In 1449, the Ming dynasty is thrown into chaos after Emperor Yingzong is captured by Esen Taishi at the Battle of Tumu. In his absence, the court in Beijing deposes him and installs his brother, the Jingtai Emperor, leaving Yingzong stranded in Mongol captivity as both prisoner and political liability. Yet, Yinzong will survive, return to Beijing, only to be confined to house arrest. But he will eventually be restored to the throne in the “Forcing the Palace Gate” Incident, a sudden coup that overthrows Jingtai. His second reign, the Tianshun era, quickly turns into a cycle of purges, revenge, and instability, as former allies and rivals alike are swept up in court violence, including the execution of Yu Qian. From Mongol captivity to imperial restoration and internal collapse, this is the turbulent return of Emperor Yingzong and one of the most volatile power shifts in Ming dynasty history.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The wind blows through the Mongol army camp on a September day in 1449.
From a felt tent emerges not a Mongol warrior, but the captured emperor of China, Yingzong.
Days earlier, at the disastrous Battle of Tumu, the armies of the Ming dynasty have been annihilated.
As a messenger from Beijing finally arrives, the captive Yingzong's anxious wait for news from
the imperial court is at an end. But when he hears the message, his heart skips a beat.
The imperial court has deposed him in favour of his younger brother, Jingtai.
Yingzong is now Taishanghuang, retired emperor. And yet, despite finding himself a prisoner of
the Mongols, deposed and isolated, Yingzong will find his way back to the dragon throne.
Yingzong's deposition was as much a blow to him as it was to his captors.
The imperial court instructed nearby garrisons not to deal with the Mongols,
and to disregard any orders issued in the name of the deposed emperor.
The Mongol commander found himself unable to use his now devalued hostage to take control of Ming
garrisons or extract ransoms. Prior to the invasion, Yingzong had refused the diplomatic
marriage of one of Esen's sons into the imperial clan of the Ming dynasty. Now in no position to
refuse, he conceded to Esen's demand, on the condition that the wedding be organised after
he was restored to the throne. Esen therefore marched on Beijing,
under the pretense of restoring his hostage to the throne.
When Yanghe mountain pass proved too strong to breach, the Mongols decided to attack the
capital from the south, breaking through at Zijing pass. As explained in my Jingtai emperor video,
the Ming successfully put together a new 200,000 man strong garrison in Beijing.
Esen's repeated Mongol charges on the capital were constantly driven back by Chinese gunpowder.
When the Mongol warlord learned that his reinforcements failed to breach Juyong pass,
he eventually decided to withdraw from the North China plain.
Marking the symbolic end of Esen's ambitions, his nominal overlord, Toktobukha or Taishun Khan of
the Northern Yuan, sent a tribute mission to the Ming court, appeasing diplomatic tensions
between Mongolia and China. Esen's failure at Beijing had further isolated the captive Yingzong.
Most of the deposed emperor's Chinese entourage abandoned him and escaped back to the Ming.
While Esen had lost the advantage, strategic plans kept flowing to him from turncoat Ming
eunuch Xining, who had defected to him after being captured alongside the emperor.
Among other ideas, Xi proposed to conquer the south of the empire and install Yingzong as a
rival emperor in Nanjing. But Esen, knowing he lacked the power for such grand campaigns,
merely resorted to occasional raids on the frontier. His encroachment on Ming lands would
end in early 1450. When Xining, sent to the Ming to negotiate Yingzong's release,
was promptly executed by the Chinese, Esen retreated back to Mongolia.
Demoralized, Yingzong was taken even deeper into the steppe.
While captivity amongst the Mongols was certainly harsh for a son of heaven,
he was treated fairly by his captors. Yingzong reportedly had his own yurt,
the company of one officer turned friend captured with him, Yuan Bin, and an interpreter,
Xining. Over time, he also seems to have developed somewhat cordial relations with Esen.
