Hyundai Palisade vs. Toyota Grand Highlander vs. Mazda CX-90 | 3-Row SUV Comparison Test

Cars Arena
18 followers
#GJWcars #GJWauto #GJWcar #cararena #choicecar #selectcar #comparecars #autos #cars #review #reviewcars
AI Generated·May contain errors
The three row family SUV.
You end up in one of these when you had a CRV or a Forester
and now it's just too dang small.
And the good news is there are plenty of great options
and today we've got three of them here,
including one that's brand spanking new.
First we have the Toyota Grand Highlander
which we like to call the grown up RAV4
because it kinda looks like one
and that's basically what it is.
And then we have the Mazda CX-90,
the stylish and sporty option
that may have flown just under your radar.
And finally we've got the redesigned Hyundai Palisade.
It looks fantastic and inside,
it just might have the best interior of any SUV
that's not wearing a luxury badge.
We're going to go through all of the details
that you might miss on a quick test drive.
We're talking tech, comfort, cup holders,
storage spaces, second row, third row,
driving aids, how they fit stuff, how they fit people
and of course what they're like from behind the wheel.
That sounds like a lot of stuff.
We better get going.
We're Edmunds and we test hundreds of cars each year
on the road and at our private track
so you get the most trusted reviews.
If you wanna know which car, truck or SUV is the best,
then stick with us.
Grand Highlander doesn't just mean a bigger Highlander,
it also means a better one.
For a three row SUV, the regular Highlander
as we have to call it now,
it really wasn't all that family friendly
but this thing, it makes up for that in a big way.
First off, it's got space for all of your stuff.
You've got a storage bin here, cup holders,
a big center console and even this nice big shelf
in front of the passenger.
For a vehicle that prides itself on practicality,
all of this is essential.
The word practicality is also what I think of
when it comes to this vehicle's materials.
It's not fancy and it's definitely not flashy
but it's well put together and I like that they kept
that fingerprint hungry black piano stuff
to an absolute minimum.
There's actually one trim level higher
than this limited that we're in
and it does add some okayish looking wood
trimmed into the mix but we think that this trim
is actually the sweet spot for the Grand Highlander lineup
and that is why when we added a Grand Highlander hybrid
to our one year road test fleet, it was also a limited.
Speaking of essential, physical climate controls.
We really like the layout of the dashboard
for the Grand Highlander.
First, because this screen avoids that tablet glued
onto the dash that our 4Runner that we also own has
and second, because buttons are just better
for things that you're going to change often
like the seat heaters and ventilation or the temperature.
Having those here where they're easy to reach
and don't move is great.
Controls that you're not going to use very often,
it's fine to put those in the screen
because you only need to find them occasionally
but the stuff you're gonna touch often,
a button will always be better.
Now when it comes to the technology,
this software suite is one that we're familiar with.
It's simple and pretty easy to use.
It's got wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay as well,
same as all the other vehicles that we have here today.
There is one particular annoyance though
with the Toyota infotainment and you'll see it right here.
It's asking me to actually subscribe
if I want to use the navigation
and you're going to need a subscription
to use the navigation and voice commands
or you're going to need a separate subscription
if you want to use any music streaming.
We recommend just plugging in your phone
and saving yourself some dough.
These seats are pretty comfortable
if a little bit flat on the bottom
but the one thing that you might wish for
is stronger seat heaters,
especially if you live somewhere cold.
Oh, and if you're looking for something
that's hotter than these seats,
head over to Edmunds where we can help you find a deal
on any of these SUVs and even help you find the best price.
Now, if you want big cup holders, storage bins
and even a shelf, you can get all that in a RAV4
but the reason that you buy one of these is this.
It's just got tons of room here in the second row
and as we're going to see in the third row as well.
Now, this limited we have came with a bench seat
but you can also get it with captain's chairs
which does make it a little bit easier
to get into the third row
but sometimes having a bench is real nice.
Beyond offering a ton of room,
the second row also has a lot of features.
Here on the Limited, you're getting heated outboard seats
but on the Platinum, they can be cooled as well.
There's also two USB ports, well-placed climate controls
and a household outlet down here which is essential
if you're going to use this thing as an office.
I should also point out that the air vents
are in the right place, in the ceiling.
