Why is Max Verstappen s Rear Wing Failing him

Formula 1 News
151 followers
165 Video Views·Jul 9, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis analysis examines Max Verstappen's crashes at the British and Austrian Grands Prix, theorizing that they were caused by a sudden loss of rear downforce. A former Mercedes aerodynamicist suggests that flow separation and hysteresis during the closing of Red Bull's active aero system led to critical instability and rear-end grip failure.
At both the British and the Austrian Grand Prix, Max Verstappen had some fairly unusual
crashes involving his rear wing.
In this video, we're going to look at the physics behind a potential cause for why this
is happening.
For those of you that are new to my channel, I was an aerodynamicist for Mercedes for the
2018, 2019, and 2020 Formula 1 seasons.
I now work as an aerodynamics consultant, designing race car aero kits in classes all
around the world.
Now, I want to start this video by just saying that there's often many reasons around incidents
like these.
They're often quite complex in nature, and usually the teams have way more data than
what we have from the outside, so we can't be 100% certain in our diagnosis of a particular
cause.
I'm saying this because it's been all too common lately in the media to go and latch
on to certain theories that are put forward about why something is happening and present
it as truth.
And I don't want people to think that this is 100% truth.
This is just a theory based on a hunch that I have based on a whole bunch of experience.
So anyway, let's get to the analysis.
So to start with, let's just briefly talk about the circumstances of the crash.
Specifically, I'm talking about the Silverstone one here because you have much better angles.
Now, Red Bull, like Ferrari, has a rear wing that flips over upside down when it's in the
straight line mode.
There was some talk of after the Austria crash that that wing might not be closing fully,
and that was what potentially caused that crash.
But what I want to show you is this video that I've synchronized of the Silverstone
crash.
So you can see that we have the car going down the straight, the DRS is open here.
So what you can see is it closes here before he reaches the start of the curb.
And you'll see that if you watch the steering wheel, just in this onboard over here, watch
that steering wheel, and you'll see that his actual turn in point, where he really starts
to turn in properly and not just following the kink of the road as you enter this corner,
you'll see his turn in's later, much later than when it closes.
So there's only two real explanations for what's going on here.
Either the wing is still microscopically open, or there is some sort of aerodynamic effect
going on.
Firstly, we need to briefly talk about the concept of aerodynamic balance.
When it comes to a downforce producing car, what you'll have is you'll have a certain
amount of downforce pushing down on the front axle, and a certain amount of downforce pushing
down on the rear axle.
This is generated by all the different devices all over the car.
This downforce helps improve the total amount of lateral force or longitudinal force that
you generate at the contacts patch, because you are able to get more force through friction
there.
If we reduce the amount of downforce on one of the axles, we decrease the amount of grip
available at the axle.
However, if we go to enter a corner, we're still trying to accelerate the center of mass
of the car at the same lateral G, and that acceleration has to come from both the front
and the rear axle.
If either one of these axles is lacking, that center of mass will not go through the corner.
More specifically, if you are lacking grip on one axle, it will not pull into the corner
like the other axle, and therefore you end up with the car rotating, and you end up with
understeer or oversteer, depending on which axle is losing grip.
I cover this more in some other videos I've got on aerodynamic balance and also how race
car tires work.
Safe to say, in the Max Verstappen incident, what we are experiencing is a lack of rear
downforce.
This is not the first time we've seen incidents of this nature at Silverstone.
I remember back in 2018 that the Williams ended up having some problems with this.
If you have a look here, this is Lance Stroll.
You can see that he goes to turn in, and then the rear goes and steps out on him like that,
and he's hitting the gravel.
Similarly, Sergei Sorotkin ended up with exactly the same fate in in fact exactly the same
corner that Max Verstappen crashed in.
If you watch, he goes and turns in, and then the rear starts to suddenly step out on him
about at the same point.
Now it came out that what was happening here for these two cars was the diffuser was stalling
on these cars.
