🎙️The Audra Lambert Podcast Home Insurance Crisis 2026 Why Rates Doubled How to Avoid Claim Mistakes and Get Covered
Home insurance market has been in crisis — premiums have doubled, major carriers are pulling out, and buyers are falling out of escrow because they can't get covered. In this episode, Audra Lambert sits down with insurance broker Kaelynn Gozony to break down exactly why this happened and what you can do about it. From the CA FAIR Plan and electrical panel issues to when you should (and shouldn't) file a claim, this is the conversation every homeowner and buyer needs to hear.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video features a discussion between a real estate professional and insurance broker Kaylin Gazzone regarding the home insurance crisis, particularly in California. They explore the causes of skyrocketing premiums, the rigor of modern underwriting, the limitations of state-run programs, and practical strategies for homeowners, buyers, and sellers to navigate a tightening market.
All right, I'm gonna get right to the point.
We're gonna talk about home insurance.
Now, a lot of us hate talking about home insurance.
A lot of us have a lot of pain.
A lot of our home insurance premiums
have doubled and tripled,
and some of us can't even get home insurance.
So today, I have invited a special guest
who I refer all my clients to.
She is an insurance broker who gets all my deals done.
So I'd like to introduce Kaylin.
Kaylin, please tell us a little bit about yourself.
Awesome, yes, thank you so much, Audra.
Happy to be here today,
and I know it's not a fun topic for everyone,
but we're gonna get right into it.
So my name is Kaylin Gazzone.
I'm with Comparion Insurance,
and I've been doing it for about 11 years.
I got my first license when I was 19 years old,
so that was my college job, was an insurance agent.
And when I was getting ready to graduate
is when I met one of my mentors and still current boss
who hired me to the same company I'm with now,
so I've been here for six years.
Wow, and what company is that?
It's called Comparion.
At the time, we were Liberty Mutual,
so yeah, people might have heard of it.
It's a fairly large company,
and the reason why we have a new name now
is a few years ago when the insurance market blew up,
it's kinda neat.
You know, they were smart.
They flipped the entire insurance company across the nation.
Now we're called Comparion
and because we can compare options for our clients.
So that was definitely helpful to us
and absolutely to our clients during that time.
Now, are you a broker?
What exactly is your role?
Yes, I'm a broker, so I do property insurance,
auto, life insurance products,
and we partner with about 15 different companies, so yeah.
So the question I have for you
is why in the world are premiums so high?
Like they doubled, they tripled.
I've heard it's because the home values have gone up,
and then I've heard, well, homes are aging
and it's just more risk,
like a re-pipe or there could be a lot of damage done,
or now that we have, at least here in California,
we have really high insurance hazards in the area,
and so why are the insurance premiums going up
and why are so many insurance companies
pulling out of various areas?
Yes, golden question.
Yeah, I love this.
So yeah, the factors that you mentioned,
these are huge, huge factors
and happy to dig into the specifics on those,
but just overall, like how did we get here?
So like pre-COVID, right,
we used to shop insurance policies, no problem.
Easy peasy.
Well, during the pandemic, the Department of Insurance,
and this is state by state,
but in California, they did not allow insurance companies
to adjust rates for three years,
and during that time, we still had inflation,
still had natural disasters.
If anyone remembers, used cars were through the roof,
and cars were sitting on barges in the ocean,
so it was just a crazy time during those three years.
So once that three years expired,
the Department of Insurance said,
okay, companies, you can now evaluate your rates
and do rate increases.
Well, that's when the insurance company said,
we're not profitable anymore.
Yeah, and companies like State Farm.
Farmers.
Farmers, yeah.
All state, I think, increased rates by 40% in order to,
because it's profitability at the end of the day.
So that was one of our biggest hits initially,
because not only did rates skyrocket,
but insurance companies either wanted to pull out
or to put on, bring on new policies.
We had to go through crazy underwriting.
It was taking people weeks,
sometimes a month to get a new policy.
So it's been absolute madness.
Over the past few years, gosh, we're still going through
total waves, for sure.
I think it's getting a little bit easier.
I think we're just acclimating.
I mean, you correct me if I'm wrong.
But one of the questions I have though,
is when we're doing home insurance,
there's now all these different things we have to do.
We got to take pictures of the backyard.
We got to get certain things installed
before it gets insured.
