Did Mayor Bissen crash the Maui real estate market? And what does Bill 88 actually mean for property owners?
In this video, I break down the timeline behind Bill 9 and Bill 88, how the Minatoya List became the center of Maui's housing debate, and why I believe the real estate market reacted the day the policy was announced—not when it became law. We'll cover: Why Maui condo values declined so dramatically What Bill 9 changed What Bill 88 does (and doesn't do) The impact on homeowners, renters, workers, and the local economy The unanswered questions surrounding Maui's affordable housing strategy Whether you're a Maui homeowner, vacation rental owner, real estate professional, or simply care about the future of our island, I hope this video provides helpful context so you can better understand what's happened and what's still ahead. I'd love to hear your thoughts. Do you agree with my analysis? Is there another perspective I should consider? Leave a comment below and let's have a respectful conversation. If you found this video helpful, please like, subscribe, and share it with anyone trying to understand the impact of Bills 9 and 88 on Maui.
If you're interested in Maui real estate, including Maui condos, Maui luxury homes, and the Maui real estate market, this channel provides regular updates and property tours. 📍 Maui Real Estate Topics Covered• Maui real estate market updates• Maui homes for sale• Maui condos for sale• Kihei real estate• Wailea luxury real estate• Buying property in Maui Hawaii
Tom Tezak with Hawaii Life provides weekly updates on the Maui real estate market, including condos, luxury homes, and investment property in Maui Hawaii. If you are considering buying or selling real estate in Maui, subscribe for market updates, property tours, and local insights.
Maui real estate, Maui real estate market, Maui homes for sale, Maui condos for sale, Kihei real estate, Wailea real estate, Lahaina real estate, Maui housing market, buying property in Maui Hawaii, Maui investment property.
Tom Tezak, Hawaii Life R(B)21167 Lifestyle Maui Team 808-280-2055 [email protected] www.tomtezak.com 3750 Wailea Alanui Suite B16 Wailea , HI 96753
Visit us on ► Facebook: / lifestylemauirealestate LinkedIn: / recent-activity Instagram: / tomtezakmaui
AI Generated·May contain errors
How Mayor Bisson crashed the Maui real estate market and what Bill 88 actually means. I want
to talk to you today about one of the most consequential and in my view one of the most
reckless acts of local governance in Maui County's recent history. Over the last two years Mayor
Bisson announced and then signed into law a piece of legislation that eliminated legally established
property rights for thousands of Maui condo homeowners. The real estate market collapsed
not when the bill was passed, but the day he announced it. Property values dropped at a rate
not seen since the bottom of the 2008 financial crisis. Jobs were put at risk, tax revenues
threatened, and the mayor has expressed pride about all of it. Here's the part that should make
every Maui resident, not just condo owners, pay attention. The stated goal was affordable housing
but there's no affordable housing plan attached to any of this. Not one new unit being built,
not one deed restriction on a single converted property, just the political satisfaction of
taking something away from people he called offshore investors. A label that conveniently
ignored the thousands of small individual owners, retirees, and Hawaii-based property holders who
got swept up in the same net. Today I'm going to take you through the full story from the moment
this started to what Bill 9 actually did to what Bill 88 means for the owners trying to protect
what's left. Stay with me because this affects all of us. The fire that changed everything. To
understand how we got here you have to go back to August 8, 2023. The Lahaina wildfire. It killed at
least 100 people, destroyed over 2,200 structures, and displaced more than 12,000 residents overnight.
It was the deadliest American wildfire in over a century and it turned Maui's already serious
housing shortage into a full-blown emergency. Governor Josh Green initially proposed a two-year
ban on vacation rentals in West Maui to free up housing for the displaced families. He eventually
backed off that approach but the political environment had fundamentally shifted. Housing
advocates, particularly the Lahaina Strong Group, had been pushing for years to eliminate vacation
rentals and apartment zone properties. The fire gave them their moment and Mayor Bisson, well,
he gave them their champion. In the spring of 2024, the state legislature passed SB 2919, a bill
giving counties explicit authority to regulate and phase out short-term rentals. Governor Green
signed it on May 3, 2024. Mayor Bisson didn't even wait for the ink to dry. The day before the governor
signed that state bill, May 2, 2024, Mayor Bisson held a televised press conference. He was flanked
and he announced his intention to phase out and repeal, in his words, decades-old transient
vacation rentals operating in the apartment district. Quoting Mayor Bisson,
my proposed bill will revert all apartment district properties to their intended long-term
residential use. The target was approximately 7,000 properties on what was known as the minotorialist,
a roster of apartment zone condominiums that had been legally permitted to operate as vacation
rentals under a county legal opinion for decades and was codified into law by Maui County Council
in 2018. These properties had paid higher real property taxes because of that vacation rental
classification. They collected and paid general excise tax and transient accommodation tax. They
operated legally and openly for 30 years or more. Bisson's message to those owners was this,
your legal rights are being phased out. And the real estate market, which is forward-looking
by nature, heard that message and reacted immediately. The market didn't wait. Here's
something that doesn't get said loudly enough. The economic damage from Bill 9 didn't begin when
it passed. It began on May 2, 2024, the morning of that press conference. By December 2025,
before Bill 9 had even passed its final council vote, the median Maui condo sales price had dropped
22.8 percent year over year. That's not a slow bleed. That's a crash. The University of Hawaii
Economic Research Organization, UHERO, produced an economic impact study on this, and here's the
critical detail. That study was commissioned by Bisson's own administration. Their own economists
projected condo price declines of between 20 and 40 percent, depending on the implementation. To
find a comparable period for sales volume, you would have to go all the way back to November
2009, the very bottom of the Great Recession, when the global financial system had just nearly
collapsed. One Maui real estate broker wrote in his April 2026 market report, Mayor Bisson is
most likely proud of the decline of the Maui real estate market, which he has been instrumental in
orchestrating, even if it's affecting the equity that all local Maui homeowners have in their
properties. Think about that. Not just TVR owners, but all Maui homeowners, because when one segment
of the market crashes, it drags everything down with it. And through it all, the phase-out hasn't
even started yet. TVR rights in West Maui don't end until January 1st, 2029. The rest of the island
has until January 1st, 2031. The market has already priced in losses that haven't legally taken effect.