Now a diffuser stall is something that you generally speaking try to avoid in a race
car because it produces a phenomenon known as hysteresis.
Essentially what hysteresis is, is that imagine I have a floor on a car and then a diffuser
like that.
What can happen is that you can end up with flow separation off here so the air does not
stay attached because my ramp angle is too aggressive, and that can happen when you get
below a certain ride height for example.
So say if the car is here, the ride height goes down, this flow separates, and it would
be attached at a higher ride height where the diffuser is less stressed because there's
less suction from the ground, but at lower ride heights it happens to stall.
The problem here is that the hysteresis means that the airflow may not attach when it comes
on the way back up.
So if you imagine a plot here of ride height along this axis and downforce on this axis,
what can happen is that as we lower the ride height, the downforce of the diffuser might
increase, say, and we reach a certain point where the diffuser gets low and this flow
separation starts to occur, so let's say there's a rapid drop-off in downforce because it stalls
and its downforce gets a lot lower.
But as we're coming back up, what can happen is that that flow can get into a state where
it's now stable in this lower state where the flow is separated.
It wants to remain separated, there's nothing encouraging it to reattach.
So what happens is that the curve instead on the way back up looks something like this.
And so there's a difference here between these two curves, and that means that on the way
back up you might not have the downforce that you had on the way down.
Basically what I'm demonstrating here is that a flow separation or stall on an item does
not necessarily recover at a specific reverse pressure gradient, and you can watch my other
video on reverse pressure gradient as to what that means.
As a quick no-nonsense interlude, I also make aerodynamic courses if you want to learn more
about the physics behind things that I'm presenting in this video.
They're on sale currently for July, so you can go over and check them out at courses.jkfaero.com.
Now this same principle also applies to wings, where if you imagine we have a wing profile
like this, we can get flow separation off the back of the wing.
Now this typically occurs at a specific angle of attack.
We normally think of this as, say, this wing will stall at 15 degrees angle of attack,
which is the angle of the wing to the free stream.
The problem is that that assumption isn't technically true.
Particularly with high curvature wings, you can have a wing that stalls at a certain angle
of attack, but if you drop the angle of attack, it won't recover.
And this is about to become really relevant really quickly.
Imagine we have a modern F1 wing system just here.
So we've got some rear flaps here, and basically they're going to be able to pivot up and down.
Now back in the DRS days, where you just had one element back here, it was a constant
thing that you had to be careful with, that as you came back down with the DRS flap, that
you would get reattachment on the wing as the DRS closed.
Now there's two potential sources of detachment here.
One is off the flaps themselves, and one is off the main plane.
Now this particular wing here doesn't have a lot of curvature on the main plane.
The main plane is highly unlikely to be separating when this thing opens.
But on higher curvature elements, so if we had a main plane that was really curvy like that,
for example, it may only be attached when the wing is closed.
The flap here, that would be attached.
And then when this flap moves up and opens, you may see flow detachment and separation
on that wing there.
So when your DRS closes, you have to make sure that the effect is strong enough and
that it pulls this flow back on to this surface, therefore restoring the downforce on the wing.
So there's two things at play here.
One is obviously the angle and the pressure gradients, but then you also have to consider
that there's a time response on this thing.
Once you close it, that flow reattachment is not going to be instantaneous.
And this is one of the reasons why even in the DRS era, a lot of drivers chose to close
the DRS before they actually got on the brakes, because they wanted to make sure they had
full downforce before slamming that brake pedal.
Now with the modern Active Aero setups, the picture is a shade more complicated because
both Red Bull and Ferrari are running these wings that flip upside down.
Red Bull's system obviously goes around that way and Ferrari's system goes around that way.
Now the Red Bull system has a lot of advantages on face value.
It looks like they can use a fairly conventional DRS pod in the center.
It looks like it's quicker to actuate than the Ferrari.
