A blue more expensive than gold − ultramarine | Stories in Colour Podcast S2 Ep2 | National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
2 Video Views·Jun 9, 2026
Travel with us beyond the sea to look at ultramarine, a pigment that was once even more precious than gold.
In this episode, writer Victoria Finlay joins Beks for a discussion on how researching ultramarine took her to Afgh …
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of the \"Stories in Colour\" podcast explores the history of natural ultramarine, a pigment derived from lapis lazuli. Guest Victoria Finlay discusses the stone's origins in Afghanistan, the arduous process of its extraction and purification, and its transition from a rare, costly material reserved for sacred art to a synthetic pigment used by the Impressionists.
A colour illustrious, beautiful and most perfect beyond all other colours. One could not say
anything about it or to do anything with it that its quality would not still surpass.
That is from Chinino Chinini which we will get along to a little bit later. Welcome to
Stories in Colour, a podcast from the National Gallery in London searching for histories of
how colour has changed the world. Today we're looking at a pigment that's been more precious
than gold, come to symbolise the holiness of the Virgin Mary and been so revered it
was specified in Renaissance artists contracts. I'm Bex Leary from the Digital Department here
at the Gallery and I'm joined by Victoria Finlay. Welcome back to the podcast Victoria.
Thank you very much. Lovely to have you on the podcast again. So Victoria has written
two books about colour, colour travels through the paint box and the brilliant history of
colour in art which involved travelling to some of the more extraordinary places that
ancient pigments and dyes came from including Afghanistan for blue inspired in part by two
of the paintings in the National Gallery. She's also more recently written a book about
the hidden stories of fabric. So today we've set up that we're looking at this very very
precious pigment and that pigment is natural ultramarine. We're going to tell the story
of ultramarine in the episode today. Ultramarine comes from a semi-precious stone called lapis
lazuli or lazuli, people like either, which is yeah an amazing deep blue and it's the source
of our ultramarine. So tell us about it. You've brought into the studio. Shall we start with this? So I am, for those who haven't got the video to
look at, I'm holding a piece of blue stone. It's sort of the size, it's bigger than my
palm and it's kind of stone heavy, it's quite heavy. It looks blue but it's also got stripes,
uneven stripes of kind of calcified white and grey and it's also got, if I flicker it
here, you can see in the light, it's got sparkles which is fool's gold. Almost little stars.
It looks like constellation. It does look like a night sky. And the makeup of this lapis lazuli
rock is sort of stripes of slightly different coloured blues. They're not even stripes but
they are obvious stripes and some of them are quite greenish, some of them are quite
kind of greyish and some of them, which is what we're going to talk about really in this
episode, are so blue they're like almost violet. They've got that shining to them. The brightest
kind of blue. Deepest blue of a summer day. If you imagine a renaissance painting, that's
the blue. But if you imagine a really satisfying colour of sky that's got almost violet that
maybe is just after rain or just before rain, when everything is kind of working quite hard
to be blue, it's that colour that we're going to be talking about.
And where might people have seen it apart from in paintings? Lapis lazuli, that is.
I mean, paintings is the key thing but lapis is also a semi-precious jewel. So sometimes
you might have kind of worn it in jewellery as a bead. And again, these are quite a wide
variety of colours. So if you've seen lapis bead, lapis just means stone but it's a good
shorthand. If you've seen a lapis bead and you don't think, oh that's pretty, then maybe
it wasn't a very good one because they can be really, really kind of lovely, shimmery,
exciting colour. And where does it come from? This one came from Afghanistan. And actually
there are lapis mines, there's one in Chile which, I mean again, it's okay stones. I've
seen them, I've seen them but they are a little bit darker than the Afghan ones. There's some
in Siberia which were used for paint but really only a few Russian icons can be made from it.
And there's a couple of very small mines in Africa but again, it's not, nothing was the
quality of this one mountain in Afghanistan. Which we will travel to later in the episode.
I can't wait to talk to you about your travels to Afghanistan. I'm going to put this down
noisily, just listen to it. I hope you heard that, listeners. So yes, you talked a little
bit about what lapis lazuli means but the pigment that we get from this semi-precious
stone, ultramarine, where does that term come from?
Ultra, beyond, marine, the sea. So it comes from beyond the seas. I mean, I grew up sure that this
word for this miraculous blue meant something like even more sea-coloured than the sea itself.
