Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/2wufkc • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
A retired man with $45 million in assets seeks advice on a prenuptial agreement before marrying a woman with $3 million. The discussion focuses on balancing the protection of existing wealth with the desire to build a shared financial future, specifically addressing how to handle investment growth and inheritance for their respective children.
Brought to you by CHM, a budget-friendly, faith-based alternative to health insurance.
chministries.org slash budget.
I'm getting married and my fiance is 50, I'm 60, we're both retired.
And based on our wealth differences, we should probably have a prenup.
What is the wealth differences?
So she's got 3 million, no debt, and I've got 45 million, no debt.
Yes, you should have a prenup.
Yeah, so the question revolves around what's in the prenup, what should go in it.
So, you know, she wants to feel like we're building something together in our marriage
going forward.
And she talked about slowly maybe moving some of my separate property into community over
time, you know, like 5% a year, you know, over 20 years.
You know, at first I thought that was fine, but then I started looking at the numbers.
How much of your 45 million is real estate?
Just a couple million.
Okay, so what is the rest of it?
So the rest of it is stocks mainly.
Yeah, and the way some people do it, and you can do whatever you want, it's kind of like a
will, you make it up and if you both like it, you've got your deal, right?
But what some people do is, A, we exit with what we entered, 3 million and 45.
And any growth from then on is ours.
Some people do that or a percentage, you know, a ratio of some kind, any growth from this
point forward is 70% gems and 30% hers or whatever.
I just made that up.
Okay.
Um, and so, but if, if yours is only growing for you and hers is only growing for her,
that does kind of leave a negative light on what she's concerned about.
And she's concerned fairly that we need to grow a life together from this point forward.
The main purpose of this is that she should not come out of this with 20 million bucks
two years from now.
You know, that's what I was afraid of.
Like, yeah, that's the main purpose.
So we, we exit with what we entered with and then have a formula for how the growth would
be dispersed.
Okay.
And I don't think 50 50 growth is fair because she would, if she met, if you made 10% on
your investments, you'd make four and a half million a year and she'd make 300,000.
Right.
So, but I mean, if you want to be generous on it and say, you know, 70% of the growth
from this point forward on our whole thing is mine and 30% on the whole thing is yours
or whatever, make up a number.
I don't care, but I mean, so the two things you have to address is.
Leaving with what we entered and then how do we build a life together and address the
growth.
If you're serious about budgeting, you can't ignore healthcare for most families.
It's one of the biggest line items.
Y'all, you can cut subscriptions and eating out, but if you're still stuck with a massive
premium every month, it's going to be stressful.
Now, Christian healthcare ministries is different.
It's not insurance.
It's believers sharing each other's medical bills.
And the best part, programs start at just $115 a month.
So go to chministries.org slash budget and use code Ramsey for 50% credit towards your
first month.
And then how do we build a life together and address the growth?
Right.
Okay.
That sounds, that sounds pretty reasonable.
Yeah, but I would not, I would not set up a roommate situation where what's yours is
mine is mine.
And we have to decide who pays for the mustard in the refrigerator.
Oh, that'll drive you nuts.
Yeah.
Do you guys have kids, Jim?
Yeah, we both have kids.
We have teen kids and I have a couple older kids.
Okay.
So I set aside some of the money in a trust for my kids.
You know, so that's, that's already, you know, separate.
Okay.
You know, that, that we're, we're not talking about splitting that up.
Okay.
It's just, I saw the 5% a year and that seemed reasonable, you know,
a little bit each year, but the problem is there's no reason to not the problem.
Yeah.
There's no reason to, it only benefits her.
If we get divorced and it ends up being a lot of money in 10 years.
But if, if you took a percentage of growth, it's going to have the same effect.
If she gets a percentage of growth without changing the name on the asset,
if she gets a percentage of growth from this point forward,
and you get a percentage of growth from this point forward,
unless it's exactly in ratio to of three to 45.
And I wouldn't do that.
You'd give her more just to, I mean, if you gave, yeah, I would be,
I would give more than that.
So, you know, so if you said, you know, we got 48 million to deal with, you get three
48ths, I get 45, 48ths of the growth.
That's a little heavy.
I probably would lighten up on that personally.
But, um, so that's like, she would be getting about 6% under that scenario of the growth,
but not of the asset.
Right.
Not the principal principle is your starting point as of today.
That's how most people address it.
Now you can sit down with an attorney.
They may have some other ideas if they're used to doing these things.
We don't generally recommend prenups except in extreme situations.
And yours, my man is an extreme situation.
Okay.
And it's, it's really good to talk about it and think it through.
And here's the other thing.
I would be sure I get under the numbers and address the concern and meaning.
And that's a form of pre-marriage counseling.
In other words, where you say, okay, what is it you're trying to address when you say
you want 5% moved?
What does that do for her?
What is it that you're wanting there?
What are you trying to do?
And if we did it this other way, does that address it as well?
You know, and you know, that kind of thing.
The thing I do, the thing I really, whatever structure you use,
make it from this point forward that you're building a life together in some manner.
Yep.
Yeah. I agree with that.
Yeah.
That's the danger of a prenup where you just turn your marriage into a roommate.
Yeah.
Cause I mean, you know, you could have another 25 great years of marriage with her, you know?
And 14 grandkids.
Yeah.
Each, you know?
And that aren't, that aren't related to the other one at all.
Yes.
Except by this marriage.
And so, yeah, yeah.
I've got a friend that has four kids and he's on a second marriage, third marriage.
And each, and she has five kids and they've all got kids.
There's a bazillion people in these two combined families now.
Right.
And you've got to address that.
Um, cause there's a lot, you know, just Thanksgiving becomes a thing, you know,
you got to, you got to think through yours, mine, and ours.
And, um, there's not.
That probably is the wisest way with the kids.
Like in his scenario.
But if the prenup says the first 45 is mine.
Anyway.
And we're only dealing with the growth and it can go to his, wherever he wants it to.
That's right.
Yep.
Yeah.
And that can be in the, that can also be in the will, you know?
So trust does that, but it's not 100% wise.
That's very interesting, Jim.
Good discussion.
Prenups have become a hot topic around here, uh, off the air.
Um, uh, I was just telling you, I was doing an interview.
They brought it up in the interview and the guy doing it on another guy's podcast.
Yeah.
And he was like an anti prenup.
And he said now over there is he has shifted to more of a, of a pro because yeah.
Pro, pro, pro.
Yeah.
Pro prenup.
Um, and I do wonder if people, if there's like a discouragement of just marriage
in general, like seeing the stats that you, you know, half the time it's not going to work.
You know what I mean?
And like, do you prep for that?
What, where's the wisdom in that versus the attitude going in preparing for the end of
the marriage is not great.
You know what I mean?
Like it's just the way you slice it as tough.
Yeah.
The other thing is the marriage, uh, statistic that half don't work is incorrect.
If you start adjusting for a few variables, if you have, if you have four years of education,
if you have $50,000 a year or more in income, if you are shared in your religious beliefs,
if you fill in about five more things and it goes to about 90% probability of success in marriage.
So it's, uh, if you get married after you're 22 months old, no, I'm kidding.
Christian healthcare ministries can save your family hundreds
of dollars on healthcare every month.
Learn more at ch ministries.org slash budget.