1320: Inside Medieval Scotland's Bloody Fight For Independence

What Was The Life
13 followers
3 Video Views·Jun 19, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the evolution of Scottish national identity through its most iconic figures and conflicts. From the early resistance of William Wallace and Robert the Bruce to the tragic Jacobite Risings led by Bonnie Prince Charlie, it explores how military struggles, political declarations, and folk legends transformed Scotland from a collection of feudal loyalties into a resilient nation.
Scotland is justifiably famous for the beauty of its landscapes, for the magnificent rivers and glens,
the forests and of course there are also the fairy tale castles. It was in places like this
where some of the great legendary stories of Scotland were hatched and played out. This is
Needpath Castle here in the Borders and we've come here because it represents many of the things
that are good about Scotland. It stands on a hill above the river Tweed and it has endured for the
centuries as have many of the stories we're about to explore. Unusually we've been spared the rain
today so we can have a look at Needpath Castle in all its glory. Normally when tourists come
to Scotland they bypass this area and they head straight for the Highlands which for them is a
great shame because they miss not only some of the best landscapes in the world they also miss
the roots of some of the real stories that colour Scotland's history. One of the most famous
figures in Scottish history is now William Wallace. Thanks to Hollywood who came here and
made the Braveheart film Wallace has become one of the single most dominant figures on the
medieval landscape of Scotland but he was certainly a character who deserved to be celebrated and in
those days when there was no real such thing as a nation he probably was one of the very first
patriots. I think William Wallace must be regarded as one of the great icons of Scottish history.
A remarkable figure by any stretch of the imagination. Historically he was the son of a
knight but in legend he became the common man the man from nowhere who appeared in the hour of need
of his country. Medieval people believed in the great chain of being that everything had its
correct place if you took one piece out and inserted it somewhere else the whole chain
was likely to fragment. So the English accounts stress the unnaturalness of this man and what's
curious is that the Scottish nobility who should have been leading the armies at the time Wallace
was leading them also distrusted him for the same reason. He was a man of low birth. We know
very little about the early life of William Wallace. What we do know is that he was born in
in the parish of Paisley in 1270 but for the rest of the detail on his colourful life we have to
rely on an epic poem which was written by a minstrel known as Blind Harry and Blind Harry
tells the story of William Wallace and his deeds from the time when he stepped onto the national
stage in 1297 AD. The first record of Wallace in the history books is the mid 1290s when we hear
the sheriff of Lanark William de Hazelrig who was an Englishman and part of the English garrison
there had assaulted William Wallace's wife. He subsequently murdered her. Wallace took swift
and instant revenge. He murdered de Hazelrig and with some followers killed the rest of the
garrison in the town. He was immediately declared an outlaw and he carried out a guerrilla campaign
against what he regarded as an army of occupation. William Wallace we think was typical of Scottish
opinion round about early 1297. Nobody likes to live in an occupied country. Edward the first
had conquered Scotland the year before as he thought and placed English garrisons in most of
the Scottish castles. It would have been fairly uncomfortable I think for people living under
such a regime. Now this is the inspiration of Wallace. He was not alone. He operated in the
southwest of Scotland. A guy called William Douglas operated in the southeast. Andrew Murray
operated in the north. It looks like they were the inspiration these men for a popular resistance and
were told of the common people coming out and supporting them. Not surprisingly the English
ruler of Scotland Edward the first would not be prepared to accept a challenge like that lightly.
He dispatched the Earl of Surrey with all of the English forces in Scotland to deal with the
rebellion as quickly as they could. They met together on the banks of the Forth in a battle
which has become famous in Scottish history. The Battle of Stirling Bridge. Murray or De Murray as
he was known and Wallace came together at Stirling in the centre of Scotland. Their armies combined
and there the approaching army of Edward under the generalship of Surrey approached them to cross
the river Forth at the one bridge at Stirling. It was an old wooden rickety bridge and the heavy
English cavalry had to cross this bridge two by two side by side. The Scots army waiting in the
woods on the Abbey Hill overlooking the bridge kept their nerve and when the order was given
they swooped down and massacred the English army who found it very difficult to manoeuvre
in the marshy ground around the bridge. Some of the knights tried to turn and flee back across
the bridge causing more chaos but they were outflanked by Wallace's force who fell upon them.
