Honda Odyssey vs. Toyota Sienna vs. Kia Carnival Hybrid: Which Minivan Is Best?

Van & Truck Lab
86 followers
When I heard that there was an updated Odyssey, a refreshed Sienna, and a Carnival that now comes
with a hybrid powertrain, I couldn't wait to jump on this assignment because I love a minivan.
We've got three minivans here competing for your family's affection, starting with the Kia
Carnival, now with a new hybrid powertrain, better technology, improved driver aids, and
more rugged styling. And if you're going to talk minivans, you can't do it without bringing the
Toyota Sienna, which is here with an improved interior that features better technology,
larger screens, and even a fridge and a vacuum right in the center of it. And then of course
there's the Honda Odyssey, which somehow outsells both of these even though it hasn't been redesigned
since 2018. It's here for 2025 with a few tweaks and some new technology in an attempt to keep it
competitive with the updated Toyota and Kia. So we're going to take all these minivans, do a deep
dive on the interior to find all those family-friendly features, tell you how they drive,
talk about fuel economy value, all that good stuff, and then we're going to culminate with
the world-famous Edmunds rating to tell you which one is most worth your family's hard-earned dollars.
But before we do that, please like and subscribe and head over to edmunds.com where you will find
all the information you need on a new or used vehicle, including the world-famous Edmunds rating,
and we'll even make you a cash offer on your current set of wheels. Time to pretend I have
some kids. We're going to kick things off here in the Kia because while all the minivans got updates
for 2025, the biggest updates were here in the Carnival, starting with that hybrid powertrain.
We're going to talk about that a little bit more later, but inside big updates for the Kia as well.
Brand new screens up here, and even though minivans, they make most of their money in the
second and third rows. That's really why you're buying a minivan, right? For that extra seating
and cargo flexibility, the front seats of these vehicles are still important because
that's where mom or dad is going to sit. So up here in the Kia, the Kia has the most aesthetically
pleasing interior of this trio by far. This cream and Navy color scheme is great. This screen setup,
we really like as well. It looks and feels more modern than the other two minivans by a pretty
good margin. And on top of that, I think that the Kia might have the most comfortable front seats of
the whole bunch. Very easy to find a comfortable driving position and very supportive for those
long road trips you're going to take with the family. Now, even though I like the front part
of this Carnival for adults, for families, there are a few compromises that you're going to need
to make, especially in the area of small item storage. The Carnival just has a lot less of it
than the other two competitors here. You basically have this bin here and a center console, which is
better than most SUVs, but in the minivan class, it's far, far behind both the Toyota and the Honda.
There is though one thing that the Kia does well, and that is it has giant cup holders so you could
fit your giant water bottle. Now, this is the eight seat configuration of the Carnival. They
actually offer a seven seat configuration as a no cost option, and that installs two, what they call
VIP seats here in the second row. But those seats are more for adults. They're not really family
friendly. So we've chosen to feature this configuration in this video. The thing that's
unique about the Carnival that we really like is that each of these three seats, they can all
individually slide forward and back. So you're not getting the same amount of travel that you're
getting in, let's say the Toyota, but the center seat here is, let's say you have a kid here in a
car seat, you can actually slide it forward so that you can reach them a little bit better. The
Odyssey's center seat doesn't do this. And the other thing about the Odyssey's center seat is
that the seatbelt is actually mounted in the ceiling. So if you're going to pull that belt
down from the ceiling, it kind of gets in the way of stuff. It's really nice to have this all
contained in one unit that can again, move back and forth. The downside though of having that is
that to take this seat out, it's really, really heavy. So we just slide it forward here. There's a
little lever back here I pull, and then I'm going to try to lift the seat out. And I cannot, it's
very heavy. There's no way that it could get this out. And even me, it's a bit of a struggle to kind
of wrestle this thing out. Once it's out, you can actually store it in the well back there or just
keep it in your garage if you don't need it. The Carnival's third row is pretty good on legroom,
but tight when it comes to headroom. So if you're an adult, you're going to want to recline the seat
a little bit to give yourself a little bit of extra space so your head doesn't hit the ceiling
in case the vehicle goes over a bump or anything like that. Two USB-C charging ports back here,
one on either side. And the nice thing about the Kia is that you get pretty good storage back here.
