I test the NEW Kirkland Signature Gen 3 Forged Wedges from Costco to see how they ACTUALLY perform. Spin, feel, forgiveness, and value all matter, but the biggest question is whether these new forged wedges are good enough to earn a spot in your bag.
0:00 Kirkland Gen 3 FORGED Wedges! 1:16 Short Game Gauntlet Testing 5:20 Gen 3 & Gen 1 Comparison 7:08 Feedback, Feel & Consistency 7:40 Launch Monitor Results 8:45 WHO Are These Wedges For?
Video Summary
AI Generated
The reviewer tests the new forged Kirkland wedges to see if they can replace premium brands. While noting some inconsistencies in launch monitor data, the reviewer finds them to be a massive improvement over previous generations, offering great feel and turf interaction for a budget-friendly price of $200 for a full set.
These new Kirkland wedges cost about the same
as one premium wedge from the big brand.
They're incredibly popular.
They sell like crazy.
They're now forged.
So in today's video, I wanna find out
if this set of wedges is good enough
to replace those wedges you currently have in your bag.
So let's get into it.
Real quick, why does this even matter?
Well, Kirkland has a cult-like following in the golf space,
but they have the same amount of skeptics in the golf space
because a lot of people think
it's just knockoff, poor quality garbage.
And I, myself, kinda teeter to that side.
I tested the driver that people loved,
and mine almost broke after 20 swings.
The quality really let me down,
but then I tested the ball,
and that Generation 3.5 was pretty damn impressive
for its price point.
I've never hit the wedges,
but these look really, really good.
And for 200 bucks, a full set of forged wedges
seems too good to be true.
So I don't care about Launch Monitor right now
because wedges matter out on the golf course,
around the greens.
Can these things do what a good forged wedge needs to do?
So let's go to the golf course.
This is my short game gauntlet.
I'm gonna take all three of these wedges around the green.
We're gonna hit a handful of shots,
but just two balls at each shot
to see if these wedges can perform under pressure,
if you will, because they're thoughtfully designed.
I really like that sole.
I like the look of them.
The leading edge isn't the worst leading edge
I've ever seen,
but I wanna know if they do what they need to do out here
because Launch Monitor performance is one thing,
but golf is not played on the Launch Monitor,
especially wedges.
We gotta get them out on the golf course.
So two shots.
I'm gonna have a high standard
if this wedge or these wedges can react
the way that I want a really high quality wedge to react.
And then we're gonna see how they feel as well.
That was passing marks there,
the right level of click off the face.
And I've got a test that I'll do at the end of this
that's really gonna see what these wedges do.
Let's grab the 56, or no, let's stick with the 60
and flight this one right here
because we just passed that first one.
Now let's flight the 60 a little longer.
So this is one where I'm gonna try to really get aggressive.
We've got a little uphill.
We can fly this pretty close to the hole
and hope it stops pretty quickly.
That came out a lot lower than I wanted it to,
but it worked.
Again, a little lower than I wanted,
but the result was good.
Let's go 52 and hit that runner.
See, I got that one a little stuck in the turf
and that got through the turf well.
That saved me and that result we will take every day.
Oh, that was awesome.
Go in.
Okay, bunker shot.
Oh man, that got through the sand so well.
Didn't hit it hard enough.
That felt awesome through the sand.
Really, really good.
So did that.
That was a terrible shot.
The result wasn't passing,
but the sand interaction was absolutely passing.
We need to get the 56 out and hit that mid-height shot.
I don't think everyone would grab the 56 from here,
but I certainly would
because there's just a little too much fringe
to run the 52 or a pitching wedge.
And I don't need to get too high with it,
so this is a perfect opportunity
to hit that kind of bump and run mid-height with the 56,
but this is very chippenable.
This is one where you want a tap in.
Oh, wow.
That did exactly what it should do, 100%.
Oh, I hammered it.
But again, it did exactly what it should do.
If anything I'm noticing,
they're jumping off the face a little faster,
a little firmer than what I like,
but let's go like a 40 yard.
Let's see how that reacts.
So we'll go to the far pin,
and this is the shot that, you know,
maybe it's the third shot on the par five.
It's very straightforward.
This thing better do what I need it to do.
If I execute.
Yeah, that's a little fast off the face,
but that turf interaction is really, really solid.
If anything, we've noticed
they launch a little lower around here and a little faster.
Yeah, very interesting.
They launch really low, which is actually a great thing.