The victory was complete and Scotland was for the moment free of the tyrannical English rule
of Edward. The Scottish victory at Stirling Bridge was a sensational and unexpected boost
for the morale of Wallace and his men and at first it looked as if they would be able
to free the whole of Scotland but what Wallace hadn't reckoned with was the intervention of
Edward I who was to become known as the Hammer of the Scots. Legend has it that about five
miles west from here William Wallace with a band of his followers were surprised by an English
force and forced to flee. The area here of course was then governed by the Fraser family. The last
of the Fraser family here as a Simon Fraser was taken at the Battle of Dunbar in 1296 and forced
to then swear allegiance to Edward I. Shortly after this Fraser then went to France as a knight
and fought for Edward I in his French wars. Fraser returned to this area and became sheriff of
Traquair and Ettrick Forests. During this period certain people wrote to Edward I
suggesting that Fraser's heart wasn't actually in the employ of the English, he was a bit of
a nationalist. Fraser shortly after this proved this by changing completely to the Scottish side.
Now Edward was not only a first-class ruler he was also a great politician, a statesman
and above all he was a soldier who knew the craft of soldiership and he knew what had to be done on
the battlefield. Edward marched north with his own army and he engaged Wallace and his forces
in the Battle of Falkirk. It's really quite hard to assess the methods of warfare used at this time
One of the mysteries is the Scots had been at peace with England and virtually everybody else
for a hundred years, so where did they acquire the military expertise which allowed them to resist
the English? The Schiltrum was used at Falkirk which is the battle that Wallace lost. It's more
of defensive I think, it's been compared to a hedgehog with a kind of semi-circle and spears
sticking out, close ranks and archers between the spears. The idea was the spears would protect
the defending troops against a cavalry charge, the archers would do the damage as well.
At the Battle of Falkirk in 1298 the Scottish army under the generalship of Wallace alone
were mainly spearmen formed into schiltrons or phalanxes. The first charge was repulsed
but Edward was a wily soldier and brought up his archers and the archers rained their deadly arrows
upon the schiltrons. Many of the Scots fell dead, their ranks were broken, the cavalry came into
charge and finish off the job. Wallace indeed was lucky to escape with his life. He had to flee to
France where he tried to enlist the help of the French king. Edward of course was back in charge
but Wallace came back to Scotland, tried to regenerate a guerrilla campaign. Unfortunately
he was betrayed by one of his own countrymen Sir John Monteith who gave the brave Wallace
up to Edward I who in typical fashion had no mercy. He had Wallace taken to London
where he was hung drawn and quartered as a lesson to all Scots that they were not under any
circumstances to trifle with the will of England. I think it's quite possible
that the wars of independence might never have come about had it not been for the actions of
William Wallace. The problem was that many of the Scottish aristocrats including Robert Bruce,
the future king, had estates in England. They did not want to jeopardise the possession of
these estates by taking on the might of Edward I. If the proper rulers of the kingdom
are not doing their duty the common man will come forth and usurp their authority and that remains
an extremely powerful idea right down through the centuries. Shortly after the execution of
William Wallace another man strode onto the stage of Scottish history and this time there would be
no mistakes. This was Robert Bruce, the man who was to become the most famous king of Scotland
and Bruce was able to unite the whole country behind him and win the independence of the
nation. Although it's now associated as a Scottish name Bruce actually was a Norman name from De
Bruce and Bruce came from a Norman family but by the 1290s they were very much a part of the Scottish
nobility. The area at that time was governed or ruled by a Sir Simon Fraser. The Frasers of course
were Norman knights. He fought with Bruce and legend has it at the Battle of Manfon he placed
Bruce back on his horse three times when he had been unhorsed. Now imagine if this had not happened
the course of history would have been changed. Robert was one of the claimants to the throne
but that claim along with those of 12 others was dismissed and the nobleman of Scotland decided to
appoint Edward I as guardian of Scotland. The nobleman of the time being practical fellows
signed what was called the ragman's roll. Bruce then was very much involved in the politics of
the time but he had for himself a long-term view which was the throne of Scotland. The switching
of allegiance in the late 13th early 14th century is fairly easy to understand. You could see the
nobles as a sort of international fraternity who moved back and forward over boundaries and
borders quite happily and they didn't necessarily have a commitment to a concept, to an idea.
