*New customers in AZ, CO, CT, DC, IA, IL, IN, KS, KY, LA, MA, MD, MI, MO, NC, NJ, NY, OH, PA, TN, VA, VT, WV, or WY. Must toggle on this promotion in your bet slip and wager $5+ cash on any market (min. odds -500) within 7 days of account opening to receive $100 in FanCash. Promotional FanCash expires 7 days from issuance (at 11:59pm ET). Terms, including FanCash terms apply-see Fanatics Sportsbook app. Use FanCash on bonus bets, profit boosts, team gear on Fanatics.com and so much more.
This video analyzes a controversial MLB play involving Ernie Clement to determine if he was correctly ruled safe despite appearing to leave the base path. By reviewing 400 similar plays from the last decade, the narrator examines the technical rules regarding base paths and tag attempts to justify the umpire's decision.
I watched 400 similar plays to this Ernie Clement one from the last 10 years of MLB
baseball to come to a final verdict.
This one's brought to you by Fanatic Sportsbook.
First, let's take a look at the overlay from Baz here.
That's the same pitch and then all of a sudden not.
So Clement can't hold up on the swing.
He puts the next one in play and Henderson botches it.
Easy routine ball.
Can't come up with it.
That puts Ernie Clement on first.
He's going to.
What are they doing?
They're fishing.
Tiny little fishing.
Is that what they're doing?
Shane Baz.
Not excited about that because it should have just been an out.
It hits the side of his glove, thumb side and just pops up into the air.
So people are frustrated already.
They were up big.
They're up for nothing.
Now it's 4-1.
The inning continues.
The next batter, slow chopper, Henderson again.
That happens.
Then he throws to the first and then they're all mad because the runner wasn't called out
and they're saying he's out.
No.
Hey, come on, Dan.
He's out of the ******* baseline.
Now everyone is at home that reads the rule book for funsies.
They're saying it's the base path, not the baseline, Pete, and we'll get to that.
And then the umpire explains it to the manager and he's just like, oh my God, say it without
giving me a headache, please.
What happened?
All right.
So let's break it down.
Here's the play.
Ernie Clement is on first.
He's running to second and he sees that the shortstop Henderson is coming in to field
this ball and if he continues to run straight, they're going to collide.
It would look like this.
And they'd crash.
I actually found footage of what would happen if he just continued running straight from
previous plays that are very similar.
Here's the little collision and then they throw the first and he's safe there.
Here's another time where you just run straight and you run into the out.
So that's not the best thing to do.
Easy double play.
What a lot of guys do when they're in Clement's position here is they stop, put on the brakes,
wait and see.
Sometimes the fielders just go get you out at second, but no double play.
Other times the runner puts on the brakes and then gets tagged and they turn it.
Sometimes though, the stopping works because you put on the brakes and they tag you, but
it took so long that they kill the double play.
That's kind of what is common.
You stop, you make it hard to be tagged, and then they don't get both outs.
They just get one.
Sometimes the fielders are smart and they're like, we'll worry about you later.
Throw it to first and then get the guy out later on.
That happens a decent amount too.
Not a decent amount.
I watched 400 plays that happened twice or three times right here.
So I'm showing you every time it happens.
So it's not that much, but it happens.
This is what I remember runners doing and it kind of becoming a fad where they just
stop and drop and make the tag hard or make a miss the tag.
But then you got to get up and get a second fast.
So it didn't work there.
But I remember runners just stopping and going fetal position and saying, you got to come
tag me.
It takes longer and you break up the double play by doing that.
Sometimes you do it really well and they miss the tag like right there.
And then you broke up the double play.
This is the best example.
10 years ago, we got Crawford running Ortiz batting and he ducks the tag.
They don't tag him and he's safe at second.
Clement did none of this.
He did not stop.
He did not try to run straight and beat the play.
What he did was something completely different.
And I did find one other example of a runner doing this.
I'm going to show you that at the end to see how the umpires handled that one.
What he does as soon as he sees it's happening, he changes his base path.
Now a runner can change his base path whenever.
If he decides he wants to round second, obviously he's going to take a giant turn.
It's paramount that he does this before the tag attempt.
