New Toyota Land Cruiser vs Defender G Class Grenadier

Family Auto
135 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedFour off-road vehicles—the Toyota Land Cruiser, Land Rover Defender, Mercedes G-Wagon, and Ineos Grenadier—were tested in Wales. The evaluation covered water wading, steep climbs, and on-road refinement. The Toyota Land Cruiser emerged as the winner, offering the best balance of reliability, ease of use, and off-road capability compared to its competitors.
The trouble with off-roaders is that no one ever takes them off-road.
I mean, why? It's what they're for and the best of them are very, very good at it.
So what we've done is brought the new Toyota Land Cruiser and three of its fiercest rivals,
the Land Rover Defender, the Mercedes G-Wagon and the Ineos Grenadier, to here,
the middle of nowhere, to figure out which one is best.
And we're going to do that by putting them through some tests.
Where do you want to start?
Seeing as you've got your wellies on.
I have.
I think we should go swimming.
Smooth as butter.
Oh, that was it.
Now, before we get into that, a quick bit of housekeeping.
Instead of taking them to a pre-prepared off-road track,
we've headed to our favourite public access byways in the depths of Wales.
This is rugged terrain, miles from anywhere,
full of watery trenches, rocky slopes and plenty more.
All the cars are wearing tyres available direct from the manufacturer.
In every case, they're optional off-road tyres.
The only thing we did was remove some air
to give us a bit more friction and squish in the sidewalls.
And reduce the risk of punctures.
Isn't that right, Oliver?
Moving on, what we're going to do is see
which one delivers the most satisfying way of getting about off-road.
Because these four cars have a variety of different ways
of delivering on their mechanical abilities.
We've also fully prepared ourselves.
Basically, we brought wellies and sugary snacks.
Now, I was always told that if you had to do a water crossing
and there was an alternative, you should use it.
Because you can do a lot of damage going across water.
But this Landcruiser should do about 700mm of wading depth
and you should enter a water crossing slowly
and then be quite positive with your throttle
so you create a little bow wave in front of you.
As we are doing now, this car should wade to about 700mm
and we just confidently and positively drive through the water.
And do you know what?
The Toyota just aces it.
This is easy for this kind of car.
And I've just got it in four low with the centre diff locked.
No problems.
So let's go and have a little go through the wade
in the Grenadier, shall we?
Right, off we go.
I'm in wading mode which disables the parking sensors,
turns off the seatbelt warning,
turns off the heated seats and switches off the fans.
Otherwise, you'd pull extra water in to the radiators
and we're just going to go for a little splash around.
This is good, isn't it?
Yes.
Oh, it just makes mincemeat out of all of that, doesn't it?
No issues whatsoever.
What a laugh.
But all rather easy for the Grenadier.
Hello.
The Grenadier made mincemeat of that.
Are you going to take the Defender through?
Yes.
What you can do?
I don't really have to do anything
because you put it in terrain response and off you pop.
Though I do have air suspension.
So you're the only one here with it.
You're going to stick a bit of lift in.
Here we go.
I'm going higher.
Yeah, yeah.
And this car weirdly does have, it's got wade sensors in the chassis
so if it gets wet, it'll go up anywhere.
So I didn't really need to do that.
Okay, well off you try then.
Thanks.
I'm going to go watch.
But the wading didn't really prove much
other than that all four cars are more than capable
of keeping your feet dry crossing a small river
that wasn't quite deep enough to genuinely test cars
that can weigh between 700, the Toyota and the Mercedes,
and 900 millimetres, the Ineos and the Land Rover.
So next we needed to see about one of the most important things in off-roading,
traction and approach, breakover and departure angles.
Right, next test.
This is the bomb hole.
Bomb hole, okay.
And this is all about angles
and whether they can climb ridiculously steep slopes.
So I'm going to get Wookie in and we're going to see
and I'm going to talk to you about angles and stuff.
Right, stand by.
In you come, Wook.
Notice he makes me do this first.
You're fine ahead.
Absolutely fine.
Keep coming, keep going.
To see whether I can do it.
And if I break the car, it's my fault.
There we go.
Right, and then slow it down as you get into here, right?
That's just a brick wall.
It is just a big wall.
So wait, wait, wait.
Right, this, this here is your approach angle, okay?
So keep coming forward, Wook.
Keep coming.
And that's crucial.
So whether you're going up steep slopes, whether you've got the clearance
and you have, keep going, keep going, keep going.
Right, I'm going to talk to him about departure angles next.
You're clear.
Going up.
That is remarkable.
It's like an inch, but you're clear.
Okay, keep going.
You've got like three foot under the car now.
