Deadly chemical cousins: oranges and yellows | Stories in Colour Podcast S2 Ep3 | National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
5 Video Views·Jun 10, 2026
What makes two volcano-born pigments so dangerous? Hint: they weren’t scorching hot when artists used them. Orpiment and realgar both contain arsenic, a foe we’ve previously faced on ‘Stories in Colour’.
…
There is also one other method of procuring gold, by making it from aupament, a mineral
dug from the surface of the earth in Syria, and much used by painters. It is just the
colour of gold, but brittle, like mirror stone in fact. This substance greatly excited the
That is Pliny the Elder's Natural History, a quote from chapter 22. Welcome to Stories in
Colour, a podcast from the National Gallery in London, where we're uncovering the mysteries
of how colour has changed the world. And today we're back on the subject of toxic pigments,
with two deadly chemical cousins. One was a favourite of the famous Venetian colourist
Titian, and the other, alchemists thought, could be made into gold. I'm Bex Leary from
the Digital Department here at the Gallery, and back with me on the podcast today is Evie Hatch.
Welcome back. Thank you. So Evie is an art historian specialising in the history and
characteristics of artists' pigments, and she is the writer and presenter of Jackson's art
Pigment Stories series. So as I said, we're looking at two deadly chemical cousins today, but
what pigments are we actually talking about? And we can start with Rialga.
Yeah, Rialga. Rialga is an arsenic sulphide mineral, and it has a very brilliant red-orange
colour. Another word for it is actually ruby of arsenic, which really sums up exactly what it
looks like. It has the crystals that are very much like gemstones. But unlike gemstones,
Rialga is quite soft, so it's not suitable for use in jewellery or things like that, but you can,
with some difficulty, grind it up to make a pigment. And that has been used in paints and
dyes and inks all over the world, from ancient Egypt, ancient China, and by the Romans and
the Greeks as well. And also, interestingly, it's been used by firework manufacturers
to make the white colour in fireworks. To make the white?
Yeah. Oh, interesting. Okay. I love hearing
about these modern uses of the pigments as well. It's really interesting. And then in its chemical
composition, could you tell us a bit about that? You've touched on it a bit.
Yes, yes. It's an arsenic sulphide, and it has something called a monoclinic structure,
and that basically just refers to the way that the atoms are arranged within the crystals.
So in Rialga, it has a slanted arrangement, and that's how you get in the crystals that very
angular, jagged shapes. Cool. And where might we find it? You've said
it's been used by the ancient Romans, Egyptians, Chinese. So does it occur all over the world?
It does, actually, yes. It's relatively common, and it's found primarily around hydrothermal
systems, so hot springs. Actually, one really interesting way that it forms is through volcanic
sublimation, and that is the process by which volcanic gases are condensed and solidify,
basically, around volcanic vents. So that's one way in which Rialga is formed. You can also make
it synthetically as well, so it's not always natural. Okay. I quite like that red-hot-orange
colour is associated with hot springs and volcanoes. Yeah, it's nice, that, isn't it?
It's nice. It's very much within the character of the pigment, I think, and as we'll discuss,
I'm sure, the kind of very reactive qualities that it has. It's very much on brand, I think.
So it can be found all over the world, Europe, Asia, the Americas?
Yes, yeah. And let's introduce Rialga's chemical cousin,
Orpiment. Yeah. What's Orpiment? Orpiment is another arsenic sulphide mineral,
but this one has a kind of golden-yellow colour instead. And again, that's found all over the
world, and it's been used as a pigment, again, since very, very ancient times. Like Rialga,
it's been ground up into a powder to make a pigment, and that's been used in painting,
in cosmetics. It's also been used as a medicine and a poison, which is very interesting.
And again, like Rialga, it's quite difficult to grind up, and this is spoken about in various
treaties. Cianino Cianini, in the 14th century, recommended grinding it onto a stone slab with a
micaceous kind of structure, and that makes it quite difficult to grind.
As in, like, physically, you need to put a lot of bump behind.
Yeah, it needs a little bit of help.
Yeah, yeah.
Okay. So it's been used across ancient Egypt, Mesopotamia, India, China.
Yeah.
So it's been found all over the world. Is it found in similar places to Rialga,
if it's chemically quite similar?
Yeah, often in exactly the same places, actually. They often occur together in the same environments.