Per the rules, the runner can go wherever he wants before a tag attempt is being made
and he's just creating a new base path.
So had he waited to make his big sweeping turn at this point, when the tag attempt is
being applied, he would be out of the base path.
But he did it so much earlier that he established a new base path.
Once the tag attempt is made, the runner has to make a straight line back to the bag.
So this is where it's a little up for debate.
But as soon as that tag attempt is made right here, he does plant his next step, plants
on his right foot so he can cut back to the base.
You know, the human body can't cut that fast, but that's what he did.
So I wanted to find all the other examples where out of the base path was either called
or the managers wanted it called.
And I found a handful.
We've got this one where they want it called, but the umpires say, no, he didn't go out
of the baseline.
And what you have here is he didn't stop.
He didn't turn.
He didn't duck.
He's just saying, I'm going to beat the play.
And yeah, you get three feet.
I think that is properly called.
He did not go out of the baseline or base path, I should say.
Now this one, that tag was never made, but they did call him out for going out of the
base path.
And this one, obviously he doesn't create a new path until the tag is being applied
and he gets three feet of wiggle room.
I think because he landed in the grass there, you know, take where his right foot is here
and where his right foot is there.
I think that's more than three feet.
So the umpires say, no, out of the base path on that one.
Here's another one where they call out of the base path.
And again, you have the runner going straight and it's when the tag is being applied that
he decides, now I'm going to create a new base path.
And they say, well, that's illegal and you're out, you're a cheater and you've been caught.
After watching about 400 of these plays, this is the only other one I've seen where the
runner changes his base path before the tag attempt.
And there is not even really a tag attempt.
It's similar to the Henderson tag, but even less.
And you can see that he changes his route before the tag attempt, if this is a tag attempt
by Miggy Roeg in the glove.
And he kind of looks at him and throws the hand out just a little bit before coming into
his glove hand.
I don't even know if you count that as a tag attempt, much less than the Henderson tag
attempt. But you can see from the overhead that on his way to second, right there, you
can see him change stride right there.
And he does a micro loop just enough to get out of, you know, a tag for Miggy Roeg.
Obviously, it's not as much as the Clement example that we have been watching where he
really goes around and then comes back.
I think per the rules, they called this correctly.
It's just do the rules feel right?
Because what's going to happen is if this play continues to happen, runners are going
to just create a crazy base path before the tag is even able to be applied or attempted.
They're just going to dart up towards the outfield and then be like, come and get me.
And then there's no double play being turned.
So I think it's, yeah, per the way the rules are written now, which is like a four part
rulebook, I think they kind of got it correct.
But I don't know if this is what they want running and avoiding tags to be.
If you perceive a tag is coming, you just create a crazy base path before the fielder
can even tag you.
And as I said, this inning started for nothing.
It becomes four to two.
And now you've got Ernie Clement on second base and Shane Baz is flustered and
frustrated. He gives up a single.
Clement scores.
They try to get the runner at first.
Pete dives for him.
Can't get him.
Damn, damn, come on, make a ******* pitch.
Let's go. Buckle down.
Nothing like a little pep talk.
And then the three two pitch wants it to be the last pitch of the inning.
Instead, it's hit to the wall and we've got another runner rounding all the bases,
sliding in and a tie game.
So the two plays really looming large and then all the other pitches he didn't make.
So he's just he's out of the game.
He's frustrated.
He's staring at the umpire.
Umpire's not even paying attention.
He says, you fucked that up.
He's staring at him.
I'm like, did you say something?
What? Watch the video later.
I think I got it right.
Now he's in the dugout and he's just got to watch as, you know, he's still got a
runner to his name on second.
And that ball's off the pitcher's foot, ricochets.
They can't get him.
And now the Blue Jays have taken the lead, went from inning ending double play, no
call. And now it's all bad and sour and not fun.
What do you guys think?
Did they get it right per the rule?
Part two. Do you agree with the rule?
Part three.
Should I dye my facial hair bleach blonde in support and join Baz?
Answer to three is no.
This breakdown was brought to you by Fanatic Sportsbook, where you can earn fan
cash on your bets, then spend it on profit boosts, merch from fanatics.com or even
bet with it. Winning hits different at Fanatic Sportsbook.