It's very interesting that in 1304 when Edward is bombarding Stirling Castle and he asks them
on whose authority do you hold this castle? Against me Edward I. They say we hold on behalf
of the lion. That's the first abstraction of kingship that you get in the British Isles.
They're having to formulate new ways of articulating their political aspirations.
What's happening in this very interesting period is that people are working out their ideas and
their identities and their commitments for the first time against a very tricky background so
they're reacting to present contingencies and redefining themselves in the process.
In the medieval world you were only ever going to be a king if you had the strength and the ability
to protect your position, sometimes physically. Bruce and Comyn were two rivals for the throne
but at the same time they were also occasional allies and the Bruce clearly decided at some
stage that he had to be rid of Comyn. There are accusations of treachery on both sides.
We'll never know what the truth is but what certainly did happen is that when the two men
met together in a chapel near Dumfries the Bruce drew his dagger and murdered Comyn. As you would
expect he was excommunicated for such a heinous sin as a murder in a chapel but with the politics
of the day the Archbishop was still prepared to crown Bruce as King of Scotland which happened
on Palm Sunday in 1306. The family of Comyn were out to settle the score and the people of Scotland
weren't sure about this man who had murdered his opponent in a church of all places. The English
sent an army to confront Bruce's small army at Medwyn near the town of Perth and Bruce was very
lucky to escape with his life. After that he left Scotland's shores and the legend tells that he
went to take refuge on an island off the coast of Ireland, it's known as Rathen Island, and it was
there that we hear the tale of Bruce and the Spider and that legend is about Bruce sitting in the cave
hiding thinking well will this ever happen will I ever be king when he saw the spider spinning its
web trying and trying again to make the complete circle of the web and finally the spider succeeded
so Bruce thought yes well one day I might succeed and I might be King of Scotland but I must keep
trying I must try again. The first reference to Bruce and the Spider comes in Sir Walter Scott's
1830. There's not a trace of it before that. There is a legend from the 17th century which
associated a spider with the Black Douglas, Robert Bruce's famous sidekick, but no association between
Bruce and the spider. What we have here is a great example of instant legend or the invention of
tradition. The spider story is a sort of metaphor inserted very much later for whatever happened
when Bruce was away taking a think to himself. What he seems to have decided upon was avoid
conventional warfare, avoid pitched battles, we'll never beat the English on their own terms
and so he actually adopted guerrilla tactics from then on and it was very very successful.
Now the story could well be apocryphal but it is an inspiring legend which has endured
down through the centuries but in 1307 there did come a turning point for the Bruce.
In that year Edward I died, ironically on his way with his own army to come to Scotland
and teach Bruce a lesson. At the age of 68 even the hammer of the Scots was so worn out by his
years in the saddle that he died at Barra on Sands on his way north to fight the Scots.
This gave Bruce the breathing space he needed and he began to take the war to the English.
There was even better news for Bruce in that the successor to Edward I, the new king
Edward II was by no means the soldier and the statesman that his father had been.
People have come to the conclusion that because this king liked art and painting, had a male
favourite and ostensibly neglected his wife he must therefore have been a homosexual and that
has become the accepted view of Edward II and I'm not sure that the evidence actually stands up
to the kind of scrutiny. A great number of kings have had confidants and favourites right through
to Charles I and beyond. In addition homosexuality could be punished by being burned alive at the
stake and even the king wouldn't have been able to escape that kind of retribution.
With Edward absent from the stage the Bruce was able to gradually win over the whole of Scotland.
One by one the castles and towns fell from English rule back into the hands of the Scots
until finally in 1314 only one castle remained in the hands of the English.
