Picking the Best Hybrid SUV: Toyota RAV4, Hyundai Tucson, Jeep Cherokee

Cars Arena
18 followers
#GJWcars #GJWauto #GJWcar #cararena #choicecar #selectcar #comparecars #autos #cars #review #reviewcars
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe new Jeep Cherokee hybrid is a modernized update with improved tech and interiors, but it struggles to compete with the Toyota RAV4 and Hyundai Tucson. While it offers a comfortable cabin, it is hampered by a slow powertrain, higher pricing, and poor value, ultimately ranking behind its rivals in efficiency, utility, and overall cost-effectiveness.
There's a new Cherokee for the first time since 2014, but we're here to see if it can hang with
the best in the biz. We're Edmunds and we test hundreds of cars each year on the road and at
our private track so you get the most trusted review. If you want to know which car, truck,
or SUV is the best, then stick with us. The new Cherokee is going to start at just under 37 grand,
but this mid-grade limited 4x4 that we have with us today, it's pushing $45,000 in other trim levels
that are going to push into the high 40s. But of course, what you're actually going to pay
depends on dealers in your area. At Edmunds, we've got tools on our site to help you know what you
should pay no matter which of these SUVs you're looking at. You'll find the links in the description
or just scan the QR code. The Cherokee has shifted to hybrid only power just like the RAV4 and it's
got a much improved cabin. But this is a big deal for Jeep, not just because of those reasons, but
also it's eight inches longer than either of the other SUVs we have here today. And we'll see if
that actually translates to more interior room. I don't think Jeep had a name for this feature,
but I'm going to call it the limbo seat because I had no idea it could go this low. This interior
is certainly a big step up from what the Cherokee used to have in it, but then again, that was
designed back in 2014. This feels thoroughly modern though. I give Jeep credit for that,
but some of these materials, they look nice like these ribbed plastics, but to the touch,
they don't really hold up. Now, these seats on the Limited, they're covered in synthetic leather,
which feels good, but I do wish that the seats themselves were a bit more supportive. They're
kind of flat in the back and on the bottom and on a long drive, I think they'll actually give you a
little bit of fatigue, so watch out for that. Now, small item storage is decent. You're not
going to find the same sort of clever storage solutions that the other SUVs have, but this
bin up here, it's pretty big and it's rubberized, so stuff won't slide around, and the center
console bin, it's also pretty deep. Now, these cup holders, they're not the biggest, but they do
still fit my water bottle, but it's what's between them that I actually like a lot. There's a little
vertical slot here and it's perfect for your phone, so you can just drop it right there and
it won't slide around. The technology in the Cherokee has definitely taken a big leap forward.
10.3-inch instrument cluster display standard, 12.3-inch touchscreen, also standard, along with
wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, and the charging options here, they're not extraneous,
but they are really well-placed. I like that the USB-C ports, you can reach very easily. They're
not buried in a bin somewhere, and this wireless charging pad, the placement of it is perfect. I
like it when these are slightly vertically oriented like this because your phone won't
slide around as much, and it's also got some rubberized humps on the bottom that will help
hold your phone in place. Now, this screen itself, it does suffer from some issues because it doesn't
use its real estate all that efficiently. This menu part here is persistent, as is this bar on
the top, so if you look at Android Auto, it doesn't actually take up the whole screen. It just uses
this lower part here and makes the whole thing feel a bit smaller than it actually is. The Cherokee
also has a little bit of work to do when it comes to its usability, though. The visible controls on
the steering wheel and down here are great, and these climate controls, even though they're
touch-sensitive, I don't mind them too much because they don't move around and because
they're illuminated so they're easy to see at night. It's just strange, though, that some stuff
is buried in the touch screen when it doesn't really need to be. So, for example, if you want
to dim the rear view mirror, you might think that that would be a button here on the mirror, but no,
you actually have to go in here, you have to go to vehicle, you have to go to controls, and then you
can dim the mirror. That should really just be a simpler thing to do. And also, these touch-sensitive
buttons down the side of the screen, they don't always really register, and they control things
like the heated seat and the heated steering wheel that you're going to use pretty often.