Yet, months went by, envoys came and went, and still no prospects for his return to China
appeared. Desperate, Yingzong reportedly begged to be brought back to China,
even to take up purely ritual duties or as a simple commoner,
but now firmly installed on the throne, the Jingtai Emperor never even mentioned his elder
brother in his embassies, let alone discussed bringing him back. It would not be until a whole
year after his capture, in September 1450, that official Yangshan, either duty-bound or perhaps
to gain a prestigious ally, offered to personally buy the release of Yingzong, despite no green
The proposed sum was meagre, but by now, Esen knew his dreams of exchanging Yingzong for
considerable concessions from China had all but collapsed. After hosting a great banquet
in honour of his hostage, he released the deposed emperor. Both figures parted amicably,
and after a few weeks, Yingzong finally saw the red walls of the forbidden city again.
He was welcomed by his younger brother, the Jingtai Emperor,
who by now was determined not to return the throne he had gained from him.
But after months of tribulation, and glad to be back in a familiar environment,
Yingzong swore his complete renunciation of the throne. This would turn out to be a lie.
Jingtai had his brother escorted to take up residence in the Southern Inner Palace,
a modest residence on the fringes of the imperial city.
It soon became clear to Yingzong that this would be a barely gilded prison. The guards posted
around the Southern Palace were as much to prevent people from entering, as to prevent him from
leaving. Although certainly better than in his yurt on the steppe, Yingzong's conditions in the
Southern Palace were reportedly harsh, with meagre supplies and oppressive surveillance.
In 1452, when construction for the Longfu Temple in Beijing required timber,
pillars were taken from the Southern Palace and its tall trees were cut down,
allowing for even more surveillance. Every year, when Yingzong's birthday came,
his remaining allies and supporters requested to go and congratulate him,
but each time they were denied by the throne. However, the deposed emperor was not entirely
alone. His consul Qian, the retired empress deposed alongside him, and his concubines joined
him. During the years of house arrest, they would bear him three more sons, adding to the three he
still had. The Jingtai emperor, determined to install his own line on the throne, deposed
Yingzong's eldest son, Crown Prince Zhu Jiansheng, in favour of his own. But when the latter died,
Jingtai firmly refused the court's requests to reinstate Zhu Jiansheng,
even having some officials flogged to death. This alienated a large part of his government,
among whom many realised they could rally around Yingzong's cause. A conspiracy began to brew to
restore him to the throne, but such a coup would need influential conspirators. Eunuch General
Cao Yixiang had emerged by serving in the Luchuan campaigns and in suppressing the peasant
rebellions in Fujian. As a eunuch, he had strong influence within and easy access around the
Forbidden City, and perhaps aimed to acquire a similar status to his disgraced mentor, Wang Zhen,
the main culprit of the Tuomu disaster. General Sheheng had become influential within the army
as a key figure in the heroic defence of Beijing. The power-hungry commander had however lost
prestige after his falling out with his ally-turned-rival Yutian, supporter of the Jingtai
regime. On the civilian side, Yang Shan, head of the censorate, was the official who had personally
paid for Yingzong's release from the Mongols. He evidently saw the occasion to be richly rewarded
for his troubles. Finally, Xu Youzhen, an official who had fallen out of favour after
urging the court to flee south during the Tuomu crisis. Though he had somewhat redeemed himself
by expertly repairing the Yellow River dykes, he likely realised the opportunity of skyrocketing
his career and masterminded the coup. In the very first hours of the 11th February 1457,
soldiers stormed the southern palace and broke in, kowtowing to Yingzong and announcing he was
being restored to the throne. Whether the deposed emperor was actually in on the conspiracy is
unclear, but he was promptly placed in a sedan chair and brought to the Forbidden City. Meanwhile,
Sheheng's soldiers had broken into the Forbidden City with the help of eunuch-general Cao Jixiang,
an event remembered as the Duomen incident, forcing the palace gate. Jingtai was thrown
out of the imperial quarters as Yingzong was sat down back on the dragon throne he had lost
eight years prior. The morning's court audience was subsequently summoned and court officials
were astonished to find not Jingtai, but the reinstated Taishan Huang. A new era name was
proclaimed for his second reign, Tianshun, obedience to heaven, an ironic choice given the
nature of his restoration. In the span of a few hours, a full-scale coup had been expertly
orchestrated. Now that he was restored to the throne, Yingzong's first orders involved promoting
the conspirators that had brought him back. Xu Youzhen became head of the Grand Secretariat,
minister of war, and an earl. Cao Jixiang was made director of ceremonies, at the top of the
eunuch hierarchy, and his adoptive son Cao Qin, soon to be the leader of a rebellion, an earl.
