What Is Prophecy in the New Covenant?

Prophecies Revealed
9 followers
10 Video Views·Jun 18, 2026
John Piper explores the difference between Old Testament and New Testament prophecy, explaining why prophetic impressions should be tested against Scripture. Through biblical teaching and personal experiences, he shares how believers can pursue spiritual gifts with humility, discernment, and a heart to encourage others.
AI Generated·May contain errors
John, there's a difference on the surface of how prophecy seems to function in the Old
Covenant and the New Covenant. Old Covenant is, thus saith the Lord, and there's a different
sense in the way prophecy seems to function in the New Covenant. How have you put that
together in your thinking and during your pastoral ministry?
It's not just a surface difference. I think it's a substantial difference.
It is remarkable, isn't it, that the apostles are not called prophets. This new office seemed
to be brought into being by Jesus of apostles. Instead of saying, I'm going to gather around
me an Isaiah and an Ezekiel and a Daniel, I'm going to gather a Paul and a Peter and a John
and call them apostles. I've been significantly influenced by Wayne Grudem's book on prophecy
trying to make sense out of texts. First Thessalonians 5, test all things, hold fast
to what is good, don't despise prophecies. That's been really relevant in my own personal experience
because I think our tendency is to despise what the New Testament treats as prophecy.
Prophecy in the New Testament, at least the way it's treated in 1 Corinthians 12 and 13 and 14,
doesn't appear to have the same scripture quality, inerrant inspiration and authority that
when in Isaiah, thus saith the Lord. You don't go up to Isaiah and say, I'm going to test what
you've said now and hold fast to what is good and throw the rest away. But you do that with New
Testament prophecy. You test it and if it proves good, that is conforming to authoritative teaching
from the apostles, then you embrace it. So prophecy in the New Testament seems to be down
a notch from the authority of Old Testament prophets and is to be exposed to testing,
which is based on the apostolic teaching, which would have the prophecy level quality of authority
and inspiration of the Old Testament. Then it would be God bringing something to mind. It's
pretty much the language that Wayne Goodman uses. God bringing something to mind that you would not
otherwise have thought of in the moment for the sake of up-building and encouragement and
consolation. Those are the three words from 1 Corinthians 14, 3. One who prophesies speaks
to men for their up-building, for their encouragement, for their consolation.
And so the way I personally appropriate it for myself now, and I really don't feel as confident
about this as I do a lot of things, and therefore I don't go around the country crusading for
prophecy. But I have to live my life a certain way, because the Bible says, earnestly desire
spiritual gifts, especially that you may prophesy. It tells me to do that. And so my best shot is to
say, Lord, so here I am sitting in the front pew 30 seconds before I preach. The text is being read
and I have prepared. I know basically what I want to say. It's on manuscript. I've studied the
scriptures. This is my authority, not stuff that randomly comes into my head. That's not my
authority. I'm not going to deliver that to this people and say, thus saith the Lord, you believe
that or you're disobeying. I'm going to say that with this book, not with what comes into my head.
Nevertheless, I pray as I'm sitting there, God grant me a gift of prophecy in this preaching.
And what I mean by that is bring to my mind things about yourself and about this text and about the
truth and about this people that I will be able to say in such a way that they will pierce with
unusual, I might say prophetic power into their lives. And it might be something extraordinary.
I'll give you one example of something extraordinary. It might be something more
ordinary. The more ordinary happens very regularly where people say, have you been reading my mail?
When you looked at me and you said, and I didn't even know I was looking at you and I didn't know
those words were not in the manuscript, they just were there. That kind of penetrating, personal,
powerful, up-building or convicting application is a gift of God in the moment.
The extraordinary one that I remember was that I was preaching on small groups
and Bible studies and I was making the case that you could have a small group anywhere. It'd be
great for you to gather people together, maybe even unbelievers and have an investigative Bible
study. And I looked to the downtown, I looked to my left at the old sanctuary and I said,
you might be working on the 34th floor of the IDS tower. Maybe you should call your people together
and have a small group meeting. This woman comes up afterwards and she said, why did you say that?
She said, I worked on the 34th floor of the IDS tower and I've been praying about whether to
start a small group. Now, what is that? I said to her, I think that's a gift to you from God.
I just think that's a gift. You can make of it whatever you want. I just think that's a sweet
encouragement from your Father in heaven. So that's the sense in which I ask for the gift
of prophecy. And I think all my people should test it and hold fast to what is good. But when
I give them the word, as much as they see the word as the word, they just take that for what it is.
God's word. For a non-preacher who has an impression, they think, from God to help
somebody, a consolation or encouragement for them, any counsel for how to go about
communicating that. Right. That's a very good application because there are people who have,
I think, abused the gift of prophecy by delivering their thoughts in a way that puts the other person
in an impossible situation. And I think that's probably why Paul says, don't despise prophecy.
Now, why would he say that? Frankly, in my experience, I am tempted to despise prophesying
because they have been so abused in my experience. I'll give you one example.
When I was trying to help our people with these things some years ago and teach them to be open
to the Spirit and pursuing the Spirit, not just cautiously open, like some people say,
but the Bible says, earnestly desire spiritual gifts, especially the prophecy. And so I'm
encouraging our people to seek the spiritual gifts so that we can minister graces to each
other, love, joy, peace, patience, goodness, kindness, those and the gifts. The gift of
faith and the gift of miracles and the gift of healing and the gift of tongues and the
gift of teaching and interpretation and all these things. Just go ahead, ask the Lord
for those things. Don't make him give you anything, but just ask him, well, a woman
came to me while my wife is pregnant with my fourth child, and she says,
I have a very hard prophecy for you. I said, okay. She said, in fact, she wrote it down,
gave it to me. Your wife is going to die in childbirth, and you're going to have a daughter.
I went back to my study. I thanked her. I said, I appreciate that. I forget what I said,
but I didn't want to hear that. I went back to my study. I got down. I just wept. I said,
Lord, I've been trying to help these people take this gift seriously, and I don't know
what to do with this. I cannot imagine why this would be helpful. It doesn't feel like it's of
you, and yet I don't want to discourage people. So I kept it totally to myself. I didn't tell
Noel, my wife, about it, and when we delivered our fourth boy, not girl, I gave a hoop,
which I always do, but this hoop was a little extra because I knew as soon as the boy was born,
this was not a true prophecy, and Noel is still alive, and Barnabas is, what, 27 years old today,
but that's the sort of thing that makes you despise prophecies. You're just like,
I don't want anything to do with that kind of stuff, and I don't blame people for feeling that
way, but the Bible says don't despise them. Be careful and discerning. So my answer to your
question is, if you sense something you have for somebody, offer it to them as a gift. Don't
thrust it at them as a demand. I sense. I would use the words like, I sense that God wants me to
say to you. I mean, I do this when I'm jogging. I'm praying for people, and I'll pass somebody,
and if the Lord seems to say that would be a good person to talk to, I don't hear any voice. I just
say, I could talk to anybody right now. I could knock on any door I want. I could do anything,
and this person seems to be the one God has appointed. I'll go up to that person,
and I'll say something like this. I'm out jogging and praying for the neighborhood this morning,
and while I was running by, I sensed the Lord wanted me to stop and talk to you.
Anything I can pray for you about, or how are you doing? Now that's just an offer that God,
and then I may have something more specific than that, but that's the way I would go about it.
Offer gifts to people. These are spiritual gifts. They're not spiritual hammers, and so
offer it to them and say, just test it, and if it seems to help, wonderful.
