I China Insights

China Insights
283 followers
118 Video Views·Jun 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome to See the World with Vivi. Hello everyone.
In CCP propaganda, Zhou Enlai and his wife Deng Yingchao portrayed his lifelong revolutionary
partners. But in reality, Deng was merely a political partner-in-tool chosen by Zhou.
His emotional life wasn't as pure as the CCP claims.
Today, we'll uncover this hidden history and talk about three people who held a place in
Many have heard that Zhou Enlai was gay, but in fact, he may have been bisexual.
The claim that Zhou was gay mainly comes from disclosures by Cui Wing-Mui,
former editor of Hong Kong's Open Magazine, in her book.
Between 1913 and 1917, Zhou Enlai studied at Nankai Middle School in Tianjin.
Cui Wing-Mui reveals in her book that a young,
naive Zhou Enlai developed special feelings for his junior, Li Fujing, during this time.
Cui believed this was a homosexual complex.
Back then at Nankai Middle School, they were almost inseparable.
In Zhou's diary, he often used nicknames like Dear Friend and Brother Hui for Li Fujing.
Zhou's Nankai classmates also said he was extremely averse to women at that time.
In school plays, he often played female roles, and he did so with remarkable vividness.
After graduation, Zhou went to study in Japan.
In his diary there, he repeatedly expressed a dislike for heterosexual marriage.
For example, on February 9, 1918, he wrote,
I think in life, love is one thing, and marriage is another.
Love is born of emotion, regardless of gender or species.
If one side shows affection and the other responds, that's love.
So even horses and dogs can show gratitude and affection.
As for marriage, that union is purely for starting a family and continuing the human race.
Zhou Enlai hoped that Li Fujing would also go to Japan after graduating from middle school.
In August 1918, when Zhou learned Li had been accepted to Hong Kong University,
he was devastated.
His diary became erratic, with brief, sorrowful entries like,
In the evening breeze or by the rainy window, I miss home and my brother Hui. It's unbearable.
The moonlit night is desolate, just like old times.
Recalling the past, my heart is filled with grief.
These are clearly the words of someone missing a lover.
Afterward, Zhou failed two exams for government-funded study.
He no longer had the heart to stay in Japan.
In early 1919, he returned to Tianjin to attend the newly founded Nankai University.
Han Suyin, a writer who greatly admired Zhou,
wrote in her book about his early relationship with Deng.
At that time, he seemed to be in love with another girl,
whose name was carefully kept secret.
This girl whose name was kept secret was Zhang Rumin.
Zhang Rumin could be described as a lady from a wealthy family.
Her grandfather was the richest man in the area, and her father was a county magistrate.
Coming from a wealthy background, she received a good education early on.
At 14, Zhang Rumin was admitted to the Tianjin Zhili First Women's Normal School,
where she became classmates with Deng Yingchao, who was a few years younger.
She was quite well-known at school, not only for her outstanding looks,
but also as a top student and a talented writer, often publishing works in the school journal.
After the May 4 Movement broke out, Zhou Enlai, Zhang Rumin,
and Deng Yingchao were all swept up in the movement.
It was at this time that their lives began to intersect.
On September 16, 1919, under the leadership of Zhou Enlai,
20 radical youths, including Zhang Rumin and Deng Yingchao,
founded the Awakening Society in an office of the Tianjin Students' Union
and invited Li Dazhou to give a speech.
Zhang Rumin's parents strongly disliked her passion for such movements
and repeatedly urged her to focus on her studies at school.
Instead of listening, Zhang Rumin became even more active,
even joining Zhou Enlai to protest the Tianjin Police Department's
closure of the Students' Union, which led to her being in prison for six months.
In a fit of rage, Zhang's father published a notice in the newspaper severing ties with her.
In prison, Zhang Rumin and Zhou Enlai became close friends,
building a bond of trust and even sharing secrets with each other.
To prepare for the worst, Zhou Enlai gave two of his manuscripts,
Celibacy and My Confession, to Zhang Rumin, while she gave her prison diary to him.
Zhou Enlai's commitment to celibacy at the time
was not unrelated to his feelings for his junior fellow student.
After being released from prison, Zhou Enlai and others went to Beijing to find Li Dazhou
to seek his advice on the future of the youth movement.
Li Dazhou suggested that Zhou Enlai go to Europe to study.
At that time, Zhou Enlai's junior, Li Fujing,
had already studied civil engineering at the University of Hong Kong for a year.
Because Zhou Enlai was going to Europe, he gave up his degree and went with him,
though he later went to the UK to study civil engineering.
He returned home in 1925 after finishing his studies,
while Zhang Rumin also resolutely applied for the French preparatory
class at Bowding Uday Middle School.
Upon learning that Zhang Rumin was going to study in France, her father was firmly opposed.
He forcibly took his daughter home, wanting to marry her off as quickly as possible.
Zhang Rumin left behind a final letter and
escaped from home by jumping out of a window under the cover of night.
On November 7, 1920, Zhou Enlai and others, as part of the 15th group of students going to France,
197 in total, boarded the French liner Porthos for the long voyage to Europe.
