2020 Mazda CX-30 vs. New 2021 Subaru Crosstrek and Honda HR-V

Cars Arena
18 followers
This is Mazda's all-new compact crossover. It's called the CX-30, and we're going to test it out.
That's coming up right now on Driving Sports TV.
This is the all-new CX-30 all-wheel drive from Mazda. It's a compact crossover that features
upscale appointments, unique design, and a new trail system, which we'll put to the test
later in this video. It competes directly against the Honda HR-V and the Subaru Crosstrek,
which Subaru just announced is getting a major upgrade for 2021. In this video, we'll include
both comparisons against the current HR-V as well as the just announced 2021 Subaru Crosstrek.
Let's get started by touring all the features. The CX-30 we're testing today is the top trim
premium all-wheel drive with a couple extras thrown in. Prices you see it here $31,670 US dollars,
including delivery. All CX-30 trims get a single engine option. This is a 2.5 liter
four-cylinder Skyactiv-G that runs on standard fuel mated to a six-speed automatic transmission.
Output is good for the size at 186 horsepower with equal torque. This being an all-wheel drive
premium model, it also comes with cylinder deactivation, which results in one mpg better
across the board. EPA rates this at 25 mpg in the city and 32 on the highway. For 2021,
the Subaru Crosstrek is getting a second engine option. It's a 2.5 liter boxer good for 182
horsepower. This will one up the CX-30 by having almost equal power, but better economy. The
Subaru is getting up to 34 mpg on the highway. This larger engine will only come with a CVT.
The Honda HR-V is the smallest of the trio, both in terms of size and power. With 141 horsepower
on tap attached to a continuously variable transmission, you would think it would have
the best economy. But in all-wheel drive trim, it's actually the worst at only 31 mpg on the
highway and 26 in town. Behind the second row, there is 20.2 cubic feet of total capacity in
the CX-30. Under the floor is a spare and a Bose subwoofer since this is an upper trim.
Fold down the second row for up to 45.2 cubic feet. Subaru hasn't yet announced cargo space
on the updated Crosstrek, but we can expect it will be very close to the 2020 model's 20.8 cubic
feet behind the second row and 55.3 with all the seats down. Now, I don't know how Honda does it,
but the HR-V is a miracle of compact design. It has up to 23.2 cubic feet behind the second row
and up to 55.9 with all the rows folded. That's just not right to be so small, so cute, yet so
big and useful on the inside. The second row in the CX-30 is tiny, definitely not a place an adult
would want to hang out for very long. There are no real features to speak of, though you do get
a fold-down armrest with cup holders. Yet again, Honda's packaging team manages to squeeze out
several extra inches for passengers in the second row compared to both the 2020 CX-30
and the Crosstrek, talking like three full inches more. This is kind of crazy. Up front,
the CX-30 has an upscale look that simply outclasses the 2020 HR-V and the 2020 Subaru
Crosstrek. The leather and metal is refined and clean. Overall, it's practically a master class
in automotive minimalism. That said, the new Crosstrek will be getting a major upgrade to
its interior as well. We'll see how that looks in person when we finally get behind the wheel,
but between the three, I think it's safe to say that the Mazda interior is one of the best,
even going into 2021. The one bone I have to pick with this interior is Mazda's continued use
of piano black. This scratches far too easily and looks awful in a very short period of time.
The CX-30 does use a nice combination of digital and analog displays in the gauge cluster,
which continues their embrace of minimalism. Like BMW, they also employ a dial to control the 8.8
inch infotainment system. This display is set back on the dash with a focus on improving the
driver's angle of view. In addition to the dial, you can also use voice commands for a number of
functions. In addition to navigation, preferred and above models also get XM satellite radio.
