The Real Reason the Celts Vanished from Germany

Population History
1 follower
Jun 7, 2026
Southern Germany was at the core of the Celtic world for centuries, potentially even a millennium. But from the 1st Century BC onwards this began to change and we still don't really know why.
In this video I'm trying to investigate this issue by comparing some of the most common hypotheses regarding it. If you'd like to find out more, check out my Patreon:
https://patreon.com/EuropeanOrigins?u...
Map of Europe Around 100 BC: https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/44798...
Map of Central Europe Around 50 BC: https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/43031...
Sources:
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/scienc...
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/s...
https://www.researchgate.net/publicat...
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
According to most modern historians and archaeologists, the Celtic language and
culture first developed in Central Europe during the Late Bronze Age.
The earliest manifestation of Celtic culture is usually identified with the archaeological
Hallstatt culture, which spanned the Late Bronze and the Early Iron Ages.
Whilst some scholars only identified the latest stage of this culture with Celts,
based on the earliest mentions of Celts in our historical records,
others view the entirety of this culture as at least proto-Celtic.
During the Iron Age, the Hallstatt culture would gradually develop into the Latin culture and
expand over large parts of Europe, which has often been seen as evidence of the spread of Celtic
languages across much of the continent. By the Late Iron Age, the Latin culture extended from
Britain to Northern Italy and from the Atlantic to Bohemia, but its influences could be felt
much further afield in places as distant from each other as Ireland and Anatolia,
as well as Iberia, Poland, Ukraine and even Denmark.
But curiously, a part of Central Europe, a core territory of not only the Latin but also the
preceding Hallstatt culture, was seemingly abandoned during the first half of the 1st century
BC, after a millennium of continuous settlement at the core of the Celtic world. The question is,
why? Why did the people who had inhabited the region for at least a thousand years
abandon it? And where did they go? Whilst some scholars have proposed that the
Germanic tribes from the North were to blame, others suggested that the turmoil caused by
Julius Caesar's conquest of Gaul lay at the root of the issue. And of course, there are also those
who think a combination of these two developments caused the Celts to abandon their ancestral
homelands in Central Europe. In this video, I will investigate both hypotheses and also explore
alternative models of explanation. In order to do so, we will first take a look at the situation
right before the first signs of population movement appear in our historical sources
and in the archaeological record at the end of the 2nd century BC.
As stated previously, during this time, much of Central and Western Europe was dominated
by the archaeological Latin culture. Meanwhile, the Roman Republic had expanded from its central
Italian heartland to encompass not only all of Italy, but also the surrounding islands of Sicily,
Sardinia and Corsica, as well as Western Iberia and Greece, and even some territories outside of
Europe. But most crucially for our inquiry, Rome had also established a foothold in Southern Gaul,
which marks the beginning of the advance of the Republic from a Mediterranean to a pan-European
superpower. But as of right now, Rome's direct influence was still largely contained to the
Mediterranean parts of the continent. It was during this time that the Romans were faced with
a new threat from the North in the form of a coalition of tribes that is known to us as the
Cimbri and Teutonis. And whilst those two are the most famous of this coalition, there were other
lesser-known groups among them as well, such as the Ambronis, and two groups, which, according to
Strabo, were sub-tribes of the Helvetii. According to Tacitus and Pliny, both of whom wrote in the
late 1st century AD, the Helvetii were one of the Celtic tribes that originally inhabited parts of
From Caesar's commentaries on the Gallic War, we also know that by the mid-1st century BC,
at the latest, they didn't inhabit this area anymore, and instead had settled south of the
Rhine and Lake Constance in modern Switzerland. Although Caesar doesn't state this outright,
it is tempting to assume that Helvetii abandoned Southern Germany in favour of the foothills of
the Alps across the Rhine due to pressure from the Cimbri and Teutonis, as Caesar himself repeatedly
points to the pressure that Germanic groups from further inland exerted on tribes, both
Germanic and Celtic, which settled closer to the Rhine in the Danube and even beyond in Gaul.
But this is actually unlikely due to at least two reasons. Firstly, there's actually very little
evidence that the Celtic inhabitants of Southern Germany left due to external or internal conflict.
The only major site in Southern Germany that shows signs of attack that might coincide with
arrival of the Cimbri and Teutonis is the Obbidum of Manching, but that site wasn't
abandoned until much later. Secondly, if the Cimbri and Teutonis came to the land of Helvetii
as a marauding army, it is unlikely that two of their sub-tribes would have joined them.
What this does show, however, is that large parts of Helvetii were willing to leave the region,
and this actually coincides with the abandonment of multiple major settlements in the region.
Although these settlements were burned down, recent archaeological excavations have uncovered
that this didn't happen in the context of battles, but rather in organised large-scale
rituals that involved the deposition of material sacrifices in the ruins of their former homes.
