What the Loch Ness Monster Teaches Us About Myth, Mystery, and Truth

Decoding Loch Ness
7 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAndy Steiger and Steve Kim explore the legend of the Loch Ness Monster while traveling through the Scottish Highlands. They use the mystery of \"Nessie\" as a jumping-off point to discuss the philosophical differences between folklore, strict materialism, and biblical miracles, ultimately arguing that a spiritual worldview provides a more complete understanding of human existence and meaning.
Hey welcome to the AC podcast. My name is Andy Steiger and I am joined by Steve Kim.
Hello.
Good to be with you man.
It's great to be with you in Scotland. It's a bit weird seeing you here.
Yeah you're here doing your PhD studies.
Yeah so every fall every October I come this way to do a presentation to
the cohort of PhD students about the research that I've been doing as part of progress monitoring
just you know making sure that I'm actually doing what I'm supposed to be doing that sort of thing
but yeah it was a lot of fun.
Yeah it's good I had an opportunity to come and give a lecture
to the PhD students which was great on the topic of artificial intelligence
and now we are off to Loch Ness in search of old Nessie.
We wanted to do a podcast on the topic of mystery and I'm looking forward to this and I don't think
that there's a better place to talk about mystery than here in the highlands of Scotland.
Old Nessie the Loch Ness monster has been famous for a really long time.
Yeah and it's not just Scotland either when I was growing up in South Korea I mean
we had heard about Nessie and we talked about it all the way over there on the
other side of the world so clearly left a cultural imprint all over the place.
Are there any mysteries in Korea?
Oh yeah I'm sure but it's just been so long that you might have to just revoke my Korean card I
don't know but yeah it's been so long for me but yeah there's for sure stuff like local
myths or mysteries and some of those things.
We have those even in Canada for example in the Okanagan
in Okanagan Lake we have Ogopogo.
That's right.
Which is kind of like honestly the the Loch Ness of Canada.
One of the things though that shocked me about talking about the subject of
old Nessie is that the the descriptions of the Loch Ness monster now that that
term didn't get coined until I think it was 1933 but the stories go back over a thousand years.
Right the story involves Saint Columba so he was an Irish missionary from the 6th century.
He came over from Ireland to Scotland to evangelize to the Pictish tribes here
and so the Scottish Gaelic tribes of old the ones that even the Romans couldn't conquer
because they were so vicious.
And they had to put up a wall called Hadrian's Wall.
Yeah and it was it was quite the issue.
Now in a biography that was written a little bit after his time by this guy Adomnen in Ireland
he records Columba's encounter with this aquatic beast from River Ness.
And so that's where we hear about Nessie for the first time or at least
people associate that account with the Loch Ness monster.
And it's pretty it's pretty shocking though like the stories go back a long ways man.
And it has certainly shaped a lot of the the culture around here.
I mean we're wearing these t-shirts and it's become a real touristy thing.
Now I find your shirt kind of is amusing.
I don't know if you can see this but it says I believe.
And here's Nessie but there's also a UFO floating up above.
Yeah I don't know if you can see this but Santa Claus is on there.
Oh and then there we go.
And then there's a Sasquatch that's water skiing.
Yes water skiing right there.
Behind old Nessie which again Sasquatch goes back to our area in Canada, North America.
Sasquatch is talked about quite a bit.
The point being that there are these discussions globally you know even have
Yeti and other things like that about these kind of mysteries of the forest or mysteries in the deep.
Now I know your shirt says I believe but is there any of those things that you know aliens,
Steve, Sasquatch or old Nessie that you are tempted to believe holds truth?
Yeah I mean I'm fascinated by the story of Nessie.
I'm not sure I believe in the existence of Nessie.
But I mean I mentioned Saint Columba earlier.
Just let me kind of lay out the story quickly for you and just see if you guys find it believable.
So the story is that he was evangelizing to the Picts and he comes to River Ness.
And he is wondering about okay how am I going to go across to the other side.
And they see a boat on the other side but somebody has to go get it.
Now during this time some of the Pictish tribesmen they come carrying a man,
a deceased man to bury him.
