As America prepares to celebrate 250 years since its founding, Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with bestselling author and historian Bill Federer to ask one of the biggest questions in American history: Was the hand of God involved in the founding of the United States? And does He still bless this nation after 250 years? Federer, co-author of Miracles in American History, explores the role of divine providence in the American Revolution, the survival of George Washington, the winter at Valley Forge, the faith of the Founding Fathers, religious freedom in early America, and the biblical ideas that shaped the nation’s founding.
Shabbos and Bill discuss:
• George Washington surviving bullets, dead horses, and impossible odds • Whether America’s founding can be understood without divine providence • The miracle stories behind the American Revolution • Valley Forge, prayer, and the faith of the Founders • Ben Franklin, the Constitution, and public prayer • The Jewish role in America’s founding and Washington’s letter to the Newport synagogue • Whether the United States was founded as a Christian nation • How Jews and Christians understand miracles, free will, and God’s role in history Was America founded by chance, courage, or the hand of God? Bill Federer makes the case that the story of the United States cannot be told without talking about providence.
Bill Federer explores the intersection of divine providence, human free will, and American history. He argues that the United States was established through a combination of human effort and miraculous divine interventions, rooted in a biblical worldview that emphasizes human accountability to God and the necessity of faith for a genuine relationship with the Creator.
He had four bullet holes through his coat and two horses shot out from under him,
but he escaped unhurt. And he gives credit to the providence of God.
You quite literally wrote the book on miracles in American history.
What would you say is the most important miracle that helped establish the United States?
The Battle of Cowpens. Three rivers in 10 days rise to stop the British from being
able to chase the Americans. And then there's the Battle of Brooklyn.
Washington's pinned up against the water with these 10,000 troops behind him.
A very dense fog began to rise off the river and settle in a peculiar manner.
The fog lifts, the British charge, no one's there.
After every victory, Washington would thank God.
Even Ben Franklin calls for prayer. And he says,
Have we forgot so great a friend? Do we imagine we no longer need his aid?
How do we understand the role of God's intervention in our lives today?
Well, happy Independence Day. As we celebrate America 250,
it's great to have Bill Federer, noted bestselling author and speaker,
and Christian evangelical. So Bill, thank you so much for coming on the show.
It's great to be with you.
You quite literally wrote the book on miracles in American history.
With my wife.
With your wife. And I think it's no greater time than now to discuss not just the miracles that
established our country, but the role of miracles and divine providence, divine intervention,
broadly speaking. And so I kind of want to set the stage as follows. In Judaism,
there's two dissenting views, essentially the Maimonidean rationalist perspective,
and then the more, dare I say, esoteric, esoteric Nachmanides perspective.
And so one perspective is that there is not a single blade of grass that does not grow without
a ministering angel commanding it to grow, i.e. God is overseeing anything and everything.
Everything is happening for a reason all the time to everyone, everywhere.
And then you have another approach that certainly says that there are miracles,
certainly in the Hebrew Bible, but we try to rationalize those miracles.
We try to limit the frequency of those miracles, because in Hebrew,
we have a term, literally meaning effort, as in, if you take the approach of, you know,
Jesus, take the wheel on the highway, you will crash and die.
So we believe you have physical effort and you shouldn't rely on the miracle
that much. You should toil in this physical world instead.
And so I'm just curious, what is the evangelical approach when we talk about God's role
in this world? We had a guest before you who spoke about intelligent design,
and that shows that there is a creator, there's someone who initiated this world,
but that in no way answers the question, okay, after that creator created the world,
what did he do after? So how involved is God in America today?
You know, Jonathan Trumbull was the colonial governor of Connecticut during the revolution,
and he wrote to George Washington. But he said,
without giving our utmost exertion would be tempting providence.
So we trust God, but we give our utmost exertion. So it is, you know, in the Christian tradition,
you have Calvinism, which leans toward God having it all planned, and Arminianism,
which means more of a free will. I sort of like to look at big picture stuff.
So the Hubble telescope was launched, and then I think around 2003, they focused it on a spot in
the sky where there was nothing. It was a tiny spot the size of a grain of sand held between
your fingers at arm's length against the night sky. Imagine that, the size of a grain of sand,
arm's length, nothing there. After 11 days, they developed the images. In that tiny spot
was 10,000 galaxies with hundreds of billions of stars in each galaxy. It's called the Hubble
Ultra Deep Space Field. And then with the James Webb telescope, they saw the red shift. So light
travels in waves, blue the shortest, red the longest. The red shift is you're seeing these
galaxies moving away from us. And so they began to look in other directions, and now the general
consensus among astronomers is the universe is 93 billion light years across and still expanding at
the speed of light. And the largest star they found is Stevenson 2-18. It's a super gas giant.
It's so large, if you were to place Stevenson 2-18 in our solar system, it would engulf the orbit of
Saturn, the sixth planet from the sun. We're the third planet. Could you imagine one single star
that enormous? And God made it all, and he made you. Why would he make you? What could we possibly
offer a being that is that incomprehensibly awesome? Nothing, except maybe something. What's
a galaxy anyway? It's a bunch of rocks. Hot rocks, cold rocks, vaporized rocks, molten rocks. A rock
cannot love you. So now it gets interesting. So in the context of everything God controls,
time, matter, space, energy, he intentionally created one tiny thing. He does not control
your will. I mean, he could control it if he wanted to. He's that powerful,
but that would defeat the very reason he made us different than everything else.
