In this Tip of the Day, Mark addresses an issue that every machinist has faced at some point: chatter. Mark is at his best in this video, taking a complex topic and breaking it down into three categories that are easy to follow. Make sure you – and every operator and machinist in your shop – check this one out.
Don’t miss any TIP-OF-THE-DAY videos. Click here (http://ow.ly/s28l30mTiUo) to join our email list! If you enjoyed this video, please hit the like button and share it with a friend who’ll find it helpful . . . and thanks! Follow Haas: Facebook – / haasautomati. . Instagram – / haas_automa. . Twitter – / haas_automation
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video provides a comprehensive guide on identifying and eliminating mill chatter, which occurs when tools or workpieces vibrate enough to cause surface defects. The solution involves balancing three interconnected factors: work holding, tooling, and the part program. If one area is weak, the other two must be optimized to compensate and ensure a stable cut.
Hello and welcome to another Haas tip of the day. Right now we're going to cover mill chatter and
we're going to give you some general tips on how to avoid it. And I promise if you
stick around to the end of the video we're going to show you what these tuning forks are for.
Okay, welcome to the chatter zone. While this is running you can make your best
guess as to the cause of this chatter. Okay, do you want to hear the most annoying sound in the world?
Okay, so we know what chatter sounds like. Let's see what it looks like. Oh, nice. Now the term
chatter is almost always a misnomer, right? It means something different to lots of different
people. For our purposes, chatter is simply when a tool or a workpiece vibrates enough
to give us surface problems. And we definitely see that now. Now the solution to our chatter
problem always comes down to these three aspects of our setup. I'm talking about our work holding,
our tooling, and our part program. But think about these aspects as interconnected, right? If one of
these aspects of our setup is compromised, the other two need to step up and pick up the slack.
So as an example, if we're forced to use a tool that is crazy long, then our work holding better
be really strong to compensate. Along those same lines, our program is going to have to be perfect,
right? We're going to have to use modern tool paths and really ideal feeds and speeds to
compensate for using that odd tool. Now let's take a look at our work holding here. Clearly our part
is not being supported well, right? With this part hanging out so far, when the tool is in the cut,
it's really going to be bouncing around, giving us a lot of chatter. So we have to dampen this.
We could go with a larger vise, right? Like an eight inch curved vise. Right off the bat, we're
going to want to center up this material. But even when I've done that, I still get some chatter on
both ends. So what I'm going to do in this situation is just go ahead and make some wider
jaws. I'm going to change out these jaws right now and we'll go from there. This work holding setup
is a problem we can fix. In fact, we did fix it, right? We centered up our material and we went
with wider jaws that get a better hold on our part along its entire length. If we couldn't touch
our setup for some reason, then we would have to look at strengthening our program and our tooling.
Now let's take a look at our tooling. Now typically, if we want to dampen vibration
when it comes to our tooling, we want to shorten up those tools. But what part of it? Well, all of
it. We want to shorten up our holders, our flute length even. Shorten up everything you can.
Now sometimes you have no choice. You've got a deep pocket you have to go into to make some
type of feature. In that case, go with the shortest flute length possible, right? You've got a solid
carbide tool here that only has the flutes necessary for the pocket that you have to create.
Now these are some unique tools, right? If you look at the end of this guy, it actually has
variable flute spacing. This interrupts our cut and cuts down on chatter. Along these same lines,
the Widiad that I'm using or will use along the outside of our part has a variable helix, right?
It's not a constant helix and it has variable pitch teeth on the end, right? Variable flute.
These interruptions in the cut keep us from finding a sweet spot where things tend to chatter.
So going with some special tools can also get you out of trouble fast.
