Pink is for girls blue is for boys Stories in Colour Podcast S2 Ep8 National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 14, 2026
Have you ever wondered whether pink really is for girls and blue for boys? In our final episode of series two, Beks is joined by Dr Vien Cheung, Associate Professor at the University of Leeds, and National Gallery Educator Ed Dickenson to explore the surprising, gendered history of pink and blue. …
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis podcast episode from the National Gallery in London examines the science, history, and cultural evolution of pink and blue. It explores how these colors transitioned from spiritual and gender-neutral symbols in classical art to rigid gender markers in modern society, driven by industrialization, mass marketing, and psychological theories.
Two weeks ago I saw Cameron Diaz at Fred Segal and I talked her out of buying this truly
heinous Angora sweater. Whoever said orange is the new pink was seriously disturbed. That's
a quote from Elwoods in the 2002 film Legally Blonde.
Welcome to Stories in Colour, a podcast from the National Gallery in London,
searching for histories of how colour as a technology and in art has changed the world
we live in. Pink is for girls and blue is for boys, right? For anyone who's seen a recent gender
reveal video, you'd think this was true, even if we are trying to be a bit more egalitarian about
gendered colour associations. But this idea that pink is for girls and blue is for boys
is actually surprisingly a recent one. We'll get into it in the rest of this episode. I'm
Bex Leary from the Digital Department here at the National Gallery and today I'm joined by
two guests Dobservian Chung and Ed Dickinson. Ben is an academic at the University of Leeds
with a research interest in colour from all angles, from science and technology to psychology
and philosophy and to art and design. Ed is an educator here at the National Gallery and started
his teaching career 20 years ago in Japan before spending many years as a primary school teacher
in London. He's since worked on the learning teams of a number of museums and galleries,
including the Horniman, Historic Royal Palaces and the Ben Uri Gallery. And he's been an educator
here since 2017, helping audiences of all ages and experiences engage with our paintings
and the National Gallery itself. Most of his time is spent explaining why there are so many
naked people on our walls. Ben, welcome. Ed, big welcome. Bien, thank you so much for joining us
today. Thank you for having us. Thank you. So, as I said, before we dive into that big question
that we're trying to answer today around whether pink is really for girls and blue is really for
boys, let's get to know these two colours a little bit more. So, Bien, what makes blue and pink
different in terms of their colour properties? Well, actually, to me, they are two colour names
in some way that they're not really different. So, first, maybe we can think about that. What
is colour? So, colour is a perception, but it has three dimensions in terms of its property.
So, it has the hue dimension, which is predominantly about the colour name that we've
been using, for example, blue, green, red, and then it's reflecting the dominant wavelength
that we are able to observe. And then it has the lightness or brightness property
that's mainly describing whether a colour is light or dark. And it also has another dimension,
which is the saturation, or sometimes we call it vividness, or sometimes more technically,
we call it chroma. That is more about whether the colour is very strong or quite weak, like pastel
colours. And so, come back to your questions, that means that to me that it is not really
anything different. But mostly, I think people differentiate these two terms for blue
with the hue in blue, that it is referring to something maybe medium in terms of lightness
and also in terms of saturation strength. But for pink, probably we will be imagining something is
quite light, and then relatively weaker in terms of saturation. So, that will be my interpretation
of that. Would it also be true to say that pink is kind of a better branded light red?
Yes, it could be. I guess there's some of the cultures that doesn't have
all the colour names that we have in English. So, sometimes that pink will be referred to as
light red, as you say. So, that is quite true. And then we can also think about that in terms
of like artists, that when they are trying to create the colour pink, then quite likely they
will be using a mixture of red and the white pigments of that. Okay, so how do we actually
see pink? And how does that work with the wavelengths of light?
We can see colours out of the visible spectrum. So, broadly speaking, in a very simple way to
think about it, this is something like from the red end to the bluish-purpleish end,
that is basically the range of colours that we will be able to observe. And obviously,
other species that they may see different range of colours, for example, like bees,
that they can see very distinctive patterns on flowers. That's because they can be able to detect
light more in the UV, like ultraviolet region. So, they see in some way, they see more.
So, that's an advantage. Yeah, it's cool. So, for all the colours, including pink,
that it is more in terms of like the reflection of certain wavelengths are more dominant. So,
for pink colours that you can imagine it will be the reddish end and also the purplish end,
that it's more dominant. And then the rest of the spectrum that has less reflection.
Fantastic. If you listening want to dive in a bit more about how we see colour,
the very first episode of series one really digs into the kind of mechanics of how we see colour.
So, you can listen back to that episode. Thinking about artists, Ed, how do artists typically make
pink paint for their palettes? Well, it's really interesting,
Vienna was saying both of us are thinking about pink as is it sort of on the spectrum from red?
Is it sort of a relation of red? Because certainly from painting rather than sort of a pink pigment
coming in its own, you're looking at tempering a red pigment, you're taking the reds, which are,
you know, ancient red pigments like red ochre, which you get from hematite, you get an iron oxide,
vermilion, which you get from cinnabar, which is a bit more orangey. Red lakes are very common,
particularly when we get to looking at our collection from sort of Renaissance onwards.