And the story is that this man had been bitten by the water monster in Loch Ness and he was dead.
They had done his funeral now he was about to be buried.
Well oh we just missed our turn.
It looks like the road's closed.
Yeah the road was closed.
It's all good we'll hopefully get some redirection going on here.
Yeah we're good.
All right keep going.
Yeah and so yeah this guy was attacked by Loch Ness.
They had done his funeral.
He's about to be buried.
Now Columba comes and touches his staff on his chest and brings him back to life.
And so everybody's absolutely shocked about this.
And then he commands one of the monks who was with him and said
go into the water bring the boat from the other side.
So he takes his clothes off the monk and jumps into the water.
And the disturbance of the water gets Nessie going.
Now Nessie is hungry and wants to eat or I should say the water monster is hungry
and wants to eat somebody else.
And so he comes and the story goes that when the monster was about a spear's length away
Columba had just prayed in the name of God
right not to touch this man and go back.
And in Adamna's account it says that as if he was pulled by ropes even faster than
as if he were pulled by ropes the monster just fled.
And maybe that's why we don't see Loch Ness anymore.
I mean the Loch Ness monster anymore.
But at least it's an account that goes that far back.
So I don't know listeners and viewers as you are listening to this
whether you find it believable.
And I guess also the question is raised if you don't find it believable why is that?
Well and to add to that there have been accounts we got a book here in Scotland about
Loch Ness sightings and there are a lot of them.
Yeah.
Which is which is interesting to go all the way back to Columba.
But you have in Columba by the way when did he live?
500s.
So 500.
So we're talking so you know 15 over 1500.
Yeah.
Years ago.
And then up into the modern times you have a lot of accounts of people who say that they
have seen you know Loch Ness monster both in the water and out of the water accounts.
But then you also get these hoax as well and people that admit to having made up
or fabricated pictures and the like.
So it's a bit of a hot mess of course like anything.
But I think the thing that people would ask or bring up is okay Steve you know you don't
believe in Loch Ness yet with these various sightings yet you believe the Bible.
That talks about you know miracles that aren't that different from Columba you know minus
the monster.
But but you know at least miracles of people being healed.
Okay so you've got people who would say you believe the stories in the Bible why
wouldn't you believe the stories of old Nessie?
The way I process it is this right I mean I don't believe in Nessie but it's not because
the stories are miraculous.
That's not necessarily why I don't believe it.
I think the the temptation is in our day and age just to write off miracles altogether
you know these things don't happen and therefore any story that contains any trace of miraculous
events you can't trust it.
That's not me I don't believe in Nessie because I have no other evidence right or
whatever evidence that was proposed were either proven to be hoaxes or something something
of that sort so I guess what I'm saying is I don't write it off from the get-go start
with the presumption that miracles don't happen and therefore the story about Loch Ness monster
I don't believe it.
So in other words you're saying you that you're open to the idea but that you don't
see enough evidence to support it.