And how would the minerals be collected?
They would be mined, and we do have one source, which is quite interesting.
A Greek historian slash geographer called Strabo, he's writing in the first century BC,
and he describes a Rialga mine, and this is in Asia Minor, which is modern-day Turkey,
and he describes the deadly air of the mine, which gives you an idea of maybe the kind of
conditions people were working under.
Okay. And how are the two chemically related, Orpiment and Rialga?
They both have that same, they're both members of the monoclinic crystal system,
so they're similar in that way. Obviously, both arsenic sulfide minerals,
but they do have a slightly different chemical composition.
So Rialga is arsenic sulfide, and Orpiment is arsenic trisulfide.
Okay. And we're referring to them as deadly chemical cousins,
and you kind of touched on it with the kind of deadly atmosphere of the mine. Why are they deadly?
They are both ores of arsenic, so very, very toxic.
And this was something that people have been aware of for a very, very long time.
The ancient Greeks used a poison called bull's blood, which is a Rialga-containing poison.
And it actually, quite excitingly, turns up in Greek mythology.
So you know the story of Midas, King Midas?
Yeah.
And he's the one who asks that everything that he touches will turn to gold with disastrous
consequences. There are lots of different versions of that story, but one of them,
which is recorded by Plutarch, he poisons himself at the end with bull's blood.
So Rialga turns up there. But as I kind of touched on with Strabo's account,
obviously, they're our real world. Real world, not just in mythology.
And Strabo describes how it was criminals that were sent to the Rialga mines.
To work there.
To work there, yeah. And it's terrible to think about now, but essentially,
the workforce had to be almost kind of disposable because the mortality rate was so high.
It tells you something about how, in the first century, they treated human life, doesn't it?
And it has also been used as an insecticide or a pesticide. There's a 5th century Chinese treaty
that describes how book rolls can be treated with orpiment to repel insects.
Oh, okay, so stopping the insects from eating the book, essentially.
Yeah, essentially, yeah.
That's cool. And you mentioned it was then used as medicine as well?
Yeah, it can be. It has been. And still is, I believe, in a more limited way.
In traditional Chinese medicine, it has been used as an anti-inflammatory and as
an anti-venom against snakebites. And that's quite common in traditional Chinese medicine,
to have the poison fighting poison. And I believe it has also been used as an aphrodisiac, which is
quite exciting.
And is that both orpiment and Rialga?
That, I believe, is mainly Rialga.
Nice. So, Rialga orpiment. How do these deadly pigments get their names?
Rialga is such a lovely name, I think. It's such a beautiful word. It comes from the Arabic
meaning powder of the minds. But it hasn't always gone by that name. The ancient Romans called it
sandarac, which confusingly then has often been used to describe other red pigments as well. You
get this a lot in pigment history, the same word being used to describe lots of different pigments.
So, it's also been used to describe red lead pigments, red ochres, and then a bit later on,
the resin from a tree. So, sandarac is a bit of a difficult one.
Okay. So, if you're looking back through texts in the time, you were like,
okay, you've got one word here, but it might have referred to loads of different types of pigments.
Yeah. In Chinese, the words for orpiment and Rialga translate to female yellow,
in the case of orpiment, and male yellow, in the case of Rialga, which is really interesting.
I think that reflects their chemical and geological proximity, almost, which is quite nice.
Of the minerals themselves.
Yeah. Kind of an idea that they're almost companions, cousins, if you will. And in a
similar vein, I saw a mineralogist describe them as mineral lovebirds, which I think is nice. So,
there is that kind of idea throughout history that they are kind of connected, which is why
it's quite nice that we're talking about them together.
Yeah.
Today.
Yeah.
I mean, that's a much more romantic way to put it than we are with deadly chemical cousins today.
I think I prefer deadly chemical cousins.
Interesting that the Chinese called them female yellow and male yellow,
because as you've described the pigments, one Rialga being much more red, bright,
and orpiment being much more yellow. Do you think there's something that perhaps in colour
categories being slightly different in Chinese culture, or is it just that they're connected?
