2026 Mazda CX-5 vs Toyota RAV4 | 1st Round Knockout

SUV review
33 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Here we are, the moment you've all been waiting for, the brand new Toyota RAV4 versus the Mazda
CX-5. Now this RAV4 won our comparison test against some of the most prestigious players
in the industry. Check out that video for a lot more detail, but now it's time for
Mazda to take a swing at it. Both these vehicles are trying to compete in a very similar space,
including dollar amount, but each have their own kind of individual flavor. When you look
at the outside, yes, they look like a small compact or midsize SUV. The Mazda is definitely
a standout. It's always been one of the better looking SUVs in its segment, and the Mazda
has continued to garner a lot of positivity for its driving prowess. The RAV4 is trying to grow
in terms of interior volume, cargo space, and trying to look a little bit more modern. Again,
it's pretty much the king of holding its value, and people want it. They've wanted it, and people
are willing to wait to get one of these at the dealership too, so there's that. But the big
difference here is price point. The RAV4 is more expensive. There's no way around it. You can get
it in front-wheel drive or all-wheel drive, but this time, this generation RAV4 is hybrid only,
where the Mazda CX-5 is now all-wheel drive across all trim levels. Toyota also gets you with
features where the Mazda is fully loaded at $40,000. To get a fully loaded RAV4, you're going
into like $44,000, and that's to get panoramic sunroof, heated and cooled seats, all the features
that you want to pack in. The Mazda just bundles it in for far less money, and that's where the
Mazda will continue to be a better value if you're looking for more features. So let's talk about the
The interior of the RAV4, to start off with, has a far superior layout in terms of storage,
from the door handle fitting a phone, a sunglass case, to the door storage where you can fit a
small or large bottle. The entire center console area is where the RAV4 definitely stands out and
beats the Mazda in almost every single aspect. You have places to put two phones on the upper
layer. When you go to the upper trim level, you have dual wireless charging pads. The lower
storage space can hold two phones, sunglass holders, your key. The center cup holder space
is amazing, and this is a far better layout in terms of usability because the shifter is much
smaller on the Toyota. It's consolidated down so you can fit almost three drinks in here. The center
divider keeps things locked in place. You can pull it out and still fit sunglasses, a key. I mean,
it is so usable. And then you have the center armrest on the Toyota, which
opens both ways. And then you can flip it upside down to have a flat surface for like work area,
or you can just take it out. I mean, the flexibility and storage in this car is tremendous,
and it's one of the best things about it. Now, yes, it does feel a little bit plasticky when you
put your arm on the armrest in the Toyota. I mean, there is kind of that clickiness because
the armrest flexibility, but if you're spending all your time and you have a family and you're
growing in this and you need a big space where you don't want to upgrade to a bigger vehicle,
this does it far better. Also, because of their interior options across the trim levels,
you have just a way better dash layout. It looks far less generic, far less rental car.
Yes, there's hard plastics in here, but really the geometry and the way that they've done the
interior layout looks and feels far more interesting. Now, some of that is subjective
and some of it is objective, but the big place where the Toyota RAV4 gains massive points is,
yes, they've gone to the big screen for the infotainment, but their technology suite is far
superior in terms of safety. Things work more consistently. There's more advancements in this
next generation Toyota safety suite and their infotainment next gen is also far better than it
used to be. Everything seems to work very well. Pairing works almost instantaneously, and they
haven't removed all the physical controls. You have physical clicky controls on the steering
wheel. You have some physical controls left for volume on the center display, temperature, and
your drive modes are all physical along with your camera button and some of your driving assist. So,
Toyota has found the perfect balance here between technology and the way to make everything
functional. The backseat space is going to go to Mazda. It's going to Mazda because of the door
opening here. The door opening in the back is far superior to get things in and out, namely if you
have two car seats or you have adults in the back. It's way easier to get in the Mazda now than the
Toyota, even though the Toyota has a lot of space in the back and then the second row.
I prefer if I was a working family, I'd want to have the ease of usability in the second row in
the Mazda, including the rear cargo hold. While it may not have the biggest opening, it is way easier
to put the seats down because they have a remote release on the side where you have to lean in or
go into the second row to put the seats down in the Toyota and the kind of the nooks and crannies
on the left and right side of the Mazda are just you can store more stuff back there. So, while
there is a wash in some ways, I feel like the Mazda's usability is better in the second half
of the car. They both have spare tires in the back and a lot of that is all similar, but again, it
depends on what your usage case is. Going back to the Mazda in the front, the things that the Mazda
does really well is it does have a more simple layout. Everything flows together. There's less
broken lines, less plasticky chunks. If you like a clean and smooth aesthetic in the Mazda, it is
better in many ways. So, if that's something that you like and you prefer to have everything in the
touchscreen and have kind of generic physical controls, hybrid controls in the center, I think
Mazda did a good job also consolidating its center screen is way easier to use and some of its
infotainment being Android Automotive, chances are there's going to be more over-the-air updates
to keep it fresh longer than the Toyota in-house developed infotainment. The last thing to talk
about here is comfort and also audio systems. The Toyota seats, while they may not have the better
posture position, you feel like you slouch more, less keeping your pelvis in place, the bottom
cushions and the back cushions are far softer on the Toyota. If you need a more like compressible
or comfortable seat, there's more cushion in the Toyota seats. So, that's something the Mazda has
better posture, but the bottom cushion is like a rock. So, it depends on who you are. The audio
system goes to the Mazda. The Bose system in this car is far superior in terms of tunability.