Well yes, that's what you think, isn't it?
It seems sort of like emphasis, doesn't it?
Sort of sea on steroids, you know, that kind of ultra-hyper-sea but it's not. It was a term
used, it's an Italian term, and it was a term used to describe something that came from so far
away that really for a long time nobody that they knew had really been there. No Europeans were
known. I mean, Marco Polo passed quite close by, a mountain away, which is not that close by,
probably a few days' journey, and he said over there were the mountains from which this
ultramarine blue came, but he didn't go there either. It's a beautiful, mysterious colour,
but also it had a beautiful, mysterious story almost by accident.
And so it's quite elusive from the beginning. But you went to find ultramarine in Afghanistan.
Could you tell us about your travels? What was that like? How did you even
get there to a part of the world that has been, yeah, there was a lot of conflict going on at the
time. What was that like? Well, we are going to look at these paintings in a minute, right? So I'm
not going to spoil the paintings, but I will just say how standing in the National Gallery in a way
that we'll tell a story about later, I realised that I had to go to where this stone came from.
It was so elusive and so expensive and it was in the National Gallery that I had that first
absolute conviction that if I was going to write this book. So one was The Entombment. Yes.
By Michelangelo. Yes. And one, which we'll also look at, was Bacchus and Ariadne.
I can't wait to discuss those. So, Afghanistan. Afghanistan. This was, I mean, I wrote this first
book of mine 25 years ago. So Afghanistan was in a very sadly similar situation to what it is now,
but it was in a different, it was in a Taliban regime and there was a lot of fighting between
the Taliban and the Mujahideen who had only one tenth of the country which was up in the northeast
of the country, right? And that's important because that bit of the country is where the blue
mines were. So I knew that I needed to go. It was really one of the hardest countries to get to
and it was, it was an extraordinary place then. It is an extraordinary place,
but there was danger on the roads and realising I wasn't going to be able to go
that way to the mines because of the fighting line and there was a lot of firing, there were
lots of bombs, there was lots of artillery. It was a ridiculous thing to even suggesting.
I decided that first year to go and see the first known use of this paint as pigment. So it had been
travelling from Afghanistan to Egypt 6,000 years ago. Okay. So it was a really ancient trade.
They'd been using it as insets, but in terms of using it as pigment, that first use had been
6th, 7th century and the first known use of it had been above the Buddhas of Bamiyan and Bamiyan
is a small town, very small town, about a day's drive through bad roads, really only a mountain
away from Kabul. Okay, still in Afghanistan. It's still in Afghanistan and not very far away and
there were two Buddhas. In fact, there were three, but one was lying on it. It was less famous one
and it was a prone Buddha. So the two that I'm talking about were, one was 55 metres,
one was a bit less. Huge. Massive and they dominated the valley and once upon a time,
they had, one was painted red and one was painted kind of blue or multicoloured
and they had these great arms, which were lost by 2000 anyway, but the arms moved up and down.
They were kind of extended, so people would pull, yeah, so they would pull the arms up and down,
probably with sort of great sound of chains and I guess that would be about prayer and calling
people and they had green eyes that, I mean, they couldn't possibly have been made of emeralds,
but because they wouldn't, yeah, you wouldn't have had the emeralds like as big as my head,
but that was the sort of the rumour that they had these emerald eyes, so were fascinating and they
came from the sort of a long-gone Buddhist culture in that area, but above the heads of
the Buddhas, which were set into the rock standing, were paintings and one of the paintings
or one of the sets of paintings had pigment ultramarine. Amazing, okay. So we went there.
So this was your first experience? So we went there and we climbed onto the head of the taller
Buddha, which is the one that we were allowed to go to and it was a big head. You could picnic on
this head, on the top of the head and people had and there'd been a sense, this was Taliban times,
the Buddhas were not respected by the commanders, so they had been lighting fires on the head and
things like that, but above us there were Buddhist paintings with paintings of a kind of rainbow. It
wasn't in the sort of the actual rainbow order, but they'd painted rainbow to symbolise sublime
intention and I saw it and this was in spring of 2000 and a few months later, both Buddhas
were blown up. Wow, okay, so you were some of the last people to see these beautiful works.
And to see that blue and to see the Buddhas in situ, it was a, yeah, it was a really sad thing.