That's right whereas in the Bible there are certain clues right so I think of for example
the virgin birth of Jesus right this idea that a man was conceived without a father
at least this is this came about by no natural means and so people sometimes question hey
Steve why is it that you know you don't believe in Santa Claus but you believe in the virgin
birth of Jesus so what I would have to say to that is hey listen like if you actually
read the account the entire account is it hinges on people not believing Mary's words
that an angel had visited her and told her that this would happen by the power of the
Holy Spirit it's not as though people were so just so credulous back then right that
so what's the word they're easily gullible there you go yeah it's not like they were
so gullible that they would believe in anything and everything it wasn't like that well because
it's interesting you see that in the Bible where often it's not it's not like a miracle
happens like oh that just happens all the time right they go no no oh wow that's amazing
we yeah and you often will even see this phrase in the Bible we've never seen anything like
this yeah especially when Jesus comes you know healing the lame you know the blind receive sight
those kinds of things they are all they all marvel at it they're shocked this isn't just
this is every day yeah it's not everyday occurrence yeah and I think a lot of people
don't appreciate that about the Bible that even for them they're trying to decide whether or not
they believe or what they believe about what they're witnessing and seeing and and I think
you would agree that say if we take something like the virgin birth or the miracles of Jesus
that we're looking at this from a cumulative case perspective not just some one-off event
that's taking place but a series of miracles that are taking place within a broader narrative
of and and compilation of evidence that would or lead me to believe that it's true yeah I think so
and really when I look at the Bible sometimes I hear people say well the Bible is full of miracles
it's just this is really problematic oh it's taken us to the same place yeah we've just we
we missed the turn as we came out that's what it is you think so yeah yeah yeah let's turn around
and go back this is really uh annoying sorry all right we uh we're sitting on the middle of a highway
because last night there was a storm that came through storm Amy and she was she was angry she
was very angry yeah and now some electrical cables came down on some highway there and we can't go
that route and that was the route that we were planning on going down so well currently there
is no route possible yeah Loch Ness they they've closed down all the highways around the area so
literally the entire lake is cordoned off yeah it's been a it's been an interesting
we've been going round and round trying to figure out what's going on but now that we've figured it
out I think we're gonna have to change our plans yeah so this podcast is gonna be paused and we're
gonna have to come back to this in a couple days when we come back through this area uh to get to
Loch Ness so the mystery continues the mystery continues we'll pick it up
in a couple days unbelievable you can't make this stuff up man oh Amy and we should also
probably say we got our good friend Jeff in the back seat if you're wondering who's that dude
hey guys all right my favorite thing about Apologetics Canada are the innovative ways
that we are continuing to use media to share the gospel around the globe hi my name is Ben
I'm the maritime director for Apologetics Canada and we are a Canadian charity that
depends on others joining us in the work that we do so whether you're giving a donation from
Canada or the U.S. both are tax deductible just be sure to choose which country you're giving from
you can go to apologeticscanada.com to give today hey welcome back to the podcast we were
out for a little bit there actually we were gone for four days yeah we we were in the midst of
filming and you where you saw us last we were in the car and we're going around a roundabout and
we're trying to get to the lake but it keeps rerouting us and won't let us go to Lake Loch
Ness so you can see Steve we've made it we've made it and we're still looking for Nessie
so we got our shirts though so
I believe man
but what happened was we were in a storm storm Amy yeah she was very angry and a lot of actually
as we were traveling around we saw a lot of trees knocked down because of a severe wind
yeah there was flooding wind trees knocked down power lines knocked down yeah upwards of a hundred
miles per hour very strong wind gusts and yeah actually the reason we couldn't come to Loch Ness
the first time was because there was a road that we needed to take where some of the power cables
had come down so they had to take care of that Loch Ness is the biggest lake in the UK like this
thing's humongous and really deep yeah and very deep fun fact by the way that you might find
interesting is that Loch is a Gaelic term for lake right yeah so it's a Scottish way of saying
lake Ness or Loch Ness and so we just decided we would stop the podcast and we would continue on
our trip we did some other podcasting we've been gone for four days yeah and now we've like we went
down to Glasgow we went over to Edinburgh and now we've come back so we we came back to to Loch Ness
the opposite direction yeah and it actually worked out better because the weather turned out much
better than yeah the first day we were here because it was just drizzly and rainy and but
actually today the weather has been I mean I saw sun we're in Scotland yeah I saw the sun
there was a little bit of blue sky out and so the weather yeah the weather's a lot better today