And thanks to the wide door openings and roominess,
this is also a very easy vehicle to install car seats in.
The lower latch anchors are really easy to access
as are the upper ones and there's so much room
that even if you have a rear-facing seat,
this passenger doesn't have to sit in the dashboard.
One thing to watch out for with the Grand Highlander
is getting into the third row can be kind of difficult
and that is because this latch that you have to use
to tilt and slide it out of the way
is kind of hard to operate
and kids might have trouble using it.
Now, once the seat is out of the way,
it is pretty easy to then climb back here
and as you can see, tons of room still.
Now, visibility could be a little bit better.
This pillar is slightly intrusive
but vents in the right place, two USB charge ports,
a big storage vent,
not much else you could ask for out of this third row.
The Grand Highlander enjoys a big advantage
when it comes to cargo room.
Now, behind its third row,
it's only got a little bit more room than the Palisade
but a lot more room than the CX-90.
However, once you start folding down seats,
that's when this thing really shines.
Now, whether you're folding down just the third row
or the third row and the second row,
the Grand Highlander is going to give you
almost minivan levels of cargo room
that the other two just can't match.
Now, when it comes to features in the cargo area,
things are a bit barren back here.
You don't even get like a charge port.
That's only something you can get in the hybrid models.
However, I'd rather have space over features in the back
pretty much any day.
Okay, so the thing you need to know
about the Grand Highlander
is that it offers three different powertrains,
two of them hybrids, one of them gas.
We're in the gas and it's probably honestly the worst one
but that doesn't mean that this is bad.
It just speaks to how good those hybrids are.
Now, this base turbo four,
it feels good enough around town.
The only time you're really gonna wish for more power
is if you're going up a very steep hill
or if the thing is fully loaded
and you're trying to get on the highway.
It'll get you up to speed.
It just might take a beat longer than you were expecting.
Now, the Grand Highlander is far from sporty
but that's okay because it nails all the other fundamentals
that you'd want out of an SUV.
The ride is comfortable.
It absorbs bumps and road imperfections really well
and it stays composed even over potholes
which in LA are a thing
that you're gonna run into all the time
and I would rather have that than an SUV
that kind of tries to be fake sporty
while still having body roll all over the place.
The thing that I can say about the Grand Highlander
that's the best compliment, it's just easy to drive.
The other nice thing about the Grand Highlander
is it's gonna come with a lot of standard driver aids
so no matter which one you buy,
you're gonna get adaptive cruise control,
lane keep assist, all that stuff
and it all works pretty well.
There's also something called predictive drive assist
so if it detects a curve coming up
or some cars ahead of you slowing down,
it'll sort of start to slowly brake the car for you.
Some people don't like that.
You can just turn it off.
The system though that ends up bothering me the most
is the traffic jam assist system.
Now, it's not available on all Grand Highlanders.
It is optional but it does make this a hands-free vehicle
at speeds under 25 miles an hour on the highway
which is good but the problem is 25 miles an hour
is way too small a speed threshold
and the system just ends up turning on and off
and on and off and on and off
and beeping at you all the time.
Don't really like that so much.
Spend any time with a Grand Highlander
and you'll come to appreciate just how practical it is.
Now, it's not the most stylish thing in the world
and it's not even terribly exciting
but it is really well executed
and very good for families with all of this space.
It's good but what I wanna find out
is that those other two SUVs might be great.
For a company known to put driving above everything else,
man, Mazda knows how to make an interior.
It all starts out with a perfect driving position
and a right-sized steering wheel
and that makes this thing feel sporty
in a way that three-row SUVs rarely do
even before you've gotten on the road.
When it comes to design and materials quality,
this is a clear step above what we got in the Toyota
and feels closer even to something like a Lexus.
They've done a great job picking out materials
that look great and also feel great to the touch.
All these touch points are awesome.
Even though everything up here looks great,
it is really lacking when it comes to small item storage.
You don't get the cool shelf
or even the large bin up here like you got in the Toyota.
To get to the cup holders,
you have to open this little thing here
but even the cup holders, they're quite small.
Not even our cup fits in the center console.
It is wide but as you can see,
it's not deep at all like what you're getting
in the Grand Highlander.