Eventually, do you, what's the story next? How do you get to? So it was really clear that I needed to go
the different way and we by then had got some contacts at the United Nations and they were
flying people into Faizabad, which was the capital of that corner of the Northern
Alliance territories and so the following year, I paid a ticket price to go on their standard
aircraft into Faizabad and was extremely lucky. One of the people, one of the Afghans who worked
at the United Nations, his uncle was a warlord, a commander up there and so he'd asked for
permission, so I got permission. That was my first state of luck. My second state of luck
was after having gone for a walk on that first day, thinking I'm going to have to, somebody I'm
sure will help me to find a transport, I came back to find a two-time journalist
lying on Time magazine and they were just kind of lounging around and they were going to the mine
as well and no foreign press had, we were told anyway, had gone to the mines for at least six
months, maybe more, so I was extremely lucky to have people to share the journey as well as the
costs of the journey, so we all went together. It was very dramatic mountain countryside and
it felt like, you know how you see in some of these paintings, these Renaissance paintings
of mountains far away? It felt like we were in the mountains far away that had been painted.
What kind of colours were around you? What did it look like?
Browns, not very much. There'd been a drought, so it was probably much browner than it usually was
and dusty, a lot of dust. The mines weren't producing for some reason that people, some of
the people thought was simply about equipment. Other people said it was about the mines and the
blue responding to the difficulty of Afghanistan. It was quite high up, it was quite hard work.
I mean, our efforts were slightly in contrast with a young boy who ran up with a great big
jerry can on his back. We felt less noble at that time, but eventually we were just going to
mine number one and there were mines, well, the biggest name numbered mine was 23,
so I don't know whether all of the in-betweens were working, but anyway, we went to the first.
And it was, you'd walk through a, it was quite a big entrance to the cave and the tunnels went
off to the left, but we were, we started off by going to the right where there was a sort of cavern
kind of as big, as big as this room. If you remember, you can hear the echo in this room.
So it was quite a, quite a decent sized cavern, maybe the size of one of the mid-sized galleries
in the National Gallery, that kind of size. And at the light of the torches that the men were
carrying, we looked up and there, the whole of the ceiling of this cavern was sparkling with this
fool's gold iron pyrite. Beautiful. It was beautiful. With the blue as well, or was that?
Yeah, there was blue, there was some blue, but it was mostly the sparkles that you could see
just by the torchlight. And we drank tea and they told us the story.
And what I, I mean, I did go, we did go down into the mines, but what, what really struck me was
before dynamite, which is what they used. To explode the mountain now.
Which is normal now in today's, but anyways, before dynamite, they did something quite
extraordinary. They used to light a fire underneath a tunnel, not a very high tunnel,
I would think. They, they used to crouch to get, to get through. So light a fire until the rock
gets really, and then, and you've got one of the lads, like the one who'd passed me,
these lads have been going up there for 6,000 years. So some lad would run up with a container
full of iced water from the river and throw the iced water at the heated rock, which would,
on the first or second or third time, crack. It would shock the rock into cracking.
Shock the rock. And so it was a completely different kind of mining, quite a slow mining.
And in a way it was a, well, it was a probably much more complicated one. And it was also unsafe,
as all of these things are unsafe. But you can imagine that it would be much
kinder on the rock than an explosion. Yes. So this is where we're still,
you know, there's, there's, there's still mining for natural ultramarine to be made.
What happens to the mined rocks there today? So remember I'm talking 2000, and a lot has
happened in Afghanistan. However, I imagine, and I understand that these mines are still being
mined. Still operational. Well, because they don't, it's really for semi-precious jewels. So
they make boxes, they make jewels, they make beads. It's not now very lucrative.
It never really has been, because even with this kind of thing, with this kind of rock that I'm
holding again in my hand, it required a lot of rock to make a small amount of paint. So it's
never been massively lucrative as a mine, but it has been there, and it has been seen as beautiful.
