1449, the Ming dynasty stands on the edge of destruction. Its armies had been destroyed, and the Emperor captured by the Mongols, who march on Beijing, the imperial capital. The panicking imperial court crowns the Emperor’s brother Zhu Qiyu, the reluctant Prince of Cheng, as the Jingtai Emperor in a desperate bid to save the empire. Discover the consequences of the Tumu Crisis, Yu Qian’s heroic defence of Beijing, and Jingtai’s attempt to stay gripped to a ‘temporary’ throne, ending in the most astonishing coup of the Ming dynasty’s history.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The Ming dynasty survived an existential crisis after the Tumu disaster of 1449, when the Yingdong Emperor was captured by Mongols. The Jingtai Emperor ascended to stabilize the empire, overseeing the successful defense of Beijing and significant military reforms. Despite these achievements, his reign ended in a coup known as the Duoman incident, which restored Ying Zong to the throne.
October 1449, the Ming dynasty is on its knees. Its armies have been decimated by the Mongols
and its emperor Yingdong taken prisoner. With the advancing hordes now just miles away from
the capital of Beijing, the Chinese empire braces for what could be the final nail in its coffin.
On the dragon throne has been placed Yingdong's brother, the Jingtai Emperor. His reign will
either see the Ming dynasty overcome or be crushed. Zhu Qiyu, the future Jingtai Emperor,
was never meant to ascend the throne. Not only was he born the second son of the competent
Xuanda Emperor in September 1428, but his mother was a mere palace maid named Wu.
Therefore, little is known about his childhood. Upon the premature death of their father in 1435,
Qiyu's elder brother Qizhen ascended the throne as the Yingdong Emperor, while he was created
Prince of Chang at six years old. As the empire entered a period of decline, the young boy would
grow up in the imperial luxury of Beijing. At around 16 years old in 1445, he was married to
one lady Wang. However, Zhu Jianji, his first son, who would soon be the object of great controversy,
would not be born to his primary consort Wang, but to a concubine of his, Lady Hang.
Qiyu, in contrast to his half-brother the Emperor Yingdong, developed into a reportedly timid and
hesitant man. This may have been the reason why he never set up residence in his fief in Shandong
province, but remained in the imperial court in Beijing. However, his relatively uneventful
life was about to be rocked to the core.
Until then mighty, the Ming dynasty was about to be crippled in a spectacular event. Its very
founding had come from overthrowing the Mongol Yuan dynasty and reclaiming the empire under
Chinese rule. In the harsh steppe, the Mongols, now cut off from the resources of China, had
been re-united by the Oirat warlord Ehsan Taixi after decades of infighting. Turning his focus
towards China, the ambitious leader saw his requests to enlarge trade and arrange a diplomatic
marriage bluntly shot down by the Ming imperial court. Ehsan therefore resorted to more persuasive
arguments. In July 1449, the warlord poured into the northern frontier in a massive invasion.
Controversially, the Yingdong emperor, aged only 21, was galvanized by his favorite eunuch Wang
Zhen to lead an expedition of half a million men and march out against the Mongols in person.
Upon leaving the capital, he entrusted his half-brother Zhu Qiyu with the affairs in Beijing,
aided by a group of advisors. The Prince of Chang had emerged from the shadows of history
and now stood at the forefront. For a while, the court, empty of most high-ranking officials,
operated confidently. Reports indicated that the expedition was going very well.
