of people who happen to meet
at this one location, hunting and gathering communities, resulting in this particular event.
This is quite different than what we see at Jebel Sahaba. And this is a case that dates to the start
of the Holocene, about 10,000 years ago. But once again, showing us that smaller-scale societies,
non-sedentary, non-farming societies, still engaging in forms of organized violence deep in the past.
If we go back further in time, there are indications that might be a bit more speculative.
We go to the modern-day parts of the UK, for instance, Goff's Cave. We have, at around 15,000
years ago, an example of individuals, several individuals, who appear to have been disarticulated
and dismembered, and maybe even subject potentially to cannibalism, where we have evidence of skull
cups. Some suggest evidence of cannibalism. But is cannibalism evidence of warfare?
I am probably unhealthily interested in cannibalism. And I think a lot of people are,
right? We're interested in things that seem odd or wrong, and cannibalism seems like the
ultimate thing that we shouldn't do. It seems so unhuman. I think cannibalism presents a really
interesting case, because we think of cannibalism as a violent act. With cannibalism, we often don't
know the intention. We take ourselves out of our modern-day context and think about the
possibilities that cannibalism might have been fulfilling other roles for societies in the
Paleolithic. With cannibalism, sometimes it happens because they have no other choice.
There are possible examples of starvation cannibalism, where consumption of humans may
have been the line between life and death for those who were still around. Anthropologists
often distinguish between what we call exocannibalism and endocannibalism. Endocannibalism
is eating members of your own community, and exocannibalism is eating members outside of your
community. So if you're able to distinguish, if you're able to say this is exocannibalism,
you're eating people who are not in your own community, that could be a sign of war. And we
do know of historic times when people would eat the dead they killed as an ultimate insult.
We also need to consider the possibility, a strong possibility, I think, in the Paleolithic
that cannibalism represented a way of treating the dead. This is a sort of maybe a cultural way
of dismembering or de-skinning these members of a society before they were buried. This is a sign
of respect and a way of treating those who have passed away in a way that maybe keeps these
members of your society as a part of you. We don't really know for sure. It's very difficult to tell
from the archaeological record exactly when we're seeing violence or when we're seeing something
respectful and ritual. Which is a very long way to say cannibalism can be the outcome of warfare,
but it doesn't have to be. And in order for us to know it is, we're going to need a really
large-scale resolution. We're going to need to see more examples than just somebody's eating
somebody else. I think we see quite a number of examples of what we might interpret as organized
violence, but at the end of the day it's really difficult to make a final assessment of these
sites. For example, we can think about a Neanderthal from Shanidar Cave, Shanidar III,
who had a rib puncture which looks very much like an impact from a projectile weapon of some sort.
Now whether this individual encountered someone in a large-scale violent encounter, whether there
was a small-scale interpersonal violent encounter, whether in fact this was a hunting accident,
is actually something that's very difficult to tell from the archaeological record. This is just
one individual. But then if we go further back in time, interestingly, we actually have a really
old example of what looks like clear violence in the archaeological record. And that's from
a site called Cima de los Huesos in Spain. That site dates to about 400,000 years ago,
and it's probably the earliest Neanderthals that we have. And there is an individual amongst that
assemblage of human remains that has two blows to the front skull, which look very clearly like
repeated blows with the same tool. And that, I think, for me and for a lot of archaeologists,
feels like a very clear sign of human violence. In 1911, Samuel Hazel Dean Warren, who was an
amateur geologist, was looking at deposits in this general area, in the West Cliff deposits
in Clacton. And he discovered something really incredible, the broken point of what is widely
interpreted as the tip of a wooden spear. And if that is correct, that it is a wooden spear,
then this is the earliest weapon that has ever been discovered. So unfortunately, the Clacton
spear is a broken artifact, and therefore it's a little bit difficult to interpret exactly what it
is and how it was used. But what I have here is a replica of one of the spears from a site called
Schöningen in Germany. And that site, which dates to about 300,000 years ago, is a really clear
example of these weapons being designed for hunting. The reason is that not only are there
10 wooden spears preserved at that site, but there are also scores of butchered animals at that site,
including butchered horses and red deer. And therefore we can see at that archaeological site
clear evidence of these weapons being associated with hunting activities of hominins deep in the
