LIVE : Fed Chair Kevin Warsh Joins European Central Bank Policy Panel

Live News Network
1.4K followers
5 Video Views·Jul 1, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedCentral bank leaders from the UK, Canada, the EU, and the US discuss managing inflation amidst global shocks. They emphasize a shift from rigid \"forward guidance\" to flexible, data-driven \"framework guidance.\" The panel explores the economic impact of AI, the necessity of financial stability regulation, and the importance of institutional independence in maintaining price stability.
The challenges we have been discussing over the past couple of days
ultimately lie on the depths of the central bank.
The members of our next panel must translate analysis
into decisions that affect hundreds of millions of people.
I am delighted to welcome to the stage Andrew Bailey,
Governor of the Bank of England, Tiff Macklin,
Head of the Bank of Canada, Christine Lagarde,
President of the European Central Bank, and Kevin Walsh,
Chair of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve.
The panel will be expertly moderated by Sarah Eisen,
Anchor at CNBC.
Thank you very much and thank you to President Lagarde and to the ECB for
having me back here. It's an amazing tradition
and one of the highlights of my year and my career and way more fun than
watching you guys on your irrespective press conferences.
This is going to be fun and I'm excited because I'm hoping we
can have a good debate about divergence in policy and approaches
and maybe with that, President Lagarde, I'll kick it off with you because you're
the only one up here who have raised interest rates in
response to the Middle East oil shock.
Are you going to do it again?
No, why did you do that? Well, we did it because we had the perfect monetary
policy circumstances to do so and when you have
your inflation outlook up, your core inflation
up, when you have the underlying inflation indicating that it's
also trending up as well and that you're only going back to your 2%
target at the end of 28 with a number of things happening in
our inflation outlook which includes the
market expectations in particular, you have
the obvious decision and it was so obvious that we had a unanimity decision
within the Board of the Governing Council.
But seriously, how will you decide whether you keep going because you're
still above target? What we decided to do is way back to
give up on forward guidance and personally and I've said that
publicly, if I have one regret, it's to have
felt bound and compelled by forward guidance.
So I think what we do is now also informing
market participants, informing financial experts from all walks of life
about how we come to our monetary policy stance
and I have called it not forward guidance but framework
guidance so that those interested in how we come
to a particular decision appreciate what we take into account,
what intellectual process we go through, what indicators we are particularly
attentive to so that of course they have to do a
little bit more work themselves. It's not forward guidance blindly and
you just assume that it's going to be what had been calibrated as forward
guidance. They will have to do a bit of homework,
they will have to look at the indicators that we're attentive to, they will have
to appreciate our intellectual process and what we are
especially attentive to and that includes, you know, if I
go through what we did on the 11th of June,
we looked at the inflation outlook, taking into account all the latest
economic and financial data with risks part of our assessment as
well and that's, you know, recent development as you know.
We looked at underlying inflation, various set of indicators
and we looked at the transmission of monetary policy. So it's taking all that
into account in the context of the supply shock
that led us to the decision that remained.
Speaking of not liking forward guidance, which is going to make this job so much
harder for me, this panel. Chairman Warsh, we have inflation in
the U.S. that is higher than Europe and farther away from our
target. Why are we not raising it? I was hoping you'd ask me about forward
guidance. We'll get there. Because you have so much to say there too,
right? So we have found common cause. It's
what President Lagarde said. I liked her when we met 20 years ago when she was
finance minister. After that answer, I love her.
Reform does not stop at the water's edge.
What I found most exhilarating about the last two days here
is the kind of discussions that we've begun at the Federal Reserve
as a lot of people at this conference open-minded,
keen to think anew about the conduct of monetary policy
and President Lagarde's answer on forward guidance, I couldn't have said
it better myself. We're going to chart a new course so
that we can make better decisions and do the right thing.
And so my few days here have been incredibly rewarding on that.
On the broad conduct of policy, at my press conference I said I'm not going
to give forward guidance because we're meeting in six weeks, but I have
an update for you. We're meeting in four weeks.