Due to the absence of signs of conflict, the most likely culprit behind those ritual burnings
were the inhabitants themselves, and Caesar actually tells us of this practice 50 years later,
so it is not too far-fetched to assume that this had started happening much earlier,
towards the end of the 2nd century BC. Interestingly, the archaeological finds
in some of these settlements actually point to the opposite of conflict.
Material associated with the northern-central European Chavous culture is found alongside
native Latin material, indicating that people from the north had settled among the local populace
and were integrated into their community. It should be noted, however, that these newcomers
probably weren't associated with the Kimri, as their homeland lay in Jutland,
whilst the Chavous culture at this time was confined to eastern-central Europe,
in an area roughly corresponding to modern western and southern Poland.
They might represent members of the Teutonis or Ambronis, as their origins are less clear.
Whilst many scholars believe that both tribes originated in the vicinity of the Kimri in
Jutland, others have pointed out that the name of the Teutonis, at least,
seems to be Celtic in origin, rather than Germanic. The Ambronis too might have been Celtic,
if Plutarch is to be believed, and it should be pointed out that before Caesar,
even the Kimri were considered to be Celts by the Romans.
But the consensus among modern scholars seems to be that the Kimri were probably Germanic,
whilst the status of the Teutonis and the Ambronis is less certain.
In this context, the Chavous material found in the opera of southern Germany is of particular
interest, as the Chavous culture itself appears to be a mix of elements of the Latin culture,
which is usually associated with Celts, and the Jastov culture,
which is usually associated with early Germanic tribes.
If the Teutonis and the Ambronis had originated in the territory of the Chavous culture,
we would indeed expect difficulties in clearly identifying them as either Celtic or Germanic.
But due to the scarcity of Chavous material from the sites in southern Germany,
as well as difficulties regarding dating this material,
and when exactly the Kimri, Teutonis and Ambronis were in southern Germany,
and for how long, this interpretation remains speculative.
What we can say with certainty, however, is this.
From the end of the 2nd century BC onwards, archaeological material from the northern
central European Chavous culture is present in Latin settlements in southern Germany,
alongside native material.
The settlements, as well as the material associated with both cultures,
start disappearing shortly thereafter.
These developments might coincide with the migration of the Kimri and their allies,
who were reportedly joined by two subtypes of the Helvetii.
Why they joined them is unknown, but it is likely that this event contributed
to the depopulation of the area and the abandonment of some of the settlements there.
The fact that groups from both northern and central Europe were willing to join up and
abandon their homes may point to a larger common issue that affected both areas
and compelled some people to move away.
The most likely reason for this decision appears to have been an increase in population density.
According to a study from 2011 by Bündken et al., central Europe,
including northern central Europe and thus probably also Denmark,
experienced much higher precipitation and higher temperatures than usual
towards the end of the 2nd century BC, peaking at around 100 BC.
At the beginning of these developments, the weather conditions would have been close to optimal,
resulting in better fields for cattle grazing,
as well as higher crop yields, which may have led to population growth.
However, as precipitation increased, some fields may have become waterlogged,
which would have made it difficult to sustain the increased population.
We may find echoes of these developments in our historical sources,
in which it is claimed that the Kimri left the homeland due to intense flooding.
Whilst this has been dismissed by many scholars as a topos,
that is a literary trope often encountered in ancient sources,
the climatic data shows that there may be some truth to it,
in the sense that there would have been much more rain during this period than usual.
Ironically, as the Kimri migrated through central Europe,
the weather had started to improve again.
Precipitation was still increasing, but so was the temperature,
probably leading to further population growth in the region.
By the time they reached today's southern Germany around 113 BC,
the region was likely bursting at its seams,
which might be why the two aforementioned sub-tribes of the Helvetii
decided to join the Kimri and their allies.
So it seems that whilst migrating tribes from the north
may have presented an opportunity for some Celts to leave their home,
the real reason was probably exponential and unsustainable population growth,
caused by simultaneous changes in both temperature and precipitation.
But due to the oval increase in population size,
the initial impact of those leaving was probably minimal.
The real changes started at the beginning of the first century BC,
and interestingly, this period coincides with a number of migrations
that are attested in the historical record.
The first of these we've already mentioned, and is only attested indirectly,
and concerns those Helvetii who didn't join the Kimri and their allies on their trek south.
Because Caesar tells us they were located in modern Switzerland by 58 BC,
they must have left southern Germany at some point before this time,
and after the Kimri and the tribes accompanying them had come through their territory.
Seeing as they were firmly established in Switzerland by 58 BC,
and there is no mention of a southern German homeland of the Helvetii in Caesar's commentaries,
this probably happened several decades prior.
Looking at what else Caesar has to tell us about the situation in the mid-first century BC,
one might think that their move may have coincided with another migration from the north.