By going with ideal tools for our job, we were able to get rid of chatter. But what if we couldn't
change our tools? What if we had to use a long holder or if we had to use a long end mill? Again,
in that case, we would have to strengthen our work holding or strengthen our program. Now we're going
to go back to the tuning forks now as promised and give you a little physics experiment that'll
help illustrate how small changes to our program can help erase chatter. So with these two tuning
forks, we're going to demonstrate resonance. Now resonance is when the natural frequencies of two
objects combine and they amplify each other, right? Sometimes you'll hear that on a CNC machine when
you hear that little that little twinge, that little high-pitched squeal, and it builds and
builds until it gets away from itself. I'm going to set this tuning fork up against our ping pong ball
and give the second tuning fork a whack.
Okay, pretty amazing, right? It's like remote control. Okay, now watch this. If I adjust this
tuning fork so it no longer creates the same C note as this tuning fork and I tap it,
it now creates a slightly different sound and it's no longer exciting the second tuning fork.
In this same way, sometimes the natural frequencies of our tooling vibrate at just
the right frequency to excite our work holding or our part that might be hanging out a little bit.
If we can just change our tooling in some way, right, adjust that tool up or down like we adjusted
our tuning fork, we can change the natural frequency of our tooling and stop our chatter.
A CNC machine is not a tuning fork though. We've got a whole lot of things we can play with from
within our program. Our feeds and our speeds, our depth of cuts, both axial and radial, and also
just our toolpaths in general, right? We've got these modern toolpaths that give us a constant
tool engagement. Now the closest thing to a magic button on our machine is this spindle override
button, right? We've all walked up to the machine when we hear that chatter start to build, start to
resonate, and we've pressed the minus 10% spindle button twice and seen that chatter disappear. But
sometimes that's not good enough. Now remember, looking at our tuning fork, when we adjusted this
down, we got out of the resonance zone. In the same way, I can adjust this tuning fork up.
No resonance. Again, moving it back down in the middle, we can end up in the sweet spot
where we create that resonance. In the same way, on a CNC machine,
moving the RPM down will often fix our problem, but sometimes, especially with longer tools,
moving our RPM up can get us out of that area of resonance and stop the chatter.
So I've lowered my RPM and my chatter goes away for about three seconds, right? And then we hear
it. We hear the chatter come right back as that tool runs into the inside corner. Let me grab my
part here and show you what's going on. Now what happened here is that our tool engagement, the
percent of the tool that's engaged in the material at any one time, is constantly changing. At one
point in the pocket, we might have a 15% tool engagement and the tool is happy running at 3,000
RPMs. At another spot in the pocket, we might have a 40% tool engagement, and at that point,
we would need to lower our RPM to 2,000 RPM to get rid of the chatter. And here in this slot or
this channel here, with a very long tool, we might have to lower the RPM to 1,000 RPMs because we've
got 50% of the tool engaged in that cut. Okay, so it's impossible to find a perfect feed and speed
that's going to work in every single corner of this old style pocket. You have to slow down your
entire program to avoid chatter in just a few of those odd spots. This is a beauty of the newer
toolpaths. We're using adaptive toolpaths, dynamic toolpaths. There's toolpaths like
volume mill that actually base a toolpath based on the size of the chips. But what we're doing here
is giving ourselves a constant tool engagement. This is a game changer. This has changed the
world of machining, right? This is using an adaptive or dynamic toolpath. Our tool engagement
is constant throughout the entire pocket of the machine. I don't even care what that engaging is.
10%, 30%. What I care about is that that tool load, the engagement, isn't changing. Once I find the
perfect RPM or the perfect feed rate, I can stick with it through the entire pocket. If I only had
one bit of information to give you today, it would be this. Find yourself a CAM system that has a
modern high-speed machining toolpath that has constant engagements. Well, this has been a
10,000-foot overview of a giant topic. Remember, your workholding, your tooling, and your program
are linked. If you're weak in one area, the other two are going to have to step up and pick up the
slack. Now, if you've learned something in today's video, be sure to subscribe to this channel. You
don't want to miss what we've got coming up next. If you're watching on Facebook or Instagram,
be sure to share these videos with your friends. Like and comment. We want to hear what you have
to say. Thanks for letting Haas be a part of your success and for watching this Haas Tip of the Day.