Yes. This feels like a good point for us to take a break. So we have travelled with you to
Afghanistan to discover where lapis lazuli is mined. And I guess from that we have a sense of
why ultramarine pigment in the Renaissance might have been quite so expensive, being so elusive
and coming from to Western Europe, very far away. After the break, we will look at who was using it
in artwork and paintings. We'll see after the break. Welcome back from the break. So we're
going to look now at just why natural ultramarine has been so, so expensive, so revered, used to
depict holiness, as I indicated at the very beginning of the episode. And to do that, we're
going to go to one of the earliest examples from our collection, where a very vibrant expanse of
ultramarine pigment has been used together with expanses of real gold, gold leaf. And that is in
a painting called the Wilton Diptych. We don't know who the painter was. It's an English or French
artist. And it was made in about 1395 to 1399. So right at the end of the 14th century for the
English king, King Richard II. And this is a sort of smallish panel painting. It was a portable
devotional object. So it's got hinges in the middle of the golden frame. And it's painted both on the
front and the back. So you have four panels, two on the front, two on the back. And the side that
we're interested in today has one panel, which is very vibrantly blue. On the left, not the
vibrantly blue panel, is Richard himself and above him standing three men, Edmund and Edward the
Confessor, England's patron saints, both wearing crowns, and Richard's personal patron, John the
Baptist, Richard's kneeling. He's being presented by these men to a group of figures in the right
hand panel. And the right hand panel is where we get this absolutely glorious expanse of ultramarine
blue in the robes of the Virgin Mary and a sea of 11 angels who are also dressed in this very
striking blue. And they've also got feathered wings and floral headdresses. So the central
character of this right hand panel is the Virgin Mary standing with her golden halo, her blue robes,
holding the infant Christ who is blessing King Richard over on the left. And really, I think
it's just astonishing. I mean, you have to see it in person to really take in how brilliantly blue
the ultramarine comes across when it is in paint. It's amazing. I remember the first time I saw this
in the gallery. And just being entranced, just going towards it and seeing it from a distance.
It was, as you said, it was like a sea of blue. And it's only as you get closer that you
distinguish the Virgin Mary from the angels behind her. And you kind of feel that this is, because of
course, the notion is that her child is the child of heaven. And there's a real sense that
he's there floating in a heavenly realm. And that feels very powerful. And he's, the child is
in a way, is in similar clothes to the King's patron saint, John the Baptist. So in, I mean, I
just think colour wise, you see the balance between simplicity and gorgeousness all in the same place.
Yes. But the blue would really have been seen as a very, you know, even though it's not austere,
it would have been seen as very holy for the Virgin Mary, wouldn't it? And how does this
relationship between the expense of ultramarine and the holiness of the Virgin Mary, how does that
sort of all tie together? Why do we, I guess, think of the Virgin Mary in blue? Because she's
not described in blue in the Bible. She's not. In Catholicism, in particular, there was,
as opposed to, I think, in orthodoxy, there's a wider variety of colours in which the Virgin
is wearing. But in this tradition, there is a sense that you dress your most holy of,
she was human after all, you dress your most holy of people in the most precious of clothes. One,
to be a visual signal that she is the most precious, but also to be a way of saying,
we think of you, Virgin Mary, Our Lady, as the most precious of all. So we want to give to you
the thing that we give to the most precious Queen, because there's a sort of sense of the Virgin
Mary as having been crowned. The coronation of the Virgin is one of the kinds of paintings that
you have in the gallery. That moment where she goes from being a human woman to the Queen of
Heaven. The Queen of Heaven. Yes. And maybe actually, I just, you know, remembered that
Christ is, he is in golden robes. It's almost astonishing that when you look at this painting,
it is the blue that stands out almost above the gold, which would have been,
and obviously continues to be extremely, extremely precious. So we've sort of covered
that ultramarine comes from La Pizla's life from the Afghan mines. And that is where it
comes into Renaissance Europe from. And also these were set to be held against gold. So that was,
you know, seeing them in churches mostly, or in private devotion, often in the evening by
candlelight. So you've got a real sense of shimmer there that we can't, I mean,
sadly, in the National Gallery, you can't show us real candles, which obviously would be heavenly
to see. But we can't see it like that. So we just have to imagine what it's like when the light
doesn't hold, when the light moves around. But in such a piece as this, you can really imagine
everything moving around. Yeah. So the gold is almost animate in the way that the light
would have interacted with it. Absolutely. So the ultramarine has come from beyond the sea,
beyond the seas, across those East to West trade routes. And that's one reason I am assuming that
it was so expensive. But also it was a very laborious process, wasn't it, to actually end up
with this magnificent blue paint from this magnificent blue rock. Could you tell us a bit
about that? I mean, it was crazy how to do it. They hadn't really guessed it. I mean, I'm not going to
read you this from... So I've got here, I have got here the holiest of holy books, the book about,
by Cianino Cianini, about how to make these paintings. And he's advising, it's as if he's
advising a young artist who's starting off, and he's saying, I advise you to start off with a
nine-inch by nine-inch boxwood board and you start off by doing this. And this is how
you start off as an artist. He was also writing it from his experience learning from masters. So
we're talking about in Italy, in kind of Tuscany, in that kind of area where everything,
in terms of Renaissance art, something extraordinary is happening. But he writes about how to make this
pigment. And it is just bizarre. I mean, so unlike some stones, this one has got all sorts of stuff.
