Effective Consequences For Kids With ADHD: 6 Must-Know Ideas

Journey of loving children
22 followers
IN THIS VIDEO
Dr. Jacque breaks down the 3 LEAST helpful ideas about consequences and misbehavior, and, more importantly, the top 3 strategies that ARE actually helpful. #adhd #parenting #parentingtips
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedDr. Jackie explains that traditional punishments are often ineffective for children with ADHD. She recommends a shift toward positive reinforcement, empathy, and structured, immediate consequences that align with the child's neurological needs to foster learning and maintain a healthy parent-child relationship.
I get asked a lot about how to discipline kids with ADHD
and what consequences actually work. Parents see the meltdowns, the defiance,
the struggles with focus, and sometimes feel lost.
Parenting kids with ADHD can feel like an everyday battle where we're
constantly wondering if we're doing the right thing.
So much so that there's an overwhelming number of opinions out there.
We're bombarded with advice, some of it helpful,
much of it confusing, and some of it downright harmful.
Now, listen, this isn't a video where I'm going to just tell you
to never use consequences or to let them learn the hard way.
I want to approach things a little differently because consequences and punishment
really deserve a sensitive and nuanced discussion
in order to figure out what's best for your child.
And asking what consequences actually work for kids with ADHD is incomplete.
Because the better question really is,
how do I deal with the misbehavior when kids have ADHD?
So I'm going to answer that by breaking down the three least helpful ideas
about consequences and misbehavior, and more importantly,
the top three strategies that are actually helpful.
Because how you respond to misbehavior not only affects your child's current behavior,
but also their future well-being and the quality of the relationship with you.
And if this is the first time you're seeing one of my videos,
I'm Dr. Jackie and I've helped hundreds of families deal with ADHD and anxiety.
I make videos to help more parents get access to the support they need.
So I hope you can tap the like button below.
It'll help spread this video to more parents who need to see it.
Now let's talk about consequences.
And I feel like it's a term that can sometimes be confusing.
So what I mean by a consequence is something that you do
or that automatically occurs following a behavior
that's intended to reduce that behavior or make it stop.
You'll understand why this definition is important a little later.
In behavioral science, this is actually called a punishment.
I think you mean positive punishment.
Or something that happens to decrease the likelihood of that behavior from happening again.
However, I think that parents usually equate punishment
with something more physical or shameful or fear-based.
So regardless of the term itself, in this video,
we're actually talking about what you do or what happens when your child with ADHD misbehaves.
And there are actually three ideas I often hear about that are least useful
and really don't work for dealing with misbehavior.
Many parents who are struggling with discipline for their kids with ADHD have asked me,
is this punishment just not enough?
Should it be harsher or should I be more strict so that they learn better?
This question is even more common as kids get older
and continued misbehavior can get more challenging and severe.
While I logically see how someone might think this way,
harsh consequences actually cause even more problems.
Harsher punishments typically involve more negative parenting interactions like
criticism, negative instructions, and sometimes verbal or physical aggression.
What we know from research is that these have many negative effects on children and on parents.
And that the harsher and more negative a parent reacts,
the more a child's physiology automatically reacts
in a way that makes it even harder for them to control themselves.
We also know that when parents are taught strategies
to reduce their negative interactions with their child,
it positively impacts the child's nervous system so they can better manage their own emotions
and subsequently their own behavior.
Kids with ADHD are not usually acting out or misbehaving on purpose,
so correcting their behavior with harsher punishment isn't going to reduce the behavior.
It just ends up making them feel more guilty for things they couldn't control in the first place
or that they genuinely have a harder time controlling.
And that guilt often turns into more emotional outbursts and problem behaviors.
Kids with ADHD also tend to zero in only on the consequence itself.
Their emotional reactivity is high and so they zero in on the thing that got them there,
the harsh consequence.
And then they miss the opportunity to learn and connect
their previous behavior to that consequence.
So there isn't any learning that happens.
So the first idea that doesn't work for most kids,
and especially for kids with ADHD,
is that they need harsher punishments to learn better behavior.
So would just a natural consequence work then?