And he doesn't need your love. He's not incomplete in your love. He doesn't need your love,
but he wants it. It's like parents don't need the love of their children, but they want it.
And then the more you love somebody, the more you want that somebody to love you back. God loves you
infinitely. He has an infinite desire for you to love him back, but he'll never force you.
Can I just respectfully, not push back, but I just want to understand,
because what you're saying is very similar to cosmologist Stephen Meyer, who addressed a similar
point. But when you talk about free will, we do have a quote in Psalms that from his dwelling
place, he oversees all of the inhabitants of the earth. That's Psalms 33, 14. So it would sort of
seem from a literalist interpretation of the texts themselves, that God's oversight is so
overwhelming that it almost diminishes free will. How do you understand texts like that?
You're made in God's image. And what's the most important thing in your life?
Somewhere near the top of the list, it's loving and being loved.
So if we're made in his image, could it be that loving and being loved is a big deal to God?
So God loves everything he created. But the question is, could what he created love him
back? Galaxies can't love, rocks can't love, electrons can't love, animals follow instinct,
and they're not made in God's image. If you look up the word angel in the King James Bible,
it appears 296 times. Not one time is the word love used to describe an angel's relationship
with God. They worship God. They praise God. They glorify God. The word angel means messenger.
They're ministering spirits. They deliver God's messages. They deliver God's judgments like in
Egypt. Did you know angels cannot forgive? God told Moses, I'm sending my angel with you into
the promised land, and you better obey him because he is not going to overlook your offenses.
They sang when the stars were created, right? The book of Job. They rejoice when a sinner converts.
Jesus said, I'll confess you before the angels. They're heavenly witnesses. They do not forget
anything. They're powerful. They're incredibly intelligent, but they're not made in God's image.
And Jesus didn't die on the cross for angels. They were made for a purpose. What purpose were
you made for? We're not very smart, and we're not powerful. If you look up in the Bible where it
talks about men and women, the word love is used all throughout the Bible. Love the Lord your God
with all your heart, soul, mind, and strength. Psalms 91, because he said, is love upon me,
therefore I will deliver him. And in the New Testament, Jesus rose from the dead and said,
Peter, do you love me? We are beings unique in creation because we have the ability to love God
back. So, first of all, what you're saying is very similar to a rabbinic exposition founded
what's called Beretius Rabbah, where essentially the idea is when God was creating mankind,
the angels start protesting, saying, well, if you create mankind, you know what they're going to do.
They're going to sin. They're going to commit adultery and idolatry, whereas we angels,
we're perfect. And God said, that's exactly why I want to create mankind, because I want
individuals who, yes, it's true, will stumble and fall, but nevertheless can exercise moral agency
and free will and can ultimately decide to come on to me in a way that angels simply can't.
In fact, the other rabbinic exposition also found in Beretius Rabbah is that angels simply do what
they are told, and once they fulfill that divine mission, their existence ceases to be, because
they were created for one purpose and one purpose only. But what you're suggesting is really
interesting, but it almost presents a theological dilemma. How can we possibly state that we have
free will, which I think we do, but at the same time also acknowledge God knows the choices we're
going to make anyway? Is that true freedom? Yeah, I think so, that he is infinitely
intelligent. He's infinite in wisdom, and he's existed for eternity, and he's eternally just,
and he cannot change his nature. He is eternally just. You know, when the scientific revolution
took place, you had Kepler discovering laws of planetary motion, and Robert Boyle discovering
laws of pressure, and Newton discovering laws of gravity and laws of optics. And then one of the
things we see is God made everything with laws, and he has laws for human behavior. It's called
being just. Abraham's talking to the Lord, and he says, shall not the judge of all the world do
justly? God is just, which means he has to judge every sin. Because if he does not judge a sin,
by default, his silence would be giving consent to the sin. And if God gives consent to one sin
one time, he denies his just nature, he denies himself. So he has to judge every sin.
And since he exists outside of time, if he were to deny himself one time, he would be denying himself
for all time. So he has to judge every sin. So that's a set. In mathematical equations,
there's constants and variables. The constant is God is just. That will never change. The
variable is who takes the judgment, you or a lamb. And so we see Noah's flood. Before the flood,
it says, the thoughts of man were on evil continually. They chose not to retain God in
their thoughts and repent to God that he made man. One translation says it broke God's heart.
He made us for fellowship, and they had structured their lives so they could live centuries and not
even think about God. They didn't even know they were sinners. They didn't even try to seek God.
And so after that, they get the law. And the people are like, oh, we're pretty good. So you
think you're pretty good? Try to keep this for a while, right? And it's like, oh, no,
I've broken all these laws. I need help. Okay. After every law, there is a prescribed sacrifice,
right? An ox, a ram, a lamb, a goat. And the shedding of blood was that the
sacrifice is taking the judgment for us breaking the sin rather than us taking the judgment.