And that's those are organic pigments. So, you're getting those from plants, you're getting them
from insects and things like that. You'll get the Kermes Lake, which is an insect largely used
around Mediterranean. And then when Europeans went over to the Americas, they started bringing
back huge quantities of cochineal, which is the most amazing red. I mean, you know, I've heard
people say, you know, if you sort of crush cochineal, it looks like you cut your hand because
it's so bright. Reds have obviously got those sort of links to blood and life and all of this sort of
stuff. So, you're getting those and then they will be mixed with, you know, small amounts of white,
which you'll get either from chalk, from sort of limestones or, you know, maybe lead whites,
horrendously poisonous, but, you know, extremely strong whites. It'd be later on that you'd see,
you know, your zinc whites and your titanium whites and things like that.
I always like to give a disclaimer when we talk about toxic pigments,
that there is no risk to the public with seeing any old paintings in a gallery.
Absolutely.
Don't worry at all.
Yes, absolutely. Looking at them, absolutely fine. But yes, in that making process,
it can be potentially dangerous. But, and then more modern, you know, as we start getting into
the era of synthetic pigments, that's when you can start seeing, you know, something sort of
particularly made to be pink. You know, you'll have the 1800s and they'll start finding like
the aniline dyes and things like that, sort of coal tar products and all these sort of offshoots
of the Industrial Revolution that would create these synthetic colours. So generally before that
you are seeing it's red mixed with a bit of white. And it depends what kind of red you want to be
using, you know, you'll get earthier colours and things like that. But I mean, a question here for
any painters listening, you know, is it white that you're adding red to? Or is it red that you're
adding white to? It's just like how that's going to work. But I think generally we'll see pink as
it's sort of, yeah. And as Vienne was saying, you know, is it lighter? Or it's interesting when we
talk about maybe words like weaker, which obviously have certain connotations in language,
version of red. But yeah, it's red with a bit of white, I think is the short answer.
Thank you very much. Vienne, you've talked a little bit about kind of colour categories
and naming of colours. How does pink get its name? Well, the word, the colour name of pink
that is not coming until around 17th century actually. So actually quite recent in broad
historical terms. Yeah, indeed, indeed. Yeah. So it started with, that has been generated from
trying to name after the flower, carnation, actually. And then, so before that, before 17th
century, most of the literature probably will be referring to this particular colour, this kind of
shade or tint, that roches, which is a Latin adjective that's describing rosy. So something
bright, red, and then fresh. So it has actually, from the beginning, has a lot of connection with
something quite natural, actually, for this particular colour name. Yeah, both flowers,
I guess. Roches, does that connect through to roses? Yes, yes. And also then extending to that
will be blossom, something bright, and then maybe even like something described in nature,
like the perception of dawn as well. So that is a lot of like natural elements that are carrying
by this name. And I think people might generally not know that there is a carnation, a flower
called a pink, but we do have some examples in our collection, don't we, Ed? Do you want to…
Good old Dianthus, absolutely. …describe a few of those paintings?
Well, absolutely. Yeah, we've got some, you know, to have a little look at as well. So,
I mean, it's interesting, isn't it, pink? I heard that pink was, it was kind of a verb
before a colour. There was like, to pink was to puncture or to prick.
You can get pinking shears, can't you? And now pinking shears are seen very much
as sort of like the crinkled, which are like the edge of the Dianthus, edge of a carnation.
For people who don't know, pinking shears are like, they're like scissors, but they're
like zigzaggy. Yes, absolutely. So yes, and you get that sort of wonderful sort of crinkled,
ruffled edge. Yeah, like the feathered edge of the flowers.
Absolutely. So yeah, I mean, we have, and it's interesting, if you type pink into the National
Gallery search bar in the website, you know, a couple of paintings will pop up and they will be,
you know, a man with a pink and the Madonna of the pinks.
And usually sort of paintings that don't really strike you as very pink, obviously.
No, exactly. Because it's about the flower.
Exactly, there's a tiny little bit of pink. I mean, there's a little bit more in the Raphael,
but you know, in the Andrea Solario, the man with a pink, you know, we are looking at the
man with an absolutely phenomenal jaw, looking out at us with one hand on a sort of black sash
going across this astonishing sort of red tunic. And then in his, on his left hand, he's got a
very visible ring on his thumb. And then in his right hand, he is holding this pink, it's very
small, dianthus, it's carnation. And the connotations of the pink there are that it is
very much like a wedding flower. It's a symbol of love. And there would be a tradition, particularly
in the Renaissance, of brides wearing a pink carnation in their bridal clothing. And so him
holding that is this sort of sense of, you know, is this a man, you know, who's recently married,
maybe with the ring? And he's showing that off. Interestingly, the stronger, the red,
the red he's wearing of this tunic is a sign of his office, because he's Venetian. And if you're
wearing red, you could only wear that red if you are a member of the council. So he's got his
uniform. So the pink here, yes, so the red here is sort of his status. And the pink, this flower
is very much this sort of sign of love. And then again, you get this idea with Raphael's Virgin and
Child. So its nickname is the Madonna and the pinks. And it's this lovely, very small little
painting of the Madonna of Mary with Christ, the baby Jesus sitting on a white pillow on her lap.