Why are we taking pictures?
Why can't you just use Google Earth or whatever
to figure out the location?
That's a good question.
You know, sometimes I still question that myself.
We can take a picture of some other person's backyard
for all, right?
Right, and with like MLS photos are pretty current,
but they want it taken with the cell phone,
make sure that people aren't being shifty about anything.
And we have to put a timestamp.
They want it with the cell phone, very specific.
So it's just a way for them to mitigate risk on their end.
And then yeah, things like plumbing is a big question.
Electrical panels.
Okay, that's coming up a lot.
A lot.
So what happens?
What happens if they have an outdated electrical panel?
What's the insurance company going to require?
Yes, so, and we have a couple companies
that don't necessarily like look at that
as strict, but the ones that are.
So I try to educate, you know, on the front end.
So if someone's purchasing a home, you know,
let's take a picture of the electrical panel,
see if it's ineligible, because if that panel is still there
when you purchase your new policy,
about four weeks after closing,
the insurance company does their inspection.
And that's when they catch the panels.
And then the client will get a letter saying,
you have an ineligible panel.
We're going to cancel you in 60 days
if you don't show us proof that you replaced it.
So that kind of sucks, you know, for new buyers.
But I got to ask, because let's go back there a little bit.
The insurance companies come out
and they do their own inspection.
So is that a new thing?
Because I'm seeing a lot more of that
where my homeowner is like,
why is the insurance company coming out?
Explain what that is.
Yeah, so companies always did that before.
It's just they weren't sending,
they weren't as picky as they are now.
So they would come just exterior,
take their photos and everything's, you know, hunky dory.
Now they're looking at panels.
They're looking at moss on roof is a huge thing, plumbing.
Moss on roof, meaning that it doesn't,
there could be leaks or what's the reasoning behind that?
So just risk of deterioration on the roofs.
So like in coastal areas, it's super common.
Even if the roofs can be 10 years old,
not even an old roof, there can be moss and algae growth
and they want those professionally cleaned.
And you send in receipts.
No way.
It is wild.
I haven't got that one yet.
Oh, that's good.
Because it's a pain.
Yeah, I'm sure.
But yeah, and then plumbing, older plumbing, older wiring.
So nowadays when you're shopping around for a new policy,
you can ask the sellers or I try to pull permits,
see when those systems are updated
because that's gonna help with eligibility for a policy.
There's discounts with that.
And that way we have a leg up
when the insurance company comes
and you're not surprised with the letter.
So I do have a question.
This one comes up all the time, okay?
So should you file an insurance claim?
Like when should you?
And who does it follow?
Does it follow the homeowner?
Does it follow the home buyer?
Like I always get different answers
depending on what insurance company I'm working with.
Yeah, and that's pretty much true
is every insurance company does handle it a bit different.
Generally speaking,
the insurance claim does follow the buyer.
So if a buyer is purchasing a new home
but they had a claim on their old property,
that will follow them
and will surcharge their rates on the new policy.
So that's generally speaking,
it's carrier specific for sure.
If the prior owner had a claim,
that's also coming up on the new buyer quotes.
So that's when buyers are like,
the insurance company said I needed to get photos
and receipts that the damage was fixed
and this wasn't even my claim,
it's from the seller
and we have to get all this information.
So it's coming up on the quotes
but it's not impacting the rates for the buyers.
Okay, so if a homeowner did like a complete kitchen remodel
because there was a major slab underneath,
that's not gonna affect the policy
or it probably will, meaning for the buyer?
Depends, right?
If anything, it would be more of like
going through some kind of an approval process.
Okay.
Yeah.
And how far back on the claims?
Five years in California.
Okay.
Is that standard usually across the rest of the nation or?
I would say so, three to five years depending
and like in California, any claim under $1,000
isn't surchargeable but it's still on your record.
So the claims, they'll come up for five years
when you're shopping and yeah,
we can talk about how, like when to file claims.
I know that was a good question.
Yeah, when to file claims and the other thing is like,
if they're little tiny things,
you probably shouldn't, right?
So what would be a good rule of thumb
as far as when you should or when you shouldn't,
you know, go out, whatever,
call the insurance to file a claim.
Yeah, good, very good point.
And even nowadays, calling the insurance company
and asking questions.
