For decades, wages were the primary source of income for most American households. Today, that picture is changing.
In this episode, macro economist Eric Basmajian explains why the composition of household income is shifting, how government transfer payments have grown as a share of income, and why that matters for the U.S. economy.
The conversation also explores why traditional monetary policy may be losing effectiveness, how demographics and industry concentration are reshaping the economy, and why programs like Social Security face mounting fiscal pressure in the years ahead. ----- 02:34 – Wage Shift to Government Benefits 04:10 – Benefits and Inflation Pressure 06:47 – Wages vs. Corporate Profits 09:30 – The Rise of Superstar Firms 11:55 – Why Small Businesses Declined 13:46 – Where Is the U.S. Economy Headed? 15:10 – Social Security's Funding Gap 17:18 – How Income Sources Have Shifted 19:32 – Can Antitrust Restore Competition? 22:43 – Why Monopolies Persist 24:40 – Debt and Shared Sacrifice 26:52 – Debt, Deficits & K-Shaped Economy 28:20 – America's Wealth & Age Divide ----- Let's Stay in Contact: • Substack - https://substack.com/@themarketinsidershow • X (Twitter) - https://twitter.com/MktInsiderShow • Linkedin - https://www.linkedin.com/company/market-insider-show/ ----- 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘦𝘹𝘱𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘦𝘥 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘷𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘰 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘨𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘥𝘰 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘯𝘦𝘤𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘳𝘦𝘧𝘭𝘦𝘤𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘷𝘪𝘦𝘸𝘴 𝘰𝘧 𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘬𝘦𝘵 𝘐𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳. 𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘯𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘦𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘱𝘶𝘳𝘱𝘰𝘴𝘦𝘴 𝘰𝘯𝘭𝘺 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘴𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘣𝘦 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭, 𝘪𝘯𝘷𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘵, 𝘰𝘳 𝘭𝘦𝘨𝘢𝘭 𝘢𝘥𝘷𝘪𝘤𝘦. 𝘈𝘭𝘸𝘢𝘺𝘴 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘴𝘶𝘭𝘵 𝘢 𝘲𝘶𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘧𝘪𝘦𝘥 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘧𝘦𝘴𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘭 𝘣𝘦𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘢𝘯𝘤𝘪𝘢𝘭 𝘥𝘦𝘤𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴. 𝘚𝘰𝘮𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘴𝘤𝘳𝘪𝘱𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘮𝘢𝘺 𝘣𝘦 𝘢𝘧𝘧𝘪𝘭𝘪𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘬𝘴.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Americans now are getting higher percentage of their income from subsidies and government
programs. Meanwhile, income from jobs has declined significantly in the last couple of decades.
Today we sit down with Eric Basmajian, who's looked into this trend. He's going to tell us
why is this happening and where we are headed next. Are the companies not paying enough
for other employees in general? We get data on what is tantamount to corporate revenue
for all of corporate America. Even private ones? Even private companies. And what we see
is that wages as a percentage of revenue used to be about 65%. Now wages are about 55% of revenue.
So there's been a 10 percentage point swing. I think that there's several reasons for that.
I'm Siamak and this is Marketing Insider. Eric, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. Thanks for having me. We want to talk to you about some phenomena that's happening in
the U.S. now. People are having different sources of income and the jobs are not providing as much
as they used to. Can you tell us what you're seeing out there in the data? Yeah. So over the
past several decades, there's been a large shift in the composition of income. So when the government
reports personal income or household income, that really comes from a combination of a lot
of different sources. People think income just means wages, but really personal income,
as it's defined in the economic statistics, is a combination of wages, interest, dividends,
rental income, as well as what are called government transfer payments,
things like Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, as well as some other programs like veterans
benefits, supplemental nutrition programs, and things of that nature. So there's really a large
mix of income sources. And the biggest shift that we're seeing, really it's been a slow moving trend
over the last several decades, this is not really a new phenomenon, is that the largest share of
income used to be wages. It was about 75% of that total household income came from wages.
