Life Beyond Earth Nears Proof - Black Holes, Time, Aliens | Brian Cox Full Interview

Truth exists
11 followers
#Mysteries #UnsolvedMysteries #TruthExists #LifeBeyondEarth #BlackHoles #Time #Aliens #BrianCox #FullInterview
AI Generated·May contain errors
Is there life beyond earth? Finding it is something that might happen in the next few years.
The laws of nature, the basic fundamental laws of nature, don't care which way you run time.
So if you throw the book into a black hole, is that information somehow imprinted in the Hawking
radiation? When the black hole's gone, Stephen Hawking's calculation said no, information less.
And the current consensus now is that the information comes out again.
Life beyond earth, the secrets of black holes and 13.8 billion years of cosmic history.
Professor Brian Cox joins our show This Is World to reveal where we're hunting for microbes today,
why information from black holes isn't lost, and how quantum computers are set to transform physics.
Is there any question that nobody asks you, but you would like to answer?
It's a good question. I've probably been asked almost all of the questions in my time. I mean,
the common ones are, you know, I think the best questions are, how do we know? Because,
you know, right at the start of the live show, I will say things like the universe is 13.8 billion
years old. There are something like 2 trillion galaxies in the observable universe. And also,
I make an argument about life in the universe, which is a guess because there are quite a lot
of things we don't know. So I think the best kind of questions are questions such as, well,
how do you find out how old the universe is? I mean, I often say to the audience,
if you think about it, if you pick up a rock from a beach, how do you know how old it is?
It's difficult. It takes a lot. Basically, we have to know a lot of nuclear physics. We have
to have a lot of equipment in order to work out how old something is that we hold in our hands.
So how do you know? And so I think those are the best questions. And I answer some of them.
There are two kinds of questions in science. There are the ones that you think you might
get an answer to in your lifetime, and there are ones that you don't. So I think a very
important question is, is there life beyond Earth? Now, of course, most people would say,
well, there has to be because the universe is so vast and so old and there are so many stars.
But actually, finding it is something that might happen in the next few years,
let's say the next decade or two. Because we have space missions out there, we have
a mission called Mars Sample Return, which is based on the Perseverance rover's samples that
it has now collected on the surface of Mars. And we want to get them back to Earth to see if there's
any traces that life may have existed or may still exist. There are two missions, one on the way and
one about to launch to Jupiter's moon Europa, which are missions aimed at trying to find out
whether that place is potentially a home for life. So I think the question, it's one of the
big questions, are we alone in the universe? Of course, you can never say, yes, we're alone.
But we might be able to say definitively, no, there is life beyond Earth in the next decade or
so. I would say, by the way, that if we find life elsewhere in the solar system, it will be at best
microbes. We're pretty sure of that. In our galaxy? The galaxy. I mean, in the show,
I asked that question because it's an important one. How many civilisations are there
in a typical galaxy? And of course, the answer is we don't know. However, we can make some
guess. And so I make my own guess in the show. And I justify why I come to this conclusion.
My conclusion is there might be very few intelligent civilisations in a galaxy.
I asked a great friend of mine, actually, Sean Carroll, who you might know, the author and
cosmologist, how many, what do you think, how many, on average, how many civilisations are
there in a typical galaxy? And he said, none, on the average. But do you believe that we ever
find bacteria in our galaxy? I would not be surprised at all. And this is part of the
life show. So I say, well, what do we know? What evidence do we have? How can we speculate about
these things? Well, we know we have good evidence that life was present on Earth around 3.8 billion
years ago, which is interesting in itself, because that's pretty close to the age of the Earth.
So on this planet, as soon as the Earth had formed four and a half billion years ago,
it cooled down, the oceans formed on the surface. Not so long after that,
we have evidence that life was present. So that's the observation that we have.
So that might suggest that if you have the right conditions, geological conditions,
then I say that what kind of a thing is the origin of life? It's a transition from geochemistry to
biochemistry. Whatever it is, you have a geologically active world, and then you
have a biologically active world. So given the right geology, perhaps it's not so unlikely that
life begins. That's what you can say from the evidence on Earth. It could be we're very,
very lucky on this planet, but let's say that given the right geology. So the strategy for
looking for life beyond Earth in the solar system is based on that idea, that if you go to places
where there was or still is liquid water, and you go to places where there's geological activity,
and you go to places where the right chemistry, we think, exists. And so that would be Mars in
the past, perhaps Jupiter's moon Europa now, perhaps Saturn's moon Enceladus now, perhaps
other moons of Jupiter or Saturn. So that's the strategy. You go to the places where the geology
looks right, and the chemistry looks right, and look. And that's all we can do ultimately.