so we're gonna we're gonna finish that podcast in the the area the thing that we were talking about
before we ended was on miracles and let's let's just pick that up real quick Steve I mean one of
the things that was interesting about you know talking about miracles is I think a lot of people
would assume that in the bible that miracles are all over the place yeah I mean yes and no I mean
you certainly do see accounts of miracles in the bible but it's not really full of it I would say
but you have to kind of think of it as I mean there is a long history that's being
talked about and in from there you see accounts of miracles come out of it but miracles are really
concentrated around specific periods of time like around the time of God rescuing Israel out of
Egypt or when Jesus comes on the scene he goes around you know healing people and and turning
water into wine and so on and so forth or when the prophets were were doing their work around the
time of the the Israelite and Judah kings and so it's not full of it in that sense it's in fact
the whole narrative of the virgin birth like I mentioned last time revolves around this idea
that people just wouldn't believe what Mary would say that's why Joseph wants to divorce her right
I know we think oh virgin birth that sounds crazy well so did they yeah right you know and they're
like well you know they they didn't they didn't believe and and then and it gets kind of back to
that idea well you know what what does cause him to believe well evidence more evidence and
particularly being uh you know an angel coming to him and saying hey Joseph this is this is real
yeah this is by the holy spirit you you should go on with your marriage right and so yeah it's
interesting people sometimes say you know extraordinary claims require extraordinary
evidence that's not actually true if you actually go by that a lot of things that we
take to be true would have to be written off so for example even yeah give me an example of that
even even from a secular perspective right let's say you know the big bang I mean personally I
hold to the big bang I know a lot of well because I believe yes the universe was exploded into
existence yeah whether that be god or whatever yeah but either way I believe that the universe
began to exist and that's the critical thing right but that that the the idea that the universe
that had that kind of it exploded up into existence that's a pretty extraordinary claim
and what kind of extraordinary evidence do you need but what you see is as scientists study this
they don't give you extraordinary evidence they they give you ordinary evidence but a lot of it
right so what extraordinary claims require is not extraordinary evidence but additional evidence
and in the Joseph's case he had uh this additional piece of evidence right I mean you you see that
Mary is pregnant right and there it just doesn't seem to make sense she's supposed to be a virgin
and then there was that additional evidence of the angel appearing in his dreams and telling him
right and and he and he saw the evidence no doubt throughout the rest of his life as he watched
Jesus grow right so which which I think one thing that's just helpful to appreciate about when we're
talking about evidence that a lot of people miss with the bible is that the miracles themselves
are evidence of something bigger right right I mean take even the virgin birth the virgin birth
is actually evidence that something even more miraculous is going to happen that Emmanuel God
with us right that God's going to come in the flesh and and then this is going to lead even to
a greater miracle and that is you know ultimately that Jesus is going to die for us and he is going
to raise again in three days so there's this there's this idea in Christianity that a miracle
is always particularly and in these cases are pointing to a greater miracle yeah and that should
give us pause for those of us who call ourselves Christians some of us can be so wrapped up in the
idea of miracles we think that's the that's the end of Christianity that is the purpose of
Christian that's the gospel but in reality in the bible um the word miracle is almost never used
the word that is actually used instead is signs and so well if it's a sign then a sign is what's
pointing at yeah what is it pointing at so even when Jesus for example turns water into wine and
heals you know the lame so that they can walk and the blind received sight all of those things are
pointing to the fact that God's kingdom is here right and he is inaugurating it and he is the
messiah who does it right and so when John the Baptist is in prison is having doubts about who
Jesus actually is and he sends his disciples to Jesus and says are you the one to come or should
we wait for another and that's what Jesus says is well go and tell John what you see and hear
yeah right the lame walk the blind received sight right the deaf hear and these are all the things
that was prophesied in the old testament that God would do and then again those miracles are signs
that Jesus can do something even greater this is one thing that always bugs me by the way
is people thinking that that a miracle you know an impressive miracle is the lame walking or
something like that but what Jesus is saying is look John at these lesser miracles and know
that I can do the greater miracle right that the messiah is here and that I am going to free you
but I'm not going to free you in the way that you think from these Romans but I'm going to free you
from the greatest enemy from sin and death and this is going to be the greatest miracle that
there is there is no greater miracle than to reconcile your relationship back with God yeah
a broken life being transformed right yeah and the and one thing that I love about Christianity