And interestingly, she's got a wonderful sort of blue skirt on. Christ is holding this little
bunch of pinks. And then behind his back, she's sort of holding his hand with her right hand,
and then behind Christ's back, she's sort of cradling him. And she has a little bunch of
pinks as well. So it's like they're exchanging them. And again, it's this idea of the pink being
this exchange of love. So there isn't really a lot of pink in that picture. But, you know,
look at their cheeks. And this is very Raphael as well. It's just there's this amazing pink pigment
in the cheeks. And it comes back to this idea, as Bien was saying, you know,
is pink sort of derived as well from rose and rosy. Rose is this connotation of health.
Rosy cheeks, yes.
Rosy cheeks, absolutely. And yes, so sort of healthy and happy and full of life
while they exchange this gift of love.
And Giannino Ciannini mentions using pink for undertones in his 14th century work, doesn't he?
I guess that might link through to Raphael's use of pink here for the flesh tones,
picking up that that was quite a typical way of working.
Yeah, because we see a lot of green as well. You know, I think a lot of people,
a lot of people looking at National Gallery paintings may go, everyone looks a bit ill.
Generally, because the oil paint or sometimes the older tempera paint is degraded to a point where
light is passing through and reflecting what's underneath. And the underneath would be, you know,
for white skin, quite often they'd use a green. But yeah, you'll start to see Ciannini kind of,
you know, he's the guy who writes the book on sort of artists. These are the things you can
use. And a lot of people use that and he's like, you know, bring out the warmth with pinks and skin.
Lovely. Let's take a step back to think about some of the different
cultural associations with pink. We talked a little bit about flowers and health,
but are there other associations? I guess this is all quite culturally relative, but yeah,
what are some of the cultural associations with pink?
Yeah, I think that it's a lot of symbolism that with pink that refer to love, actually.
So if we look around like campaigns, for example, the LGBTQ plus, then their flag
is particularly has a pink element in there representing the diversity and inclusion.
And also that if we look a bit further, like in Asia, for example, in Singapore,
they had a campaign more than 10 years ago called Pink Dot. And it's particularly about
inclusion of trans people. And so particularly they are picking pink that is more like trying
to be like illustrating the love and the inclusion in that. So I think there's
a lot of elements with pink that is associated with that.
I guess we'd associate it with Valentine's Day as well with love.
You know, if you imagine a rack of cards in a shop for Valentine's Day,
that's going to be a suite of pink and red, isn't it?
Yeah, I don't have a lot of options.
Do you have any of your own cultural associations with pink?
It's so interesting, isn't it? This idea of sort of inclusion,
and we've used a lot of words like softer, or, you know, I mean, better used in sort of
scientific terms, we use terms like weaker, you know, cultural terms that has a completely
different connotation we should be careful of. But it is there's this sort of idea,
isn't there a sort of softness and even looking at these Renaissance paintings,
the idea of a pink being a symbol of love, of rosiness of health, sort of happiness,
abundance, there are those sorts of things. And is it, does it need to be sort of softened
this red, you know, from the stronger, vibrant to make it maybe, you know, I hate to use words
like gentle, but it's a tricky one. It is a tricky one. And then of course, you know,
we're speaking in, you know, the 21st century. So there's all this culture, it's just like,
how much of this is a product of our upbringing and our cultural upbringing,
and how much has changed. But at the moment, yes, pink is very much, it's got that connotation of
love of inclusion. And then there are gendered associations as well. But yeah, it's a tricky one.
We will indeed have a look at that later. Now is a good time for us to take a quick
break. So we've looked and introduced pink and blue. But after the break, we will get into
the question that I asked at the first about whether pink is really for girls.
We'll see after the break. Welcome back from the break. So let's ask the question,
is pink really for girls? And is blue really for boys? And what's the history there?
For this statement, I think it is relatively a modern norm. Because until 18th century,
there isn't really a particular like dominance of like boys or girls who wear which colour.
It's quite equally in terms of clothing that they are like using just for that.
But then moving on to 19th century, that particularly in the US, that there's a still
starting to have a trend that for menswear, it becomes having quite a lot of dark colours,
like the blacks, the greys, and then like dark blue navies, things like that. And that is trying
to impose a particular image that is like, they're serious. Whether we think that is or not,
then this is another question. But that is how that at that time, there is trying to be
like pushing through this particular image that have a seriousness of that using darker colour,
particularly for menswear. And then moving on to 20th century, there's a lot of post-war
advertisement, particularly in the United States. And then you may have heard of like a term called
white collar, blue collar, and then pink collar. Yeah. So white collar refers to at the time that
the people, usually they are office workers. So they describe it that they will have a desktop
work that they go to office and then they may be nine to five, that is their working hours.
And then blue collar refers to those that have jobs that they are quite labour intensive,
maybe people repairing the roads and then the engineers. And at that time, in terms of textile
technology, then denim has been a very, very good material for those jobs. So it's very sturdy,
and then very durable and heavy duty material, basically. So that comes with the blue collar
terminology for that, for those jobs. And then extending to that, there's the pink collar,
which is basically describing jobs that primarily that will be taken up by females,
for example, nurses, school teacher, kindergarten teachers, and then maybe house workers,
things like that. So then that becomes in terms of like a society categorisation,
using colour to represent that. So that probably in a way that I would say that is kind of like a
starting point that using colour to kind of signal particular type of identity, whether it is job or
actually gender. So that's my understanding, I think. And that's a very interesting one.