Select and above models can also plug in mobile devices for Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Unfortunately, these are not included in the base CX-30. All trims of the Mazda get advanced safety,
including collision mitigation, blind spot warning, and lane departure warning. Adaptive
front lighting is standard only on the premium. The standard rear view camera includes cross
traffic alerts. There are tracking lines, but they are non-responsive. Now let's look at the
competition. Honda's offering matches Mazda, but Honda only offers it on the three highest trim
levels of the HR-V, whereas Mazda has its standard. Subaru goes even further with the new 2021
Crosstrek, including lane centering standard on the new EyeSight system. Even beyond that, the
highest trim level offers automatic rear braking and lane change assist, making it the best choice
in safety if that's your number one concern. The transmission has a couple of different driving
modes, as well as a manual override with included paddle shifters. There is also a separate sport
mode, which quickens throttle response. Clearance is an issue on most small crossovers. The CX-30 has
up to 7.9 inches, which is of course better than Honda's 7.3 inches. But then you get to Subaru,
and they almost always offer up to 8.7 inches, a whole inch more. And we expect the 2021 model
to continue that tradition, giving it the win in that department. As we know, mini cars look great
on paper, only to fall apart when used in real world challenges. And with Mazda now finally
including a trail mode with their all-wheel drive system, will they finally rise to the occasion?
Let's start our testing with a full throttle launch on gravel.
In sport mode, all the power is clearly channeling through the front wheels.
Even traction control does very little to stop the action.
Engage the new trail mode, and you can see more torque is going to the rear wheels. Mazda hasn't
disclosed the exact amount. This does minimize spin from the front tires. Mazda says their iACTIV
all-wheel drive calculates individual tire load in real time to shift power as needed. More torque to
the back when accelerating, less when decelerating. It transfers power with an electronically controlled
clutch. On the highway, it'll sit mostly in front-wheel drive mode to improve economy,
but it will be ready to push power to the back at a fraction of a second.
Mazda really prides itself on handling. And with the CX-30, they succeeded in combining sporty
handling along with a popular crossover package. But how about a launch from zero? Let's try a 0-60.
I'm going to go ahead and put it into sport mode. I'm going to put the transmission,
just keep it in drive, stop completely, and 3, 2, 1, go. Ooh, that's really slow to get started.
29, 40, 50, 60. And there we go. It's about as quick as you would expect. I mean,
it has 186 horsepower and 186 pound-feet of torque. That is, you know, par for the class.
Actually, probably pretty good for the class, but not an exceptional 0-60 machine.
I think it's just fine. This is equipped with Mazda's i-ACTIVSENSE system. That is their
active safety setup. That means it has collision mitigation, blind spot warning,
rear cross-traffic alerts, but it also has adaptive cruise control. However, that adaptive
cruise control, I'll just set it here. Let's set and we'll pace the vehicle in front of us.
It does not do semi-autonomous driving. If we hit a lane, it'll try to bump us in, but not really.
So we're just going to cut straight to the chase here because I really want to see what this trail
system will do. And it's all about losing traction on two wheels and how it responds.
So we're going straight to the rock trail. Now, this portion right here is kind of the
first good test. Right now, I have the car still in standard drive mode. I have not engaged trail
mode and we're going to see how well it does. Crawl ratio is pretty good. This is, of course,
a six-speed automatic. I'm going super slow because this has very little ground clearance
compared to other crossovers. Well, we got through that without grinding anything.
Hopefully we can do this next portion too. Now let's put the trail system to the test.
This is a new feature now included on the 2021 CX-5 Turbo, the CX-9, and the CX-30.
On the same trail, the Honda HR-V was far less capable. In fact, I think it's safe to say that
it is the worst performing all-wheel drive non-hybrid crossover we've tested yet. Now,
we haven't tested a non-hybrid Crosstrek on this trail yet since we're still waiting for the new
2021 model to get delivered. But given our extensive experience with the Crosstrek and
Subarus in general, we expect the new model with more horsepower will eat up this trail
without issue. Now let's see how the Mazda CX-30 does on the same course.
What we're going to do here is focus on how well this new trail button works. What it's supposed
to do is redistribute torque into the system like we've seen so many other crossovers do.
Basically, when a wheel starts spinning because this has open differentials, it would normally
lose all the power through that spinning wheel. What the trail mode is going to do is it's going
to apply the brakes to slow down the bleed of that power and put it back into the system,
presumably to the wheels that have grip. So to see how well this system works specifically,
first we're going to go halfway up with the system not on. Basically, this is just standard
open differential all-wheel drive up the first half of the rock trail. Right now I'm in nothing
special, just drive. And again, clearance is an issue here. Not only clearance, but then we also
have the issue of, you know, these are 18-inch wheels. Is this the only CX-30 that'll do this?