So cup holders, but also little cubbies for your phone and stuff like that. Fitting three people
back here will be a tough proposition. Two would be fine. And kids, they'll fit back here all right.
We do like that the air vents in the Carnival's third row are up here. So they give you a bit
better air circulation, but this really big and chunky C pillar definitely cuts into visibility
and can make it feel a bit claustrophobic. We're now here in the Honda, which for 2025,
also got new screens. But just looking at the setup that you have here, it doesn't really
compare to what you're getting in the Kia. Not only are the Kia screens larger, but its
infotainment system is a generation newer. Honda does offer a new Google-based multimedia system
with a larger 12.3-inch touchscreen on some of its vehicles. But for whatever reason, you're not
getting that here in the Odyssey. You're getting a nine-inch screen and you're getting one that's
mounted so high up and far back that it makes it feel even smaller. Well, that kind of speaks to
the overall feel of the front of this interior. This is probably the worst van for adults because
the seats aren't all that comfortable. And on top of that, I mean, just look at it. We had that really
nice navy cream sort of color in the Kia and here everything is black, black, and more black,
which might be flattering if you're wearing it on you, but on a car, it just feels boring and a bit
old. When it comes to front storage, the Odyssey is pretty good. You have nicely sized door pockets
and you also have this nice open area here between the seats so you can fit like a bag in there. But
the center console is a little bit small and a bunch of this storage is also taken up by the
position of this wireless charging pad. I sort of wish that this was moved somewhere else so that
maybe this bin could be larger. Then you can fit a little bit more stuff. Now that we're out of the
front row, the Odyssey finally gets a chance to shine because we think that the second and third
row of this vehicle in particular are the most family friendly of the bunch. Now the setup is
similar to what we had in the Carnival, an eight seat configuration overall with a removable center
seat here that takes you down to seven. But if you don't need to use it often, you can actually just
rip this out really easily, store it in the back or store it in your garage. Two big differences
though between the Kia and the Honda. For the center seat here, the seatbelt is not contained
within this center seat. It actually comes down here from the ceiling. So if you are going to have
three people here, you kind of have to bring this down. And as you can see, it sort of impedes on
the space for the passenger over here. So that's not ideal. But the benefit of that is that overall
this center seat is much lighter. We had a real struggle getting the Kias out, but here in the
Honda, I can pick it up while sitting down. It only seems to weigh about 15 to 20 pounds, making
it much easier to maneuver. Now with the middle seat out, we can show you what a very cool feature
of the second row is and why we like it so much for families in particular. Now you're not going
to get quite the same level of forward and back adjustment in the Odyssey. These tracks don't go
back as far, but that's okay. You can still move the seat plenty forward enough to be able to easier
reach a kid from the front seat. But what we really like about it is that if I reach over here on the
side and pull this little lever, I can actually slide all the way over. Both of these seats can
move left, right, however you need them to. So if you have two kids, you can put them in a spot
where it's easy for a front passenger to reach. Or if you're a parent who wants to ride next to
your kid and not have to sit in an uncomfortable middle seat, you have that option as well.
The Odyssey's third row is the most spacious and comfortable of the bunch. The recline
on this third row is pretty comfortable and you can sit back here even as an adult for a long trip
and be okay. In this seat at least. On the other side, it's not so great and that's because the
mount for the center seat seatbelt is right above your head if you sit on this side and it ducks
down pretty low so it really cuts into headroom. A kid will be okay but for an adult their head's
going to be really close and if you go over any kind of bump their head is probably going to run
into some pretty hard plastic. There's a lot to like about this third row. Visibility is quite
good. You get big windows here but one thing I don't like is that the vents are not ceiling
mounted. They're actually down here so they're tucked in right next to where your leg is and
it doesn't really circulate air as well back here as a ceiling vent would like you're getting in the
other vans. And finally we've come to the Toyota Sienna. The most expensive vehicle here but the
inside actually kind of feels like it. I think this has a slight leg up on the Kia when it comes to
sort of materials and overall niceness of the cabin even though I do prefer the design of the
Carnival a little bit more. Inside the Sienna got a bunch of changes as well including a new 12.3 inch
touchscreen that matches the size of the one of the Kia though base trims of the Sienna are going
to have to make do with an 8 inch screen. Toyota has made the center console here kind of like a
bridge and what that does is it sort of separates the front two seats quite a bit. I feel like I'm
on my own little cocoon here but it's a very comfortable cocoon. This seat has a lot of support
again very one that you'd be very happy to sit in for a long road trip. The Sienna kills it when it
comes to small item storage. You get big pockets in the doors like you got in the Odyssey but this
whole center console layout is much more conducive to storing all of your stuff. Down here underneath
the tunnel you get a pretty big area to fit a bag and here in the center console much much deeper
than the one the Odyssey as you can see I can basically fit my whole arm in there but my
favorite part about the front is this shelf that runs basically across the entire width of the
dashboard. This is where the wireless charging pad is so it's very easy to put your phone there out
of the way. It's also been increased in power so it now charges faster for 2025 but you can basically
put all sorts of tiny odds and ends right up here they don't slide around because they have a little
ridge right here to keep everything in place and it's just basically a nice spot to put phones,
pens, little bags, snacks, anything. The only downside is these cup holders they're a little
bit small you can probably fit a can but you can't fit any type of big water bottle or anything.