Just like in the Grand Highlander,
we really like these physical controls
for all the climate stuff
but when we get up here to the screen
and the technology package overall,
our impressions are significantly less positive
and that is because this isn't really a touchscreen at all.
It's only usable as a touchscreen
if you're using Android Auto or Apple CarPlay
while you're not moving.
Otherwise, you're going to be using this knob down here
to interact with the screen and control everything in it.
Now, some Mazda folks have been in the comments
saying that they've gotten used to this over time
and I don't doubt that they have
but I still think that this is a really inefficient way
to use the screen and it also doesn't change the fact
that this system feels a whole generation behind
what we're getting in the other two vehicles.
And this navigation system,
it looks like it's printing out maps from 2008.
Here in the second row,
materials are pretty much just as good
as what you're getting in the front row.
The problem is in the CX-90,
that's about where the good news ends.
As you can kind of tell,
there's just less overall space here in the Mazda
than you're getting in the other two SUVs
and while the second row does have a lot of travel,
which you're going to need to use
to make yourself some space,
that might compromise things for anyone sitting behind you.
Now, the other problem with the second row
that we really have is the position of the air vents.
Climate control's here, which is good,
but the air vents are also down here
and that means that they're not in the ceiling.
And the problem with that is if you have a child
in a rear-facing car seat right here,
they're not gonna get any airflow at all
because it's actually below where they're sitting.
Up in the ceiling, way, way better.
Now, when it comes to car seats,
this thing is actually pretty good for installation
and that's because the doors open super wide
and the lower latch anchors are even easier to access
than in the Toyota
because you have these handy little covers,
but you should probably put these somewhere
so you don't lose them.
The only problem is if you have a rear-facing seat,
this passenger is gonna have to sit a bit forward
because of those space issues.
Oh, and if you're looking for a cup holder
in the second row, it's this little fold-out thing here,
which is not great because it's super flimsy
and if you forget that it's up and you step on it,
that's gonna break real quick.
Now, the CX90's third row issues start
before you even get back there.
Now, this latch is easier to operate
than what you had in the Toyota.
However, this opening here to climb in is pretty small
and if you're an adult like me,
you might have some issues squeezing in that space.
And before you say that you might just walk
between the captain's chairs, that space is even smaller.
Now, as you can tell just from kind of looking at it,
the space back here is a lot smaller,
really no legroom to speak of.
We've set this seat up to where an adult
would be reasonably comfortable behind the driver
and as you can see, my knees are touching it.
But even worse, there's really nowhere to put my feet.
They're actually stuck underneath the seat.
When we slid the seat back, my feet got trapped under there
and I can't really pull them out
without doing a bit of contortion.
The other problem with this backseat
is there is absolutely terrible visibility.
This window is small, this pillar is huge.
So huge, in fact, that if the car were to turn right,
my head would go straight into it.
Other problems, the air vent is in the absolute worst place
unless you really get hot on your calves
because it's gonna blow right into them.
Really, this third row is only meant for sometimes duty
and that is the difference between this vehicle
and the other two SUVs.
Those two, you can use the third row
pretty much at any time for a person of any size
and for the Mazda, it's kid duty
and adults, they will rebel instantly.
The CX-90's space issues extend from the third row
to the cargo area where it's got significantly less room
than both of the other vehicles.
In fact, we put that same amount of gear
behind the third row that we did in the Toyota.
In the trunk, it wouldn't even close.
Now, even though it is smaller,
this cargo area does have a few more features.
You've got a household outlet and a 12-volt power plug,
although I do wish the household outlet
was behind the center console where it's a bit more useful.
And the other thing that I like about this
is it's a touch easier to fold these seats down
than it is in the Toyota.
You don't have to reach up on top to do it,
you can just use the strap.
Now, this is where the CX-90 finally has a chance to shine.
A perfect driving position, that's not something
that you're going to say about most other SUVs out there,
but this is where Mazda starts designing their vehicles.
This has to be perfect,
and then everything else kind of falls into place,
and that explains maybe why it's not as great for passengers,
but for the driver, it is awesome.
The steering here is noticeably heavier
than in the other two vehicles,
and the suspension is tighter as well,
and that gives this a sporty feeling
that the other two simply can't match.
Now, you do pay for that on comfort quite a bit
because it does bounce around a touch more,
but if the trade-off is that you have an SUV
that's actually kind of fun to drive,
I'd probably make that deal.