Zhang Rumin was on the same ship,
having been hired as a special correspondent in France for the Beijing Morning Post.
After arriving in France, Zhou Enlai wrote to friends at the Nankai Awakening Society,
saying that when he first arrived in Europe in late 1920,
he still had some reservations about radicalism.
By the fall of 1921, he was determined to follow communism.
In Paris, he joined the Socialist Youth League.
The Comintern sent people to guide foreign students in studying Marxism
and the International Communist Revolution, and also provided financial support.
Zhou Enlai's English was good,
allowing him to communicate directly with Comintern representatives,
so his status in the Youth League grew.
The Comintern began training Youth League members on how to engage in struggle.
In September 1921, Chinese students in France illegally occupied the University of Lyon.
Many were arrested by French police, and 104 students,
including Kai Hessen, Li Lisan, and Chen Yi, were forcibly deported.
Meanwhile, Zhou Enlai, who stayed behind the scenes, managed to escape.
The following year, the Chinese Youth Communist Party in Europe was founded in Paris.
Both Zhou Enlai and Zhang Ruming were members.
Due to her excellent French, Zhang Ruming could read Marx and Engels.
She often led study groups and published articles in their official journals.
The relationship between Zhou and Zhang became very close at this time,
and they even lived together.
During this period, Zhou Enlai stayed in various European cities
due to Comintern intelligence ties,
while Deng Yingchao was running the Women's Daily in China.
Zhang Ruming also actively contributed articles to it.
Deng Yingchao also never stopped corresponding with Zhou Enlai.
In 1924, Zhang Ruming was secretly investigated by French police
for speaking at a Lenin memorial event and was nearly deported by the authorities.
At the same time, due to her wealthy family background,
the CCP also subjected her to strict scrutiny.
Zhang Ruming felt very confused by this
and finally decided to distance herself from politics and focus on academia.
She withdrew from the Youth Communist Party
and moved into a Catholic women's dormitory.
With the support of a Chinese widow, she continued her studies in France alone.
In 1927, Zhang Ruming was admitted to the University of Lyon
with honors and a full scholarship.
Her doctoral thesis was a study of the most famous French writer of the time,
André Gide.
Zhang Ruming's desire to stay away from politics
might have been related to Gide's ideas.
Like all left-wing intellectuals,
Gide once had high hopes for the Soviet Communists
and even participated in French Communist Party activities.
But after returning from the Soviet Union,
he found that the Soviet Communist Party was not the world he longed for.
At that time, for security reasons,
Zhang Enlai had already returned to China.
When news of Zhang Ruming leaving the party reached China,
Zhou Enlai was deeply shocked.
Years later, Zhang Enlai told his niece that
after she announced her withdrawal from the party,
it helped him make up his mind to end their relationship.
When Zhou Enlai broke up with Zhang Ruming
and wrote to Deng Yingchao to express his love,
Deng was very surprised and wrote back asking,
What about Ruming?
Why haven't you mentioned sister Ruoming in your recent letters?
CCP history expert Sima Liu,
summarizing the love triangle between Zhou Enlai,
Zhang Ruming and Deng Yingchao,
said Deng was initially at a disadvantage
because she stayed in China to build her own political status.
While Zhou Enlai and Zhang Ruming were deeply in love in Paris,
cooperation between the nationalists and communists
was brewing back in China.
Deng Yingchao was a publicly active female communist.
She served as the head of the women's department in Tianjin
and later as a committee member
in women's department head in Guangdong.
After Sun Yat-sen passed away,
Soviet advisor Mikhail Borodin
became the de facto power behind the Nationalist Party.
Deng Yingchao was very close to Borodin and his wife,
which made her well acquainted with the top figures
of the Nationalist Party.
Returning to China,
he became Wampoo Military Academy's
deputy political director at the end of 1924.
Deng Yingchao was a woman who wielded influence
over Borodin from behind the scenes.
Zhou Enlai recognized Xiao Qiao's power
and finally gave up his celibacy
to officially marry Deng Yingchao.
Afterward,
Zhou's steady rise within the Nationalist Party,
even winning Chiang Kai-shek's trust,
was all thanks to Deng Yingchao's
behind-the-scenes groundwork.
In the 2nd Central Committee of the Nationalist Party,
Deng was elected as an alternate member,
ranking ahead of veterans like He Yingchen.
At that time,
Zhou Enlai was a nobody.
So his decision to leave Zhang Rumin
and marry Deng Yingchao
was purely a political marriage.
It's worth noting that,
well,
Zhou Enlai wanted to carry on his family line,
but he did too many bad things
and was destined to have no heirs.
They actually had two children at one point.
Deng Yingchao took it upon herself
to abort the first child.
Zhou Enlai was fierce when he found out,
shouting,
why didn't you consult me?
The second child was a 10-pound boy,
but he was severely injured by forceps
during delivery and died shortly after.
In the spring of 1930,
in a small café in Lyon, France,
under dim candlelight,
Zhou Enlai met Zhang Rumin,
disguised as a young businessman in a suit.
