The Battle of Hastings stands as one of the most legendary and storied conflicts in English history. At its heart was King Harold Godwinson, fighting valiantly to defend his crown and his claim as the rightful heir to the English throne. Opposing him was William, Duke of Normandy, who asserted that the late King Edward the Confessor had promised him succession.
What followed was not just a battle for the throne—but a moment that would reshape the destiny of England. Among the most iconic and enduring images of the battle is that found in the Bayeux Tapestry: Harold struck down by an arrow to the eye. Yet, this dramatic scene raises a question—did it truly happen?
The accounts of the time offer differing versions of events, and the truth remains shrouded in uncertainty. What we do know is that Harold was no stranger to warfare. Just weeks before Hastings, he had crushed a Viking invasion and slain the legendary Harald Hardrada of Norway at the Battle of Stamford Bridge—an act that marked the end of the Viking Age in England.
So, how fierce was the struggle at Hastings? And how, in truth, did the final battle unfold? The sources from the period offer conflicting tales, leaving modern historians to piece together a moment of history that remains contested. I will present some of the sources in chronological order to see how the source material for the battle evolved and why modern history teaches us the famed death of Harold with the arrow to the eye. Norman propaganda implies that the arrow that killed Harold was an act of divine punishment. By portraying Harold's death as a consequence of God's will, the Normans aimed to legitimize William the Conqueror's invasion and claim to the English throne. This narrative was largely driven by the Norman perception that Harold had broken an oath to William, and therefore deserved divine retribution. How true however, is this propaganda?
00:00 Introduction 02:20 Anglo - Saxon Chronicle (1066) 03:10 The Song of the Battle of Hastings (1066-1067) 05:35 Bayeux Tapestry (1070s) 08:26 Gesta Willelmi ducis Normannorum et regis Anglorum (1071 - 1077) 11:01 Chronicon ex Chronicis (Early 1100s) 12:25 Gesta Regum Anglorum (1125) 14:10 Historia Anglorum (1129 - 1135) 15:00 Vie de seint Aedward le Rei (1230s-1240s) 17:06 Conclusion
The Battle of Hastings stands as one of the most legendary and storied conflicts in English
history. At its heart was King Harold Godwinson, fighting valiantly to defend his crown and his
claim as the rightful heir to the English throne. Opposing him was William, the Duke of Normandy,
who asserted that the late King Edward the Confessor had promised him the succession.
What followed was not just a battle for the throne, but a moment that would reshape the
destiny of England. Among the most iconic and enduring images of the battle is the one found
in the Bayer tapestry, Harold struck down by an arrow to the eye. Yet, this dramatic scene
raises a question, did it truly happen? The accounts of the time offer differing versions
of events, and the truth remains shrouded in uncertainty. So how fierce was the struggle
at Hastings, and how, in truth, did the final battle unfold? The sources from the period offer
conflicting tales, leaving modern historians to piece together a moment of history that remains
contested. I will present some of the sources in chronological order to see how the source
material for the battle evolved, and why modern history teaches us the famed death of Harold with
the arrow to the eye. Norman propaganda implies that the arrow that killed Harold was an act of
divine punishment. By portraying Harold's death as a consequence of God's will, the Normans aimed
to legitimise William the Conqueror's invasion and claim to the English throne. This narrative
was largely driven by the Norman perception that Harold had broken an oath to William,
and therefore deserved divine retribution. How true, however, is this propaganda? And
how true is the arrow to the eye narrative, which is now presented as historic fact?
First, let us look at the Anglo-Saxon chronicle. William the Earl landed at Hastings, and Harold
came from the north, and fought against him before all his army had come up. And there he
fell, and his two brothers Girth and Leofwine, and William subdued this land. Not much is said
about the battle, perhaps because it was written by the defeated side, who may have wanted to downplay
the loss. Its writing style is generally concise. After the conquest, writers may have faced
political pressure or censorship. Lost materials or edits over time could also explain the lack of
detail. However, this is described as the earliest source of the battle, written in 1066.
Next, we have the Song of the Battle of Hastings, which is generally accepted as the earliest
surviving written account of the Norman conquest by many historians, apart from the Anglo-Saxon
chronicle. The song goes like this. When the Duke spies the King above on the steep hill,
his hard-pressured men are torn to pieces. The Duke summons Eustace from the Franks,
then clearing the battlefield, like a second Hector, the noble heir of Pontiu.
Hugh accompanies these ever ready for duty. Fourth is Guilfard, called by his father's surname.
Although many others join, these are the best of them. Harold is forced to go all the way of
The first, cleaving his breast through the shield with his point, drenched the earth with a gushing
torrent of blood. The second, smote off his head below the protection of the helmet,
and the third, pierced the inwards of his belly with his lance. The fourth, hewed off his thigh
and bore away the severed limb. The flying rumour, Harold is dead, spreads through the battlefield.