That's so interesting. I do wonder how much of that as well, you know, would be a post-war,
because obviously a lot of people wearing military fatigues during war, certain uniforms,
and so many women going into roles particularly reserved for men during the war. And then after
the war, there's a lot of push of women, they need to return to the home and let the men go back,
you know, all this sort of stuff. And I wonder if there's an element as well of it being culturally
reinforced to try and define gender boundaries unfairly.
There was some research, wasn't there, in 1918, so just over 100 years ago,
which suggested that pink was for a boy and blue was for a girl. And the reasons were because pink
was regarded as a strong colour, whereas blue is more delicate, so that this is an American
trade publication that says, the generally accepted rule is pink for the boys and blue for the girls.
The reason is that pink being a more decided and stronger colour is more suitable for the boy,
while blue, which is more delicate and dainty is prettier for the girl. And I just find that
absolutely fascinating that we just think that these things are true, that we have this perception
that pink is a girly colour. And yeah, even 100 years ago, you know, not least going back to the
18th century, as you were alluding to at the start of your answer to the question. Yeah,
people were thinking so, so differently. We have a question from our audience, which relates to
this, which Ed, I think you might be able to help us with. So this is one of our listeners on
YouTube. Thank you for your question. I once visited an exhibition in Glasgow about dress
colours throughout the ages and was fascinated by the idea that boys used to wear pink as it
was perceived as a softer version of red, which was suitable for men being masculine and warlike.
I would love to know if this was reflected in the art of the time. So we've got a Veronese
painting, haven't we, that we can look at from the mid-16th century. So that's Paolo Veronese,
and it's the family of Darius before Alexander. So perhaps you could describe this for us.
Yeah, it's such a tricky, I love that trade publication about the, you know, the pink and
the blue. You see that so often coming up as the thing. And we could talk a little bit more about
sort of whether the trade publication sort of represents general views of the time or
maybe people trying to sell things. But yeah, you certainly see this idea of blue being seen
as slightly more, I don't know if passive is the right word, but there's a serenity to it. There's
calmness that is generally seen, which is why, and we'll talk more about it in a bit, but yeah,
the idea that the Virgin Mary tends to wear blue. But if we're looking at this scene, a huge,
huge painting, it's four metres across, almost five metres across by, over two metres high.
And you have got this sort of exterior scene in a courtyard with these all sorts of people milling
about, but these two really distinct groups of people. One on the right is standing,
one on the left is kneeling, and they're both looking at each other. The one on the right
are all male and wearing armour and carrying weapons. And the one on the left are all female.
Apart from there is a man sort of who's standing above them, sort of gesturing, sort of like a
chaperone bringing them in. But generally this group of women and girls are all kneeling,
looking up at these men. And if you look at the women, there are, you know, there's a really great
range of colours. The woman at the front, who's a really important figure in this,
is wearing this amazing deep blue, which I believe in this case would have come from
ultramarine, the extremely expensive pigment that would have come from crushed lapis lazuli.
She's at the front and behind her, to her left, we've got a younger woman in yellow. Again,
a very sort of a regal colour here. And then we have these two sort of younger and smaller
princesses, what they look like, wearing quite light pink dresses and then these slightly more
lighter pastely blue dresses, robes over the top. And then you compare this with the men on the
right and you have just amazing colour blocking. You've got bright oranges, bright greens, and
they're right at the front as sort of their leader and wearing a different kind of armour,
is this man stepping forward and sort of gesticulating with one hand and wearing this
amazing pinkish red sort of piece of armour. He looks like this sort of fancy dress Roman
general. It's all weird and anachronistic and it's difficult to know exactly what time. It's
all a bit fancy dress, a lot of this. Who is this? This guy, this guy stepping forward is none other
than Alexander the Great. And here he is sort of calming these women in front of him because they
are the family of the defeated King Darius or Darius III, the King of Persia. And they know
exactly what awaits them as the defeated family, but Alexander is showing them clemency. He's going,
it's okay. Don't worry. You're going to be okay. Especially seeing as the woman at the front has
got completely the wrong guy, thinking she's talking to Alexander and has got the wrong guy.
He goes, okay, it's okay. He is described as wearing, in our catalogue, is crimson.
You know, is it red? Is it pink? Is this idea of, you know, do we really have a word for pink when
Veronese is painting this in the late 1500s or mid to late 1500s? But it is, you look at it and
it's unmistakably pinkish, I think to us today, because there were other reds in the picture.
You know, you can see his cape at the back and it's much darker red. And there's some little
sort of boys, maybe little pages around her wearing these wonderful reds. But the way the
light is catching this crimson, or it looks quite pink, but he's unmistakably Mr. Power,
you know, very masculine, very dominant and very much in charge. But also going back to this idea
of maybe gentleness and he's sort of welcoming them and going, no, it's okay. He's calming
this terrified family and going, no, it's one of these things, it's a sign,
what a good leader should do. You know, they're strong, but then they offer leniency.
So this is an example of a powerful man dressed in pink or red. You touched on the Virgin Mary
and that association with blue. What's that all about? We have looked at it more in our
Ultramarine episode, but it would be good to kind of touch on that here.
