Tesla Model Y vs. Honda Prologue vs. Hyundai Ioniq 5 vs. Chevy Equinox EV | Electric SUV Battle

E-Moving
15 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Five years ago, if you wanted an electric SUV with good range, this thing was your only choice.
But now, ooh baby, you've got options. In addition to the updated and popular Tesla Model Y,
we've brought along three other strong contenders. The highly rated Hyundai IONIQ 5, the affordable
Chevrolet Equinox EV, and the sort of a Honda Prologue. We're going to tell you the good and
the bad for each of these electric SUVs, things that you can't find out from a Google search or
quick afternoon at the dealership. And then of course, we're going to tell you what results each
of these vehicles achieve on the world famous Edmunds EV range test. And you can trust us
because we've spent literally hundreds of miles behind the wheel of each of these SUVs, since here
at Edmunds, we test everything. See this big Cybertruck-esque light bar right here? That is
the strongest indication that you are looking at the new and very much improved Model Y. Now,
if you're looking for all the details on what makes this new Model Y different from the old one,
good news, we've already got a video on that, that you should check out. But if you want the
CliffsNose version, here it is. New styling, better interior, quieter inside, more comfortable,
improved materials, and supposedly more range. We're starting here behind the wheel because this
is where we found the biggest issue with the last Model Y that we owned. To say that ride quality
was an issue would be putting it so, so mildly. The old car had a tendency to make good roads feel
bad and bad roads feel like you were pushing a shopping cart over those yellow bumps outside
of target. So if I told you that the new Model Y rode better than the old one, that really wouldn't
mean very much because it was so bad before. So instead, I'm going to put it to you this way.
I think that now the Model Y is perhaps the best riding SUV in this entire class and one of the
quietest and most comfortable electric vehicles you can buy today. Tesla's have generally done
okay with wind noise, but road noise and tire noise was always an issue. So now they've changed
with the formula. So it's whisper quiet on the interior and that combined with the suspension
improvements mean that this is just a really comfortable and nice car to drive around for
short, medium, or even long distances. We also need to talk about Tesla's full self-driving
supervised or FSD for short. Now to turn the system on, you do need to enter a destination
into the navigation system, which we'll do. So for here, my favorite local Japanese market,
pop that in. And then all you do then is click the start button on the screen, hold that down,
tap the break to confirm release, and we're off. Now, when you turn the system on, there is a
little pop-up that comes up that tells you to keep your hands on the wheel. So this is technically
not a hands-free system, but it feels really weird because the car does all the steering and all the
braking and accelerating for you. And you just kind of have to lightly put your hands on the
wheel while it's doing all this stuff. And it's very, very weird. Unlike other automakers, if you
take your hands off the wheel, the system will keep working and pilot the car on its own as long
as you keep your eyes on the road. But for right now, it still tells you to keep your hands on the
wheel when you start it up. So that's what we'll do. There are some things that this system does
quite well. I like this view on the screen. It really gives you confidence. It shows everything
happening around you from road signs, stoplights, even direction arrows painted on the ground.
But at the same time, it also makes some really questionable decisions.
In the first few minutes that it was on, while it was turning out into traffic,
it edged the nose all the way into the lane, which is pretty rude and a bit scary.
Oh, that's terrifying. I am in the lane. I really want to back up. I'm sorry.
And it also had me merge right during an intersection out of a left turn lane and cut
someone off. Oh my God, we're going to merge, right? I was such an a**hole.
So yeah, it kind of drives like a human, but that human is kind of a jerk.
Taken as a whole, this technology sort of oscillates between being really impressive at
times and then being really confusing at others. So you do have to pay close attention while it's
on. And the other good reason to pay attention is that if it's on and something happens to you
like a crash, that's not on Tesla, buddy. That's on you. It's going to park for me.
Chose a really tight parking space for no reason, but it's going to park for us.
We're here and it even parked for us. I don't know what to do with you.
In another big change, the interior of the Model Y finally feels like it's worth its big price tag.
This faux leather here on the seats feels really nice and supple, and the seats themselves are
actually pretty comfortable and supportive. Although over our year long tests with this
vehicle, we'll see how white they stay. I also like the look and feel of this new steering wheel,
but I like what's next to it even more. Yes, that is a turn signal stock and it is back after
disappearing on the Cybertruck and the Model 3. Tesla must have realized that that was not a good
move. So it's back and better than ever. If you're looking for buttons, the only ones that you'll
find are here on the steering wheel. Otherwise everything is controlled through the screen.