And so the first reiteration of this, or iteration, was Adam and Eve sinned and hid from God.
God still wanted to walk with them in the garden, but they wanted to get away.
And it's like two magnets that are stuck together. One of them turns. The first one wants to touch,
but the second one repels, wants to get away. So it's not so much that God sends people to hell.
It's once people sin against God, their own conscience makes them want to avoid him.
A day, a week, a month, a lifetime. And so Adam and Eve said, we blew it. We have to do something
to make ourselves acceptable to God. They put on fig leaves. That was the beginning of false
religions. Man coming up with man's own idea how to make man acceptable to God. Did the fig leaves
work? Well, no. And then this little line, God made Adam and Eve coats of skins. How do you make
a coat of skin? Something has to die. You think God went to the other side of the garden, killed
an animal, and brought Adam and Eve some nice tailored outfits? Or do you think maybe he killed
the animal right in front of them? And they witnessed the first death ever. And they're
watching this innocent animal go through the pains of dying. And they're like, we're the ones that
sinned, but this innocent animal is the one that's dying. And God wanted to make it really clear the
animal was dying in their place. That right in front of him, he strips the skin off the animal
and he puts it on their naked bodies. Maybe it still had a little blood on it. There's a gospel
song covered in the blood. So Adam and Eve tell Cain and Abel. Cain does an offshoot of the church
of the fig leaf. He starts the church of the fruits and the nuts. Cain's was a religion of
works without a lamp. We know that because God told Adam, the ground is cursed for your sake and
you'll bring forth fruit by the sweat of your brow. Sweat is work. Cain's trying to work his
way. He's coming up with his own idea of how to make himself acceptable to God. Did Cain's works
make him acceptable? No. And if you do works, you're going to be proud of your works because
you're doing more than your brother. And God resists the proud, but he gives grace to the
humble. And so Abel trusted in the lamb. And it's this picture. God is on one side and he is just.
We are on the other side and we have sinned. And the lamb takes the judgment for the sin
instead of us taking the judgment for the sin. And once the judgment is made, we can be reunited
with God. So God is just. He has to judge every sin because if he doesn't judge the sin, by default,
his silence is giving consent to the sin. In law, it's called the rule of tacit admission, T-A-C-I-T.
And it's in number 30. If a daughter's living in her father's house and her youth finds herself
with a vow and the day the father hears that if he's silent, her vows stand. But if he disallows
it, she's released from the vow. That's come down to us as vows in a wedding ceremony. And the
pastor tells the church members, if you're silent when you hear these wedding vows, you're giving
your consent. And it's even in our Constitution. Article 1, section 7. Congress puts a bill on the
president's desk. If any bill should not be returned by the president within 10 days, the same
shall be a law in like manner as if he had signed it. So just be silent for 10 days. Your silence
equals your signature. So this concept of tacit admission, if there are sins and God is not judging
the sin, by default, his silence would be giving consent to the sin. And if God gives consent to
one sin, one time he denies his just nature, he denies himself. And he cannot deny himself. So his
very nature is he has to judge the sin. He can put off the judgment, but he has to judge. So if he
creates free will beings and we step out of line, he still has to judge us. I'm glad you mentioned
the Constitution because that's a really perfect way to ask about how you see this happening in
American history. But just before I do, I want to make sure I understand your point.
To play devil's advocate, maybe I shouldn't say devil in this context, but to play advocate of
the opposing side, the examples you gave in the Hebrew Bible, the Garden of Eden, Cain and Hevel,
if I'm new to religion, I'm growing up in the context of Gen Z in the United States,
I would say, well, those are obvious examples of the divine manifest. As in, if God split the sea
for me today in the 21st century in Tulsa, Oklahoma, of course I would believe in God.
But God isn't doing that thing. So how am I meant to believe? And some people, maybe yourself,
but certainly some preachers in this country would say there are miracles. We might call it nature.
We might just say, well, the sun rising, but that in and of itself is in fact miraculous.
So I guess my question is, is how are we meant to decipher what it is that God wants us to do
based on how he's speaking to us in this world? In Judaism, we have this idea that when we pray,
it is mortal man talking to God. Yet when we interact in this world and when we learn the
Bible, that's God speaking back to us. But how do we decipher that language? So again,
if I put my hand in my pocket and I reach for three coins, how am I actually supposed to
understand what God wants for me? If I miss the bus, how am I supposed to understand what is
the lesson there? Because it's so difficult to decipher and discern. Yeah. I think God is speaking
to us all the time. We just have to listen. I was reading through my daily Bible and then
going through Elijah and Elisha and the sons of the prophet. And they're like,
don't you know that your master Elijah is going to be taken away from you today? And Elisha says,
I know it. I know. It's like, how did they know this? I mean, they were in tune with the spirit
of God in a level that most of us want to be and strive to be, but their potential is there.
And it makes no sense until we realize that God wants a relationship. I believe that He does
have control of everything, but He also wants an interaction with our free will.