is that it's not just even about being forgiven I mean it is about that yeah but it God to you
know almost one ups himself I mean if that's hopefully that's not too irreverent way of saying
it but what the Bible tells us is is that not only does God forgive us the rebels who committed high
and we become his children and we become therefore his heirs who will inherit his
kingdom to rule in it with Christ I mean that that blows my mind yeah yeah I love that uh I
should say that the location that we're at currently along uh Loch Ness is at a castle
why don't we find another spot to film from that you can get a better view of the castle and let's
continue this conversation and particularly we also want to want to get into the topic of of
mystery right as as we talk more about about this in this very cool location here in Loch Ness let's
do it ladies and gentlemen viewers and listeners I am so excited to finally announce to you our
upcoming conference series for 2026 with a brand new theme the church in history it's going to be
amazing and this time you get three opportunities to join us for the AC conference so kicking it
off January 30th to the 31st we're going to be heading to Willingdon Church that is in Burnaby
British Columbia for those of you who don't know the area it's relatively close to Vancouver then
we're going to be heading to our more well-known location at Northview Community Church in
Abbotsford that'll be happening March 6th and 7th then September 25th to the 26th we're going to be
heading to Hope Bible Church in Oakville Ontario this is going to be an amazing conference series
we cannot wait to meet you we cannot wait to see you guys there and if you want some more details
on who the main session speakers are like Andy and Wes Hough and some other amazing speakers and
breakout sessions that will be available head to the website right now apologetiscanada.com
slash ac-conference and we hope to see it all three why not that'd be awesome but at least
one of them but you know the drill you know the model until then love God love people bye for now
all right here we are at Urquhart Castle right on the coast of Loch Ness it's a very famous
remains of a medieval castle that's right here in the highlands along the Loch Ness and people
usually come here looking for Nessie it's a beautiful spot and I think you'd agree Steve
it kind of really adds to the mystique of this whole of this whole area and and there is there
is something kind of mysterious and cool about this area that doesn't doesn't surprise me but it
attracts so many tourists yeah and I mean again the story of the Loch Ness monster and old Nessie
I mean it's just so iconic for this area just everything around here when you go to shops and
when you see logos of different organizations that work around here it's all based off of that
Loch Ness monster shape yeah I asked I asked one local whether or not he had seen old Nessie
uh and uh and he said no and I said well what do you think about you know what do you think about
the stories and he said well he said uh they uh they definitely help tourism very very pragmatic
yeah yeah but I think there is something to this idea of mystery right I mean there is something
about I mean mystery is ultimately not knowing all that there is to know and that's what mystery
is but one thing that this does is that it gives you a sense that there's something more than just
what you see immediately around you yeah right that that this world is more than just the the
rocks and the and the water and the trees that you feel around you so it gives you a sense of
really in a not just in a fairy tale sort of way although that is one aspect of it but even more
than that maybe there is more to life than just this world that we're standing on yeah which I
think is part of part of the mystery that everybody wants to to be a part of a part of the world at
some level is that is that there is more there is more to to all of this and so I think I think in
one sense you know we're drawn to the stories of you know old Nessie, Sasquatch, Aliens, Santa Claus
if you can see you know Steve's shirt here uh obviously as we've already been talking about
in this podcast that that when we're talking about what do we actually believe you know and obviously
Steve doesn't believe in all these things yeah right but we do but we do have interesting beliefs
as Christians they don't that that we do have beliefs that some people think oh that's a that's
a strange belief yeah but but it's a belief that is rooted in fact it's a belief that we would argue
is rooted in in evidence that we have good reason to believe what we what we believe and that's not
to say that I couldn't be convinced that old Nessie exists or or Aliens or Santa Claus or
Sasquatch for that matter yeah so it's interesting you mentioned that because we were just talking
about this this morning about GK Chesterton and his writing and where he actually mentions in his
book Orthodoxy somebody very specific Joseph McCabe who was an ex-Catholic priest he left he he
renounced his vow he left the church and he joined like the rationalist groups and he really pushed
for secular humanism and he was very much a materialistic determinist meaning he believed that
this physical stuff that we they experienced that's all there is to this world
one of the things that Chesterton pointed out is that Mr. McCabe thinks I am not free
to think like I'm not a free thinker because I'm bound by my dogma well I think he is he can't do
free thinking because he's a materialist because he can't admit just even a speck of spiritualism
in his spotless machine of materialism right so if you believe that the physical stuff of which
we're made is all there is to this world then really you can't admit anything else to it you