Paleolithic record. So when we find these early examples of weaponry in the archaeological record,
really what we're looking at is probably not warfare at that point in time. We find these
weapons associated with the remains of butchered animals and really signs of consumption of these
animals. And so the best interpretation for the earliest weapons is that they were used
for hunting. And it was an important point also that the hominins were sharing this environment
with some large and dangerous prey, like saber-toothed cats, for example. And so these
weapons would have been important for self-defense as well. We can't say for sure that they weren't
used in violent encounters and that may have been the case, but we have no evidence whatsoever of
any sort of large-scale organized violence early in the Pleistocene. If we go to Spain, modern-day
Spain, to the Atapuerca Mountains, there's a site known as Grandolina. The remains here are associated
with a population that we call Homo Excessor. But within this particular setting, there are
individuals who also appear to have been mutilated, dismembered, and butchered. So signs of cannibalism.
And this has prompted some researchers to speculate that perhaps we are looking at some of the earliest
evidence for warfare that exists anywhere in the world at 800,000 years ago. It's intriguing
and it tells us that something could be happening,
but whether or not it's warfare is, I think, quite ambiguous.
So the question of how old warfare is, like do primates engage in warfare, do non-modern humans
engage in warfare, is really the big question we have. If you think warfare is very, very old,
you might want to look to the non-human primates and say, are they doing warfare?
So we definitely see cases of aggression in primates, but probably, as far as we know,
there isn't a lot of advanced planning. Unless we are looking at chimpanzees, one of the closest
species to humans, you see forms of aggression towards other groups that are comparable to early
forms of warfare in humans. Early forms of warfare in humans are considered to be
ambushes and raids. Some communities of chimpanzees do raids relatively frequently,
so you see usually males moving very quietly and silently into the territory of another community,
and if they find a single male or an isolated couple of individuals that they outnumber,
they will attack these individuals and kill that animal. And these forms of raids show some level
of organisation that you see in early human warfare, but you don't see the complexity of
organisation that you see in human warfare in terms of
different platoons, different soldiers with different tasks and so on.
Also similar to humans, you can have dominance hierarchies that are relatively long-lasting
and stable between groups. There are some countries that are more powerful than others
in terms of technology, population size and so on. You see something similar in non-human primates.
There are some groups that are either larger or composed of more adult individuals that are very
often dominant over smaller groups, meaning that when these two groups encounter, usually the
The difference I think is between humans and non-human primates is clearly in the use of tools.
As far as we know, non-human primates don't use tools for aggressive interactions between groups,
while humans, including early humans, as far as we know, use tools to compete and to fight with
Certainly, human advanced cognition allows us to perform a number of different tasks.
And one of the things that has been proposed in explaining our advanced cognition is that we
perform what is very often called Machiavellian intelligence, so our capacity to use the behaviour
of others for our own advantage. For example, screaming, there's a fire in the building,
so everybody leaves and I can eat the cake that is left there without any competition from other
people. So, advanced cognition allows us to perform a number of different tasks.
What type of task we perform usually is explained by our end goal and what we gain from these tasks.
So, theory says that we should only display aggression when the chances of getting the
benefits are high and when the benefits outweigh the potential costs. Now, there's a difference if
you analyse aggression in terms of cost and benefits between human aggression, modern warfare
and what you observe in animals. In humans, during war, especially in technologically advanced warfare,
you can shoot weapons, you can shoot a cannon, you can fire a cannon from a distance and inflict
severe harm to your enemies at relatively little cost for yourself. In animals, aggression always
involves an element of risk because animals need to get close to each other to fight and so even
if an animal is larger and more powerful than another one, getting into a fight is always
dangerous. And this could be an explanation why aggression in humans is more common, especially
warfare, than aggression that you observe in animals. Because in humans, the cost of violence
and the cost of warfare, especially for the political leaders, becomes minimal but the benefits are
extremely high. This kind of behaviour that's been observed has prompted some researchers to argue
perhaps we've evolved to become this way and that chimpanzees have evolved to become this way.
