Ethiopia STOPPED Planting Trees in the Desert — Nobody Saw This Coming!

Flowers and plants
71 followers
9 Video Views·Jun 16, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the highlands of northern Ethiopia, in a region called Tigray, that sits between two of the most
extreme landscapes on the African continent, there is a forest that, 20 years ago, almost everyone
believed was dying. The Desa'a forest sits roughly 400 kilometers north of Addis Ababa, perched on
the edge of a steep escarpment that drops down towards Danakil Depression, one of the hottest
places on Earth, where summer temperatures regularly exceed 45 degrees Celsius. On the
other side of the forest, the land rises into the Tigray Highlands, an area that has supported
continuous human agriculture for over 3,000 years. The forest itself spans an enormous elevation
range, from 900 meters in the lowlands up to 3,100 meters at its highest reaches. It is, by
international scientific classification, a dry Afro-Montane forest, one of only a handful of
ecosystems of its kind left in the entire Horn of Africa. And by the early 2000s, roughly 40%
of its closed canopy was gone. For over a century, the forest had been slowly chipped away by overgrazing,
charcoal production, expanding farmland, and the simple, brutal mathematics of a half a million
people depending on the land for survival, in a region where the rainfall does not always come
when it should. The trees came down. The hills went bare. And then, in a process I think more
people need to understand, the entire water cycle of the region began to collapse. I'm Edmund Hale,
and this is the story of one of the strangest and most genuinely successful land restoration
projects in modern Africa. Not because of what they planted, but because of what they refused to
plant. Stay with me, because what the engineers, the villagers, and the international researchers
working in Desai discovered is something that fundamentally challenges how the world has been
thinking about restoring forests for the last 50 years. And once you understand it, you cannot
really look at a tree planting campaign the same way ever again. Let me start with something I think
most people don't realize. Because to understand why the Desai project worked, you first have to
understand why almost everything else doesn't. For most of the modern era, the global response to
deforestation has been the same. Plant more trees. Buy nursery seedlings. Dig holes. Put them in the
ground. Take photographs. Report the numbers to the donor agencies, the government ministries,
the news outlets. Move on. It is, on paper, the simplest, most photogenic environmental intervention
humans have ever devised. And it has dominated environmental policy in country after country,
from China, to India, to Pakistan, to Ethiopia itself, for the better part of half a century.
There is just one problem with it. In a 2019 announcement that went around the world,
the government of Turkey claimed to have planted 11 million trees in a single day. The photographs
were spectacular. The international press celebrated the achievement. And then, within
just a few months, an investigation by the Turkish Foresters Association reported that as many as 90
percent of those 11 million trees had already died. The wrong species had been chosen. Trees
had been planted in the wrong season. There was no follow-up care. The soil had not been prepared.
The land had not been ready. This is not unusual. It is, in fact, the rule rather than the exception.
Across the world, large-scale tree-planting campaigns regularly report failure rates
between 60 and 90 percent. The reasons vary, but they generally come down to the same underlying
truth. In a degraded landscape, the problem is almost never that there are not enough trees.
The problem is that the land itself has lost the capacity to grow trees.
The soil has compacted. The water has stopped soaking in. The microbiology that supports
plant life has collapsed. The grazing pressure has not been removed. Planting a tree into that
kind of broken landscape is almost literally like trying to plant a tree on concrete.
This is what was happening in Dessau for decades. International organizations would
arrive with funding, plant tens of thousands of nursery seedlings in neat rows, take their
photographs, write their reports, and leave. And within a few months, the goats would eat what
survived the first dry season. The water would run off the bare slopes faster than the roots
could anchor, and the forest would, year after year, continue to die. The local people watching
this cycle had a name for it. They called it planting graves. By around 2010, after decades
of this, a different idea began to take hold. The idea did not come from international experts.
It came, in large part, from the villagers themselves. From local Ethiopian agronomists
who had been quietly studying the problem for years. And from a small number of foreign
researchers who had figured out, in other dry African landscapes, that the standard approach
was fundamentally broken. The idea is so simple and so counterintuitive that when you first hear it,
you may need a moment to absorb it. The idea is this. Before you plant anything, you have to fix
the ground. And in many cases, you do not need to plant trees at all. The trees are already there.
They are just hiding. Let me explain both halves of that, because each one is genuinely fascinating.
The first half, fixing the ground, comes down to something the project leaders eventually started
calling planting the rain. The phrase is more literal than it sounds. In a place like Dasar,
the average annual rainfall is not, by global standards, especially low. There is rain.
The problem is that the rain hits a landscape that can no longer absorb it. Decades of overgrazing
have stripped the topsoil of organic matter. Livestock hooves have compacted the surface
into something that behaves more like asphalt than soil. The deep root systems that used to crack
and aerate the underlying earth are gone. So when the rain falls, it does not soak in. It hits the
bare ground, beads up and runs sideways down the slope, picking up speed as it goes, scouring away
whatever soil is left and disappearing into the lowlands before any plant can use it.