The Toyota is the only seven seat minivan that we have here and that's because once you get past
the bottom two trim levels they all come standard with captain's chairs and seating for seven so if
you want a bench you're gonna have to go down the model lineup. Here we're in the top trim level and
so it's got all the bells and whistles pretty much but the goodies in the Toyota start before you
even get in and that's because it's got these nice really large grab handles with two spots one for
adults and one for kids so even though all these minivans are actually pretty easy to climb into
even easier to hop up into the Sienna. Now these captain's chairs have one really cool feature and
that is they can go really really far back and they can go really really far forward so if you
need access to your kid you can move them closer and if you want some space for you to extend this
footrest and relax for a bit you can do that too. Now since this is a platinum trim it comes with
this extended center console standard and this includes a fridge as well as a vacuum so the
little fridge unit here is actually quite big it'll fit six of these water bottles and the cool
thing about this refrigerator is it comes with two coldness settings so one just for keeping drinks
cold but also a freezer setting so if you want to bring things like popsicles for the kids you can
finally do so without having to lug a cooler around. Now down here this little hole in the
bottom of the center console that's for the vacuum and now in preparing for this video I don't have
kids of my own but I was told that kids they just dump everything everywhere and they pour things
all over the place and so things get all over the car where you wouldn't expect. The nice thing about
the Toyota and actually all these vehicles all the channels for the seats here have these little
rubber gaskets on them so they do a pretty good job of keeping things out but only the Toyota now
offers a vacuum. All right now it's time to test out how powerful this vacuum really is.
Well the good news is there's a vacuum the bad news is it doesn't seem to really work on anything
as large as goldfish so it seems to do pretty well when it's sucking up smaller objects. Anything
goldfish size or larger is going to get stuck but for smaller stuff the vacuum is actually pretty
good so for cleaning up dirt and things in the cabin it's going to be fine but for anything
bigger probably going to need to pull out the shop vac or something like that. Now the third
row within Sienna it's going to be in between size wise what you're getting in the Odyssey
and the Carnival but I do think that the Carnival's third row seat even though it's less roomy is a
bit more comfortable and that's because in the Sienna this seat cushion ends pretty abruptly.