Explain that, yeah, yeah, ask, tell them about that.
Yeah.
That's a big deal.
Oh my gosh, we see it all the time
and it's caused such havoc.
Even just calling the company for claims,
asking for questions, when you call in,
I will be very specific.
I do, I'm not filing a claim, it's just questions
because they'll put a claim number
and then it stays on your record
and sometimes it just shows open
because you didn't go through the insurance company.
So now we have to call the old company, get it closed
and it's just, it's been a nightmare.
It's just calling it in.
So couple rule of thumbs that I give my clients
when filing a claim, number one, what is your deductible?
Is it 1,000, 5,000?
Because say you have water damage
and it costs $6,000 to fix
and you have $5,000 deductible,
you're going after the insurance company for 1,000,
your rates are gonna go up for five years.
It makes absolute no cost sense to do that.
Yeah.
When you say the rates are gonna go up five years,
is after five years they stop or is incremental?
Is there a certain percentage
that they increase year after year or is there a max?
There's no set percentages,
but the claim will surcharge your policy for five years.
So during that time,
like you're not getting claims free discount
and you're paying more on your policy.
I mean, we've seen increases anywhere from 10, 20, 30%
because of a claim.
It's insane.
Yeah, that's crazy.
It doesn't even offset what you got covered.
Not at all.
It doesn't make sense.
It's kind of like car insurance.
Seriously.
Yeah, yeah.
Or you get a ticket or accident
and it's like, oh my gosh, this is double my car payment.
You know, it's nothing crazy.
So let's talk about, so I reside in California,
but a lot of the other states
have their own wraparound policy.
Let's talk about in California,
the California fare plan, okay?
So when I'm selling a home,
a lot of homebuyers are asking me,
hey, is this Cal fare?
And I'm like, what?
And what they mean is, do we have to get another rider
to get the home insurance for the property?
So explain what that is.
And I'm sure that, you know,
other states do something similar,
like hurricane season, hurricanes, Florida,
hail, hail's a big one in some areas, right?
Absolutely.
Floods, Texas floods, right?
Totally.
Yeah, so these state run programs,
they're in high risk areas for natural disasters.
And it's not funded by the government.
It's funded by the insurance companies
and us paying premiums.
So like fare plan premiums.
And then if you are an insurance company
and want to do business in California,
you have to fund the program, Cal fare.
And what's crazy is right now,
this is something newer that just happened
earlier this year,
because of the fires that happened in LA,
the fare plan pretty much blew through their reserves.
And now on the policies,
you see an extra charge on us,
even if you're not with fare plan.
So if you have a homeowner's policy,
you're getting an extra little fee
to build up the fare plan again.
So yeah, we absolutely try.
This program is a last resort.
So if you're shopping for insurance
and you get a fare plan quote, shop around,
make sure that this is absolutely your last resort option.
It's such basic coverage.
It covers fire,
theft and wind and hail.
But you have to customize it.
So I always add all those coverages
when I'm quoting a client.
And then you also have to purchase the wraparound
or difference in conditions policy,
because that's going to pick up your liability,
water claims, things like that.
So together you have a full standard policy,
if you will, coverage wise.
And then you got to do the fire wraparound
with Cal Fire.
Exactly.
Oh my gosh.
Okay, you mentioned that it's a last resort.
Why is it a last resort?
The coverage is cost.
And coverage, right?
And coverage for sure.
And on the fare plan applications,
it says this is a last resort plan.
So what we do is over the past couple years,
me and other brokers and farmers
and all these other agencies,
we're partnering together because carriers were so tight.
We're like, we only have fare plan.
What do you have?
So we're trying to help clients out
because we don't want to put clients in there.
We want to do our due diligence to make sure,
I mean, they blew their reserves
just with one catastrophe earlier last year.
So that's just scary in general,
funding wise to put clients in there.
But the coverage is extremely basic for-
What's the maximum?
Because I had this big buck property
and they backed out because they go,
we can only use Cal Fire program
and it wasn't the full insurance coverage.
What is the max coverage on that?
Yes, it's 3 million aggregate.
So on these high value homes,
it's absolutely terrible coverage wise.
3 million aggregate.
What does that mean?
Like when you say aggregate,
just want to make sure everybody knows.
Yeah, absolutely.
So-
Includes what?
