How Tech Companies Lie to You.

PageTech
205 followers
#tech #industrial #technology
Let them know with your wallet 🫡
Huge thanks to @mkbhd for jumping in on this!
He's just done a deeper dive into the whole "Glass is Glass" concept on his channel!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTech companies employ deceptive marketing to exaggerate product innovations. By using vague terminology, \"imaginary\" specifications, and misleading comparisons, they create an illusion of significant progress while delivering minimal real-world benefits to the consumer.
Tech companies have, I think,
reached peak levels of deception.
You will see incredible headlines everywhere you look,
but as soon as you peel back the clever wording,
you take away the hidden asterisks
and you remove the sneaky manipulation of data,
you realize that never in history
has such little change been sold to us as if it's so much.
So I've teamed up with Marques from MKBHD
to show you how they get you.
And I feel like we have to start
with the magic new catch-all term of the tech industry,
up to.
What we need to see,
and what we used to see a lot more of,
is this new product is X percent better than the last one.
This very simple idea basically doesn't exist anymore.
Practically every single tech company
quotes every single change as up to.
Up to two times faster.
Gets up to eight more hours.
Is up to two times faster.
You'll notice they don't even write it
as up to a lot of the time.
They'll just like mutter it quickly under their breath,
like it's some sort of pedantic footnote
that you don't need to pay attention to.
But if you think about it,
any stat that starts with an up to doesn't mean anything.
I can say this video is gonna reach up to a billion people.
And if it only ends up reaching my parents
and then like one cousin in India, I was still right.
And you could argue, well, you know,
workloads are more complex now.
It's harder to estimate exactly
how much better something is.
But the real reason this is being used is very clear.
It's to be able to stick a massive number on your webpage
and not be sued for it.
So if you see up to followed by a percentage improvement,
honestly, just disregard it and go search up
specifically how much better that product is
in exactly what you're planning on doing with it.
But I'll leave the next one up to you, Marques.
Okay, so in announcement keynotes
and a lot of advertising specifically,
a lot of companies like to do this thing
where they combine a bunch of different specs
from different versions of the same product into one page,
creating what I like to call the imaginary spec.
So like one of the most common versions you'll see
is a company will put like the maximum
up to performance number
alongside the minimum starting at price.
And they'll put them next to each other
in a product where you can't actually get
the maximum performance for the minimum price.
Here's Rivian, for example, on the R1T website.
You'll see, wow, 420 miles of range
and a zero to 60 in under 2.5 seconds,
starting at under $74,000, but not exactly
because the one with 420 miles of range is the dual motor,
which has a 3.4 seconds zero to 60.
Still quick, but the 2.5 second version costs $30,000 more
and has 40 miles less range.
And for $73,000, you don't get either of those things.
So yeah, this here is an imaginary spec.
Oh, and by the way, that's another one while we're at it,
EV range claims.
Now there are laws around how accurate
your range claims actually have to be,
just like with gas mileage.
And some companies are a little more optimistic
about that range claim than others, fine.
But the fact is we are still pretty early
in this battery tech and the tiniest,
even seemingly insignificant things
can make a pretty significant difference to your range.
And so even when you break it all the way down
to specific Rivian models,
the one that does the 2.5 seconds zero to 60,
you can see that 374 mile range claim right here.
But when you actually click in,
that's when you realize that's on a specific wheel
with a specially designed sticky Michelin tire.
And then, oh, look at that.
You're actually getting 338 miles of range.
You'll have to switch down
to the standard sport wheel and tire
to get the 374 miles of estimated range.
So yes, even this here was an imaginary spec.
And I promise you Rivian is far from the only offender
in the world of cars and in tech.
And if you thought that companies exaggerating their specs
to seem better than others is a problem,
then how about when companies just invent entirely new specs
so that you can't even compare them to others?
When companies start to build loyalty,
they want to be able to charge more for the same stuff.
But how do you get away with that
in a world where a comparison
is just one quick chat GPT search away?
Well, make it so confusing for customers to compare you
that the easiest thing then becomes
for them to just take your word for it that you're better.
One of the most prolific examples of this right now is RAM.
Any computer, any phone, any laptop,
even your smartwatch needs RAM to be able to juggle tasks.