There's still an EQ, but it doesn't sound so muddled and mid and bass heavy as the Toyota. The JBL just
doesn't matter if you spend more money from the base to the upgraded JBL. It just sounds
very, very flat and very bass heavy. So, if you like music, you're going to like the Mazda, but we're
briefly going to talk about some of the mechanical differences in the shop, comparing the hybrid
system to the non-hybrid system and the Mazda and take them both for a drive. Welcome to the shop
segment, where I'm going to give you a high-level overview of the Toyota RAV4 and the Mazda CX-5,
starting with the Toyota RAV4. This generation comes standard with hybridization only, unlike
the previous car. That means using a 2.5 liter naturally aspirated engine, no turbos, and electric
motors, including a battery pack to power those motors. The electric motors are also able to
regenerate power and give you the energy back to the battery without ever having to plug this in,
which is a huge advantage of the hybrid tech here. The other thing it does is it gives you an ECVT,
which uses gears or a planetary gear set to infinitely vary the gear ratios. So, it's
technically feels a little bit like a CVT, but has the reliability of a gear-driven transmission.
Toyota just does not have problems with these. So, the benefit here is it delivers more power
than the CX-5, around 236 horsepower, which is a massive difference here, and the fuel economy is
super important. It comes standard with front-wheel drive only. You have to pay extra for all-wheel
drive, and what it does here is it adds an electric motor in the back that is powered, again, by that
battery pack. The electric motor has an advantage here for packaging, takes up less space, and they
can control and vary it through software, unlike a mechanical unit where you have a driveshaft to a
differential in the back. They really can't do much with that, aside from the electromagnetic
clutch that kind of engages and disengages it. So, there are some benefits to it, despite its
cost difference. Now, the Mazda CX-5, well, you got one option here, a naturally aspirated 2.5 liter
that makes around 186 horsepower and about the same amount of torque. The reason they ditched the
turbocharged engine for this generation is a lot of people weren't buying it in the previous car.
To be fair, it was also the most expensive trim level. So, you know, if you need more power, this is
definitely going to be a massive difference between the two. It is paired to a six-speed automatic
transmission that has been recalibrated and reprogrammed for this generation. It is also its
big selling feature. Even for 30 grand, it comes standard with all-wheel drive. You don't have to
pay extra for it here, although it is a mechanical all-wheel drive system with a driveshaft and a
differential in the back. This is essentially tried and true. It's what Mazda has been doing forever
and really it's worked for them. Now, there have been improvements to the body structure, namely
on the back, where they've lowered the noise floor, reduced the booming and some of the airborne noise
for the back passengers. It is also more compliant, which means it's more softly sprung because they've
been able to improve structure or local stiffness in different areas of this car. So now, they figured
out about a better balance of making it firm, but also making it softer to compete with things like
the RAV4, which has generally always been kind of a boaty feel. But from this point, we're going to
take these both for a drive and explain some of the differences in philosophy and how they feel.
You ready to see if the CX-5 Jinbuys your e-ties, Mark? Not anymore.
187 horsepower, torque converted, six-speed automatic.