Helpful. So is July on the table for a rate hike?
So Sarah is trying to get me to break this rule.
She's going to fail. There's a lot of data that we received
in that meeting. I see many of my FOMC colleagues here in
Sintra. I take their views very seriously. I want
us to have a good family fight when we meet in four weeks.
There's a lot of late-breaking news on a series of these things.
When we get into that room and shut the door, we're going to have a good debate.
But I don't have much more for you than that.
Okay, we'll get back to that. I have more questions for you.
Governor Bailey, you did not raise interest rates, even though your
inflation is above target, but there are members of your committee that want to
raise interest rates. So why are you holding back?
So, I mean, like Kevin and Christine, you know, we all spend a great deal of
time looking at the substance of the evidence.
And I think an important piece of the substance of the evidence for us is
that we've got a softening economy. So we're seeing a softening
labour market. We're seeing some softening of activity.
We think we've got a bit of an output gap opening up, and we had that before
the prosperity broke out in the Gulf. So that's the
contextual setting. I mean, because we're very focused on
the risks of pass-through of the energy prices to
the indirect effects and things like food prices and the second round effects.
We don't want, obviously, to become embedded. It is very frustrating. I was
very much of the view that we were going to
have inflation back at the 2.0 target, you know, in the late spring.
Everything I've seen actually since tends to confirm me
in that previous view. It's obviously not there because of the effects in the Gulf.
But the decision not to raise rates for me was based on,
you say, reading, you know, the evidence of a softening economy. And then a second
thing, and this is probably where we're in a
little bit of a different position from the ECB to start with, because it's the
sort of the adage, you know, where you get to depends on
where you start. You know, there was an expectation that
we would cut rates this year. That's not unreasonable in the context
of the softening economy. Yeah, that was off the table in
March and, you know, it's off the table at the moment.
So, you know, that was the context for me that I think we had some
time because by taking that sort of, in a sense, that
loosening off the table, you know, the mortgage rate went up one percent. So you
can argue that we've actually tightened policy in the period since the conflict
broke out. But like, you know, Kevin and Christine,
you know, we review at every meeting. So we've got a meeting coming up at the end
of July, and we will be looking at all the
evidence again then. So we return to it. Yeah, the weakening economy,
though, it sounds like, are you more worried about that than
higher inflation? Well, I'm not going to give you any prediction as to
what we will do. I think, obviously, the thing that has happened is that energy
prices have come down quite substantially. They're still a bit
above where they were pre-conflict, but they've come down. But the other thing
you have to be a bit careful with in the UK is that we have a delayed reaction
mechanism to energy prices because of the way our household energy price cap
system works. So I always say, you know, it's
appropriate at the moment to borrow a soccer analogy.
We always look, I'm afraid, we always look a bit better in the first half than we
do in the second half. I'm proud that you use the word soccer.
Governor McAlum, your inflation rate for May was 3.2 percent. It was above your
your range for the first time in a long time, but you
have not really spoken about raising interest rates.
Are you comfortable where you are? Well, we left our policy rate unchanged last
time, so yes, I guess we're comfortable where we are.
Look, on the going forward without forward guidance,
you know, what's interesting is we're all facing
pretty similar shocks, but we all start from slightly different places
and we have different proximities or different exposures for these shocks and
the benefit of our frameworks with flexible exchange rates is we can
direct policy for what we need in our country. So yeah, you're going to see
some differences. In Canada, like the UK, the economy's
growing, but it's been weak. There's excess supply, the labour market,
there's some slack in the labour market, but yes,
inflation is clearly above the target, 3.2 percent in May.
That's a dilemma for monetary policy. If we raise rates
to pull inflation down, it's going to weaken the economy further
and if inflation comes down quickly, we're going to regret that we did that.
On the other hand, if we cut rates to support growth,
there's a risk that the rise in inflation becomes more persistent.
So, you know, when we looked at it, you know, we think, you know, our
range for neutral is 2.25 to 3.25 or 2.25.