All of that just feels a bit more difficult than it needs to be. But you know what's easy? Whether
you're buying gas or electric, check out Bumper.com. With just a VIN or license plate number,
learn about a car's history quick. Find out how many owners a used car has had, where it was
registered, and more. To learn more, visit Bumper.com slash Edmunds. Now, as we mentioned earlier,
the Cherokee is just a bigger vehicle than the other two SUVs we have here, but it doesn't use
all that extra length very efficiently, because on paper, this technically has less legroom than
the Hyundai Tucson, which we're going to hop into a bit later. But I'm just under six feet tall,
and sitting back here, I have absolutely no complaints about the amount of room. Plenty of
legroom, plenty of headroom, and that also makes it easier to load in a car seat. It's got really
wide door openings too, so you can put a rear-facing seat here and not have to worry about moving the
passenger up really at all. Now, these seats, I do wish that they had a bit more cushioning,
just like up front, and they do recline, but they only go back about an inch, so they're not all
that more comfortable, but I would say that the natural rake, it's good enough for even a long
trip. Now, amenities back here, they're fairly standard for a compact SUV. You're getting air
vents and a pair of USB-C charging ports, but we should mention that the top trim level of the
Cherokee, that's going to also offer you heated outboard seats. Just like the back seat, on paper,
the Cherokee has less cargo room than both the Tucson and the RAV4, but I like that this cargo
area is pretty deep. You've got plenty of room here for luggage. The only problem is that vertically,
it's not very tall. There's not as much space here as you have in the other SUVs, so if you're
trying to load in anything taller, that might be a problem. Now, under the floor here, the Cherokee
has significant storage. If you don't have a spare tire, there's a little hookup for a spare tire
there, but without that, you can fit plenty of stuff down here and keep it secure. Now, when it
comes to features in the cargo area, there aren't many. You're getting a 12-volt outlet, but what I
really miss is a way to lower the back seats from here because, since this cargo area is so deep,
you can't quite reach them. You end up having to walk around the car to put the seats down. Oh,
and when it comes to towing, this thing can pull 3,500 pounds, which ties the Toyota for tops in
this test. The Cherokee has the least power of any of the SUVs that we have here, and predictably,
it's the slowest, though it is slower than we thought it was going to be. Just 8.7 seconds
from 0 to 60 miles an hour, and that's over a second slower than the Toyota and the Hyundai.
Now, around town, this does feel quicker than that, I have to say. Like most hybrids, that little bit
of electric boost goes a long way to making it feel pretty good from stoplight to stoplight, but
if you're getting on the highway or you're merging or passing, you're definitely going to wish for a
And this hybrid powertrain is tied to a continuously variable transmission, or a CVT,
and the consequence of that is that the throttle response, it's not quite what you really want it
to be. Does this thing feel slow day to day? Not really. It's just that when you want power,
it's not quite going to be there. The Cherokee's handling is just okay. The steering is pretty
numb, but that's kind of par for the course for a lot of these compact SUVs. The ride quality is
pretty good at low speeds, I would say. The suspension does a pretty good job with road
imperfections, but if you do get on the highway when you're trying to cruise, it can feel a bit
choppy and stiff. Braking distance is also unremarkable, 127 feet to stop from 60 to 0.