The screen itself is great. It's high resolution, intuitively laid out, and super responsive. And
for this year, it has smaller bezels and a bump up in processing power. We even get better audio.
So the problem isn't the screen, it's that everything goes through it. Shifting into drive,
changing the direction of the air vents, turning on even your heated or ventilated seats. Those
are things that all have to be done through the screen and it's just harder than it should be.
And there's still no Apple CarPlay or Android Auto, even though yes, you can use some apps
natively in the system like Spotify. We've always just really enjoyed the comfort and familiarity
of having your phone mirrored on the screen. Small item storage is pretty good. You have a
well-placed wireless charging pad here that can charge two phones at once. You have a pretty good
size bin here and another good size bin here. And you do get cup holders that aren't that big.
So they'll only fit a cup and not a big water bottle like this, but you can also just drop this
right into that bin. And you're also going to get a glove box, but of course that can only be opened
through the screen. The Model Y's backseat is really an excellent place to be for a few reasons.
The first one is that it's roomy and really comfortable, as you can tell, tons of leg room
and headroom. And if I want to change the recline of the seat, I just do it via this button here
until I find the perfect place to sit. The second thing that we really like is this screen taken
from the Model 3. Tons of functionality in here. You can adjust seats, you can change climate
controls, you can even play games or watch videos. Although if you get car sick, you should probably
refrain from doing both of those because the screen is positioned pretty low. If the backseat
has a weakness, it is when it comes to car seats and you won't have trouble fitting them. The
problem will be installing them because the latch anchors are well labeled, but they're really hard
to access. And the upper latch anchors are very far down the seat backs, just like they were in
the old Model Y. For SUVs, even electric ones, the size of the cargo area is very important.
And that is why we have brought along eight pieces of luggage to do a cargo test in each
of these vehicles and see how many of them fit behind the second row. This is actually really
impressive. The Model Y has 29 cubic feet of space behind its backseat. But beyond that,
it has useful storage in other areas as well. Impressively, the Model Y fits seven pieces of
luggage behind its back seat. And if you have that eighth piece, you don't even need to worry
because this thing will fit in the front, has the biggest front or will even fit in the underfloor
storage space here. It has the biggest underfloor storage space, along with two messenger bags as
well. Cargo room galore in this thing. When we purchased our Model Y, it was only offered as
a launch edition and cost over $60,000. But since then, Tesla has started to offer the regular
long range all wheel drive versions of the SUV. And those started just under $50,000.
However, if you add on all the options that our vehicle has, including FSD supervised,
which costs $8,000 on its own, you end up with a similar price to what we paid.
So the Model Y is more classy and sophisticated than ever before, with great room for both
passengers and cargo. It's an impressive car if you're OK with doing nearly everything through
that touchscreen. The Hyundai IONIQ 5 won our Edmunds top rated electric SUV award back in 2023,
but now it's 2025 and the Hyundai is back to reclaim its crown with some big upgrades,
including more range, better technology and one important change when it comes to charging.
The IONIQ 5 might look futuristic on the outside, but once you get into it,
you'll find an experience that's much more traditional. Look, buttons, knobs, real air vents.
After spending all day in a Tesla, I missed you guys. This is exactly how it should be.
Anything that you're going to adjust frequently when you're driving, like the temperature or the
volume or even the direction of the air vents, those things all work better as physical knobs
and buttons, because then you can use them without having to take your eyes off the road.
And in this updated IONIQ 5, Hyundai has actually added back physical buttons for some features
based on customer feedback. And of course, you get standard wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay,
which always makes me happy. Thankfully, in this update, Hyundai didn't do too much to deviate from
its winning formula of an attractive yet practical interior. It starts with this center console right
here, which can actually slide forward and back a unique feature for the Hyundai among these
competitors. And while these cup holders are a bit on the smaller side, they won't fit your big
water bottle. You have this really nice, large, open storage space right here that can easily
swallow it. And the cup holders are still just big enough to fit your big, dumb cup. Otherwise,
things are great. These front seats are ultra comfortable, even for really long drives. And
this driver's seat, it can even recline with a footrest if you want to take a nap while you're
charging. Though the IONIQ 5 doesn't look that big from the outside, once you get into it,
the interior feels cavernous. This seat is set up where I like to drive. And as you can see,
I just have legroom and headroom galore. It also has a pretty good amount of recline for the rear
seat, too. So for longer trips, you can lean back and get more comfortable. And we also really enjoy
the fact that the air vents for the backseat aren't mounted on the center console. They're
actually mounted up here on the door. So that means that you can circulate air without making
your knees super cold. There's also two USB-C charge ports back here, heated rear seats.