Say you have on the dwelling structural coverage,
2.5 million and then you have your,
you need personal property coverage.
So maybe we put, you know, $150,000 there,
150,000 on loss of use.
And then there's a couple other coverages
that takes up some of the money.
So this multimillion dollar home,
they're only getting such minimal loss of use,
such minimal personal property, 150,000.
If your home burnt down
and you have to live in a hotel for a year-
Doesn't even cover it.
Not at all.
It's so, and then personal property, 150,000.
I mean, I've seen homes that burnt down
and they had $500,000 paid out in personal property.
So on these high value homes,
the Fairfax is not able to adequately cover it
at the end of the day.
So I have a question.
I don't know, it just just popped in my head.
With the LA fires,
a lot of people are coming down here, South Orange County,
and they said, hey, this is really highly recommended
that if you have a home,
you need to go around and document
everything in your home.
Because apparently when you have a,
you have to claim everything.
Like we had Kleenex boxes, we had side tables,
like you have to give a long laundry list.
Is that true?
Yeah.
So explain what that form looks like,
because a lot of you don't know that.
And I've, in past videos,
I'm like, go around and videotape your home
and stick it in the cloud.
Because if your house ever does, you know,
burn down or there's a mudslide or whatever,
at least you know,
or you can prove that those items were in your home.
Exactly.
And if something, you know,
that tragic happened to you,
that you lose your home,
the last thing you want to do is think about
every single room in your home
and try to get, you know, your things covered.
But talking with claims adjusters,
that's what we've heard, is take a video.
Okay.
And I've told-
But I mean, you're opening drawers.
Like I love clothes.
Like I got quite the clothes collection and coat.
I love clothes.
So, but I mean, it's like,
take pictures of the labels and the shoes.
If you have nice shoes,
or if you have nice furniture, videotape it.
But also open drawers,
because you've got to prove what's in those.
Because if your house burned down
or the mudslide takes your house out,
how can you verify what you had in the home?
Is that fair to say?
Absolutely.
Okay. And you guys, I still haven't done it.
So that's, I'm glad we're talking.
This is a reminder to both of us.
Yeah, yeah.
Got to do it.
See, and that's what we think.
It's never going to happen,
but when it does,
you're going to be really grateful you did that.
Oh my gosh.
Absolutely.
Yeah.
And I've heard from clients,
like trying to recover their personal property
was like one of the hardest things to do.
So yeah, really good tip.
And big ticket items that you purchase.
Save those receipts, you know, in a little folder.
That's always really good to have.
Yeah, but if it burns down.
Or on the cloud.
On the cloud.
Yeah, I told you.
A folder in the cloud.
Right?
Yeah, exactly.
So, yeah.
So I'm going to kind of pivot here.
We had a situation that came up this week
and I'm like,
Caitlin, help me.
I don't know what I'm going to do.
So a lot of us are closing on a property
and then there's like a two month rent back.
Okay.
Remember this?
And the big issue is,
how do you insure that?
Because the insurance is being insured
as a primary residence,
but you actually have a tenant landlord agreement,
but you're still the owner.
So how does that work?
Do you have to do a wraparound policy?
Like, I know we were going back and forth.
Explain how that works.
I want you all to be really cautious
because we all usually require the renters
to get a renter's insurance policy,
but it's not their primary residence.
So people don't know this.
So talk about the concerns
and the pitfalls of doing that.
Absolutely.
And rent backs continue to be a pain.
They are a pain.
I hate them.
That's why I don't like doing them.
I hate doing it.
Absolutely.
And because we want to, you know,
protect the new buyers of this home
and there's a lot of liability risk with that.
So there's no perfect solution.
Okay, so wait real quick.
I'm going to back up.
So let's say the home buyer just bought the home
and we got two months of rent
and then the old owners slash tenants now
burn down the house because they left the oven on
and the whole house burns down.
Because they're not the owners.
Right.
It's a tenant-landlord relationship.
What happens in that situation?
Yes, and it is carrier by carrier specific as well,
especially in different states,
there might be a little more leeway.
Here, insurance companies are finding
every which way to deny claims.
Right.
So it's even more difficult because in theory,
what we would want to do is start with the landlord policy.
And then once the tenants leave the old seller,
then we do the homeowner's policy.
Well, that then becomes an issue with the loan.
That's right.
