Embracing the Moon - Chinese Ceramic Art, Old and New

Chinese Antiques
7 followers
16 Video Views·Jun 12, 2026
The Art Institute’s Pritzker Chair of Arts of Asia and curator of Chinese art Tao Wang discusses two newly acquired Chinese moon flasks.
Though created centuries apart, the Ming Dynasty Yongle Moon Flask (early 15th century) and Fu Yiyao’s The Essence of Light and the Cadence of Rhythm (2010) share striking similarities. Wang provides a closer look at both in this lecture, delving into the history and cultural significance of the moon flask.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello everyone. Good afternoon. Welcome to the Art Institute's beautiful Fullerton Hall.
I'm very happy to be back in this room and welcoming you all in person today.
I'd like to thank JPMorgan Chase for supporting this event. My name is Jill Begeiske. I am the
Executive Director for the Research Center here at the Art Institute of Chicago and I am thrilled
that you're joining us this afternoon to learn about two newly acquired Chinese ceramic moon
flasks made centuries apart. As we begin, a brief reminder to please silence your mobile devices.
It's my pleasure to welcome you to today's program with Tao Wang. Tao is the Pritzker Chair of Arts
of Asia, Executive Director of Initiatives in Asia, and Curator of Chinese Art at the Art
Institute of Chicago. You might be familiar with Tao's curatorial handiwork if you visited the
monumental 2018 exhibition, Mirroring China's Past, Emperors and Their Bronzes. Tao has also taken an
innovative approach to bringing contemporary Chinese paintings into our historic galleries
with exhibitions such as Expressive Ink, Paintings by Yang Yongping and Sheng Chongqing in 2019,
and Xu Longshan, Light of Heaven, 2018. Prior to joining the Art Institute, Tao served as Senior
Vice President and Head of Chinese Works of Art at Sotheby's New York, and he trained students as
an instructor at the University of London. Tao is a consummate scholar who has published widely
on topics related to Chinese art and archaeology. He is a recipient of the China National Book Award
and he has also received a prize from Antiquity, a peer-reviewed journal of world archaeology,
for his outstanding scholarship. Tao holds a PhD in Early Chinese Culture from the University
of London, and he joined us here in Chicago in 2015. Now please join me in welcoming Tao Wang
to the stage. Thank you, Jill, for your kind introduction. Yeah, it's been a long time
since kind of coming back on site and talking, standing up here, so it's quite
exciting, but a bit also, I'm a bit anxious just to see how it goes, but you know it's a,
it's always a privilege and a pleasure to talk about the collection under our care.
In particular, I'm going to talk about a very significant acquisition that was made in 2021,
so that's fairly recent. Right, that's the piece, and now it's in our Asian Art Gallery,
gallery number 134. This is a ceramic vase and called Moon Flask. It has a
actually very poetic Chinese name, Bao Yueping. That's how the title of this lecture derived,
Embracing the Moon, Bao Yue, Embracing the Moon. So that is already kind of added a bit kind of
extra to its story. I mean we, as a Greek museum, I think one, probably the most important thing is
its collection and the stories associated with it, because as curators, we come and go,
but the collection stays, and they also make the story, people remember the story,
and the new story is also being added to it. So that's a, it's also a great experience working
as curator in this great museum. And this Moon Flask is made in the 15th century during the
period of Yongle, that is say the early Ming, early Ming dynasty, and as you can see it sits
beautifully in its case in our gallery. And it's also called Blue and White, that is of course you
can see it's painted with the cardboard style pigments that is come out as blue against this
very fine white glaze. The Art Institute has an excellent collection of Chinese art,
especially ceramics. Thanks to many distinguished Chicagoans, including the funding trustees,
such as Martin Ryerson and Charles Hutchison, Samuel Nicholson, and many other generous patrons
over the years, just to name a few, Kate Buckingham, Russell Tyson, Henry Schwab,
and most recently Dorothy Edinburgh. But it doesn't matter how great a collection is,
there's always something missing. When I came here in 2015, and we started a new accession,
assessment of the collection, and we have identified a few areas that need some strengthening.