So the goal is a relationship. And He is so awesome. People say, why doesn't God just appear
to me? Why doesn't God just make it so clear? If He were to appear to you in all of His universe,
creating omnipotent power, brighter than a trillion, trillion suns, your response,
if you didn't melt, would be like the Apostle John in the book of Revelation. I fell at his
feet. He's dead. It would be an involuntary response. In the presence of all the power
in the universe, it would be an involuntary response. And God's like, I can do involuntary.
I'm interested in this voluntary love response. So He has to hide Himself behind His creation.
And the same hiding of Himself that allows us to have free will necessitates that we have faith.
People say, I wish I knew the future. No, you don't. Because if you knew the future,
you wouldn't pray. You wouldn't seek God. I know it's going to happen. I seek God.
No, He wants, He hides it. So we seek Him. And that's all He's after in the first place. He
wants a relationship with us humans. He doesn't want before the flood where they
go for centuries without thinking about God. I do want to go back to your point on the
Constitution, which brings me to your book, Miracles in American History,
which I happen to have just sitting down. What a weird coincidence.
But as we celebrate America 250, I was really inspired by your central argument, which to me,
however, implicitly was that you cannot talk about the establishment of our great country,
the United States, without talking about the miraculous nature by which we were established.
You can't disregard the open hand of God. And I was just wondering if you can give us some
examples, whether it was George Washington in Valley Forge, whether it was the freak accident
against Andrew Jackson. How do you see the hand of God as manifesting and creating the country that
we know today? Yeah. So Europe, really all the way back to Nimrod, you have kings and the king
is a glorified gang leader and you have to surrender your will to the king's will or you
get burnt at the stake. And so you have the founders leaving the most powerful king in the
world, the king of England. The sun never set on the British Empire. He was a globalist. He was a
one world government guy. And our founders broke away and flipped it and made the people the king.
Interestingly enough, the Puritans look back to the pre-King Saul part of the Bible as their
inspiration. So you have 400 years where the Israelites come out of Egypt with no king. It's
a total anomaly in world history. Millions of people and no king. Israel is the first literate
population. Only 1% of Egypt could read. They had 3000 hieroglyphs. Only 1% could read. Sumeria had
1500 cuneiform characters. Moses comes down the mountain with the law in a 22 character alphabet.
First letter is the left, second letter Beth. Sound familiar? And so ancient Israel was the
first literate population. And so here you have a country with no king. Everybody taught the law
and everybody personally accountable to God to follow it. And that inspired the Puritans because
they break it away from the king of England and they set up a covenant form of government. It's
like a triangle. You get rights from God, you're fair to your neighbor because you're accountable
to God. It's not just getting rid of a king because if it's just us, any one of us could
potentially want to be the next king. So it's the first four commandments that motivate you to keep
the last six commandments. Your awareness of God and I'm accountable to God so therefore I'm going
to treat my neighbor nice and I'm not going to lie and cheat. So this covenant form of government
is based on God expressing his will but instead of his will being top down through a king,
it's bottom up through the people. And so the people are taught the law.
Matter of fact, the first election in America was in a church. It was 1629 in Salem, Massachusetts.
They were having to pick two new pastors and so they had been taught the Bible. This is how you
choose leaders. They hate covetousness. They can't be bribed and so they would fast and pray
and then they would write the name of who they thought was God's elect or God's chosen
and they would pass the name forward and so they called it an election. So God is expressing his
will. Mostly Salem is not given as an example of the intersection of religion and politics in a
positive way but I digress. This is interesting. I've never heard this before. So instead of it
being God's will expressed top down through a king, it's bottom up through the people,
the pilgrims. They come across to America and the first, I'm skipping a whole lot,
but the first winter half of them died and they probably would not have survived.
Well then out of the woods comes this Indian speaking to them in perfect English
and it's like what? So the pilgrims were religiously motivated but others weren't
and you had unfortunate people luring the Indians onto the boat, taking them to Malaga,
Spain, selling them into slavery and so the monks in Spain found out about this and they
got possession of these Indians and one of them was to Squanto or Squanto and they give them
their freedom. Squanto makes his way to England, works there for like a dozen years, finds a
Newfoundland fishing expedition. He agrees to be a translator and he comes across and then finally
they drop him off only to find out that his tribe had been wiped out by a plague. So he's dejected
living with another tribe and it was that winter when the pilgrims come and half of them die and
then this is the next spring when Squanto walks out of the woods and he's like, oh you guys from
London? Yeah I used to live there and it's like oh here I grew up here. I know this place like the
back of my hand and he taught him how to plant corn, how to catch fish, how to make you know
popcorn. I mean all this and William Bradford says that he was a special instrument sent of God for
their good beyond their expectation and so this is a miracle. You know one of the things that really
stood out to me was our founding father George Washington who faced these bullets during the
Indian War. Can you talk a little bit about that? Yeah that's one of the stories in the book my
wife and I did, Miracles in American History. So French Indian War, you have the Battle of Manan
Gehela and Edward Braddock is the commander of the British forces in America and he has a young
colonel named George Washington and matter of fact there was a wagon driver for the British
named Daniel Boone. I mean so but they're going to Pittsburgh, Fort Duquesne and the French and
the Indians ambush them and like 1,500 of the British are killed and George then Braddock is
killed and so George Washington takes command and he's able to get the rest of them you know
to safety and builds a fort necessity but he's writing to his younger brother and he says you
know by the almighty providence of God I was spared. He says first of all I take the opportunity,
I heard that there's a rumor that I gave my last dying speech and he says I haven't died yet.
