The XC Trend That Might Be Holding You Back

RockShades
98 followers
#sport #travel #running #marathon #cycling bicycle #training #race #triathlon #swim bike #run adventure #inspire
AI Generated·May contain errors
Dropper posts have changed mountain biking. Even cross-country riders, the last to be
convinced all now run them. Why for dropper post is actually making you slower? Today,
I'm finding out if droppers really make sense for XC or if we've all just been following
the trend. There's no denying just how good dropper posts are. They allow you to shift
your body weight around the bike more, always have your seat set to the correct height,
and generally just ride more confidently. Gone are the days of getting to the top of
a trail, having to get off your bike and manually lower your seat before you drop into
a descent. Now, with the push of a lever or button, you can lower your seat on the fly.
Dropper posts became a common appearance on mountain bikes in the early 2010s, but it
wasn't until a lot longer after that that we started to see them appearing on XC bikes.
Why did it take so long for cross-country riders to put droppers on their bikes? Well,
for a while, one of the main reasons was actually compatibility. A lot of early XC bikes often
came spec'd with a 27.2-millimeter diameter seat post. On a short travel full suspension
bike or a hardtail, these thinner diameter seat posts are more compliant, therefore giving
a more comfortable ride. A lot of early dropper posts only came in a 30.9 diameter or a 31.6,
so simply you just couldn't fit one to an XC bike.
Then there was the big one for XC riders, the weight. The original RockShox Reverb weighed
around 515 grams without hardware, whereas the top-of-the-range carbon seat post can
be as light as 140 grams. That's nearly a 400-gram weight penalty for the seat post
alone, never mind the remote and cable. In a sport where every gram counts, most riders
weren't willing to sacrifice climbing speed for a little bit more confidence on the descents.
A modern-day RockShox Reverb AXS in its longest drop can weigh as much as nearly 700 grams,
which is a huge weight penalty. Finally, for a long while, XC courses just weren't gnarly
enough to justify a dropper. Descents were fairly tame and riders could get down them
quickly enough and efficiently enough without needing to lower their saddle.
What changed? Well, XC courses got a lot more technical, dropper posts got lighter, and
they became available in smaller diameters that actually fit XC bikes. It turned out
it wasn't so much about descending faster, but about descending easier. Using less energy
on the way down meant riders could recover more and then hit the next climb harder. It
only took a few riders to make the switch, and before long, it seemed like every XC rider
had a dropper post on their bike. Interestingly, though, the GOAT of XC and arguably one of
the best bike handlers of all time, Nino Schurter, was one of the last top riders to adopt a
dropper post, not putting one on his bike until 2021.
Now, that actually brings me on to myself. I didn't run a dropper post on my XC bike
until 2023. I'm obviously no Nino Schurter, but it's no secret I'm a huge fan of his.
I race mainly at national level here in the UK, where generally the courses aren't that
technical. I found myself being really confident descending with the seat post up, and that
wasn't where I was losing time. Quite simply, I was losing races because I was getting spat
going uphill. My thought process was simple. Why don't I make my bike heavier and potentially
slower going uphill, where that's where I was getting dropped? I needed every advantage
I could get, and adding weight to my bike felt like a backward step. In the end, I put
a dropper post on my bike, quite simply because I wanted riding to be more fun.
I might only race 10 to 15 times a year, but I rode my XC bike almost every day. Adding
a dropper meant I can enjoy my local trails more. When I was racing, I did find it helped
me attack descents and recover better between climbs.
Recently, I've started to question that decision. For most types of XC racing below World Cup
level, would you actually be better switching back to a fixed post? Would the weight savings
help you that much more on the climbs? How much slower would you really be on the descents?
Well, today I'm going to find out. I'm going to test the dropper post against the trusty
old fixed seat post on my go-to XC lap. Some of you younger viewers probably don't even
know what one of these is, but this is what we all had on our XC bikes back in the day.
To truly test both posts, I am going to try and ride at somewhat of a hard XC pace. I
think one of the main things you notice with a high post is when you're descending with
those really high heart rates after you've smashed it up a climb, it's really difficult
to recover with the seat up. I'm going to really smash it up the climbs, but I am going
to use my Garmin XC Rally Power Meter pedal. Hopefully, I'll be able to replicate the exact
same power on each climb to make the test as fair as possible so we can see how much
difference the weight makes. The lap's not stupidly gnarly, but it's got
a few testing technical features that should really test me when I've got the seat post
fully up. Also, it's got two notable climbs where I should notice the difference in weight,
hopefully, between the fixed seat post and the dropper post. Talking of weight, let's
actually weigh these on the scales to see what difference there is between the two posts.
This is the bit all you weight weenies will have been looking forward to. I'm going to
weigh the two seat posts to see how much difference it actually makes. Now, on the Orbea always
I have, I have got one of the lightest dropper posts going, so it's a Fox Transfer SL. The
weight differences won't be as big as some other bikes, but I think it will still be
significant. I'm going to weigh the carbon post first. Let's have a look. That is 214
grams. Then I'm going to weigh the Fox Transfer. I think it's important to remember as well,
this is the post only. There is the outer cable that runs from the remote all the way
to the dropper post, as well as the remote itself, which will add probably another 100,
150 grams, but I've not taken them out on the bike. Post alone, 432 grams. The seat post alone
is about double the weight of the carbon post, which is quite significant off-camera as well.