Like if a child doesn't do their homework, they might get a bad grade.
Or if they don't take a shower, they might stink.
This may not play out like you'd imagine though.
Kids with ADHD have problems with impulsivity,
where they might act without considering potential consequences.
And when you also have problems with working memory, like kids with ADHD often do,
it's harder to remember instructions and plan ahead to what might happen.
All of this makes it difficult to change kids behavior based on a future consequence.
So if you think, well, if he doesn't study,
then he might get a bad grade on the test and maybe even in the class.
It'll teach him that he needs to put in more work.
Know that I haven't seen this to be true for kids with ADHD.
There are genuine difficulties that are getting in their way,
like being able to break big tasks into smaller chunks or huge emotional overwhelm.
Ignoring these genuine problems can actually put them on the path to delinquency
because that future consequence doesn't help them learn for the next time.
The consequence actually comes too long after the behavior.
It's already too late.
The damage has been done.
So the second idea that doesn't work is to just let it take its course,
to let the situation play out
and hope they'll learn from the thing that naturally happens when they do or don't do something.
But then wouldn't using consequences yourself damage your relationships with them or damage them?
I know a lot of parents are genuinely concerned about how consequences and punishment
affect how their child feels about them and about themselves.
And I do like that parents are thinking about this.
They want to do right by their kids and their relationship.
But is there any validity to these parents' fears?
Research has shown that things like corporal punishment and excessive yelling
can damage your relationship and negatively impact kids' emotions and self-esteem.
So you should definitely avoid those.
But what about consequences like timeouts or losing a privilege?
What I've seen happen online is that conclusions that are made from one specific scenario,
like with corporal punishment, for example,
get extended to other situations where we don't have the same evidence.
I actually have not found any research showing that teaching consequences,
like losing a privilege or timeout,
are damaging to the parent-child relationship or to the child themselves.
If you're aware of scientific research that says otherwise,
please put the title of the article in the comments so I can take a look.
Know that consequences are used and taught in evidence-based treatments
like parent-child interaction therapy or parent management training.
These behavioral interventions have been shown to reduce the problems
and improve the parent-child relationship.
But here's the key with this one.
Consequences are taught as just part of a larger parenting intervention
in a very specific and pre-planned way and used sparingly.
I'll actually get more into that in a little bit.
But this is the final idea that doesn't work.
Avoiding consequences altogether because of fear that it will damage the relationship.
This can often turn into permissive parenting
where children are allowed to make their own decisions without repercussions.
And to be mentally healthy and strong, kids need boundaries.
So how do you do this then?
How do you build those boundaries?
And how do you use consequences better in a way that deals with misbehavior
and works for ADHD brains?
There are three key strategies that are far more effective than traditional punishment.
And three practical types of consequences you can use
that I'll tell you about after I introduce those strategies.
I actually already introduced the first strategy just moments ago
when I mentioned the evidence-based treatments.
Before you even get to giving a consequence,
know that there are a lot of strategies to help your child with their behavior
and to teach them right from wrong.
And research has shown that positive reinforcement strategies
like praise and rewards and encouragement
are more effective than punishment in changing behavior.
In all of my clinical work with ADHD families,
the first thing they always say helped them the most
wasn't learning and using specific consequences.
It was how to positively influence their child's behavior instead.
Consequences are intended to stop or reduce a behavior.
They don't help a child learn skills to handle that problem
or negative emotion in the future.
And they don't teach a child what to do instead.
If kids don't get enough practice or acknowledgement
when they're doing the right thing,
you'll have a much harder time dealing with misbehavior,
no matter what consequences you're using.
So the first key strategy to dealing with misbehavior
is to actually focus on positive reinforcement most often
and use consequences only sparingly.
And I have several videos about this that I'll link at the end,
some of them with practical parent examples
from my online 12-week ADHD program.
But there's also something else that's very important
when it comes to misbehavior in kids with ADHD.
And before I tell you about that,
it's time to tap the like button and subscribe
if you found this video helpful so far.
And as a positive reward for you,
I'll put up a picture of my little puppy when he was a baby.
But seriously, there is a lot more to talk about
when it comes to consequences.