Okay, wait, wait, wait, wait.
I'm going to check you around the back.
This here is your departure angle down here.
And that's to make sure you don't scrape and rip your back bumper off.
Okay, Wook, a little bit forward.
Just creep it forward.
So I'm going to go very gently forward.
That's it.
Look at the roof levels by my chest.
Keep going.
Ready?
Yeah, yeah.
Little scrape.
You're fine, you're clear.
Go on, stop it there.
And then let's see if you've got traction to get it out.
So the other thing about this kind of thing, obviously, it's about grip and about traction.
Now, all of these cars have very sort of exceptional traction control systems
and decent tyres, even though they're the ones that do come from the manufacturers.
Yep.
So what this will test is whether this car has inherent traction.
You ready?
On a ridiculously steep slope.
On wet rock.
Ready?
Oh, that's your breakover angle.
So what's that?
That's the bit where we've not got enough height between the wheels to clear the actual obstacle.
But I don't think that was expensive.
Right, get it out.
I'll go and get something else.
So now it's time for Ollie in the Land Rover Defender.
Now this is a 110, so it's the mid-wheelbase.
You can get a 90 and a 130.
And as we can see, it's approaching the bonnet.
You're doing well there, Oliver.
Thank you very much.
Look, there's your approach angle.
Now, the Defender's got air suspension, so it's actually got a better approach angle
than any of the other cars.
It does feel like the bonnet is just going to plough straight through there.
And it's not going to, it's absolutely fine.
Keep an eye on my back wheels.
Right, I'm just watching your back wheels.
Now, we've got a bit more of a bum on this car,
but the suspension's lifted the body out of the way.
The departure angle's actually all right.
You're fine, Ollie.
You're fine.
Now, you've got to go all the way up and then stop to make it a fair test.
It's 30 degrees.
Okay.
And now we test the traction.
Ollie, what do you reckon?
Well, I'm hoping it's going to pull forward, not backwards.
We ready?
Let's go.
This is so unnerving.
Little tap.
I'm going to drop it backward.
That was quite a solid little tap.
I think you'll be all right.
You sure?
Yeah, I think you'll be fine.
I'm going to bring it over this side a bit.
Slowly.
You're all right.
You sure?
Yeah, I think you'll get over.
It doesn't feel all right.
I think we might need a different line from here.
Do you want a different line?
I think you'll get over, but...
Okay, go backwards.
You were almost over it.
I think that's driver error.
Essentially, you need a more skilful driver.
I'm going to come up this side a bit more.
Wheels off the ground.
Keep going.
Oh, look at this.
I'm just pointing at the sky.
No, stop.
Come back.
It's not going to make it, is it?
Oh, it is going to make it.
It is going to make it.
I'm sorry for laughing.
Do you want to have a go?
Go back.
Go back and perhaps give it a slightly more left side.
I thought you were going to say, give it a bit more pedal.
And you'll be fine.
So this is the break over angle issue.
So the car's got less distance.
Now, go that way.
Yeah.
And it'll go up.
I guarantee it.
Yeah.
Go, go, go.
You're fine.
Gently, gently.
Go on, go on.
Keep going.
So the Defender, surprisingly, made a bit of a fuss of the bomb hole.
The others were pretty much unruffled.
With only the Ineos scraping even a bit.
I haven't even put the rear differential in yet.
Little touch on the break over, but otherwise great.
Both the Mercedes and the Land Cruiser made it look, well, pretty ordinary, actually.
That is amazing.
Right, onwards over a few miles of mixed surfaces,
which mainly involve breaking ice in puddles, deeply satisfying.
Picking our way over rocks, wading through trenches,
and a couple of more river crossings.
They all cope with this no problem, although the Defender felt big
and the Grenadier slightly unwieldy in tight spots.
Meanwhile, the softer suspension of the Land Cruiser and G-Class
meant they were more comfortable and didn't get tipped around so much.
None of them struggled particularly until, yeah,
the Defender snagged a rock under the water, which ruptured a sidewall.
Right, we've had a little issue, as you can probably tell.
Come round here and step behind Wookie,
who's currently busy with an air hose for a very obvious reason.
We got a bit of a gash in the tyre and it just deflated immediately.
And it's one of the big ones, I'm surprised.
On the Defender, that's gone.
Now we're going to try and reinflate it.
We've got a puncture repair kit and we're going to try and reinflate it.
See how that goes, shall we?
It actually went pretty well,
although we didn't fully trust our repair skills,
so switched to the proper spare for our next challenge,
which wouldn't normally be any sort of challenge at all.
Although this is an off-road test, we did take on-road manners into account.
And yes, there is a road somewhere under the snow, mostly.