Then there was a small amount that came from interest, dividends, assets, and a very small
percentage came from the government. Over the last several decades, as the population has gotten
older, more people qualify for government social programs based on age, that has really shifted
dramatically to now 20% of household income is coming from government social programs or
government transfer programs. And the wages portion of the pie is closer to 50%. So really over the
last several decades, what we're seeing is a smaller share of household income is coming from
wages. A larger share is coming from government transfer payments. And on the surface, that sounds
benign, because of course, these programs were created with good intention, and people have paid
into these programs. But as with everything in economics, there are unintended consequences,
and there's no free lunch. So that's really the crux of what I believe people are starting to
notice as the income distribution has changed so dramatically. When you're looking at this data,
and you're seeing it, how will this impact us in the future, in the long run? There are
a lot of issues that have cropped up as a result of this. Of course, all of them are unintended
consequences for the most part. None of them were obviously done with this intent. But as a larger
share of income is coming from government sources, which are completely immune to changes in monetary
policy, it's harder, for example, for the Federal Reserve to slow down the economy and get inflation
under control. Because when, let's say, all of the income in the economy comes from the labor market,
the Federal Reserve can raise interest rates and cool down the economy, and that therefore gets
inflation under control. But when the Federal Reserve raises interest rates, that doesn't
change anybody's Social Security payment or Medicare benefits. So if a larger and larger
share of income is coming from sources that are completely immune to monetary policy,
it's harder for the Federal Reserve to get inflation under control. What that means is
the Fed would have to inflict more pain or more economic pressure on the sectors that they do
have control over, which primarily is the housing market, which creates another set of political
problems. We have a difficult situation in the housing market across the country today. Home
prices are very high, and interest rates are high, which has made the situation unaffordable.
But the Federal Reserve still doesn't have inflation back to their 2% target. Therefore,
there's a lot of calls. And more recently, people are now expecting the Federal Reserve has to raise
interest rates even more to get inflation down, which will make the housing affordability issue
for the time being even worse, unless the prices come down, of course. So that's one set of issues
that has come up as a larger share of income is coming from the government, is that the Federal
Reserve has a more difficult time getting inflation under control. The second issue is it's causing
distortionary effects in the labor market. The reason for that is, again, unintended, where
if you are, let's say, a 65-year-old and you are a recipient of Social Security benefits as well as
Medicare benefits, that may amount to, let's say, $30,000 per year, $40,000 per year, $50,000 per
year of total benefits. You may only have to go out into the marketplace and obtain an additional
$20,000, $30,000, $40,000 of supplemental income to live your lifestyle. You may be able to go and
take a job for a much lower wage than someone who's 25 to 54, who can't live on just $30,000,
that would be a wage that they can't live on, but that job would be taken by someone who is
older, still able-bodied, still has the ability to work, but has supplemental income coming from
government sources. So that's another issue that's created in the labor market, where we have a
situation where young prime-age people, 25 to 54, are experiencing lower wages, difficult time getting
jobs, and some of that, not all of it, but some of it has to do with the fact that they can be
out-competed by older demographics that may not have the same need for income because they have a
perpetual, guaranteed, inflation-indexed income stream coming from government sources.
Now, you mentioned that now the workforce, some people that are semi-retired, essentially,
they're getting these benefits and they're coming to the workforce as a result of it.
Are the companies not paying enough for other employees in general? Is there a trend for
companies to not share as much income with their employees? Yeah, so I don't think that the
companies are, you know, paying below market wages. I think that they're paying wages that
the market will bear. It's just that there are people that are willing to accept the lower
income because that's what their situation dictates. You do bring up an interesting point,
though, where if we look at the government statistics, they report essentially what's a
corporate revenue number. So they report, and this is, you know, not to be mistaken for S&P 500
companies, this is all corporations in the entire economy. Even private ones? Even private companies.
We get data on what is tantamount to corporate revenue, and we also get a number on what's
tantamount to corporate profits. We also have wages and all different types of things. So we can
essentially have an income statement for all of corporate America. And what we see is that
wages as a percentage of revenue used to be about 65%. Now wages are about 55% of revenue. So there's
been a 10 percentage point swing, and that's fallen essentially directly to the bottom line.
So what that means is that corporate profit margins have gone up by about 10%. So 30 years
ago, 40 years ago, corporate profit margins were running at about 9 or 10%, and now corporate
profit margins as of the latest data are at 20%. So we have seen a 10 percentage point swing of
you know, 65% of revenue was going to wages, now 55% of revenue is going to wages.
I think that there's several reasons for that. Number one is that the phenomenon that I
just described where some of the workforce may be willing to work for lower wages because they have,
in effect, the government is subsidizing a portion of the wages. So you can go out into
the workplace and you're willing to work for maybe less than a full market wage because of
that supplement. Another factor, however, is over the last 30 years, an increasing share of
revenue has gone to a smaller and smaller number of firms. Now, everyone will jump and say it's
large tech companies and that's the reason, and that is true. But we see this trend across
every industry, not just technology. So for example, 30 years ago, I think the statistic,
if I remember correctly, was about 8% of new homes were built by the top 10 home building companies.
