Money, happiness and eternal life - Greed (1/2) | DW Documentary

Happiness in life
10 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video analyzes greed as a mutated survival mechanism, exploring its biological, psychological, and sociological roots. It argues that the drive for wealth and status is an attempt to escape the fear of mortality and existential anxiety, resulting in a systemic cycle of consumption, financial corruption, and environmental decay.
I had a strange dream.
I was walking through a golden temple, beneath a dome of glass, and through chambers of splendor,
filled with so many objects that the heart so desires.
I saw miracles of human skill and artistry, and flawless beings who seemingly lacked nothing.
But it appeared they were all searching for something, such strange creatures.
The whole world is in a big mess.
The more they get, the more they want.
President Bush, after 9-11, said,
I urge all Americans to go shopping.
This brain would still make me money.
It's the thing in me.
I grew up in a way that I would still make money, even if I was left in the desert.
There is somebody who tries to say, you need this.
There are enough people who think they need that.
That's what the marketing strategy is, is that it always tells you, you shouldn't be content.
Humans are by nature greedy.
Evolution has shown us that.
As long as this mechanism doesn't become too dominant,
it serves the goals of the individual perfectly.
Today, I'd go so far as to say it's a symptom of an illness.
I wonder if we're a viable form of life.
Maybe we're just an evolutionary flash in the pan,
and we'll be sitting right next to the dinosaurs at the cockroach museum.
I kept asking myself, why are we like this?
We're caring and compassionate, but we're also egocentric and reckless.
We give and we hoard.
We create and destroy.
What is our problem?
What drives us?
I went in search of answers.
Humanity's at the crossroads.
I think a historical moment.
The physical environment is undermined to the point where we need to attend to it.
War is something that we ought to think about.
Well, why does that happen?
People are pervasively unhappy.
On top of all of that, we keep building Walmarts.
I see insatiable greed as inextricably connected to all of these other
difficulties that if we don't recognize and come to terms with,
we're literally putting our species at risk.
You might ask to talk about Darwin.
Well, if you're asked to talk about Darwin, it has to be about evolution.
Evolution is an idea that Darwin is trying to understand.
And what's his strikingly original proposal?
Natural selection.
Humans are, on the one hand, very similar to all other forms of life
in that we share a basic biological predisposition towards survival.
But on the other hand, we're so smart that we actually recognize that we exist.
And the point here is that being alive and knowing it is grounds for great joy.
On the other hand, it also carries a very terrible existential burden.
If you know that you're here, you know that someday,
like all living things, that you won't be here.
If that's all we thought about, I'm gonna die, I may walk outside and
get hit by a meteor, we would literally be paralyzed by abject terror.
What human beings did is to construct and
maintain what the anthropologists today call culture.
And all cultures offer some recipe for immortality.
Either literally through the heavens and afterlives and
reincarnations of all the world's great religions, or
symbolically through the belief that some vestige of our identity will persist
over time, nevertheless.
That's why you wanna have children.
That's why you wanna build pyramids.
That's why we wanna write great books and symphonies.
That's why we wanna have a lot of money.
Human beings are motivated to have a lot of stuff because psychologically speaking,
it gives them a sense that they may be able to live forever.
Desire, greed, and the struggle that brings about anger and aggression.
From the Buddhist philosophical perspective are all resultant states
of a person consistently trying to look at what is not true.
We talk about three fundamental truths, that things are impermanent.
Secondly, the fundamental principle of everything is said to be emptiness.
But now what happens is,
we try to build something that makes us forget about this.
We try to make things permanent, and
that struggle creates the third truth of this suffering.
We begin to then hang on to things.
I'll give you an example.
If I have a shirt, and every time I go out to do some shopping, you buy another shirt.
You may have 12 in your closet, but you'll buy the 13th just so
that you have a sense of you'll live long enough to wear all 13 shorts,
or perhaps even more than that.
So there's a sense of every day consistently doing something
because of which we may be able to more solidify our sense of immortality,
our sense of living continuously, not changing.
And that struggle consistently builds up all these neuroses,
and the prominent one of them becomes the greed.