The affordable housing illusion. Now let's talk about the justification for all of this, because
it deserves serious scrutiny. Mayor Bisson said, and I'm summarizing in his own words, that Bill 9
would return more than 6,000 units to long-term residential use, significantly expanding the
housing inventory, without the need for new construction. Without the need for new construction,
I want you to sit with that phrase for a moment, because that's not a housing plan. That's a
rezoning exercise dressed up as a housing plan. The properties on the Minotaua list are mostly
oceanfront and resort adjacent condominiums in South Maui and West Maui. Their market values
put them well beyond the reach of working-class Maui families, whether purchased or rented. The
UHERO study found that most of these properties would likely be sold or converted to long-term
rentals by their current owners, or become second homes, market-rate long-term rentals, and not
affordable housing, not workforce housing, not units priced for behind-the-fire survivors. If the
true goal was affordable housing, what would that actually look like? It would look like new
construction of deed-restricted affordable units, funded in part by the tax revenue that vacation
rentals generate. It would look like incentive programs to encourage long-term rentals at the
low market rates. It would look like public-private partnerships to develop workforce housing on
county-owned land. It would look like a defined affordability mechanism tied to any converted
unit. None of that exists in Bill 9, not one single provision. The bill eliminates TVR rights and
trusts the market to somehow produce affordable outcomes, despite every market signal pointing
the opposite direction. And the offshore investor framing? Politically effective, factually misleading.
Yes, the county's own data shows that more than 90 percent of the Maui STR owners don't live in
the county, but that figure includes retirees who bought a Maui condo as a retirement investment.
It includes small individual owners who depend on rental income to cover their mortgages and
carrying costs. It includes people who purchased legally in good faith, paying premium prices and
premium taxes because the county told them this was a legal way to use their property.
Calling them all offshore investors was a way to make political opposition easier and human
consequences harder to see. The taking Bisson chose to pursue. There's a legal concept called
a taking. When a government eliminates a legally established property use, it may be required under
the Fifth Amendment to compensate the owners. It's a serious constitutional issue. Mayor Bisson
is a former judge. He knew the risk. He said publicly that he expected litigation and he signed
the bill anyway. Within days of Bill 9 being signed into law, the first constitutional challenge was
filed. It raises exactly these vested property rights and arguments. More lawsuits are expected.
This litigation could cost Maui County taxpayers millions of dollars over the next several years,
regardless of the outcome. The politically harder but legally cleaner path would have been
to build affordable housing the traditional way. Fund it, plan it, develop it. That requires making
hard budget decisions. It requires the slow, unglamorous work of actual housing development.
It doesn't give you a televised press conference with the community advocates standing behind you.
Bisson chose the path that looked bold on camera. The property owners, the hotel workers, the vacation
rental managers and the cleaning staff, they're absorbing the cost. So Bill 9 passes and the
damage is done. Just imagine if instead of upending the vacation rental and tourism industry, the mayor
would have started the process of building affordable housing. It is possible that by the
time the first vacation rental becomes phased out, we could have had thousands of affordable units
becoming available without the cost and destruction to our current economy. I believe there is more at
work here than affordable housing with our current mayor. After 19 months of hearings, hundreds of
hours of public testimony, a you hero economic study that the county struggled to find anyone
willing to conduct, and a temporary investigative group, the Maui County Council passed Bill 9 on
December 15, 2025 and the vote was 5 to 3. Mayor Bisson signed it into law that same afternoon.