Yes, I think so. I don't quite know enough about it. I imagine that it also has a bearing on how
they're used in medicine. Because the idea of certain materials being male and female turns
up quite a lot in traditional Chinese medicine, I believe. King's yellow is a word that's been
used to describe very fine grade orpiment, also synthetic orpiment. And that comes from,
in the kind of Arabic tradition of alchemy, orpiment and Rialga have been called the two
kings. So again, that kind of pairing up, which is really, really nice. So that's where
king's yellow might come from. The term orpiment comes from the Latin ori pigmentum. And that
means literally, golden paint. So that kind of relationship between orpiment and gold,
which we will be coming to at some point, I'm sure.
Yeah, yeah. Fantastic. Yeah. Ori, I guess the other AU is the chemical symbol for gold,
which comes from the Latin. So yeah, that makes sense when you hear it out loud. When you see
orpiment written with the OR, I guess you don't immediately make the connection. But with the
Latin AU, yeah, that brings that to mind. It's deteriorated over time. Actually, there's a
connection between gold and the word arsenic as well. The English word arsenic comes ultimately
from the Greek arsenicon. And that in turn comes from a Persian word, zarnik, I believe is kind of
how you pronounce it, meaning gold coloured. So even in the English word arsenic, that idea of
kind of gold is very much in there. So that's... Okay, the etymology is so interesting.
Now's a good point for us to take a break. So we've introduced our deadly chemical cousins,
and when we get back, we will talk a little bit more about that connection with gold.
So having been introduced to our deadly chemical cousins, we have found that there is a connection
with gold through language and orpiment's name. But is there another link? And how does that
relate to alchemy? Yeah, so the link, well, so I think it's worth just saying briefly what alchemy
was. Alchemy was a kind of proto-scientific practice, very, very ancient, has roots in
ancient Egypt, ancient China. And it's about the transformation of materials,
the relationship between the heavens and the earth, very much mixed in with mathematics,
theology, philosophy, often using language loaded with symbolism. We talked about the two kings in
Arabic alchemy. And yeah, it's a practice that continues kind of throughout the Middle Ages,
kind of begins to turn into what we would consider to be modern chemistry.
So alchemy was a way in which people would kind of understand and seek to understand the world
around them, including minerals and metals and where they came from. So Aristotle was really
important in the kind of development of alchemy. And he believed that metals and minerals kind of
grew in the ground. Like organically kind of grew up like a plant. Yeah. Well, yeah.
And maybe not quite like that. So his kind of theory was that exhalations from the earth
would get trapped and would condense and form all of these minerals. And that was his way of,
there's an amazing variety of different colours and materials that lie beneath our feet. And this
was kind of his way of explaining it. Actually, now I'm saying that it's not far off when it comes
to the formation of Rialga and Orkham and Izzi, like with the exhalations of volcanic gases.
Not a million miles off the mark, I don't think. And famously, one of the aims of many alchemists
was to transmute base materials into gold. Yeah, I think this is the view that I had of alchemy.
Originally, it was literally all about gold. They just wanted to make gold. I didn't realise there
was such a broader kind of way of trying to understand the world around you practice associated
with alchemy. But yeah, gold does feel like the main thing that people connect with alchemy.
Yeah, and alchemy is very much why we consider, I think, gold to be such an important substance
because of its connection with the divine, with the sun, the fact that it's almost kind of
indestructible. These are all things that were highly prized by alchemists. So Orkham, speaking
of transmuting base materials into gold, Orkham was thought to be one of those seeding materials
that you could ripen, I guess, into gold. And there is actually quite a good reason for believing
this. Okay. So you often find Orkham running in kind of seams in gold mines. So gold can sometimes
turn up in Orkham as almost like an impurity. So when you're processing the Orkham, you actually
end up with a bit of metallic gold, almost like a by-product. So that led to a belief that the
gold was being produced by that process, which obviously is very exciting for alchemists.
Very exciting.
Very exciting. So it's not just that Orkham looks like gold, it also has a kind of,
it can have a proximity to it, you know, geologically, I guess.
So it's, yeah, a golden yellow colour as well. So there's that similarity.
So you can see where that kind of, where that comes up. Yeah.
And I think the ancient Egyptians used it for its likeness to gold, right? Because of the colour.
Yeah. Yeah. I believe they did. Yeah.
Yeah. And I read a quote at the beginning from Pliny the Elder's writings on Orkham,
and he related it to a Roman emperor.