Brakes work fine most of the time, although I will say that when you're trying to come to a
complete stop, you do have to apply a bit more brake pressure than you think, so you'll actually
overrun the line a few times until you kind of dial that in yourself, but it's nothing that you
can't get used to after a few days behind the wheel. Visibility is weird out of the front because
this thing has a really long nose and kind of a pinched windshield. It's actually better over each
shoulder and to the back, I would say, than the front, and it's also strange that this limited
model, it's not going to come with a surround view camera, only a rear view camera, and it doesn't
even take up the whole screen, so even though the picture is clear, it's just not quite big enough
to be as useful as what we're going to see in the other two SUVs. Now when it comes to safety
features, all three of these are going to have pretty similar equipment. Well, that's kind of a
missed opportunity for Jeep because they do offer a hands-free system on the Grand Cherokee and the
Wagoneer. Now I can understand why they might not want to put it in the Cherokee. It would add cost
and a little bit of complexity, but it would be a feature that no other compact SUV currently offers,
and for a vehicle that needs a bit more differentiation, that's a missed opportunity.
Now at the Cherokee's release, it doesn't offer an off-road oriented trim, which is a strange
thing to say about a Jeep, but they recently debuted a Cherokee Upland concept that should
fill the gap where the Trailhawk once sat, so we'll keep an eye out for that and hopefully get
to play around with that vehicle in the dirt in short order. After spending some time with the
new Cherokee, the word that comes to mind is better because this is an improved vehicle in pretty much
every way. That hybrid powertrain is going to make it more efficient, up to 37 mpg combined,
and it's got a much better cabin and technology than the old Cherokee. The problem is, like we
said in the intro, better might not be good enough because this thing is going up against two SUVs
that are the best. So let's see how they stack up. Just like the Jeep Cherokee, the RAV4, the most
popular car in America, is brand new for 2026. It starts right around $33,000 and tops out just under
$45,000. Unless you want a plug-in hybrid model, those will cost you a little bit more. Now this
RAV4, it is fantastically efficient, thoroughly modern, practical transportation that we would
recommend for many people. But that recommendation, it does come with a few caveats. I can't believe
this car has space for all of my stuff. Even a pocket in the door. That's wild. Interior storage
is a huge win for the RAV4. Everywhere you look up front here, you're going to find some kind of
storage nook or cubby to put your stuff. There's a good size shelf here in front of the passenger,
and another two-tiered shelf right here. This is where it houses its dual wireless charging pads
as well. In the center console, this lid actually flips over and it's hard on this side. So if you're
going to eat in the car or something like that, just turn this over because this surface is going
to be much easier to clean than the upholstery. Now I don't think that materials here in the RAV4
are appreciably better than what we saw in the Cherokee. There is a lot of hard plastic
on this interior, though Toyota, they do a pretty decent job with their touch points. Now the seats,
they're also going to be covered in synthetic leather, just like they were in the Jeep. Feels
pretty good to the touch, but just like those front seats, I do wish that these had a bit more
support, a bit more bolstering, and were softer on the bottom. That would make them more comfortable
for long drives. The RAV4 didn't just get a new interior in this redesign. Toyota also took this
opportunity to debut a brand new infotainment system, and it's one that we really like. It's
got a very clear, concise menu structure, and it's very easy to use with wireless Android Auto and
Apple CarPlay as well. The cool thing, though, is with this standard digital instrument cluster,
you can also mirror your directions that you're using from your smartphone right here in front
of the driver, and that frees up the screen to be used for other things. And Toyota is also going to
offer one more tech feature that we really like. All RAV4s are going to come standard with an
integrated dash cam. The control scheme for the RAV4 we like for the most part. You're getting
physical controls for a lot of the important stuff. The only one that you're not getting
is for fan speed. You're going to have to do that through the screen, but it's fairly easy to see,
and it doesn't move, and it doesn't take up a lot of screen real estate like it did in the Cherokee.
Charging options are also great here in the RAV4. You're getting dual wireless charging pads,
a pair of USB-C charging ports that can charge up to 45 watts, and another one here in the center
bin. The RAV4's rear seat is the smallest on paper, but as you can see, it's still got plenty
of room for adult passengers. Where you're going to feel the space crunch might be if you have a
rear-facing child seat in here. You're going to have to move the passenger seat up slightly, but
it's still pretty easy to load in thanks to these wide door openings and a fairly low step-in height.