And one of them is the ceramics from the 15th century China, because we have a wonderful
collection of Song ceramics, 11th, 12th century, and we also have a wonderful collection of later
imperial period, the Qing dynasty, that is from the 18th century up to 19th century. And those
two areas we are exceptionally strong. But for the Ming period, particularly early Ming period,
we are comparatively weaker. We need have some transformative pieces to elevate the collection.
And so maybe it's fate or it's luck, 2011, and we were approached by a collector who has this
amazing piece, and after some negotiation, we finally made the acquisition in the following year,
2021. And we were very excited for the opportunity to add this iconic piece to the museum's already
extensive, distinguished collection of Chinese ceramics.
So what's special about this piece? In fact, the direct origin of moon flask was not in China,
it's not indigenous, but it's come from the western side or from the Africa and Middle East.
This particularly double-handed oval-shaped shape is flat, and it's probably derived from a
prototype that can be traced back to ancient Egypt. Like on the screen on your right hand,
and this is probably some of you may already know this one, it's a very famous
lentoid bottle at the, I think it's at the Met in New York. And it's come out from the Egypt
later period, around the 7th and 6th century BC. And it's very interesting because the name
flask really came out from the function of this particular vase, because this vase with the
inscription, inscription on the front, and actually talking about the sacrifice during the new year.
So it was perhaps contained with the perfume oil or water for from the nail and to the sacrifice
altar. So that is how this name flask derived. And the second on your left, it's also interesting
because this particular shape continued to be very popular in the Middle East.
The metal flask, it's at the Freer Gallery in Washington DC. And it's also inlaid with
the pictorial depictions of the life of the Christ. It is from Syria, dated to the 13th century,
just a little bit earlier than the Ming dynasty. And so that's, as you can see, there's a very
almost direct relationship between this particular type to the Chinese moon flask.
However, we do have some Chinese examples dated earlier than that, earlier than the 15th century,
like two very interesting pieces in our collection. On your left is a bronze
bottle, and also known as the Chinese name, flat bottle. And as you can see the shape,
even it's got some kind of a foot, like this square foot, but the basic shape is very much
related to the Middle Eastern, or this prototype of moon flask, but just being added with the
base. And it's also in our collection. It came in in 1937, gifted by Kate Buckingham. So it's
very, got a great history, and very rare, I would say, because it's incised with the decorations
related to some nomadic people in the first century BC. So the influence could already kind of
came out, or came to Eastern Asia from the Middle East. And the other piece on your right hand,
it's made of clay, and it came into the museum even earlier, 1924, also a gift from late Kate
Buckingham. And this piece, it's clearly related to Central Asia, because even the motifs showing
some foreigners dancing and making grape wine. So it is related to mythology of winemaking in
in the Middle East. So that's just to see the cultural, or the traces of cultural change started
much earlier, before the moon flask we are talking about. By the 15th century, when Chinese
potter became interested in this particular shape, it retained only a basic relationship to the
original form. The sophisticated, very circular outline of this flask, and its bulging sides,
which makes very soft, kind of around the edge, and they are difficult things to make with the
pottery. It is a challenge, because we know by the time the most popular method for making
pottery vessels was a wheel, a potter's wheel. You can sew a potter's wheel, but for moon flask
of this particular shape, it has to be handmade, really hand built up. So it is a very much a job
for very skilful craftsmen, and also, as we can see on this blue and white moon flask,
involving some painters' activities. It's beautifully painted. This kind of
moon flask, of course, some of them, they have unpainted pieces too. I mean, there's two pieces.
One, the left one, is from the Palace Museum in Taipei. Another, the right hand one, is from
Palace Museum in Beijing. So clearly, those things were highly treasured and kept in the imperial
collection, because traditionally, the Yongle period has regarded as the golden age for Chinese
ceramic production. They are admired for their intrinsic visual beauty and technological quality.
The moon flask we have, it is a work of absolutely singular quality, given its size, decoration,
and rarity, and historical context. The fine workmanship and its harmony of form and
decoration reflect the fundamental strength of Chinese potter of this period. It has almost
irresistible charm, and it's really pleasing to hold in hand, because if you haven't been
to the gallery, I would encourage you to go to see it, because as you can see from this very
round shape, I mean, I'm sorry to say, we will not encourage you to hold it, because it's very light,
and the paste, if you look at the base, it's so fine, so smooth, like a people's, someone's skin,
like a baby's skin, it's very, very smooth. So it's, some people may say it's like a quiet
connoisseur's taste, because it's not huge or imposing, but you have to get it close, and to
feel about its charm and its attraction. This particular piece, both sides are painted.