I feel like it should extend maybe another three or four inches for it to be really comfortable
for adult passengers. Kids with shorter legs probably okay but for adults this third row
is not the best and it's also not the best because just like in the other vehicles the
center mounted seat belt is up here and so to pull it down it's going to come over the passenger here
this is probably again a third row best for two people rather than three. One other weird quirk
about the Sienna's third row it has two USB-C charging ports which is good but they're both
way over there so if you're sitting in this seat and you need to charge something you're
gonna have to go across the other occupant potentially to plug in and if that other
occupant happens to be your sibling that could be a point of conflict. For this section we combined
the interior and comfort parts of the Edmunds rating into a single score. The Sienna came out
on top thanks to its well-appointed interior, easy to use controls, and comfortable seats well
across the first two rows at least. It was followed by the Odyssey which impressed with
its interior flexibility in that easily removable second row middle seat. Last was the Carnival
Hybrid but this was a really close race and if it had just a bit more room in its third row
and a more comfortable quieter cabin it could have closed the gap. Kia offers a very strong technology
suite here in the Carnival these 12.3 inch screens the pair of them are standard on all trim levels
which is really nice and they're significantly larger than the screens that you're going to get
in the Odyssey especially. Other things that we like about this infotainment system its simplicity
very easy to use very shallow menu structure and of course wireless android auto and apple carplay
which is helpful because the native maps app is not so great. One thing that we don't like is this
part right here and Kia has put this on several vehicles that it's made before we just don't like
the fact that you have to choose between having climate controls or multimedia controls here so
basically if I have climate up I lose access to the volume knob so someone in the passenger seat
can't change the volume of the system not great there but Kia does one other great thing here
on the interior you get a very nice passenger view camera so if you need to take a quick look
at kids in either the second or third row you can easily see them there and on top of that
the surround view camera is also excellent multiple views including this handy view here
where you get a kind of a fly around of the van and you can sort of see if there are any small
objects and things around you. The Kia is also well equipped when it comes to safety technology
with adaptive cruise control lane keep blind spot warnings all that good stuff. All in all
the tech package in the Carnival really compelling easy to use and family friendly. Another feature
that the Kia has that it shares with the Toyota is a rear view camera mirror and that means that
if you have folks sitting in all three rows or a lot of cargo and things you can actually still
see out of the back using this camera very handy. Inside the Carnival has six USB-C ports to charge
all the devices and while that's not quite one per seat we do really like where they're placed.
Kia puts the one to the second row in the back of these seats here which actually makes them more
convenient to reach and on top of that it has two household outlets one on the back of the center
console here and one in the cargo area so even though there's not the same amount of USB-C ports
that you're getting in the other vehicles I think that the raw charging power in this vehicle is
pretty much equal because those household outlets really useful. Now when it comes to technology
the Odyssey just feels deficient against the other two vehicles and that's not just because
its screen is smaller it's also because it lacks a lot of features that the other two have that I
think are very important for minivans. Now this screen the only thing that I like about it is
that Honda puts a very nice small shelf right here for you to put your thumb so it's very easy
to sort of balance and use the screen but the problem is that the menu structure is a bit
convoluted and it's a lot of button presses to get wherever you need. The saving grace for this
system is wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay so you'll just get in fire up your phone and
hopefully not have to use this too much. When it comes to safety features the Odyssey is missing
one key one and that would be a surround view camera so I'm going to put it in reverse here
as you can see all I get is a rear view. Now what we did was we put a piece of luggage just
basically right off the passenger side rear bumper and as you can tell I have no idea that
it's there. The other two vehicles have surround view cameras which will tell you if there are
things around and the Toyota even goes a step further and we're going to show you that in a
second but here in the Honda just having a rear view camera is really really disappointing and
on top of that the driver aids on the highway the lane keep isn't great you could bounce between
the lane lines like this and the adaptive cruise control system the moment you come to a stop you
have to resume it the other two give you a bit more leeway so they're easier to drive in traffic.