So I wouldn't be surprised, to answer your question, if we find some kind of life on those
moons or perhaps subsurface on Mars. I would be extremely surprised if it was complex life,
by which I mean multicellular life. And that's based on the fact that we have no evidence of
multicellular life on Earth, back further than let's say a billion years at most,
actually maybe six or seven hundred million. So the evidence from Earth is that life remains simple
for something like three billion years. And that's why most biologists will say that whilst
microbes might be common in the solar system, complex life, it would be very surprising indeed
if we found that. How do you define the term time? Absolutely superb question. The answer
is that this is a current area of research. We don't know what time is. So in Einstein's theory
of relativity, which is our best theory of space and time, we have a picture of space and time
woven together into what's often called the fabric of the universe. It's called space-time.
And there's a notion of distances on that surface. And they're measured by clocks.
So a clock is measuring, let's say you have a perfect stopwatch that you start the moment
you're born and you keep it with you for your whole life and you look at it now,
then that's measured your age. It's also, in Einstein's theory, measured the distance you
have travelled over space-time during your life. That's fine, but it assumes there's such a thing
as a clock. So the age of the universe, by the way, is defined as the time that would be measured
on a freely falling clock that had started ticking at the Big Bang and you had a look at it now. So
a clock that just falls freely through the universe. But it still doesn't say what time is.
So you will see discussions in the textbooks and online about something called the thermodynamic
arrow of time. So it is true to say that, for example, the laws of nature, the basic fundamental
laws of nature, don't care which way you run time. So basically, if you know everything about some
system at some point in time, then the laws of nature will allow you to run that forwards to
see what it's going to be doing in the future. Or they will allow you to run it backwards to
see what it would be doing in the past. So it's completely symmetric. But of course, there is a
notion of past, present and future. It's complex, actually, in relativity to define what that is,
but we feel it. We think the future is yet to come and the past has happened. So we do know
that that asymmetry has a great deal to do with the presence of this unusual thing in the past
called the Big Bang, which was very highly ordered. Technically, you say it's a low entropy.
And we have this idea of this thing called the second law of thermodynamics, which
tells us that entropy always increases. And so the future is in the direction of entropy increasing,
right? So things are getting more disordered. So that's an idea of time. It's called the
thermodynamic arrow of time. But when you get into what a clock is and what it's measuring,
you could go now online and you'll find a lot of research papers, interesting fields of research,
such as what's the minimum clock you can make. You'll find, actually, that there are papers,
I read one last week, which was a clock made of three atoms, basically. And the ticking of the
clock is associated with light being emitted from the atoms as electrons jump around in the
energy levels. You do need what's called a hot reservoir and a cold reservoir for that to work.
So a clock is a thermodynamic machine. It's like a steam engine, right? So one way of thinking
about clocks is that they measure the flow of entropy and so on. So the reason I say all this
is it's quite technical language. I mean, it's well-defined as the time measured on a clock
that's been freely flowing through the universe. Another way to look at this question, though,
is, so we say how old the universe is. The measurement we have is the time on that clock
from the Big Bang to now, which is the time from when the universe was hot and dense
to the present day. Now, our best theory of how the universe came to be the way that it is
is a theory called inflation, which has space-time being present before the universe was
hot and dense. So before the Big Bang, in that sense. We call the Big Bang the hot Big Bang now
for that reason. And then you get into questions about, well, what does it mean for the universe
to have a beginning? For that, we need to understand what time is. And there are other
theories, so-called quantum theories of gravity, which are being developed now, particularly,
actually, in response to research into black holes, which are suggesting that space and time
themselves emerge from a deeper theory that doesn't have space and time in it. These are theories
called emergent space-time theories. And so you need to know. Ultimately, my view is we need to
know what space and time are before we can talk with confidence, even begin to answer the question,
did the universe have an origin? Because we don't actually know what a beginning is
in a universe without space and time. So, you know, these are great questions.