This was the castle of Stirling overlooking the plain of Bannockburn. Sir Hugh de Cressingham,
the governor of Stirling castle had agreed to surrender to the Bruce if he was not relieved
by midsummer's day 1314. Now even a king of questionable strength and vigour such as Edward
II couldn't afford to ignore a challenge like that. If he lost Stirling he lost Scotland
and to try and make sure that didn't happen he assembled one of the greatest armies ever to
leave England. It was led by a powerful vanguard of knights, there was a huge body of men at arms
and of course there were the famous Longwomen. They were to meet on the field at Bannockburn.
It came to pass in 1314 the battle to end all battles in Scottish terms was fought. The army
of Edward II was very much stronger in terms of numbers but Bruce had made preparations for the
coming of the English army. He had took up a very strong defensive position. He had dug pits. In
these pits he had put spiked poles to trap the cavalry and he waited patiently for the English
army to advance. The battle of Bannockburn was Bruce's defining moments and one of the reasons
for his success in that battle was his ability to prepare not only his army but also the ground
on which they would fight. He chose the river Forth to define the boundary of the battlefield
and he knew the English had to come and relieve Stirling Castle. He knew the road they would be
approaching and as a consequence of that he was able to spend time preparing defensive positions
on the battlefield. Those defensive positions took the form of a number of pits which were dug across
the projected path of any English cavalry charge and a number of fiendishly horrible devices known
as caltrops which were metal spikes that were strewn across the path of any projected cavalry
charge in the hope that they would stick into the hooves. By doing so Bruce was able to spend time
drilling the men, getting his army to act in a cohesive fashion and preparing the terrain. That
was very unusual on a medieval battlefield and it paid dividends in the battle of Bannockburn.
Instead of awaiting the English attack he launched his own
children's and an attack against the English cavalry. This was certainly
throwing a spanner in the works and certainly not the kind of thing that Edward II would have
expected. By his ability to use the river to define the battlefield the Bruce was able to
pen the English army into a fairly compact and fairly narrow piece of ground. They couldn't use
their archers as they'd done at Falkirk because the archers were behind not only the cavalry but
the billmen who were in the second rank. This meant that the Scots infantry were free from the dangers
of the arrow storm that had decimated them at Falkirk and also in the battle of Mervyn. So what
we had here was a general who was able to decide not only his tactics also how he was going to use
the field to his own advantage. Some of the English archers did actually manage to take up a
position on the flank and begin to cause casualties among the Scots infantry with their arrow fire
from the flank and the Bruce had had enough wisdom to keep back the tiny reserve of cavalry he did
have. Only 500 men lightly armoured on small horses but they were to prove absolutely decisive at that
point because it was then that he released his small force of cavalry to disperse the English
archers and keep the battle going in favour of the Scots. The English cavalry advanced but could only
advance very slowly because they had a very limited section of dry land in which they could advance.
That attack was repulsed easily by the Scottish spearmen and then the next day the spearmen beat
off the English army. As the English army were turning to flee the reinforcements or the camp
followers came in to the battle and the rout was complete. The English made off. The king himself
was lucky to escape but his wife and daughter were taken prisoner and ransomed for a great price.
Bannockburn was undoubtedly a colossal victory. There's no question about it. Probably the most
spectacular victory in Scottish history. As such has never been forgotten by certain sections of
the Scottish community. The Scottish National Party for example still holds annual rallies at
Bannockburn. I suppose it's seen as a kind of a shrine of Scottish independence or whatever
but it didn't really achieve very much as a battle. The whole point of fighting the battle was
a. to get rid of the English which they succeeded in doing b. to get the English to recognise the
legitimacy of Bruce's title to be king of Scots. He had to raid all the way through England to hit
the king at Westminster so they could run around the north of England till the cows came home.