This phenomenon has a name. Hydrologists call it green drought. The land is dying of thirst,
not because the rain has stopped, but because the rain can no longer get into the ground.
The water cycle has been physically broken. So the project leaders, working with thousands of
villagers across the Dasar landscape, started with the ground itself. Not with trees, with
engineering. Across the bare hillsides, they began digging. They dug long, shallow trenches across the
slopes, perpendicular to the direction of water flow. They dug small bowl-shaped pits a metre or
so across, scattered across the hillsides like dimples on a vast golf course. They built low
stone walls along the elevation lines, hundreds of kilometres of them in total, stacked by hand
from whatever rock the slope provided. I want to be honest about what this work looked like,
because the scale is important. According to research published in the journal
Frontiers in Forests and Global Change in 2022, across the Tigray region alone, communities have
moved an estimated 90 million tonnes of soil and rock by hand over the past several decades
to restore roughly one million hectares of degraded land. 90 million tonnes by hand.
Most of it done by villagers, many of them women and elderly residents, wielding pickaxes, shovels
and crowbars, working for weeks and months under conditions that would defeat almost any mechanised
operation. It is, by some measures, one of the largest hand-built engineering projects in modern
African history, and almost nobody outside of Ethiopia has ever heard of it. The point of all
of this earthwork is the same – to slow water down. A trench across a slope catches water before
it can run off, and gives it time to soak into the soil. A pit fills with rainwater and slowly
releases it into the ground over hours or days. A stone wall along a contour breaks a long slope
into shorter segments, each one a smaller catchment. None of these structures by themselves
are dramatic. None of them look like environmental restoration when you are standing next to them.
For the first two or three years, the landscape just looks scarred, pocked, like an open-pit mine.
But underneath, something is starting to happen. The water table, which had been dropping for
decades, begins to rise. Springs that have been dry for a generation begin to flow again.
The soil begins to hold moisture for the first time in years. And that is when the second half
of the breakthrough comes in. The part nobody outside of the regenerative agriculture world
tends to talk about. The hidden forest. Because here is the thing about a place like Dasar.
The forest was never really dead. It was just underground.
The dominant native trees of this ecosystem, species like the East African pencil cedar,
Juniperus proserra, and the African olive, Olea europaea, have evolved an extraordinary survival
strategy. When their stems are repeatedly cut, browsed by goats, or burned, the trees do not die.
They retreat. They survive as underground root stocks. Massive, ancient, biological batteries.
And they wait. Some of them have been waiting like this for decades.
The above-ground stems may have been cut a hundred times, but the root system,
slowly mining the deep soil for whatever water remains, is still alive. Still ready.
This is called natural regeneration capacity, and it is one of the best-kept secrets in the
world of forest restoration. Once you understand it, you start to see a fundamentally different
landscape. What looks like a barren hillside dotted with twigs is often, in reality, a forest
with no canopy. Trees are there. They are just compressed underground,
waiting for the conditions that would let them rise. The technique of working with these hidden
root stocks, rather than planting new seedlings, has a name. It is called farmer-managed natural
regeneration, often abbreviated as FMNR. Its modern formalization is largely credited to an
Australian agronomist named Tony Rinaldo, who in the 1980s was working as a missionary in Niger,
watching tree-planting campaign after tree-planting campaign fail in the Sahel.
One afternoon, frustrated and ready to give up, he stopped to examine what he had assumed
was a small shrub by the side of the road. And he realized, with what he later described
as a kind of horrified clarity, that the shrub was not a shrub at all. It was the top of a tree.
A full tree that had been cut to the ground over and over again, but whose root system was alive
and active beneath the soil. And once he started looking for them, he saw them everywhere.
The Sahel, which had been described in international reports as a denuded, lifeless
landscape, was actually full of dormant forests, waiting for permission to return.
For his decades of work developing FMNR and demonstrating it across Africa, Tony Rinaldo
received the Right Livelihood Award in 2018, what is sometimes called the Alternative Nobel Prize.
The technique he helped pioneer has since been documented to restore tens of millions
of hectares across the Sahel. And it forms the scientific backbone of the work now underway
in Dassar. The actual process is almost shockingly simple. Villagers walk the landscape,
looking for the dormant rootstocks. When they find one, they do not plant anything next to it.
Instead, they prune. They identify the strongest one or two stems on the existing rootstock,
and they remove the weaker, browse-damaged sucker growth around them. That pruning
channels all of the stored root energy into rapid upward growth from the chosen stems.