Yet, Beijing's optimism was about to collapse into utter panic. Exactly one month after
Yingdong had left the capital, an urgent report received in the middle of the night shattered
everything. In a great battle near the post station of Tumu, the entire Ming army had been
wiped out. The most eminent civilian and military figures had all been killed. Shockingly,
the Yingdong emperor had been captured. Panic seized the imperial court. Many officials,
headed by Xu Youzhen, advocated to immediately flee the capital and relocate to Nanjing,
the dynasty's original seat of power. However, they were all silenced by Yu Qian, the vice
minister of war, most senior military official left, who claimed that those of that opinion
ought to be put to death. Yu Qian, emerging as the strongman of the crisis, rallied the court
into making a stand in Beijing. But it first had to handle one immediate priority. The dynasty
could not function with an emperor prisoner of war. To revive morale and reduce Yingdong's value
as a hostage, a new emperor had to be crowned. However, Yingdong's son, the heir apparent Zhu
Jiansheng, was not yet two years old. Naturally, all eyes turned to the prince of Cheng. Zhu Qiyu
was convinced to temporarily ascend the throne until the crisis was resolved. On the 22nd of
September 1449, Zhu Qiyu ascended the throne as the Jingtai Emperor, bright exultation,
with a minimal of ceremony. Crowned out of desperation, he would however not relinquish
the supposedly temporary throne willingly. The Mongol attack was imminent, but Beijing's
garrison had been emptied and annihilated in Yingdong's disastrous expedition.
The Ming dynasty thus went into overdrive to ensure the defence of the imperial capital
through sweeping reforms, emergency financial measures and nimble logistical operations.
Yu Qian organised a prompt assembly of reserve forces from neighbouring provinces of Shanxi,
Shandong, Henan, Liaodong and recalled the garrison of Xuanfu.
When in late October, news arrived that Usen had broken through the last defences at Zijing Pass
and was marching straight to Beijing, the city's defences had been skilfully enlarged
to over 200,000 men. Two days later, the Mongol army, a third of that size,
was spotted from the northwest of the city's walls. Usen first offered to negotiate with
besieged Ming, but sensing a trap, the imperial court merely sent two low-ranking officials,
who were indeed promptly taken as additional hostages by the Mongols.
Negotiations broken down, Usen Taixi confidently launched his attack at the Shangmen Gate. Yu Qian,
in charge of the defence, had to overcome or see the empire defeated.
Each Mongol attack was skilfully lured into ambushes
and torn down by the Shanjiying, firearm-wielding Ming battalions.
After repeated unfruitful attacks day after day, Usen soon realised he could not defeat
Beijing's garrison. Isolated in enemy territory, he decided to withdraw after four days of battle.
Beijing had been saved, but with Usen and his army remaining within Ming borders,
the empire was yet far from secure. The assertive Yu Qian, architect of the critical victory in
the capital, immediately ordered great cavalry patrols of the inner steppe between Datong
and Xuanfu and the strengthening of the local garrisons. Early in 1450, the Mongol leader
dispatched his envoy, Xining, for a final negotiation attempt. But this eunuch, one of
Yingdong's attendants captured alongside him, who had switched allegiance to the Mongols,
was promptly apprehended and executed for treason by the imperial court. His Chinese advisor
eliminated, Usen ultimately decided to withdraw to the steppe, the Yingdong emperor still in his
By not attacking Beijing immediately after the battle of Tuomo, he had arguably lost his chance
to defeat the Ming dynasty. The empire was saved, but now that the emergency had passed,
what was next for the imperial court? It soon became clear that the Jingtai emperor was in
no hurry to free his half-brother, nor return the throne. His emergency government therefore
gradually settled into regular affairs. It would initially be remarkably united and stable.
Most ministers, censors and other high-ranking officials, remaining of the previous reign,
retained their positions. Eunuchs also stayed influential, through figures such as Jin Ying,
soon replaced by Xing An, for regularly advocating the rescue of Yingdong.
But the issue of the missing emperor could not be permanently ignored.
In August, diplomatic exchanges with the Mongols resumed. However, Jingtai's envoys never brought
up the subject of Yingdong, withering after a whole year of custody. Usen, however,
eventually released his prisoner in exchange for a fraction of what he once demanded,
and mainly the promise of restoring peaceful relations and trade with the Ming. Under Oirat
escort, the Taishan Huang, or retired emperor, finally reached Beijing on the 19th of October.