It would never affect the attitudes of the kind of home county mentality. Sadly the battlefields
of Britain haven't benefited from the kind of protection that a field like Gettysburg has had
for example in the States. They've been encroached by modern developments and in Bannockburn's case
housing development right on to the battlefield and also the landscape has been changed by the
advent of modern farming techniques. Behind me here we've got the River Tweed which can
represent for us the River Forth that was going to give the English army so many problems
particularly during the retreat. Opposite we've got the mature trees similar to the kind of
features of the new park which hid the Scottish army so effectively on the days before the battle.
Then across here we've got a flat plain which stretches from the river. It hasn't been changed
by modern farming techniques, it hasn't been intensively cropped by animals and as such we can
see the the tussocky nature of the ground and you can appreciate just how difficult it would be for
cavalry to make progress across ground like this. There are a number of things that can trap the
ankles and break legs of horses. Towering over this landscape we have the castle of Needpath.
Now Needpath is obviously a much smaller castle than Stirling but you do get a feel almost of the
battlefield in miniature and what the main features were. In 1320 the Scots did the nobles,
barons, freeholders and the community of the realm of Scotland. They sent a letter to the Pope of the
day really asking the Pope to put pressure on the English king to recognise Bruce's title.
A declaration of Scottish independence and there are some very very interesting ideas in this
document. They actually say if Robert Bruce should ever submit our kingdom to the King of England or
the English we will remove him and set up another better able to govern us in his place. They had no
intentions of removing Robert Bruce but they're trying to show if Robert even hints at stepping
out of line they're going to remove him. So what's that? That is the earliest statement of the
contractual theory of monarchy in European history. They're saying the king is answerable to his
subjects. The next section of the declaration of our Bruce goes on to say and this is quoted all over
the place but it's still good it's very moving. For so long as a hundred of us remain alive we
shall never surrender. It is not for riches nor for glory nor for honours that we fight
but for freedom alone which no honest man will lose but with life itself. If the Battle of
Bannockburn was to prove Scotland's greatest day in its military history the blackest day was to
come almost 200 years later at the Battle of Flodden. On that day in a field in the north
of England 10,000 Scotsmen lost their lives under the leadership of King James the fourth.
In many respects James could have been a greater king than the Bruce. He was a cultured man and he
understood the need for education in a changing world. This was the time of the renaissance and
James was very much a renaissance king. He established Scotland's third university at
Aberdeen for example and he was terrifically interested in the fields of literature and art
and science. For him the application of science came very much in the exploration of gunpowder.
He was fanatical about artillery and its employment on the battlefield. Unfortunately
the artillery was to let him down on the day of his greatest trial. James the fourth of Scotland
came to the throne in 1488 following the untimely death of his father. Much trade was carried out
between Scotland and the Low Countries and France. In terms of culture he set up the third university
in Scotland in Aberdeen, the College of Surgeons in Edinburgh, set up a printing press, encouraged
writing and literature and so did a lot of good for the education of Scots and Scotland.
His brother-in-law Henry the Eighth of England had formed the Holy League with the King of Spain
and the Doge of Venice and their aim was to attack the power of Louis the King of France.
Now there had been an ancient alliance between France and Scotland called the Old Alliance
which went back to the 13th century but Louis knowing that James was a very gallant and
chivalrous gentleman decided that it would be better if his wife the Queen wrote to James
seeking his assistance. This she did with all pomp and circumstance and with her letter she sent
a lovely turquoise ring. Unfortunately James was not the kind of man who could resist a call
to chivalry like that and he brought together a great army of Scotland and invaded England.
It was a big mistake on James's part and the Scots army came disastrously unstuck when they moved
into England in order to support the French in September 1513. The Battle of Flodden was an
unmitigated disaster for the Scots and the famous image of the sole survivor returning to Edinburgh
still haunts the Scots today. James himself is alleged to have been forewarned by an apparition
the famous blue man who appeared to him before the campaign. At Linlithgow where the King was praying
this man came to the church knocking on the door insisting that he saw the King. The man
wearing a blue cloak it is said had been sent by his mother with a warning a dire warning to the
King that he should not set out in this journey because it would be very very dangerous both for
him and his companions. Furthermore his mother had told him to give the King the message that
the King should not take the advice of women. Whether it's true or not or whether it's been
embroidered over the years it certainly was a legend that was prevalent at the time of the battle.