Because they need a homeowner's policy.
That's right.
So, I mean, it can be very situational
because the banks and underwriting is different.
So if the lender allows for the landlord policy
to be in place for that period of time
and we can show an approved homeowners quote, ready to go,
we can even activate it the day,
we can finalize the policy for July 1st is when the,
so they have an active policy in place
that they allow us to do that.
That is how we would love for it to go down.
Okay.
So it is situational in that case,
but yeah, it's a tricky one.
It is.
I just want everybody watching this video to realize
that rent back is really tricky
when it comes to home insurance.
And because the insurance carriers
are getting really picky, the underwriters,
like it's just know the risk going in there
and make sure that you're clear on what's being covered.
And if something were to happen,
you need to know exactly what the,
I don't say the remedy for it is, right?
Because it's scary.
It's a lot of risk when you do that.
If you're going into a rent back situation,
talk to your agent.
Yeah.
Talk to your agent, see what's going on with the carrier,
you know, what you got to do, but yeah.
Get, start planning because then we might need
to start talking to the lenders and it's a whole,
we're all going to be working together to figure that out.
Now, so a lot of people are watching right now saying,
we want to, we want to, you know, talk to Kaylin.
Like, so what's, what areas of the nation do you cover?
What areas is your company cover?
Yes.
So I'm primarily in California.
I am licensed in Texas,
but I have a Texas agent with my company
that just has access to more carriers.
He's amazing.
We have agents in every state and we have phenomenal agents
that have been with the company for 20, 30 years.
That's pretty common in our agency.
So yeah, anyone that needs help in other states,
we have that resource and, you know,
always happy to figure it out at the end of the day.
I've never told a client, sorry, you know,
go call 800 numbers and figure it out.
You know, we'll work together and make it happen.
Yeah.
So the funny thing is I have people calling me
all the time saying, Otter, how do you get your deals done?
And I always refer them to Kaylin.
So how do you get it done?
No one else can get it done.
I've had buyers,
cause I'm usually the listing side
or representing the seller.
And they say, we've called all these insurance companies.
We can't get it done.
I'm like, here, here's Kaylin's number and you get it done.
How are you able to get it done?
Is it because you're working with so many different,
I'll say options or what do you call them?
Insurance carriers?
Cause you're a broker, but I mean, you're smart.
You know how to do it.
So why can you do it?
No one else can.
Say no one, but most people.
Right, right.
And a lot of carriers, they only have, you know,
one solution.
We have 15 different carriers,
but also I partner with other brokers.
So, you know, farmers, AAA.
So when they come to me, between all my partners,
we're shopping nearly every single company in the market
if we have to, before we go to FairPlan,
which I also have access to.
So, you know, worst case scenario, we go with FairPlan.
Otherwise, you know, we're looking around
and trying to help these clients out.
Okay.
I'm curious, I don't know if you know this,
but what's the highest risk state with insurance?
It's like the most expensive for premiums.
Florida.
Yeah.
What's going on in Florida?
It's a pain point.
With the hurricanes.
Yeah.
And your roof and windows are a big deal out there, right?
When you're going to sell your home,
you have to have a new roof or in good shape
is what I'm understanding.
And the windows are really important as well.
Right.
Yeah.
It's tough.
And I know that Florida's gone through a lot of transitions,
but they heavily use their state-run programs
and flood insurance and hurricane insurance.
So insurance out there is just crazy
because these natural disasters are,
I mean, just absolute devastation.
So insurance companies,
they don't necessarily want to do business there.
Yep.
Okay, what's the best state to have, you know,
the lowest?
Anybody?
Is there anybody that's in particular a state?
I'm just curious.
Yeah.
You know, California, believe it or not,
had some of the lower rates.
Texas has been higher than us for years.
So we're,
the reason why our rates are increasing
is we're kind of catching up with some states
in the country.
Low cost states,
I can't really say offhand
what would be the lowest cost state necessarily.
Okay, so you said you've been in the business
for 11 years.
Okay, is it true that you feel like
there's a lot more natural disasters?
Or is it,
because I'm looking,
I'm like, we've always had fires.
I mean, for the Laguna fire,
I always remember floods.
I mean, granted now social media,
we are a lot more in tune to it,
but I'm just curious,
being in the business for 11 years,
are you starting to see like,
yeah, there definitely is an increase
in natural phenomenons or acts of nature
or whatever it may be?