Zero to 60 now, so just over eight seconds, which is feels about like 130 horsepower. Yes,
at least when you compare it to the as standard hybrid drivetrain in the RAV4, you definitely
lack the low down electrified torque and power on this car. It's very noticeable,
the fuel economy is an easy 10 miles per gallon worse than the real world. So why would you buy
this other than the fact that it has a bigger back seat and it's basically $4,000 to $5,000
cheaper if you compare like to like trips? Well, if you're cost conscious, that's a huge one. I mean,
you can't downplay the fact that this is far less money for what you get. I think the driving,
despite the engine and drivetrain, which, you know, they're going to have a hybrid option for
this soon, which is going to then probably equalize the price. Yes. Assuming that,
you know, the hybrid system is good. But where we're at today, I think this delivers something
that's still kind of driver centric. Somebody that likes to drive their SUVs where it doesn't
feel like everything's been turned into mush. It's a really anti-mushy car. The steering feels
good. The brake pedal calibration feels really good. Even the throttle, right? We talked about
the transmission calibration in our standalone drive of this. All of those systems are working
really well. And now this is a much quieter car than it used to be. I think driving them back to
back, despite the lack of acoustic glass versus the old one, it is quieter overall and it's going
to be quieter in the back seat. I think that's a big thing to note about this as they made those
improvements. A lot of the improvements are in the back of this. So that back passenger,
the ride quality is better. It's quiet. The airborne noise is very similar, but the structure
born noise is more, more control. There's less boominess in this than the RAV4. That's something
that the RAV4 and a lot of Toyota struggle, struggle with is low frequency. So, you know,
but at the end of the day, those are very, very minor things, very minor things. So from my
perspective, comfort, usability, those things are more important overall. And then when you get past
all these things, when you drive it every day, Jack, how, what's your feeling like long-term,
what car would you rather be in? The Mazda, well, Mazda has lost a lot of their identity in the
interior space of this car, but Mazda has still managed to hold on to is their almost over-focus
on driving dynamics in vehicles that driving dynamics don't particularly matter in. Like the
CX-50, which is not this car is the greatest example of that. They gave up ride quality and
livability and some, some of the day-to-day stuff for the better inputs and better handling this
car compared to the RAV4. I don't think it's necessarily as soft, but it has a lot less
head toss, a lot less like boom ride over things, but in the inputs are much better. But honestly,
in the real world, to your point, what are you normally doing? You're doing this. You're sitting
in traffic, you're driving in, you know, to pick up your kids. So if you do like hot dogging it
around in that sort of driving environment, this is better than the RAV4. But I think just as an
NPC car, which is what these things really are. I think the, the added refinement from the hybrid
four-cylinder and the better fuel economy of that car, I think sort of wins me over. Yeah. And I
think the suspension calibration, if you're concerned about ride, I think the suspension
calibration is better in this car. And it's not, it's still firm, but it's comfortable. Like it's
not like the CX-50 people like, well, the CX-50 is more of the driver's SUV. And I would argue
that the inputs get tiring on that car. It's a much more jouncey, bouncy ride. This is far more
controlled than the CX-50 is. It's a way better riding car. It's more comfortable and it still
handles well. Yes. It's on a little bit softened up now, but it's softened in a good way. Something
we complain about with Mazdas or they were too firm for what they were. This is no longer a
problem. You don't get in here and think, oh, this is just too firm or it just is a good balance.
Again, all of the things as a driving machine are really good. It's just now they're behind
in some of the other aspects. I, as the deer run out in front of us, I, I think I agree with you
that I, on a long ride, this is probably less fatiguing than the RAV4, but for individual
impacts, the RAV4 is still soft. Yeah, it is. It's a, I mean, if you care about more torque,
more power, softer couch-like inputs and super, super soft and easy to use inputs, the RAV4 is
going to be less fatiguing because we talked about that when we did our original comparison. It's
like a car you could pinky drive. Like the brake pedal is so soft, the throttle is easy, like
steering is easy. It gets going easy. It's a car you don't have to work so much and you just turn
your brain off. And I think that's what a lot of people want. You turn off all enjoyment of driving
where this has some level of steering feedback. You feel in the wheel, it's perfectly weighted.
The throttle linearity and the fact that if you push all the way down and you hit the detent,
it will auto downshift, auto downshift. It will hold revs if you don't. The brake pedal cowl is
perfect. Yeah. It turns in well. All of that is what the Mazda does still well, like Mazda does
in every single car other than the CX-90 and the CX-70. Yeah. Again, it comes down to priority,
I think, really, but you want to head it in the RAV4? Yeah, let's talk through that, Jack.
I just put this thing in a sport. I don't know why, but I did. Akio Toyota smiles upon you, sir.
Feel that? I feel him. You feel torque? You feel his electric motor that he installed in
the factory with his hands? He truly is the automotive Christ, Akio Toyota. I feel like
we just got to 60 in about half the amount of time we did. Instrument testing is like in the
really what it shows is, you know, nobody really cares about the specs as it's more effortless.
And we got into that when we're talking in the Mazda video, like everything is just easier to
do in here. You literally just have to tap, you know, just get into the throttle a little bit.
You don't have to beat the piss out of it like a 90s car to get it going like the Mazda. And
there's nothing wrong with the Mazda drivetrain. It's just people in this class of vehicle want
this. That's why this sells, you know, and I think, you know, once we get going here and feel
the suspension and you combine that with the seats and like the give the comfort, the visibility.