It's got sodalite, and I don't even know how to pronounce them, nozian, and hyene, and
lazurite. It's got all sorts of stuff happening. Some of it has got more sulphur than others.
Some of it has got less. So that changes the colour of it. Oddly, if it's got sulphur in it,
then it's going to be one of the most extraordinary bright colours that were so expensive.
But what you'd need to do is you'd need to grind it down. Then you would mix it with alkali and
lye and all sorts of other things like waxes and gums and mastic. And you're doing it and
mashing it and doing it and mashing it. And he says, just keep on coming back, you know, for
an hour a day, for days. So this is apprentices, right? This is not the artist. This is a young
apprentice has to do this again and again. And then you've got something a bit like dough,
which you're rubbing and rubbing.
So this has all come together now, all of these materials as it's been beaten up.
And it's translated in here as a plastic, but I don't quite know. I mean,
the translator didn't quite know what that meant. But sort of, I imagined it as a kind of dough.
Yes.
It's been described elsewhere as that kind of thing. And you're just mashing it and mashing
it. And then you're letting the top powder come off. And then that's the first grade.
And then you do it all again. And the next grade.
So the highest quality comes out first?
It does. And then the next grade and the next grade and the next grade until what you've got
is quite a grey grade, which is not bad. So some different grades had different points.
So they did have their uses.
And they were cheaper, which is also quite useful. If you're an impoverished artist,
you can use a little bit of it more cheaply.
But what would happen if you just crushed up the whole rock and sort of use that?
Great. It would be great because you wouldn't have sorted out all the other things out of it.
The ordinary bit of the stone in Afghanistan was called rangi ob, which is the colour of water.
And then there's another one which you can sort of half see if you look really closely
in the loud shimmer, which has got sort of little bits of green, little tiny bits of green.
And then you've got rangi sopa, which was described to me rather oddly, I thought,
as red feather. But a minor, I said to one of the miners, and I said,
what does that mean, red feather in this blue stone? And he said, oh, you know, in a candle,
you look at the colour of the candle, of the flame, and the middle bit is blue.
That is the red feather of the flame.
Oh, OK.
So to get the red feather.
So maybe colour terms are kind of being used in a kind of different way to leeward,
but that's very beautiful. Red feather. I love that.
So they, the artists who, I mean, this was expensive stuff. And also it took hours,
days of work and grinding and pummeling and dough making and everything needed to be done
in great detail and with great patience, which I think patience has its cost as well, doesn't it?
It does indeed.
So how would artists in the Renaissance in Europe have obtained the natural
German pigment? Would it have, was there one place that it came into?
It came into Venice. Venice was the real centre. I mean, it came from Afghanistan down different
routes, but I mean, quite a lot of it would have been by ship because it's heavy, donkey at first,
and then by river and then by ship and then by rivers again to get to Venice.
And that was the centre for all, for really the artistic movements in Europe in that from there,
if they were exotic, exotic colours from elsewhere, then they would go from Venice and
they would be bought and distributed to Britain, to Germany, to Spain.
Amazing. Okay.
And obviously each time gathering just that edge of margin. So it was more and more expensive as
it moved away.
More expensive as you go. Okay. We get to a Venetian artist later so we can
look at his access to colours. But first, we're going to go back to one of the paintings that
you mentioned was your inspiration to go to Afghanistan. And it's by Michelangelo,
the entombment Christ being carried to his tomb, painted about 1500 to 1501. And
this painting we see in the centre, a kind of limp and naked Christ being carried by a man
behind him. And another man with long hair wearing vibrant red clothes. And there's a woman kneeling
to the man's left and another two women standing on their right. And large sections of this work
are unfinished and left blank. So there's quite an obviously empty space on the
bottom right hand side of the painting. And this is where this connects into Ultramarine, isn't it?