And if that's true, then perhaps our last common ancestor, going back several million years ago,
may have behaved much a similar way as well. So this has begged the question whether or not we've
evolved to become quite violent, whether or not violence and warfare are parts of our innate
sorts of evolutionary development. I think a lot of us, either explicitly or implicitly, thinking
about the origins of warfare are influenced by 2001 A Space Odyssey. So I think maybe one of the
problems with that opening sequence is that it encapsulates what a lot of people may still think
about human nature as being violent. There's a scene where these apes are around an obelisk
and they pick up the bone and one of them whacks the bone when they think of somebody else.
Primates discovering bone tools and discovering weapons and then using them quite quickly in
violent encounters, you know, going from hunting and then associating that hunting to
violence against another group. We sort of see that as the impetus, what we sometimes call
the prime mover. We see the hominin throwing that bone into the air and it cuts from that scene into
the future in space. And one of the implications of that particular sequence then is perhaps it's
that bloody past, that violent past that propelled our evolution into the future, allowed us to be
successful. I don't believe the opening scene of the 2001 A Space Odyssey is really a reliable and
true representation of human nature. If we think about it, it glosses over millions of years of
history and humanity and change. It's very much a product of its time. There was a very popular
writer at the time named Robert Ardrey and he was actually a failed American playwright. He went to
Africa and met a paleoanthropologist, Raymond Dart. He was trying to make the case that
australopithecines had discovered bone tool technologies and weapons. And so Robert Ardrey
took this idea, which wasn't very popular with the other scientists at the time, and he popularized
it. And these illustrations of these australopithecines discovering these bone weapons
was something that really captured the public imagination hugely in the post-World War era,
when people were really trying to find a justification and a reason for understanding
the huge level of violence that the world had gone through in the early 20th century.
I think it's very interesting to think about the topic of gender and warfare,
especially from a Western standpoint, where we sort of have this view, many of us do, that might
be biased. There are some scientists out there who will say, well, war is a man's game or violence is
a man's game. And, you know, my response is, of course, anything as stupid as war would have to
be a man's game. But I also think that gender is a reflection of a way society deems certain people
should act. Well, we see men as not only the hunter, but men as the warrior. And we see women
in a very different light and different role, maybe as passive participants in war, maybe as
victims of war. But I think the historical record, as well as the archaeological record, tell us a
very different side of that kind of puzzle. We can go back and look at various cases throughout
human history where women not only participated in various aspects of war, but on equal footing
with men. And here I'm thinking about various cases with my own ancestry, for instance. In
Vietnam, there are legends and historical texts that talk about an uprising that happens in the
first century AD. These two sisters, known as the Trung sisters, leading a rebellion against the Han
Empire, who were trying to come in and colonize northern Vietnam. They led a rebellion and led
armies against the Han Empire. Across the Eurasian landmass, right around the same time in the UK,
for instance, there are stories about Boudicca, who leads an uprising against the Roman Empire.
In the Shang Dynasty, for instance, this is the Bronze Age of China. In the Royal Cemetery,
there's one particular tomb that has hundreds of artifacts, jades, bronzes,
weapons. And what's interesting about this tomb is that we know its occupant, its main person of
honor, was a woman. She led armies, she gave birth, she was a religious figure by the name of Fu Hao.