They painted, of course, with flowers, as most Chinese porcelains do. They have some significance.
The painting here, as we can see, there are carnations, and also ester.
These two plants, I mean, why these two plants? Because if we look at all the painted Chinese
blue and white, it's very, very rare. I mean, you find many camellia, and leech, and you have
even blossom, and all different kinds of flowers, but these two, carnation and ester, they are
extremely rare. So there's already a puzzle. Why? And of course, we know all these flowers
depicted on Chinese porcelains, particularly during the Yongle period, they often bear
some significance or symbolism. As we, now, if you check dictionary and look at all the,
this medical, Chinese medicine texts, and you find some stories related to these plants.
They somehow related to, they can be used, of course, as remedies, but when they come into,
as a decorative motif, they often associated with sometimes marriage, sometimes
love. For example, the carnation, of course, they often been used during the wedding. So that's,
of course, tell a story about it. Ester, it's very rare, I already said, because it's used
also as a dyer, as a dyer for dyeing cloth. But it's also has a very interesting name in Chinese,
known as wangluo, don't forget me. So it's, there's almost like a phrase used often between
lovers, kind of a say, don't forget me. Or sometimes in Japan, they say, I wouldn't forget
you. That's a kind of a reversed. We now kind of think about kind of this to, of course, move
out from the symbolism of this decoration. We also want to look at closely of what stories can we
get from the object itself. And the one clue is the mark found on the base. It's very interesting,
they have this weird mark. And that is, it doesn't happen. I mean, if you are a collector of Chinese
ceramics, you often look at the base, oh, this is mark of, of the ring, like a Qianlong Emperor,
Yongzhang Emperor. So you know, when it was made, but this one, it's not like that. And it's very,
very strange. It's drilled mark. And we now maybe we say, oh, it must be owner's mark.
But who's the owner? Interestingly, we find the similar kind of the mark on porcelains,
particularly Chinese porcelains found in Middle East, in Syria, in India,
in Turkey. Very, very interesting. So we, with this question, we did a bit of research.
And then we had help from Regina Kroll, one of the leading experts of Chinese ceramics.
She studied the Chinese ceramics comprehensively, but she also studied similar pieces like almond
flask. So she offered the following comments. These drilled marks were most likely put on
Iran. Many pieces with such marks came to Turkey, probably through conquest, but they were also
dispersed elsewhere in the Middle East. Of course, she said, there's no firm evidence
where the piece may have been. Turkey is possibility. So she made this observation.
And we also learn more kind of interesting stories about its provenance. This object was first
bought into Sotheby's London in a damaged condition like this. It was in the 1990s.
And so Sotheby's kept it for a number of years and eventually offered it at its auction in
2005. So it was acquired by the collector. But interesting stories from the vendor.
The vendor who brought this piece to Sotheby's, who told Sotheby's that he obtained this
moon flask as part of a furniture decoration from a hotel he bought in the 1950s
in London. So that's very interesting because I don't know whether we were trying to
locate this gentleman. I believe he may be still alive, but very, very old. So
through Sotheby's, we tried to contact him, but he already kind of not in, basically come back,
couldn't have direct communication with him. So all the information we have came from the
information he offered to the Sotheby's experts in the 1990s and 2000. So that's a very interesting
how this piece may be made in China and then exported to Middle East and then came back to
Europe. So that's just a lot of stories. I mean, we as a curator, as a museum, we always study
the provenance of objects. So we keep searching for new information. So maybe one day we can find
more stories to piece together the fuller picture. So when the piece was found,
sorry about the black and white photograph because it's what they found in Sotheby's archive.
But when we got it, we actually did a very thorough study of the object. And as you can
notice from this x-ray and the top of the vase is missing. And like, sorry, can you see here?
Yeah, so it's reinstalled or I would say replaced. And also there is an extensive crack
across the body, one side of the body. Another side of the body, the front is perfect, but on
the back, but there's a long crack. But most interestingly, the crack, you can see the holes
along the crack, that is stitching holes. Very, very interesting, because that is a method
we often find on old Chinese or even just find on porcelain or ceramic pieces like this.
