Elizabeth Warren And Bernie Moreno's Social Security 'Fix' Would Usher In Disaster: Steve Forbes

Elizabeth Warren's News
3 followers
15 Video Views·Jun 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedSteve Forbes criticizes a proposal by two U.S. Senators to remove the Social Security earnings cap. He argues that this massive tax increase would stifle economic growth, divert capital from the private sector, and encourage tax avoidance, ultimately harming the very system it intends to save. He advocates for personal accounts as a sustainable alternative.
A lot of bad ideas are being floated to save Social Security. Two U.S. Senators just floated
a dreadful one in the New York Times that would clobber both the system and the economy.
Hello, I'm Steve Forbes and this is What's Ahead, where you get the insights you need
to better navigate these turbulent times. For years, we've been deluged with stories
about the Social Security system going broke in the early 2030s. The trust funds are paying out
more in benefits than they're taking from payroll taxes, thereby depleting reserves.
The purported villain is that we're living longer and the number of working people are inadequate
to pay for the promised benefits. In a New York Times op-ed earlier this week, two U.S. Senators
proposed removing the earnings cap of $184,500. The 12.5% Social Security tax, which is split
between employer and employee, stops at that level. These Senators want the cap gone. It's
no surprise that one of the sponsors is Elizabeth Warren, a socialist in all but name. The other,
though, is a Republican from Ohio, Bernie Morino. He represents a disturbing trend among some in the
Republican Party who think the way to victory is indulging populist sentiment, whether it's
boosting taxes on the so-called rich, imposing price controls on pharmaceuticals, which will
eventually smother innovation just as they've had in Europe and elsewhere, or catering to
power-hungry unions, let's force rail shippers to hire unneeded work crews, going against Israel,
scapegoating certain industries for high prices, or imitating socialists of old by taking ownership
stakes in companies in the name of national security. These Republicans should ask how well
such pandering did for the Conservative Party in Britain, which is now on life support. The scheme
of these two Senators would constitute one of the biggest tax increases in history. It would
effectively send the top income tax rate to over 50 percent, a level not seen since 1969.
Some 5 million Americans earn above that $184,500 level, and their numbers are rising,
thanks to inflation and an improving economy. The tax increase would disproportionately hit people
in high-cost, tax-heavy blue states like New York and California and Massachusetts. This
harebrained scheme will harm the economy by diverting trillions of dollars of potential
capital from the private sector. The billionaires, so hated by Democrats and certain Republicans,
have ways to escape this tax. Those who get most of their pay and salaries will be slammed. The tax
will lead to a proliferation of ways to avoid the higher levy. Tax shelters and other schemes will
proliferate. Considerably more time and brain power will be diverted from productive economic
activities to such dead-end efforts. That too will harm the economy. Such efforts at avoidance
will lead to cries to apply payroll taxes to non-salary incomes like dividends. It will fuel
proposals for a national wealth tax. This means even more capital destruction and less investment
for productive growth, another downer for future prosperity. Two big things tax raisers like those
senators never seem to understand is that, first, taxes are a price and a burden. Real world
experience repeatedly shows when you boost the price of productive work and success, you get
less of them. Less growth means less revenue to pay for social security benefits, among other things.
Second, victims of higher taxes don't stand still and get sheared like obedient sheep. These two
facts mean that revenue estimates from higher levies are rarely realized. Another fact these
tax lovers don't grasp is that the predictions of the demise of social security are based on
historically low rates of economic growth and productivity. For most of our existence as a nation,
we've averaged three to three and a half percent growth. Reasonable government policies make that
eminently achievable, which puts off doomsday for many years. The best answer for the future of
social security is to establish personal accounts with proper regulations for young people, where
part of their payroll tax would be deposited. This would turn social security from a capital
destroyer to a capital creator, and participants will get far higher benefits than the current
system can possibly provide. Another thing, politically there's no way social security benefits
are going to get cut. I'm Steve Forbes. Thanks for listening. Do send in your comments and suggestions.
We look forward to being with you soon again.