It was said that there wasn't a single family in the whole of Scotland that was left untouched
by the disaster at Flodden. So great were the casualties that they were lamenting
throughout the land. The legend of Robin Hood is an enduring tale. Scotland has its own version
of that in the legend of Rob Roy. I think the thing that appeals to people about Rob Roy is
much the same as that which appeals about Robin Hood. The fact that he's what's called a social
bandit an outlaw who defends his community against alien or elite influences. Rob Roy first of all
came from an outlawed clan the McGregors who'd been outlawed as a result of the exercise of
state power in the 1590s. He was associated with the Jacobite risings and their opposition
to the union in 1715 and 1719. He was also associated with the ability to act autonomously
in defiance of authority. In Scotland we have our own version of Robin Hood and his name is
Rob Roy McGregor and he lived here in this area called Balwhydder. Behind me is the Kirkton Burn
which flows down to Loch Boyle and passes by the ale house where Rob Roy used to drink, not 300
yards from here. He drove cattle to markets in the south down to England and as he reached his late
teens he was installed in a farm not far from here on the southern shores of Loch Boyle. Later
in 1693 he was married to Mary McGregor of Cromer and it was here in this glen that he started his
married life. As well as farming and droving he engaged in a little what we call lifting or
that was stealing cattle and reselling them. At that time Rob's business was doing very well
and he arranged to borrow some money from a wealthy landowner, the Duke of Montrose.
Sadly all did not go to plan. Rob gave the money to his trusty lieutenant, the man disappeared,
so did the money. Rob Roy was declared bankrupt and in his absence his wife
and children were evicted from the property on the shores of Loch Lomond. Rob took revenge on
Montrose by stealing his cattle, stealing his rent and in some cases stealing the rent that
the tenants, the poor tenants, had paid to his factor and then giving the money back to the tenants.
Many dramatizations of Rob Roy were put on from the 1820s onwards. I think there were
30 or 40, my memory serves me right, dramatizations of Rob Roy in the 19th century. He was very much
a figure taken up as a result of Scott's novel and yet Scott's novel was called Rob Roy for a
reason because Rob Roy already had a status on which Scott was drawing. So I think we can say
that Scott was a great publicity agent for Rob Roy. Rob became implicated in the political struggles
of the time, the struggle to replace the Stuart Kings on the throne of Scotland. He was given a
pardon towards the end of his life and he ended his days here, further up the glen at Inverloch
Larrig. He had a dispute with a neighbour called James McLaren over a field at Invernenty. Rob
came marching down the glen with a force of about a hundred men but when he came to the western side
of the burn at the bottom near the loch there was a force of 300 waiting to meet him. Thinking upon
this and being quite a sensible man in his old age he thought this is not the day for a fight
because we're sadly outnumbered but he felt that all these warrior-like men having come together
they should have some fighting at least. So they decided to fight a duel and there was Rob being
the man he was putting himself forward for the fight, the other side put forward a young champion,
a young Stuart. They fought and the agreement had been first blood and eventually the young man
got the better of Rob and gave him a nick on the arm but that wound was the end of him.