We're kind of at the bottom end of our neutral range, providing a little bit
of support, but, you know, we think it's about the
right level to keep inflation contained.
You know, the other thing I would say, though, is,
and this gets a bit back to your forward guidance, but we've got to be humble.
There's a lot of uncertainty out there. Those risks could shift quickly
and the other part of our message is, if the situation changes,
we're prepared. We're prepared to take action.
Do you think that the inflationary spark that everyone's seeing and feeling
is a temporary phenomenon as a result of the rise of energy prices,
which the party started reversing pretty sharply?
Does temporary sound like transitory?
Is that what you were trying to sneak in?
Yes. Is it transitory?
So, I'll build on what Governor Macklin just said.
By the way, the four of us all served together
in the global financial crisis in different roles.
So, I would say for us to be back on this stage in this circumstance is great
and they've been incredibly warm to me.
President Lagarde has sort of welcomed and encouraged these sorts of new ideas
that we've talked about at the Federal Reserve on these series of task forces.
And Sarah, my hope is that the results of these can be a public good.
If we make progress in thinking about the effect of productivity,
the effect of data, new inflation frameworks,
this is something we can all borrow and use from.
The other thing I'll add is that monetary policy spills over
from one of our economies to the other and it spills back.
I think the way Governor Macklin said it right,
which is we're all being hit by a series of shocks.
In the US, the AI shock is leading to a boom in capital expenditures.
We see that first and foremost in demand,
but I'm confident we're going to see it in supply at some point.
So, we're spending most of our time trying to monitor those developments.
Is it inflationary?
Well, in the near term, we can observe it on the demand side,
but it's up to the central bank to decide whether it's inflationary.
That's why I'm asking.
Whether, in fact, it finds its way into a broader set of goods.
I don't have any news for you on that,
but I would certainly rather be in a position where we have two things.
Where we recommit, the way I know my colleagues have,
to deliver price stability.
And the other piece that I'll take note of,
which shows some difference, I think, among our nations,
is the AI boom is showing itself first
and very prominently in the United States.
I'd certainly rather have this problem,
where we have massive capital expenditures,
instead of thinking years back where we had financial engineering,
where we had companies that weren't able to deliver profits.
So, they would do shareholder buybacks.
Well, right now, they're investing in the future
because their expectation is the supply side of the economy will expand.
And if it does, that has huge implications for monetary policy.
But again, I'm not going to make a judgment now.
We'll meet again in four weeks.
But this is as exciting a time,
and also as consequential a time to be a central banker
that I can think of at any point,
maybe outside of a crisis in my adult lifetime.
Can I pick up on a point that my friend Kevin made?
It's the speed at which things change,
and that is clearly accelerated by AI.
And I think in that context,
we have to be open to new measurements,
new ways of thinking,
new tools that help us and assist in making the right decision.
So, I think in that context,
the use of scenarios, for instance,
that we have now really nailed down
with milder, severe, and adverse scenario
to make sure that our decisions are solid and robust across scenarios.
The fact that we're incorporating risk into our assessment of inflation.
And I think risk, by the way,
that we have to the outside and more accurately using AI, for instance.
How do you make sure Europe doesn't get left behind on AI?
I know it's not necessarily...
It's not the central bank governor's question in a way.
I know you probably have thoughts.
I'll tell you something.
One, I think that we have to consider that
as a transformational technology breakthrough
and diffusion and material technology.
It needs to be analyzed from our perspective,
both in terms of how much CapEx is doing in that particular domain,
what impact it will have,
how fast will it develop,
how will it diffuse,
how will we reorganize the way in which we conduct work,
including at our central banks, by the way,
to really appreciate what impact it will have on productivity.
But if it delivers the productivity expectation that we have,
then it is going to be a radical change going forward.
And we need to, of course, from our perspective as central bankers,
we need to measure the disinflationary, inflationary impact
it will have over the course of time.
And it might be disinflationary first and inflationary second,
or probably more so the other way around.
But it all needs to take into account.