There's a very well-known Viking burial site in Sweden known as Birka. This particular site dates
to about a thousand years ago. In the tomb, we have the remains of this individual, we have horse
remains, we have weapons, and all kinds of artifacts that are prototypically representative
of a Viking high-status warrior. And for years, this Viking was interpreted as a male. And then
a couple of years later, geneticists did genetic testing and found that the individual was
biologically a female. And it made the press, the media was talking about it. People were asking,
are you sure you did this correctly? Are you sure that this is indeed a female? But maybe there was
a mistake made in the analysis. For me, it's somewhat symptomatic about our own Western bias.
We seem surprised, but maybe the people in the past weren't surprised. Maybe we're just putting
our beliefs onto the past. Studying gender is really, really tricky because it is almost
impossible for us to forget what we culturally know. We have to shed our sorts of biases about
gender, that gender can be very fluid in various contexts around time and space in the world,
and that there are various categories that don't necessarily fit to this male-female binary
that we accept in many Western societies today. I think if we're going to ask the question about
the origins of human violence and how far back in the archaeological record can we see
signs of violence, we also have to ask the question about human altruism. How good are
we at looking after one another? And actually, the evidence for altruism in the archaeological
record goes back quite a lot farther than any clear evidence of violence. So just like that
example of violence in Shanidar Cave, we also see evidence on Shanidar 1, Nyandutul, of a significant
level of support that that individual would have had from society. This was an individual who had
multiple injuries throughout their life, were probably partially blind if not fully blind in
one eye, had a withered arm, likely injuries or difficulties with walking. So this individual
would have needed a lot of support from its society in order to get to the age that they did
when they died. And we see lots of examples of this sort of social care of the disabled,
of the elderly, of the sick, and of the young in not just our own society, Homo sapiens,
but also in Nyandutuls and even as far back as Homo erectus and Homo ergaster.
One of the earliest examples we have of altruism comes from a site called Dmanisi in Georgia,
which dates to about 1.7 million years ago. So this is Homo erectus and one of the
skulls found in the assemblage actually had no teeth. And we think that probably this individual
would have had to have their food chewed for them in order to survive. And so I think this
is a really interesting example and a really sort of nice way of thinking about, you know,
the archaeological record shows us all sorts of things. And yes, we see signs of violence,
but we also see signs of our own genus, the entire genus of Homo looking after one another.
I don't believe in the idea that humans are more aggressive than other species. In fact,
if you want to make a comparison between humans and chimpanzees, it's likely that humans are less
aggressive than chimpanzees. A chimpanzee can easily be very aggressive towards another member
of their community if this other individual is trying to steal an apple or a piece of fruit.
But we don't kill each other if someone steals a small amount of food from our hands.
I would love to be able to define the moment we see warfare.
When we think about the origins of war itself, it is a very speculative exercise because the
further back we go, the more fragmentary and incomplete and ambiguous the picture becomes.
So what I can offer in terms of an answer for when warfare starts is admittedly speculative.
You know, warfare sometimes is the ultimate last resort. So forging societies, hunters gather
societies. When they're angry at their neighbor, they will do what we call vote with their feet,
and they just get up and leave. So I think it's gonna be hard to find evidence of warfare before
people are really settling down, building towns and villages, because you'd probably just want
to avoid it. You know, my take between friends, right, is you could probably push it back quite,
quite old if you take an evolutionary approach. If you take an approach where you say,
it's not going to be like it is today. Warfare, it might be just a couple of skirmishes between
people who have over the years have gotten mad at each other. But it's going to be really,
really difficult to prove that. But absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.
I think what it is evidence of is that people are not going to be engaging in these long-term
violent battles until there's enough people around where it makes sense to do that.
But for me, and for my colleague, Mark Kissel, we have come to the conclusion that
the origins can be pinpointed to the origins of humanity itself. When I say humanity, I mean
certain kinds of capacities and thinking. So the ability to communicate with one another,
the ability to compel each other, to engage in risky kinds of behavior, to go out and sacrifice
our lives and our health for some common cause. That, I think, is at the root of human forms of
warfare. And if that's the case, X marks the spot for us in a speculative fashion,
maybe around 300,000 years ago. How sweet the rewards of peace.