All in all even though the Odyssey got a tech update for 2025 it still feels in a lot of ways
like it's stuck in 2019. In the cabin though there are two handy tech features the first one is a
cabin watch monitor as you can see though the camera isn't quite as good as the one you're
going to get in the Kia but the nice thing about this is that if you have a child here
in a rear-facing car seat you're actually going to be able to see their face so if you have a
really small child that's helpful. The other feature that they have here is of course cabin
talk and this is going to transmit my voice throughout the speakers in the cabin the Kia
also has a similar feature but for some reason Toyota discontinued it in 2025 so no more cabin
talk in the Sienna. Odyssey actually does quite well when it comes to charging though you have
the wireless charging pad here and you have eight usb ports two type a six type c and three of them
are actually found in the third row so plugs for all the devices. Technology in the Toyota is a
plus it starts here with the screen the latest Toyota infotainment system and Toyota has by far
the best native navigation of these they actually pull in google results ratings and phone numbers
and stuff so you get much better navigation experience here and if you don't like it
of course there's wireless android auto and apple carplay stop me if you've heard that before. I do
really enjoy the placement of this screen it's easy to reach from both front seats and you can
even reach the edge here without really stretching out too far and Toyota's new menu structure is
very shallow it's pretty easy to find what you want and if you can't its voice commands are a
hair better than both the Honda and the Kia as well. Now it's not all good news for the Toyota
because they have for 2025 lost some family-friendly features so we showed you those in-car
cabin cameras and we showed you the microphone systems in both the Kia and the Honda those are
two features that the Toyota lacks if we're going to talk cameras we have to talk surround view
cameras and the one here is excellent so if I toss the car in reverse you can kind of see
we have a pretty good just kind of standard surround view camera view but the other cool
thing that you can do is if you're in park and you hit the camera button you'll actually fly
around the car and it will kind of show you all the small objects that are around you so we did
the same test here in the Toyota that we did with the Honda with the piece of luggage that is kid
size and it showed up easily anything being left around the car this view is a really quick way to
make sure that everything is okay before you back up. When you're on the move when it comes to safety
technology the Toyota has roughly the same set of features as the Kia you don't get that blind
spot monitor but you do get a rear view camera mirror and of course you get adaptive cruise
control lane keep all that good stuff the lane keep a little bouncy but not nearly as bad as
you're getting in the Honda and the adaptive cruise control both speeds up and slows down
very smoothly. Thanks to its solid in-car technology offerings and useful driver aids
the Sienna takes the win here followed by the Carnival Hybrid. Clearly in third though was the
Odyssey with its small touchscreen and buggy driver aids though it offers plenty of charge
ports for all of a family's devices. So let's talk cargo now the Carnival has the most room behind
its third row but let's be honest all three of these minivans really excel when it comes to space
in any configuration a minivan will always be better than an SUV because this load-in height
is a lot better and because all three of these have giant wells behind the third row to fit stuff
now if you need to fit really really big items the Kia and the Honda are going to be much better for
that because their captain's chairs and their middle seats both come out in the Toyota you're
stuck with those captain's chairs which do collapse a little bit but will still be there
so for carrying really big items Kia and Honda have a big advantage. You didn't actually think
that we'd go over all this minivan stuff and not cover car seats did you? Because here at Edmunds
we test everything. The reason that we're here in the Odyssey is because we think that
in a field of competitors that's all pretty good when it comes to car seats the Odyssey is still
the best and the reason for that is in large part due to the second row flexibility so we've taken
out the middle seat right now and as you can see we've slid both of these seats over to the left
to demonstrate that even with a car seat installed you can still get pretty good access to the third
row here in the Honda. None of these vehicles do a great job with a car seat installed of tilting
and sliding forward so you can't actually fit behind most of these seats to get to the third
row but with the Honda since you slide them all over even an adult can fit through this gap right
here and get to the third row easily and even though these seats again they don't have the same
backwards travel so you're not going to get a ton of room like you're getting in the Sienna or the
Kia with the captain's chairs they do come forward quite a bit and you have a better way to reach
small children. Let's say a newborn to three or four years of age where you really need to have
access to be able to hand them snacks tissues whatever they need at all times the Odyssey is
a clear best choice because of one easy to reach them and two just the flexibility with these
captain's chairs. Now the Carnival it has pretty good room but it struggles because its upper latch
anchors are located in a really weird spot instead of just being on the back of the seat
for whatever reason they're way down at the bottom of the seat where they're really hard to reach.
The other problem the Kia faces is that it's not as tall vertically as the other two minivans so if
you have a tall child seat like this one it can be hard to maneuver it into place in the Kia
easier than in an SUV let's say but not as easy as it is in the Odyssey or the Sienna. Car seat
installation in the Sienna is quite easy it has a really good set of lower latch anchors but the
shape of those captain's chairs means that if you want the seat to fit snugly both on the back and
on the bottom you kind of have to recline the seat a little bit and in doing so that actually pushes
the kid away from the parents a little bit more so it's again harder to reach and access them.