That's about 45% today. So that market share or that market concentration of, let's say,
the top 10 home building companies has gone from 8% to 45% or thereabouts. That phenomenon
is happening across every single industry in the country. You could look at healthcare, home
building, and of course, technology. So there was a paper written about this, and the paper called
these superstar firms, which I think is a polite way of saying monopolies. They're not exactly
monopolies because, of course, 10 companies is not a monopoly. But together, it could be counted
as a monopoly. Together, the concentration is becoming quite extreme. And like I said, you
could see this across every industry. So what that does is it shifts work towards larger companies
that have more economies of scale, and those companies are able to operate more efficiently
in the standpoint of profit margins. Now, some people will say, I work for some of these companies,
they're not that efficient. And yes, they do become somewhat of bureaucracies, but they can
certainly out-compete smaller firms when it comes to competitively bidding on healthcare for their
entire company, or competing on materials, or all the different ways that they have economies of
scale. And that allows them to then grab even more market share. And if there's less dynamism
in the workforce, if you are a construction worker, let's say as example, and there's 10
companies to work for versus 100 companies to work for, your ability to bargain for wages is
lower as you have less choices. So that's a huge thing that's happened over the course of the last
30, 40 years, is the hyper-concentration of really large firms dominating every single industry.
And that could be a whole podcast in itself, perhaps. But some of the top-line issues that
seem to be causing some of this are perhaps some more relaxed antitrust laws. And as these
companies get bigger, they sometimes lobby for more regulations. It sounds counterintuitive,
but that prevents incumbents or new entrants from coming in.
It's harder for small companies to compete with when there's a lot of regulation.
So essentially, you regulate to put your competition out of business.
Exactly. So a million dollars in compliance cost is nothing to a multi-billion dollar firm,
but a small business, of course, can't pay that at all. Another issue is after the great financial
crisis, we obviously had a major issue in the banking sector. And regulators were appropriately
freaked out by that. And they tried to impose regulations to essentially prevent us from having
a large-scale banking crisis again. Understandable, of course, given what happened after 2008.
And what those regulations did, very, very complex, but from a high level,
is they really prevented or disincentivized or regulated away the bank's ability to make lots of
small business loans. Large-scale banks have become much more incentivized to just hold
securities and treasuries that they purchase from the government. And they're less incentivized to
make loans into the private sector, thereby trying to decrease the risk in the banking sector.
So they've pushed a lot of that lending out to other types of companies. That's created a lower
dynamism of small business formation. Again, makes it harder for new businesses to form,
makes it harder for competition to enter the market. So, we can never blame any of these
issues on one specific cause. There's always an array of issues, but those are some of the
headlines that I think are driving some of this concentration. Where do you think things are
headed from here? I've had this conversation a few times with some friends, some colleagues,
and the easiest answer is we're just going to continue along the same path until we're forced
to make a change. And if we were having this conversation five years ago, that would sound
like an issue that's so distant in the future that we can come back on a year, two, three years from
now, we'll have the same conversation. But I actually think that there's one issue that's
actually starting to come into the viewpoint that will define the fork in the road or where we go.
The Congressional Budget Office, a nonpartisan institution, puts out budget forecasts. They
usually do it in 10-year periods. So, what's going to happen over the next 10 years for
the U.S. budget? And they make some projections about growth, about spending, and all the rest.
And there was a recent report that they put out that said that the Social Security trust funds
will run out in 2032. And what they mean by run out is just that there won't be a leftover pool
of money, essentially, to pay benefits. So, right now, we have people who are working.
Some of the money comes out of their paycheck and goes into the Social Security system.
That money goes to paying current recipients right now. Now, because the demographics are
a little bit lopsided and we have more people receiving the benefits, that means that the people
paying into the system are only covering, the estimates vary a little bit, but they're covering
about 75% of the benefits, which means that remaining 25 comes out of those trust funds or
those pools. That trust fund is what they say is going to run out in 2032. And what that would mean
by law, the way that the law is written, is that they would only be able to pay out what's coming
in, which is about 75%. So, what that means is Social Security benefits would be cut by 25%.
Now, the CBO at one point said that the trust funds would run out in 2040, and then it was 2036,
and now it's 2032. They have a tendency to maybe overestimate some of these things. So,
if they're saying 2032 now, I think it's fairly safe to say it may actually be 2030 or 2029. And
given that we're halfway done with 2026, that's something that really is two and a half years
from now. And I just saw politicians on Twitter yesterday starting to make rumblings about how
they're going to maybe try and rectify this situation. There are a lot of different things
that you could potentially do, increase the retirement age, you could reduce the benefits,
you could increase the payroll tax, you could lift the cap on payroll taxes. There are a lot
of different ways that you could try and rectify this issue. Point being is that how we end up
solving that problem, which is now a two-year problem, I think will tell us a lot about the
direction that we're going. So, that's one thing that I'm paying pretty close attention to. And I
think that perhaps after we get through this midterm cycle, that is going to be an issue
that's going to be front and center for the next election, because that's a 2028 election.