I mean, it's a really puzzling picture. It's puzzled experts for a long time. And I remember
it was kind of coincidence that I came across it just at exactly the point at which I was thinking,
can I really write a book about colours? Is that something that people would be interested in? And
can I do it? And what can I find? And I came, I was living in Hong Kong, but I came to the National
Gallery to think, well, this must be a place if I can find stories, then I will find it here.
And I found myself in that gallery and I stopped. And it was almost nothing to do with my colour
search at the time. And I thought, what on earth is happening? It's the most bizarre. I mean,
it's bizarre because John, the beloved disciple, looks actually quite female in the orange.
Orangey red robes.
Red robes.
Yeah, I guess, yeah, traditionally.
And that is because of the discolouration of the vermilion that makes it look as if some of the
lines are his quite feminised body. So it was kind of, so that was bizarre. And then Christ was kind
of, he's kind of propped up and he was kind of floating. And I thought that is bizarre because
usually often an entombment, the crucified Christ is being carried by his friends and his family
to the tomb that Joseph of Arimathea has given him. And he's being carried. And what's he doing?
I mean, it's obviously not a finished picture, but he's floating. What's that about? And what
on earth is the human-sized gap in the bottom? And I was standing there thinking, this is bizarre.
When one of your 25 years ago, docents or lecturers came by with a small group and said,
you might be wondering what this painting is all about. And I thought,
I'm going to listen into this one. So I kind of snuck in.
And she explained about John and the strange colouring of the vermilion red paint. That was
interesting. The Christ is sacrament. So the sense of the bread and being holy and rising
was being shown by the floating Christ. And then we came to the hole in the right hand,
lower right hand. And it kind of, the figure who is not, there's nothing happening in this bit of
canvas at all. It's kind of empty, which is so strange. But it clearly could be a kneeling
person, a kneeling woman. And the explanation was that it was the Virgin Mary, the mother of Christ,
kneeling and wailing and weeping at the death of her son. And because she's painted in blue.
Traditionally at the time.
Traditionally in time, in that time. The paint maybe hadn't arrived from the
patron because it was so expensive that the artist would not have been able to afford to
just have it in stock and reach for the, obviously they weren't tubes at the time, but reach for the
pigment and then start to use it. He would have had to have waited for that and any gold that
might have been wanted to be used in any painting. Those would have arrived from the patron and they
clearly hadn't come. And then he went off to do some other work and he never came back to this one.
And it was often actually written into artist contracts, wasn't it at the time? It was so
precious, as we've said, worth more than gold.
And any patron would say, you know, it's not just that I want this painted. I want there to be used,
at least I'm going to invent this amount, at least five ounces of blue on the dress or at
least a pound of blue on the dress. And this is what I want to be there. And I want this much of
gold. So that's got to be in the contract because you don't want to be shortchanging
a good patron.
You don't want to be scrimping on the amount of ultramarine or them using a lesser blue.
But also you don't want to be splashing out on incredibly expensive, I mean, financially
crippling. What if the patron doesn't like it and doesn't want to pay for it? Then at least you've
the big expenses up front paid by the patron. So you're not going to be out of pocket that much,
as not as much as you would have been.
Okay, this feels like a good point to take a break. I've really enjoyed looking at these
paintings with you. We will look at another example of the Virgin Mary in our collection
after the break, who's also painted in ultramarine. And we will get to that Venetian artist
that I mentioned as well. See you after the break.
So welcome back from the break. We have looked at just why ultramarine has been more precious
than gold, why it was so difficult to make the beautiful blue pigment that has been
in so many amazing Renaissance paintings and beyond. And now we're going to have a quick
look at another painting in our collection, a slightly later painting of the Virgin Mary,
just as another beautiful example of how ultramarine blue has been used in her robes.
So this is by Sasso Ferrato from the middle of the 17th century. It's called The Virgin in Prayer.
And she is dressed in ultramarine, or sometimes called Marian blue, because of this association
with the Virgin Mary. She's praying in this very beautiful portrait of her. She looks very pious
and pensive, looking down very respectfully with her hands, touching at their fingertips in prayer
in a moment of private devotion. She's very strongly lit with strong contrasts and shadows in
her robes, very flawless, pale skin with a very dark background that she's contrasted against.