They have a metal pin, stapled, almost like stapled into this relevance. But of course,
it's not stapled, it's just a few very skillful craftsmen, they drill little holes, so they stitch
the crack together just to prevent the further damage. It's not already broken, it's cracked,
but they want to solidate the piece. And this piece, you may say, where does it come from?
Actually, it's in the National Museum of Japan in Tokyo. You may think, oh, what's special about
this cracked Chinese bowl dated to 11th century? But actually, it's probably the most famous
Chinese ceramic piece in Japan. You find it's classified as national treasure, because it's
exported to Japan when it was made, in the 11th century, 12th century. And then when it's
cracked, the craftsmen or restorer stitched together. So actually, it's the history,
and also it's part of the story of the object. And of course, the piece we have, you can see
in the gallery now, it's been very sensitively restored, and to bring back its original aesthetic
appeal. So you don't see it, but as a curator or as a conservator, I think we like to keep that
story. And so if you look at the back very closely, we still have a little bit of trace,
not too obvious, but we can still see that very fainted mark on the body.
So this moon flux, extremely rare, I said. It's actually, there are two pieces in the world.
One is here, you can see. Another one is in Turkey, at the Topkapi Palace, Topkapi Sari
Palace Museum in Istanbul. And they have probably one of the best collections of Chinese ceramics
from the 13th century up to 15th or 16th century. Really incredible collection.
But this piece, that moon flask, is probably the most important piece in that collection.
As you can see on this cover of this catalogue, this is an exhibition organized by the Museum
for Japanese Exhibition, and this is a cover of that piece. And you can also notice that the top
is also have a metal cover. So the top is already also a bit missing, and then so they put that
metal lid on top. But it's very strange that we know, it's a shame I've never been to the place.
But I was told this piece is not on view because we're trying to find any image or any information,
contact the museum, we hear nothing from them. Very, very bizarre. And I started to
think what happened to that piece. Because we know there was an earthquake a few years ago.
I said, oh gosh, I hope it's not damaged. But still, and one day I think I will probably make
trip to Istanbul and to find out what happened to that piece. I mean the museum itself, Topkapi,
sorry, it's incredible site. I think anyone goes to Istanbul would visit that site because it's old
imperial palace. And it's full of beautiful tiles and also Chinese ceramics. They do have a
made a display of Chinese porcelain. And that's like you see those, they are also 15th century.
Like this one is the white kind of here, and it's also made during the Yongle period. Very,
very beautiful. But you can find quite a number of these things around. For the moon flask,
if you compare them, the size, the decoration, they just, you just see like maybe a little bit
kind of a hand like variation. But you can clearly see they were made as a pair. So they are two
existing samples in the world. And so that's amazing how they kind of survived. And maybe
one day we can try to put them, reunite them, put them together for exhibition or something
like that. And it's also, to be said, the Chinese like Yongle porcelains were probably the most
sought after in the Middle East. But there's another reason because many of them actually
copies after the metal works, Islamic metal works. They're taking almost sometimes almost exact kind
of a copy. But of course, because you never find this shape like on the right hand, it's again
blue and white porcelain in Palace Museum Taipei. And its prototype, it's based
in the British Museum. It's also 13th century, maybe just 150 years earlier. And so clearly,
the Chinese porter copied this particular shape. And that's one, two, the metal
is also in the British Museum. And it's actually dated. It's very interesting, it's dated, it's 12.
Do I have the date? Actually, I probably do have the date, if I can find it.
Sorry, maybe I missed it. Yes, I do find the date. It's actually dated
1232. So it's again, it's early 13th century. And the Chinese copy is 15th century.
So it's just less than 200 years gap. And because this and you find this very much
a cultural exchange between East Asia and Middle East during the 15th century. And it was much more
the activities. I mean, I think right now, many historians or archaeologists have been trying to
reconstruct that kind of trade route. But we know from just from porcelain, we know that
during the 15th century, when the Chinese court, the Ming Empress, they controlled the
Jin Dezhen, built its imperial Qiong. So they were very much making a lot of international pieces.