Without much of a choice, Yingdong publicly confirmed his definitive renunciation of the
throne in favour of his half-brother, and was promptly invited to stay in the isolated
southern inner palace, where he would essentially be placed into permanent house arrest.
The Tuomu crisis, which had lasted an entire year, was over. But it had exposed the urgent
need for a complete transformation of the Ming military system. Not only had it proven absolutely
ineffective in combat, but the permanent Beijing garrison had been wiped out entirely.
In two great reforms in 1451 and 1452, Yutian, minister of war, created a new imperial garrison,
numbering 150,000 men divided in 10 drill units. This unity of independently operating forces,
having been a key factor in the Tuomu disaster, each drill unit was placed under a field commander,
each of which answering to a single field marshal, commanding the entire garrison.
To compensate for the loss of myriads of hereditary soldiers, men were hired from their
The Tuomu disaster thus served as a necessary spark for a revival of the obsolete Ming military.
Nailing in his intent to keep the throne, Jingtai would make a highly controversial decision,
a breach of propriety, which would end up alienating a significant part of his own court.
Following secret bribes and threats towards the government, Jingtai deposed his nephew,
the four-year-old heir apparent Zhu Jiansheng, in favour of his own son, Zhu Jianji, in May 1452.
Alongside this change, he elevated the boy's mother, Consult Hang, to the rank of Empress,
deposing his sonless wife, Empress Huang, in a striking parallel to what his father,
the Xuanda Emperor, had done. But this change of heirs would soon backfire against him.
The Ming's revival under Jingtai's reign did not only concern the military, but also
administration. The emperor commissioned the compilation of an exhaustive gazetteer,
or geographical index, an immense general geographical record of the entire empire.
In 1454, 29 scholars began touring the nation to collect data, as Grand Secretary Chen Xun
supervised the compilation of the document. After months of work, the Huanyu Tongzhi,
or comprehensive gazetteer of the realm, was assembled. Finalising the work, the emperor
personally wrote its preface, but any credit of his work for the document would eventually be
destroyed and appropriated by his brother. Although still under house arrest in the
southern inner palace, Yingdong would indeed soon sit once more on the dragon throne.
Despite revival in many aspects, the Jingtai era was not a time of tranquility.
Much like during the first reign of his brother, it was a period of regular natural disasters,
including famines, droughts and flooding. The winter of 1453-1454 was marked by unbearable
cold and heavy snow, which killed dozens of thousands of people and livestock.
Following moral obligations, the imperial court organised relief for the affected regions
in grain distribution and tax reductions, which further strained the Ming treasury.
But the era would also see a remarkable answer to a natural calamity. Uncontrollable for several
successive years, the Yellow River bursts its dikes twice in 1452, leading to massive flooding
and destruction, as well as disturbance of the strategic Grand Canal. While the government was
unsure on how to handle this additional issue, a disgraced figure came back to light with a
detailed plan on how to tame the river, Xu Youzhen. After having advocated to flee south during the
Tuomo crisis, the official had fallen out of favour and been relegated to minor posts,
but his determination convinced the court to entrust him with the issue.
With dedication and skill, Xu carefully surveyed the area personally and mobilised 58,000 workers
to not only repair the dikes, but dig over 100 miles of canals and many ponds and reservoirs
to protect the Grand Canal. The extensive works, completed in 1455 after a year and a half of toil,
would last for over three decades and withstand several further great floods. Xu Youzhen's
remarkable feat was greatly rewarded. But in addition to natural disasters, Jingtai also
inherited the social unrest issues of his brother's reign. An ongoing rebellion of silver
miners in Fujian was quelled after six years. In Guangxi, authorities were unable to quell
the rebellion of Yao people. Youzhen denounced the local commanding officers as incapable and
self-interested, and stressed the importance of a commander capable of understanding and
gaining the respect and obedience of native peoples. The Minister of War recommended the
appointment of an overall commander of the Liangguang region, including both Guangxi and Guangdong
provinces. Wang Ao, a sensible and experienced commander, thus became the first to halt what
would later become the viceroyalty of Liangguang and successfully pacified the region. But the
main rebellions of the Jingtai reign would be centered in the ethnic minority-rich region
of Guizhou. The Miao people had rebelled late in Ying Zong's first reign due to economic difficulties
and demobilization of local Ming forces. These rebellions were not unified under a single figure,
but launched by several independently operating leaders, referred to as Miao kings in Ming sources.