Death is a very real physical phenomenon, and
it doesn't matter how good your symbols are, your religion, your politics,
your money, they're still symbols, and none of them will be sufficient
to minimize death anxiety, or rather to eliminate it.
You can reduce it, but you can't get rid of it.
And then finally, just really to make matters worse,
we also don't like the idea that we're animals.
From a starkly biological point of view, we're not all that much more significant
or enduring than lima beans or armadillos.
An animal takes only what it needs, but the human animal is different.
More than 7 billion of us populate the planet.
Chivas desires something, desires more.
Is this perhaps the secret of success?
We've now developed instruments to measure greed as a personality trait,
and also to elicit a state of greed in people.
This is the balloon task.
We use it to measure our test subject's willingness to take risks.
The subject has to try to keep inflating a balloon.
The larger the balloon, the more it's worth.
In each round, the subjects play for real money.
Every time they inflate the balloon, they're risking that it might burst,
and then their money would be gone.
We've been able to demonstrate that people who tend to be greedy
are more likely to take risks when performing this task.
So they inflate the balloon further than do normal test subjects.
And we see that people who tend towards greed
also demonstrate an altered brain response.
In this graphic, we see how our brain responds to rewards and to punishment.
So far, we've been able to demonstrate that the more greedy the test subject,
the weaker are the punishment signals.
What is interesting is that these people also tend to want to maintain that state.
The classic experiments of Olds and Miller on the brain's dopamine system
are very interesting in this respect.
If electrodes are implanted in exactly this region of a rat's brain,
and the rat is then put into a situation where it can stimulate that dopamine system
directly by pressing a lever,
the rats will continue pressing the lever until they die.
And this is presumably one of the biological mechanisms
that helps explain excessive greed.
Come on, Ren. There you go.
Where'd Lily go?
Oh, you can have two, okay.
Where'd Lily go?
You already have two.
Come here.
Most primates are highly social,
but these guys are atypical in that they're also highly tolerant.
There is a hierarchy, and everyone knows who's on top
and the individuals at the top get more.
Males get more matings.
Females get more access to resources.
But you don't have this really steep hierarchy
where there's one individual at the top who gets everything.
And you also see some things that you don't necessarily see across the primates
like respect for possessions.
So we can look, for instance, at how do you respond
when you get more and I get less?
Or how do you respond when you get less and I get more?
And that's tractable to study experimentally.
So the experiment itself is very simple.
You take two monkeys or two apes,
sit them next to one another,
and you interact with them sequentially.
And what they have to do is a very simple task.
So we give them a token, they return it,
and give them a food reward for having completed it.
But then the critical component is
how does this individual respond to that medium-preferred food
like a cucumber or a piece of bell pepper
when their partner gets something much better?
That could be due to inequity.
It could be due to, hey, look,
my partner got something better than me.
Or it could just be due to general sort of greed,
for lack of a better term.
Hey, there's a better food out there, and I want it.
From an evolutionary perspective,
the behavior that we consider greed,
which is acquiring as many resources as possible,
is important.
Most animals live more at the margin
than modern Western humans do.
So not acquiring as many resources for them
is a real risk of death.
In human societies, though,
my perspective is that greed has taken on
not just acquiring as much as possible,
but acquiring as much as possible
explicitly at the expense of other individuals.
And I don't think that that's something
that you can apply to animals.
One day Narcissus came upon a spring
that was so clear that he could see himself in it,
as if in a mirror.
When he saw his own reflection,
he fell in love with its beauty.
We, too, like to see ourselves
as the center of the world.
The individual is now
the measure of all things.
And so we yearn for recognition
and self-esteem.
We collect relationships,
photos and likes,
SUVs, shoes,
records.
Are we like Narcissus?
Addicted to our own egos?
Being successful in business
is an art.
And when you have it,
you can be able to
take things to a level
that people will be surprised.
How much is the square meter price?
Let's not talk about the international price.
Let's talk about our prices.
700 square meters per floor
multiplied by 8 floors
multiplied by our local price.
1,000 what?
It's 1,000.
It will cost you 5.6 million.
I'd rather deal with those types of figures.
