Best Walking Shoes By Foot Type: Flat Feet, High Arches, Pronation & Supination (Podiatrist 2026)
2 Video Views·Jun 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
There aren't enough people talking about good shoes for supernation.
That's a real comment from my last video on city walking shoes and it's not the only one.
After part one went out the comments were full of four clear themes.
People asking about supernation because no one ever covers it.
People asking what to do with bad knees because the wrong walking shoe makes them worse.
And people asking about the best shoes for overpronation and flat feet.
Those are real concerns from real viewers and we're going to deal with them all in today's video.
By the end of this video you'll know exactly which walking shoe is right for your foot type.
Whether you've got flat feet, high arches, you supernate or you overpronate.
I'll tell you the one shoe I'd reach for in each category.
The brand name pick I'd actively avoid.
And the at-home test you can do in 10 seconds to figure out which category you're in,
if you're not sure.
There's also one shoe in this video that every physio and shop assistant recommends for supernation
and it's the wrong call for half the people who buy it.
I'll show you exactly when it works and when it makes you worse.
Let's step into it.
I'm Paul McCauley, a British trained podiatrist based in Singapore.
Quick thing before we get into it.
You'll hear me talk about four foot types in this video and they're easy to confuse.
Two of them, flat feet and high arches, are about the shape of your foot
when you're standing still.
Two of them, pronation and supernation, are about how your foot moves when you walk.
They overlap a lot.
Most people with flat feet do overpronate.
Lots of people with high arches do supernate, but not always.
Some people have flat feet that don't roll in.
Some people have high arches that don't roll out.
So when I'm telling you the right walking shoe for each,
I'm covering both the shape and the motion.
Stick with me, this matters.
The two tests.
Before I lose you, this next bit is the part you can't skip.
If you get your foot type wrong, every shoe recommendation after this is useless to you.
So give me 90 seconds and we'll do two quick tests.
One tells you how your foot moves.
The other tells you what shape it is and you need both.
Test one, the wear pattern test.
Grab the oldest pair of trainers you own and flip them over.
Now here's the bit most people get wrong.
What you want to look at is two specific places.
Look at the inside of the heel.
If that's really worn down, you're a pronator.
The foot is rolling inwards and grinding the medial side of the rubber off.
Now look at the outside of the midfoot and the outside of the forefoot.
If you've got noticeable wear on the outside through these zones, you're a supernator.
That pattern means you're not toeing off through your big toe properly,
which means you're still supernating right through to push off.
That's the most reliable signal you'll get without coming into clinic to see me.
If you've got fairly even wear, you're closer to neutral.
That's how your foot is moving.
Now we need to know the shape it's in because the two don't always match up.
Some people pronate with a high arch.
Some people have flat feet that don't roll in.
The wear test alone will miss that.
So test number two, this one's been around for decades
and it still works better than half the gait scans you'll pay for.
Wet the bottom of your foot, step onto a piece of paper or a dry patch of concrete,
lift the foot off and look at the print you've left behind.
There are three patterns to look for.
If your print comes out as full rectangle,
where the whole sole has made contact from heel to forefoot
with no curve or cut out of the inside, you've got a flat foot.
If you can see a clear forefoot mark, a clear heel mark
and a strip of contact running down the outside connecting the two,
you've got a neutral arch.
That's the most common pattern.
And if you only see a heel mark and a forefoot mark
with nothing connecting them down the side, you've got a high arch.
The middle of your foot isn't touching the ground at all.
So now you've got both pieces, the shape from the wet foot,
the motion from the shoe, put them together
and you know exactly which of the four categories in this video you belong in.
This is literally the first thing I do with my patients
before I recommend a shoe for them.
And you've just done it for free.
So pause the video right now and do both.
One more thing before we start.
Everything I'm covering applies regardless of sex.
Let's talk about supinated feet.
Published data suggest only about 10% of the population are true supinators.
In my Singapore practice, it's even lower, maybe 2-5%
because the local foot demographics here skew flatter and more pronated.
Which is probably why nobody makes content for you.
The comment at the top of this video isn't wrong.
So this section is the one I've put the most work into.
Big misconception.
A lot of people self-identify as supinated because they've got a high arch.
High arch doesn't equal supinated.
A high arch foot can still pronate dynamically when you walk or run.
That's why the worn shoe test matters more than just looking at the arch.
Now the knee.
Supinated feet can cause knee pain, but it changes depending on the timeline.
Short term, the pain shows up on the outside of the knee.
The rigid foot doesn't absorb shock, so the force travels up into lateral structures.
Long term, that flips.
Supination causes a medial shift in ground reaction force, which increases knee adduction.
Acute pain on the outside, chronic pain on the inside.
The same foot type, but two completely different stories.
So if you're a true supinator, getting the right shoe matters.
This is specifically true if you're dealing with peroneal tenopathy,
which is pain on the outside of the ankle from the foot rolling out too much.
Let's look at two options.