Do you believe that we can see the light that has been traveling to us from before Big Bang?
No. So the oldest light in the universe, we know we've captured that. It's called the cosmic
microwave background radiation. So that was emitted 380,000 years after the Big Bang.
We know that because before that time, the universe was so hot that it was in what's
called a plasma state. So it's primarily hydrogen and helium gas. But if you go back beyond 380,000
years, so earlier than that, then the universe was so hot that atoms couldn't form. So you have
hydrogen and helium nuclei and electrons all over the place in kind of like a soup.
And that's opaque to light. Light can't travel through it. So you can't use light to see further
back in time than 380,000 years after the Big Bang. But we have a beautiful photograph of that
light. The most recent is taken by a satellite called Planck. And it's a remarkable image.
And it's an image of the universe as it was at that time. But further back than that,
you need to do something else. You need to use the neutrinos or gravitational waves potentially.
So our universe is expanding. And that's a discovery that was, it was actually,
believe it or not, not quite a prediction, but it was thought to be likely shortly after
Einstein's theory of gravity was published in 1915. So the idea that the universe can stretch
or shrink, the fabric, imagine space stretching or shrinking, was noticed theoretically. And then
in the late 1920s, Edwin Hubble, the American astronomer, demonstrated that indeed, if you
look at distant galaxies, they're all moving away from each other and from us. And through those
measurements, that's essentially what we feed into Einstein's theory to calculate the age of
the universe. So we can measure how it's expanded and how the expansion rate changes over time.
And so that's been known since the 1920s. So the universe is expanding and cooling.
And that's the way that it is. It's actually accelerating in its expansion.
Do you believe that the Rosen-Einstein bridges or wormholes let us ever travel around the galaxies?
Well, so it's an interesting question again. So the idea, by the way, the Einstein-Rosen bridge,
wormhole, that comes from a paper in the mid 1930s from Einstein and Rosen. And it's a property
of the space-time, which a man called Karl Schwarzschild discovered actually way back in 1916.
And it's if you have an eternal black hole, an eternal universe, so a black hole that's always
existed, then you have this formally, this mathematical solution, which is a black hole
and a white hole and a wormhole connecting them. And it turns out you can't go through it because
of the way the wormhole evolves as you fall in. But you can imagine those geometries,
those so-called wormhole geometries in relativity. Now you need, in order to construct stable ones
that you could travel through, you need forms of energy or matter that we don't think exist in the
universe. So you can read this. It's a great book actually from a long time ago by Kip Thorne on
I think it's called Black Holes, Time Warps and Time Machines or something like that. It's a great
book by Kip. And in there you'll see a discussion. And so the guess, it's not been proved beyond
doubt, but the guess is that nature will not produce stable wormholes that you can travel
through as an astronaut or with a spaceship or so on. So that's where we are at the moment. There
are good reasons for thinking that whilst they can exist theoretically, then stable ones that
you could go through will not exist. But it's not been proved conclusively from first principles.
I should say that there are different kinds of wormholes. So there's a, in the study of black
holes at the moment, the really cutting edge study of black holes, there is some kind of suggestion
that a sort of wormhole might be present and might play a role in solving something called
the black hole information paradox. And so there's an idea that you can kind of, and I keep using
these caveats because they're not, it's complicated, but you can sort of imagine the singularity in the
black holes. I remember one of your lecture about the information paradox that we can burn the book
and the atoms left, and then we can reconnect atoms to recreate the books.
As far as we understand the laws of nature, then in principle, you could set fire to a book and
you could, you could burn it. And if you could perfectly collect everything, the light and the
heat and the atom, everything that comes off the book, all the photons, all the bits of smoke,
and you could measure it all perfectly. And in principle, you could reconstruct the book.
So obviously in practice, you can't, but in principle you can. Now the big, the wonderful
argument triggered by Stephen Hawking's work initially in the 1970s about black holes
is, is that true of a black hole? So if you throw the book into a black hole,
then is it, does the information somehow get stored? Does it ultimately get returned to the
universe because black holes have a lifetime? We now know, so they ultimately evaporate away
due to this process Stephen Hawking discovered called Hawking radiation.