Exactly. I mean, it is the big colour. If you look at any colour association in the National Gallery,
the number one will be blue for the Virgin. And she usually wears red or pink with it. But I'd
ask a lot of people to have a little look at images of the Virgin on our website and decide
what they think is, is it pink with a lot of blue? Or is it blue with a lot of pink or red?
So I think blue is definitely the dominant one. And blue is almost always coming from
this Ultramarine beyond the sea, this pigment that would have at the time come from Afghanistan.
So it has crossed mountains, it has crossed deserts, it has crossed the sea to then be
purified and ground up. This ridiculous process that basically means it is a hundred times more
expensive than any other pigment. So there is a period in our collection,
basically, where the most, I guess, holy of women is really associated with blue.
Absolutely. And it's expensive and royal, but also it is this sense of serene and calm.
And those are the sort of attributes that tend to go with the Virgin, but also a lot of pink.
She does have pinks and there will be images of the Virgin represented as flowers or holding flowers
or wearing a sort of a lighter red, but that blue is really the dominant colour.
Moving from adults to children, Vienne, there is a kind of association, isn't there,
particularly with this gender dissociation of pink and blue today with children's wear.
And I guess maybe you could talk a bit about that. Ed, you could talk a bit about how
we don't see that in the collection, really. We see lots of
boys not really wearing the typical blue that we might think of.
Yeah, I think that in some way, there probably aren't a lot of options in the market now that
if you look at children's wear or like babies wear, that it is actually a lot of light blue
products, whether it's clothing or toys for boys. And then there's lots of pink and
probably maybe also purple, light purple. Yeah, maybe light yellow as well.
Yeah, yeah. So those are kind of pastel colours for like reddish hues, basically, that's for girls.
So I think that in some way, probably it is more like a society norm that imposes,
reinforces that idea. And I did have a small survey in the past, checking with primary school
children about their favourite colour. Actually, quite a lot of little boys, they like pink.
So I think that before they like been exposed to understanding what is available in the society,
then if they pick, then it is actually quite equal in terms of number of votes between girls and
boys that their favourite colour. So it is not like born with that boys will be naturally like
blue or girls will be naturally like pink. I think that's what I observed. And then connecting to
Ed's just now talking about analysing the painting, and actually it reminds me also in
terms of clothing in modern days, if I talk with fashion consultants, they will recommend that
if you go for an interview, for a job interview, then let's wear navy in terms of like generally
your suit, you know, and then with a little bit of red in terms of like a tie or braces,
because what it is trying to like have this combination, it is to illustrate the candidate
is that has the calmness, has the loyalty with the blue, and also a source of energy and confidence
with the red. So actually, that example with your painting reminds me quite a lot of those
kind of connotation about power, confidence, and then calmness, like be quite consecutive,
things like that. Yes, it's quite consistent, seemingly over time in paintings and then now
in the modern world in terms of fashion, you know. Absolutely. Reminds me of the quote I
said at the start from Legally Blonde, where for Elwood's actually pink is kind of the most
powerful colour because it's super fashionable. And for her that is, you know, she just loves it.
And, you know, that movie does a lot to kind of rework gender stereotypes, doesn't it? And,
you know, women can be top lawyers and it doesn't matter. She wouldn't be wearing a plain navy suit
to her job interview, would she? She would be wearing a bright pink dress.
Okay. But it's so interesting. If we're seeing pink as a relation of red, and it's that sort of
to what degree? Because we're seeing, you know, the red is, as you say, it's the energy.
I mean, there's a fab study, I think, around the 2004 Olympic Games, which was, you know,
they looked at combat sports like taekwondo and boxing. And they said, you know, when the teams
are just randomly assigned blues or reds, and they said, you know, all things being equal,
you should have an equal number of wins. Red won 20% more of the time. And then there was another
study done about the English premiership here. And over time, for whatever reason,
red teams seem to win, which is nothing to say why Arsenal and Liverpool are currently
top. And yes, there's nothing to say about that. But yeah, it's a really interesting one. Is red
sort of energy and motivation, whereas blue is slightly calmer and more passive. It's very
tricky. But then with all so many of these things, we get these ideas and we can find something to
fit sometimes, can't we? And you go, aha, yes, I will look at the person in charge here and
they're wearing the red. And is it there to draw the eye? Or is it just sort of, yeah.
Are there examples from our collection of children wearing blue or pink?
Yeah, it's really interesting, talking about this sort of when gender colours tend to come in. And
it's also this idea of gendered clothing. Because let's say if you look at something like Hogarth's
beautiful family portrait by Hogarth called the Graham Children, and you've got four children.
And, you know, you've got these two girls standing up. The eldest girl, interestingly,
is wearing a wonderful blue. And then there is a boy sitting down wearing his breeches.
And then there is a little baby down in the bottom left corner wearing a sort of a baby's frock.
And it's great fun working with this with the kids, because I say, you know, what do you think
the baby's name might be? And they're thinking of posh baby names. And they go, who's Elizabeth?