Sort of like you know Mark Twain the rumors of my death are exaggerated
but then he says that he had four bullet holes through his coat you know and lead bullet fragments
in his hair and two horses shot out from under him but he escaped unhurt and he gives credit
to the providence of God and so the idea was that I give my life to the Lord, my life is in his hands
and he's not going to let me die before it's his will and time for me to die so I'm going to be
bold for him and courageous and then he'll take me home whenever it's his time to take me home.
Let's fast forward 250 years. It is a hot July afternoon in Butler, Pennsylvania
and at the time presidential candidate Donald Trump is giving a speech. He turns his head ever
so slightly to look at a graph on illegal immigration and then shots ring out one
grazes his ear. Can you talk about how you saw God's hand at play during Butler, Pennsylvania?
Yeah you know I believe it was it's God miraculously had him spared not just to help
make America great again but to give us an opportunity to maintain the freedoms we have
in America for the sake of our kids and our grandkids and I thank God for him not being shot
and I look at what's happening in the world and he is pushing back against a lot of the
ungodly agenda that we've all witnessed for the last generation.
Up until this point we've been discussing divine providence in positive ways so saving President
Trump, saving George Washington. What about another example of divine providence but in a very
terrible way and that's of course September 10th where a young podcaster a young political
commentator Charlie Kirk is speaking at Utah Valley and shots ring out and instead of it
grazing his ear instead of being off the mark it it's a direct hit and and he's shot on sight.
How do we understand the role of God in things that are overtly negative?
We have to go back to free will. If God were to stop somebody from doing something bad like
shooting Charlie Kirk in a sense for him to be just he would have to stop everybody from doing
something bad and he'd even have to stop Adam and Eve from eating from the tree
and then we would be naked in the garden more or less robots and God for him to
want to have free will so that people could love him back he had to allow people to choose not
to do his will in order for the choice to do his will to be the choice and if he were to
intervene and stop one person he'd have to intervene and stop all persons for him to be just.
It's a difficult thing that everybody wrestles with but it doesn't make sense unless you look
at it from an eternal perspective that God is desiring us to have a relationship with him
and that whatever purpose we can do during our short time on earth that can point people to him
that is his will that you know there's a verse Romans 8 28 says that he works all together
for the good to those that love the Lord who are called according to his purpose
and that word work means to weave like you're weaving and so sometimes you can see the yarn
above and sometimes you know you can't and because it's weaving in and out but if we trust him and
surrender our lives to him we just have to put it in his hands okay God we've done all that we've
done we've prayed all that we've done but at the end of the day we just have to surrender it all
to you and trust that you're going to have good come out of it and I have seen good come out of
it with lots of young people and churches filling up and people that had never saw his videos before
all of a sudden they start watching his videos so you know and of course the biblical example
for Christianity is it was horrible that Jesus got crucified but he rose from the dead and now
filling the theology angle that he was the lamb that took the judgment so that all of humanity
Jews and Gentiles can have a relationship with God again right that oh sorry go ahead
yeah so they said well the you know that for what there's this one brief period in the history of
Israel Judea where the Jewish leadership did not have the authority to put somebody to death
which means they had to go to the Roman occupying forces to say okay you know so the Romans
participated so you had the both the Jews and the Gentiles help sacrifice the lamb why so that the
forgiveness can go upon both Jews and Gentiles right so and and I tell people you know my
attitude is as Jews don't convert it's Christian it's it's Gentiles that convert to believing in
the Jewish scriptures whatever pagan culture they had they're thrown that away and says we're going
to believe in these Jewish scriptures we believe they're from God and we believe there's prophecies
in there prophesying a messiah and that he's coming he came once he's going to come again
and first time he came as a lamb like the Isaiah 53 that all the iniquity of us all was laid on
him and he's going to come again as a lion and he's going to establish his kingdom on earth and
and get rid of all the the evil and and it'll be a great place yeah amen so if I'm to understand
your theology correctly it's essentially while it is true God will allow a bullet to graze
President Trump's ear other times he will allow a bullet to go straight into you know the the
throat of Charlie Kirk and we may not understand why but as the Jewish expression goes all that
God does is is for the best I do want to quickly go back to American history as we celebrate 250
years I think another incident that I'll be honest I myself did not know was the divine
role at the Battle of Brooklyn can you talk a little bit about that yeah so the British had
the largest military force in the world and they pull it into the New York Harbor 400 ships 32,000
British troops and the British find a loyalist who's somebody that lives in America but they're
to the enemy we know it's hard for us to imagine that type of person but but they show the British
where to land far away from where the Americans were dug in looking at the water and they marched
the 10,000 British troops all night long through Jamaica Pass and they attacked George Washington
from behind on August 27 1776 300 Americans die only 60 British it's the largest battle of the
entire revolution and it's the entire American army and so the sun goes down Washington's pinned
up against the water with these 10,000 troops behind him and the thoughts going through his
mind right well lo and behold like a month earlier is the Continental Congress had a day of fasting
and prayer and well Washington gets this idea to get every boat he can find and ferry the troops
across the East River to Manhattan Island they're doing it quiet in the dark and they're halfway