And that means that that president or whoever's elected will have to deal with that in probably
the first year of their term. So, that I think is going to be one of the big forks in the road.
You mentioned that 20% of the income is not coming, household income is coming from these
benefits, and 50% is coming from the salaries, and 30% is from investment, right?
What did these numbers look like a few decades ago?
Several decades ago in the 60s, 70s, 80s, it was about 75% of the income was coming from wages
and salaries and various forms of compensation. About 5% was coming from the government social
benefits, and the remainder was coming from investment income dividends, as well as small
business income. Small business income is another part of that puzzle. But it was about 75% wages,
5% government benefits, and 20% was from investments in small business. And as you
mentioned, that's flipped to now 20% is coming from government social programs. Another 15% or
so is coming from the investments, and it's down to about 50% coming from wages. So, it's been a
huge change. And why did this change happen? You said there was a few factors, but is it because
is demographic have a play in this? Because people are getting older now, and they're taking
social security? That's definitely the biggest factor. That's definitely the biggest factor. I
would say that the biggest factor is the demographic change. Just as the baby boom generation
enters the 65 and older years, they become automatic recipients of both social security and
Medicare. So, that's the biggest driving issue. And then I would say the secondary issue
is what we discussed about the hyper concentration of corporations across industries, and that
putting perhaps a dampening effect on wages or bargaining power for employees. So, that would
be secondary. And you are seeing this trend continuing until something major happens. And
what can happen to change this? Will there ever be a change from what you're seeing in the
corporation side of it? You mentioned the social security side, but is there a change from the
corporation side? I think it would have to be a regulatory change in enforcing maybe some sort
of antitrust or breaking these companies up in somehow. Not that I'm necessarily in favor of
that, but that's just what would have to change because the dynamic is somewhat self-fulfilling,
where as the companies get bigger, they can lobby for regulations and then out-compete smaller
competitors and thereby take more market share and more market share. So, I think that we're
going to see that trend continue. Also, as technology advances and technology becomes
more prolific, that also favors large companies. So, for example, one thing that the viewers could
take as an example is maybe 20 or 30 years ago, let's say before the internet was very prolific
or somewhere around there, if you wanted to buy, let's say a hammer, you'd have to go drive to your
local hardware store. And you probably would have bought the hammer at whatever the hardware store
was listing the price as because you'd have to drive to another hardware store to maybe get a
better price. And it probably wasn't worth your time to go 20 minutes or 30 minutes for maybe a
couple of dollars difference. But now with the internet and Amazon, you can go online and you
could look up 50 hammers and you could get the cheapest one and it could be delivered to your
door in 24 hours, which obviously out-competes the local hardware store. So, it makes it much
more difficult for that business to survive against a business that is utilizing technology
and has obviously built up some incredible logistic systems. So, as technology expands,
and that's obviously one crude example, it will continue to favor these really large companies
that can deploy some of the more advanced technology. You could think maybe AI in a way
that would advantage them and disadvantage maybe smaller businesses. This is just something of a
symptom of capitalism, of course, but we used to have antitrust laws that were more focused
on market concentration. We've shifted that dynamic a little bit to now enforcing antitrust
has to make some case that the company is harming the consumer. And all of these companies that we
think of as modern day monopolies, consumers love. Most people love Amazon. Most people love their
iPhone and really there's only two competitors for iPhones or whatever. So, these companies are not
adversely impacting consumers. So, while they continue to dominate and get larger and larger
market shares, consumers like them more and more and more. And that's created a dynamic where no
one really wants... It would be a very unpopular position, I think, for someone to try and break
up some of these big companies if it meant that their phones or services would be more expensive.
So, on that side, I don't see a huge avenue for change other than regulation. And I'd be very
skeptical that that could get over the line. And on the other side, the benefits issue,
I think that the one that's going to be front and center is going to be
the social security issue that comes to the table in a couple of years.
Do you have any recommendations for policymakers? What's the solution to this?
