It Turns Out, Hybrids Are Really Hard On Engines

Autos hacks
81 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everyone and welcome. In this video sponsored by Mobil1, we're going to be talking about how hybrid vehicles can be
surprisingly hard on engines. And so we're going to be focusing on three main questions.
First, a quick recap on how hybrids work. Second, why are hybrid vehicles hard on engines, as it's a
commonly overlooked challenge. And finally, what solutions exist to combat these challenges.
Starting at the beginning, the idea of a hybrid vehicle is very simple. So with a traditional
gasoline vehicle, you have a fuel tank and that gasoline is sent to an engine which powers your
driven wheels. Now with a hybrid, it's very similar except you add a few components. So now you also
have a battery which can send energy to an electric motor which can also drive the driven wheels.
Electric motors are super efficient and the battery pack allows you to store energy from
regenerative braking. So this results in vehicles that get better fuel economy. But rightfully, you
might wonder if an electric motor is actively helping the combustion engine move the vehicle,
why would this be hard on the engine? There's three main challenges we'll discuss. Lots of start-stop
cycles, water in the oil due to lower operating temperatures, and similarly fuel in the oil.
Starting with the engine turning on and off frequently, this is inherent to the design of
hybrids. In scenarios such as decelerating, going down a hill, stopping at a light, or simply when the
battery is full, the engine can shut off and the electric motors take over. Now this saves fuel,
but it also means your engine is turning on and off frequently. These frequent start-stops can
be problematic as MobileOne estimates as much as 80 to 90 percent of engine wear occurs from
engine startup. That's because when the engine starts, it needs 12 to 15 seconds before the
lubricating oil is fully circulating throughout the engine, thus preventing metal-on-metal contact
and thus minimizing wear. Now there are several ways you can combat this. First off, it's important
to recognize that the most harmful engine startup is when it's been sitting for a long time, like
overnight, and it's starting up dead cold. The colder the oil, the more challenging it is for it to flow.
So this zero W, or the cold viscosity grade, is very low, meaning the oil will flow easily at lower
temperatures, especially in comparison to oils like a 5W or a 10W, as long as the engine is designed
to use it. But what about when you're sitting in a stoplight and your engine shuts off, then cuts
back on, say a minute later? Well, it's still an engine startup, which is a challenge, but there are
numerous reasons why this isn't as difficult to offer protection here. Since your engine oil is
already warm or hot, it flows faster, and thus it doesn't take as much time for it to circulate
throughout the engine versus a cold start. Also, some of the oil will still be in place in the needed
areas. So if I have oil on some aluminum foil, as I lift the aluminum foil, the oil drains down,
but it doesn't all immediately flow off. If I were to hold this up overnight, the vast majority of
the oil would flow to the bottom, leaving very little behind. But after just a minute or so,
there's still some oil on there. It's like when you change your oil. After a minute, most of the
oil has drained out. But if you were to wait, even hours later, you can still find oil slowly dripping
out. All of this meaning if the time between the engine cycling on and off is short, it's not as
much of a concern since some of the oil remains in place. Finally, you have anti-wear additives,
things like ZDDP or zinc, which under high temperatures and pressures, creates a protective
layer on metal components. So next time the engine starts up, that ZDDP acts as a sacrificial barrier
to reduce wear from any metal on metal contact. But there's another really big challenge for hybrid
engines, and that's water. So what causes this? So here's an example of what engine oil temperatures
look like for a hybrid vehicle versus a traditional gasoline engine. And keep in mind, this is after
both vehicles have already warmed up, which can take longer for hybrids since the engine is running
less frequently. And so as you can see, since the gas engine is always running, the engine oil
temperature floats around 95 to 100 degrees Celsius. Now the hybrid will have cycles where it
reaches these higher temperatures, but you can see often it's running at about 70 degrees Celsius.
Because it's running less often, the temperatures consistently remain about 20 to 40 degrees lower
on average. And yeah, this is just my sketchy whiteboard drawing, but it's based on real data
from MobileOne's testing. So what's the problem with lower average engine temperatures? Well,
it makes things like water and fuel dilution a bigger issue. Water can get into your engine oil
in several ways. Of course, if you have a blown head gasket, your engine's coolant can leak into
the oil. But that's a mechanical failure, so let's assume we have a healthy engine. All piston cylinder
engines have some amount of blow-by, where combustion gases within the cylinder pass by the
piston rings and enter the crankcase where your oil resides. Water is a byproduct of combustion.