And she's dressed with swathes of white, red and this striking brilliant blue, which is of course
ultramarine. It is. And by that time, I mean, it was so entrenched that she should be wearing blue.
There was a story in France that when mothers took, parents took their sick children to the
to ask for her help in restoring their health. There was a promise that sometimes parents would
make that if she made them better, then they would dress them entirely in blue.
Children vowed in blue. And when I look at that, I just think of some of the children
in little tiny blue outfits as gratitude that something worked and that they are healthy.
That's so lovely. That's a lovely story, isn't it? Now we will head to that elusive Venetian that
we mentioned earlier, the city of colour, the city where all of these amazing pigments from
far away arrived into the seafaring port town, municipality area of Venice at the time.
And we're going to look at Titian's back as an area. Now, if you're familiar with our collection,
this probably is one of the most famous examples of ultramarine. But if you're not, we will describe
this painting for you so that you can imagine it. It's, as the name suggests, a mythological painting,
a mythological scene with quite a tumult of different figures, most of whom are not very
clothed. But in the centre, we have our leading man, the god Bacchus, who's sort of leaping from
a chariot that's being led by two cheetahs. And then he's followed by this group of rowdy followers,
which are nymphs and satyrs, and there's some trees behind. And he is sort of leaping with a
flowing red cape behind him, or maybe robes that have been untucked and unfurled towards
a young woman in the bottom left hand corner of the painting. His gaze is fixed on her,
she is Ariadne, whose arm is flung out to the sea behind her, where the ship of Theseus is.
And he has abandoned her here. Ariadne wears vibrant blue robes, and the whole scene
takes place beneath a stunning blue sky, which is where the ultramarine comes in.
And there's a constellation of stars above Ariadne's head. So let's talk about this
beautiful painting and how Titian is using natural ultramarine.
Before Ariadne, she's had the most awful time. There she is. She helped Theseus work his way
through the labyrinth, not get eaten by the minotaur. He takes her with him as he escapes,
and they land on an island. And when she wakes up, there he is in the distance, his ship
disappearing to goodness knows where, leaving her alone, abandoned and without everything.
So that's kind of what's happening in this story. But in this myth, along comes Bacchus,
dancing, beautiful young man. And he says, I will give you the seven stars.
I will give you everything. So she is kind of half looking at Theseus, who is the past,
and half looking at Bacchus, who's very much the present. And all through this painting,
there is ultramarine blue. And the ultramarine blue is extraordinarily vibrant. I mean,
it is like jewels. And actually, the other colours are like jewels as well. The vermilion,
the crimson, the reds, they're all kind of shimmery when you see them in the actual gallery.
It is something to behold. And there is the sea as well, which is chitlamarine, the nearby sea,
which is azurite. So another pigment, a less expensive, but also a contrasting one. So this
is a jewel box of a painting. And it made me really amused to hear something that I think
was controversial for your gallery. But when the conservators in 1968 showed this painting,
which had been quite dulled down by time and varnish, and it was put on view, lots of people
loved it. I'm sure had I been grown up at that time, I would have loved it too. But some people
who were used to the browns and the subdued quality of what they'd seen before, were sure
that Titian would not have had such bad taste as to have such bright colours. And it is really
exciting. I promise you the sky and the stars, I promise you. And so in a way, it's not just
a really good colour. It's also about promises and future. And this isn't a sacred painting in
that usual sense. But it is a sacred painting in terms of how we can be in this world and how
there's hope and future. And that's, in a way, amazingly, what the ultramarine seems to symbolise.
And you've pointed out something obvious, which is that this is not a sacred painting, but actually
talking of shocking things, that was quite shocking in Titian's time to be painting a
secular, although obviously mythologically religious, I guess, in theme, but you know,
not Christian. It's not a Christian painting. Quite shocking for so much of this precious,
precious, precious ultramarine blue to be used for this topic of painting. And it does mark a real
shift where we start to see this amazing blue pigment being used, you know, not just in the
Virgin Mary. I mean, Titian was known for his colouring. There was a whole debate going on about
drawing versus colouring, disegno, colore, and those two things, which is the more important?