Three council members voted against it. Tom Cook, Ellis Lee and Yuki Lee Sugimura, who is currently
running for mayor, their concerns were consistent. The bill would damage the economy, undermine tax
revenue, put jobs at risk and lack any serious mechanism to ensure that displaced units would
actually become affordable housing. Council member Tom Cook, who would later introduce Bill 88,
wrote publicly that his opposition was not to addressing Maui's housing challenges, it was to
doing so in a way that wrecked the economy with no plan to replace what was lost.
As signed, TBR rights end January 1st, 2029 in West Maui, January 1st, 2031 everywhere else.
Lawsuits are already in motion and the market has already priced in the damage.
So now we come to Bill 88, which is what brought many of you here today and I want to be direct
about what this bill is. Bill 88 is damage control. It was introduced by Tom Cook, one of the
three council members who voted against Bill 9. The Temporary Investigative Group had recommended
this exact companion legislation before Bill 9 was even passed. The fact that it had to be
introduced separately after the fact by an opponent of Bill 9, rather than being built into
the original framework, well that tells you everything about how poorly Bill 9 was constructed.
What Bill 88 does, it creates two new hotel zoning designations, H3 for former A1 properties
and H4 for former A2 properties, that allow qualifying apartment zone properties to continue
operating TBRs legally. The zoning designation applies at the building level, but TBR rights are
effectively enforced at the unit level, capped at whatever was documented as of January 7th, 2022.
This creates a two-layer test. The building must qualify and your specific unit must have been
documented as a rental. To qualify, a property must meet all four of these criteria, miss one
and you're out. Item one, the 1989 building age test. So a valid permit on or before April 20th,
post-1989 buildings categorically are ineligible. Provision number two, proven TBR history before
September of 2020. Active legal TBR use before September 24th, 2020 with paper proof real
property tax records or GET and TAT payment documentation. No paper trail, no protection.
Number three, unit count freeze at January 2022. No new TBR units can be added, frozen at whatever
was operating on January 7th, 2022. The final version of the bill specifically removed the word
expanding to prevent renovation loopholes. And finally, number four, current tax compliance.
Active GET and TAT licenses, fully current on all taxes and fees. Outstanding issues,
automatic disqualifier. All right, the list problem. Let's talk about that. Here's where
Bill 88 has its own serious flaw. And it's one thing that was created by the people trying to
fix the problem. Exhibit one, the list attached to Bill 88 includes roughly 130 properties
and about 7,167 units that the planning department identified as potentially qualifying.
But the bill itself says the list does not grant any entitlement and is subject to error.
Worse, the final amendment to Bill 88 called FD1 removed the only defined pathway for unlisted
properties to make their case. The original version had a notification requirement. If you
weren't on the list, you could notify the planning department, document your TBR use, and get
confirmation before the ordinance took effect. That pathway is now gone. In its place, a legal
gray area with no clear process and no defined appeal mechanism. For unlisted owners who believe
they qualify, the options are approach the planning department directly, hire a land use
attorney, challenge a denial through the board of variances and appeals, or wait. None of these are
the clear, fair process these owners deserve. So as I close out the video, let me give you
the entire complete picture. Maui's condo market is experiencing its worst environment since the
bottom of the Great Recession. Property values have declined 20 to 40 percent, numbers the county's
own economist projected. Thousands of legal property owners are navigating uncertain zoning,
active litigation, and a market that has already priced in their losses. And affordable housing?
The units being stripped of vacation rental rights are not becoming affordable housing.
They're becoming second homes or a market rate long-term rental that most Maui families still
can't afford. There is no new construction plan. There is no affordability mechanism.
There is no workforce housing initiative attached to any of this. Mayor Bisson got his political
moment. He got to stand at the podium with grassroots advocates and call it a victory for
local families. The property owners, the workers, and the broader Maui economy are still absorbing
the cost of that victory. Bill 88 is an important bill. For qualifying owners, it's a genuine
lifeline, but it is fundamentally an attempt to repair damage that didn't need to happen the way
it happened. Damage created by passing Bill 9 without the companion zoning framework in place,
without an economic replacement plan, and without a serious funded pathway to actual affordable
housing. If your property is on exhibit one list, get your documentation together now and confirm
your unit status with the planning department. If you're not on the list, don't wait. Talk to a
Maui land use attorney immediately. If you're a Maui voter, ask your elected officials what the
actual affordable housing plan is. Ask what replaces the jobs and tax revenue. Ask why this was done
before H3 and H4 framework was in place. Those are not unfair questions. They are the most
important questions. Mahalo for watching. If you found this useful, please share it. There are a lot
of people on Maui who need to understand exactly what has happened here and what still needs to
happen to make it right. I'm Tom Tezak with Hawaii Life. Please let me know what questions you have.
Comment below. Let me know what your thoughts are or if you interpret the Bill 88
or what has happened in a different way. I'd love your thoughts and your ideas so that we
can get to the bottom of all of this and help everybody make some great decisions.