He did. Yes. Yeah. So he refers to him as Caius in that quote, but actually that is the emperor
Caligula. That's how we kind of recognise him today. So in this story that Pliny the Elder
tells, this is in the first century AD, he tells a story of how Caligula ordered in a massive
amount, a huge amount of orpiment and had it melted down in the hope of making all of this gold
and then only ended up with the most, like, tiniest little bit of gold. He tells it in such a
frame. He tells it through the lens of his greed and avarice and things like that and how he kind
of ultimately makes a loss. Because it was such, he needed so much orpiment to even get this tiny
bit of gold. Yeah. Which is probably because the gold is in there. So it's a story that,
you know, maybe it did happen.
I'm going to read the whole quote actually because I think it's really interesting.
So this is Pliny's chapter 22 on orpiment.
There is also one other method of procuring gold by making it from orpiment, a mineral dug
from the surface of the earth in Syria and much used by painters. It is just the colour of gold
but brittle like mirror stone in fact. This substance greatly excited the hopes of the
emperor Caius, a prince who was most greedy for gold. He accordingly had a large quantity of it
melted and really did obtain some excellent gold. But then the proportion was so extremely
small that he found himself a loser thereby. Such was the result of an experiment prompted
solely by avarice and this too, although the price of the orpiment itself was no more than
four denarii per pound. Since his time, the experiment has never been repeated.
At least he learned from it. I love that.
Didn't repeat his mistakes.
It's nice as well because you can see the point that he's making there is that the orpiment is
very, very cheap.
Yeah, so you'd expect to kind of get bang for your buck.
The prospect of getting all that gold for, you know, I get it, I get it.
Let's skip forward quite a few centuries to, back to, you mentioned him before,
who wrote Libro dell'Arte, written in the 1390s, describing 14th century Italian
painting practice. And he is this wealth of resource for us studying pigments today.
But yeah, tell us about his kind of reaction to orpiment.
Yeah, like you say, he's a real wealth of information. He had a lot to say about a lot
of things. He described orpiment as a most handsome yellow, which I love,
more closely resembling gold than any other colour. So again, that connection between,
the visual connection here between gold and orpiment.
He also warns artists against soiling their mouth with it, lest they suffer personal injury.
Why would they be soiling their mouth with it?
Well, so it was, I believe what he's referring to here is the really common practice of pointing
the tip of your brush with your mouth to get a really fine point.
Okay, so you wet the brush and it makes it easier to paint.
Yeah, so you can see how people would have ended up with pigments in their mouth, certainly,
from doing that. But he warns against it, which I find really interesting because I think we do,
we tend to have this idea that artists were using these really, really poisonous,
quite dangerous materials with no regard for health and safety. But I think what
kind of tells us here is that actually that was something that did concern people,
because arsenic poisoning is not very nice at all.
No.
Sometimes I think we have quite a prideful view of ourselves and not enough humility for the
artists and workshops of the past.
Yeah, yeah, I think that's very true, actually. And I think it is also worth remembering that it
wasn't primarily the artists that were at risk from harm from these materials. There were
apprentices grinding arsenic and lead, mercury containing pigments, kind of in the background,
making those paints. And then also, as I said before, Strabo's account of the workers in the
mines, in the deadly air. So I think…
And mining just itself being a really dangerous process.
Yeah, incredibly dangerous, yeah. Yeah, so people were working with those materials,
but I do think, by and large, there was an awareness of how dangerous they could be, yeah.
Yeah, we actually, we did an episode in series one on deadly green pigments.
So, yeah, if you listening want to dive in a little bit more to the toxicity of not yellows,
oranges, but greens, there's that episode to dive back into. And after the break, we will dive in
to how Rialga and Orphamint have been used by artists.
So having looked a bit at Orphamint's links with gold through alchemy and language, we're now going
to deep dive into some paintings and some artists who have used these pigments, both Orphamint and
Rialga. And we're going to start with the 16th century Venetian artists, so Titian, Tintoretto
and Veronese. And look at how they've used these pigments. Yeah, yeah. I think it's worth saying
just beforehand that Orphamint has been used much more so, or appears to have been used much more
so than Rialga. Rialga's use tends to be a bit more sporadic. But there is one very exciting
use of Rialga by Titian, and this is in the early 16th century. It's a painting from 1510
called The Holy Family with a Shepherd. And it's a beautiful painting,
very rich blues, what we would expect from Titian, rich blues, earths and oranges. And in the very
centre we have Joseph wearing a very richly coloured orange robe, and that has been painted
with Rialga. I'll describe the painting just so that you can imagine it at home if you're listening.