It went septic but before he died McLaren this neighbour with whom he had had the dispute
heard he was dying and came to gloat at Rob on his deathbed. Rob heard he was coming, called for
his wife to dress him in his best plaid, bring him his sword and his gun and when McLaren came in
he was aghast to see Rob looking as fierce as ever, nowhere near death he thought. So he made his
grovelling apologies and left hurriedly. When he did die he was buried down here at the cemetery
at the churchyard. There was a huge funeral, hundreds of people came and the funeral bill came
to over 400 pounds. Rob's estate was valued at 146 pounds so even in death poor Mary, that long
suffering wife, had to work with the help of her sons to pay off the debt for the funeral. The story
of Rob Roy goes beyond the bounds of his locality, the west of Scotland and Perthshire, they're
spread throughout Scotland, even in Aberdeenshire there are caves which are associated with Rob Roy
and these are a function of storytelling not of history and it's very interesting that such a
powerful folk mythos, mythology has been built up around somebody who is a historical figure and
died no more than 260 odd years ago. What we do know for certain is that Rob Roy was present at
some of the biggest battles of the Jacobite Wars. He fought at the Battle of Sheriffmuir
in 1715 and he was also present on the ill-fated campaign which led to the Battle of Glenshield
in 1719. By 1745 the cause that Rob Roy had gone out to support should have been dead and buried
but there was one last act to be played in the tragedy and that tragedy would be led by the son
of the old pretender Charles Edward Stuart. Charles Edward Stuart is better known to Scottish
history as Bonnie Prince Charlie. Prince Charles Edward Stuart was born in 1720 in Rome,
he was the son of the old pretender to the throne of Scotland. His father was in turn the son of the
deposed king, King James II of Scotland and England who had been deposed in what was called
the glorious bloodless revolution in 1688. The powers that be, the British government of the time
felt that they should have a protestant king so they invited Prince William of Orange in the
Netherlands and his Queen Mary to become King and Queen of Britain. They came to the throne
but there was a movement called the Jacobite movement who were keen to have the Stuart family
line restored to the throne. The clans and other supporters whom General Cope and the government
army counted on as coming out to support the government simply didn't do it. There was
relatively little interest even from opponents of the Jacobite cause and actually standing up
and fighting against them. There was a good deal of passive sympathy with the Jacobites among those
who weren't prepared to support them and effectively the rest of the political nation sat on their
hands. Indeed it's arguable that that was the case in England too, at least while the Jacobites
were marching south. The religious landscape had also changed. Scotland was very much
a protestant country and for many the Stuarts represented a return to the old catholic religion
and as such they couldn't command the popular support in what was very much a Presbyterian
country. In 1719 a great storm had destroyed the Spanish fleet which had been brought together
to support an attempt by the nominal head of Scotland James III to regain the throne.
In 1744 another great storm wrecked the French fleet that had been brought together
in support of a claim by his son Charles Edward Stuart. There were never enough people who were
prepared to support the cause and when the French help that had been promised failed to materialise
really the whole expedition should have been cancelled then and quite a few of the
the wiser highland chiefs knew that the end had really come. Nonetheless Charles was able to
persuade them to continue on in the cause and the ill-fated rebellion of 1745 was the consequence.
He had arrived with just seven men. They were known as the Seven Men of Moirat.
In August 1745 he arranged to raise the standard at Blinfinnan. That morning he was rowed up a
loch to the point at the top of Loch Shield where he had put out the word for the highlanders to
gather. At first they came in dribs and drabs there weren't many there but by the end of the day
Cameron of Loch Shield had come with over 500 men and so the tally at the end of the day was
almost a thousand. He marched south with his army gathering men and support as he went and in no
time at all he reached Edinburgh. He took Edinburgh quite easily. He defeated the army of the government
under Johnny Cope at the Battle of Prestonpans and the famous tune Hey Johnny Cope are you walking
yet are you awake yet General Cope became a byword for the Jacobite army. After the Jacobite
army left Edinburgh it split into two columns. One column actually ended up here between Peebles
and the castle and camped overnight en route to England and it's also recorded that the local
populace were much put out by this. Now this column was commanded by Sir George Murray
contained most of the artillery. We're talking about a considerable number of men and horses.
The officers themselves probably took billets in the town itself but the men would have been left
to rough it down in this flat area by the river. The river of course providing water for the horses
and the men. It was then that Charles' real master plan was unfolded. Despite the fact that he had
claimed the throne of Scotland and actually had his father proclaimed as James VIII of Scotland
he decided that his real mission lay in winning the throne of England and that's when things
really went wrong. Lord Murray proved himself to be an excellent commander at Prestonpans
and it was his ability that glued together the Jacobite army but Murray was no fool
and he agreed to march on England only on the condition that they would receive French help.