Now I got a cool test.
This is super short-sided.
This sole and back should allow me
to really get underneath this.
A little heavy, but that's not a little heavy.
That's freaking perfect.
And this is just a kind of normal fairway lie.
A little heavy there.
I caught that a little thing.
That was more execution why it went a little long.
They're doing pretty solid,
but I want to see if this forged actually feels different
and is noticeable than the old one.
So I've got my buddy's gen one.
Let's hit a couple of chips side by side
and see if there's a difference.
If I'm honest, this thing looks like garbage.
Kind of a sharp leading edge,
really unappealing back flange.
Whereas this, we have this nice two level sole.
The shape isn't terribly different,
but we should expect a difference in feel.
So this is the gen one, like a cast face.
That was pretty soft.
That was softer.
A good softer, a softer that's feedback.
Like we noticed in all the shots I hit,
I could tell if I caught it a little heavy,
if I caught it a groove low and it launched lower.
This gen one, that softness was almost a dead feel.
Like it's soft, but it has no feel to it.
Like there's no feedback.
It just feels mushy.
And then when you try to go low, that just sounds clanky.
Whereas gen three, that just sounds nippy.
Night and day, I've never hit a Kirkland wedge.
I know they're loved by many.
These are so much better than their old generations.
And maybe gen two was a wee bit better than gen one,
but this gen one just feels like insert wedge here.
Not a lot of feedback, not a lot of feel.
I mean, it still reacts fine with the turf.
Thinned it.
But this thing has feedback, feel, good turf interaction,
a lot more versatility with the sole.
And this whole set was $200.
The feedback, the feel of the wedges was really good.
The consistency of what it did off the face,
like I'm gonna really nitpick, was fine, but not the best.
We noticed the launch maybe sometimes was a little lower,
a little faster off the face.
Compared to the gen one, it's night and day.
Let me know if you use the gen two,
because even just listening to the video,
the gen one sounds like a pickleball paddle.
This sounds like a good forged wedge when you hit it.
I came in here and I hit them on the launch monitor
after the short game session.
They kind of did what I expected.
They were a little inconsistent.
I hit like an 80-yard lob wedge
just to see if I can hit the shot.
And I could, but the ball speed, the spin, the launch
varies a great deal across the 11 shots I hit.
And then I took the 52.
I was like, let's just hit a full shot and see what happens.
The wedge shaft in here is just too soft for me,
but the wedges aren't for me,
so I'm not getting too upset about it.
But again, the spin, the launch,
the ball speed varies quite a bit.
So to me, as a skeptic in this scenario,
it does speak, I think, to the quality assurances
and assembly that I personally experienced with the driver.
My driver started shake rattling after, like I said,
20 shots, but some people are amazing.
And then we've seen ball tests where they're cut open
and the insides are different.
And that Gen 1 wedge was brutal quality, let's be real.
So for 200 bucks, who are they for?
They're not for a good player.
They're a really great design.
That sole is awesome.
The feel, the forge is there,
but I don't think they're gonna deliver the consistency
and the predictability that a single-digit scratch
plus handicap player needs.
But that golfer, I don't think, is looking at these.
Someone that needs decent to good wedges
and is conscientious of the cost, these are amazing.
200 bucks for this?
Solid, great first step into forged wedges,
because if you use the Kirkland wedges,
like Tim, I borrowed his Gen 1s.
I wanna give him these.
It'll be night and day for him.
He's got a set of P790 irons,
so he's got a forged feel,
and then he's got wedges that feel like pickleball paddles.
I wanna give these to him,
because they're not gonna do me any good here.
So they're great for a player like Tim
who's shooting in the 90s,
but wants better feedback, better feel around the greens,
and the consistency of the ball speed and the spin
isn't really gonna show itself.
So that player that doesn't have wedges, perfect for them,
that needs new wedges but doesn't want to
or care to spend as much money on Vokies,
Clevelands, what have you,
because they don't really know the difference
in terms of consistency, predictability,
that kind of stuff.
These are awesome.
And to the Kirkland heads, you're gonna love these,
because they are night and day better than the old wedges,
and you saw that in that test.
Let me know, do you use Kirkland wedges, irons?
Do you have a full bag?
Because they've got literally everything.
Do you have that bag?
Are you excited to get these?
Are they sold out where you live?
Sound off in those comments.
Let's talk Kirkland Gen 3 wedges,
and we'll see you in the next one.