through and the sun starts coming up and now they're really a sitting duck they don't have
enough troops to fight the British and so his chief of intelligence Major Ben Talmadge says
at this time a very dense fog began to rise off the river and settle in a peculiar manner over
both encampments I recollect this providential occurrence perfectly well and so very dense was
the atmosphere that you could scarcely discern a man at six yards distance we tarried until the sun
had risen but the fog remained as dense as ever Washington's continues moves the troops he's on
the last boat that leaves the fog lifts the British charge no one's there it was the last
chance the British had to capture the entire American army all at once and Washington says
the hand of providence is so conspicuous in the course of the war that he must be worse than an
infidel that lacks faith but it will be time enough for me to turn preacher when my present
appointment ceases and even Ben Franklin at the Constitutional Convention he calls for prayer
he says during our contest with Great Britain we met daily in this room and he says those of us who
were involved must have seen frequent instances of a divine intervention in our behalf divine
interposition and have we forgot so great a friend do we imagine we no longer need his aid I move that
we have prayer open every assembly and and that was Ben Franklin so but then they're in New York
after six months they're pushed all the way across New Jersey and across the Delaware River
into Pennsylvania their troops dwindle from 20,000 to 2,000 and now they have to cross
the Delaware River on Christmas Day evening 1776 and he breaks Washington's the code word is victory
or death breaks his men into three groups two don't make it across because the ice in the river
one makes it across it's a blizzard one of his men freezes to death on the march and the British
were expecting it and one of Washington's detachments does this half-hearted uh raid
at a British outpost and uh and they shoot a couple shots and they leave and when Washington
finds out about this he was all upset at this detachment you just blew our surprise but he he
continues to march well lo and behold John Rall was the Hessian mercenary commander and he had word
that the Americans were up to something and then when they come in they said it was a skirmish and
he's like these Americans can't even plan a decent ambush you know and so he goes back into the house
he's like playing cards and then somebody comes with a note and the the guard won't let him in
the house and he says well write what you write it down so he writes it down and uh and so he gives
it to the guard the guard takes it in and John Rolls there and he's like okay the note surprise
attack has been there already and he gets back to it and then so Washington uh comes as men are
shooting from behind barns and fence posts and the the German Hessians wake up and they're they're
trying to assemble themselves and um because they're taught with European warfare you get in
one square and you shoot a volley and the other side shoots back Americans are shooting from
everywhere and then John Rall gets on his horse but he gets shot and now these 2,000 Hessians don't
know what to do and uh and they end up surrendering and uh so this is a great victory uh that that
took place and that just shot adrenaline into the continental army in the in the whole country that
gee we're able to push back and capture a bunch of British um 10 days later and the British send
Cornwallis uh to Princeton and Washington does the same thing in reverse he has his men uh across the
river uh creek uh bang pots and pans and he moves his entire army around and they attack the British
from behind uh in January of 1777 and um and when the British fire back some of the men start running
away and uh and Washington gets on his horse and rides up to the front and commands his men to stop
running to follow him and he goes within 30 yards of the British he turns and faces his troops and
says fire and they fire past Washington at the British the British fire past Washington a um
American soldier Fitzgerald pulls his hat over his eyes because he didn't want to see Washington shot
when the smoke clears Washington's on his horse waving his hat saying charge and we capture 800
of the British and those 10 days are considered to be some of the most significant in world history
wow I'm really glad you mentioned Ben Franklin because I think there's this misconception
in American political discourse pertaining to the separation of church and state because the
overwhelming majority of the founding fathers were in fact pious religiously observant individuals
and I think that's manifested most greatly at the prayer of Valley Forge if you go to the Museum of
the Bible in Washington D.C. there's a whole exhibition about it but can you just educate
myself and our viewers not only Washington's prayer at Valley Forge but also how dire it was
for the American soldiers that winter yeah well 2500 soldiers died uh 500 women they were camp
followers but that term does not do them justice they were the ones that took care of the wounded
like scavenged for food cooked the food so sewed the clothes for them and uh and so um the um uh
the British had occupied Philadelphia uh and so the Americans had to be about 25 miles away
um and it was freezing cold Washington was not getting supplies they found out later that there's
a General Mifflin who was in charge of logistics and he was having all these supplies in a barn
and Patrick Henry's writing letters to the Continental Congress says I sent Virginia sent
a bunch of stuff why isn't it getting to Washington uh and then they found out that
there's the Conway Cabal they were a group of them wanting to intentionally have Washington
the original deep state yeah they were wanting him to fail so they could replace him with another
general and um Benjamin Rush sort of blew the whistle on that what um Washington would say
to the distinguished character of patriot it should be our highest glory to laud the more
distinguished character of Christian right um and there were some Jews well even at Valley Forge
there was a Jewish doctor that was there it was what George Washington's doctor was Jewish and
was there at Valley Forge um and so uh George Washington faced this situation where every
colony was started by a different denomination Virginia was Anglican Massachusetts was Puritan
Rhode Island was Baptist New York was Dutch Reformed uh Delaware New Jersey were originally
Swedish Lutheran then they got taken over by the Dutch and then taken over by the British
um Pennsylvania Quaker uh Connecticut New Hampshire Congregationalist and they did not