And they, maybe it's just to say that the another story related to Yongle Empress,
we know the Emperor Zheng He, who sailed along the Pacific, went to all the islands. And then
one of thing he did was also carrying a lot of this porcelain silk as gifts for those
kingdoms. So that's how kind of you find this Yongle as probably thought as like the China
kind of at that time, they were the most sophisticated, the most beautiful
things you can obtain. So that's how I think all moon flats fit in with that big background
or historical context. And let me just to also to say that it was the piece in the Topkapi
Museum, actually, give us a further thought on the this kind of ownership of some, what we call
on the cultural objects, because sometimes we say it's Chinese and it's, it's Persian. But then,
when we look at many of things in our collection, we find the question maybe should be asked
differently. And we need to find out what's the made for and also the function in different
cultural contexts. Okay, just to make it a bit short. Oh, and added a bit of archaeological
background to that. Just very recently, I think maybe two years ago, in Jindezhen,
they constructed a new museum called Imperial QM Museum. Again, sorry, it's because of pandemic,
I haven't been able to visit the site. So I just got some images from people sent to me.
As you can see, it's the new Imperial Museum, Imperial QM Museum. And again, they've been
excavating the QMs. What happened is when the Imperial QM was under the
patronage of the court, they made things only for Imperial Court. And the Imperial Court
will send them out, they were not allowed to sell them at the market. And if there are pieces,
by any imperfection, or be broken and buried. So that's why actually at the Imperial QM Museum,
the archaeologists there have been digging up the site and they find, again, some moon flasks
also made there, but obviously they were not perfect. So they were smashed and buried and
maybe pieced together. And so the story is that this moon flask also become an iconic piece,
like I said. The tent is really, can be reflected on some of the
imperial collections built in the 18th century. And if you remember, Jill mentioned the
exhibition, Mirroring China's Past, we actually borrowed one very important painting from the
Palace Museum in Beijing, from an old imperial collection. And as you can see, it's a portrait
of Emperor Qianlong. And he's sitting among his most favorite antiquities. He was probably the
biggest collector in Chinese history. And as you can see, there's a Jungler blue and white
moon flask on the table. That table is French. It's actually a French table. Very, very
interesting painting. And these two pieces are found in the Palace Museum in Taipei.
One is actually very interesting. This one is a painting of a camellia. Yeah, I said it's a
plant you find in China with a strong symbolism. But this one is really interesting. Scholars
been researching on this particular piece. And so far they found it's actually a person's story
of searching for water source. So it's actually related to some Persian story. It's not a Chinese
story. But this one remained. There's another one, I think, in Top Copy Museum, I believe.
And but this, there are maybe like two or three of the same motif. And this one is in the Palace
Museum in Taipei. Qianlong, and he was such passionate about Jungler moon flasks, so he
tried to make copies. It's also in our gallery 134. And as you can see, there's a very large
moon flask on display. That is made for the Qianlong Emperor because on the base, there's
so it's made during the reign of Qianlong. It's very big, and it's very well made. I think
technologically, it's really superior, because to make large, flat flasks like that,
it's extremely difficult. And the painting is very meticulous.
I mean, it's imposing, but somehow, if you put together with the Jungler one,
you feel just a bit of the subtlety and elegance. So Qianlong's father also copied a moon flask,
but I'm not going to show here. I mean, there are quite a number of them in the museum collections.
But compared to our Jungler one, it is not the same league. So now, the second puzzle,
what are they? These two, actually, moon flasks are in our collection, but it's not in the Asian
Art Department. It's actually in the Applied Art of Europe. So they were known as the Mittens.
Mittens is a ceramic factory in England in Staffordshire. And they started, one of the
earliest ones, already in the 18th century, kind of Victorian time. And then in the 19th century,
particularly around the 1870s, it started to work with a very famous Scottish designer,
Christopher Dresser. So those moon flasks were made or probably designed by Dresser.
Because Dresser was famous for his style called Anglo-Orientals, because he was copying Persian,
Japanese, and the Chinese design for his ceramic designs. And these two pieces also, very
interestingly, came into a museum, to the Art Institute, about the same time, 2020. And that
time was the decorative, European decorative art, received these gifts from a couple, Helena
Fortunoff and Robert Grossman. So they, I mean, there are more, but these two, I thought,
if you don't know they were Mittens, you would think they are Chinese, would you? Yeah. But again,
you can see after a couple of years, 100 years, and the story kind of back to Europe, the same
story. So this, that's how kind of art really changes the world, kind of really make things
happening around the world. And now I want to use the rest of time to talk about a new acquisition.