Although we should note that these lower latch anchors, they're a bit tougher to access than
they are in other SUVs. Now here in this RAV4 Limited, plenty of amenities in the back seat,
heated outboard rear seats, two USB-C charging ports, air vents, all that good stuff, and you're
even getting a nice little storage pocket here in the door for backseat passengers as well.
On paper, the RAV4 is going to have a bit more cargo room than the Cherokee. Now its cargo area
isn't quite as deep, but it is definitely taller, and its load-in height is also lower. For loading
in anything tall and heavy, the RAV4 is going to be a better choice. Now just like the Cherokee,
not many features in this cargo area. I also wish again that we had a way to drop the rear
seats from back here, but what the RAV4 has that I do like are these extra LED lights here on the
liftgate, and those are super helpful, especially at night. And the RAV4 can also tow 3,500 pounds,
matching the Jeep, both of which beats the Tucson. Man, if they feel like this, they should just all
be hybrids. The RAV4 is the quickest of this trio at just 7.4 seconds from 0 to 60, and it's also
the most fuel efficient, so you're getting the best of both worlds with the Toyota. 42 mpg combined,
even with all-wheel drive, and that's significantly better than both the Hyundai and the Jeep. And as
I mentioned, that efficiency doesn't take away from performance. It has the CVT, just like in
the Jeep, but this just feels way more responsive, especially if you're merging or passing. And even
though the suspension doesn't feel quite as taut as the Jeep, I actually prefer this. It makes it
a bit more comfortable. I'd say the ride quality is better in the Toyota, and whether you're driving
around town or on the highway, this thing is going to be comfortable and smooth in pretty much every
circumstance. I also prefer the braking feel here in the Toyota. It doesn't have a much better stopping
distance, but it is easier to stop smoothly, and Toyota's experience with building hybrids really
shines through with this RAV4. The way that it accelerates and brakes, everything happens really
smoothly. The drivability of this car is really, really good. The Toyota has roughly the same
driving aids as the Cherokee does, but they do feel a touch more dialed in here. The systems feel a bit
less intrusive and more natural, which is a great thing. There's also something called proactive
drive assist, which scans the road ahead. If it notices cars slowing or something like that,
it'll slow the car down a bit before you even get there. If you don't like it and it feels a bit
unnatural to you, you can just shut it off. Now, if there's one driver assistance feature I don't
like in the RAV4, it is the driver attention monitor. That's because they placed it right here
behind the steering wheel, and that means for someone like me who likes to drive like this,
you end up covering it up, and then the system kind of beeps at you. It's something that I just
turn off usually if I'm behind the wheel of the RAV4. But I do have to say that the visibility
is noticeably better here. You get a bigger windshield up front, and unlike the Jeep,
you're getting a surround view camera, and it actually takes up the whole screen. Imagine that.
Overall, the RAV4, it's just a super easy vehicle to live with. It's got great technology,
and it's efficiency bonus over the other two vehicles. You're going to feel that in your wallet
every day in a good way. The only thing that might give you pause is the fact that the back seat is
smaller than some competitors, so if you're going to carry taller passengers often, or if you have
big car seats you need to toss back there, that might be worth a second thought. But otherwise,
I think for most people, you could own one of these, drive it every day, and be pretty happy.