If your kids are a bit older let's say five and up where they can be a bit more independent and
maybe even buckle themselves in then the Sienna becomes a great option because it's a bit roomier
you have a bit more travel in that second row but until then the Odyssey is a better choice for
young children. One more thing about the Sienna that we want to mention if you do want to have
better access to that third row don't get the top trim level the platinum just adds that large center
console it makes it really hard to climb to the third row even through the middle go for a lower
trim level save some money you don't need that weak vacuum anyway and just give yourself more
flexibility in the interior. All these minivans offer great storage in the rear and are better
at handling car seats than any mid-size SUV but what decided this category was in-cabin storage
where the Toyota and the Honda hold a clear advantage over the Kia. The Sienna and Odyssey
share this win with the Carnival just behind. Okay so when it comes to driving none of these minivans
are really going to blow your socks off but that doesn't mean that there are some slight differences
in how they drive. We're here in the Carnival Hybrid and this is the minivan that got the
biggest mechanical changes for this year with the addition of that hybrid powertrain.
It makes very similar power to the Toyota but both of them make less power than the Odyssey
does and also less power than the V6 versions of the Carnival does as well. The hybrid system in
the Kia it doesn't really feel like you're giving up a lot of speed compared to what you're getting
out of the V6 but I will say that the hybrid system in the Sienna is smoother especially at
low speeds. The Kia is a bit jumpy while the Toyota does a better job of blending from electric
to gas power and just gives you a very sort of smooth driving experience from a stop to about
15 or 20 miles an hour. Not to say that the Kia is bad it's just that the Sienna feels a bit more
refined. When the gas engine kicks on in both the Carnival and the Sienna it does so in kind of a
loud coarse fashion and the Odyssey is the quietest and most refined of this trio. The Carnival does
ride pretty well most of the time but when the pavement gets a little bit broken or you're going
over bumps and things it does feel a bit sort of jittery. Sienna does a much better job of ironing
those things out and the Odyssey even better still. If we're talking about which of these
three is the best to drive the clear winner is the Odyssey. Its powertrain is the most responsive
and its steering and handling also gives it the best agility of the three. Where the Toyota has
an advantage though over its two rivals is that it offers all-wheel drive. Now Toyota tells us
that 63 percent of people who buy Siennas actually option all-wheel drive and what that says is that
it's really something that people who are buying minivans are looking for. So it's a bit of a
missed opportunity for both Kia and Honda to not offer all-wheel drive versions of these minivans.
You're not buying a minivan to go all speed racer but how they drive is still important. The Odyssey's
robust V6 powertrain and well-composed ride lead it to a victory here while the Sienna and Carnival
follow behind with the same driving score. But if we had to pick one we'd give the Toyota a slight
edge since its hybrid powertrain feels more refined than that of the Kia and it offers
all-wheel drive. Now we're going to talk about something extra important to families, value.
Looking at the as tested prices of these three vans the Odyssey is the cheapest by a good margin
with the Carnival splitting the difference between that and the Sienna. But for that money we found
the interior quality materials and design to be better in both the Kia and the Toyota. On top of
that the Sienna offers two years of complimentary maintenance while the Carnival's 10-year 100,000
mile powertrain warranty can't be touched by either of the other two vans. So after a long
day almost into night of testing each of these minivans out we have a clear winner by turning to
the world famous Edmunds rating. Coming in third place was the Kia Carnival in second is the Honda
Odyssey and our winner is the Toyota Sienna. Now despite the Toyota coming out on top in the overall
rating I think that we've demonstrated that each of these minivans can make a case for a different
type of family. The Carnival has the most modern feeling interior and I think the best styling of
the bunch and with its new hybrid powertrain you're not giving up much fuel economy anymore
at all. The Odyssey with its old v6 much much worse at the pump however its family friendly
features can't be denied and if you're a family with young children where you really need to have
easy access to be able to hand them things its second row flexibility might make it the best
option for you. And our winner the Toyota Sienna is the nicest it's also the most expensive and we
actually think that if you go down a trim level that would be a more family-friendly version
because then you'd have better access to that third row without the giant center console but
the Toyota's combination of value fuel economy luxury even hard to deny in this competition.
The final thing that I hope we've proven out today is that if you have a family and it is growing
that you consider a minivan over an SUV. I think that these vehicles offer a lot more practicality
and a lot more utility than so-called sport utility vehicles because of their lower height
their greater comfort and their more flexible interiors. So if after seeing all of this you
still think a minivan isn't cool enough for you you should probably suck it up and buy one anyway.
Thanks for watching. It doesn't seem to really work on anything as large as goldfish
so I don't know it doesn't seem all that useful to me. What if you just do this? Is that easier?
I was gonna eat those.