Under the hood here,
you've got a straight six-cylinder engine,
and it's my favorite engine of the three that we have here.
This thing feels a touch quicker than the Toyota
and much quicker than the Hyundai,
especially if you put it into its sport mode
where it loves to hold gears,
and if you want to take control for yourself,
paddle shifters.
The brake pedal is a touch grabby at the top,
but it's something that you can learn,
and you'll be able to stop smoothly
after a few hours behind the wheel.
The thing that doesn't work quite as well, though,
is the auto start stop system.
That has a tendency to sort of lag
when you're trying to get the car to move.
We end up just turning that thing off
by a little button here next to the steering wheel
that says I Stop.
The Mazda does come standard
with a good amount of safety features,
adaptive cruise control, lane keep assist,
all that good stuff,
and most of it works pretty well.
The exception would be the blind spot alert system.
It's just simply too sensitive,
and it's beeping at you all the time,
but the problem is you can't just go and shut it off
because this vehicle has pretty big blind spots
over both shoulders,
so you have to leave it on for safety,
but just know it's gonna bother you a little bit.
By the way, I know we've been giving you
a lot of information on all these SUVs,
but if you want even more,
or on any car, truck, SUV on the road today,
head over to Edmunds
and check out our full ratings and reviews.
Even though the CX-90 is clearly
the best driving vehicle of this trio,
it was always going to have a hard time in this comparison
because of its space limitations.
In that way, it's sort of the antithesis of the Toyota,
which puts a real emphasis on practicality,
while this thing seems to put an emphasis
on being kind of fun to drive,
but if you're buying a family SUV,
you're probably thinking about people other than yourself,
and that makes it tough on the Mazda.
Now, I'm really excited to hop in the Palisade
because I think that thing has a few tricks up its sleeve
that we're gonna find really enticing.
This thing's gotta be like 75K, right?
In its redesign, the Palisade
got an imposing new exterior look,
but I think that the star of this update is this interior,
and Hyundai says that this design was inspired
by mid-century modern pieces of furniture,
and you can definitely tell.
This dashboard looks like it could double
as a TV stand in a living room in Palm Springs,
and I mean that in the absolute best possible way.
Now, this interior is offered in a few different colors.
You can get it in black, you can get it in gray,
but I think that if you're going to pick one of them,
you should definitely pick
this Jif Creamy Peanut Butter color.
It is absolutely fantastic.
Now, this design, it's very kind of circular.
There are no real hard edges.
If you look around the interior,
everything follows this kind of oval-y motif,
and it also makes it feel very Genesis-y,
and that's backed up by materials
that also feel like they come straight
out of a luxury vehicle.
There is probably a Genesis version
of a three-row coming down the line,
but I honestly don't know where they're going to go
from here to make this any nicer.
Now, this is a loaded-up calligraphy model,
and that means that both of these front seats
are going to come with leg rests that fold out
so that if you're just chilling somewhere,
you can actually lean back like a recliner
and do so in great comfort,
and when you're on the road,
these seats are also comfortable and supportive as well.
I also really like this padded armrest right here.
Just, you're going to hear me say this a lot.
This cabin is absolutely stellar for this price.
Small item storage kind of falls somewhere
between the Mazda and the Toyota.
You get a shelf in front of the passenger,
but it's a little bit low.
It can actually be kind of hard to see what's in there,
so it's not quite as usable,
but this area down here is great for storing larger items
like a purse or a small bag.
I also like that these two cup holders here are pretty big.
They fit our large water bottle
as well as our big cup,
wireless charging pad right here,
and this center console, it's also not very deep.
It doubles as a disinfecting chamber,
so you can actually put things in here.
It'll shoot them with UV light to kill germs.
For a vehicle that has climate controls in a touchscreen,
we like this about as much as is possible.
One, because that touchscreen,
it isn't used for anything else,
so these don't actually move around
and you can kind of learn where they are,
but second, it's because this area up here
I think is absolutely fantastic.
One thing that Hyundai always includes on their vehicles
that a lot of other automakers don't
is a dedicated home button,
so if I'm using Android Auto or Apple CarPlay,
I can simply hit home
and then go all the way back to the home screen
without having to dig into menus at all.
That's great.