And it's the Defender that was the most comforting and best on-road,
not least because it has an EV-only mode for silent running.
Beyond that, it's also the only car here with a monocoque construction,
which aids refinement rather than a separate body and chassis.
It's also the only car here with fully independent suspension, surprisingly.
The G-Class and the Land Cruiser are similar underneath,
with independent front suspension but a solid rear axle.
The G is the quieter and better behaved,
but you'd expect that given that at £146,000,
it's approaching twice the price of the Toyota.
Still, it's calm, super solid, and although there's a bit of structural shimmy,
the inline-six is strong and makes a very good noise.
The Land Cruiser does without the Merc's luxe vibe.
It looks suitably modern,
but the 2.8-litre four-cylinder diesel sounds anything but.
It's gruff, tough, and makes the sort of reassuring noise
you just know would survive Armageddon.
There's a bit of shake and shimmy from the chassis,
but it churns through miles happily,
and returning 29 mpg was the most efficient of our four.
The least efficient was the heavyweight 22-to-the-gallon Ineos.
At 2,740 kilos, some 400 kilos more than the Toyota.
The twin-turbo three-litre diesel's strong enough to cope,
but with solid axles front and back,
plus outdated recirculating ball steering that needs constant correction,
doesn't self-centre and has a rubbish turning circle,
the agricultural Ineos really suffers doing normal road stuff.
Where are we then, Borg?
We're here.
We're there. We're on a map.
There's a little river there, but we're on a sort of a hill,
and we've just paused for a minute.
Yeah, yeah.
To work out what we think so far.
Yeah, exactly. A sort of status update so far.
Okay, so we've got all the cars out there.
Grenadier, what do you think so far?
I thought I'd hate that car, but it is a little bit of me,
in that it's very old school.
Yeah.
And I quite like the kind of modular bit,
like I could see myself strapping a winch and a roof rack
and to make the light to it.
But it's a bit, you have to stop to do everything.
So it's quite annoying, isn't it?
To have to stop, to put it into neutral,
to engage the differentials and things,
because you can't do them on the fly.
It's very deliberate.
And even to do the off-road mode.
Yeah, that's the thing.
Yeah, yeah. To do anything, you've sort of got to stop it first.
It's a little bit irritating compared with some of the others.
It's very single-minded.
It's very designed to do one thing, and that thing is not go on a road.
Yes.
It's, I mean, it'll do the road stuff,
but it's, compared with the rest of them, it's not very civilised, is it?
Well, the thing is, I like playing with all the gear levers and stuff,
but probably 75% of the time I would be on a road going,
my God, the steering is really weird and slow and doesn't self-centre.
Yeah.
And it would get on my nerves a lot.
I get used to that.
I find it, I do find it really cumbersome,
even if off here doing all this,
it feels the heaviest, the most durable of all of these.
It feels like the one that's probably least likely to go wrong,
although it hasn't, you know, it hasn't been around long enough
to know if it's got that reputation for reliability yet.
You're right about it feeling like it's going to go anywhere, though.
Like it'll keep just motoring.
If you look under the front wheel wells of that
and just look how massive the bits of metal are that it's built from,
it's really toughly assembled, isn't it?
And it's gone over absolutely everything without any problems.
A couple of scrapes of the toe ball, which you'd expect.
It's like, there's nothing wrong with how it gets down off-road.
No.
It's really, really good.
On the opposite end of the scale, though, you've got the G-Wagen.
Yeah.
Now that is a serious dark horse.
That thing's amazing off-road.
It is.
It's really impressive, isn't it?
It just feels like it's had so much engineering budget hurled at it over the years.
But the thing is, the reputation, this is the thing.
Could you actually be seen driving that if you were a serious off-roader?
I think you could because it's ex-military.
I think the modern ones still have that idea of it comes from the right place.
But the engineering, the way that it's been put together,
I've not put that in low range for a good third of what we've done already.
Yeah.
Because it didn't need to do it.
No.
And then when you want to lock the diffs and stuff, you just press a couple of buttons.
It's the most logical to operate.
It's the easiest to operate.
You've got a button that says off-road mode and you've got three diffs.
It does feel a bit weird, though, doesn't it?
Because it's quite nice inside.
It does.
But it's also got no space inside.
I know this is sort of tangential to what we're talking about,
but it is small inside considering the outward scale of it.
But in terms of how it gets over things and round things.
Fussless.
Yeah, really good.
But I'm going to point this out again.
Watching a £137,000 car bounce down rocks makes me wince.
Yeah.
And not in the same way that the Ineos or any of the other cars do.
It just feels a little bit wrong.
It does.