Their suppression would be a painful and long process, during which Ming troops reportedly
looted Guiyang twice in 1449 and 1450. In April of that year, Miao rebels besieged the strategic
Annan guard, prompting an urgent counter-attack. Mo Bin, hereditary leader of Yunnan, mobilized,
ultimately breaking the siege. Successive Miao leaders such as Huang Long in 1454 and Meng Nong
in 1455 were killed in battle or captured and executed. But the Miao uprisings also took more
surprising forms. Around the same time, a Taoist priest named Li Zhen reportedly led 20,000 Miao
into rebellion. Li declared himself emperor with the era name of Tianshun. Astonishingly,
despite no apparent connection, this would be the exact same era name Ying Zong would return
to the throne with. The rebel priest was however promptly captured and executed in 1456.
Though containing the Miao rebellions for the time being, the Ming were unable to pacify Guizhou yet.
Back in the Forbidden City, Jing Tai found himself isolated. His empress Hang died in 1456,
three years after his nine-year-old son and heir, Zhu Jianji. As the emperor had no other sons,
the imperial court repeatedly urged him to reappoint Ying Zong's eldest, his nephew,
Jianshun, as the heir apparent. But not only did Jing Tai vehemently refuse their request,
he had the most vocal officials imprisoned and flogged, some such as Zhongtong, to death.
This was a turning point. The Jing Tai emperor had alienated a major part of his own government.
With no one designated as his successor, the emperor was sitting on a fragile throne
and he was about to lose it. Late in 1456 or early 1457, the Jing Tai emperor fell severely ill.
The weakened monarch was compelled to suspend court audiences and cancel New Year celebrations,
but his demise had already been secretly orchestrated in the shadows.
At dawn on the 11th of February, imperial bodyguards stormed Jing Tai's quarters
and evicted him from the throne. On it was placed none other than Ying Zong,
brought back from house arrest on a sedan chair by conspirators.
The gravely ill Jing Tai was immediately demoted back to Prince of Chang, but he would not live to
see the brutal purges of his spiteful brother. The only 28-year-old overthrown monarch died
barely a month later, on the 14th of March 1457, either of illness or possibly strangled by eunuchs
on the orders of his brother. The Ming dynasty had just experienced the most spectacular internal coup
of its history, which would be remembered as the Duoman incident, forcing the palace gate.
Ying Zong would try to erase all legitimacy from his brother's reign,
labelling him a rebellious prince. He denied him the imperial mausoleum Jing Tai had built for
himself in the Ming tombs, having him instead buried in the northwest outskirts of Beijing
as a mere prince. Similarly, he was granted neither posthumous imperial name nor temple
name for imperial religious ceremonies. Ying Zong's successor Zhu Jiansheng, the future
Chenghua emperor, would ultimately grant him the posthumous name of Jing, bright, in 1475.
A temple name for Jing Tai would not be granted until after the collapse of the Ming,
over two centuries after his death. The Hongguang emperor of the southern Ming dynasty would give
Jing Tai the temple name of Dai Zong, surrogate or substitute ancestor. Jing Tai's extraordinary
reign nonetheless saw the revival of a Ming dynasty that had been in decline for years.
But the throne was now back in the hands of the vengeful Ying Zong, who, after eight years
of captivity, was eager to carry out brutal purges. Thank you for watching my video,
I hope you enjoyed it. If so, please leave a like and subscribe to the channel.
If you have any questions or requests, feel free to leave them in the comment section below.