Now, I take your point about Europe lagging behind
in terms of investment and the frontier companies
that are leading the game at the moment.
But I think that we are all sort of hostage to each other, if I may say.
Because we need those frontier companies,
but they need the market.
When you represent 25% of the revenues of many of those hyperscalers,
we need each other.
We are in this game together.
At which end of the spectrum,
at which set of the supply chain to be determined,
and there will be healthy competition, I'm sure.
But we depend on each other.
We can't dispense of them
because to let the best minds participate in that.
There's also been a lot of talk here about coordination
and influence on each other.
And I am curious, President Lagarde,
now that you do have a little bit policy divergence,
you guys going maybe in different directions,
is that a good thing or is that a bad thing ultimately?
The divergence between who and who.
Policy.
I mean, you're raising rates.
They're not raising rates.
I totally endorse the comments made by,
I think it was both Tiff and Andrew.
We started from different places.
We were at 2% interest rates.
I think the Fed was at $3.50 thereabouts,
and you were at $3.25.
Inflations were at different levels as well.
And markets were expecting cuts in various corners.
So the situation was entirely different.
I don't regard that as a divergence.
I think the commitment is the same
to maintaining price stability
and doing what it takes to actually deliver on that commitment.
But sometimes you see wild swings.
And I mean, the dollar-yen, for instance,
is at the highest level in 40 years.
Is that okay, Chairman Moore?
Well, before we came here,
we each told a small story about Governor Ueda,
who's been a great colleague of many of ours,
and we're rooting for his good health
so that he can join us on panels like this
in a couple of months.
If this central bank stands for anything,
it's staying in its lane on monetary policy.
So do you think I'm going to wander
into yen policy in Japan?
You're asking way too much of me.
Well, it's making a move, that's all.
You know, Governor Mack, I'm on the markets.
You recently, I think, warned about excess,
just given the AI trade, speculation.
I think that's very much on the markets' mind.
Do you see signs of that?
I'm thinking of irrational exuberance.
Great, Alan Greenspan.
We've been warning, really, of two things,
and I'm going to draw Andrew into this.
Andrew chairs the Financial Stability Board.
I chair the Vulnerabilities Committee.
So, I mean, as Governor of the Bank of Canada,
I'm looking at this from a Canadian perspective,
but at the FSB, we're looking at it
from a more global perspective.
And I would highlight a couple of vulnerabilities.
As we've already said,
there is so much potential to raise productivity growth
with the adoption of AI,
with the fusion of AI tools which will create jobs.
You know, we've seen this before
in when there's a new breakthrough technology.
I mean, the internet proved to be,
you know, better than anybody imagined.
Created whole new businesses.
But we still got the dot-com bubble.
It doesn't mean there can't be a period
where the market gets ahead of itself
and you see a retrenchment.
So, look, it'd take two sides to make the market.
We're not in the business of giving investment advice
to the central bankers.
So, but, you know,
from a financial stability point of view,
you know, you look at the sort of,
you know, historical benchmarks,
PE ratios, forward ratios.
Yeah, things look stretched compared to those.
So that doesn't mean there's a problem,
but it does mean you need to take that risk on board.
The other risk we've been highlighting
is we've seen very large growth of hedge funds
in the sovereign debt market.
And to some extent, that's been very welcome.
They've been very efficient in buying
and distributing government debt.
There's lots of issuance out there.
Governments need investors.
But a lot of this is being done
with a lot of leverage, very short-term leverage.
And that does make you,
a lot of it overnight in the repo market.
And that does make you nervous
that if there was a period of volatility
and haircuts in repo markets went up
or there was some disruption in repo markets,
you could get a rapid unwind.
You know, again, part of our job
is that markets do a good job
of seeing the risks they face individually.
They have a harder time seeing the systemic risks.
These trades are very low risk for each hedge fund.
But when they're all doing something similar,
there could be a systemic overlay.
And the idea is if we can point that out,
the market can guard against that risk.
Do you agree?
Yeah.