And that brings us to the last of our contenders, the Hyundai Tucson Hybrid. It's cheaper than the
other two SUVs by a couple grand across the board. Now, if you're a follower of the Edmunds
channel, you'll know that we're big fans of this Hyundai. It's won a handful of comparisons,
and it also does very well in our ratings and rankings. Check those out at Edmunds.com. This
is one of the most easily recommendable, well-rounded SUVs on sale today, but that doesn't
mean that it's without its flaws, and one of them might cost you. If you were sitting in this driver's
seat and I told you that this was the cheapest vehicle that we have here today, you wouldn't
believe me, because this interior is a clear step above what you're getting out of the Jeep or the
Toyota, except for this piano black stuff on the doors. But this is the only one that's going to
come with real leather upholstery, and these seats are also much more comfortable than what we had
in the RAV4 of the Cherokee. If I had to drive one of these SUVs for, let's say, six hours or more,
this is definitely the one that I would take solely for that reason. And these front seats,
they're also going to come with heating and ventilation. Now, small item storage, probably
the best in the RAV4, but the Tucson, it isn't far behind. You're getting a really big shelf here in
the front of the passenger, and you're not getting those little nooks and crannies, but you are
getting a nice big open space down here, and that makes this better for fitting a purse or small bag
so it doesn't have to live on the floor or on the seat next to you. These cup holders, they're not
the biggest either, but that's true of all three of the SUVs that we had here today. And the center
console bin, it's pretty deep if it's not that wide. Here in the Tucson Hybrid, you're getting
it matching 12.3-inch screens, one for the instrument cluster and one here for the touchscreen.
Now, just like in the Toyota, we like this infotainment system a lot because it's responsive,
it's quick, and it's simple and easy to use. Also going to come with wireless Android Auto and Apple
CarPlay, of course. The only thing that we wish for out of this tech suite is that the instrument
cluster was more customizable. It won't show directions or anything like the stuff that
you're getting in the Toyota, a chance for Hyundai to upgrade there in the next generation of the
Tucson. Now, charging options are good, pair of USB-C ports down there, wireless charging pad
that's easy to access right here, and another pair of USB-C charging ports in the back. Now,
the Tucson Hybrid, it does have my favorite control scheme of the three. Everything is
laid out and easy to use. And this camera button, a favorite feature of mine, is very easy to find.
But it's not perfect though. The climate controls, they still do live in a screen. You don't get
buttons for a lot of this stuff, which is our ultimate preferred method, but at least you're
getting knobs for the temperature. And at least those controls don't live in the main screen.
In the Toyota, for example, if you want to turn on the heated seat, you've got to use the big
touchscreen. But here in the Hyundai, they're down here where they're still nice and easy to see
and nice and easy to reach. All three of these SUVs, they're going to be very similar when it
comes to the actual features you're getting back here in the back seat. The top trim levels are
all going to offer air vents, pair of USB ports and heated outboard seats. But there are two
reasons in particular that I prefer the Tucson Hybrid's back seat to the others. The first one
is comfort. Just like the front seats, the back seat is more comfortable and it's also got way
more recline than the other two SUVs are going to offer you. And I also really like that to lean
it back. You don't have to reach over your shoulder all awkward. The latch is down here next to your
hip so you can get to it even easier. And the second reason is going to be all that legroom
makes it even easier to fit a rear facing car seat back here. Although I will say the lower
latch anchors, they're a bit tough to access. The Tucson Hybrid is going to offer the largest
cargo area of this trio with the most cubic feet behind its back row. But what I like about it
personally is that we're finally going to get some seat releases so you can just drop those rear
seats without having to climb around the car. This also has a two tiered cargo floor so you can
actually lower it and fit taller items in here than you can even fit in the Toyota. The only
real downside to the Tucson Hybrid, it's not going to be able to tow as much as the other SUVs. So if
you plan on dragging stuff behind you, you might have to look elsewhere. Now from behind the wheel
of the Tucson, it feels a lot like the RAV4, but that's a compliment because I would say that these
are two of the best driving compact SUVs around. This thing is comfortable whether you're on city
streets or on the highway and it's pretty quiet for the most part unless you're really, really
trying to accelerate. Now at zero to 60 time, it's a 10th off what the Toyota offers, but I prefer
this powertrain for one key reason. Hyundai uses a standard six speed automatic transmission instead
of a CVT and that means that it makes it a touch more responsive. You put your foot into it and it
just gets up and goes, finding the right gear pretty much immediately. Now that choice might
have knock-on ramifications down the line, which we're going to cover in a second, but purely when
it comes to driving, I think I prefer the Hyundai. But again, the margin is just very, very slight.