get along and they would tar and feather each other and so when the First Continental Congress
met uh there was a motion to open with prayer um in um September 1774 and you had the delegate from
South Carolina Rutledge and the delegate from New York Jay uh they objected and John Adams wrote
we were so divided in our religious sentiments that we could not join together in the same act
of worship and Sam Adams stands up and he goes I'm no bigot I can hear a prayer of any man of
piety who at the same time is a friend of our nation and so they pray and John Adams says that
they were kneeling and crying and they were reading Psalms 35 you know fight those that
fight against me oh lord you know and um and there were tears in the eyes and Washington was kneeling
and and so God blessed them even though they didn't agree on everything doctrinally they said
look let's all work together so that we can maintain freedom so that each of us can do what
we think is best uh after we win rather than having to to surrender and be under the king and
and his uh official Anglican church and at the time of the founding you had uh about three million
people 98 Protestant of these denominations that didn't always get along one percent Catholic 30,000
Catholics in a country of three million people and Catholics originally were only allowed in
three colonies Maryland Pennsylvania and New York and then one-tenth of a percent Jewish
3,000 Jews in a country of three million there were seven synagogues in the entire country
and um and then after that you had an Irish potato famine in the early 1800s and millions
of Irish Catholics came to America and the Catholic percentage went from from one percent
to 20 percent in a decade and there was an anti-Catholic backlash and that finally settles
down and then there's a persecution of Ashkenazic Jews in Germany in the middle 1800s and they come
across and that's when Maryland changed its constitution in 1851 to say every officeholder
had to be a Christian but if the party shall profess to be a Jew his declaration shall be of
a belief in a future state of rewards and punishments you mentioned the seven synagogues
can you just briefly address why was Washington's letter to the synagogue in Newport Rhode Island
so critical not just for the Jewish community the United States but really establishing religious
freedom throughout this newly established country yeah Washington understood that we needed to work
together when you read through a lot of the colonial documents if one denomination thought
they could have been successful in rebelling against the king by themselves they would have
been tempted to make their denomination the national one which is what every country in
Europe did and and for whatever reason no none of them had a majority so they had to work together
and it was cut the articles of confederation the different states were voluntarily giving money
to the federal army and and so they weren't giving the money because like we got our
Massachusetts battles we need our Massachusetts militia and so Washington is always struggling
for money and so a Jewish financier Chaim Solomon uses his own personal credit to borrow money from
the Dutch and borrow money from Europe and then gives it to Washington and um in Washington
several of the founders says the the revolutionary cause would would not have succeeded without
Chaim Solomon and um and it is interesting because um after the the Dyspora and then Jews are scattered
around the world uh the the rabbi in Babylon was um Samuel and he said the law of the land is the
law in other words you know just live under the the laws that we're in um and but they historically
would not get involved in the politics um but in America is like this first time when they the Jews
would participate in getting involved and um there was one who's in the like in the early 1800s
a letter from a Jew in America to a Jew in London who says that the Jews have experienced more
freedom in America than ever before in Europe and we get to participate and and we get involved in
the government in the army uh Uriah P. Levy was the first like you know commander of the the navy
it was a Jewish commander and uh and he actually paid personally for Thomas Jefferson's statue
that's in the U.S. Capitol Statuary Hall and um and he owned Monticello for a while um and preserved
it when it was you know going bankrupt. What what you're referring to is uh Dina Demochus Adina
that Jews are commanded to observe the laws of the country they're living in and the historic
aversion to government is mostly owed to conflicting statements in ethics of our fathers the
second century rabbinic text where on the one hand the rabbis are saying you should sort of flee from
the government because they're out for personal interests but at the same time they make a
statement a few lines later saying without government people would just be swallowing
other people it would be total anarchy but yes I would very much agree with you that the United
States is not just a collection of peoples but it's a collection of ideas chief among them is
religious freedom and the fact that you are not restricted from civic participation due to your
religious identity. So then let me ask as Jews and Christians all over this country and people
of all faiths and backgrounds come to celebrate America 250 you spoke a lot about the hand of God
what would you say is the most important miracle that helped establish the United States that we
can reflect on this July 4th? Oh that's a that's a good question I mean there's Benedict Arnall was
about to betray West Point and at the last minute it got discovered you had the Battle of Cowpens
where the British are chasing the Americans and three rivers in 10 days rise to stop the British
from being able to chase the Americans. You had the Battle of Saratoga where the British were
inciting the natives to scalp the Americans and David Jones's fiancee Jane McCraig ends up she's
she's he's a loyalist and yet his fiancee got scalped and so General Johnny Burgoyne has to
meet with the Indians and tell them to tone it down and they get offended and leave and so now
you have an entire British army in the middle of the New York forest they don't even know where
they're at and the Americans surround them and 6,000 British surrender that would be a big deal
today if 6,000 troops of any country surrendered and that ricochets across the ocean the painting
of the British surrendering at Saratoga is in our U.S. Capitol Statuary Hall right I mean in our
rotunda so if you're in the rotunda in the in the D.C. Capitol you look around there's these big
