An address to the Ninth Annual Cambridge International Law (CILJ) Conference in April 2020, in Panel 12: Addressing Environmental Risk through International Trade and Investment, by Grégoire Lunven de Chanrond, Ph.D. Candidate in Laws, Chinese University of Hong Kong.
The Cambridge International Law Journal 9th Annual Cambridge International Law Conference on the theme of ‘International Law and Global Risks: Current Challenges in Theory and Practice‘ was held as an online webinar series due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This presentation explores how green finance taxonomies—classification schemes that define \"green\" economic activities—serve as practical modalities for implementing international environmental treaties. By translating broad treaty goals into specific technical criteria and managing climate transition risks, these taxonomies bridge the gap between global legal commitments and real-world financial activity.
Okay, so I'm going to explore how green finance taxonomies can be seen as a way to implement
environmental treaties. Definitions of green finance taxonomies are classification schemes
setting criteria for determining when an economic activity or asset or sector can be considered
green. The definition of green so obviously differs according to taxonomies but it generally
amounts to saying that the activity contributes to a given environmental objective. What I'm going
to try to defend in this presentation is the idea that exactly like other mechanisms designed by
multilateral development banks, for instance safeguard systems or the World Bank Inspection
Panel, green finance taxonomies can also be seen as a modality for implementing environmental treaties.
I will start by doing a sort of genealogy of green finance taxonomies or a sort of
little small history of green finance taxonomies to explain a bit better this
new object of study. Then I will try to see how these green finance taxonomies enable
implementation of environmental treaties at the level of economic activities by designing specific
criteria. And finally I will see how the implementation of these environmental treaties
through these green taxonomies can be done thanks to reducing climate transition risks.
First a couple of elements on the genealogy of green taxonomies. The first two green finance
taxonomies that I could find are actually tools that were designed by the OECD and the IFC,
the International Finance Corporation, and other multilateral development banks to track
climate finance. And not only climate finance but also the finance dedicated to fight against
deforestation and fight against the depletion of biological diversity. So this is the Rio markers
at the first line. These are criteria to follow finance deployed for the Rio Conventions.
Then this concept of climate finance taxonomies was reinterpreted by the Climate Bond Initiative
which is a London-based NGO focusing on climate bonds as its name can tell. And the
professional banking organization called the International Capital Market Association
who both developed their own classification of green activities for the purpose of the
green bonds being debt titles for which the proceeds is allocated to an environmental
beneficial activity. And then in the third time this concept was
implemented by national regulators like the People's Bank of China
or the EU Technical Group on Sustainable Finance. So national institutions.
I'm going to focus on one of the taxonomies by Chinese authorities and the EU taxonomy.
Let me just give an idea of their characteristics very simply.
So about their legal status, the Chinese taxonomy is an administrative measure
issued by the People's Bank of China whereas the EU taxonomy is just a report at the moment. It's
an open standard. If you want to label a green bond by this taxonomy you can but it's not
necessary. And it will become by the end of this year a delegated act drafted by the Commission
under the regulatory framework set by the taxonomy regulation which reached a political
agreement by the end of 2019 between the European Parliament and the European Council.
About the scope of application, so one is mostly focused on the green bond markets, the other one
targets more broadly financial standards and reporting by financial market participants
and large companies. And finally about the structure of these taxonomies,
both actually are based on national industrial classification and both define criteria.
So it's a bit more complicated on the EU side but it's the same principle. You have the example here
with just one criteria for one activity involving the Chinese green taxonomy.
So you can see here the categorization of the economic categorization and the criteria
runs through the national industrial classification code and then the reference
to an international convention. Just to explain very quickly how environmental treaties are
implemented to economic activities through these green finance taxonomies,
I would say there are three different modalities through objectives of these taxonomies,
through criteria and through interpretation. So let me go back to the objectives.
So I give here as a first example, I will just go through examples because obviously
these taxonomies are extremely dense and sophisticated so it's only possible to
explore everything. But it's an example with the EU taxonomy, the article 6 of the regulation
states actually that an economic activity that is recognized as having a substantial
contribution to climate change mitigation, so one of the type of green activities,
actually the definition of this activity is based on the objectives of the United Nations
Framework Convention. The red words are a copy paste from the article 2 of the United Nations
Convention on Climate Change and obviously on the objectives of the Paris Agreement.
Let me see if, yeah, this is a bit different in the Chinese taxonomy
since this taxonomy follows first the necessity to stick to national conditions,
but nonetheless it has an objective to facilitate international cooperation with green finance
and therefore implements international practices and international standards.
Regarding criteria, international law is also, international treaties
are also implemented through the criteria applied to each activity. So this is an example
in the Chinese convention, there would be many examples as well in the EU taxonomy.
Regarding interpretation, the EU taxonomy regulation states that for many of the
activities defined as green inside the taxonomy, the taxonomy should be interpreted in line with
environmental agreements. So here, just an example with the Sendai framework for this
activities reduction applicable to adaptation activities, so one of the types of the green
activities. Let me then reach my last point. The idea that climate transition risks can be also
a conceptual tool to implement, to show the implementation of international environmental
treaties for green taxonomies. So climate transition risks are defined as a financial
risk related to transition to a lower carbon economy by opposition to risk related to the
physical impacts of climate change. So paradoxically, environmental treaties generate
such transition risks. Just take the Paris Agreement, if you follow the IPCC's estimate
of a carbon budget that would enable to reach, to respect the goal of the Paris Agreement,
we could only exploit between one-fifth and one-third of the world's reserve of oil,
gas and coal. So you can imagine that there is a huge transition risk for any company having
businesses in oil and gas, if we respect actually the goal of the Paris Agreement. But actually,
translating this international, this vague international commitment down to the level
of economic activities can reduce this climate transition risk. It's very clear, for instance,
that fossil fuel activities are not in green taxonomies with exception in the Chinese taxonomy.
This possibility to use the taxonomy as a way to reduce transition risk has been already
taken into account by the European financial regulators. This is the article 501A of the
proposal for amending the capital requirement regulation, which proposes to lower capital
requirements applicable to certain types of projects that would prove that they contribute
to one of the objectives of the EU green taxonomy. So consequently, lending to green
activities would be less expensive. This is what is called the carbon shadow pricing,
which then could set a complement or an alternative to carbon markets, which is
specifically important given the debt systems are at the moment at the core of the response
to the economic crisis provoked by the coronavirus. Thanks.