And I wish we'd got the diesel.
You know, there you go.
What about the Defender, though?
That's the one.
It's really surprised me, that car, because it's the only one that's on air suspension.
So it's height adjustable.
And you think, oh, that's going to be a proper game.
That's going to get it over things.
It's the one, when we stuck it through the bomb hole.
Yes, when you stuck it through the bomb hole.
I stuck it through the bomb hole.
That really struggled.
And yet it looks, perceptively, it looks like it's on a really gnarly set of tyres
and shouldn't have had an issue with it.
But it did struggle.
It's about the same weight, and I tried twice.
I think what's happening is, you know when you put it into the off-road mode,
the highest setting in the air suspension, it gets really stiff-kneed.
Yeah, it does.
Like, it really struggles to have any kind of softness.
And it means that it's always picking a wheel up.
But I thought the Defender would be the one that was just swanning around being perfect
and making everything look easy.
Yeah, which the G has actually done better than the Defender.
But have you tried knocking it around in EV mode?
No, it's always flat.
No, when I got it working this morning, and I was like in the countryside in EV mode,
going off-road, and it was completely silent.
And I thought it was really cool.
That's a nice thing, actually, isn't it?
I mean, in a way, it would have been amazing to have had the EQ, whatever, the G580, whatever
they call it.
G580E, because that is incredible off-road.
But again, that's like £130,000 again.
No, £80,000.
Yeah, I think it's even more, isn't it?
Also, Defender, though, is the nicest on-road.
Oh, I drove, yeah, for a long time yesterday.
It's really nice.
And if you were plugging it in a lot, it would be quite efficient.
It's not efficient when the battery's flat.
No.
But if you were plugging it in a lot on-road, that thing is really comfy, very quiet.
Yeah.
And all of that.
But then we come to this, don't we?
Yeah.
The Land Cruiser.
And I have to say, when I first got in it, I thought it's quite unrefined engine-wise,
because it's a big four diesel.
So it's like, and then I thought, I quite like that.
It's comforting.
It's a noise that you think it'll just carry on doing that until doomsday.
Nothing will ever change.
It just carries on.
It's not silky.
No.
But it is confidence-inspiring.
And then off-road, so far...
It's like the G.
Yes.
It just feels its way over stuff really easily.
Where the Ineos feels quite heavy in how it deals with it, but it feels unstoppable.
These two pick their way quite delicately, almost.
And you can really control them on the throttle.
Whereas the Defender is a bit sharp when you're on and off the throttle at really low speed.
This feels so controllable.
Both the G and the Land Cruiser feel smaller than the Defender and the Ineos.
Yes.
And they're not necessarily less heavy, but they feel smaller.
And I like the way in here, you know, when I was just...
I wanted to...
We were on those tracks, which you don't really need low range for.
And then there was a little bit that you needed to put it in low four.
You can just stop, put it in neutral, whack it into low four.
It's quick, isn't it?
And then here, you've just got centre diff and rear diff and stabiliser bar disconnect
and a couple of drive modes.
It's quite intuitive.
It is.
So this and the G, I think, are the easiest to operate.
The Defender, you're sort of occasionally with the terrain response, you're trying to go...
And to be fair, that terrain response a couple of times has failed to respond.
Yes, it doesn't work.
And hasn't worked.
But even then, even when it does, it's sort of one layer back, isn't it?
Because it defaults to the heating control.
So to get to terrain response in the first place,
you've sort of got to overcome the heating control.
It's almost as if it's not as important.
It's not as important.
That is how it comes across.
And then the graphics are quite small on screen.
So it's there, but it's like the people have gone, well, it's there.
It will do it.
And it does do it.
But it's like you're never quite aware of when the diffs are doing what they're doing.
You can go into that configurable mode.
But still, if this feels like it's more obvious what goes on and you...
It's a more mechanical sensation in this and the G than it is in the Defender.
Isn't it weird though? The Defender is like it's trying to almost hide away its off roadiness,
which surprised me.
The Grenadier is making it really deliberate, really obvious.
And then these two are somewhere in the middle.
Exactly.
The G-Wagen and this.
And I think this is where I would be most comfortable.
Yeah.
Something I can still fiddle with stuff,
but I'm not messing around necessarily with 64 levers and 20 buttons on the roof.
Yeah, exactly.
Right.
Should we go and do some rock crawling?
Let's go and see.
And I just want to take this, if that's all right.
I'm going to make sure that this is as looked after as possible.
Nothing can go wrong.
I mean, to be fair, this one has barely scratched so far, has it?
I mean, like this and the G and the Ineos have only done little ones.
This one had a little bit of a...
This will not struggle at all.