When you burn fuel, you get water and CO2. So this water that ends up passing pistons is
inevitable. In addition, if you live in a humid environment, that means you're adding more moisture
into the equation as your engine pulls in that humid air. Now, if your temperatures aren't high
enough, this moisture can condense. If you're increasing in temperature, water boils at 100
degrees Celsius. If you're decreasing in temperature, water condenses at 100 degrees Celsius. So in the
case of the hybrid vehicle, we're taking hot water vapor and introducing it to engine oil that's below
water's condensation temperature, meaning we're now introducing liquid water to the oil. This is a
problem. Okay, so if I pour water into this cup with vegetable oil in it, you can see they do not
mix. And no matter how much time you spend trying to mix them, once you stop, the two liquids will
separate. And yet, if I look at a jar of mayonnaise, the two main ingredients are oil and water, but
clearly it's not separating into these two separate components. It's one thing, mayonnaise. So how does
it do it? Well, the third main ingredient in mayonnaise is egg, and egg has proteins in it that
act as emulsifiers. So one part of the egg protein is attracted to oil, and another part of the egg
protein is attracted to water. So when you mix the egg in with the water in the oil, you create this
emulsion where the ingredients don't settle out. Super cool! Unfortunately, both of these scenarios
are terrible for an engine. If you have standing water, say in pockets of your cylinder head, that
can lead to corrosion. And water is pretty terrible as a lubricant. So if water ends up circulating
between moving parts, you have increased wear. But as you can imagine, you really, really don't want
an emulsion to form in your oil. And with engines that never get up to temperature, you can actually
see this happen, which is a dangerous condition. You can plug up the oil filter so it can't clean
out contaminants, and you can also plug up passages, meaning you have limited or no oil flow to certain
regions of the engine. And once you stop oil flow, you get more wear. And this problem only gets worse,
because once you start having metal wear, that means you have abrasive particles flowing through
your engine oil. And hopefully, eventually, your oil filter takes them out. But along the way, these
abrasive particles are now creating more wear. So the problem compounds, and you end up destroying
your engine. So what's the solution? Well, you actually want something between these two extremes.
So the oil is designed with base stocks as well as additives that help promote a condition between
these two. Ideally, what happens is that as you introduce water into the oil, which again is
inevitable, you want the oil to capture the water and temporarily absorb it. Basically, the oil will
hold on to small amounts of water and have it travel through the engine with the oil until the
oil is hot enough that the water boils off and evaporates. As an additive, you'll have demulsifiers
in the oil, which are used to break down oil water emulsions that form, so that you reduce the
likelihood of having mayonnaise in your engine. Simply put, you don't want eggs in your engine oil.
Incredible insight, I know. But ultimately, there are limited ways of getting the water out.
It's important to get the engine temperature high enough so that this water evaporates.
Water boils at 100 degrees C, and is expelled from the engine through the PCV system. Within your
engine, you have a vent which allows the positive pressure that builds up within the crankcase
to be vented to the intake. So this gives you a mechanism for allowing that evaporated water
to travel back through your intake, through the engine, and eventually out the exhaust,
expelling it from the engine. The same logic is true for fuel dilution, where lower engine
temperatures can promote more fuel getting mixed in with the oil. The two main ways you have of
getting this fuel out is bringing the engine up to temperature and changing the oil. And it's worth
mentioning things like water and fuel don't immediately disappear once your engine oil
reaches, say, 100 degrees Celsius. Think about boiling a pot of water. Once the water reaches
the boiling point, it doesn't all immediately evaporate. That takes time. The other method of
getting rid of this water that remains in the oil is, of course, changing that oil. But you want to
ensure that you don't accumulate too much water within the oil drain interval. In the case of
Mobil 1 Hybrid, this is guaranteed for 15,000 miles. This number really comes down to looking
at a worst-case scenario and ensuring the product still works in that environment. For example,
let's say you have a car driven in Key West, Florida. So you're on a small island, you've got
really short travel distances, so your engine's never really getting up to temperature, and it's
a really humid environment. Versus somewhere like Las Vegas, where you're traveling further distances,
getting that engine hot, and it's a dry environment. So they have to look at all
of the possible scenarios and ensure the product works for the most difficult ones.
From a formulaic standpoint, what you're doing is choosing the right balance for the application.
For example, take zinc and corrosion inhibitors. Both of these are surface additives, meaning they
react with the metal surfaces they come into contact with. So both of them are competing for
the same real estate. If you use too much ZDDP, you reduce the probability that your anti-corrosion
additives interact with the surface. And the reverse is true as well. The same is true for
non-surface acting additives, like detergents, dispersants, and demulsifiers. The proportions
you choose mean the oil is designed to maximize the probability of addressing certain issues.
So while this is using many of the same ingredients you'd find in other Mobil1 oils,
the proportions of the ingredients differ to suit the application, with more focus on dealing with
things like water and fuel dilution in the oil, since that's a critical part of protecting hybrid
vehicle engines. So for a product like this, Mobil1 tells me they started out with about 25
different formulations. Each of these formulas goes through a series of bench tests, which narrows
it down to about 5 top performing formulas. Then these 5 formulas end up going into actual engines
and a further series of tests, and the result of all of this testing is that you find the formula
that works the best, and that's what ends up in this bottle. Now one of the easiest ways to know
you're buying a quality oil is to look at the certifications, and in particular here, looking
at the API SP rating. Not every oil you can buy at the parts store has this, and SP has 7 additional
industry standardized tests versus SN. These tests cover many areas, providing effectiveness for
things like valve train wear, sludge protection, chain wear protection, avoiding LSPI, engine
cleanliness, and of course fuel economy. It's a no-brainer when buying oil for your car to ensure
that what you're getting has passed the industry's latest tests, and this is very easy to check. Also
I think it's worth mentioning Toyota has a deserved reputation of reliability. You'll see plenty of the
older models of these with over 200,000, even 300,000 miles on them. All that's to say, with
proper maintenance, the reliability of a hybrid vehicle doesn't need to be a major concern.
Hopefully this has provided insight into the unique challenges and solutions facing hybrid
vehicles. A big thank you to MobileOne for sponsoring the video and providing access to
their engineers, and thank you all so much for watching. If you have any questions or comments,
feel free to leave them below.