When Caesar started his campaigns in Gaul,
he was confronted with someone he described as a Germanic king by the name of Ariovistus.
Although he doesn't mention this outright, a later source speaks of a king of the Suebi,
and it is thus often assumed that Ariovistus was Suebian himself.
If that were the case, it would mean that he most likely
originally hailed from modern northeastern or eastern central Germany.
According to Caesar, Ariovistus had arrived in Gaul 14 years prior to himself,
meaning that he had left his homeland by 72 BC at the latest.
Although Ariovistus is described as a Germanic king,
he ruled over a coalition of tribes that probably didn't solely consist of Germanic groups,
but also of Celtic ones.
Indeed, there's reason to believe that the majority of the people on this command were Celts,
as there's no archaeological evidence of his presence in Gaul itself,
indicating that the vast majority of his followers were native Gauls
or Celts from across the Rhine who had joined him on his migration,
much like the sub-tribes of Telvetti had done several decades earlier.
This hypothesis is further strengthened by the fact that Ariovistus had a Celtic wife
from the kingdom of Noricum, which roughly corresponds to modern Austria.
This means that this Germanic king had good relations with at least some of the Celtic
speaking groups in central Europe, possibly even before he left his homeland,
which wasn't too far from Noricum.
Because Caesar doesn't mention that the Helvetii were pushed out by Ariovistus,
which he surely would have for propagandistic reasons,
we can assume with a relatively high degree of certainty
that Ariovistus wasn't responsible for their displacement from southern Germany.
Thus, it is likely that the rest of the Helvetii left southern Germany
before Ariovistus came through the region,
which must have been before 72 BC,
which would roughly coincide with the abandonment
of many of the remaining Celtic settlements in the region from the 1st century BC onwards.
So, in this case too, external pressures don't seem to have been the primary cause
for the exodus of Celtic populations from southern Germany.
But if Ariovistus isn't to blame, what is?
Well, if we look at the climate data for this particular period,
we can see that precipitation reached an all-time high at around 100 BC,
higher than at any other point between 500 BC and 2000 AD.
Meanwhile, temperatures were still rising.
Whilst before, these developments probably led to population growth across central Europe,
the specific combination of high temperature and high precipitation
may have caused an increase in crop parasites and fungal blights.
Because the population had probably expanded dramatically between 120 and 100 BC,
it was no longer sustainable, and this was only the start.
From around 90 BC onwards, both temperature and precipitation decreased dramatically,
leading to a shortened growing season and thus a reduction in overall crop yields.
This might explain why the towns were ritualistically burnt down as well.
Perhaps the people felt that they had exploited the land during the population boom,
which had contributed to the growth of these towns towards the end of the 2nd century BC,
and wanted to make amends by destroying what they had built through that exploitation.
Caesar tells us that the Gauls, and by extension probably also the Celts of southern Germany,
had a close connection with nature,
so they were probably very sensitive to changes in climate and weather.
By the time Caesar arrived in Gaul, the only Celtic tribe he mentions in southern Germany
are the Volcaetectosargus, which he locates somewhere in the Assyrian forest,
although he doesn't specify exactly where.
He also tells us that the Boii had originally lived east of Delvetii,
and most modern scholars believe their homeland lay in modern Bohemia and potentially Bavaria,
both of which derive their names from the Boii.
But they too had abandoned the region at some point before Caesar's arrival,
and archaeological findings suggest this was a gradual process
that took up much of the 1st century BC.
So by the time Caesar arrived in the region,
most of the Celts of southern Germany had already left,
ruling out that the advance of the Romans had much to do with these developments.
Some exceptions to the general depopulation of the area can be found in the archaeological record,
Along the River Rhine, for example,
some Celtic settlements remained and were inhabited for decades,
sometimes well into the Roman period.
And Strabo, around the time of the birth of Christ,
tells us of the Vindadici inhabiting the region south of the Danube.
Although there's little archaeological evidence of this group,
this doesn't mean they didn't exist.
The modern town of Augsburg in Bavaria was originally named after them,
Augusta Vindadicorum.
So there's good reason to believe that Strabo didn't just make things up.
And if they are pretty much invisible in the archaeological record,
there is a possibility that other Celtic groups had also stayed behind,
although probably at population levels much lower
than at that peak towards the end of the 2nd century BC.
And there you have it,
my take on why the Celts largely disappeared from southern Germany.
Whilst migrations from the north may have provided the spark for these developments,
I think the main reason as to why the Celts left the Hermand
was actually climate change.
Let me know what you think about this in the comments below.
This video was largely based on research I conducted for my master's thesis
which will soon be available on Patreon.
If you'd like to dive deeper into this topic,
head over there using the link in my description and become a member.
All support is greatly appreciated and will help me fund my PhD.
But for now, thank you so much for watching
and I'm looking forward to seeing you in the next one.
