Ostrogothic Italy and the Franks

Population History
1 follower
12 Video Views·Mar 19, 2026
This lecture deals with the end of the Roman Empire of the West and lectures on the barbarian kingdoms that took its place such as the Franks and the Ostrogoth's.
Bilkent HIST417 20111014 LECTURE06 Ostrogothic Italy & The Franks
Asst. Prof. David E. Thornton
This course traces the history of western Europe from the fall of the Roman Empire to the Renaissance, and deals with the main political, social and religious changes during that period.
HIST 417 Medieval Europe (500-1500)
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Right, today we're going to look in a little bit more detail at Western Europe, excluding
the British Isles, during the 5th and 6th centuries primarily, during which time we
see the Ostrogothic peoples dominating a large part of what is now Italy and into what is
in fact sort of Provence in southeastern France. We see a number of people coming into what
is now Spain and Portugal, but in the long term most significantly the Visigoths arrive.
We see lots of people making their way into what is now France, but ultimately it is the
Franks who take over there, and at a later stage we see these Longobards, the Lombards,
coming in and exploiting the decline of the Ostrogothic kingdom, partly under the influence
of what the Byzantines are doing, and establishing themselves in there.
Our presenter for today is Theodoric, I mean Ravel, who will come up in a minute and tell
us all about the Ostrogoths, because chronologically they're perhaps the most important. But I
thought we'd just kind of mention, highlight at the start a few kind of themes which I'm
hoping will come up more than once and that I want us to look at in the discussions that
we will have. And with reference to that, I hope therefore that you have all either
printed or, to save the Amazon rainforests, read online, or with your mobile device or
something like that, whatever you all do these days, the two texts which I connected via
Moodle, the letters sent by, or rather on behalf of King Theodoric to various individuals,
they tell us a little bit about his administration as a king in Italy, and then the various references
and discussions of the Frankish king Clovis by Gregory of Tours, which gives, in my view,
a very interesting picture of both Clovis and a little bit about what Gregory is doing.
So if you haven't looked at those, we will be discussing those, I think, for a large
part of the second hour, so you better have a quick read of your friend's copy or something
during the break if you have time. So a number of themes then that I think we might pick
up on and so on, some things that we discussed more generally on Tuesday in class. Romanitas,
Roman-ness. How do these individuals, Theodoric, Clovis, or Gregory, and Cassiodorus, the secretary
of Theodoric, how do they kind of present Roman-ness, and how do these people perceive
themselves in connection to Rome? And again, it's one of these things I've been banging on
about more than once, that we don't want to see a kind of sudden break somewhere in the
century and we say, okay, end of Rome, that's the end of everything Roman, now we're all
kind of medieval and wearing kind of simple clothes and talking bad Latin and whatever
it is. There was a transitional period, and can we even talk about a kind of change, and
certainly how did the people see it at the time? They may be right or wrong, but it's
important to see, understand how they perceived things there. Part of that, in a way, because
we shouldn't exclude Christianity from Romanitas, because by the end of the Roman Empire it
was an integral part of it, and we'll discuss that in a bit more detail in a few weeks,
but what's the importance, what's the role, religious but also political and cultural
role, of Christianity in all of this? Where do they fit in, in a sense? And lastly, we've
called this topic Rome's Heirs, the Barbarian Kingdoms. We talked a lot about the barbarian
side of the equation on Tuesday, what that means and so on, or doesn't mean, or whatever.
