You Can't Heal Broken Family Relationships, They Said... #$h^TTherapistsSay

Affection avenue
2 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedAlicia and Jonathan Decker discuss the role of therapists and the complexities of repairing damaged relationships. They emphasize that while therapists should provide tools and guidance, they should not make life decisions for their clients. The conversation explores the criteria for salvageable relationships, the importance of boundaries, and the distinction between forgiveness and trust.
I'm Alicia Decker, co-founder of Mended Light. And I'm Jonathan Decker, licensed therapist,
and we are going to talk about what therapists say. Because as much as we'd like to put therapists
such as myself on a pedestal as these pair- no, no, no, no! As the gurus atop the mountains who
have the answers to all of life's questions, a good therapist is going to guide, is going to
give you tools and techniques, is going to help you to explore your options, but is not going to
tell you what you should do. And a lot of therapists seem to think their job is just to say,
here's what you should do with your life. It's my job to make your decisions for you. So we polled
our community on social media, our Mended Light community, what are some of the outrageous things
therapists have said to you. And one of them was, you can't save your family. Like, you can't save
your family relationship. It's broken. Just let it go. Stop trying to control everything and just
let go. Now, I'm not saying that's categorically bad advice. I would have a hard time categorically
saying that to somebody, because I got into the therapy business believing that people can change
and that relationships can get better. If I didn't believe that, I'd be in the wrong business.
Do I think that there are times where maybe walking away is the best situation?
Yeah, I think there are toxic situations like that, but that's not for me to decide.
I wanted to pick your brain, because you've got this amazing brain. That is why I married you,
by the way. I looked at you and I said, look at the brain on that one. It's on me. And I wanted
to... I do want to pick your brain, though, about when are relationships salvageable versus not?
What does it take for a relationship that's quote-unquote broken, toxic, or damaged? There's
a lot of hurt. There's a lot of bad history there to survive and thrive versus, yeah,
we just got to cut it loose. So often when there's conflict,
there's hurt behind that conflict. And when we meet hurt with more hurt, it just blows up,
like it gets bigger, right? So it's worth recognizing the hurt of both sides that are
involved. And as long as people are willing to be honest and to take accountability, so to be
honest about their behavior, to be honest about their hurt, and to take accountability for their
behavior, and then make changes, right? So honesty, accountability, and changed behavior. As long as
both parties are willing to do that on some level, then a relationship can be worked on.
Whether it's a spouse relationship, whether it's a parent-child relationship, it's a sibling
relationship. Those relationships can improve and be worked on. There's definitely circumstances
where an individual is toxic, right? Where they're not willing to take any accountability for their
behavior. They don't see anything wrong with what they've done, and they're not willing to change.
And at that point, that's when you decide, okay, what does a healthy relationship for me look like
with this person? What's a relationship where I can feel safe? And if it's an abusive person,
I would say absolutely. Mentally, emotionally, or physically abusive. That's where you say,
no, I will not allow that abuse to enter my life. And you definitely cut it off. But there's
other times where maybe there's mental health issues involved, and there is a complete
lack of awareness or willingness to take accountability. You can still have a relationship
with that person. It's never going to be a deep connected relationship. It's going to be very
surface level. Well, and I look at that. I mean, we decide what our relationships look like, because
I definitely have people in my life that I have what I call like a Sunday dinner relationship
with, right? Like you meet, you talk for 20 minutes, an hour. It's all small talk. It's fine.
And you do love them, but you can't trust them because of the patterns of behavior.
I'll tell you what a paramecium is. That's a paramecium. It's a one-celled critter with
no brain that can't fly. Don't mess with me, man. I'm a lawyer. And that's why for a lot of people,
it's hard to walk away from an abusive situation. It's not just, well, because I love them,
but also because I can see this comes from a place of despair, or a place of mental illness,
or a place of past hurts that haven't healed. Unhealed wounds. Yeah. So it's like, I can't turn
my back on them when they're going through this, but at the same time, they're hurting me so much.
The solution for that, I think, is knowing what your boundaries are. Saying,
this is how I will and won't be treated, and this needs to change if we're going to be close.
And if it doesn't, okay, we may not be close. Or in some cases, we may not talk anymore.
You brought up earlier the concept of changed behavior. I often say that the best apology
is changed behavior. I love that phrase. I'm trying to live that phrase. The fact is,
it's way easier to say than to do. The reason why the best apology is changed behavior is because
that is a freaking monumental gift. Right. Changing behavior, it's hard. We have ways of
thinking and feeling and behaving that we get locked into for years and even decades,
and getting out of it is exceptionally difficult. And then sometimes it goes well,
but then when we're under stress or duress, we fall back into those old patterns.