It's just a really comprehensively featured and roomy backseat that we like a lot.
The IONIQ 5 has 27.2 cubic feet of cargo room behind its second row,
but it was only able to fit six of our luggage pieces, one fewer than the Tesla. And the other
piece of bad news is that if you do have any extra luggage, it's going to have to live on
someone's lap because there is no good underfloor storage here in its frunk. That's not really big
enough to be helpful either. While the IONIQ 5 can't quite match the Model Y's acceleration,
it's still plenty quick. It's quicker than plenty of sports cars out there. And if you're coming
from a gas SUV, especially, you'll find it to be plenty punchy. The IONIQ 5 suspension
does a really good job of being both comfortable and fun, which means that if you're on a canyon
road, it's nimble enough to make the car feel sporty and light. But if you're just driving
around day to day, it'll still be really comfortable. Hyundai has also done a really
good job calibrating its different levels of regen. So whether you're using one pedal driving or any
of the other modes, it's all very smooth and easy to modulate. Now, the Hyundai doesn't offer a
hand-free driving system like some of the other vehicles that we have here. But what it does have
works quite well. So you get adaptive cruise control and you also get a nice blind spot
camera. So if you turn the turn signal like this, you can see right here in the instrument cluster
what's in either blind spot. They also do automatic lane changes when you're using
the adaptive cruise control, but those can be a little slow and the system is rather cautious.
Now, if you're more of a dirt devil than a pavement pounder, the IONIQ 5 is unique in that it offers
an off-road trim, the XRT, which we tested out recently. And that gives you a bit of extra ground
clearance and an all-terrain tire. And that means that it can get down any sort of fire road to any
campsite that you would want with much more confidence. While there are more affordable
versions of the IONIQ 5, even the 60 grand you're going to pay for this loaded all-wheel drive
version seems like a pretty good price for what you're getting. The build quality is excellent.
Hyundai doesn't skimp on the buttons and it drives like a more expensive car. And on top of
that, you're getting the best warranty of any of the vehicles here and three years of free maintenance.
The IONIQ 5 feels like a generous offering and that's a big part of the reason we like it so much.
Speaking of getting a lot for your money, the Equinox EV will give you 356 miles of range
for just around $35,000. That's it. That's the whole review.
Okay, not really. A lot of people can't charge at home, so range anxiety is real. And it used to be
that if you weren't willing to spend about 50 grand, you'd have to give up a lot of range in
the bargain. But this vehicle, even though it costs just over half of what the other ones do,
offers the most range of any of the vehicles that we have here today. I am curious though,
if Chevy still spent big on the battery and the motor, how was it able to achieve that price
point? And I had the suspicion that we'll find that answer inside. The materials in here make
it clear how Chevy cut those corners. There's a lot of black plastic in here and none of it
looks particularly good. The touch point that bothers me the most though is this steering
wheel. It feels cheap in your hands for lack of a better word, but then you remember how little you
paid for the whole thing and it all starts to bother you a little bit less. These seats though,
they're not that comfortable. They're a bit too flat and a bit too firm and they don't come with
heating or ventilation like the seats in all the other vehicles do. Small item storage in the
Equinox, not as good as the other vehicles that we've seen so far. This center bin is kind of
small and the cup holders are a little bit small as well. So they do fit the cup, but they don't
fit the water bottle. Fortunately though, there's a little pass through down here where you can just
tuck this thing with a little bit of finessing. You know what doesn't feel cheap? This giant
screen. The $35,000 Equinox EV has the largest screen of any vehicle in our test and it's really
good with one big caveat. I love the full Google integration, which means that you can use the
Google voice assistant, the play store, and if you log in and even load in all your places on
your maps so you can see all these dots, those are all of my favorite restaurants. The big catch
though is that to power all of these great features, you need data. And after a free trial
period, Chevy charges you for a data plan to have access to maps and the play store and the assistant.