And Titian was criticised by the great biographer Vasari for actually not being that good at
drawing. He really concentrated on, yeah, so it's really about, do you plan, or do you go for more
spontaneity? And he planned less and went for more immediate colour impact. And you can, I don't know,
this is one of my favourite paintings in the gallery, because it really, it shows a whole
art history and it's beautiful. Amazing. So we are going to skip forward in time to when actually
natural ultramarine stops being used on artists' palettes. Can you tell us why that is? It was so
expensive. I mean, the price was beyond anything. And if artists wanted to use it, and there was
quite a lot of requirement for ultramarine, for a very good, I mean, there were other blues, but
they tended to be more greeny. Like the azurite. Like the azurite, and less bright. And there was
a kind of competition for how are we going to be painters in this new century, which was the 19th
century. And the whole, I mean, there had been massive Napoleonic wars in France and with
neighbours. So France was kind of in this idea of going into the new century in a new way.
And they wanted to lead the certain technical improvements. And so they offered a huge 6,000
francs prize to anybody who could produce a kind of ultramarine, scientific chemical ultramarine,
for I believe it was a tenth of the price of this Afghanistan ultramarine. And it took a few years.
But kind of bizarrely, a French chemist and a German chemist both came up with the idea at the
same time. So they duked it out for a little bit. And I don't know whether it was connected with the
French award or not. But anyway, the French won, the French team won the prize. And from then on,
it's been called French ultramarine. Or synthetic ultramarine. Or synthetic ultramarine. Yeah.
And you can see synthetic. But French ultramarine is a kind of better title.
Well, it's nicer. If you're selling it on a paint tube.
Much better for country branding. So yeah, if you want to see synthetic ultramarine, which
really is, I mean, chemically, it's the same as natural ultramarine. So looks just as beautiful
in paintings. And you can see it in works in the gallery by artists like Renoir in his umbrellas,
Monet in irises, and Cezanne in Hillside in Provence. So they're synthetic pigments.
And they were really looking at how shadows can be blues and violets and yellows.
Yes.
So they needed these colours very much.
The Impressionists did, yeah, for their shadows.
Yes, absolutely. Have a look at the shadows in those paintings. That's a good tip.
So we're coming to the end of our episode on ultramarine, but we will answer a question from
the audience before we close, which is what did writers themselves say about the colour
blue and its significance? And perhaps we look particularly at medieval writers.
Well, looking slightly later at 1508, Albrecht Dürer, Renaissance-based, and he wrote from
Nuremberg, and he wrote in fury, because he said, why can't I get hold of this pigment?
It's so expensive. It was at the time, 100 florins for a pound of it. And that was beyond
his ability to use it as a paint, which he really wanted. So they were upset that they
couldn't get their materials. I mean, I think that one always wants to get the best materials
for the best thing that you can do. And this was beyond them. And why was it? Why was it
so expensive that only the wealthiest patrons could have it?
And it is because it, as we opened with, with the Giannina Giannini quote,
was the most illustrious, beautiful and most perfect of all of the colours. And there was
none other that's quality would surpass it. But also, if it hadn't been that expensive,
maybe it wouldn't have been seen as such an absolutely brilliant colour for all the
most expensive, precious things. Who knows? So we have come to the end of our episode on
Ultramarine. We've gone beyond the sea to discover this most precious pigment. So if
you have enjoyed this conversation and want to discover more stories about how colour has
shaped human history, please do subscribe to this podcast, Stories in Colour on your
podcast platform of choice or on our YouTube channel. And please do leave us a rating and
review there too. We would really appreciate that. You can also discover more about the
science of colour and how art materials are made on our YouTube channel, National Gallery's
YouTube channel. There is a video on Ultramarine, which looks in more detail at exactly how natural
Ultramarine is used in the Wilton diptych and how synthetic Ultramarine is used in Renoir's
umbrellas. So do go and look for that video on our YouTube channel. If you've got more questions
about the story of colour, you can email us on podcast at nationalgallery.org.uk,
or you can send us our questions on our social media channels, just mention podcast. So thank
you ever so much for joining us for today's episode of Story in Colour, with huge thanks
again to our returning guest, Victoria Finlay. Thank you so much. I've been your host, Bex Leary,
our producer was Harry Rosehill, our researcher was Hannah Rogers, our scientific advisor was Joanna
Russell, our technicians were Ian Warren and Tom Gulliver, our video editor was Jeanne Kenyon.
Thank you ever so much for listening. We'll see you next time.