For the people in charge, the small minority, the guy at the top and his kind of band of
followers who keep things going and so on, okay, the kings and their entourage, what's
going on? Okay, we don't have an emperor anymore, in a sense, though, as we said, there may
be some aspirations in one way or another. And in the Latin texts we get the word rex
being used, these people are called king. Now the question is, do we see, oh well they're
just Germanic kind of people and they're Germanic kings or whatever, but this is a Latin word
being applied to people who are now living in what had been the Roman Empire, still might
be in a sense. So we can't say that they're necessarily coming in and bringing in their
Germanic style of rule. Something new is happening here, it's not an emperor, it's
not a Roman emperor, but it's not just some kind of Germanic warlord, it's something that
perhaps mixes the two together. As I mentioned the other day, for example, many of these
kings issued laws, codes connected to their names, okay, they're trying to rule more in
a Roman way, in accordance with Roman rule and so on. The laws themselves might be old
Germanic customs, but they're writing them down and they're communicating them to their
people like a Roman emperor might have done. So again, what kind of people were they in
charge, what's going on here? And I think everything is kind of mixed up, okay, and
we can't necessarily push it one way or the other. And probably when we get to our discussion
we will see, in theory at least, a contrast perhaps between what appears to be a very
sophisticated, very Romanised theodoric in his letters and so on, and they're quoting
old classical literature and all sorts of things like that, in contrast to the picture
we get of Clovis, and although he's a kind of hero figure for Gregory of Tours, I at
least get a rather different impression. Now maybe it's the sources that give this impression,
the two men may have been very similar, whatever, we'll have to discuss that and so on. So in
terms of Romanus, in terms of the role of Christianity and so on, and therefore also
their identity as kings, very important. And I mentioned again on Tuesday, and we should
stress it again with reference to Christianity, very important, at the time and kind of subsequently
especially, the most dominant form of Christianity in Western Europe was Catholicism, okay. But
during this period, during this very late Roman or sub-Roman and early post-Roman period,
we see a lot of people, including quite a lot of these Germanic kings and their followers,
following this Arianism which becomes a heresy, okay, or because it's not the dominant form
so the people in charge call it a heresy, where they interpret the Trinity in a slightly
different way. And we're going to come back to the issue of the role of these two forms
and what's going on, and how much this is perhaps a political issue and so on going
on, particularly with reference to Gregory of Tours, because Gregory of Tours really
hated Arianism and Arius. He loves to tell the story about how the heretic Arius died
while sitting on the toilet. He really thinks that was a good way for this bad man to end
and so on. So how he presents Christianity, okay, not just as a member of the clergy himself
but with a certain axe to grind here, I think is important. So we'll come back to those
issues later. Okay, any questions now? Okay, Fatih.
Sir, when we are talking about Rome, was there a synthesis between being Roman and German
or are we talking about a complete being German or trying to be German?
You mean in Western Europe?
Well I think, yes, synthesis might be a good concept for us to think about. I'm not saying
I would agree 100% because I think we need to discuss this or whatever, but a synthesis
might be something that's going on. We don't have the Rome of Julius Caesar anymore, but
then we didn't have the Rome of Julius Caesar for a good few hundred years. But these people,
Clovis and his followers, and their successors especially, are not really comparable to their
own Germanic ancestors a couple of hundred years earlier either. Something else is going
on. Now people and things are constantly evolving, so we're not expecting things to stay the
same anyway, but this is a new situation which is both developing from Rome and is bringing
some Germanic things in. The Law Codes is a very good example of that. They issue a
law, they print a law, they give a law in the way that a Roman emperor would have done,
but a lot of the laws they're giving are Germanic customs about, okay, if you kill someone then
we punish you this way or that way, and depending on your rank and so on. It's the same in Anglo-Saxon
England as well, we'll talk about Anglo-Saxon laws later. So that's one example where Germanic
Law Codes are taking what we might call Roman form, a Roman idea, but then putting it into
a kind of more Germanic context, but then everything in it isn't necessarily Germanic
either in a traditional way, so it's very hard to know how far we can go back and things
like that. And we'll see when we look at Christianity and the conversion of Clovis
and so on, okay, it's perhaps a little bit more complicated than we see Gregory of Chor
showing, and there's a lot more going on there, a little bit more synthesis perhaps going
on there as well. Any other questions? Any other points? Okay, Ravel, come and tell us
about Theoderic and those Ostrobois. Okay, let's spend a few minutes just summarising
the early history of the Merovingian Franks, Frank being a bigger term for West Germanic
tribes that entered up in north-eastern Roman Empire, originally around what's now Belgium
and then spreading further south to various areas, and one particular family ends up becoming
the dominant one and taking over, and it's their perhaps most famous king, Clovis, that
we shall talk about in more detail later, who largely kind of set them up and so on.
What is the other big dynasty of Franks about whom we shall have some discussion in a number
of weeks' time, maybe after the Byron? Carolingians, okay, they're successors of the Merovingians
and called Carolingians in their case because lots of them were called Charles, Carolus
in Latin form, whatever, including obviously Carolus Magnus Charles, the great Charlemagne,
as perhaps their most famous. Merovingians taking their name from a kind of mythical
ancestor, Merovec, and lots of the Germanic dynasties trace their genealogies, their ancestors
to these kind of semi-godlike figures and things like that, and he's their kind of ancestor
figure for them and they end up becoming known as Merovingians. And they dominate what is
now France and other parts of Europe in various ways from the end of the 5th century when
Clovis was active down into the 8th century when the Carolingians kind of take over, though
the Merovingians were pretty much in decline at that point. While we're on names, Clovis,
which as I said is the most, perhaps most famous and most important retrospectively
of their rulers, his name becomes what, do we know? Everyone sharing gum down there?