And this is true no matter which company's product it is.
But Apple now refers to their RAM
almost exclusively as unified memory.
They can say this because their RAM
is actually part of their chip
as opposed to a separate component,
which does make that RAM
a little more efficient in some ways.
But it glosses over a very important detail
that Windows laptops often have dedicated graphics cards
that have their own additional pool of RAM.
Whereas unified memory means that both the CPU and the GPU
share from one small pool.
So you're pretty much always getting less RAM.
And yeah, I mean, Apple executives have famously boasted
about how their unified memory is so efficient
that just eight gigabyte of it
is equivalent to 16 gigs on Windows.
But it's not really true.
There just will be a hard cap
on how much multitasking you're able to do
because eight gigs is eight gigs.
But even so, can you see how this whole concept
of unified memory still helps Apple?
It makes something as simple as RAM
feel like some sort of gray area,
which means they can give you a lot less of it
and they can charge you more to upgrade it
than any other company.
I'd say to be honest though,
the worst example of the invented spec is the TV market.
TV makers will try absolutely everything
to make you feel like you're getting the real deal
apart from actually giving it to you.
Like when Hisense tells you
that a TV has a motion rate of 120,
it doesn't actually mean that the TV
has a 120 Hertz refresh rate like you think.
And like clearly many other people
have been led into believing.
Motion rate is another invented spec
that just means the TV is running
Hisense's motion smoothing software.
Or let's say that you tell your less tech savvy buddy
to make sure you get a TV that has OLED tech.
What are the chances that they accidentally
end up buying a Hisense ULED or a Samsung QLED
or a LG QNED?
I'd say pretty high,
even though all of these are in fact invented specs
designed I think to camouflage as OLED,
even though they're actually much cheaper LCDs.
Now, okay, maybe you're not convinced.
All right, maybe you're watching this thinking,
you know, it's fine if they make up specs
as long as they're technically true,
but I'll do you one better.
What if there's made up specs
that are actually numerically factually false?
I actually made an entire separate video all about this,
but one inch camera sensors are not one inch
in any dimension.
And 1.5K displays are actually not 1500 pixels
in any dimension either.
How is that possible?
Well, it's because the way we measure things has changed.
Like something like this camera, for example,
this is a Sony ZV-1.
A lot of cameras like it.
This camera has a one inch sensor.
It says so on their website.
And that sounds amazing.
A one inch sensor in this little camera.
Have you ever looked inside like a pro DSLR
or mirrorless camera at the size of that sensor?
That looks like about a one inch sensor.
So this must also have a huge sensor like that,
but it's not.
It's way smaller.
Why is that?
Well, it turns out this is a one inch sensor
because in 2026,
that's what we call a one inch type sensor.
See before digital cameras,
cameras didn't have sensors at all.
They actually used vacuum tubes.
And so the size of the tube
was actually what they measured.
So a one inch vacuum tube
would create an image area inside it
closer to about 16 millimeters diagonally.
And that is actually about the size
of the one inch type sensor in this camera.
So it's 2026, but we're calling this a one inch sensor
because that is the size of the theoretical vacuum tube
that would be required to produce an image
the size of this sensor.
Why?
Turns out one inch sensor is a marketing name
more than it is an actual measurement.
And I have the same beef with displays
because you've probably already heard
a lot of smartphones recently have like 1.5K displays.
You've heard this.
You've seen a lot of these floating around,
but none of them have 1500 pixel measurements.
So what's going on here?
See, this is where it gets weird.
Okay, so intuitively we all agree that 4K for example
is referring to the horizontal resolution, right?
So this video is 4K
because it's 4,000 pixels across, roughly.
It's 4096 by 2048.
Sometimes it's 3840 by 2160,
but it's roughly 4,000 pixels wide.
And 8K would be 8,000 pixels wide.
But at some point, for some reason,
we started calling 2560 by 1440 2K,
which is close, but a little bit off.
And then for some reason, 1080p,
which is now referring to the vertical resolution,
is 1K, which is weird
because 1080p is actually 1920 by 1080.
So it should be 2K, but now we're calling 1080p 1K.
And so now smartphone companies are using 1.5K
to refer to a measurement somewhere
in between 1080p and 1440p.