Choosing the conventional transmission, it does hurt efficiency. So this thing is going to be down
on fuel economy versus the RAV4 and there's no real way around that. Now this also comes with a
camera system like the Toyota, takes up the whole screen, looks great, big thumbs up from us.
One of the reasons that I love doing these comparisons is because it's really instructive
to get into these three SUVs in such close proximity. Because in a vacuum, the Jeep feels
pretty good, the Toyota feels even better, but then when you get into this Hyundai, you're reminded of
why it has such a high spot in our rankings. And that's before we even get into its tremendous
value proposition. Before we get into value and share our verdict, if you have any questions about
these three SUVs or any other comparisons that you'd like to see us do, let us know in the
comments below. And if you've been enjoying our videos and find them helpful, the best way to
help us make more of them is a like and subscribe. All right, it's time to talk value. And for the
Jeep, it's going to struggle a bit because it does start at a higher price than the other two
vehicles. It's actually about five grand more to get into one of these than the Hyundai Tucson
hybrid and two grand more than the Toyota. Now it is going to offer you standard all-wheel drive,
something the other two don't offer. And I think in a vacuum, you would look at this vehicle and
think it's got decent value with its new interior and better tech. And that's definitely true versus
the old Cherokee. But the problem is, again, this isn't even a top trim level of the Cherokee,
and it costs more than that Tucson hybrid that we like so much. So take this thing out on value.
Its warranty is also nothing to write home about. Now the Toyota, it starts at a lower base price
in the Jeep, but a higher one than the Tucson. But it's going to give you good value on fuel
economy because with all-wheel drive and even with the big wheels, you're going to get 42 MPG combined
versus 36 or 37 with the others. Now, does the Toyota's interior live up to its nearly $46,000
price tag? For me, not quite. The distinction for the best interior here goes to the Hyundai.
As we mentioned before, it is absolutely wild that this thing has the lowest price among all
vehicles that we tested, topping out at just over $43,000. Hyundai's value proposition has
always come down to the fact that it's going to give you more features for your money. And that's
definitely true of the Tucson hybrid. Plus, we just like how practically this interior is laid
out. Of these three, the one that definitely feels the most worth the money is the Hyundai.
And that's before we even talk about its exceptional 10-year, 100,000-mile powertrain
and five-year, 60,000-mile basic warranties. All right, now it's time to check out those
individual category scores, which make up the Edmunds rating. The Hyundai impressively wins
or ties for the lead in six of our seven categories. The RAV4, it also did well,
taking the top spot for efficiency and tying for the lead in others. But the Cherokee,
improved as it is, struggles. The Jeep didn't win any individual category, and its best finish was
in comfort, where it beat the RAV4 with its roomier cabin and better anchors for installing
car seats. And as a quick reminder, if you're looking for ratings and reviews of any vehicle,
head over to Edmunds. We've got all the segments covered. Now let's check out those overall rating
scores for these three SUVs. And it's no surprise the Cherokee is going to bring up the rear. It is
a vast improvement over the old Cherokee, but it didn't solve what to me was the biggest problem
that that vehicle had, and that was value for money. It was too expensive before, and it's too
expensive now. You're not quite getting what you pay for with the Jeep. That's something that they're
going to need to work on to move up our rankings. And in second was the Toyota. It's just a very
solid vehicle, great small item storage, nothing to really hate about it, but it also doesn't quite
feel exceptional in the way that our winner does, and that's the Hyundai Tucson Hybrid. It is one of
the top rated vehicles that we have on our whole site for a reason. It's going to give you a ton
of value for your money. It looks great, it drives great, and yeah, if I had to pick one of these
three to take home, it would definitely be the Hyundai, even if it did cost me a little bit more
at the pump. Thanks for watching.