I can't do that, obviously I'm talking. Clovis gets changed gradually and ends up becoming
what? Nice guess, I don't even know where the name Clive comes from. No, that's Charles.
Okay, the original name in fact was probably something like that, Clodovicus or something
like that. It's a Latinised Germanic name, but let's just do this. Louis. How many kings
of France have been called Louis over the many years and so on, and they're all really
just Clovis's. Harking back to this very, very early king of the Franks, so very important
in that sense there. For the period we're looking at, it's Gregory of Tours, Gregory
Bishop of Tours and his ten books of histories that I mentioned on Tuesday that is our main
source, particularly for Clovis but also for the period after him, a hundred years or so
after him, and it's some of his paragraphs about Clovis that we shall be discussing later.
But let's look at the background a little bit more, start as a background of what's
going on, and we've got this map here which shows primarily the spread of the Franks during
the late 5th and early 6th centuries under Clovis's control and so on. So we begin up
here. The Franks are one small group of Germanic peoples who've kind of crept across the badly
defended borders of the Roman Empire and are in kind of north-eastern France and Belgium
somewhere around about there, okay, up here somewhere that they begin their life. They
kind of appear historically under a king called Childeric who was during, probably during
the 460s, was some kind of a war leader for these people and we do actually have his,
supposedly his grave survives and we can see that he was quite a wealthy kind of socio-economically
as well as militarily important person up there, working with the local authorities
but also trying to do his own thing probably is what was the case.
Somewhere around about 481 he was succeeded by his son Clovis, okay. So he dies around
about 480, 81, something like that, we're not sure exactly, Gregory of Tours doesn't
always give exact dates and so on but it's round about that period that he dies and then
Clovis takes over and he is really the one who establishes the dynasty and establishes
the Frankish power and as you can see from these big thick arrows pretty much takes over
the whole of what is Gaul, what was considered to be Gaul during that time from various,
primarily other Germanic peoples. Now we can go through lots and lots of dates and so we
don't need to worry too much about these things and the dates, we've got some dates on here
so let's not get too hung up on these but during the, starting in the 480s but especially
490s and the early 500s is when he makes some of his biggest conquests of various sorts,
okay. He begins obviously naturally with his immediate neighbours, other Germanic peoples,
the Thuringians up here and the Alamans over there, we have some references to these battles
and these victories going on and exactly his motivation is quite important and so on.
4, 9, 6 or 7, it could be 7, what's the importance of that one, what is important about that
battle, his victory over the Alamans, the Alamani, what is the importance of that victory?
It figures in our reading material, it's part of the reading material there, it's important
because it's important, sorry? Yeah, it's the point that marks or inspires his eventual
or alleged conversion to Christianity so according to the narrative that we can traditionally
understand from Gregory of Tours, 496-37 victory over the Alamani and that's when he decides
in one way or another to become a Christian. Fatih, you wanted to add? No? Yeah, okay,
anything you want to say, we're going to come back to this in more detail later on.
His conversion as described in Gregory of Tours and as usually kind of thought about
is making a very clear parallel with what? He's doing badly in a battle, he calls upon
the Christian God or Jesus Christ, he wins the battle, okay, who else won a battle because
he said, okay, let's give the Christian God and Jesus Christ a chance? Who else? Constantine,
okay, his conversion is connected to a rather pagan interpretation which is if this God
helps him in the battle then this God must be good or whatever and things like that.
We'll come back to that issue in a minute.
He himself also, he saw a vision too and after he decided to pass on to Christianity.
Well, yeah, possibly.
Of course, firstly because of his wife's brainwashing but after the vision.
His wife's persistence perhaps or something, yes, yeah, yeah, okay. So there are strong
parallels which either were historically accurate or obviously Gregory of Tours is trying to
get into the details of this afterwards because it's an important way of us understanding
our sources and what's going on in them and so on.
Somewhere around about 500, 501 he then begins the move further south. Now this area again
had been controlled for a little while by these Burgundians who were connected to the
Ostrogoths as well as we heard before where they were also a Germanic people, obviously
the French regional name Burgundy comes from that. I think it's even connected ultimately
to things like Bavaria and things, I'm not sure of the details of that, okay.
But that's an important step.
But most importantly is his move into this area which is marked roughly here.