Also have a dedicated camera button, which we like,
although it's a bit weird that it's on this side.
Everything is laid out super, super logically.
Now, up here we have matching 12.3-inch screens,
nothing new there for Hyundai,
and this infotainment system is also not new,
but the reason that we're going to spend some time
talking about it is because it's the way
that you access a bunch of new features
that this vehicle has
that you're not going to find anywhere else,
and that's really what you want to see in a redesign.
You want to see a vehicle and an automaker
bring new things to the table
that the competition simply can't match.
For example, powered first, second,
and third rows in this vehicle,
and not only that,
I can control them through this screen right here.
I can control the heating.
I can control the ventilation.
I can control folding.
I can even move the seats forward and back,
all from this screen right here
without ever leaving the driver's seat,
and you'll also see an icon here for an integrated dash cam,
and that is another feature you're not going to find
in not just the vehicles here,
but any other three-row SUV.
Now, up here you're going to get a wireless charging pad,
which is nice and easy to access.
The problem is, though,
the sun can hit your phone here
and bounce up into your eyes,
so that's not great,
but these USB-C ports,
they will actually charge it up to 100 watts,
and that is a ton of power.
A MacBook Pro with a brick charger,
that thing can only charge it up to 95 watts,
so that means that if you need to charge a laptop
or anything else,
you don't even need to carry the brick.
You don't need to plug it into the household outlet.
You can plug it straight into one of these USB ports.
Now, this is the largest second row
of any of the SUVs we have here on paper,
more legroom and headroom than anything else,
and it's also the only one with powered adjustments,
so you can move the seats forward and back like so.
It's also got some features
that you're not going to find in the front row.
For example, these headrests,
they fold up on the sides like this,
so you can be a little bit more comfortable,
and these armrests are also awesome.
I don't know if you can hear this clicking,
but there are 12 different armrest settings
for however you like to sit.
Also awesome.
This thing is just absolutely fantastic,
not just from space, but from look and feel.
That oval motif from the front continues here.
You have a household outlet.
You got vents in the ceiling.
You got climate controls that are easy to reach.
You got four cupholders in the second row,
four cupholders in the third row,
and you even have a pullout storage bin.
This is part of the reason the center one is so shallow,
and that gives you more storage here in the second row
than you're going to find in the other vehicles as well.
I could go on and on.
I'm rambling, but that's just simply
because the second row on this thing
is better than the front row in some other vehicles.
Another unique feature to the Palisade
is found on these rear doors.
If you look on the speaker grates,
there's actually a little icon
with a little warning triangle and a car icon,
and what this does is it'll light up
if there's a car or a cyclist coming,
so you know not to open the door,
and those of you with kids know
that kids tend to just fling the things open,
so it might help prevent an accident.
Now, for car seats, very easy to install
with all of this room.
Lower and upper latch anchors are both easily accessible,
but what I like is that if you press this button
to get into the third row, as you can see,
the seat as a whole picks up and slides forward,
and that means that you can do this
and keep a car seat installed
and then just climb behind it to get into the third row here.
Kind of a tight squeeze, though.
Now, these second row seats are heated and ventilated,
and you can get the same thing
in the Toyota Grand Highlander's top trim,
but what you can't get in the Grand Highlander
is a heated third row, and that is awesome,
and you also get a power sliding third row.
I have never seen that before.
Also, power reclines, so I can just add
or take away room from the cargo space
if I'm not using it to give myself even more room.
The only downside to this third row,
these storage bins, they're kind of dinky,
but otherwise, 100-watt USB-C here,
100-watt USB-C there, air vent there,
big window here, big window there.
I'm running out of superlatives.
This really is a absolutely nailed cabin.
If absolute maximum cargo room is what you're after,
then you're gonna go with the Grand Highlander,
because yes, it can fit more stuff than the Palisade,
but I prefer this cargo area for a few key reasons.
One, it has much better underfloor secure storage,
and two, it's because I'm real lazy.
Now, you don't see any straps or levers here,
and that's because all three rows
of the Palisade are powered,
and that means that if I wanna drop the third row,
I can just do it like that.
Now, I know what you might be thinking.
Brian, those seats fold down kinda slow.
I don't wanna wait for them.
So, I came up with a race.
We're going to see how long it takes for me
to lower all the seats in all three vehicles.