I have weighed another brand of post with a longer drop because this is only 100 mil. The longer
drop seat post was around 650 grams, so that's even more significant. I guess it's only 215
grams weight penalty, but when you're doing really hilly races where every gram matters,
that does actually count for quite a lot. Then like I said, if you had a heavier dropper post,
it is quite significant, but let's go see what difference it makes out on the lap.
Three, two, one. First climb, four minutes on the dot. That drop will be harder with the high
post. See if I can get the jump. Yes, that's the first ascent done. Felt comfortable on this,
but still tricky. Heart rate, 187. Should make the descent interesting. That's the first lap
done with the dropper post on, and that was hard work. Definitely made sure I tested that theory
of droppers help you descend better when you're knackered because my heart rate was 188 at the
top of that last descent, so definitely tested that theory. I've fitted the normal seat post,
and I'm just going to go out for a few laps first to get used to riding it again. I don't
want to do a time-lapse straight away because it's going to feel really alien to start with.
At the top of the first descent, it feels right on my bum. I don't know if this is higher than
I used to run in, but definitely found it easier back in the day riding like this. First impressions
of going back to the standard seat post, that was really hard, harder than I remember. Maybe
I've just been spoiled with droppers now. Just riding up to the second descent. I think that
one should be a bit easier, but we'll see how we get on. I'm glad I'm doing this sighting lap. If I
did the time-lapse now, I'd feel terrible. Oh, God. That was nearly enough. Cornering's really
feeling quite difficult. See if I can still do this. That made that one. Got this built really
hard. How did I do this? Okay, so I've done the lap with the dropper post. I was really pushing
on that, and I definitely think I actually needed it. It was really slippy, and at a few points,
I was glad I had my seat post down. I switched to the trusty old high post. Let's go put in a
time. I'm interested to see if the weight will make a difference on the climbs. All right,
three, two, one. First climb done. Three, three, one. Okay, first drop. Oh, God. Feeling a bit
more used to it. These corners are really hard with it. Oh, I'm not recovering as well. Can't
just relax as much on these. All right, that is the time-lapse done. Some fairly hairy moments,
but I will get to the high post. I think that's because of the conditions out. I'm going to go
back, analyze the results, and I'll let you know how we got on. Okay, so it's the next day,
and I've just done the two laps with the dropper post and with the carbon seatpost installed. The
results are really interesting. First off, I did the lap on the dropper, and I did a time of 9
minutes and 52 seconds with an average power of 252 watts. Second up, I did the lap with the non
dropper post, the carbon seatpost. I did 9.51, so one second faster, and that was of an average
power of 249, so a little bit less, give or take the same though. One second quicker without the
dropper. I don't think we can read too much into that. The actual interesting results are the first
climb I did with the dropper, I did 332 watts, and that gave me a time of 4.01. Then when I put the
carbon seatpost in, I did the exact same watts, 332, but I did a time of 3 minutes 54, so seven
seconds quicker without a dropper post on give or take a four-minute climb. It's pretty massive.
It's hard to tell. There's obviously quite a lot of variables. I might have rode a slightly
faster section of track on that climb. I might have distributed the power a bit better,
so I rode at higher power on the steeper bits. I think seven seconds on a climb like that,
it's only four minutes, it's fairly massive. Then going into the descent, this was the
interesting part. On the first descent with the dropper, I did a 1.10, with the non dropper,
I did a 1.13. Only three seconds over a minute and 10 descent isn't massive. I think in the
dry, like I say, that would have been a lot less. Going into the second climb, this is the one
that's a little bit less technical, a bit more gradual. With the dropper, I did 353 watts. That
was with a time of 2 minutes 49. With a non dropper, I did 355 watts and the exact same time,
2.49. That 200-gram weight penalty obviously didn't make too much of a difference on that
climb. On the second descent, I was two seconds slower without the dropper, so I did a 1.01 with
the dropper and a 1.03 without. Give or take, I think the non dropper wasn't too much slower on
those descents. I particularly picked fairly technical descents that you might see in a
modern cross-country lap, but nothing too gnarly, nothing that steep. The conditions definitely made
it harder. I think if we're doing a motoring style leaderboard, there'll definitely be a
W on that for a wet lap. I really struggled with the non dropper to start with. It felt
really sketchy. I couldn't get my weight around, but as I started to ride it more, I did find I
got a lot more comfortable. I was really interested to see that I was actually seven seconds faster at
the climb without the dropper post on. It has made me think if I'm doing marathon style events
that typically have less technical descending or just local cross-country where the courses
are nowhere near as gnarly as a World Cup course, would I be better off switching to a non dropper
post? I definitely think for my day-to-day training, I'll always run a dropper post because
it's so much more fun being able to throw the bike around and you just generally have more fun
descending. For racing alone, I think I might make the switch back to a rigid post every now
and again. Definitely not for every type of racing, but I did really enjoy it. I'd be interested to
hear what you guys think. Are you someone who still runs a normal seat post and haven't converted
to a dropper post, or are you a complete convert and wouldn't live without your dropper post now?
It's definitely got me thinking about maybe switching back every now and again. Let me
know what you guys think in the comments. If you've enjoyed the video, leave us a like
and a subscribe. I'll see you in the next one. Cheers.