First up, the Hoka Bondai 9.
This is the shoe most people get recommended for a supinated foot.
Stay with me because whether it's right for you comes down to one thing.
Most people never get told.
It's a max cushion shoe with a rocker,
and for high arch, mildly supinated foot, that rocker actually helps.
Supinators often struggle to push off properly through the big toe.
The rocker encourages that toe motion for you.
The cushioning matters too.
High arches concentrate pressure on the heel and the forefoot,
so a max cushioning shoe acts as a shock absorber
and takes compressive load off those two pressure points.
The Bondai also has a lateral flare,
which means if we look at the outside of the shoe,
you'll see it's wider than where your foot actually sits.
That extra foam catches the foot when it rolls outwards
and stops it rolling off the edge of the shoe.
Without that flare, a supinated foot would just tip off the side.
Here's where it falls apart on a different front.
If you're really supinated or if you're carrying a bit of extra weight,
the Bondai's foam compresses too easily under the lateral load.
The foam is soft.
Soft foam under heavy lateral forces just gives way
and the foot rolls further into supination instead of being supported.
The same shoe, the opposite outcome.
Great for the lighter, mild supinator.
Counterproductive for the heavier, more supinated foot.
That's the Trap, a shoe that gets recommended for a foot type
when it actually only works for half of that foot type.
If you bought a Bondai expecting it to fix your supination and it hasn't, this is why.
Shoe number two, the Mizuno WaveRider 29.
If you're a heavier supinator or your foot rolls out too aggressively for the Bondai to handle,
the Mizuno WaveRider 29 is the shoe I'd go for next.
And this is a shoe I haven't seen a single other podiatrist recommend for this use case.
Here's why it works and why the Bondai doesn't.
It's still a neutral shoe but it's firmer than the Bondai and that's the key difference.
From the heel to just before the forefoot, there's a nylon plate.
That gives torsional rigidity and reduces how much your foot collapses
as you move through mid stance into push off.
What that does is encourage you to load more through the central portion of your foot
and push off through your big toe rather than your lesser toes,
which is exactly what a supinator struggles to do.
The foam bevels out beyond where your foot sits and the toe box is nice and wide.
There's plenty of rubber through the outsole too,
with more on the lateral side of the heel and a generous amount through the forefoot as well.
That extra rubber gives the shoe more stability on ground contact,
which matters a lot for walking where you spend more time on the lateral side of your foot.
That's really nice for walking, especially for older patients
who are used to a lower stack height and don't want a shoe that feels too tall or unstable underfoot.
One thing to flag, this isn't the shoe for someone with a very flat,
excessively pronated foot.
The foam is still on the softer side and it's a neutral cushion shoe, not a stability shoe.
Next up is the Mount2Coast H1, a niche shoe on this list but one that's thoroughly impressed me.
I took it to Hong Kong recently and put it through proper miles
and it's earned its place in this video.
It's designed for ultra marathon runners,
which means it's built to handle road, light trails and gravel paths.
That makes it ideal for summer dog walking in the UK or US
or for slightly rainy days when you want a bit more grip underfoot.
What stood out to me is how lightweight it is for the amount of cushioning it has.
For someone with a higher rigid arch,
that cushioning takes the impact load off the heel and the forefoot,
which is where pressure tends to concentrate.
There's also a nice rocker in the midsole,
which makes the shoe feel easy to walk in at the start and the end of a long day.
It's also got an interesting adjustable lacing system
with a separate lower section you can tighten independently.
If you're hiking downhill, that's a really nice feature
because you can lock the foot down and stop it sliding forwards,
which reduces how much your toe jams into the front of the toe box.
A quick warning for supernators.
Here's the thing, though.
If you supernate, stay away from this shoe.
The soft foam and the lack of stability will make your foot roll out further, not less.
It's a brilliant high arch shoe and a poor supernator shoe.
Same brand, same model,
but completely different result depending on what your foot is actually doing.
A few more things to flag.
This shoe is not that stable.
When I twist it, it flexes pretty easily.
When I flex the toe box, it flexes really easily.
The foam is on the softer side throughout, which is ideal for that higher arch foot,
but not great if you're looking for stability
or you're dealing with arch pain, plantar fasciitis or posterior tibial tendon issues.
It also sadly only comes in one width and that width is pretty standard.
If you've got a wider foot or forefoot conditions like Morton's Neuroma,
you're probably going to want more space than this shoe actually offers.
Now we're flipping it.
What about the foot that needs all of this in reverse?
The flat, excessively pronated foot looking for proper stability.
That's where we're going next.
And if you've been waiting for the pronator section because that's you,
this is the section of the video that you want to zone into.
The third foot type, pronated and flat feet.
For most people, flat feet and overpronation come together.
The flat shape leads to an inward roll and the shoes that work for one work for the other.
So one section, two shoes, both targeted at the same foot type for slightly different reasons.
If you've got flat feet that don't roll inward when you walk,
that's the rare representation, but the same shoes still work for you.