The defeated English refuse battle. They demand pardon.
It is worth noting that the song of the Battle of Hastings makes no reference to the feigned
arrow in the eye. Instead, it describes King Harold's death as the result of a lance blow,
followed by his body being savagely hacked to pieces by Norman knights.
The work is attributed to Guy, a nobleman of Pontiu, a monastically educated bishop,
and a skilled administrator, closely connected to the French court. He would later serve Matilda of
Flanders, the Queen of William the Conqueror. Given his intimate ties to the Norman elite,
and his role within their political and religious circles, it is curious that he
omits the dramatic arrow, an image so vividly portrayed in the Bayeux Tapestry, and one that
supports the established Norman narrative. One of the most iconic and haunting images
in medieval art appears near the end of the Bayeux Tapestry, where a figure identified by the
inscription of Harold Rex is shown struck in the eye by an arrow, and subsequently cut down in
battle. This moment stitched in wool on linen in the 11th century has long been interpreted
as depicting the death of King Harold Godwinson at the Battle of Hastings. The image is stark,
the King once crowned in triumph after the death of Edward the Confessor,
now brought low by a Norman arrow, a fitting end from a Norman point of view to a man they
considered a usurper. The arrow in the eye carries layers of meaning. On one level, it is a brutal
physical death in battle, on another, it serves a symbolic function. Harold is struck down not
just in body, but in vision and in judgement. In medieval thought, the eye was the gateway to the
soul. To be blinded or struck in the eye could suggest divine punishment, a loss of insight or
retribution for betrayal, namely Harold's alleged oath breaking when he supposedly swore fealty to
Duke William and later claimed the English crown for himself. However, scholars continue to debate
whether the figure shown with the arrow is in fact Harold. Some argue that the tapestry seen
is ambiguous. Two figures lie dead beneath the final inscription, one pierced by an arrow,
and another being cut down by a sword. It's possible the sword struck figure is Harold,
or perhaps the arrow and the sword together represent a single moment of violence in dramatic
sequence. Regardless of the literal truth, the image has endured as a powerful piece of Norman
propaganda. By immortalising Harold's death in this manner, the tapestry reinforces William's
legitimacy and Harold's downfall, not just as a military defeat, but as the rightful end of a
vow. Created likely in the 1070s, under the patronage of Bishop Odo, William's half-brother,
with other sources telling it was William's wife Matilda, the tapestry reflects the Norman's
perspective of the conquest. But its artistry and ambiguity leave space for interpretation,
and that a single arrow, whether real or symbolic, continues to capture the imagination
nearly a thousand years later. The Deeds of William
Duke of the Normans and King of the English was written by William of Poitiers, a Norman
priest who chronicled the Norman conquest of England. His account on the Battle of Hastings
is estimated to have been written in the years 1071-1077. In summary, this is what the text says
about the Battle of Hastings. William of Poitiers portrays Duke William as a divinely sanctioned
leader, chosen by God to bring justice to England. The Duke is described as courageous, wise,
and disciplined in battle. His leadership is seen as the reason for Norman victory,
and the Gesta emphasises that God's will was behind William's success. The English,
under King Harold Godwinson, are presented in a negative light, proud, disorganised and
overconfident. Poitiers describes Harold as a perjurer, referring to his broken oath of
allegiance to William. This implication is that his defeat was a moral and divine judgment.
The writing gives a dramatic and detailed account of the Battle of Hastings including
the valour of the Norman knights, especially William himself, who is said to have fought
bravely in the thick of battle. A tactical feigned retreat by the Normans to lure the English down
from their strong hill position, which turns the tide of battle. The intensity of the fighting,
noting that the Normans struggled to break the English shield wall, but eventually succeeded
due to discipline and superior tactics. William of Poitiers describes Harold's death as particularly
violent, but does not mention the famous arrow in the eye image. Instead, he says that Harold
was killed and mutilated, implying a gruesome and final defeat. One translated passage,
paraphrased in modern English says, Harold, surrounded by his bravest men, fell fighting,
as befitted a prince, defending his kingdom and his life to the last breath. Again, this account
written just years after the battle, although favourable to the Norman point of view,
mentions nothing of the arrow that struck Harold in the eye.
The Chronicon Ex Chronicis is a Latin chronicle compiled in the early 12th century,
originally attributed to Florence of Worcester, but now widely understood to have been completed
and expanded by John of Worcester, a monk at Worcester Priory. The chronicler states that
Harold was killed in battle, along with his brothers Girth and Leofwine, and that the
Normans emerged victorious. However, no graphic or detailed description is given of Harold's
manner of death. There is no mention of an arrow in the eye, it simply states, King Harold along
with his brothers Girth and Leofwine were killed among the enemy at Hastings. The Normans won the
victory, with many of the English having been slain. The Chronicon is generally sympathetic
to the English, and reflects the perspective of a monastic community that had lived under
Anglo-Saxon rule and witnessed the dramatic political shift following the Norman conquest.