So it's not actually 1500 across or 1500 tall.
It just means somewhere in between 1K and 2K.
And that's super annoying to me, but it's how we talk now.
And that's if there's even a hardware change at all
with new products.
What's becoming increasingly common these days
is this focus on vaguely defined new software features.
So if you're launching a new smartphone, let's say,
you're holding a big event and a live stream
to tell people what's new about it,
then the thing that is useful to see
is what specifically is new about that product.
A good example of this is the privacy display
on Samsung's Galaxy S26 Ultra.
It's a software feature,
but it's one that actually required them
to physically change the way they built the display to work.
So it's made for this phone.
But unfortunately, the vast majority of new features
that we actually see marketed here are not that.
Like if we pull up the Galaxy S24 event,
they spent this much time
talking about the new Samsung AI features,
and then literally just as long
talking about circle to search.
They talked about it like it's this revolutionary new feature
that's only made possible
thanks to Samsung's deep partnership with Google.
Our partnership continues to go strong
as we create new ways to do more with Google
on Galaxy devices.
But circle to search is also on Google phones.
It's on Xiaomi phones.
It's not really got anything to do with Samsung
apart from just them being the first to show it.
And they do this every year to buff out their presentations
and try to make you associate
those Google features with Samsung.
And it's not just confusing
which features are also coming to other brands.
Where I think it gets really intentionally confusing
at these launch events is
which features that you're talking about
are also coming to your own older phones.
Don't get me wrong.
It's a good thing that big companies
support their older models.
I mean, they kind of have to.
They didn't promise you when you bought them.
But the thing that's misleading is
spending 60% of the next phone's launch event
talking about how it's the coolest phone in the world
and you should upgrade
because it has all these next-gen features,
but then never mentioning that those features
are also coming to the phone
that you're watching the event on.
We added a brand new capability
that goes beyond device control.
Now Bixby can bring you up-to-date information
directly in the conversation.
So you see how this new Bixby is being positioned
as one of the perks of the Galaxy S26 series,
but actually it can run on even a Galaxy S23.
And this kind of stuff is genuinely
most of these launch events now.
And speaking of older products,
what's with companies now who launch a new product,
but then only compare it to another product
that came out like three plus years ago?
Apple is the worst for this.
Like take the latest MacBook Pros.
So we go to the performance section
and the headline number is,
oh, would you look at that,
up to eight times faster AI performance.
So they've got the up to in there,
they've got the specific use case,
all to make sure that they have this super impressive
quotable eight times number,
but then also it's eight times faster than the M1 family.
What?
These are the M5 generation chips released in 2026
and they're comparing them to the M1s,
released across 2020 and 2021,
five to six years apart.
And what they would say is,
well, you know, many users will be upgrading from an M1,
we're just being helpful.
To which I would say,
if I was using a worn down,
slightly busted six year old M1 laptop,
my decision is not, do I upgrade?
It's actually, do I upgrade to the M5
or do I instead buy the last gen M4
and save a bunch of money?
How much difference is there between those two choices?
I don't know, Apple won't tell me.
All this is, is a thinly veiled tactic
to help take what is in most instances,
like five to 10% of real world improvement
all the way into these astonishing sounding numbers,
like eight times.
But let's be honest, this is a joke.
It's a bit like if you were a world-class runner,
but then the way that you prove you're a world-class runner
is by comparing your speed to when you were eight years old.
Now there's another funny way companies compare
to their previous selves,
specifically smartphone companies
when talking about the glass and how tough the glass is.
Surely you've heard this before.
This new smartphone or this new glass
is twice as shatter resistant as the previous year.
Wow.
And then the next year it'll come out
and say this new glass
is now twice as scratch resistant as last year.
That is amazing.
How are they making such massive improvements
in the quality of the glass every time?
But it's not as insane when you realize
that scratch resistance and shatter resistance
are inversely related.
So the more of one you have, the less of the other you have.
Think of it like this.
If you want something to be super, super scratch resistant
and super, super hard,
that makes it more likely to be
a little bit brittle and shatter.
But if you want it to be less likely to shatter,
you make it a little bit softer,
which makes it more likely to scratch.