Because the rootstock already has years of underground biomass,
those stems can rise meters in a single growing season, far faster than any nursery seedling
could ever match, far cheaper than any nursery program could ever produce. And with survival
rates that, in well-managed FMNR projects, regularly exceed 90%, many times the survival
rate of conventional planting. In Dassar specifically, the project being run by We
Forest Ethiopia, in partnership with the Tigray Bureau of Agriculture and Rural Development,
formalized in a Memorandum of Understanding signed in March 2019, has applied these techniques
across a project area of roughly 38,000 hectares. They have combined the FMNR work with the earth
work, the trenches, the pits, the stone walls, and with a third critical element that I have
not yet mentioned, because it is the one that requires the most from the local people.
They close the land to free grazing. In the regions where the restoration work is most
intensive, livestock, particularly goats, were banned from the recovering landscapes.
This was, by far, the hardest part of the entire project to negotiate. Free grazing
has been part of the cultural and economic fabric of Tigrayan agriculture for centuries.
Asking families to remove their livestock from large areas of land, even temporarily,
is not a small thing. The project worked with village councils, traditional leaders,
and local communities to design what amounted to a new kind of land use agreement.
Some areas were closed to grazing entirely. Others were opened only seasonally. In exchange,
the project introduced what is called a cut-and-carry livestock system. Farmers harvest
grass from the recovering areas and bring it to penned animals, rather than letting the animals
roam free on the hillsides. Studies have shown that animals kept in cut-and-carry systems often
gain weight faster and produce more income than free-grazed livestock anyway, because they are
not constantly walking miles in search of food. But the cultural transition was real, and it took
years. The combination of these three elements – plant the rain first, regenerate the hidden
forest instead of planting seedlings, and close the land to free grazing – is what produced the
results in Dessa. Not one of them, by itself, would have worked. All three together did. I want to be
honest about what those results look like, because the story is more remarkable than I think most
viewers realize, and I do not want to overstate it. Within roughly five years of the work beginning
in the most intensively restored areas, the satellite imagery is unmistakable.
There is a visible green line cutting across the Tigrayan landscape. On one side of the project
boundary, the dusty, eroded, scrub-dominated hillsides that were standard for the region.
On the other side, recovering juniper and olive canopy, returning ground vegetation,
stabilized soil. Streams that had been seasonal trickles are running clearer and longer into the
dry season. Springs that local elders remembered from their childhoods, but have been dry for 30
or 40 years, are flowing again. Bird species and pollinator populations that have been absent from
the survey records have started showing up in monitoring data. And then, in 2020, the work
survived something that, frankly, almost destroyed it. In November of 2020, war broke out in the
Tigray region. For the next two years, the area was largely cut off from the outside world.
International aid organizations evacuated their staff. Most foreign-funded projects shut down
entirely. The infrastructure of restoration, the technical assistance, the nursery support,
the financing, collapsed. But the work in Dessa continued. The trenches kept being dug.
The stone walls kept being repaired. The rootstocks kept being pruned. The reason it continued is, I
think, the single most important lesson the entire project has to offer. The knowledge of what to do
by 2020 was no longer held by the international NGOs. It was held by the villagers themselves.
The restoration was no longer a project being done to the landscape by outsiders. It was a
practice being performed by the people who lived on it. When the war isolated the region, the people
kept working because the work was now theirs. The forest came through the war. Some of it diminished.
There is no honest version of this story in which a two-year war over a vulnerable landscape produces
no losses. But the core restoration work survived. And in the post-war assessment,
ecologists found that many of the most intensively restored areas had actually continued to advance,
even without any external support. So that is the story, or most of it. A handful of villages,
working with a small number of patient Ethiopian and international scientists,
refused to plant trees in a dying landscape. Instead, they spent years preparing the ground,
slowing the water, finding the hidden forests already in the soil, and rewriting their
relationship with their own livestock. And in doing so, they pulled off something that,
by global tree-planting standards, was almost statistically impossible. A high-survival,
low-cost, community-owned forest restoration that has now been studied as a model for similar work
across the African continent. There is a lesson buried in this whole story that I think is worth
sitting with, because it applies to far more than just trees. We are entering a century in which
humanity is going to be attempting ecological restoration on a scale never before required.
The conventional approach – plant more, plant faster, plant for the cameras – has been failing
for decades, and it will continue to fail. The Dessau story suggests something simpler and
harder. Stop trying to put life back into broken ground. Fix the ground first. Find the life that
is already there, waiting, and then get out of its way. Or, as one of the village elders working
with the project put it more succinctly when an interviewer asked him to summarise what the team
had learned over the years, the land was never dead, we just stopped listening to it. If this
story changed how you see what is possible, or how you think about restoration in general,
let me know in the comments. And subscribe, because the real stories of how the world's
broken ecosystems are coming back are stranger, slower, and more important than the headlines
tell you. There are more of these stories than you would ever guess. I'm Edmund Hale, thanks for watching.