John of Worcester does not indulge in Norman propaganda, nor does he glorify Harold or
William excessively. The chronicle instead presents events in a chronological and somewhat
impartial tone, though it sympathises subtly favour to the Anglo-Saxon cause.
The Deeds of the Kings of the English is an early 12th century history of the Kings of England by
William of Mamsbury. His account reflects what seems to have been a growing Norman tradition
that Harold died by an arrow to the eye. In the chronicle, a translated version of the text
states, Meanwhile, arrows from the archers fell all around King Harold, and he, being struck in
the eye, fell down. Then a throng of mounted knights burst forth and slew the wounded king,
and with him Elgirth and El Leofwine, his brothers, also perished.
The arrow in the eye is particularly vivid, and it matches the Bayer tapestry's image.
William of Mamsbury's inclusion of that detail helps reinforce William of Normandy's legitimacy
and the dramatic nature of the conquest. The arrow in the eye might have been folklore that
solidified into history. William was a historian and storyteller, not just a compiler. He often
infused his writing with vivid narrative detail and moral reflection, including a graphic tragic
image of Harold's fall, which may have been part of this dramatic method which made the death more
memorable and symbolic. William of Mamsbury likely said Harold died with the arrow in the eye
because, the story had become established tradition by the early 12th century, it carried
moral symbolism, fitting medieval values of divine justice, and it added vivid drama to his historical
narrative. The Historia Anglorum, meaning the history of the English is a work depicting
England's earliest period, and bringing it to modern times, ending it upon the ascension of
King Henry II in the year 1154. In it, it also describes Harold's death at Hastings. It states,
Meanwhile a shower of arrows fell around King Harold, and he struck and the eye collapsed.
Then a multitude of horsemen burst in, and killed the wounded king, and with him Elgirth and
his brothers. By Henry's time, the first half of the 12th century, the arrow in the eye story
had begun to circulate more widely among Norman and Anglo-Norman writers. The Anglo-Norman verse
Life of St. Edward the Confessor, written in England probably in the later 1230s or the 1240s,
is a beautiful chronicle with many illustrations regarding the events that took place during the
life of Edward the Confessor, and the events after his death. Some theories suggest that
Matthew Paris was the author, but this cannot be verified. The work was sponsored by King Henry III.
At the end of the chronicle on page 74 is an illumination of the Battle of Hastings,
where Harold lies on the ground on the lower right, an arrow in his left eye. By the mid-13th
century, the arrow in the eye tradition was widely known in the Norman and Anglo-Norman histories.
The artists and scribes of the manuscript would have been influenced by that tradition.
They would treat it as an acceptable, if not factual way to show Harold's demise.
In addition, medieval manuscripts of saints' lives often used striking, even somewhat iconic
images to teach or impress. The arrow imagery is concise and evokes a strong emotional response.
By that time, readers and viewers may already know the story of Harold's death,
via other sources, tapestries or local tradition, so depicting him with an arrow in the eye meets
audience expectations, reinforcing the familiar narrative. The very patron of the work,
King Henry III, descended from William the Conqueror, would have seen the image of Harold
struck by an arrow in the eye as a sign of divine judgement, if affirmed that Harold's
death came by the will of God and that William, his own ancestor, had been divinely chosen to
rule England. In doing so, it subtly reinforced the legitimacy of Henry's own reign. By the mid-13th
century, the arrow in the eye has become a normative story, but was it simply propaganda
turned into folktales, then turned into symbolic tradition? The arrow in the eye story is not
supported by the earliest sources, even those written by Normans who had every reason to
amplify such a vivid and symbolic death. Instead, it emerges decades later, likely drawn from
interpretations of the Bayer tapestry and oral tradition. It was then reinforced by 12th century
writers like William of Mamsbury and Henry of Huntingdon, who were working on a Normanised
political context and had incentive to dramatise. By the 13th century, it became a visual and more
symbolic story, used by Henry III's court to justify the Norman lineage and its divine right
to rule. Therefore, the arrow in the eye story should be seen not as factual, but as a crafted
piece of Norman propaganda, a symbolic narrative that served to legitimise conquest, reinforce
the moral failings of the vanquished and dramatise divine justice. In my opinion,
Harold died at the end of the battle of Hastings, in the chaos of the battlefield,
likely hacked to death by Norman knights after his army had lost its formation of the Shield Wall.
At school, I was taught that Harold met his end by an arrow to the eye. It's striking how a story
rooted in uncertain evidence, likely shaped by Norman propaganda, has come to be accepted as
historic fact. I would like to give a huge thank you to all of my members.
Your contribution is valuable to the continuation of the channel, and I appreciate you all immensely.
A special thank you to John Seitz. I hope you all enjoyed the video, if you did,
be sure to like, subscribe and share, and I'll see you all next week for another history profile.