Right.
OK, let's go.
Let's go and find out.
All right, what we got coming up then, Ol?
We've got a lovely little rock crawl.
It's quite possibly bangy on the axles.
So this is where everything comes into play, isn't it?
Yeah, yeah.
So we need super relaxed suspension.
Yep.
So I need to disconnect the anti-roll bar.
Disconnect your anti-roll bar in this.
In this car.
And we need loads of grip.
Yep.
Good angles.
All the things we've been talking about, basically.
Good throttle modulation so you can ease it over without it all getting carried away.
And we also need our favourite thing.
Diff locks.
So a diff lock, essentially what it does is it locks the axles so that they move at the same speed.
So you don't spin away power on the side that has no grip.
So a centre diff will lock front to back.
So they move at the same speed.
And then a diff lock front or rear will lock them side to side.
So you've not got one wheel.
If it gets in the air, it's not just spinning around.
As long as one wheel's got traction, you've got traction.
You've got traction.
But what happens when you're on a road and you have your diff locks in?
Yeah, it goes all crunchy.
It doesn't like changing direction.
When you go round a corner, the wheels on the outside of the car have to spin faster,
have to travel a further distance than ones on the inside.
So eventually, your transmission will explode.
Hopefully, that's not going to happen right now.
Let's see if we can do this in a very gentle, gentle way.
OK, let's see.
Ready, go.
Here we go.
Off you pop.
Keep going.
You've just got a bit of a drop now.
That's it.
Just roll over it.
That's it.
And let it potter down.
We should be fine.
Big drop coming up.
That's the one.
It's absolutely smooth as butter.
And it's not going to...
Oh, that was it.
That was the drop.
It's smooth as butter.
It's quite a big hole.
Now, I think this is the sidestep's fault.
What have you done?
No, nothing.
It's basically, if the sidestep wasn't there, it would have cleared the obstacle.
You nearly can't open the door now.
No, you can.
It's only plastic.
There we go.
See, a Land Cruiser is self-healing.
Well, self-healing with a little bit of bounces.
There you go.
I think that's done.
Well, it's just slightly curved for next time.
OK, Ollie, I'm going to help you, even though you did not help me.
Saying he's going to help me.
Yeah, he's got a point.
I was only looking at one side of the car.
And I'm just going to tickle it forward.
Oh, it feels so tilty.
I don't like this.
I feel really high up in the air at the moment.
And then you sort of pucker as the thing drops off another ledge.
No, that way.
That way.
Now, straight.
Straight.
Yeah, straight, straight, straight.
No, no, no, you're fine.
Go straight.
You're fine.
You see, if you have a proper spotter...
I thought this might be one time it went through without clipping something.
Not quite.
I think that's down to the spotting marriage.
That was better.
That's the best thing the Defender's done today, I think.
Bye bye.
As before, with proper help finding the correct line,
both the G-Wagen and the Grenadier simply climb their way down
this particular set of steps without any problems,
both making it look pretty effortless.
And after a few more miles of track, we started to figure out a conclusion.
You know what I was saying at the start of this
about why does no one take their off-roaders off-road?
I think we might have found out.
Yes, because there's been a couple of things that have gone slightly awry,
but they're all here.
They're all here.
They're all working through.
So, right, okay, what are your thoughts?
My big thought for the day, these past two days,
is that that Land Rover Defender has struggled slightly.
I've driven it on the road, it was fabulous,
but actually it hasn't been that brilliant off-road.
And this is an off-road test, right?
The Ineos, slightly annoying,
fiddling around with all the levers and stuff,
but brilliant off-road.
Yep.
On-road, a little bit old school.
A little bit old school.
Very old school.
G-Wagen, dark horse, absolutely fabulous off-road,
really good on it, but very, very expensive.
Land Cruiser LC250, a bit of an all-rounder, actually.
It has done everything we've asked for it.
It's been as impressive off-road as the Grenadier.
It's been as smooth and you can use it so easily.
The only drawback I have is that engine is a little bit agricultural.
Apart from that, I think we've found our winner.
Really? Okay, well, give me an order then.
Right, what do you reckon?
Right, off-road only, fourth.
A Land Rover Defender comes third.
Third, well, I'll argue with that,
because I think the G-Wagen and the Ineos are sort of...
A second equal, aren't they?
They've both got their things going.
The G-Wagen being very expensive,
that being a bit rubbish on road, you know, but that leaves one car.
It's this, the Land Cruiser LC250, top gear's off-roader of choice.
If the G-Wagen was the cheaper diesel in the right spec,
I would have made a case for that winning,
but I'm not allowed to go past Ollie, who is the king here.