So instead of making some huge improvement
every single year, like the headlines might have you think,
it's actually more two different graphs,
one for scratch resistance and one for shatter resistance.
And they kind of do this.
You know, scratch resistance does this every single year
and shatter resistance does this every single year,
but in the opposite phase
because they're not able to do huge improvements
of both at the same time.
There is some material science
and they're both getting slightly better,
but that's an easier way to understand
that it's not as crazy as it sounds.
It's no coincidence that, you know,
the first generation of this dramatic new ceramic shield
for the iPhone was four times better in drop resistance
than any previous iPhone.
And then when they finally got
to ceramic shield generation two,
it was three times more scratch resistant specifically.
Every single one scratches at level six
with deeper grooves at a level seven
because it's still glass.
But hey, at least tech companies are generous enough
to upgrade the storage on our phones
and laptops every few years.
The new iPad Pro comes with double the storage,
which is now 256 gigabytes.
Oh, thanks Apple.
Oh, so it got $200 more expensive.
So they position it to you
like they're doing you some kind of massive favor,
when in fact, all they've really done
is stopped selling the cheaper, lower storage model.
And so you have to pay more.
But at least that one's kind of easy to see through.
The one that I find much tougher
is what I would call the efficiency improvement trap.
And it's a specific problem
with the way that performance improvements are sold to us.
Every year, we hear a very similar story.
Performance wise, we're seeing a 23% boost
and 20% more efficiency too.
So even just ignoring for a second
how they've slipped in that little up to behind him,
even though he didn't actually say it,
this guy is very clearly implying
that this chip lets you game
with about 20% faster performance
while your battery lasts 20% longer.
So not only you're getting smoother gameplay,
but you're also getting better battery life while doing it.
But the important thing to understand
is you don't get both.
If your efficiency goes up by 20%,
but then you're using all of that extra efficiency
to get this 20% extra performance,
then what you're actually getting
is the same battery life.
So when you then bundle that back in
with the fact that the entire thing
is only up to 23% faster and up to 20% more efficient.
And what we're really often talking about
in these kinds of situations
is an average expected improvement of like 5%
to your performance and your end battery life.
Surgical grade stainless steel,
aircraft grade aluminum, military toughness.
Tech companies feel like they're always super excited
to sell you something
that has maybe the most premium materials
on planet earth forged in an oven at a million degrees
that only the most exacting customer could possibly accept.
But you know what's funny about that?
There's actually nothing super special
about any of those things.
In fact, they're actually quite common.
Like most airplanes, it's true.
They use a whole bunch of 6,000 and 7,000 series aluminum
because those alloys are super strong and light
and cheap enough for mass production and good quality.
But that does also mean that
when your phone uses aerospace grade aluminum,
you know, it's technically true,
but that's also true about a razor scooter.
And a whole lot of the stainless steel
you'll come across in life is just 316L steel,
which is an alloy that is one of many
that is pure enough and high quality enough
to be used in surgical tools
and in the iPhone 14 Pro's rails
and in most kitchen sinks that you come across,
which technically means the kitchen sink
is also surgical grade stainless steel.
It's not lying technically, but now you know.
The truth is the specs of tech products
are chosen around how those products
are going to be marketed.
And that's kind of a given, it's just business.
But the issue is that very often in today's world,
the specs that make a product the most marketable
are not the specs that are most useful to a user.
Take thickness.
The spec that matters here really is the maximum thickness.
You want to know how thick the new phone or laptop is
at its thickest point, because that's going to determine
what bags or pockets you can fit it inside of.
But the spec that companies talk about
is thickness at a product's thinnest point.
And as soon as that genie's out the bottle,
you can call it whatever you want to.
Like Apple calls the iPhone Air the thinnest iPhone ever.
And while that's true for this section of the body here,
it's not true for the whole phone.
I've got an iPhone 7 here,
which is thicker than the iPhone 6, by the way.
But still, this is thinner than the iPhone Air
when you factor in the cameras.
And it's not like you can take them off.
It's just such dumb logic.
Like if we carry on this train of thought,
then what's to stop Apple at the next iPhone launch event
taking all the rest of the components in the body
and shoving them into one massive block at the end
that you have to hold like a camera grip,
but then calling the phone five times thinner
than the last iPhone,
because all that's left in this part is the display.