And right now it costs about $25 a month. There is a workaround. You can actually pair the car
to your phone as a mobile wi-fi hotspot and use them that way. But something about that just
doesn't quite sit right with me. Now I hear you saying, Brian, if I don't want to pay for a data
plan and still want to use Google maps, why don't I just plug in my phone and use it through Android
auto or Apple CarPlay? And the answer is because you can't. Chevy doesn't offer those things on
its EVs. You can only get that on gas powered Chevys now like the Silverado I was in last week.
And it's frustrating because that vehicle had basically the same infotainment system. But for
some reason, the EVs Chevy locks you out and it is maddening. The Equinox EVs rear seats aren't
very comfortable, just like the front seats. And you can't even adjust the level of recline on them.
But room is pretty good back here and you still get rear air vents and two USB charging ports.
The thing I do appreciate about the Equinox EVs backseat though is that the lower latch anchors
are covered by these nice little plastic covers. It makes them super easy to access and much easier
to install a car seat here than in the Tesla. The Equinox EV has 26.4 cubic feet of cargo room
behind its backseat. And it also fits six of our bags, just like the Hyundai, although it was a bit
of a tighter squeeze to get them in here. Now we should also note that this is the only vehicle
here without a power lift gate, because again, this is a base model and it does have underfloor
storage, but it's not big enough to fit a piece of luggage either. Just a couple messenger bags.
When you step on it, it's clear that the Equinox EV is playing a different game than these other
SUVs. Its performance, I would say, is just on this side of adequate. It is quicker than the
gas version of the Equinox, but you're not going to get that same futuristic rocket ship feeling
that you get out of the Ioniq 5 or the Model Y. This version of the Equinox EV is also front wheel
drive. If you want to get all wheel drive, you're going to have to spend about an extra five grand.
And of course you'll lose some range, but you'll gain confidence in inclement weather or in the
snow. Now, when you're just cruising, you get to relax. This thing is comfortable and quiet way
more than you'd think a $35,000 vehicle could be. And also because it's got those entry level
smaller wheels, that means you get thicker tires and thicker tires puts more rubber and air between
you and the road. So the ride quality is excellent. Now, when it comes to driver aids here on the base
Equinox EV, adaptive cruise control is all you're really going to get. And it does work pretty well,
we have to say, but on the top trims of the Equinox EV, you can equip Chevy's super cruise
hands-free highway driving system. And it's a system that we quite like. And we've found that
it really does reduce fatigue, especially on longer drives. Now it's different from Tesla's
system because it won't try to drive you at all on city streets. But even when you're in the Tesla,
you have to pay such close attention to it that we don't really mind that super cruise is highway
only. Oh, and one more important point. You can get the Equinox EV with a light metallic purple
paint job. And that rocks because it's cool to be able to show a little personality with your
vehicle. So sure, you could take an Equinox EV, option it up to nearly 60 grand and get basically
the same features you're going to get in all these other SUVs. But what we like in particular is that
Chevy opens the door for those who don't want to, or can't spend that kind of money on a vehicle.
And it still gives them good range, great technology, and a comfortable and quiet driving
experience. In this group, the Equinox is the EV for the people. And now we come to the final vehicle
in our test, the Honda Prologue. Underneath, it's got a secret. This is actually a retuned and
re-skinned Chevrolet Blazer EV. And it shares a lot of the same components along with the Blazer's
smaller sibling, the Equinox EV that we just covered. Inside, it's a lot like the Equinox when
it comes to design. And sadly, just like the Equinox's front seats, these are too flat and
don't offer enough support. Although the materials in this cabin are a lot better because this is a
top of the line Prologue. The biggest difference between this and the Chevy's interior is the
screen. And even though this screen is smaller, I would not call it small. I actually think it's a
pretty good size. Sometimes those big screens can feel like they dominate the dashboard too much.
This one, still easily visible, still easily reachable. I like this form factor a lot. I also
enjoy that here in the Honda, you're getting that Google integration. So Google Maps, the Play Store,
all that good stuff. But if you would rather use Apple CarPlay, you can do that too. And that power
of choice feels excellent. The interior feels quite spacious, even though legroom measurements
are similar to the other vehicles. When you're sitting in here, it just feels more expansive.