That's a good point.
And there's different views on that.
So people are saying yes,
due to global warming,
things like that,
that we are seeing that kind of devastation.
Right.
And then how inflation has gone up,
these costs of labor and materials,
availability,
you know, things like that,
that's also caused insurance to skyrocket.
So very well could be
that we're experiencing it more now.
And the insurance companies
have not been rate adequate long enough
to keep up with it.
And then it's just complete mess
is what ends up happening.
It is, I know.
All right.
So I represent primarily,
or I say majority of sellers.
So I always want to sit down with them
and I'm like, okay,
so tell me about your home insurance.
You know, what's your rate?
So they go, oh, I use State Farm.
And I already know in my head,
State Farm ain't gonna insure.
They're not taking on any more policies.
So if I'm selling somebody's home,
how would I like coach my sellers
on just being able to make it easier
for the buyer to qualify for insurance?
Is there certain things they can do,
maybe electrical panel,
or what advice would you give home sellers
out there right now?
Yeah.
Or should we try to go out there
and get some quotes ahead of time?
Will you tell me?
I don't know.
I would say both.
So things like the electrical panels,
what's the condition of the roof?
Roofs aren't cheap to replace,
but those are things that the insurance companies
are gonna ask for in the quoting process
or cancel you on the back end for.
I would say those are the main items.
Aluminum wiring, cast iron plumbing.
So those are the physical features.
Debris on the property.
So insurance companies,
they want the debris gone.
So we've had cases where someone's
purchasing a hoarder house,
and that becomes very difficult
because it's hard to move all that stuff
in that short amount of time.
But yeah, those are the kinds of things.
Dogs, too.
A lot of insurance companies are still asking
about high-risk dogs, pit bulls,
Rottweilers, stuff like that.
So that can also cause an issue.
But for the seller,
the seller's having problems and feedback
as far as high cost of insurance,
availability for insurance.
You could ask the insurance agent.
I would say probably more
on the realtor side.
Because the seller would be asking
their agent, hey, you already have a policy.
On the realtor side,
if you have someone to partner with,
they can start running addresses.
It's very preliminary because there's
so many factors on the buyer side.
But at least you can get a sense,
is cost of insurance 10 grand here?
Or is it five?
Yeah, exactly.
And then, last question, the buyers.
What guidance would you give buyers?
Because they're really the ones
that are suffering right now.
Absolutely, yes.
Shop early.
And after those three years post-COVID
when all this blew up,
it was so sad to see people go in escrow
and then they're shopping for insurance
and they didn't qualify because of DTI.
Cost of insurance was $8,000
and then they're pulling out of escrow.
So thank goodness they put that contingency
early on in escrow.
Which they didn't have.
They didn't have before.
They did not.
Yeah, it kind of caught on after a little while
because that was happening so much.
It was so sad.
But even now, shop early.
If it's a high-risk area, shop around.
You know, use different companies.
Call Kaylin.
Call me.
I'll shop it for you, absolutely.
So we're gonna wrap up here.
But is there any closing statements?
Anything that you wanna say to the viewers here
that could just help them with insurance moving forward?
You have the room.
Absolutely.
Yeah, so with all this craziness going on,
if you have any changes, title changes,
maybe you're renting your home
and you used to live in your home, things like that,
call your insurance agent.
These big changes, make sure you update them on your policy.
Maybe it's under, yeah, Trust, LLC, whatever it might be.
Because carriers are looking for ways to deny claims.
So I think that's a huge thing.
If someone's had their policy for 10 years,
they forget to notify.
So that's really, really big right now.
And yeah, if you have questions
or you're purchasing a home, selling a home,
just shop early.
Start the process early.
And that way, by the time you close, you'll feel good.
Insurance is done.
Everyone's happy.
So yeah, I would say those are my two big tips.
Well, Kaylin, thank you so much.
And also, let's not forget to go get our video camera,
photos, upload it into the cloud.
Now, we will link Kaylin's information down below.
We can link it right here as well.
Thank you so much for being here and educating us.
We appreciate your time.
You're amazing.
Thank you so much.
And if you're in California,
use her as your insurance agent.
She's just incredible.
Oh, thank you so much.
Thanks for watching.