So as the title suggests, it's a moment from the Bible showing the adoration of the shepherds in
which the shepherds visit the infant Christ once he's been born. And the focus of the painting is
these figures. So the three figures sat around the baby Jesus. And on the left hand side of the
painting, we see the Virgin Mary, she's got a reddish pink dress with her characteristic bright
blue kind of fabric robe over the top and a white scarf over her head. She kneels on the ground
holding up her son, who's resting on a rounded manger made of woven wooden sticks. And he's
leaning in towards his mother, his head appearing to rest next to hers. And then, as he said,
there's Saint Joseph in the centre of the painting, seated to the right of the infant Christ,
and he's wearing purple robes and then the orange that you have mentioned with bright orange fabric.
He's got really curly brown hair and a beard covering the lower half of his face. And he's
presenting the baby to the young shepherd, who's our third figure, kneeling in reverence at Joseph
and Christ's feet. And then behind the Virgin Mary, just in the background, we've got this little
donkey and an ox. And in the distance, as you said, the bright blue sky with some clouds.
There's a hint of orange light on the horizon. And we can also just about see, although very small,
a flying angel wearing a pink robe. He's announcing Christ's birth to some men tending to a herd
of sheep, or a flock of sheep. Heard of sheep? Flock of sheep. Flock of sheep.
That's a beautiful painting, isn't it? There's a lot going on, actually, when you start really
looking at it. When you start looking into the background and everything, it's not just these
curly figures at the front. But yeah, talk to us about the use of pigments.
Oh, it's a really, it's a lovely example of how incredible Titian was as a colourist.
And the role of that orange is really, really important. And because blue and orange are
complementary colours, they kind of... Sing against each other.
They do. They sing against each other. Exactly. Yeah. And you see that throughout not just
Titian's work, but I think Titian is a master of it. You get it in Bacchus and Ariadne, another
really famous painting in the National Gallery's collection, where the very, very bright blue
ultramarine sky is intensified and heightened by the orange in the figures. And you get that here
as well. So that orange robe, which actually is in the centre of the composition. It's not the
Virgin and Child in the centre. It's Joseph with his robe. That orange is so important when it
comes to, it's important in the whole kind of the visual colour landscape of the painting as a whole.
Really beautiful. And our technical bulletin, which, you know, if you want to get really deep
into these pigment histories and the kind of chemical makeup of our paintings, is exciting
reading for some. It does say that there was a shift in taste towards draperies of this colour
painted with realgar, which became so common later in the century that it's seen as very
characteristic of Venetian technique, which is really interesting. And we should maybe point
out as well that Venice, being a port, being by the sea, was this kind of like import state for
loads of exciting pigments. It was like one of the first places in Europe, amazing pigments being
imported. And so this is why you get such amazing colours from the artists in the city at the time.
Yeah. So the Venetian palette is so, during the 16th century, is so distinct for that.
Yeah. They had access to incredible things.
And realgar is only in the brightest highlights and mixed with earth pigments in the lightest
mid-tones, with the shadows and the underpaint instead being a darker orange mixture based on
red and yellow earths. So that's for the cloak. So yeah, he's doing quite complex things with his
pigments.
Yeah, he is. Yeah. Yeah. He was a master of it. And then later on in the century, you have
artists like Veronese and Tintoretto, actually Titian, Veronese and Tintoretto are the kind of
big three of the 16th century Venetian art. So in Tintoretto's, speaking of orange cloaks,
in Tintoretto's Christ Washing the Feet of His Disciples, you have this, it's a very dark
painting actually, very large painting. And it's Jesus kind of in the centre kneeling on the floor
and he is, as the title suggests, washing the feet of his disciples. This is from a story in
the Gospels. And he is washing the feet of Saint Peter in this painting. Saint Peter is wearing
another lovely orange robe. And that has been painted in various layers that include Orpiment
and Rialdo. So there we have the two pigments kind of working together, which is quite nice.
Nice. And another Tintoretto example would be the Origin of the Milky Way,
where both pigments were found in bright touches of orange in the sash of the poteau.
Yes.