In the backseat, we like the convenient covers on the lower latch anchors and the fact that you also
get a household outlet on the back of the center console. Interior storage in here is better than
the Chevy. You get a bigger center console bin and you also get that underneath space as well,
but you won't need it because this is the only vehicle here with big enough cup holders
to fit both our big cup and our big water bottle. Some trims of the Prologue have 25.2 cubic feet
of cargo room, but this elite model that we have here only has 23.7 and that's the smallest number.
However, in our test, it actually fit seven pieces of luggage in it, and that's one more
than both the Equinox EV and the Ioniq tying the Model Y. Just like its Chevy colleague,
this one doesn't have a frunk as well, but underneath the floor, a decently sized storage
bin that fit both messenger bags. Similar to the Equinox EV, the Prologue for the most part
feels pretty unremarkable from behind the wheel, though it is noticeably quicker from that car,
thanks in part to its extra electric motor. What you do notice immediately, though, when you're
driving the Prologue EV is that its suspension has made things worse. Honda tightened it up
compared to the Blazer EV, so the ride quality feels busy, and I think that the goal of that
was to improve the vehicle's handling, but it doesn't really handle that great either. So what
you end up with is a bit of the worst of both worlds, a car that doesn't ride great, but also
doesn't handle particularly well. It can also be concerningly hard to see out of this thing.
The rear glass is really slim, so you don't get a really good view out of the mirror, and also
there are giant pillars all around you, so blind spots are everywhere. You can't see anything on
this car. All things considered, the Prologue is a pretty good car, but there's just one thing
I can't seem to shake. It just feels like Honda is trying to trick me. A big part of the reason
that people buy Hondas is for the brand's reputation for reliability and for a great
driving experience, but all the mechanical parts related to those things, they're quietly made by
Chevrolet. Even the key fobs are the same, they just have different badges. Let me put it to you
this way. Would you buy a Honda CR-V if you knew it was actually a Chevy Equinox underneath?
Maybe not. Now it's time to talk range, because we figured it'd be easier to show you those
numbers all at once than to ask you to remember them. Here's what each of these vehicles achieved
on the world-famous Edmunds EV range test. And as a quick reminder, on this test, all these vehicles
go for an average speed of 40 miles an hour with a 60-40 mix of city highway driving to better
simulate real-world conditions. The Equinox EV leads the pack, followed by the Model Y,
then the Prologue, with the Ioniq 5 bringing up the rear. The Equinox's win does come with a tiny
asterisk. It is the only vehicle here that's front-wheel drive, so it only has one motor to
all the other vehicles too. Both the Model Y and Ioniq 5 offer a little bit more range after their
updates, though the Tesla is far more efficient because it went further and these two have roughly
the same size battery capacity. Also, the Ioniq 5's 280 miles or so of range, that's plenty for
daily driving, but it's still under that magic 300-mile threshold that so many people consider
important. One thing to keep in mind, not all superchargers are being opened up to these other
brands, just about two-thirds of them. So that means that if you're driving a non-Tesla vehicle,
you should use the native navigation to get there. Because if you use Google Maps, it might lead you
to one that you don't have access to. That was a lot of SUV talk, and now to rank these four vehicles,
we're going to turn to the fabled Edmunds rating. Bringing up the rear is the Honda Prologue. It just
isn't comfortable enough and feels a little bit expensive for what it has to offer. But on the
other hand, the Chevy Equinox EV almost gets to the top spot on its value proposition. And if you
want to get the most range out of your dollar, that is the clear choice. So that just leaves the Hyundai
and the Tesla, which tie for the top spot. This is a big improvement for the Model Y because the last
generation of this vehicle, it would have only gotten third place in this test. But now it is on
equal footing with the Ioniq 5, and that is no small feat because this has been one of our favorite
electric vehicles bar none for the past several years. These vehicles both have sterling overall
rating scores, but they do differ widely when it comes to design and execution. So what it will
come down to is which approach do you vibe with more, the Ioniq 5's futuristic familiarity or the
Model Y's uncompromising minimalism. While a tie might seem unsatisfying to some, to me it actually
feels pretty good because it's never bad to have more than one good option. Thanks for watching.
Wax figure.