And I say, well, no, the baby's name is Thomas. And they go, ah. And they go, ah. And I say,
because, yeah, they look at it. And really, you know, clothes were genderless. They were the same,
you know, particularly for children. There's an amazing photograph of Roosevelt, of FDR,
wearing this wonderful frock. And boys would be dressed. This is a picture of my grandfather,
actually, in the early 20th century, wearing a dress. Because boys and girls would be dressed
like that. It's quite practical if you think about it. If you need to change someone,
it's easier to pull up a skirt rather than taking breeches off. But then wearing breeches was part
of a sort of a rite of passage into manhood. The clothes themselves are sort of genderless and then
becoming gendered. And the colours are generally genderless as well. And then it's as we're moving
into the 20th century is starting to see with like the trade publications, trade, yes, people
marketing things and saying, OK, yes, we're recommending certain people wear this. Other
people should wear that because if you can gender colours, you can sell it to parents more than once.
This is the big thing. So, yeah. Yes. This is a good point for us to take a quick break. And
afterwards, we'll be asking Vienne about a study that resulted in the colour Baker Miller pink
and getting a little bit more into the 20th and 21st century and our associations with pink there.
We'll see after the break. So welcome back from the break. Vienne, can you tell us about this
colour Baker Miller pink? I'm sure most people won't have heard it. So what is it and how did
it come about? Yes, yes. In the US that we often maybe see seeing from television or movies that
if anyone that go to prison and then they will be wearing orange as their uniform. So that's
quite commonly that we come across from this media. And then there was a time that
that is as a suggestion that let's look at applying pink, this colour, to this kind of
environment like prison and then correctional facilities. So that they put the inmates there,
that their uniform, not wearing orange, but in pink, and also painting all the walls, ceilings,
floor, all the facilities there basically in pink. And because at the time the officials
suggesting this proposal are Baker and Miller, so that conveniently that has been named Baker
Miller pink for the colour. And the purpose for having this like quite radical change for the
colours in this facility and the uniform is thinking that pink as a colour will be able to
make the inmates more calming. And then, interestingly, in terms of statistics,
that it does reveal that there are less fighting and then less argument, that it does seem to have
an effect. So that is a very, very interesting example and also a very positive way to apply
colour for a particular purpose. And it came out of some research,
didn't it, by Alexander Schuas, who studied the psychological and physiological
responses. And it's a particular colour pink, a particular shade, P618, which he discovered in
1978, he thought had these effects. And I think some of his research is slightly contested now,
but really interesting that they embedded it into these correctional facilities.
That's right. Yeah. So it's a real world, like a scenario that applying and then
showing some effectiveness. So that's quite nice.
And there's another example from the US, isn't there, of pink being used?
Yes, that's an interesting one. That is actually in 1979. So in the US, the University of Iowa,
and they have a football stadium facility. So it's a huge space. So sometimes they will host
events for the football competition. And then at the time, the coach of the university that
designed it, that let's make the opponent's locker room all in pink colour. So ceiling, floor,
walls, like everywhere, including toilets, that's everywhere is pink for the opponent only.
Okay. And the idea, being quite criticised later on, is actually that thinking that they
tried to make the opponent team less competitive by exposing them, like really surrounding,
immersed in the pink colour. That says a lot about the mindset,
doesn't it? Yeah.
And going back to your point earlier about, you know, children, particularly young boys,
wanting pink, you know, this idea and that this cultural reinforcement.
That's true.
And it's that horrendous developmental stage where children, you know, voraciously wanting to do
things. And then they start around about four and five looking around and seeing what other children
are doing. And then judging themselves by that standard. Yeah, you'll never see a baby go,
I'm not going to bother learning to walk because, you know, that kid will do it better than me. But
you do see that with dress, with, you know, reading, writing, all sorts of different things.
And I think, yeah, that something is being culturally reinforced that pink means a certain
thing. And I think, yeah, that locker room thing is a perfect example of some coach going,
that's going to work. It probably won't. Because blue, I mean, you know, I think blue probably
would have a better calming effect. You know, there's studies to show it lowers heart rates
and things. And it's, yeah, it's a very funny one.
We've kind of entered this kind of post-war, post-Second World War period of Western culture,
where we've touched on the fact that mass marketing and consumerism had quite a big role
in how pink being associated with girls really took off. And I guess the association that most
people would have, or the most famous example would be the Barbie doll, which Mattel launched
in 1959. So how does Barbie get so associated with pink? Yeah, what is that? What's the story
there? Yeah, I think that is connecting to the post-war advertisement in terms of pink connecting
to the gender female. And I also think this is a very interesting example. I mean, obviously the
Barbie doll has been regarded as one of the most influential toys over time. And so I see that the
idea of using pink particularly for these toys is that instead of trying to kind of like get rid of
the connotation, it's actually trying to make use, make the most of that to enhance the positive
connotation. So the idea of Barbie is basically that it can be inspirational and then basically
encouraging that you can do anything that you want, that you dream of. And so I think that that
is a very, very interesting idea and then pushing actually further, but in a very positive way.
And it becomes quite, I guess, commercialised, this particular pink, doesn't it? So Barbie pink
is Pantone 219C and it's a kind of combination of magenta and pink. So I think maybe you can
explain this more, but I think the specific shade isn't registered as a trademark, but it's still
gained trademark protection for Mattel to distribute it. How does that work? How can a colour be
protected legally?