Probably. But you will now know what it is capable of. Let's see. Now the six-speed automatic
transmission is doing a very good job of keeping a slow velocity. We're crawling along at one,
two miles per hour here. Of course, I don't have any status as to what my all-wheel drive system
is doing, so I'm just going to have to go with my ears and kind of with, you know, general feel.
This should be where I start to lose some grip.
Yep, there we go. Losing grip. I'm just keeping it on and we're just spinning wheels. Okay,
so that's not doing anything.
Okay, this is perfect. So I am slipping right here, so I'm going to go ahead
and I'm not even going to back up because I can't get out of this right now. So instead
of going back down, what I'm going to do is I'm going to turn on trail mode right now
and we'll see if we can escape this hole. So trail mode should be redistributing power.
It did it. It works. I had no doubt. Good job, guys. So what you saw there was power was just
bleeding through the wheels that were spinning because it was open differentials. Power was just
going to the wheel that had the least resistance. Once I enabled that, it started to use brakes
to be able to stop that wheel from bleeding power and it put it back into the system. So
it didn't waste it on the wheel that was just free spinning. It really functioned. Now,
this is very similar to Subaru's X mode, if you're familiar with that,
though, of course, there's only one mode here. So it's similar to single stage X mode. Now,
let's see how it does the rest of it. And I think for the rest of it, not only will that be a
challenge for the trail system, it'll also be a challenge for the clearance and for these tires.
Let's carry on. I'm just crawling along as slow as possible because I'm really concerned
about these approach angles. And I am taking the easier line for obvious reasons.
Okay, so far we're doing pretty good. Dare I dip my nose in here? Sure, why not?
Forget the easiest line. We'll go a little harder. This all-wheel drive system seems to be doing
pretty good. Of course, clearance is still an issue. Oh, that's pretty good. Pretty good. Come
on. Let's feel it. Feel it. Yes. It did it. Okay. Don't know what I was worried about.
Now we're going to go down. And this does not have, even though it has a trail mode,
that doesn't engage hill descent control clearly because when I release the brake pedal, I just
roll. So what I'm going to do is put it into manual mode, put it into first gear, and see if
that's slow enough. Nope, still not slow enough. We're just going to have to use good old-fashioned
brakes on the way down. And where going up the approach angle was an issue, going down it's even
worse because we have all the weight going towards the front of the vehicle now. Okay, we got this.
We got this. Not worried. Not worried at all. Oop, slip. I think we answered the question,
does the trail button work? Yes, clearly it does. It's something we've seen on so many other
crossovers as they've added this technology. It's really leveled them up in terms of capability.
And with this vehicle, it's no different. The new CX-30, very capable off-road. The only big
problems are the physical limitations. Approach, departure, breakover, those are all issues with
this vehicle that you can't fix. Not without lifting it up and getting crazy. If you're
going to do that, just buy a different vehicle. If you're looking for a city-focused crossover
with legitimate trail capability, the CX-30 is a much better choice than the HR-V, which is already
starting to show its age. We do expect Honda to refresh the HR-V in 2021, but so far, it's just
rumors. Subaru, however, is killing it these days. They were already selling almost every
Crosstrek they could build. Now that it's finally received a much-needed horsepower bump and
available dual-mode X-mode, as well as improvements to the interior, it'll probably continue to eat
up the sales in the class. However, the highest output motor models will only be available with
continuously variable transmissions. If you want a manual, you'll have to stick to the slower 152
horsepower 2-liter engine option. That means if you want a traditional automatic, between the three,
your only choice is the Mazda CX-30. And really, if you can live with a limited second-row space
and you want what is probably the best handling crossover around, the CX-30 is an excellent option.
It's like the Goldilocks for small families, or small commuters that also seek a little adventure
on the weekends. Which would you pick? Post a comment below. Also, please share and like our
video. Your support makes our channel possible. For Driving Sports TV, I'm Ryan Douthit. Thanks again for watching.
