Diesel problems? Low Power Concerns, Won't regen the DPF? EGR could cause all these issues. Here we discuss what role EGR plays in the diesel engine emission control strategy. Is it part of the aftertreatment system? Where does that system start and end, is it just after combustion and sticking with the big 3, DOC, DPF and SCR? or will we include things that happen before combustion as part of the aftertreatment. Let me know what you think in the comments, if you disagree I promise not to hate you for being wrong! https://tidd.ly/4o40nIM Emanual Free Trial Get vidIQ to grow your channel faster! 🚀 https://vidiq.com/CharleysGarage https://www.amazon.com/shop/charleysgarage?ref=ac_inf_tb_vh&isPublicView=true
https://try.printify.com/n7roh39suo5n If you have TikTok and YouTube and post content don't forget that you can very easily open a shopify store and connect it to printify to sell you own designed branded gear and swag. It is easy and printify walks you through every step.
https://tidd.ly/48oVmFy Our friends at 9phx Racing have great deals on lots of cool diesel stuff including EGR delete kits.
All right, what components make up an aftertreatment system?
I recently had this discussion with somebody on one of my channels where I had posted a video
about the aftertreatment fuel injector and I said something along the lines this is one of
the first aftertreatment system components that you're going to see and this guy in the comments
mentioned that the EGR is actually the one of the first ones not this aftertreatment fuel injector.
So number one he's nitpicking and he was being a keyboard warrior but that's not the point. The
point is that I am man enough to admit that I do not know everything and I don't consider EGR to
be part of the aftertreatment system so after just dismissing this guy for being the keyboard
warrior that he wanted to be I went online and I kind of went and did some research right.
So the first thing I did was I google searched is exhaust gas recirculation part of the
aftertreatment system and the truth is that a lot of very reputable places that came up in
the google search like Cummins for example states that they do consider the exhaust gas recirculation
system to be part of the aftertreatment system. All right so that didn't make any sense to me so
I'm like is it possible for big companies and big diesel people to be wrong about this? Am I right?
Am I wrong? Is the truth somewhere in the gray in the middle? So I kept looking right and there are
a few sites that didn't list the exhaust gas recirculation as part of the aftertreatment
system but like I said there was some pretty reputable sites that did. So at that point I was
kind of in the gray area where maybe depending on your point of view it could be or it couldn't be
but then I started thinking that it sounded like intellectual laziness to me where people just
didn't understand the terms pre and after. So I google searched what does the after in after
treatment mean right and I'm going to read this to you right off of google in exhaust after
treatment the word after indicates that the treatment process happens following the primary
combustion process in the engine. All right so what EGR does is it does take exhaust gas but
it puts it back in the cylinder during the intake stroke to pre-treat the cylinder prior to combustion
so that the temperature does not get high enough to create knocks.
In charlie world that equals pre-treatment not after treatment. We are prepping a cylinder to
not create the emission to begin with. After treatment would be dealing with the emission
after combustion after it's been made. So there is that gray area okay there and that's where I
companies like the ones I saw in my first search like cummins and a few other pretty reputable
companies that I don't have a problem with who list the EGR as an after treatment part.
I do think it's an intellectual laziness and even some of my fellow diesel instructors that I went
and asked to a couple of them agreed with me a couple of them said no it's part of the after
treatment system. I think you know I don't have a problem saying I think they're being intellectually
lazy too and if we can't do something as simple as explain to young people the difference between
pre-treating for emissions versus after treatment for emissions then what are we doing right?
Are we assuming that people are too dumb to understand the difference between
preventing a emission from being created in the first place with pre-treatment versus dealing
with it after it's been created with after treatment. So what are your thoughts on this
and there is no right or wrong I'm not saying that I'm going to just hate all things cummins
because they said something I disagree with I'm not going to hate you guys for disagreeing with
me I don't hate my fellow instructors that disagree with me I just think they're wrong.
So what do you think let me know in the comments is EGR after treatment pre-treatment or where I'm
at right now is that I really don't give a ---- so it could be either one but again now they've
turned me into being intellectually lazy as well. So what are your thoughts let me know in the
comments please like and subscribe let me know what video ideas you have for me and I'll put
some out there for you. Thank you!