can't be open to the possibility of there being Nessie whereas people who believe or God or or
God or Angels or anything of that sort whereas people who believe in some kind of a spiritual
reality that goes beyond just the physical dimension they're free to believe in that
they don't even though they don't have to think about that all the time but there there is an
allowance they're allowed to be able to believe that right they don't have to so they're freer in
that sense now one thing that I think is interesting about that is that in that strictly materialistic
worldview there is this lack of mystery even to who and what we are as as human beings right as
a person that I have a mind or a soul that I am that I have free free choice speaking of free
free choice of what I believe because strict materialist doesn't even believe that they exist
you know they they believe that that they're just a bag of chemicals that that they're just
you know a brain having chemical reactions that has an illusion of thinking that they're a person
but they're nothing more than that well if you actually start thinking in those terms what you
realize is that the materialism right that physicalism is it's a simple worldview but it's
too simple because it doesn't take into it can't account for all the experiences that we have
because it certainly seems at least like we have free will and we certainly believe that words have
meaning right because meaning is not a physical thing right right and so that would be a mystery
or that would be for a strict physicalist that's an impossibility yeah and you said something very
interesting about the importance of meaning in law do you want to hash that out in law we our
law is predicated on the belief that words have meaning and in fact that you can know the meaning
of words and more than that that you can be held accountable to those to those rules I mean that
that's what a contract is all about is that we believe you that that those words have meaning
you know what the meaning of those words is that can be known and you can be held accountable to it
yeah and when a witness says something that means something yeah right there is some correlation
between what the person is saying that it has actually purchased on reality the way things
actually are even the physical the way how it physically played out and so forth and so yeah
materialism just kind of boils down to it and in a sense right these days you know physics is the
queen of sciences right if you understand how the different bits of particles work together then
you basically have the seeds to know everything that there is to know and in some ways I think
a lot of people are experiencing this sense of disenchantment that this world is really just
nothing more than what we're experiencing there's nothing beyond and it's just particles colliding
in motion and so I think mystery plays a very important part in kind of turning our eyes to
something beyond just what we have here well now I think that's one of the things that I
I love about the Christian faith is that this idea of fact and mystery can kind of come together that
we have good reasons to believe that Jesus is who he claimed to be but at the same time we're drawn
into a mystery in just the depths of who he is and the reality of what he's done and one
one of the ways I love that Michael Polanyi put it in his book personal knowledge is he says that
Jesus provides the comfort of the crucified God and ultimately what he talks about in this passage
is this idea that there is a mystery to Jesus that actually is comforting because he put it like
this he said when you make a scientific discovery it'll in you know it it's a mystery and then you
you learn about the mystery and you're you're enchanted by it for a moment but it fades and
then then there's these moments where you go and maybe see a beautiful work of art right beautiful
painting and again there's this mystery that kind of draws you in why did they paint it what did
they paint and it will entertain you for a bit or you know enchant you for a bit but but again he's
calling Jesus the comfort of the crucified God because there's a depth there's a well that you
just will never you know that will never run dry that you can continue to come back to over and
over again because that mystery is going to just draw you deeper and deeper into who Jesus really
is and one thing that I love about the Christian faith is that you don't just have to deny the
spiritual or the physical right right so you can embrace both right so it's not just a very simple
simplistic kind of a thing and in the person of Jesus what you see is God who is spirit takes on
flesh and comes to dwell among us so what that means is that that spirit and the material come
together and it's not just those two substances coming together but you can actually have
relationship right relationship with God and relationship with one another why is that why
I mean we are just physical beings right and how does a physical thing have any relationship with
God who is spirit right well as it turns out we are also made of body and soul right and Jesus
actually demonstrates what we can be like who's somebody who has that loving right relationship
with God and with one another and that's one thing that I love about the Christian faith and how
Jesus fulfills who we are supposed to be I love that well this is a fitting place I think to end
our podcast here on Lake Loch Ness full of mystery still haven't seen old Nessie
I will keep looking thank you for joining us on the AC podcast has been a mystery of
Apologize Canada we will come back next week with more things to think about until then
you know the drill love God love people bye for now