So you can have a look at that as well. Let's skip forward a bit into the late 20th century
for some Dutch and Flemish flower painting. So Rachel Rausch in about 1685 painted flowers in
a vase. So a painter, a specialist in these amazing flower portraits almost. And she
paints this amazing bouquet with peonies and hawthorn and honeysuckle and columbine, all
of which bloom early in the year. But the burnt orange and deep green of the lilies you get,
you get a seed pod sort of straggling over the edge of the shelf. There's ripe wheat and dry
veined leaves, which kind of give a sense towards summer. And then the light on the pale flowers
kind of sweeps upwards, making them seem really luminous. And she's used these really delicate
brushstrokes to skim over the surface of the picture so that the dusky blue columbine seem
as though they're kind of drifting in the darkness. And the background of this painting is very dark,
the small vase, which mostly is obscured by all the flowers, sits on a table that we can see
at the bottom of the painting. But yeah, tell us a little bit about the orange here.
This is a really, really beautiful painting. I think it's one of my favourites, actually,
in the gallery's collection. Yeah, so she's used realgar in those orange flowers,
and there's something kind of fiery about it, which is, I think, a really lovely quality.
I think realgar is definitely kind of contributing to that here.
So we've kind of looked at where realgar and ornament are going really ripe for some artists.
What can go wrong with these pigments? Let's look at The Virgin and Child Enthroned by
Margarito D'Alesso, around 1263 to 1264. One of the earliest paintings in our collection,
very, very early. It shows us the Virgin Mary seated on a throne with the Christ Child on her
lap, enclosed within an almond shape, which is called a mandorla. And around them are the eight
scenes depicting lives of various saints. There's a lot of gold going on, actual gold going on in
this painting, as you would expect. There are kind of four scenes on the left and four on the right,
each in their own little section or square. So we've got gold leaf background with decorative
black borders and a limited use of colour, so reds, blacks, browns and golds. But tell us
about the ornament here and what's going on in this painting.
So exciting. So conservators found that parts of this painting had been overpainted later on,
and when they removed the overpaint, they found that there was a red border around the whole
composition. And within that red border is a yellow foliate design, so scrolling leaves, I suppose.
And that has been painted with Orpiment. But what is really fun and exciting is that because it's
been protected by that overpaint, the yellow is still very, very rich. And through, again,
using specialist imaging to have a look at the painting, you can use x-ray fluorescence basically
to almost map the chemicals that have been used and that are present in a painting. It's a good
way of kind of getting a good idea of what the pigments are. And when they were making a map for
where the arsenic was in the painting, they found that it had been used much more extensively, but
because it had deteriorated, it's not visible anymore. So it's also found in the border of
the mandala that's surrounding the Virgin and Child, as well as in the pattern on her robe,
that brocade pattern. And I think there's also some in Christ's baby Jesus's robe as well. And
as you say, there's a lot of gold in this painting, but then also Orpiment as well. So again,
there's a nice proximity there. Hand in hand. Yeah. So yeah, that was revealed by
MAXRF scanning of this painting. And it's a reminder that the colours we see on the walls
in galleries today might not always be the colours as originally intended. And there are things we
can see behind the paint that aren't visible to the naked eye, which is really cool.
It's really, and it's so exciting as well, because the better that the modern technology gets at
detecting these things, there's so much to learn about these paintings and what they might, you
can recreate what they might have looked like. You know, it's such an amazing resource. I think
we'll probably only get better and better. Really exciting. Let's hop over to the Rijksmuseum's
Still Life with Flowers in a Watch by Abraham Mignon around 1660 to 1679.
Yeah. So it's a painting made just before Rachel Rauch's. And yeah, I mean, it's a lovely example
of the genre, isn't it? But when you look very closely, or actually you don't need to look that
closely. It's quite obvious. There's a yellow rose kind of just off the centre as part of this
luxurious bunch of flowers. There's some carnations, I believe. There's definitely some lilies, I think.
But yeah, we can just say that it's a really lush bouquet, which has been really carefully
arranged by colours and shapes. And there's a lot of luminosity and light. And next to the bouquet,
there's an open pocket watch with a blue ribbon attached, which is really quite bright against the
table that it's perched upon and insects crawling over the flowers, which I always love in flower
paintings, trying to spot like the butterflies or the caterpillars or the little signs of life
going on. Yeah. So much detail. So much detail, which is why the yellow rose really kind of sticks
out because it's completely flat. It looks really flat, doesn't it? It looks very 2D rather than 3D.