He had specifically detoured through France
to see her
while on his way to a meeting in Moscow.
Zhou Enlai told Zhang
that he had already married Deng Yingchao
back in 1925.
Looking at her former lover
with whom she once shared such glory,
Zhang Rumin's eyes filled with tears
and she was overcome with emotion.
Zhang Rumin never could have imagined
that this handsome man before her
would soon personally plan and participate
in the massacre of Zhiyu Shenzhen's entire family.
Before leaving,
Zhou Enlai told Zhang Rumin
that although she had left the party,
she must protect its secrets with her life.
Zhang Rumin promised
to keep revolutionary secrets for life.
She probably didn't realize
what that promise would eventually mean
for her.
Was she, in some mysterious way,
signing another life-and-death pact
with the devil?
On May 31, 1930,
Zhang Rumin married Yang Kun,
a folklore scholar pursuing his doctorate
at the University of Lyon.
They agreed to stay out of politics for life
and focus on academic research.
In 1931,
China's first Ph.D. couple,
Zhang Rumin and Yang Kun,
returned to Beiping.
Zhang Rumin was hired as a professor
at the College of Liberal Arts
of Beiping's Sino-French University.
In 1948,
Yang Kun followed Wu Wenzhou's advice.
He felt Yunnan was a multi-ethnic province,
and to study ethnology,
it was best to go there.
So the couple went to work
at Yunnan University.
During this time,
Zhang Rumin kept her promise to Zhou Enlai
and never revealed her former identity.
Unexpectedly,
the CCP soon seized power
and established its regime.
Starting in 1950,
Zhang Rumin began asking
to rejoin the party.
Little did she know,
her 1924 withdrawal
had become an indelible stain
in the eyes of the CCP.
Even as her applications grew longer and longer,
she failed to gain the trust
of the party organization.
Zhang Rumin remained a primary target
for struggle sessions
throughout various political movements.
On April 8, 1955,
on his way to Indonesia
for the Afro-Asian Conference,
Zhou Enlai made a special stop
in Kunming, Yunnan.
He was accompanied by Chen Yi
and others at the time.
Zhang Rumin and Yang Kun
were granted an audience with Zhou Enlai.
Zhang Rumin reported to Zhou Enlai
that she was actively trying
to align herself with the party.
She spoke with some excitement
about her time in France.
Suddenly, Zhou Enlai interrupted her,
saying,
back then,
you joined the Youth League,
not the party.
Zhang Rumin was stunned.
30 years ago,
she had clearly joined the party
in the presence of her sponsor,
Zhou Enlai.
Looking back on this years later,
Zhou Enlai solved the mystery
during a conversation with Chen Yi.
Leaving the League
is a lesser mistake
than leaving the party.
It seems Zhou Enlai
still harbored some personal concern
for Zhang Rumin.
This meeting would be the last time
they ever saw each other.
How could Zhang Rumin have known
that Zhou Enlai
was originally headed to Indonesia,
but his intended flight
had been targeted with a time bomb?
Zhou changed his plans
at the last minute
and went to Kunming.
But he let the delegation staff
board his plan
to deceive the enemy
and ensure his own safety.
This decision resulted
in the deaths of 11 people,
including his subordinates
and foreign journalists.
During that time,
Zhang Rumin was almost obsessed
with the idea of joining the party.
In 1957,
her son, Yang Zidelle,
expressed some differing political views
in a letter home.
She actually turned the letter over
to the organization,
asking them to help educate her son
as a show of her loyalty.
As a result,
her son was labeled a rightist
and imprisoned in a labor camp
for 22 years.
Zhang Rumin and her husband
were not spared either.
They were also labeled as rightists.
Zhang Rumin's loyalty
was met with prolonged struggle sessions
against her at Yunnan University.
In her despair,
Zhang Rumin thought of Zhou Enlai.
In fact,
two months after meeting Zhou in Yunnan,
Zhang Rumin received a letter
from the State Council
inviting her to Beijing
to work as a foreign language secretary
for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs
and as a French translator
for the Women's Federation.
But Zhang devoted herself
to academia for years
and declined diplomatic work.
Zhang Rumin sent a letter
to Zhou Enlai through someone,
but she never received a reply.
On the morning of June 18, 1958,
the Chinese Department of Yunnan University
held another struggle session
demanding Zhang Rumin
explain her traitorous experience
of leaving the party in 1924.
Unable to bear the humiliation,
Zhang Rumin jumped
from the Panlong River railway bridge
during the lunch break
of the struggle session.
It's said that
when she was pulled ashore,
she was still breathing.
But because of her status
as a key rightist,
people didn't dare to rescue her.
Zhang Ruming lingered
for an hour or two
in a dying state
before finally passing away.
She was 56 years old.
On June 24,
Zhang's husband, Yang Kun,
returned from a meeting in Beijing.
Upon hearing of Zhang Rumin's suicide,
he immediately stated
that she was a traitor
and deserved to die.
This was the life of Zhang Rumen,
Zhou Enlai's first love.
Well, that's all
for today's history story.
See you next time.