Yes. So colour actually cannot be copyrighted, but it can be part of the trademark or as a
wholesome as a trademark. So and lots of brands that basically would like to have the ownership
of a colour so that they are distinctive to any other competitors. So it is not just about like
Barbie and then basically all the brands, they will have a registered colour denoting maybe for
their logo and then other advertisement materials. That is very, very important. And for this
Pantone colour, I think it is in some way just slightly strong pink, not very pastel
ones that they pick. They may be trying to denote that, that OK, female can have the power as well.
Yeah. And other brands that actually can go into quite like a serious dispute if it is actually
not careful using the colour that other companies, other firms has been registered. So that is
another whole story about like, yeah, the correct use of colour in a way.
Barbie pink is not passive, which I think is so interesting because we said pink is this lighter,
you know, or in some ways in terms of sort of, you know, chromatic strength, maybe weaker.
But Barbie pink is it's sort of weapons grade.
Hold on. And I think that's that's a really interesting part of it. It is,
you know, it is unmistakably pink. It is unapologetically pink.
And unmistakably so because also our association with it, with the brand is so strong that when
the Barbie movie, which came out in 2023, starring Margot Robbie and Ryan Gosling,
they had billboards out, advertisements with just the date, July 21st, July 21,
when it was being released. And it was just that word with the bright pink background. And everyone
knew, everyone knew what that meant. Everyone knew that that was the Barbie movie coming out
and the date. They famously ran out of paint, didn't they? They painted the set
with so much pink that there was a global shortage of that particular colour. It was amazing.
Yes, they they contributed to a worldwide shortage.
It wasn't a total shortage. Yeah. But yeah, because the construction of Barbie Land
did use so much pink by the designer, Sarah Greenwood. Also interesting, the director,
Greta Gerwig, said that the bright pink shade was important for her in maintaining the
quote, kidness of the Barbie world. So that association with childhood coming back,
I find quite interesting. I think it's like a synthetic thing as well. Is it a plastic pink
rather than a pastel is more? I wonder. I don't. Just those connotations. We sort of go,
yes, but yes, who knows? And it is interesting talking, what you're saying about the kind of
strength of the colour pink. I feel like that is very much tied to the themes that they looked at
around individuality and patriarchy and being able to challenge women's role in society and
things that were being looked at in that film. And the strength of the pink has some
good associations with that, I think. Another very strong pink, actually called Shocking Pink,
caused a sensation in the 1930s, didn't it? What's what's the story there? And perhaps we
can talk about pop art as well in relation to that. I think that Shocking Pink is quite a familiar
like a terminology that we use is a very strong and then bright pink colour. And it's been
starting to become very popular that particular to the pop art period and where artists prefer
to use some strong colour to draw attention and then make impacts. So I will be also interested
to ask Ed, is there any collection more modern ones than in the gallery that illustrates that
these are very, very strong and eye-catching colours? Oh my goodness.
We probably didn't get late enough. I know, I know. We start pretty much at early 20th century.
What's interesting is that the strength of colours is something you see really change
in the National Gallery's collection as it gets later with the commercial dyes, with the
synthetic colours that are being created, sort of these byproducts of the Industrial Revolution.
And you can just get stronger polychromatic colours. I mean, the ultramarine is a perfect
example of they actually worked out the chemical structure of ultramarine so they could create
it synthetically and they go, aha, now it's so much cheaper, but the same colour. So yes,
generally you will see, you know, the consistency of the paint, the colour of the paint changes.
And so you can get much deeper, harder fixing colours within our paintings. So you will see
people using much more. I mean, colours obsessed people for ages, but particularly when you get
to people like Monet, extremely famously Van Gogh as well, you know, would obsess over colours and
they would talk about particular shades and then where they can get them. You know, with Van Gogh,
it was, you know, pleading with his brother Theo to post these tubes out to him. Can we get these
particular colours? Can we replicate what we're seeing in the world and use it to, you know,
it's not just this is the yellow of a sunflower, this is the yellow of life or hope or, you know,
there's something else going into it. But yes, the synthetic things are definitely stronger or able
to be. Yeah. So this, yeah, Shocking Pink became the signature hue of Elsa Schiaparelli, who was
a prominent fashion designer of the mid 20th century. She was really known for her bold,
avant-garde designs and she did a dress for the 1952 film Moulin Rouge and her perfume brand. So
she became quite like associated with this very bold pink. And then I guess the other really
famous woman that we would associate with this Shocking Pink is Marilyn Monroe, who wore a very
iconic pink dress in the song Diamonds are a Girl's Best Friend from the 1953 film Gentlemen
Prefer Blondes. And so whilst not in our collection, I guess with pop art, the way that
we might associate this bright pink with art history is Andy Warhol's Marilyn series. These
kind of very vibrant portraits with completely mono-coloured pink, bright pink backgrounds,
other colours as well, but pink particularly associated with Marilyn there. I guess we've
kind of got these almost generational pinks coming through here. You've got kind of Barbie
of the late 20th century. You've got this 20th century Shocking Pink. The 21st century, we get
this real association between the colour pink and a particular generation, which is called
Millennial Pink or Tumblr Pink. Vianne, can you describe what is happening there? How does like
colour get associated with a generation? Yeah, I think that moving on to the time that we are
more going back to look at gender equality and trying to kind of like break the richness of
colour associated with particular gender. But whether it is successful or not, I'm not quite
sure because you might have heard of a term called pink tax. That is basically in terms of
like the consumer market, companies or brands will try to make the pricing for female-oriented
products a little bit more higher, even if it's just the same type of product used by men or
female. But as long as this is particular in the female collection, that it becomes
like in general, like something like 40% more expensive with the same product. So there are
still some places starting to ban this pink tax and trying to observe a little bit more
in terms of pricing, particularly in the States. But still that we see this phenomenon still quite
prominent and at least existing in the market. So I don't know. I think it is still a long way
that we can kind of like detach in a way that pink is for girls and then blue is for boys.