A bruised and suffering world stirred again to the triumphant strains of victory.
For the soldier, it was the proud end of a long and arduous road.
These examples we find in the deep historical or archaeological record are anomalies of warfare,
of violence. The majority of time, people are getting along with each other.
So if warfare is a form of cooperation, but it's one group cooperating against a different group,
there are mechanisms, social, cultural mechanisms, that are associated with warfare
that are also associated with the avoidance of conflict, what we might consider peacefare.
Peace is not the opposite of war. It is not just not being violent. It is actively working
toward peace. But it's a lot harder to study because unlike war, we're not going to see
signs of it as easily reflected in the bones. He returned to the life he had left as citizen
soldiers for generations before him had done. And because the world he had preserved
seemed at last so ready for peace, he turned his pursuits to peaceful things.
But despite man's bright hope, aggression had not yet been eliminated from the world.
When you try to understand in absolute terms how violent or aggressive humans are,
you don't need to look at the consequences of war, which clearly are much more dramatic
and significant in humans than any aggression that you observe in other species. But you need
to look at the causes of warfare and the causes of aggression and how likely aggression is
displayed under the right condition. I'm standing here at the Stoughton Area Veterans Memorial in
Stoughton, Wisconsin. This is a very sobering place to be standing in and to think about all
the war that has happened over the last couple of centuries. And it makes me think about my
own family's history. My father grew up in Korea. He was a teenager when the Korean War started.
He was displaced from his hometown, ended up fighting in the conflict, surviving it.
My mother is Vietnamese. She grew up in a war-torn environment as well, forced to flee her
ancestral homelands. The two of them met in Vietnam in the 1960s in the midst of another conflict.
I'm very much a product of cold wars in the 20th century. I was born in Saigon and as an infant,
my parents and I escaped right before the toppling of Saigon in April 1975 by helicopter.
As sobering as that topic is, as an anthropologist, I also realize the cultural dimensions tied to
human warfare. And it gives me hope for the future because I also realize we have choices
and we have a moral obligation to think about the kinds of decisions we have in front of us.
And coming to the realization that at this point in human history, we have the technological
capability for the first time as a species to be able to destroy the entire planet, to understand
that past, to inform our present, and to construct the kinds of futures we can imagine, to avoid
conflict. This is an obligation that all of us have, that all of us can share. I take that with
a grain of hope for the future. I am biased, right? I have a fairly optimistic view of human
behavior. I think humans innately want to get along with each other. Not everyone agrees with
me. And certainly nowadays, you turn on the news, it doesn't seem like a very easy thing to defend.
So I think that we have to be aware of that too, right? Sometimes the past is a reflection of the
current situation and how we see it. Probably the strongest parallel between humans and other
species is that we can display a range of behaviors and we cannot simply be characterized as
being aggressive or peaceful or prosocial. So I think to say in a black and white way, humans are
violent, humans are peaceable, would be a little bit too simplistic. For me, I think humans are
complex is really the way we need to try and think about human behavior. What I've come to realize
is that we have choices. We have the ability to manufacture not only our physical surroundings,
but our cultural ones as well. So I take a more optimistic view. History is full of war,
but it's also full of people avoiding war. I sort of think one of the things about warfare is it's
sort of a trick people use. People trick us into sort of using what might be a human-like thing
of collaboration, of agreeing, of trying to live well in a group and use it for other ends. Do we
interpret this as, oh look, people are going to be violent unless we tell them not to be,
or do we interpret it as people are going to be people. And you know, we're not innately violent
or innately warlike or innately peaceful. We're innately human and humans have been doing human
things for the last hundreds of thousands of years and we're going to continue doing those things.
Again, man's ingenuity has written a flaming chapter across the sky for all the world to see.
Whether this mighty force we have unleashed will be for evil,
or whether it will be harnessed for peace and good, time alone will tell.