I mean, Kevin has referred
to the financial crisis a few times.
And he's absolutely right to do that.
And one of the big questions at that time
or before it was,
is the subprime mortgage market
going to be, in a sense,
the trigger and the cause
of the wider financial crisis?
We didn't get that call particularly right, frankly.
But the thing that we have to bear in mind
is what we're trying to look for here
is sort of tail risk.
Is there something in these markets
that could trigger a wider consequence
in terms of financial stability?
And that's just, as Tiff said,
that's what we're trying to do.
Tiff leads the work
in the Financial Stability Board globally to do that.
So we're absolutely right.
We look at the increase in leverage
in core government bond markets.
I mean, these markets have changed substantially.
I think the thing we've seen actually
in the course of the last few months
is an increase in leverage in equity markets.
So you look at hedge fund leverage
in equity markets.
You look at leverage exchange-traded fund markets.
Those things are changing.
If you look at private credit,
the questions we're asking is,
are those the things that actually can move
from tail risk into a broader consequence?
So then you have to say,
what are the channels through which it can happen?
So at the Bank of England,
we're doing a second system-wide exploratory scenario
to ask that very question about private credit.
That's our job.
Do you see any other broader risks emerging?
And do you agree with the characterization
of stress for the market?
So, look, I mean, we are looking, obviously,
yes, we do look at asset valuations
because you are living in a world,
I mean, you've seen this, obviously,
over recent months
where you've got quite a divergence
between how bond yields are moving
and how equity markets are moving.
Now, I think a lot of this comes back
to what Kevin was saying about AI.
I think it's explicable in broad economic terms.
But the question is,
is that going to lead to some wider stability issues?
So that's on the list.
And then going back to what I was saying earlier,
I don't want to reopen it again,
but frontier AI is obviously high on the risk as well.
So we've got quite a list of things
that we're looking at at the moment.
I wonder if you, Chairman Warsh,
see any signs of excess trillion dollar IPOs,
high margin debt that was referenced
and other things that are going on in this market
that remind you of those other times?
Well, I would say,
I've been out of this business for 15 years,
but I still have the scars
from the global financial crisis.
I suspect my colleagues do too.
We take risks seriously.
And that's part of the reason why each of us,
I think at the core,
have sort of a reformer's heart on this.
What can we be doing in the conduct of monetary policy?
How should we be revisiting fundamental reforms
to supervision and regulation?
How should we think about the payment systems
that connect us all?
So this conference is principally about monetary policy.
I must admit my first four weeks at the Fed,
my attention has been focused on monetary policy.
But our governments have tended
to give us larger jobs than that.
We take it all very seriously.
I'm not prepared to sort of make a broad comment
denoting risks that are available in the system.
But I will say this,
this is the biggest time of consequence
to each of our economies, I think in our lifetime,
maybe absent the shocks of 2008 and the COVID shocks,
the dramatic change in how businesses do business,
how households are thinking about employment and inflation.
And so this is the time
we have to go back to first principles.
I know at the Federal Reserve with my colleagues,
many of whom are here, we're doing that.
So I don't want to sound complacent.
At the same time, I do want to say,
at least for the United States,
this is a time of huge opportunity.
And if the Fed can deliver on its remit to deliver prices,
I've never been more optimistic
about what the growth engine of the U.S. could produce.
The growth outlook of the U.S. economy this year is...
We're playing Mad Libs now?
So I would just say this,
over the last four quarters in the U.S.,
structural productivity is in the high 2% range.
So potential growth looks like it's trended up.
This is a time that the labor markets,
hours worked are relatively flat.
History says that we go from periods of low productivity
to periods of high productivity.
Nothing is in the bank at this time of consequence.
But if the last four quarters are an indication,
which is really largely before the advent of the new surge
in what artificial intelligence can do,
I think there's reason to be optimistic.
Does that optimism convey into policy
in the next six or nine months?
Still too soon to say.
But strong, strong outlook, sounds like.
You're back to forward guidance.
I'm going to disabuse you of trying to extract that.