So I think for me that there's no problem basically with colour association or symbolic
meanings in a way because we see a lot of usefulness actually that with colour and then
attach some identification or categorisation purposes. So if we take pink and blue kind of
like equally as if that we look at red or green, like traffic light signals, then so we understood
that red has been signalled that it is dangerous and then we need to stop. Green is like go and
then just go ahead and there's no problem that it will be smooth. It's acceptable. Then we don't
put a lot of like attitude or emotion into it. And then it's just basically making use of that
have a clearer idea. Then it's actually not a bad thing. So that's what I would say.
I find it really interesting that these, yeah, whilst that feels a bit more universal,
that traffic lights example, maybe not universal, but like has persisted through time
a bit more that we do still get these kind of generational fashions almost for pink. So like
the millennial pink with kind of makeup packaging with a brand like Glossier and then
being quite associated with Tumblr and the late 2010s. And then in 2016 you get Pantone
colour of the year, but they actually picked two pastel colours. Interestingly,
they picked Rose Quartz, which is a pink and Serenity, which is a pastel blue. And
this quote from their website is quite interesting. I think that they felt that
quote, the prevalent combination of Rose Quartz and Serenity also challenges traditional
perceptions of colour association. In many parts of the world, we are experiencing a gender blur
as it relates to fashion, which has in turn impacted colour trends throughout all other
areas of design. This more unilateral approach to colour is coinciding with societal movements
towards gender equality and fluidity and consumers increased comfort with colour as a form of
expression. And so we've got a generation that has less concern about being typecast or judged.
And an open exchange of digital information that's opened our eyes to different approaches
to colour usage. And I think, I think that is so interesting because I think I probably am seeing
that with more like Gen Z, maybe into Gen A, Gen Alpha. But I don't know, you were saying before
we started Ed about, you know, your little girl, her favourite colour is pink. One of her favourite,
And there are still very strong cultural associations.
It's going to be time, isn't it Vex? And I think that's what will change it. You're seeing
much more because of modern technology and how it works. You're seeing a greater atomisation
of sort of cultural colour associations and cultural interests, because you can be into
all sorts of different things. It's not just sort of a, we will join a certain camp. At the moment,
we still have that sense that, you know, if you are, if pink is, pink and blue, you're either
sort of conforming or you're rebelling against. And in a way to do that, you are still fundamentally
accepting that there is a thing that is, you know, pink has a certain connotation,
blue has a certain connotation, regardless of which way you want to take it. And I think that
will dilute with time when people start blurring that to a point where that connotation, I mean,
2023, it was Barbie pink. 2024, we had Bratz summer, which is a completely different colour
and we have a green. So it's just like, I think that reflection of what femininity can be and what
youth culture wants to go for will change. And I think, you know, the pink and blue thing,
it'll be interesting to see what people hopefully listen to this in a hundred years time,
will associate with blues and pinks, because, you know, we still have these colours. We will still
use these colours. The sky, you know, hopefully will always still be blue, appear to us in that
way. Blood is always red and there are elements of pink, you know, related to that. But I think,
you know, that atomisation of culture and tastes will change, I think, a lot. So we will see.
The very final bits you want to add.
It's just this idea that I think we've hit upon it and I think it's probably worth sort of stating
that you can almost find something to justify a colour or a picture or something to justify
how you'd like to use it. You know, there are definite prevalent things, but, you know, we're
both beholden to them and capable of shaking it up. But it's, yeah, it's really, it's really tricky.
I mean, particularly with kids, you know, it's just like, who's going to go against the grain?
We're fundamentally social creatures, aren't we? So it's the gumption to sort of, you know,
stand up, you either go with the flow or stand up and go, no. But even then you're sort of
reinforcing it by saying, I'm going to go with it or I'm going to go against it. You are saying
it is a thing. So maybe that's the point I make.
In a few words, Vienne, to conclude the podcast with the original question,
is pink for girls and is blue for boys?
At the moment, yes.
So that brings us to the end of today's episode of Stories in Colour. Thank you ever so much for
listening. If you've got questions about the story of colour and how this amazing technology
has interacted with human history, you can email us on podcast at nationalgallery.org.uk
or you can send in questions via our National Gallery social media channels. Just mention the
podcast and we'll do our very best to answer those in a future episode. So we hope to see you next
time for Stories in Colour. Thank you so much for joining us. With huge thanks to our guests,
Dr. Vienne Chung and Ed Dickinson. I've been your host, Bex Leary. Our producer was Harry
Rosehill. Our researcher was Hannah Rogers. Our technicians were Tom Gulliver and Timothy
Carpenter. Our video editor was Jeanne Kenyon. And with a huge thanks to the scientific team
as well at the National Gallery. Thank you very much for listening. We'll see you next time.