And why is that? That is because it's been painted with orpiment, also combined with a yellow lake
pigment, which is derived from a dye. And this is a good example of what can go wrong when you use
orpiment. So orpiment is very prone to degrading. And what happens when it degrades is that the
surface becomes kind of powdery and it becomes semi-translucent, almost. So that, combined with
the fading of the yellow lake pigment, has caused some darkening there.
And so all of that detail, which you see in all of the other flowers in this painting,
has kind of disappeared. But it is still there, which is interesting. So when you look at the
painting using specialist imaging, you can actually see where those brushstrokes are
and where the dimension has been formed. But to the naked eye at the moment, it's now
invisible. So that is a really good example of how orpiment can change. That's amazing, isn't it?
That it's sort of locked in time and the eye can't see the detail that's actually really there.
Yeah. So how do realgar and orpiment react with other pigments? Do other pigments blacken or
change when combined with them? Yes, they can do, yeah. So there's plenty of treaties,
painting treaties, from the past that warn against mixing them with copper-containing
pigments. So that would be verdigris, most notably, which is a green pigment. And with
lead as well. So that would be lead white, red lead, which is a shame because obviously
both of those pigments we use so much. And what happens is that the sulphur reacts with
the copper and lead ions. So you get lead and copper sulphides, basically. And there are some
examples. So some Persian manuscripts where you can see that the lead white has gone black
when used adjacent to, I can't remember if it was orpiment or realgar, but certainly one of them.
So yes, that's one. And it is a big disadvantage, certainly, yeah.
Of using these pigments. So have artists stopped using these pigments today?
Yes, they don't. Generally, they're not used anymore. They went, fell out of use. I find it
quite kind of sad, really. They kind of slipped out of use, I guess, in the 19th century. I mean,
realgar was never incredibly widely used, especially not in European painting anyway.
So it's quite difficult to trace that. But orpiment was superseded by 19th century yellows,
like the chrome yellows, cadmium yellow. So you certainly don't find them in artist paint
ranges anymore. You can still get the pigment from specialist sources, but in general,
they have fallen out of use. And you can see why, you know, they're reactive, unstable, poisonous.
It's interesting with realgar, though, because it was the only real,
true orange pigment, right? Before the synthetic ones came in.
Yeah, it was. Certainly, I would say the only kind of bright orange pigment.
I see that said a lot, actually, about realgar, but I do question it sometimes because you can
get orange earths, depending on where you find them. But generally, yes, I would say that in
terms of a bright orange, a bright red orange, yeah, it was, which is remarkable, really,
considering how many oranges there are today. Yeah, yeah. So not widely used as pigments,
but are they still mined? Are they still used for anything?
Yeah, they are. So they are still mined as ores of arsenic, because arsenic is still quite widely
used in alloys for making batteries. Ah, okay. Yeah, yeah. And I guess batteries are kind of
toxic anyway, so yeah, it doesn't really matter. Yeah, exactly. So they're not, in terms of
historical pigments, it's interesting because there are loads of historical pigments that
really capture the imagination, and rightly so. Like ultramarine blue, obviously, being one of
that amazing mineral blue that really completely blows everyone away.
And then other historical pigments that are kind of toxic as well, so shields green,
emerald green, arsenic-based greens, and they're also, you know, they're quite widely discussed.
But orpiment and realgar, I think there's a kind of... They're definitely not as famous,
are they? Yeah, they're not as famous, yeah, and I don't, which I think is a shame,
so hopefully we've done them justice. Hopefully we have. Introducing them to listeners today.
And actually, thank you to one listener who asked that last question about whether these,
whether arsenic-containing pigments were still around today. So thank you for sending that in.
That brings us to the end of today's episode of Stories in Colour, and if you've got more
questions about the story of colour, you can email us. We're on podcast at nationalgallery.org.uk,
or send in your questions via our social media channels. So thank you so much for joining us
for today's episode of Stories in Colour on deadly chemical cousins, with huge thanks to our guest,
Evie Hatch. And I've been your host, Bex Leary. Our producer was Harry Rosehill. Our researcher
was Hannah Rogers. Our technicians were Ian Warren and Tom Gulliver. Our video producer
was Alessandro Sorrenti, with thanks to the scientific team here at the National Gallery.
Thank you so much for listening.