Change? Yeah. Big change.
And so you brought up, are they working on it? Do you see the effort?
Right.
Because we also can't fall into this black or white, all or nothing
thinking. Either it's all good or not, because we're all human. But what is, I love the phrase
that you use, what is safe for me? What does this relationship look like for me in a safe way?
Can I have this relationship in a safe way or does it need to be time to be done? And this is true,
whether it's parents, your parents, or your siblings, or your spouse, or your boyfriend,
girlfriend. There's a lot going on right now. We were talking about this before the shoot.
A lot of people aren't talking to their parents or their siblings, or they have high school
friends. They don't talk anymore. So when it comes to healing and restoring these relationships,
because they matter so much to us, and people don't walk away from relationships willy-nilly.
Some people are like, well, you hurt me or it's hard and we're done. But that's the minority.
Most people fight for their relationships until they're just like, I can't.
So what's the difference between forgiving someone who's hurt you
and trusting them enough to keep them in your life?
Right. Well, we need to recognize, and we've talked about this a lot in our videos,
that trust and forgiveness are two separate things. And that we don't forgive someone
because they deserve forgiveness. We forgive someone for ourselves. We forgive someone
so that the weight of that hurt, and that anger, and that resentment
isn't something that we're carrying around with us.
I forgive you.
And we also have the maturity to recognize they have their own challenges. They have their own
needs. They have their own perspective. And just because they didn't meet our needs the way we
wanted them to isn't something that's innately wrong with them. You can grieve over a parent
that is unable to meet your needs in a healthy way. But you can grieve over it and you can let it go.
Yeah. Well, I've heard it said that every... I think of that example of the parent.
Every successful relationship requires a high degree of mutual tolerance.
We're just different. John and Julie Gottman, they were talking about marriages,
but this is true of just relationships. They said that something like 60% of problems in
a relationship are unsolvable. They literally just boil down to differences of perspective,
differences of worldview, differences of ways of thinking, or of personality.
And there has to be a balance, I think, in healthy relationships between growing and
becoming better for one another and accepting one another for who we are. And if we go too
far to either way, then we're out of balance. Any thoughts on how to find that balance?
Well, I teach my kids a concept called MFED. It's make allowance for individual differences.
And so when it's not a question of morality or ethics-
Or abuse.
Or abuse, right? We need to make allowances for those individual differences.
I will never be a karaoke king or an entertainer of any kind. That is not my strength, right?
And if you were to expect me to be that person-
If I'm like, get up on stage with me! Yeah.
Yeah. I'm never going to be that. Likewise, John-
I'm never going to be as organized or detail-oriented or able to balance so many things
like you can.
Yeah. And so that's where that conflict of each person living in their strengths,
but the conflict of those strengths being opposite, it's going to come up.
And it is always going to come up. And that's where we make allowances for individual differences.
And we show love and respect and acceptance for their strengths and their weaknesses.
At the same time.
Yeah. And that's what a loving relationship is. That's how you make them work.
There are people who are toxic. There are people who are abusive, who are dishonest,
whose behavior is disrespectful to the core.
And I agree with Alicia. In those cases, you can love them and you can forgive them.
Doesn't mean you have to trust them or have them in your life.
There are also maybe other relationships where it's like, I don't have the bandwidth for this
because I got a bunch of other relationships and tasks and other things going on.
So this is going to be a Sunday dinner or a once a year.
And I still love that person, but they're not a fit for my life. And that's okay.
You decide what your relationships look like.
You decide if your family, your friendship, your marriage.
Well, I mean, it's a two-way street, obviously. It's not just you deciding.
But you decide whether it heals or not with the other person.
And you definitely decide for yourself what your boundaries are,
what your limits are, what you will and won't do.
And if others are willing to be in step with that or not, that's up to them.
We want to thank you all for joining us for Therapists Say.
I do believe that therapy is a great thing.
I think a qualified therapist who knows what they're doing,
who's educated and experienced and compassionate is a wonderful thing.
But just like an amazing sous chef is a wonderful thing,
there's a chef that will give you food poisoning.
Not that great of a thing. They're both chefs, right?
So as always, ask for a second opinion.
As always, listen to your heart, listen to your mind,
and do what you think is the best thing for you to do.
Now, if you enjoyed this discussion today,
we want to invite you to check out our other video,
How Childhood Trauma Affects Health Across the Lifetime.
That's one of your videos.
I think that's one of your best videos, actually.
So you guys do not want to miss that link right down there in the description.
Will you do me a favor?
If you found this video helpful,
share it with those you know that could use this support in their life.
And remember to subscribe and click the bell
so you don't miss any Mended Light goodness.
Remember to keep shining.
We need your light.