We can't expect this to be a perfect line at that period.
But this southwestern part of Gaul had been for a long time controlled by the Visigoths
who were the dominant group by this point in Spain, in the Iberian Peninsula, okay.
And it's usually accepted as being 507, you can't see it very clearly on there.
At the battle of Vouillé that he makes his first big defeat of the Visigoths and then
begins to penetrate slowly in the following years down to their dominant area further
south and so on. For a while they control what's called Septimania down here but then
that goes as well, I think perhaps under his sons that finally gives in to the Franks and
so on and this is a very important battle and we'll have a look at the documents and
the accounts of that later on because it marks an important step there.
And it has a religious, it almost is presented like a crusade or something again in Gregory
of Tours and how we, because the Visigoths were Aryans and how we interpret that of course
is another matter.
Now, what happens is that Clovis had, by his Christian wife, he had other sons by, at least
one other son, probably more by other women, but by his Christian wife Clothilde, he had
four legitimate sons who all, in this case, survive him.
He dies 511 and he has the strategy of dividing his kingdom up between his four sons.
So rather than saying we're going to give it to the oldest son and then maybe there
might be some fighting because the other guys feel annoyed or whatever, he decides rather
to divide up the kingdom between his sons.
And this starts a pattern that we see at a number of stages in Merovingian history whereby
we have a kingdom but we actually have three or even four kings ruling in different areas
and then they kind of fight and eventually sometimes kill each other, brothers and cousins
and so on.
And then periodically again things get focused in on one son.
As others die, one is left and then he, in this case, he then ends up dividing it between
his sons or it divides.
And then for a while, in the case of Lothar, for example, we have one king for a while
but then things begin to spread out again.
So this is a recurring theme in Merovingian history.
And just to illustrate that here, we can see a couple of examples.
This is the situation in 561, the sons of Lothar there.
You can see the different areas marked in with this little region down here still connected
to the Visigoths.
And then if we superimpose, it's interesting, these pictures are more or less the same.
We superimpose that on.
You can see some regions seem to have an identity.
They recur as a little area that a king gets and other ones are more flexible.
So there's a lot of chopping.
The cake sometimes is chopped in similar ways and other times a little bit different over
times as they argue and expand and things like that.
But this is a recurring problem.
It's either a problem because it leads to division or else it's a solution to the danger
of people, one guy getting the stuff and the other guy is trying to undermine or fight
him, whatever it might be.
And as I said, the Merovingians carry on for a good while.
But by the 8th century, whether it's because of their sort of political situation, whether
it's because of this habit of dividing up the empire and so on, we do find the kingdom,
we do find that the king becomes a less and less powerful figure.
And by the time that the Carolingians come and take over, they haven't got really much
resistance.
Everyone's pretty much happy to have a new bunch of people taking over and setting themselves
up and so on.
So we start out very big and then the history of the Merovingians kind of peters out a little
bit.
Okay, that's a very quick summary of the Merovingians with a main focus on Clovis.
Let's now, for the rest of the class, we've got about half an hour left, let's dig out
our texts.
I've said a bit about Clovis and we've heard during the last hour information about Theodoric
and so on.
So let's discuss these two texts, one after the other, and then we might make some comparisons
at the end to see what we might say about the two different kinds of text and also about
the two different kinds of individual that are presented there.
So, okay, chronologically, let's begin with Theodoric then.
We heard all about Theodoric from Ravel in the previous hour.
Okay, before we actually get into the text, before an historian starts reading and making
any kind of interpretation, we have to step back first and we have to think, okay, what
do we know about this text?
Where did it come from?
Why is it written?
A whole host of questions that we must very explicitly or implicitly ask ourselves before
we try and interpret this and extract information out and so on.
So what do we know about these, it's called here on this website, we've printed it from
Letters of Theodoric.
Tell us about these Letters of Theodoric before we actually look at the content of them.
What are they?
What are these letters?
Who wrote them?
Cassiodorus, who was, right, he was the secretary of Theodoric, he was closely connected to
Theodoric's court.
He was a great intellectual, he wrote some philosophical work and obviously an intellectual
as well as an important aristocratic kind of figure I suppose as well.
So it kind of fits into our traditional image of an educated political Roman in that kind
of a sense.
So here he is preparing these letters as the secretary, which means to a large extent he
writes the words and then Theodoric kind of will say yes that seems fine or that's what
I wanted you to say.
We do that at the library all the time, these blue letters, these blue memos come in Turkish
which I then sign.