Because that's exactly what it's going to be?
Makes sense.
I will tell you my philosophy
is very simple.
There is a thin line separating a businessman and a criminal.
Why?
Because anything I do,
somebody is bound to say I've cheated him.
So all of us as businessmen throughout the world,
whether it's Bill Gates,
it's Richard Branson,
we are all viewed as criminals.
But it's because we think beyond
what other people think.
President Mugabe
is my brother.
From a European perspective,
I would be a nephew.
From an African,
I would be a brother.
We cannot have a world
full of critics.
We want to shrink.
Fewer critics,
more doers.
That way the world economy will be nice to live in.
Welcome to my house.
I want to show you around
as well as the achievements I've had
for so many years.
At a school which is near my
old offices,
they gave me an award for building a school block.
And then an organisation,
Help Us Help Ourselves,
honoured me for my work for humanitarian reasons.
They gave me this award.
We have this award from BAFTA.
Its main focus is to
recognise those who have
done a lot of work in human rights,
affirmative action and empowerment
issues internationally.
That's me.
In here
is my main lounge.
We're in
if you come in
and
friends and family.
We
do meet
and toss around
and have
conversations of thoughts,
political, economy
and family.
It has a helipad on top
so when it's cold here
we do put
the heaters.
It really has heaters over here
and this room
is called the Mugabe dining room.
If I'm refurbishing
this house, this is the only room
I don't refurbish because it gives me
that sentimental
relationship with the President
and
yeah
the man that money can't buy.
And this is it.
I know where I came from.
I came from being a vegetable vendor.
My bed was the floor
the granolithic floor.
That's where I used to sleep
with a very poor linen
blanket that goes beneath me
and one on top.
And that history
is why I want to
be able to show
I got to live well.
Things like the racetrack
and all other
forms of public spectacle
are of interest to folks
for so many reasons.
One aspect of the
racetrack is gambling.
Another
part of it is to highlight
one's status relative
to one's fellow
human beings.
Somebody is quote better
not by how big or strong he or she
is but rather how one dresses
how you conduct yourself
and how you establish
that you are richer
than, more worthy than
and therefore more
immune from death than
all of the other folks who surround you.
In some
ways this is no different than
dominance hierarchies in
primates.
We love heroes and
therefore have become
preoccupied with being the best
at something
even if it's how many
hot dogs I can eat in ten minutes.
In America
we're number one
not in science or
literacy or anything important.
We are number one in depression
however.
How could this be?
What you have to do is look at
cultural values to see if
they're realistically attainable by the
average individual.
If you're a male, you're
basically valued by how
much you have.
And this is the so called American dream.
If you work hard enough
you can have as much money as
LeBron James or Warren Buffett
or Bill Gates.
But
realistically for every millionaire
there's gotta be hundreds of thousands
of people working part time
at Walmart without benefits.
Same for
women but they have a different cultural
burden. We teach
women that in order to be beautiful
you have to be ridiculously thin.
Your breasts excluded of course
so if I can't floss my teeth with you
you're too fat.
And you have to remain
perpetually young which of course
is biologically impossible.
Wow.
We cherish values that
are simply not possible to attain.
If you say I want
to be true to the world
you gotta get rid of all your
I'ms. And when I say
your I'ms I'm talking about
I'm this and I'm that.
I can do this and I can do this.
Oh yeah I did this last year.
Oh I can do that. Oh I'm
better than him. So all
those I'ms it's eagles.
There's a lot of people in South
Africa both black and
white who carry the eagle
badge on them and they carry it high
as a flag. You see
and those are the people
who we would see as
the future bureaucrats of the country.
If you are driving into
a poor neighborhood where
you know people are starving to death
and you're driving down with your
Mercedes Benz or your
Rolls Royce that is the worst thing
you could ever do.
Driving with this ego to say
I'm better than you.
You know you'll never be where I am.
Those people are lost.
If I believe I have to assert
my ego the only way I
can do that is through greed.
I'm forced to constantly
incorporate something into myself
that lends stability to my ego.
Those can be material things
but they can also be spiritual things
for example ideas
like I'm important for example
or I'm somebody due to money or fame
or my title or something like that.