And they probably had to spend a lot less time developing the mechanism as a result
of being able to use that central DRS pod.
The Ferrari one has a bit of an aerodynamic advantage though in flow reattachment.
With a conventional DRS style opening, imagine that your wing is sitting here.
This wing is at a low angle of attack.
Now at that low angle of attack, it's pretty likely that these underside surfaces are going
to be all attached.
If I had to pick a separation on a wing here, I would say that it's probably going to be
separating off this leading edge along here and there'll be some loss going along there.
But as you go and pull the wing back down, this flow is all attached here.
So you don't have to worry about getting that flow reattached.
You don't need to worry about that hysteresis because fundamentally the flow is attached.
So you're just restoring an attached flow back to its old position as you come down.
Conversely, if we go and rotate the wing like this, what you'll find is that this particular
wing would be very separated on here and probably here depending on how effective the slot is.
There'd be a lot of separations on the back of here, whilst the flow on the top surfaces
would be incredibly attached.
Now flow on top surfaces is generally not the most useful thing in the world.
One of the other things too is depending on the location of this wing element, and that's
going to depend a lot on the kinematics of your linkage system that's holding the thing on.
If you have a huge amount of pressure here and this pressure field is extending underneath
the wing, you might be causing some real funky effects on what's happening on the
trailing edge of this wing.
But I think the dominant negative effect is that you're getting some big separations
off the back of this wing here.
Now because you've got those big separations, as you go and rotate the wing up, you need
to be confident that that wing is going to reattach on these surfaces.
If it doesn't reattach on those surfaces, well, you're kind of screwed.
Because it's not like you can go and push the wing angle further up and then back down
again.
I mean, I suppose you could do that in the mechanism, but you probably wouldn't want
to.
But you instead would generally speaking do this by going aerodynamically a little bit
conservative, and of course with a three element wing that should be well possible.
However, with these sort of stall phenomenon, the hysteresis and things like that, they
are very, very finicky phenomena.
They can be set off by relatively small disturbances, a small crosswind, a slight bump.
Things like that can locally change the angle of attack.
So let's say you're going along and this wing is closing and you happen to hit a bump
whilst it's in the closing process.
That bump could be occurring over a stretch of tarmac that's, say, a couple of hundred
mil long, but your closing position of your wing could be different every single lap.
So there's no guarantee that you end up with exactly the same behavior every single time.
And so there's inherent risk with having a wing that rotates in this direction to close
instead of in that direction to close.
And this I think is likely a significant cause of Red Bull's issues in that the Ferrari wing
as it rotates around this way is getting attached on the bottom surface.
It has lots of time to recover because it's a slightly slower rotation as well.
And by the time it gets to here, it's basically like conventional DRS closing.
Whereas the Red Bull wing, it starts up here, it's attached on the suction surface.
We flip around, it's detached on the suction surface.
And then at some point through this sweep, it has to try and recover
before it gets onto its normal position.
And that I think is quite challenging.
As I alluded to earlier in the video, there's also a scenario where their mechanism doesn't
quite close fully and, say, ends up somewhere like this.
And what happens there is that you obviously could end up with the alignment of this edge
basically going straight onto the wrong part of this element.
You wouldn't get a good slotting effect through here and you could end up with separations
as a result of that.
It's worth noting that if the wing isn't closed as well, this whole assembly here is at a
higher angle of attack than you would expect, which again could mean that this whole bit
is separated.
With all these cars, the triple element, you should be able to make it work.
And you can tell that it largely does work because the Red Bull works pretty much every
lap.
It's just when those odd circumstances combine together and you end up with a failure, its
consequences are quite significant.
So that is my best theory as to why Max Verstappen's rear wing is failing him.
Well, that's all for this analysis.
If you liked it, don't forget to hit that like button.
Subscribe to the channel for more content like this and make sure you turn the notification
bell to on.
Leave a comment on what videos you'd like to see next from me and hopefully, I'll see
you next time.