And then you've got Honor,
who marketed their Magic V5 as world's slimmest foldable.
But then people got it in their hands,
put it side by side with Samsung's foldable,
and found that that was actually slimmer.
Wanna know why?
Because Honor, in their measurements,
excluded not just the camera bump,
but also the outer and the inner screen protector.
You know, the one that you're not actually even allowed
to take off yourself.
That's not the only pointless spec though.
Like screen brightness.
It's become an arms race to just be the one
quoting the highest number of nits possible.
But the more the company's focused
on just reaching a really high peak nit number,
the less that number actually tells you
about how bright the screen is day to day.
They could literally be describing
how bright one pixel on the screen could go
while playing HDR content in direct sunlight
for like three seconds.
So this, for example, is an Honor Magic 8 Pro.
The company makes a pretty big deal
about how this has a 6,000 nit peak brightness.
That's the figure that's marketed.
But if we pull up a plain white image on this phone
and put it next to a Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra,
which only advertises a 2,600 nit peak brightness,
you can't actually tell the difference at all
in this day-to-day scenario.
These are both on Macs, by the way.
So when you're looking at brightness numbers,
just get rid of peak brightness.
Look at typical brightness.
And when it comes to phone cameras,
what mostly matters is sensor size.
The bigger the sensor, the more light
and the more real detail that your shots have.
What most companies spend far more time talking about
is resolution, which beyond a certain point
doesn't matter at all on a phone.
Like the last four generations of Samsung phones
have had a 200 megapixel resolution.
They're still shooting their actual photos in 12.
And don't even get me started on maximum zoom magnification.
Look at this page for the Nothing Phone 4a Pro.
The headline feature, the number one thing
being used to sell this phone
is world's first 140 times ultra zoom.
Oh my goodness.
I mean, my iPhone only has 40 times max zoom,
so it's gonna get cooked, right?
Okay, zoom all the way to 40 times on the iPhone,
40 times on the Nothing.
Oh my God.
Right, yeah.
So it's exactly what we expected.
The Nothing Phone, regardless of whether you use
the AI enhancement or not, just looks worse.
It's just not capturing as much information as the iPhone
and AI can't help you there.
Let me make something very clear.
How far your phone can digital zoom
has literally zero correlation
with how good of a camera it is.
What it actually does correlate with though
is how low a company's standards are
for what counts as a photo.
Damn, because I could literally go back
to the first smartphone I ever owned if I wanted.
Take a photo and just keep cropping in
until all I can see is a single brown smudge
and technically that could be 300 times digital zoom.
Best zoom camera in the world, everyone.
Can't do this anymore.
All right, so speaking of phone cameras,
last but not least is the classic
shot on a smartphone trope.
First of all, several companies
have already been caught lying about like sample images
that were supposed to be shot on that smartphone
that were just licensed
from some professional photo shoot somewhere
on a random DSLR, which is already crazy.
But even the ones that aren't lying
do feel like they're kind of stretching the truth
with the amount of extra hardware
that's being added to shoot it on a smartphone.
Like the whole point I feel like
of this awesome piece of content
was shot on a smartphone is to sort of inspire
and empower you to shoot your own awesome photos and videos
with that tiny sensor and lens
that fits in your pocket everywhere you go.
But when there's a massive external stabilization rig
and huge lenses and filters
and all sorts of other things added to the phone
and millions of dollars of lighting
and set design to make that all possible,
I guess it's still impressive,
but it also kind of defeats the purpose a little bit.
I can almost guarantee there are features disabled
on those phones to make those accessories work.
Like if I'm shooting with all that stuff,
I'm disabling the built-in stabilization
if I have a five-figure jib to shoot with.
Like if the only thing from the original phone
that you're still using to shoot
is just the sensor technically,
then is it still shot on a smartphone?
I guess technically yes,
but I'm now actually way less impressed.
So treat everything that these tech companies tell you
with a heavy dose of salt.
You don't need to upgrade every other year.
Nothing's actually getting eight times better.
And when you see a company bragging about their maximum zoom,
run for the hills.
If they can spot you,
at least you'll be super low resolution.
Thanks to Marques for joining forces with me here
and catch you at the next one.