Our entire modern world is based
on this.
Greed destroys people. Why?
Because it isolates us
and because greed is something like a drug.
The more I have the more I want to have
because whatever I have no longer
satisfies me.
So it's not what I actually possess
that satisfies me.
It's the constant striving for more.
Religion has known for centuries
that this drive lies within us humans
but this drive is also our ruin.
Since time immemorial
there have been stories of people
who could never get enough.
People like King Midas.
He asked Dionysus to grant him a wish
that everything he touched
would turn to gold
but even his food and his drink
turned to gold.
It seemed he might starve or die of thirst.
Gold and riches
have always been cast under the spell
of omnipotence
and a whisper of eternity.
What, I ask myself,
gives money
such a powerful allure?
I chose banking as my career.
I'm a trained accountant
and I worked with the Julius Baer & Co.
RG Bank.
First in Zurich and then in the Cayman Islands
which is a tax haven.
I was promoted to compliance officer
meaning I was the legal conscience
of the company.
A certain amount of greed
is instilled into you.
That was true for me too,
I have to admit.
You start to think only in monetary units
the dollar signs appear
before your eyes and in your heart.
Then they're there
and they're the only thing that matters.
A lot of profit
and making sure you don't get caught.
That's the way I operated too, of course.
In my function as compliance officer
I determined
that we had criminal clients.
There were names like Bin Laden
there was a Mexican drug boss.
It became clear to me
that I was working
for a criminal organisation
and that the bank
was a participant
in tax evasion and fraud.
I ended up feeling morally conflicted
then took the matter up
with management.
We were threatened
and the entire family
ended up leaving the Cayman Islands
very suddenly.
There have been Swiss bankers
in the Cayman Islands
who have been killed.
To an extent
my decision to leave the system
was a moral issue.
But what was more important, I think,
was that I realised
the system had turned against me.
For example the threats
that were made against me
in the Cayman Islands
the way I was fired
and then threatened again.
The bank would destroy me
if I tried to file charges
against them.
The bank sent private
detectives after us.
I was followed on my way to work.
I had to change the route
I took to work, change my work hours.
The sight of a black car
would upset me.
I was completely spooked.
I even considered suicide.
They wanted to drive me crazy.
The state prosecutors
had all the information
but they did nothing with it.
It's a political problem.
It would make the criminal clients
uneasy. They would realise
they're no longer safe and protected either.
So with that in mind
the authorities don't go after the bank.
No, they go after the man
who made the truth public.
I spent 217 days
in prison.
The first 30 days were in 2005
and the rest in 2011.
Both times I was
in solitary confinement,
spending 23 hours a day alone
in my cell. There were prisoners
who flipped out, started banging
against the doors, screaming.
Switzerland
and basically every country,
they protect their golden calves.
The golden calf in Switzerland
is banking secrecy.
That's why no one will ever investigate
the Julius Baer bank,
even though the state prosecutors
know that Julius Baer
had helped deceive the US tax authorities
and so forth.
For political reasons,
the state prosecutors will never
investigate any of that.
Our question was
how could we create test conditions
that would approximate the behaviour
of a stockbroker, for example?
We used functional
magnetic resonance imaging
to investigate brain activity
in our test subjects.
We can look deep into the brain,
including into the structures
responsible for the reward response.
Our subjects play a stock trading game
and have to decide
whether they want to invest
a large amount of money
or a small amount.
Then they get feedback during the game
as to whether the share price
is rising or falling.
We've been able to determine
that people who are especially greedy
display a more muted response
in regions responsible for punishment
and loss of money.
This mechanism enables
a kind of disinhibition.
Based on the assumption
that ordinary and average people
will be risk-averse,
it makes sense for the finance industry
which is optimised for outcome
to hire people who are more inclined
toward risk.
They achieve that with bonuses
and with targeted hiring practices.
I believe it's just a matter of time
before the next finance crisis will hit.
Good morning, gentlemen.
What's your name?
Thank you very much.
When I started hearing about
Warren Buffett's and Bill Gates' wealth,
it was round about the $30-40 billion.