My view, and my colleagues, I think,
have said this better than I.
My view is financial markets and the real economy work best.
When you look at what's happening in the real economy,
you make your own judgments.
There has been a tendency,
and I take plenty of blame from this DOA crisis,
where we were trying to suppress volatility,
where we thought we needed to spoon-feed markets
to get out of that.
That was the right policy for a crisis.
It is not the right policy for the time that we have now.
Sometimes unlearning is harder than learning,
and I'm going to keep at it.
What are the, President Lagarde,
how do you think about the best levers
to boost growth in the Eurozone right now?
Capital markets union.
28th regime and boost the venture capital.
That would be on the growth front.
But I would like to add one thing.
Thanks to the veterans at this podium,
and a few other people,
we have a strong, solid, robust banking system,
which is strongly well regulated, well supervised.
I think we should be cautious about what we are throwing away
by way of simplification.
We do simplify things,
and I'm delighted that, for instance,
the ECB has done away with 40 different sets
of declaration disclosures
that were unnecessary out of the 130 plus.
So we have to go through that process.
But I think we have to be cautious
about how risks actually move.
And risks were squarely in the banking system
back in 2007, 8,
when we were all together fighting
this global financial crisis.
Risks travel fast,
and there is no limit to the imagination
of those in the financial sector
who are trying to make money,
as is their business,
and who are taking risks.
The question is really,
who eventually ends up taking the risk
and flipping the mess?
So I would contend that this regulatory work
that we did at the time,
we need to be very attentive,
as Andrew suggested,
to make sure that the risks that have moved
and traveled afar
through different structures,
bodies,
and the different names
are also looked at carefully,
and that the right measures are taken
to protect the public good
and to protect the principle
of who takes risks
to bear the responsibility that goes with it.
The other big topic that I know
that you all think about
and is part of your remit
is the balance sheet.
And Chairman Warsh,
you have talked about
before you became Fed Chairman,
that the balance sheet was too big
in the United States.
So it's at $6.7 trillion right now.
What level would you be comfortable with?
No forward guidance.
And I'm not going to give...
It's a balance sheet.
I'm not going to give...
It's a balance sheet.
Okay, we're just among friends.
We have a task force for that too.
We're going to play drinking game on task force.
I'll say this.
There is no secret
that from the 2011 period
when I was leaving the Fed through now,
I wanted the Fed's balance sheet
to be smaller.
And I long wrote about and described
interest rates should be the dominant means
through which we make monetary policy.
If we're in a crisis,
there could be a different set of rules.
It's always struck me
that interest rate policy is the fairest
to the broad constellation of our citizens.
Interest rate policy,
whether we move it up or down,
transmits its way into a new mortgage,
credit card debt,
transmits its way through a lending channel
and credit channel.
I've always had a view
that the balance sheet works
mostly through asset prices,
works mostly through signaling effects.
My four weeks at the Fed
haven't disabused me of that idea.
As we're hearing an alarm,
that must be my way of saying
that I've gone too far on the balance sheet.
But we have a task force
that you'll find out of outside people
that are going to debate this topic,
bring it back to my colleagues and me
to see whether we can have a judgment
about whether the balance sheet
should be made smaller.
The only thing that I'll repeat here,
which I've said repeatedly,
is if there's a change in balance sheet policy,
it'll be a change of my colleagues
in the FOMC and the board.
Those decisions will be
well-deliberated publicly,
well-understood,
and will not be implemented
until financial markets
have come to understand what those are.
It took us about 18 years
to find our way into this big balance sheet,
which again, in my biased view,
borders on fiscal policy.
It took us 18 years to get out of it.
It'll take us more than 18 weeks
to bring it down to size.
I'm open-minded on the question.
We're not going to prejudge it.
But I want interest rate policy
to be the working order for monetary policy.
Governor Bailey,
you've been focused on the balance sheet.
I guess at one point,
we were asking how big
can your balance sheets get?
And now I'm wondering
how small they can get.