Sheheng was made a duke. Yangshan became minister of rights. Wang Zhen was posthumously rehabilitated
and a stele commemorating him was raised in Zhihua Temple. Just as he promoted his allies,
Yingzong purged the court from any protesters or supporters of Jingtai. The latter was discredited,
demoted to a simple prince, and died of illness or assassination shortly after the coup.
His works were banned or appropriated by Yingzong. Jingtai's senior Grand Secretary,
Chen Xun, and many other ministers and Grand Secretaries were stripped of their ranks,
relegated to minor posts, or banished to military service in the frontier.
Only one minister, Wang Ao, was allowed to stay in office. In a case of blatant injustice,
Yu Qian, arguably the saviour of the Ming dynasty, who had rallied the court into making a stand at
Beijing and expertly organised its heroic defence, was sentenced to death for treason,
having been a key supporter of Jingtai and having become an enemy of the conspirators.
Initially sentenced to Lingchi, slow slicing, or death by a thousand cuts,
he was finally simply beheaded, alongside Minister Wang Wen and four chief eunuchs.
These great purges made the Yingzong Emperor greatly unpopular. Before long,
he would even purge some of the conspirators who had brought him back to the throne,
tired of their constant demand for further rewards and bickering between each other.
The first to fall was Senior Grand Secretary Xu Youzhen in June,
who was demoted and banished to the frontier and replaced by Li Qian.
Many Grand Secretaries resigned in protest.
Yingzong had to improve his image. He would find opportunity in one forgotten figure,
Zhu Wengui. This now elderly imperial prince had been placed under house arrest as a toddler
by the Yongle Emperor after he had overthrown Zhu Wengui's father, the Jianwen Emperor.
Yingzong may have genuinely experienced compassion for the man after his own years under house
arrest. Zhu Wengui was freed, but after having spent 55 years, his entire life, under house
arrest, it was said that he could not recognise common animals like horses and cattle, and died
Speaking of horses, an interesting anecdote recalls that Yingzong once offered rewards for
any soldier capable of capturing a live tiger. Such an animal was delivered three days later
by frontier soldiers. The Emperor later had the tiger fight against his prized warhorse,
the white-hoofed jujube-red steed. After the imperial steed defeated the tiger by a kick to
its face, Yingzong commissioned paintings of the horse by court artists and personally wrote a
hymn of praise titled, Song of the White-Hoofed Jujube-Red Steed Defeating the Tiger.
Initially simply forced to retire, he was eventually found complicit in the affairs
of his allegedly corrupt nephew, Shi Biao. Shi Heng died in prison in March 1460,
shortly after the execution of his nephew and other relatives.
Yingzong's control tightened over his former allies. Eunuch General Cao Jixiang and especially
his adoptive son, Commander Cao Qin, reportedly also implicated in corruption scandals,
perhaps realised they would be the next on Yingzong's list. They would thus try to outmanoeuvre
the throne. In the dark of night of the 7th of August 1460, loyal General Sun Tang sent an
urgent message to the Emperor. A coup was about to take place. Sun Tang was supposed to depart
later that day and lead 15,000 troops out of the capital to reinforce the northwest
in the context of Mongol raids. But it had leaked that Commander Cao Qin was apparently waiting for
the occasion to then rise up, storm the Forbidden City using his command of the Beijing garrison
and overthrow the Yingzong Emperor in a repeat of the Duomen Incident.
Upon learning the news, the Emperor ordered all gates of Beijing, including the Nine Outer Gates,
the Four Imperial Cities Gates and the Forbidden Cities Gates to be immediately sealed.