One way or another, the politicians will have to tackle the entitlement programs. And by
entitlement programs, I mean Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid. There are a lot of people
that say we can inflate the way out of it, we can do X, Y, and Z. But when you really go down
the chain long enough, all roads lead back to these programs based on the lopsided demographics
as well as the way that they've been constructed are just simply unsustainable. And they are
outpacing our ability to pay for them. The taxes will probably have to go up as one part of the
solution, but taxes can't possibly go up enough to cover the programs as they're currently
structured based on the future trends 10, 15, 20 years from now. So, at some point,
as painful as it may be, these programs will have to be tackled. And there's no way to do that,
of course, without some level of discomfort. Everyone wants a solution to the problem,
but what they really want is a painless solution to the problem. And it's just not possible.
So, once people realize that there's no painless way to solve this, people start to try and solve
the problem by pushing the discomfort onto another group. So, whether it's all the problems should
fall onto wealthy people to pay taxes, or all of the problems should fall onto the benefit holders
and we should cut the benefits, or all of the problems should be solved by increasing taxes
on the working population today. And I think that the answer probably has to come from some form of
shared sacrifice across all of the groups is the only way it seems somewhat equitable to solve for
this. I think this is going to be a tremendously difficult problem. My fear is that politicians
decide not to solve this problem. They decide not to tax to pay for it. They decide not to
cut the benefits to pay for it. And they rewrite the laws of the programs and allow the government
to simply just issue more debt to pay for these programs, which are already clearly underfunded.
And I think that will exacerbate all of these trends that we are talking about, where
if you project out the numbers far enough, that government transfer payments will rise from 20%
of personal income to 25, to 30, to 35. And you'll end up in a scenario where literally a majority
of household income will be coming from social benefit programs and assets. And it's going to be
extraordinarily difficult for people who have wages as the primary source of income to keep up,
because like I said, all of those benefits are indexed to inflation. And it just creates so many
distortionary effects if government is supplying a third of the economy's income through guaranteed
transfer payments. And the sad reality is, yes, people did pay into these programs over the years,
and that's something to be respected when we decide on how we're maybe going to fix these
problems. But the other side of the coin is that there were just broken promises on the government
side, and we'll have to come to terms with that as well. So I think that it's going to have to
come in some form of shared sacrifice. But my fear is they decide to try and fix the problem with
more debt, because the problem as you get further out gets so large, you just can't solve it through
taxation. And it's going to be a bigger problem, I think, if they decide to delay the inevitable
even more than they already have. And how would it impact people? Would the inflations go up if
we decide to add more debt? Yeah, so if we decide to add more debt, what we'd see is we'd see a
continuation as well as an acceleration of the trends that we're seeing now. So everything that
people are feeling now would get worse, and it would get worse in a faster pace. Like the K-shaped economy?
The K-shaped economy. So asset prices would rise far faster than wages because the government
deficit will get larger. So right now the deficit is 6% of GDP. It'll go to 8% and 9%
and 10% of GDP. And given that we're a reserve currency, that doesn't give us a superpower to
avoid rectifying our fiscal situation forever. But it certainly does give us a long runway to
the point where I don't think that just because the deficit goes to 8% or 9% that the currency
will collapse or anything like that. Of course, it's always possible. But given the fact that we
are a reserve currency, I do think that we would have more rope to run 6%, 7%, 8%, 9% deficits.
And what that will do is a lot of that money will flow to corporate profits. And corporate profits
will rise faster than wages. Asset prices will rise faster than wages. Home prices will rise
faster than wages. The wealth divide will exacerbate. And there will be lots of societal
divides, one in terms of wealth, where there's classes of wealthy people and less wealthy people.
But it will also create a really strong divide in age-based groups. So people 65 and over that are
recipients of these benefits will become their own K relative to people that are 25 to 54.
So it will just continue to increase the divides across the economy. And to use,
I think, what the most appropriate phrase is, is the government will increasingly pick winners
and losers. And that doesn't ultimately lead to a society that has a lot of cohesion.
So Eric, hopefully, something will happen in the next couple of years, next few years. And
there's good discussions to see how there should be a solution. Hopefully, there's a solution to
this. And we reverse this K-shaped economy that's hurting a lot of people. Yeah, it's funny. As we
were discussing having this conversation just a couple of days ago, I saw a lot of rumblings on
Twitter and other social medias where politicians are starting to bring this issue up because
it is going to be an issue over the next couple of years. And another fear is that they will perhaps
try and solve the problem in a way that's most politically palatable, not the way that would
actually solve the problem. But that's going to be a discussion to be had. And I think that it's
necessary. Eric Basmajian, it was great to have you on Market Insider. Thanks so much. Tell us
what you think about this conversation with Eric. Do you agree with his thoughts? And where do you
think we're headed? I'm Siamak. This is Market Insider. We'll see you next time.