This is clearly the better everyday car. And it takes about two seconds to realize that
Toyota has a lot more money than Mazda has. And they know why and how people buy vehicles like
this. And they know exactly what their customers want. You can tell they've been building the
RAV4 for about a billion years. You tell them they put a ton of money behind this car and they
thought everything out. Yeah. They didn't screw up the infotainment. People want a big screen.
It has a big screen. There's still some physical controls. They want to be able to place their
phone places. They want nooks and crannies. They want soft seats with long seat bottoms.
They want a safety suite that can basically drive the car for them. They want a big trunk.
They want over 40 miles of the gallon. That is all delivered in this vehicle at the expense of
the dynamics aren't as good. Yeah. And it's a more lazy feeling car. It's far less direct.
It's far less engaging to drive. But at the end of the day, that's why I was kind of starting to
say the more I drove these back to back and then I got in my regular daily commute and I wasn't
overthinking what the car was doing. I just wanted to be in this. And again, I think it does go back
to those comfort elements of the visibility seems better. It feels less of like a coffin in here.
It feels brighter. And I know the interior has a lot to do with it. But, you know, overall,
I think the ergonomics and where you put everything and how you use everything is
just so much easier in here. My brain as a commuter, it just clicks. And I think that's
why it clicks with so many people. And there's nothing wrong with the Mazda either. Like there
really isn't. I think if it was just a choice between do you want soft versus firm driving
dynamics, then it would be more of a pick your poison. Yeah. But in this case, for three or
four thousand dollars extra, the fact you get 10 miles per gallon more with gas prices continuing
to increase, that's going to be a problem. The fact that the residuals for RAV4s are so much
higher than CX-5s. So your cost to own is going to be lower on the RAV4. Well, at the end of the
day with these things. Right. I think that's the thing is when you have this car that you're
piling the miles on like you would with this, like I don't want to be at the pump. Like I,
you know, like I'm getting more power here. I'm getting easier drivability and I'm getting over
40 miles to the gallon. I'm not having to fill it up and a higher residual and a higher residual.
Like all of this stuff starts to stack up. And the fact that there's like a drive recorder now
built into the infotainment where you basically can keep your eye on everything. If somebody hits
you or something happens, like all of these things that take your mind off the car, right?
And you just live your life. This is just a better choice. And is it the better car? I guess that's
the question. Is it really better? What's better? I guess becomes the question again, the dynamics.
If you care about the way something drives, the CX-5 drives more like a sporty vehicle. If I'm
on a back road, I live in the Pacific Northwest. I live in California and I want to drive my
CV like an idiot when my family isn't in the car. The Mazda does a better job. It really does.
To be fair, we haven't driven the GR Sport variant of the RAV4. You can't really compare that with
these. It's also a lot more money. The regular RAV4 that we're in versus the regular CX-5,
even when the CX-5 in the future gets a hybrid drive train. The CX-5 is a more engaging car.
It's just on the inside part of it. It's other than the back seats being slightly bigger in the
CX-5 and the doors opening 90 degrees, at least for the front occupants. This is a far more usable
car. Well, Jack, I think we can beat a dead horse and keep talking. Actually, I could talk about
this a lot more, but we're just going to get into the final thoughts and sum all this up. All right,
let's do it. Final thoughts on the Toyota RAV4 versus the Mazda CX-5. This is a clear case where
you win because there's so much competition in this space, even the brands can't keep up anymore.
You're dealing with two cars here that deliver uniquely different experiences, but here it is,
the Toyota wins. I'm sorry to say, and it wins for a few reasons. One, hybridization is standard.
Yes, it's going to cost you more, but when you go to trade it in or sell it, it's going to hold
its value. It delivers more power and better fuel economy. It also has better usability in the
frontal occupancy space. It's a more comfortable car. It feels more livable every single day.
Now, that doesn't mean the Mazda doesn't have its pros. It's clearly the value winner. It's
all-wheel drive is standard for $30,000. You get one that is pretty much loaded with the features
you want for $35,000. So, if you can't afford to spend over $40,000 to get things like panoramic
sunroof, a better audio system, and all those features, the Mazda is going to be your car.
The Mazda is also the winner here on the used market. I'm sure Mazda does not want to hear that,
but if you're going to find a couple-year-old CX-5, you can find them all day long where you're
quite a bit to find a used Toyota for a similar price. The Mazda does have advantages in terms
of drivability. The inputs are way better. Braking, steering, all the driving things you love
to do. But at the end of the day, that kind of wears off when you're just going to pick up your
kids or going to your Costco run or the basics that people do. Mazda has made a much quieter
car than it used to be. It has a better rear half of the vehicle, which is the important part to
talk about here, is if you put two kids or two car seats in the back and you need to use that
back space more, it's easier to use the Mazda than the Toyota. But other than that, you're
going to have to take a look at both of these and make a decision for yourself. Thanks for watching.
I'll see you next video.