But now it's $70 billion.
You know, in life,
if you have only a billion dollars,
you can be able to live
for 273 years.
And it will spend
$10,000 a day.
How many of us
live for 273 years?
So if you've got a billion,
that means you can even spend
$30,000 a day.
Because you're not going to last that long.
But still, other people make much more.
You know,
nobody can say,
I don't want more.
If people like me don't make money,
there's no taxes that enables
government to function.
So therefore, people who make money
enable things to happen.
And I'm one of those people.
More growth, more affluence,
more contentment.
This is the promise
of those who mean well with us.
And we're only too happy to believe them.
We do our part.
Are we hoping to buy ourselves
happiness?
Many Western Europeans
and Americans, they no longer really
have a firm belief in
God.
But you have to believe in
something.
You know, we have these belief systems
that reduce death anxiety.
But there's always
going to be a rumble of panic
beneath the surface of consciousness.
We're going to take this death anxiety
and we've got to do something with it.
And one thing that we can do
is buy a lot of s***.
By the time
you can talk, you have already
been pelted with
commercial images like the Nike
check and the golden
arches. We know them
subliminally.
Our children are growing up
in a world that is radically different
from the ones that you and I grew up in.
Their brains have been
modified accordingly.
Manufacturers of
consumer goods, they are spending
literally billions of
dollars to ensure
that no child
is left behind in
the commercial rat race.
We're basically
in a sense, no different than
amoebas. We are
attracted to anything
that fosters life and
pleasure. And we're
repulsed and afraid of
anything that threatens that state of
affairs.
Shoes.
Shoes, everywhere
shoes. Sometimes
you don't want to let go of
something you keep. For instance, this
shoe. I've never worn it, but I think
it's been sitting here for
three years.
Still brand new.
And it's the same thing with this one.
Still brand new.
This is a designer shoe.
I don't want to be limited because
in the Bible
Genesis says
you must have dominion over everything.
That gives me that strength.
Nobody
in the Bible, I can
open it for you, nobody is poor.
Abraham, Moses
everybody, he's a rich
man in the Bible. Bible does not
talk about poverty.
The Bible is the biggest
money
machine.
Every verse,
each verse, talks about money.
That is something that people need to
realize.
I'm happy that there's something
like this.
I think the key
for the material society
is that it will always tell you
that there's something missing. You need
something else. We're all
contributing. I don't think it's only the
you can't just blame someone
who's trying to sell you something.
Demand and supply.
We're all supporting each other in it.
We've all gotten into this
cycle that we are
unable to find ourselves
free from.
Talking about 24 hours,
I would say 23 hours
and 55 minutes
Samsara is saying
come
you're missing something.
And by Samsara I mean
the habitual patterns.
And you keep thinking
they're calling me.
Samsara is calling me. I need to go
there. Have a car. Have a house.
Have a partner.
Be busy. Be neurotic.
That's what I would say.
Of course you don't call it that way. You call it
being someone.
Being capable.
Finding your identity.
When there's discontentment
you're always looking for more.
That struggle
brings about so much insecurity
and unhappiness.
One of the
reasons why people acquire so
much is because it feels good.
There are both neurochemical
and psychological feedback loops.
It causes you to continue
doing it well beyond what you
actually need.
It's one thing when you go out and get a cup
of warm coffee on a cold rainy day.
It's completely another thing when you buy
a 75th pair of shoes.
You really, really don't, in any stretch
of the imagination, need those shoes.
But they're still going to make you feel good.
There is this drive to, as we say in the U.S.,
keep up with the Joneses.
In our wealthy set on
Park Avenue, everybody's
16th birthday party.
Last year everybody handed out iPods.
This year we're going to hand out iPads.
This year we're going to do this.
There's also this
ratchet effect.
There's nothing wrong with
being a consumer.
To stay alive, we have to consume
things.
But then we literally
surrounded ourselves with stuff
to the point where we become
imprisoned in a gilded cage.
We became consumed
with consumption.
We're going to keep
buying stuff until
the last drop of petroleum
has been burned.
It's very ominous, I would argue.