I hope to do a deeper dive on the research in the future
and your support motivates me to make that happen.
Until then, I want you to think about this.
No child wakes up and thinks,
what can I do wrong today?
Kids want to be good.
So treat them as if they're trying to do the right thing.
And when they don't,
consider it a mistake or a lack of skills
rather than coming from a place of malice.
This simple mindset shift will give you more empathy
and help you better problem solve
how to approach more negative behaviors.
Put yourself in your child's position.
What's going on from their perspective?
What got in the way of them making the right choice
or behaving more appropriately?
Address that instead of doling out a punishment
for a poor behavior choice.
Connect with them about what's happening
or how they're probably feeling
before you do anything else.
Connection and validation
turn down the volume on emotions, especially shame.
You need to bring down the emotional intensity
kids are feeling
so that they have a chance to learn a different way.
What this second strategy means
is that instead of immediately jumping to punishment
for every misbehavior,
focus on understanding why your child misbehaved.
The key idea here
is to address the underlying cause of the behavior.
And you start doing that
by approaching your child with empathy and understanding.
So when might a consequence actually be appropriate
to help deal with misbehavior?
By now, I hope you've gotten the idea
that consequences should be your last resort
after you've exhausted positive reinforcement
and empathy-based approaches.
Then it really comes down to two situations
when you could use consequences.
One is when you've told your child
they need to do something
and they genuinely do need to.
And the second is when they've broken
an important pre-planned rule.
Given what we know about the genuine difficulties
for kids with ADHD,
any consequences need to have three elements
for kids to have the best chance of learning from them.
For example, let's say your child yells at you
every time you tell them no
and you've exhausted all your other positive strategies.
The first thing you need to do
is to actually plan ahead for the consequence.
For example, ahead of time,
tell your child,
every time you yell from now on,
I won't be able to help you
with anything you want or need
until you speak with me calmly.
You need to plan for these situations ahead of time.
If your child was not aware of the consequence,
isn't it kind of unfair to give them one?
And this also means that your consequences
need to be consistent.
You need to consistently give
the same pre-planned consequence
for the same misbehavior.
And then finally,
you also need to make sure
your consequences are immediate.
Remember what I said before
about consequences that may happen in the future?
For kids with ADHD,
pre-planned consequences
that have an immediate effect
and are used consistently work best.
And this is the last idea that does work.
Consequences should be pre-planned,
immediate, and consistent.
But what kind of consequences
can you plan for then?
You learned about some consequences
that aren't effective,
but what does work for kids with ADHD?
Sometimes there are natural consequences
that can happen immediately
and are a direct result of the child's actions,
but those can be harder to plan for
or do consistently.
So many times a logical consequence
may make sense.
Like if you ride your bike without a helmet,
you won't be able to ride it for a day.
But sometimes these logical consequences
aren't feasible or don't exist.
When that's the case,
remove a privilege that your child has
for a specific amount of time.
Ideally, this privilege is something
that can be repeated throughout the day
in case you need to use it multiple times.
It might be the privilege of certain toys
or devices or certain activities
or even transportation to those activities.
There are lots of possibilities here.
Choose something that makes sense
for your child and family.
And sometimes for younger kids,
the consequence can just be,
I will help you do it
or I will do it for you.
Like take a look at this example
from my 12-week program
where this parent did that really well.
The parent said,
I can't let you hurt the puppy.
Move your hands away from it.
And then the parent said,
if you don't move your hands away
from the puppy,
I will do it for you.
And then the parent said,
you're not doing what I told you to.
So now I will gently move your hands away.
It's all about setting a boundary
that doesn't allow the child
to continue the behavior.
So we should add this as a bonus idea.
Consequences that work better
for kids with ADHD
should also be focused
on setting clear boundaries
and be logical
or involve the removal of a privilege.
Ultimately, I hope you've learned
that consequences should be used
strategically, sparingly,
and as the final option
because they are not the only way
or the best way for kids
to learn about their misbehavior.
And to learn more about other ways
to encourage better behavior
in kids with ADHD,
check out these next.
As always, put your relationships first.
I'll see you in the next video.