So ultimately the question is, is that information somehow imprinted in the Hawking radiation?
When, when, when the black hole's gone and all there is, is this radiation that's been
emitted from it? And the, the initially, the great paradox was initially Stephen Hawking's
calculation said, no, it isn't in the radiation. The information is featureless, information less.
It will not contain information. So it meant that whatever goes in essentially gets completely,
not only completely scrambled up, but erased. That was the calculation, right? Stephen Hawking.
Now we've spent by we, I mean, hundreds, thousands of physicists have spent 50 years
trying to understand what actually happened. And the current consensus now is that the information
comes out again. So ultimately in a very scrambled sense, it is imprinted in the radiation.
And so then you get really interesting questions like, well, how? Because, because the radiation,
that comes, first of all, Stephen Hawking's calculation said it doesn't, right? So there's
something wrong with the calculation. And secondly, the way it's produced, the interesting
thing about Hawking radiation is that how does it, you have to think just a step back, a black hole
in Einstein's theory is described as pure space-time, right? It's just space-time geometry.
This radiation is coming from what's called the event horizon of the black hole,
which is just space. So it's almost as if a way to think about it is the black hole is kind of
shaking or tearing this radiation out of the vacuum of space. It's coming from the vacuum.
It's not coming from the thing that fell in, right? So the question is, if something goes in
and then all, and then this black hole disappears and all the radiation has come from something to
do with the event horizon and the vacuum of space, how can it be that this thing that fell
in gets imprinted in it? And that's where the recent calculations, I mean, very recent in the
last few years have suggested the information comes out. And then the way it comes out,
this is active research. But as I mentioned earlier, one picture, which is very speculative
is that some kind of wormholes, some sort of wormholes, not the Einstein roads and bridges,
by the way, some other kind, kind of open up from the interior of the black hole to the exterior.
And somehow the information comes out through wormholes, but that's very, very a speculative
interpretation of some difficult mathematics. And there's no consensus on that. It's very exciting
because what it's doing, what it's actually doing is it's showing us a glimpse of a deeper theory
of space and time. On that, I think most physicists agree, but what we're glimpsing,
I don't think most physicists agree on. Do you believe that we will ever connect quantum physics
and classical physics? Yes, I do. I mean, even now, you know, there are several questions in
there. One is just how quantum mechanics produces a world, the world that we see,
which doesn't appear to us to have quantum-like properties. Things can't be in several places at
once, for example. And we're beginning, I think, to get a good understanding of that.
I think the consensus would be that the world is described at its base level by quantum theory.
But another question, which we're also making progress on, is there's an idea called the
holographic principle, which is related to the idea that you can represent space and time
themselves as a quantum theory, an entangled quantum theory. If you want to look things up
on the web, there's something called ADS-CFT, which is a very famous conjecture theorem
discovered by a physicist called Juan Maldacena a long time ago.
So there are windows, I think, into this possibility. I think most physicists in the
area would agree with it. The base level of reality looks to me, and virtually everybody
else does, like quantum mechanics, a quantum theory of some description. And out of that,
the challenge is to decide, and we don't know how this works yet, as you said, to decide exactly how
the reality that we perceive emerges from the deepest theory. But I'd be surprised,
there are very few people now, I think, who think that the deep theory is not quantum mechanics.
It's interesting that very precise questions in the study of black holes have led to
our leading us down these interesting paths. That's one example. So the reason black holes
are interesting, there's lots of reasons, they're interesting things, but one of them is you can
pose very simple questions about how information behaves, quantum information, questions about
quantum entanglement, which we can also study, of course, we're studying in laboratories around
the world. So we're building quantum computers, which are also giving us a deeper insight into
this theory and how it behaves in practice. So I think we're on the verge of a real
leap in our understanding of what quantum theory is, and what it implies for the way that the
world works. A quantum computer is a great example. These are real things, they're physical
things that we can program them to do useful things. You can go on the web and use a quantum
computer as a subroutine in your computer program. But those things are operating purely according
to the laws of quantum mechanics. These ideas about, for example, quantum entanglement, which
if you go back a few decades, were purely theoretical, are now experimental. They're
not only experimental, it's engineering now, because we're building systems,
quantum computers, that rely on it to work.