It's something we've discussed or even things I haven't even discussed necessarily but okay
this is what we need to do so I sign it and things.
It looks like it's from me but definitely I didn't write the words because my Turkish
isn't that good and so on.
But you could say in many cases at least it's what I would like to say or what I've agreed
that the library will be saying or something like that about a particular issue.
So firstly we've got a certain remove.
So we've got kind of letters, Cassiodorus, Theodoric.
So we're at a certain remove already okay.
So if we're trying to get at this man, we're going to him via this guy in a sense,
which may in some cases be straightforward, in some cases we may have to do that
and then this bit might be questionable, might be something we should think about.
Any letters for historian are interesting documents okay.
Now a letter is what?
Think of it structurally.
What is a letter trying to do?
How is a letter put forward?
If we approach a letter, what is a letter doing at the time it's written?
What do we know about letters that we often don't know about other sources?
I haven't phrased the question.
Difficult to phrase a question without sometimes making the answer very obvious.
Or at least the institution.
It's the institution that he represents or whatever written on his behalf.
You're still getting back to something.
It's clearly a primary source because we've got a letter,
we've got the words that that man or that institution put together.
For the Middle Ages we often don't have that.
We have in a sense secondary reporting.
We have someone else saying this is what they did.
For example in the Clovis material,
Gregory of Tours gives all these little speeches which will be in quotes in our translation.
Now how the hell a hundred years later does Gregory of Tours know exactly what people said
in Germanic and he's translated it into Latin or something?
Of course not.
He's made those words up.
He's created those little dialogues or whatever.
He thinks they're expressing probably what people said or what he wants them to say.
But we're at a great...
This remove is less.
It's still a certain remove for these particular letters.
But a letter in theory,
we've got the name of the author somewhere at the beginning or at the end
and usually we also know to whom the letter was written.
So we've got author to audience or something.
And knowing both of these or having some idea of both of these
is very important for our interpretation of a document.
Because knowing who wrote it obviously is very, very important
because then we need to know his or her attitude,
his or her background,
possible bias and things like that.
But also to whom you are writing is equally important
because you say different things to different people.
Just as we were saying before about the persons,
David Thornton as the three persons of David Thornton or something.
When I write a letter to send an email to my father or whatever,
a very different kind of email to the one that I would send
to the rector of the university and so on.
So knowing whom it's written to will tell us
what the kind of things we might expect
and what kind of things we're not expecting to be said.
And what you don't say is often very important as well.
Many historical sources we have to guess.
We don't know who the author is.
Oh, he was a member of the church and he probably lived in England.
And that's about as far as we can go.
And he was probably writing for educated audience
or something like that.
But we can't get much clearer than that.
In a letter we usually have one or even two names
that tell us very clearly who the people are.
So it's quite an advantage in a sense.
But letters, particularly historical ones,
are rather formal documents.
And so their relationship is a formal one.
So what they're saying is more like me writing to the rector.
We don't have many me writing to my father
kind of letters surviving from the late Roman or Middle Ages.
In the later Middle Ages we do have quite a collection of letters
that are written by sons to fathers and things like that.
But from the earlier period we've primarily got formal letters
between people in authority.
So again what they say there is going to be rather different.
Well, I don't know the exact transmission of these letters.
We will not...
It's very rare for something from the late 5th and early 6th centuries
to have the original pieces of parchment
or papyrus or whatever it was.
We have copies of copies of copies.
And we often have lots of different copies.
And then by looking at all the different copies
from 400 years, 1,000 years later, we try and reconstruct.
So I don't know the manuscript history
and transmission of these letters
of where they survive and in what context and so on.
That's something which I find very interesting in general
but it doesn't make for great kind of classes
to be trying to reconstruct manuscript histories and so on.
But this may not be complete.
It may come from various places.
There may be a single manuscript which just happens to survive
that was based on one that somehow got out of Austro-Gothic Italy
before the Byzantines came in or something like that.
I don't know the exact context of the survival and so on.
But there are a relatively small number
compared to what things were done at the time.
So we're lucky to have these in a sense.
But a good question.
OK, a few general points to start us off with.
Let's look at the letters now.
Let's go into these letters.
What kind of subjects, what are the things
which Theodoric and or Cassiodorus
thinks are necessary to write about?
Why are they writing the letters?
What are the subjects of these letters?
Some general points here.
What are the issues covered in these letters?
Taxation comes up a couple of times.
The issues of taxation and so on.
What else?
The city of Rome.