Well, there's a nice sort of sense of irony,
I appreciate,
from this conversation.
Because I've been accused
of having two bigger balance sheets
and reducing it too quickly.
Well, really.
Can I go back to forward guidance for a moment?
Because I've really eschewed
forward guidance on the balance sheets.
I have to prejudge the outcomes.
We want more reserves.
We want big reserves, small reserves.
My line has always been
we will meet the system's demand for reserves
because that's the system's demand for liquidity.
Now, we will also spend a lot of time,
by the way,
understanding the key principles.
And also, the key other point
which Kevin has made very forcefully
is that's the way we actually implement
monetary policy
through the short-term interest rate
transmitting out of our balance sheets
into the system.
And that works very well.
So our world is, look,
we will meet the system's demand for reserves.
We will seek to understand
very closely why it's doing that.
The other policy I have
is that I want to take interest rate risk
off the central bank's balance sheet
because with a public balance sheet,
interest rate risk should be in the market,
not on our balance sheets.
And so that's why we're moving
to a repo asset side of our balance sheet
because that takes the interest rate risk
off our balance sheet,
which is what should be the case.
You mentioned that you alluded
to the political heat that you get over this issue.
Does that influence
the way you think about it at all?
I know it's not supposed to.
No, I think we must have a sensible policy
for moving to a system
where our balance sheet reflects
the system's demand for reserves.
So yes, it went above that level
during the QE period.
It's coming down to that level.
Well, I want the interest rate risk
off our balance sheet.
Those are the policies we're pursuing
and I think those are the right policies.
Being in politics,
do you get let off the hook, Governor Macklin,
because the prime minister used to be in this seat?
We get some free advice
from elected officials across the country.
And as I tell them,
I appreciate understanding what's going on.
It's a big country.
I appreciate understanding
what's going on across the country,
but I don't appreciate telling me
what we should do with interest rates.
You've got your job.
We've got our job.
And that needs to be respected.
So I'll just come back to the balance sheet.
Interestingly, if you compare
different central banks,
you'll see a pretty wide range of size.
In Canada, we didn't do QE in 08, 09.
Fortunately, in Canada, no banks failed.
We did get a big shock,
but it wasn't so big that we needed
to invoke that emergency policy.
We did use QE in the pandemic.
It's the only time you have with it.
But the fact that we only did it once
meant that our balance sheet
wasn't as big to start with.
And we let the bonds run off.
So our balance sheet has run back
to its new steady state.
And if you compare central banks,
as I said, the size of the balance sheets
can be pretty different.
I mean, Canada's balance sheet is a percentage.
Bank of Canada's balance sheet
is a percentage of GDP.
It's about a third of the Fed.
Now, look, Canada's not the world's
global reserve currency.
So yeah, there might be some differences here.
But I think the results of Kevin's
task force is going to be
very informative to us.
And the other thing I'll say
about balance sheets is
it's a very inside baseball
kind of discussion.
It's not the sort of thing
most Canadians are really that engaged in.
But it does, you know,
it is how we,
there is an element of
how do we implement monetary policy?
What is the demand for reserves?
We've spent the last couple days
talking about new kinds of money.
What do those,
what do those potentially mean
for our balance sheet?
So these are questions we need,
we need some thinking on.
And in the short time
that we have left, President Lagarde,
I did want to get to you
on this political point.
And because you have been
a forceful voice for
central bank independence,
I know you continue to do so.
And you, I mean,
unlike these guys,
you have to battle
more than 20 different governments
and leaders, 21.
So you're a pro at that.
I'm just, I'm curious
if you think that there are,
if you look across,
if you look out and see serious risks
to central bank independence,
especially in light of
the Supreme Court ruling
that we got in the United States,
letting Fed Governor Lisa Cook
do her job.
I think, you know,
the best way we can actually
all do our job
is to be number one accountable,
number two independent,
and the two come together.
You know, when I go to
the European Parliament
on a regular basis
to report on what we do,
to explain what we do,
that's the counterpart
for this independence that we have.