This is a moon flask, actually made in 2010, by, actually it's a work collaboratively between the
painter, artist, a woman artist, Fu Yiyao, and a porter, Huang Yunpeng. And this piece, as you can
see, it's painted with blue and also with copper. But it's interesting with the landscape,
and on the back, like two boys playing. So it's very, very modern, and it's almost like
landscape painting together with the fictive paintings. But they somehow, on this very
charming vase. And Fu Yiyao is the fifth child of probably the most famous Chinese artist of the 20th
century, Fu Baoshi. And Fu Baoshi, he started in Japan, and then he came back to China, and he
wrote books on Chinese, theory of Chinese paintings, and he also taught in different places.
And, but he's very famous for creating a new style, combining Chinese traditional ink painting
with the 20th century, some of Japanese influence too. So he really, I mean, he's probably the most
sought-after artist on the market today, and we don't have anything by him, very sadly. But Fu Yiyao,
she was born in Nanjing, and then he graduated actually from Nanjing Normal University in the
70s. She studied literature, but in the 70s, when China was just open after cultural revolution,
and she wanted to study art, at the same school, her father studied painting. So somehow, he was
managed to be, I mean, I can tell you all the stories she told me, but it was so rare in the
study abroad. So I think one of the vice-premiers helped her, because the vice-premier was a friend
of her father, so helped her to go to Japan. And so she started there in Japan since 1970s, and
she established the artist, very famous in Japan now. She painted all the temple manuals, and
doing all sorts of exhibitions. So she's basically still Chinese origin, but she's very much
integrated into Japanese society today. But she still goes back to China to particularly work
at Jindouzhen with the local porters. That's a picture of Fu Yiyao and her father.
And her collaborator is a master craftsman, Huang Yipeng, and he's also very famous in Jindouzhen,
like local hero. And he makes the most beautiful copies of imperial ceramics. So like, if anything
sold for over a million dollar on the market, and the next month, and you produce one, of course,
he's not going to sell a fake. So he put his name, say, okay, look, my craftsmanship can compete with
the best postings ever made. So he's very famous in China, and taught a lot of students. So in
2010, the two collaborated, and for quite a long period, they made a number of pieces, but this is
probably the most beautiful one, Moon Flask. And we're lucky to get it as a gift from a friend of
the artist, Dr. Ye Guoxin in Taipei. So that's just, again, a very generous offer to the museum.
And now, I'd probably just like to really conclude. I mean, this is Jindouzhen you
visit today. And they're still making some high-quality porcelains, and some are just
households, utensils. So it's probably most active, one of the most active centers for ceramic
productions in China today. And many artists established studios, workshops there. And just
very recently, I've been kind of looking at one Chinese ceramic artist who actually was
born in Jindouzhen, and now he's in Beijing at Tsinghua University. One of the leading
ceramic artists in China today, Mr. Bai Ming. I know he has done a lot of exhibitions in
China and in Europe, but maybe one day we can also introduce his works into our collection.
And I think I've run out of my time, and thank you very much for coming. And I still have some time
to take questions. Thank you. So I can't see you because the light on my eye, but if someone,
if you put your hands up, I think someone is going to hand you a microphone.
Yeah, it's nothing. It's just a really just protective reason. When China made it,
particularly for interior collection, but when they were exported to Middle East,
I think they were actually used as a flask for oil or water. And because that's why you often
There's a question in the front, if you could just repeat it after.
That's maybe just to explain. I'm sure we have a
photo. When we say porcelain, it's actually made from Jindouzhen. They use a special
clay from Jindouzhen. So you have this very high-five, very strong body. But the clay,
clay is just a material. And it's low-file.
No more questions? Okay, yeah, one more question from there.
No, sorry. I explained in lecture, it was discovered in 1990s and sold at Sotheby's in
London, 25, and it was bought by a collector. We acquired it from the collector in 2021.
So that's, yeah, we didn't buy it at auction yet.
Okay, if no more questions, and yeah, I'd like to thank everyone again for coming. Thank you very
much.