Now of course they're based in Ravenna, aren't they at this point?
So Rome is more of a...
I thought it was a bird.
Rome is more a kind of symbol of past greatness and things like that.
But they're obviously concerned with Rome.
They're giving importance to Rome
to use the Turkish kind of English phrase.
But it comes up more than once,
the idea of Rome.
Taxation, anything else?
Praising the gods.
Where was that?
Is that a subject of the letter or something?
I'm not sure.
Maybe it's not.
The virtue of the barbarians.
Right, well that's an interesting one there.
We'll come to that in more specifically
this one about the...
Oh, the Goths. I thought you said the gods.
I was getting a bit confused there in a Christian context.
I've had enough Christianity problems before
with Aryans and the Goths.
Something to do with the Goths
and organizing this kingdom
according to the people there
and so on.
Now this is a very small selection
but
yes,
toleration of
Jewish people there or something.
What else then?
Generally?
Yes, that's true.
We're interested
in maintaining morality
as we can possibly be in war.
This is focusing
on the concept of law here,
the importance of law,
the law of the Romans as he specifically calls it
in that sense.
Most of these letters, if we're trying to find
a single word or couple of words
that would encompass
cover all of these letters.
Balancing what?
Maybe what aspect
of their life?
Is it language or culture
or what is he trying to balance
in these letters?
I'm trying to balance now.
Ideals?
Yes, there's a lot of idealism
here in a sense.
Right, we'll come back to that issue
in a minute.
What I wanted was, it's kind of government
in a sense, that's kind of an obvious one.
But
these are his way
of communicating
his government.
One of the ways in which they're trying to communicate
his government, his administration
to various parts of
his pseudo empire,
his kingdom, whatever you want to call it
in a sense.
So they're dealing with the city of Rome.
They're dealing with the issue of taxation and so on
and the relations between the Romans
and the Goths,
which obviously is the population of them.
And then there's the issue of the religion that comes up
and things like that.
So balancing
the decisions
for the state or whatever you might say,
something like that.
So these are government things.
They are him, not as a private individual,
but as king
trying to make decisions for his
state and things like that.
Okay?
Now, to quickly go to what I think
we can, Fatih's point before,
often
he's making decisions here.
He says, this is the law. This is what you must do.
This is the way it must go.
Now if someone is saying that,
what does that mean? If someone is saying
you must do this,
then what is the implication?
Why does he need to say
everyone should pay fair taxes?
Because everyone's not.
So sometimes very explicitly,
but sometimes again it's suggested
that we can see that things are
failing, that the government isn't
working. So he's trying to correct that.
So can you give me some examples of
how we can see
the kind of negative side of the society
in these letters?
What it can tell us is the problem
and he's giving the solution to that.
So yes, some greedy
merchants are obviously shipping loads of stuff out
not leaving enough behind because then they can
make a profit and sell it, whereas that stuff
should start off at least
to feed the population here and the surplus
the word they use, the extra
will be sent out. So the implication
is there's not just one guy doing that,
but there's lots of merchants or whatever
it is, who are doing that. Others?
You wrote something about
the Senate's tax
payment system because
at that time the Senate members
paid taxes and
he tried to equalise
the administrative units
and the general
There was a very, very common
it comes up in many
documents, we don't have that many documents
from this period, but it's a very common
claim that
one of the problems with the late
Roman Empire was to do with taxation
where the government wanted money
and it felt that it needed more money, it was imposing
taxes, it put the taxes
on the rich people, on the upper
parts of society and all they did
was extract that money from below them
and the people below them extracted
it, so the burden was then
pushed down to the lower parts
of society and that was a very common complaint
that this is some kind of issue here. So it
comes up in this letter in a more practical
issue as well. Taxation should be
fairer and should start at the top
and so on. It's a common theme all the way
to French Revolution and later of course
these issues.
What does the word
embezzlement mean in the first
document? To embezzle
means what, do we know?
By exploiting
the weakness
of the system
and stealing some money.
Usually it's money that's being taken. I mean if I
get, old Jan obviously is a very
honest young man I'm sure, I'm not
just picking him because he's the nearest one
to me, but if I gave him some money
and said okay look, I'm in the boss
you use this money and go and sort things out
over there. The guys at the back, the desk
is broken, they need better pencils or something
you go and help them, that's your job.