Staying in our mandate,
the entirety of the mandate
is also the cynical non-condition
for deserving that independence,
which is a precious good,
without which we would not
do a good job.
That's my view.
How did you feel about
the Supreme Court ruling?
We were doing so well.
So before the Supreme Court,
the Fed acted independently
and followed its remit.
After the Supreme Court ruling,
the Fed will continue to do so.
I read the opinion
on the plane over here.
One of the secrets
of the productivity-led
economic growth
that I was talking about
at the outset
is because of the constitutional
design in the U.S.
It's the foundational element
that has given us 250 years
of outperforming expectations.
I believe in Article III judges.
I believe in the rule of law.
We'll follow the Supreme Court decision.
But day to day,
the decision reaffirms
what President Lagarde already said.
We are calling balls and strikes
as best we can.
We're taking seriously
the reform objective.
And we're going to deliver
on the high promise
that Congress gave us
to deliver price stability
in the context of our dual mandate.
And when we do that,
we don't have to worry about politics.
We don't have to worry
about judicial intervention.
We get to look in front of us
because it's a challenging step.
Okay, we have a minute left.
I'm going to ask everybody
one quickie for everybody.
Two quickies, actually.
Governor Bailey, I'll start with you.
So favorite economic indicator
right now.
Your favorite economic indicator.
Oh, that's a trap question as well.
You see, that's a trap question
and it's forward guidance.
Thank you, brother.
I'm trying.
I'll tell you what, I'll answer it.
Oh, there you are.
My inflation forecast.
Governor Bailey, you have to answer.
Well, we look at a whole range of data.
Honestly, if you sat through our meetings,
you would see more data
than you could ever dream of.
The other thing I say, look, I'll say this.
I spend a lot of time
going around the country
and I talk to a lot of businesses
and it's absolutely imperative
that we stay in touch with the economy.
President Lagarde.
Inflation outlook, balance of risk,
underlying inflation,
transmission of monetary policy.
Thank you.
I guess I have the last word.
With the data project,
the data task force,
my hope, my aspiration
is that nine, 12 months from now,
we're going to be using new technologies
to understand what's happening
in the real economy
in a contemporaneous, real-time way
that positions us as central makers
to make better decisions.
That we're no longer
going to have to rely solely
on data that we get
from government agencies
with mismeasurement problems
that have surveys
that are no longer relevant.
That every business we know
that are leading in our country
are using new data sources
to make better decisions.
My favorite data is upon us
and if we do our jobs,
we'll be here a year from now
and we'll say we've discovered data
that helps us make better decisions.
And we live up to our promises,
we strengthen our credibility
and politics stays at bay.
Least favorite economic indicator?
The conventional wisdom
that we hear from time to time
tells us nothing.
Monetary policy works
with long and variable lags as we know
and many of these indicators
are echoes of history.
We need indicators that tell us
what things are.
We look out our window today
so we make judgments
when we next convene.
They're as close to real-time as possible.
I thought you were going to say the dots.
I'm going to let one panel discussion
go without me wagering on the dots.
There will still be dots for a short time
at the very least
but we have a task force for that.
I know.
We'll revisit it.
Do you have a least favorite
economic indicator, President Lagarde?
What did you say?
Least favorite economic indicator
that gets too much attention?
Those that are wrong.
Governor Mackey, help me out.
What I say is,
especially a lot of the monthly data,
it can be very volatile.
Sometimes the market over-rotates
on the last number.
You've got to correlate it with other things.
You've got to smooth it a bit.
The last monthly number
is never going to be the best indicator.
I'll give you one
that we're wrestling with at the moment
and have wrestled with for years.
It's obviously relevant
which is oil and gas futures prices.
They are terrible indicators in history.
The problem is that everything else
is also a terrible indicator.
Very good.
Finally, when we were coming into this year,
everybody was talking about rate cuts.
Is anyone still talking here about rate cuts?
Show of hands.
Well, that's a nice try.
That's a nice try at forward guidance.
I tried.
Thank you all very much for the candor.