The prince by this stage must have known that no French help was ever going to materialise
but nonetheless he allowed the army to embark on its march into England probably in the hope
that what he saw as his English subjects would raise up in arms to help him. Once again this
didn't happen other than a motley collection of volunteers that they picked up and formed into
what was optimistically known as the Manchester Regiment. The English population were at best
indifferent to the Jacobites and certainly large sections were openly hostile. They advanced as
far as Derby just 120 miles north of London but when they got to Derby they hesitated. They had
a council of war and Charlie was advised that he should turn back but in London they were making
arrangements to move the king from town and it was at that time our national anthem God Save
the King was penned because there was such a fear that these wild highlanders would come and take
the town. Murray and the other chiefs were prepared to allow the charade of an invasion to progress
as far as Derby but by then they knew the army had to be turned for home. Having done so they
were able to forge together a victory over the forces of Hawley who were pursuing them into
Scotland but ultimately they were once again forced to retreat this time to Inverness the
Even at Inverness they were still pursued by William Duke of Cumberland, second son of George
the second. Cumberland was on a personal mission to ensure there would never again be a Jacobite
rebellion in Scotland and as such he used the government forces to ruthlessly suppress
the Highland army in the Battle of Culloden in April 1746. Cumberland and his men an army of
about 9,000 strong were camped at Nairn not far from Inverness and the prince heard of this he
also heard it was Cumberland's birthday and he reckoned that Cumberland would be entertaining
his army to a night of celebration in honour of his birthday so they planned a night raid, a night
attack. On their approach the guard was alerted and the attack was aborted. The troops hungry and
tired now made their way back to Culloden Moor. The next morning the government army marched up
the Highlanders stood in tight ranks against them was a highly regimented army of 9,000 troops
mostly regular troops but believe it or not there was some Scots fighting on that side as well
those Scots who took the government side. There was some confusion in the Jacobite ranks as opposed
to the giving of orders. The command to charge was not passed and the English artillery wrought havoc
in the space of 45 minutes the battle was lost. The order had been given to the government troops
to spare no quarter the wounded were killed where they lay. Bonnie Prince Charlie though escaped
in the battle as part of his escape he was disguised once as an Irish maid and was assisted
in this part of the escape by one Flora Macdonald. Charles and Flora are a very poignant pair a young
woman doing her duty as she sees it to protect and succour her prince from the threat of arrest and
death. It is innocent and therefore very much closer to a fairy story than these things so often
are but it also has very powerful symbolic resonance that it makes a very good counterpart
to a male-oriented military campaign that when he falls on hard times it's a woman who succours
and rescues him and so on. It gives a kind of domestic order to the public political side of
the earlier part of the Jacobite Rising. One of the things that's very important is that in the 18th
century Jacobite political rhetoric, political discourse Scotland, indeed Ireland too, but Scotland
was portrayed as a woman. A woman who would only be restored to fertility when her king
came back. This drew on ancient Celtic mythology and her land was made fertile again.
Therefore Flora with a good name for that kind of symbolism stood in very effectively for Scotland
as a whole receiving Charles into her bosom and that meant in a way that you could portray
the essence of the land with its feminine essence remain true to the Stuarts. After the battle the
prince rather ungraciously told his followers to fend for themselves though he himself tried to
escape back into exile into France. The famous incidents where he had to dress as a woman and
hide in the heather are all very well documented but if we look at the evidence I'm afraid the
prince's later behaviour certainly doesn't reflect well on him as a man. He doesn't appear to have
shown much gratitude for the people who had lost everything in the support of the Stuart cause.
Charles remains a controversial figure. He became a Scottish icon despite the fact of his
mixed Scottish, English, Polish ancestry and the fact that he was born in Rome and the fact that
Lord Elko one of his supporters said there you go you cowardly Italian as he was led off the
battlefield of Culloden. Despite all these things Charles first of all cultivated a Scottish
identity. All his army were uniformed in tartan including himself. He appointed a Gaelic tutor
who was in fact one of the foremost Gaelic poets of his day and so it was a very shrewd move
because that was more free publicity and on the route south he marched on foot at the head of
his army as if he were a great chieftain of old more in a Finn McCool than an 18th century
claimant to a throne.