He says okay, hot jam, I'll go and do that. He goes off
and he uses some of the money
to fix the pencils and the chairs
but he also pockets a little bit
of it on the way. He comes back and says oh done it,
you spent all that? Oh yeah, very expensive pencils
alright, okay. He's embezzled
the money, okay. And again this is a
common human
vice or failing and obviously
in a system where you don't have strong
authority and ways of following
up orders and so on
in a pre-modern
society without the kind of organisation
or even in a modern society, it's clear
that there was a lot of corruption
and embezzlement of one sort or another
going on. So he wants to make sure
that the money that's given for particular purposes
and this one has to do with Rome I think
again, isn't it? It's used for that purpose
it's not just siphoned off into
individuals bank accounts or wherever it
might be and so on.
What about
the document about
the Goths?
There's one about the laws and there's the previous
one as well which
Eliph mentioned there and I thought she said gods
but it was Goths.
Theodoric to
Colossaeus
and then Theodoric to Onigis
Onigis looks fairly
kind of Germanic as a name
whereas the previous one clearly is a Roman
Latin name.
What do we get from those two documents?
Because here we have the issue we've been talking about a lot
Romans and Germanic peoples
and we've got them together
in one document.
As far as I read, the Roman elites
were the civilians and Goths
are contracted to be the
guards of those Romans and people
so there is something they cannot
have settlement if I'm sure
and then but they
started to settle down
and the population mixed and they
also started not to pay taxes
and now in this case
there is
well Theodoric himself
is Gothic but he
leads to Roman population
and Goths are a minority but
maybe somehow he tries to balance
them in the second and the last letter
and maybe the Goths wants to
rival against
rebel against Romans and he tries
to calm them down.
Yes, there is definitely
an idea of balancing as you mentioned before
and compromising the two sides
of his society that he's got.
One thing that interested me when I first read this
a few years ago
was the phrase which is kind of
a bit like we were discussing two weeks
ago from
was it one week ago Tacitus
to unite it is
theirs the role of the Goths
to unite the forethought
of the Romans so the
intellectual and culture of the
Romans and the virtue
of the barbarians so that
again that idea of the kind of noble savage
the purity of the Germanic people
that's a theme a topos
which we can trace back hundreds
of years now back to Tacitus as well
and these guys whether it's Theodoric
himself or the educated Cassiodorus
is picking up on that
idea as well that we get
a perfect society we bring the purity
of one people with the
intellectual and cultural
achievement of the other put them together
and we have Ostrogothic society
in a sense we have the population and we
have the guys on top who can make it kind of
work and things like that.
So he's dealing with organising
society but he's also got this
strained society where you've got a kind of military
and political minority
which is the Goths with
some other people some other Goths
mixed in but the majority of the population
are the Roman traditional people
who are needing to be
kind of placated because they're not necessarily
happy with being ruled by Goths so he's
again this issue of balancing.
What do you think about Theodoric?
Last question.
From the letters we've got here
Would you have liked to meet him do you think?
Does he seem like a reasonable guy?
I think he wouldn't have.
Right.
He seems like a guy.
But surely of an evening
he would have sat down with a
large flagon of Gothic
ale or something and we could have
knocked on his door
Right.
He would have
Yes.
He may
yeah I mean I don't know
it's kind of a silly question obviously but just
again it's this issue of how
far we can reach him and how far
it's Theodoric the King is kind of
being represented here and so on
we were talking before in
Ravel's presentation about the issues of
religious tolerance
and things like that again that must be
something which at least was a practical
issue but must be partly personal as well
so there are some personality issues
which might come through
He doesn't come off as a very
ruler
maybe I missed it but
they don't tell
what would happen if things don't change
Right. Okay.
Okay the follow up from that
you can write a letter and say do this
Get this fixed or else
it doesn't make sense
Right. Well yes we need to I mean other
sources might not
tell us that. Laws
and these are kind of little bits of law
decisions often are
just have that form and we don't have
some kind of a we don't have a police
system we don't necessarily have some
explicit statement which says
I'll come and deal with you and so on but
it's part of the picture but you're right this is a
reflection of kind of medieval government working
but how far we can then see
whether it works or not is another matter
of course. I said if there's a problem
then he's addressing the problem
so we have to say the problem exists
here's his solution and you're saying
we don't know if the solution was actually put
into effect or not. Now
it's a mood quest in the end because by the
time he dies everything kind of begins to break
down but yeah that's
a reasonable point as well.