Circulation within the capital was to be impossible. When Cao Qin found himself unable
to pass through East Chang'an Gate, he realised his plot had leaked. The rebelling commander
changed plans and stormed the residence of Lu Gao, head of the Imperial Bodyguard and Secret Police
who was investigating him. He promptly murdered him and captured Senior Grand Secretary Li Xian,
Esteemed Minister Wang Ao and other high-ranking scholars. Without much of a choice, Li Xian agreed
to write a personal note to the Emperor, claiming Cao Qin just wanted revenge against Lu Gao,
but had no intention of harming the throne and was asking for a pardon. The memorial to the throne
was then slipped through the doors of East Chang'an Gate, but it remained utterly sealed.
There would be no talking his way out of this. Realising the opportunity had slipped, Cao Qin
decided to engage fully in his rebellion. His troops stormed East and West Chang'an Gates,
trying to break into the Imperial City, but the guard held firm, despite Cao Qin's use of fire
to try to destroy the gates. As General Sun Tang counter-attacked, hostages Li Xian and Wang Ao
were able to escape, though other high-ranking officials were killed by the rebels. Around
daybreak, Cao Qin, unable to breach Chang'an Gate, tried to break into the Imperial City at
By noon, Cao Qin's rebellion was failing. Two of his brothers found their deaths in the fighting
and he, injured, had to retreat outwards to the Great Eastern Market. Sun Tang deployed the Ming's
artillery and began ploughing through the rebel forces as rain began to pour on the capital-turned
battlefield. All was lost. Cao Qin now tried to escape Beijing. His attempt at Chaoyangmen,
tightly sealed as well, only saw his third brother die. Desperate, Cao rushed North,
but he failed to break through both Andingmen and Dongzhemen. After a final attempt at Chaoyangmen,
Cao Qin and the remainder of his forces entrenched themselves in his private residence.
To escape the excruciating execution by Lingchi, slow slicing, Cao Qin took his own life by
throwing himself down a well, as Imperial troops broke through. As the rebellion was ending,
the government announced that anyone who captured a rebel would be entitled to their property and
rank, which however led to abuses in cases of personal vendettas and false denunciations to
acquire property. Cao Jixiang, reportedly involved in his adoptive son's rebellion,
was publicly dismembered the next day, and Cao Qin's fished-out body, as well as those of his
brothers, were left to rot in public. Captured rebel troops, allies and associates of Cao Qin,
were promptly executed as well, imprisoned or banished to the edges of the empire.
Conversely, many defendants were richly rewarded. But the crackdown led to fear among Mongol
subjects of the Ming, especially within the army, who were certainly viewed with suspicion
after the Tuomu crisis and the rebellion of Cao Qin of Mongol background. Possibly fearing
copycat uprisings and mutinies, the Emperor reassured there would be no persecution against
them. Little is known of the remainder of Yingzong's reign. Like his father and grandfather
before him, the Emperor would not live long. In early 1464, seven years after Jingtai,
he fell greatly ill. Of note, on his deathbed, Yingzong banned the practice of Xunzhang,
funerary sacrifices of concubines and empresses to follow the Emperor in death. This practice,
banned since the Han dynasty, had actually been revived by the Hongwu Emperor upon founding the
Ming, emulating the Yuan dynasty which practiced it. Yingzong died on the 23rd of February 1464
at only 36 years old. He was buried in the Yu mausoleum, fifth of the Ming tombs,
and received the posthumous name of Rui, wise. With his death, the Ming dynasty, which had been
brought to the brink of defeat, seen its Emperor captured, experienced several successive breaches
of propriety, purges, a spectacular successful coup and another failed one, could finally regain
a stable flow. Its reigns were now in the hands of Yingzong's son, the 16-year-old Zhu Jiansheng,
the Chenghua Emperor. Despite a promising start, Chenghua's reign would be tarnished by his
increasingly autocratic rule and favouritism. His infatuation with his former childhood nurse
turned favourite concubine, Lady Wan, 17 years his senior, would also cause much chaos in the
Thank you for watching my video, I hope you enjoyed it. If so, please leave a like and
subscribe to the channel. If you have any questions or requests,
feel free to leave them in the comments section below.