paintings one of them is the British General Burgoyne surrendering to Gates at the Battle of
Saratoga well this goes across to Ben Franklin who's in the court of Louis the 16th and the
King of France is not in a hurry to get in another war with America because he lost the French and
Indian War and lost all the land you know from the Appalachians to the Mississippi and so but when he
Franklin tells him hey we just captured 6,000 of the British the King Louis the 16th says well
maybe I'll get involved again once that happened British had to stretch its military around the
world why because the British and the French had colonies all around the world and now that we have
the French in a war with the British instead of the British just putting down one little rebellion
in one part of the world now they have to and that it takes the pressure off America and then you
have the Dutch was actually helping us and then the Spanish people forget Rochambeau when he was
coming over from France stopped off at Cuba and the ladies of Havana gave all their jewelry and
silver about 28 million dollars and they brought this to Washington at Yorktown and the army was
disappearing I mean guys were going back to their farms and so Washington this money helped keep
the army together so here who would have thought that Spanish women in Cuba gave the money for
Washington to complete the victory at Yorktown and anyway just fascinating hand of God but
they I've read through almost after every victory Washington would thank God
and thank Providence and no Webster's 1828 dictionary says by Providence it is commonly
commonly understood to mean the will of God so it's just a respectful way of talking about God
so when we talk about the religious lives of our founding fathers they were Christian and to your
point they praised God openly and blatantly and they wanted other people to praise God with them
so what does it mean that we are a Christian nation and how can we be a Christian nation
while also accompanying other faiths as well yeah so when you look at the U.S. government
cia.gov website as a world factbook and it lists every nation in the world and every imaginable
statistic and you look at India and it's um you know 80 percent Hindu and you look at Pakistan
and it's 90 percent Muslim and you know you look at Japan and you know 80 percent Buddhists or
whatever you look at America 30 years ago when I checked the site it says that we were 92 percent
Christian wow about um you know what 24 percent Catholic 69 percent Protestant and so forth
now it's gone down now it's like 65 percent Christian which is still a majority so if we're
going to call you know Saudi Arabia a Muslim country uh and Japan a Buddhist country and
India a Hindu country there's nothing wrong with 65 percent if you own 65 percent of a company
you're like the owner um so population wise but it has gone down um and and secondly it's the
I mean I read through every state constitution in 1776 nine of the state constitutions I shared
shared this with Charlie Kirk and he used it all the time nine of the state constitutions required
office holders to be Protestant Christian the whole state office three said all you had to do
was be a plain Christian um Ben Franklin signed Pennsylvania's constitution that said every office
holder had to make a declaration of belief in God creator and governor of the universe rewarded
the good punished for the wicked and acknowledged the scriptures of the old and new testament to be
given by divine inspiration so you not only had to lay your hand on a bible when you were sworn to
office you had to swear you believed in the bible right and this was Ben Franklin um and so America
even South Carolina's constitution says this state is as the Protestant Christian denomination is the
established denomination of the state they they said this is the established right um so America
was established a Christian nation on the state level and it was the states that created the
government and their fear was the federal government would pick one denomination make it
the national one so um so number one it's the population number two it's these founding documents
number three the constitution has a reference to the bible without referencing the bible
and it's the sinful nature of man that's why there's checks and balances that's why there's
three branches of government it's not like the French revolution where they said oh man it's
basically good you just take away these you know other influences it'll just turn out no it turns
into a bloodbath and man's basically a sinner and goes back to Adam and Eve sinning in the garden
and and so it's it's a biblical concept of checks and balances based on the fallen selfish human
nature of man and and then the other is institutions um marriage being a man and a woman
in the bible in genesis god made them male and female right the man shall leave the father mother
cleave to his wife islam you can have you know four wives um hinduism you know and these other
they can have all their different uh arrangements with multiples and so forth child brides and
things um but so these are uh and then honesty that's a judeo-christian concept that you're
accountable to a just god the whole idea of an oath is you're calling a higher power god to hold
you accountable for what you said you're going to do in front of everybody if there was no god who's
this only works with the god of the it doesn't it didn't work in athenian democracy how can you be
accountable to aphrodite the goddess of love when her temple has temple prostitutes right no you
can't see it any other way than the founders were basing it on the god of the bible bill this has
really been so eye-opening when i think of america 250 one of the things that has sustained and
blessed our country for so long is what you write in your book leviticus 26 and deuteronomy 28 are
quite clear what happens to a nation when they hearken on to the word of the lord and what
happens when they don't do that thing and the fact that we have been a christian nation and
a nation of peoples who strive to do the will of god i i really think that is what makes america
unique and you talk about only 62 of americans identify as christian i would argue that if we
can get those numbers back up we would be better off as a result and we can continue to be a
country that has religious freedom but at the same time makes makes it clear that we are created in
the image of god and that we will be much better if we learned the bible and we went back to our
original founding so bill thank you so much again and um happy july 4th chalice thanks for having
me on it's a great honor