Okay ten minutes slightly less than ten minutes
we've done too much on the theodoric. Clovis
okay now
different situation here
what do
we know about his
tell me about his conversion to Christianity
yes he's married
to
Clothild who was
Christian and
and
she was persistent
patient however you want to look at it
in her attempts to
convert him
quite naturally
what happens first
first
thing they have a son
she baptises
him
and the son dies
okay so that obviously was
unfortunate
for Clothild that's not going to help
her case. The second time
almost happens again
but then she prays and so on and then
the son survives
so
that's a kind of one step
now what else happens what's the
big issue in terms
of
the conversion here and so on
which we talked about
before how does he finally come round
to becoming Christian
right okay
tell me a bit more about that then
from this account
he was about to
fail and
he promised
to be Christian
and prayed
in order to win
the battle and then he
won the battle so he became
Christian he got baptised
and he converted
right and that's as I said kind of got parallels
with the conversion of Constantine
as is the sort of basic
description of that as well
and this is meant to be connected
to
his victory of the
Alamans
460
96
to 7
now
it's presented
here that Clovis
becomes
Catholic he converts from being a pagan
Germanic pagan to becoming
a Catholic at this point
there is another document written
by a Bishop
Avitus which has been interpreted
so I'm not saying it's the correct interpretation
but which has been interpreted
by some historians to suggest
the picture the reality
was more complicated
he talked about
a heresy and I think they've added Aryan
here but the followers of the
Aryan era
have in vain by a cloud
of contradictory and untrue opinions
sought to conceal from your
extreme subtlety ha ha
your cleverness the glory
of the Christian name and so on
okay and there is a reference
somewhere in here
to yes on page 3
is the way I printed it out near the top
one of his sisters who had fallen
into the era of the Aryans
so some historians
have suggested
that like Theodoric
Clovis
originally was actually
an Aryan Christian
and that possibly on this occasion
he gets persuaded
by whatever means his wife or in this case
victory in battle to adopt
the Christian interpretation
the Catholic interpretation
of Christianity
but Gregory of Tours
didn't like Aryan
Christianity
he doesn't like that at all
so he's setting up Clovis as the big hero
the guy who does the conquests
the ones who establishes the true
faith amongst the people
so it would perhaps
spoil his picture
if you have pagan
then Aryan and then finally
Catholic the bit in the middle
the Aryan bit kind of compromises
the simpler
and clearer picture he wants
so it's been suggested that he deliberately
smooths over that
and presents what happens here
as a conversion from paganism
to Catholicism
now I don't know whether
we can't prove that we don't have
firm evidence it's based on interpreting
documents and so on
but it's a possibility
so if that's the case
which it may or may not be
then we have to be very careful
about how we interpret
the accounts
of
his behaviour
and things like that
what about his relationship
to other
barbarian
or Germanic rulers
what can we say about his
diplomacy his international
relations or whatever
however you want to describe it
at that time
what does he do how does he behave
towards other Germanic kings
in Gaul
in the way that Gregory
presents it
is he nice to these people
or is he not so nice
that's different
there are other people who were kings
or claim to be king
right at the bottom of page 3
two minutes to go
Cloderick
the son of Sigbert the lame
who I think was a different
kind of Frank
he wasn't a salient Frank like these people
he was a ripuarian Frank
another tribe another group of Franks
Clovis obviously
doing all sorts of naughty things there
to get his best of them
and what about on the last page Ragnacar
who was king at Cambrai
so some kind of a warrior chief
based in Cambrai
what happens here
what does Clovis do
with this guy
and this is one of a number they haven't given all
the examples here of what he gets up to
against other noble men
and so on
sorry
he basically
does the dirty
on him by one way or another
and there are other examples of this kind of thing
and the ironic thing
is the quotation right at the end
right at the end of that paragraph
woe to me oh what a shame
he says woe to me
who I who have remained as a stranger
among foreigners
in this strange land or whatever
and have none of my kinsmen
none of my relatives
to give me aid if adversity comes
what Gregory had been showing for a while
is that Clovis had been
going around killing most of his
distant relatives who might threaten his
power so whether he's being
sad that he doesn't have the relatives
or whether he's just waiting for someone to say
oh actually Clovis I'm here
and then you'll get him as well I don't know
but Clovis
presents rather explicitly
a very
realpolitik
kind of a Clovis who
Gregory presents very clearly
someone who's very practical he's using
military power and political pressure
to expand his kingdom
and so on that's what he does
ok I did want us to sit down for the last 5 minutes
and chat about these two guys
but as usual we've run out of
time because we've had so much fun
so let me before you
escape I still have you for
at least 30 seconds pass out
the reading
material for
next week