On your mark, get set, go.
All that and a bag of chips.
The Palisade drives sort of like its interior would suggest.
It's kinda like a living room.
It's big, it's comfortable.
The steering has absolutely no feel,
but I think this has the best ride quality
of the three vehicles here,
and that's probably the most important thing.
However, and yes, we've finally come to a but
with this vehicle, the powertrain,
it is definitely a letdown.
This vehicle, in its redesign,
gained about 400 pounds because of all that new stuff,
but it didn't add any more power,
and so it now takes 8.8 seconds to get from zero to 60.
Around town, just cruising, it's fine,
but if you have to get on the highway and pass anyone
or if the car is full of people and all their stuff,
you definitely find yourself wishing for more power.
And honestly, if I had to call out
one part of the vehicle as being the worst,
it's probably the powertrain.
Now, help is on the way
because Hyundai will be introducing
a hybrid version of the Palisade finally,
and it's going to have more power,
and it's also going to be more efficient,
and that might end up making the hybrid
the one you'll actually want to get,
but we won't know that until we test it.
What I do have to applaud the Palisade for, though,
is its visibility.
You get big windows all around you,
so it has good natural visibility
with not very big blind spots on either side,
and on top of that,
it's also got an excellent surround view camera
and blind spot monitor.
So if you turn on the signal here,
it's actually going to show me a live picture
in the instrument cluster of what's in my blind spot,
and it just makes lane changes that much safer.
Now, to wrap things up here in the Palisade,
I thought to myself,
if I had to take a road trip with five or six people
and I had to take one of these three vehicles,
I'll be reaching for the Hyundai's keys every time,
in large part because of how nice this cabin is.
It really delivers a luxury experience
at a non-luxury price point,
and yes, you're not going to win any races,
but you're going to be so comfortable
and your friends are going to compliment you
on this tan interior so much that you probably won't care.
Now, before we talk money
and which one of these three you should actually take home,
please, if you've been enjoying our videos,
toss us a like and subscribe
so we can keep making more of them,
and if you have questions about any of these cars
or other comparisons you want to see us do,
let us know in the comments below because we read them all.
Let's talk value starting with the Toyota.
Now, it has the highest starting price
of any of the vehicles here,
and it gets even more than that
if you want all-wheel drive.
This limited model that we have
sits right at about 52 grand,
and for that, what you're really paying for is space.
The interiors of these other two,
I would say that they're nicer
when it comes to materials and design
than the utilitarian Toyota,
but if you're a member of the never minivan club
and you still want that level of room and space,
that's really what you're paying for
with the Grand Highlander.
Now, in the Mazda,
it actually has the cheapest starting price
of the three vehicles here
and comes with standard all-wheel drive.
In this example, right around $51,000,
very similar in price to the Toyota.
Now, we should remind you,
both of these vehicles have higher trim levels
that are even more expensive,
but we still like the level of equipment
that they have to offer,
and if you're buying a Mazda,
its driving experience
and the way that it sort of looks and feels,
that will appeal to you,
but simply put, it doesn't have enough utility
or space or advanced technology
to make it justify its price tag.
And now we come to the Palisade,
a slightly higher starting price than the Mazda,
but this example is the most expensive vehicle
that we have here in this test, 57.5.
However, it still feels like the best value,
even though it's the most expensive,
and that is because of the level of features,
the level of refinement,
the level of just thoughtfulness
that they put into this vehicle.
And on top of that,
it also has by far the best warranty of the bunch.
So if you're looking for value out of this trio,
the best one is definitely the Hyundai.
So to declare a winner,
we are going to turn to the fabled Edmunds rating.
Our crack team has driven, tested,
and gone over all these cars with a fine tooth comb.
Here's what they got.
Now, at the end of these videos,
I like to think of a silver lining
for the vehicles that didn't win,
some reason why a consumer might still want them
over the winner, even though we think the winner is better.
But in this comparison,
I'm having trouble finding silver linings
for the Toyota and the Mazda,
because even though they might have small individual things
that they can do better than the Palisade,
if you look at the overall package,
it's just an absolutely overwhelming advantage
for the Hyundai.
And with a hybrid model on the horizon
that might solve its performance issues,
this thing, it might get even better.
Thanks for watching.