The shape needs to support either way.
This shoe, I'm really excited to share with you.
It's a New Balance 860 V15.
When this dropped, I was really happy to see
they properly improved the stability aspect compared to the previous version.
If you own the V14 and you've been happy with it,
I'm about to tell you why you shouldn't replace it with another V14.
This is a genuine upgrade, not a rebadge.
Here's the problem we're trying to solve.
If you've got an excessively pronated foot and you wear a shoe that's too soft,
the foam compresses under you, your foot rolls in further
and you end up with more strain on your posterior tibial tendon,
the arch, the plantar fascia, your bunion and the big toe joint.
That's how soft shoes can make plantar fasciitis,
post-tiptoe dysfunction, bunions and arch pain so much worse.
The V14 was a decent shoe, but it lacked stability.
It twisted and bent in half pretty easily
and they'd made it softer than the previous versions.
With the V15, they've gone the other way.
The foam is firmer, there's a larger stack height
and they've added more rubber on both the medial and lateral sides of the sole.
The heel counter is firmer too, so the rear foot stays locked in.
But there's one thing to flag.
With this higher stack height, your foot hits the ground earlier in the gait cycle,
which can put more load through the knee.
The V15 also has a higher heel-to-toe drop,
which can mean a bit more strain on the front of the knee.
If you've got knee issues and you look at your shoe collection
and you notice every shoe has a very thick sole,
the stack height could be part of why your knees hurt.
That's the frustrating part.
The same feature that fixes your arch pain might be the thing winding up your knees,
which is why I almost never stop at one shoe for this foot type.
The next one is the fix of the knee pain.
Quick word on how pronation affects the knees,
because it's the mirror image of what we covered for supernators.
Short-term, pronation causes acute pain on the inside of the knee.
The foot rolls in, the tibia rotates inwards with it
and that puts extra pressure through the adductors and the medial structures.
Long-term, it flips.
Excessive pronation pushes you towards a knock-kneed alignment over decades,
which loads the lateral compartment of the knee.
That's where you end up with lateral compartment osteoarthritis.
A stability shoe like the 860 V15 should help both sides of the knee feel better,
because it stops the pronation that's driving the issue.
But if you're feeling more pressure on the front of the knee,
the higher stack height might still be working against you.
But don't worry, the next shoe we're going to talk about is much lower in stack height
and still works really well for flat pronated feet.
The Asics Canon 14, same foot type, different shoes,
because some of you are going to want a lower stack height for your knees.
The next shoe takes a bit of a turn,
because it's very different from anything else in this video.
It's a lifestyle shoe, the Asics Kayano 14.
This is the rule breaker I mentioned.
Every other shoe in this list is a proper performance walk-in or running shoe.
This one is essentially a 2008 running shoe put back into production,
and it might be the most useful shoe I've bought in a decade.
If you've been around long enough,
you'll remember the glory days when every shoe looked like this.
A lot of you watching probably preferred them.
Honestly, this is one of my favourite shoes.
As someone with very flat, very pronated feet,
who's dealt with plantar fasciitis, posterior tibial pain and an ankle sprain,
this shoe ticks every box for me.
I wear them on every trip.
I took them to Australia at Christmas and played golf 12 times in them.
They've seen a bit of the world.
What makes them work is the combination of a firm sole with a low stack height.
The firmness gives you proper stability,
so the foot doesn't collapse inward like it does in softer shoes.
The lower stack height means your foot contacts the ground
slightly later in the gait cycle,
which reduces the load on the knee every step.
This is a shoe I'd recommend if you've got on with the 860 V15,
but found the stack height was bothering your knees.
If you've been gripping the floor with your toes
to feel stable in your current trainers,
your shoe is fighting you.
The Kayano 14 is your halfway house.
Firm enough to give you proper stability,
low enough that you're not towering over the ground.
A couple of things to flag.
They only come in one width,
a B width in women's,
a D width in men's.
If you've got a wider foot,
these probably won't work for you.
They're brilliant for a sporty everyday look
and great for long walking.
Some of my patients even run in them too,
but personally, I'd stick to a running shoe
with better technology for running.
So that's the four foot types covered.
Now you know which walking shoe is right for your foot type,
what to actively avoid
and quick test to figure out which category you're in.
And if you did the 10 second test at the start,
you know something about your own feet
that most people go their whole lives without figuring out.
If you missed part one
where I covered the best city walking shoes overall,
that's linked in the description
and at the end of this video.
Watch them in either order.
About 75% of people watching this video aren't subscribed.
If you're one of them, hit subscribe.
I'm going to be posting one of these every week
and the next one is going to be specifically
for women over 50
because that came up over and over again in the comments.
And if you want personalized advice on your specific feet,
you can book a session with me
in person here in Singapore
or online wherever you are in the world.
The bottom line, the right walking shoe isn't about brand.
It's about your foot.
Thanks for watching and I'll see you in the next one.

